Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Knowledge for fishing and aquaculture into the future Page i Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 VISION Vibrant Australian fishing and aquaculture sectors, adopting world-class research to achieve sustainability and prosperity. Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 By 2020 … … fishing and aquaculture will continue to be environmentally sustainable. … science and management related to the sustainability of fishing and aquaculture will be more transparent … fishing and aquaculture will be more resilient to social, environmental and economic change … fishing and aquaculture businesses will be more productive and profitable … recreational fishers will have improved opportunities for better fishing experiences and will play a greater role in the stewardship of fisheries resources … more Indigenous people will derive benefit from fishing and aquaculture activities and will play a greater role in the stewardship of fisheries resources. Page ii Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 CONTENTS Executive summary ................................................................................................................................. 4 Planned outcome and role...................................................................................................................... 5 REvenue Base ...................................................................................................................................... 6 FRDC’s stakeholders – communication, consultation and accountability .......................................... 7 The operating environment for Australian fishing and aquaculture ...................................................... 9 Drivers and opportunities for 2015 – 20........................................................................................... 11 Sector profiles ................................................................................................................................... 14 A new strategic focus ............................................................................................................................ 19 The National research priorities ....................................................................................................... 19 National initiatives ............................................................................................................................ 21 Implementing the FRDC RD&E Plan ...................................................................................................... 25 The FRDC RD&E Program areas ........................................................................................................ 25 A balanced research portfolio........................................................................................................... 28 Applying for funding ......................................................................................................................... 28 Extension and adoption of research outputs ................................................................................... 28 Collaboration within the national research framework ....................................................................... 29 Australian Government research and development priorities ......................................................... 29 aligned Research priorities ............................................................................................................... 30 Evaluation framework ........................................................................................................................... 31 Funding and expenditure ...................................................................................................................... 32 Page iii Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The aim of the FRDC is to ensure that Australia’s fresh water and marine resources are used and managed for the benefit of the whole community, based on the science it funds. This includes that; aquaculture and commercial fishing continue to provide food for the nation and are viewed as a key part of Australia’s primary production systems, there is recognition of the customary and historical role of fishing for Indigenous communities and to derive benefit from fishing and aquaculture activities, and to ensure recreational fishing is satisfying and rewarding experience. This RD&E Plan signifies an evolution in the way the FRDC invests. The FRDC will now focus its investment during the life of this plan to three national priorities that the FRDC will lead on: To ensure the product of Australia is sustainable and acknowledged to be so. To improve fisheries productivity and profitability. To develop emerging aquaculture opportunities. The FRDC does not spread its efforts too thinly across a large range of Research Development and Extension (RD&E) – this means doing less, but doing it better, focusing on outcomes that have greater impact on the future of fisheries in Australia. The evolution in this RD&E Plan has been driven by extensive consultation with stakeholders and the people who use the research the FRDC commissions. This consultation has included the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, the Department of Agriculture, those involved in aquaculture, commercial fishers, Indigenous fishers, recreational fishers, research providers, post-harvest processors and fisheries managers from federal, state and territory governments. The FRDC will take the lead on national research initiatives that address whole of industry and community issues and opportunities. These are: aquatic animal health and biosecurity; recreational fishing; Indigenous fishing and aquaculture; people development; social sciences and economics; and delivery of key services (e.g. Fishnames, SafeFish). The FRDC will continue to partner with various fishery industry groups and regions that have developed their own RD&E plans and undertake collaborative research, particularly where it addresses national priorities. Figure 1 the framework for RD&E investment by the FRDC for 2015 – 20 Page 4 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 PLANNED OUTCOME AND ROLE The FRDC is a statutory corporation within the Australian Government’s Agriculture portfolio. This portfolio aims to enhance the sustainability, profitability and competitiveness of Australia’s agriculture, food, fisheries and forestry industries. The FRDC contributes to the achievement of this portfolio aim through achieving the following planned outcome: Increased knowledge that fosters sustainable economic, environmental and social benefits for Australian fishing and aquaculture. This includes Indigenous, recreational, commercial and aquaculture sectors, and the community, through investing in research, development and adoptions. To give effect to this planned outcome the FRDC plans, manages and extends knowledge, created through FRDC funding processes The FRDC is accountable to the Parliament of Australia through the Minister for Agriculture. It was formed on 2 July 1991, and has two pieces of governing legislation: Primary Industries Research and Development Act 1989 (PIRD Act); and Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013. The Corporation is governed by board of directors. The board has a number of advisory committees, and one executive director who manages the day-to-day operation of the Corporation through a small office-based team of people. BREAKOUT Box: The PIRD Act sets the FRDC’s objectives as follows. a) Make provision for the funding and administration of research and development relating to primary industries with a view to: i. increasing the economic, environmental and social benefits to members of primary industries and to the community in general by improving the production, processing, storage, transport or marketing of the products of primary industries; ii. achieving the sustainable use and sustainable management of natural resources; iii. making more effective use of the resources and skills of the community in general and the scientific community in particular; iv. supporting the development of scientific and technical capacity; v. developing the adoptive capacity of primary producers; and vi. improving accountability for expenditure on research and development activities in relation to primary industries. b) Make provision for the funding and administration of marketing relating to products of primary industries. The FRDC invests in RD&E that supports aquaculture, commercial fishing, Indigenous fishing and recreational fishing. These four sectors operate across environments that range from the northern tropics through to temperate seas and icy Antarctic waters, from freshwater rivers and lakes, to estuaries and to the depths of the ocean. The FRDC does not undertake RD&E itself. Rather, it partners with other organisations that have the necessary capabilities to undertake the varied specialised activities. With a focus on end users of RD&E and markets, the FRDC facilitates the extension adoption and commercialisation of research and development and evaluates the benefits. The FRDC Page 5 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 contributes to a strategic national approach to fishing and aquaculture RD&E that aims to share knowledge, build cohesion and establish common goals between sectors. Partnerships and previous RD&E are considered in planning and investment processes, to maximise leverage and reduce duplication. As a quality-certified organisation (AS/NZS ISO 9001:2008), the FRDC’s RD&E investment is underpinned by a quality-management system, which includes mechanisms for reviewing performance and implementing changes, to ensure continuous improvement. While the FRDCs focus is on delivering benefits to primary fishing and aquaculture stakeholders, the RD&E the FRDC invests in also benefits other participants in the Australian seafood industry value chain, research providers and the wider Australian community. REVENUE BASE Revenue for RD&E investment is based on a co-funding model between the Australian Government and the fishing and aquaculture industries. It is collected through the Australian Fisheries Management Authority and state and territory governments. Rationale for the FRDC’s revenue base The high component of public good in the operating environment of fishing and aquaculture has significance for the FRDC’s revenue base. The Australian Government’s contributes funding equal to 0.50 per cent of Annual Gross Value of Production (wild-catch and aquaculture) on the grounds that the Australian Government exercises a stewardship role in relation to fishing and aquaculture resources on behalf of the Australian community. The fishing and aquaculture industry contributes to the FRDC on the basis that RD&E will be orientated to its needs and will deliver economic and social benefits. The Australian Government matches industry contributions on the basis that the beneficiaries of research should pay roughly in proportion to the benefits received, but that the government should contribute to the spillover benefits to the wider community. Figure 2 The basis of, and rationale for, the FRDC’s revenue base. Page 6 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 FRDC’S STAKEHOLDERS – COMMUNICATION, CONSULTATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY “Consultation, networking and connecting those involved in fishing and aquaculture is the strength of the FRDC and is pivotal to how we do business.” – FRDC executive director, Patrick Hone The FRDC’s stakeholders include: The Federal, state and territory governments, including fisheries and natural resources managers All of the fishing and aquaculture sectors The Australian community, on whose behalf aquatic natural resources are managed Consumers of seafood. The research community including universities, government fisheries organisations, further education organisations (eg TAFE) international research organisations and private-sector research providers. Box: Evolving our engagement 1996 – The term fishing industry includes any industry or activity in Australia concerned with: taking, culturing, processing, preserving, storing, transporting, marketing, or selling fish or fish products. The fishing industry comprises the recreational, commercial, and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander sectors. The commercial sector, including pearling, is also referred to as the seafood industry. 2000 – Three sectors of the fishing industry; The commercial sector comprises enterprises and individuals associated with wild-catch or aquaculture resources and the various transformation of those resources into products for sale. It is also referred to as the “seafood industry”, including non-food items such as pearls. The recreational sector comprises enterprises and individuals who – for the purpose of recreation, sport or sustenance – are associated with fisheries resources that are not for sale. The traditional sector comprises enterprises and individuals associated with fisheries resources from which Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people derive products in accordance with their traditions. 2005 – Three main sectors of the fishing and aquaculture industry – commercial (wild-catch and aquaculture), recreational fishing and Indigenous fishing. 2010 – The fishing and aquaculture industry’s three main sectors comprise: Commercial wild-catch fishers, aquaculture producers, including post-harvest enterprises Recreational fishers and associated commercial enterprises Indigenous customary fishers. 2015 – There are four main sectors involved in fishing and aquaculture in Australia: Commercial wild-catch fishers and businesses Commercial aquaculture businesses Indigenous fishers Recreational fishers and associated businesses. The term seafood industry incorporates the commercial sectors of the industry, including those concerned with the commercial take, culturing, processing, preserving, storing, transporting, marketing or selling fish or fish products (including pearling). Page 7 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Fishing and aquaculture industry refers just to those who operate commercially in the catching/harvesting or growing of seafood. The FRDC regularly engages with its stakeholders through a range of mechanisms including: four ministerially appointed Representative Organisations to which the FRDC is accountable under legislation: o National Seafood Industry Alliance – representing the seafood industry o Recfish Australia – representing recreational and sport fishers o Commonwealth Fisheries Association –representing commercial fishers who operate in Commonwealth fisheries o National Aquaculture Council – representing the aquaculture industry the Governance Committee that support the National Fishing and Aquaculture RD&E Strategy and the National Research Providers Network (representing fisheries researchers) (FRDC is a member of both groups) partnerships between the FRDC, industry sectors and regions the Australian Fisheries Management Forum, representing government agencies responsible for fisheries management (FRDC is an observer) FRDC subprograms and coordination programs. Page 8 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 THE OPERATING ENVIRONMENT FOR AUSTRALIAN FISHING AND AQUACULTURE Australia has the third largest marine territory in the World. The diverse marine seascapes, stretching from the tropics to Antarctica, reflect unique biodiversity values and deliver a valuable flow of ecosystems goods and services. In addition to the marine environment is the freshwater environment which some fishing and aquaculture occurs in, stretching again from the tropics and almost outback conditions to the temperate highlands of the southern states. Australia is a maritime nation - over 80% of its 23 million population live within 50 km of the coast - and citizens have sovereign rights over the world’s third largest fishing zone. This marine territory covers 8,148,250 square kilometers – but, because of a lack of nutrientrich currents (and so relatively low productivity), Australia ranks only 52nd in the world in terms of volume of fish landed. In line with Australia’s diverse environments, that support the 600+ targeted and produced species, there is equal diversity in those who fish and farm these species. Each is unique and having their own specific practices. This ranges from short fishing trips to longer voyages out to fishing grounds at the boundaries of Australia’s fishing zone. They operate on land, rivers, estuaries out to the sea using a wide variety of methods and equipment to catch and produce. Commercial fisheries production in 2012-13 was 157,252 tonnes with an approximate value of this harvest of $1.38 billion. For the same period aquaculture production was around 80,066 tonnes with a value of around $1.03 billion. Estimates of harvest, participation and value of the Indigenous and recreational fishing sectors are harder to determine. Indigenous fishing which is commercial wild-catch or aquaculture is included in the figures above but is hard to separate from the rest of the data. Most recent estimates from 2001 have recreational catch at 48,400 tonnes with a retained catch of approximately 30,000 tonnes. For Indigenous customary fishing practices the estimate was approximately 2,000 tonnes. A recent FRDC project (2012-214) has established a proxy valuation methodology for estimating the economic value of recreational fishing. It has often been discussed that the recreational sector contributes significantly through investment in boats, fishing equipment and other associated overhead costs. With the inclusion of these flow on contributions from recreational fishing the report has estimated for 2013 a value of $2.56 billion. Page 9 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Box: The Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation in partnership with CSIRO has identified the five major trends” that are expected to influence primary industries globally during the next 20 years, in its report Rural Industry Futures – Megatrends impacting Australian agriculture over the coming twenty years. These trends are described in figure 2. Figure 3 the five “Megatrends” that will influence primary industries over the next 20 years as identified in the report RURAL INDUSTRY FUTURES – Megatrends impacting Australian agriculture over the coming twenty years. In developing this RD&E plan, the FRDC undertook extensive consultation with its stakeholders and evaluated the drivers and opportunities in the fishing and aquaculture operating environment. To ensure the best understanding of the operating environment and to assess the model from figure 3 to fishing and aquaculture, the FRDC commissioned a review. Information from the resultant report titled 2014 Australian Fishing and Aquaculture Sector Overview (sector overview) (FRDC project 2014-503.20) has been used along with other relevant planning document such as the Australian Fisheries Managers Forum Statement of Intent, to identify the drivers and opportunities for 2015–20. Page 10 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 DRIVERS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR 2015 – 20 Public perception of Australia’s fishing and aquaculture operations (social licence) Fishing and aquaculture in Australia has a history of high performance, good stewardship and a focus on best practice. However, community perceptions do not differentiate Australia’s good fishing and aquaculture management and practices from sometimes poor global records. This influences the way in which Australian consumers perceive and purchase seafood, and which, in turn, flows onto the onto the community’s perception of fishing and aquaculture operations. Community perceptions – good and bad – have strong influence on access to natural resources across all sectors and on commercial profitability. Opportunities: Communicate information to the community on the improvements in Australia’s fishing and aquaculture management and practices in an accessible, engaging and trustworthy form. Create standards to guide the science and management of natural resources in the marine environment to ensure best practice and improve transparency. Use research to understand and anticipate community concerns and target research to formulate appropriate responses. Food security, globalisation and market access The global population is rising and with it the demand for food and seafood. An extra billion consumers globally are expected by 2030, requiring an estimated additional 25 million tonnes of seafood. Seafood is an important dietary component for the expanding Asian middle class, which increasingly seeks branded safe seafood. It is also a much-needed protein for developing countries. Globalisation and efficient trade are pivotal to meeting these dietary needs. Already, fishery products are one of the most traded human food commodities, and the most consumed by volume. Commodity price forecasts from the World Bank (2014) indicate a modest real price gain for fish to 2030, but larger gains for fishmeal and oil ingredients needed for aquaculture. Aquaculture production has grown in Australia over the past 10 years and has shown potential for further productivity increases, both in currently produced species and in new and emerging species. Bycatch and discards continue to be an issue in wild-catch fisheries worldwide, but also present a potential source for increasing the harvest by adding value to the caught product. Adding value to processing waste also presents the potential for increasing seafood availability. Australia’s Indigenous communities are increasingly seeking opportunities to develop their fishery resources to achieve outcomes that include improved diets, nutrition and health; retention of young people in communities; local employment, trade and business skills; demonstration of cultural heritage and collaboration in investments. Opportunities: Understand consumer and market requirements and needs (domestic and international) to assist both aquaculture and the wild-catch sectors optimise production efficiency and overall profitability. Page 11 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Add value to bycatch, discards and processing waste to increase seafood and other products availability. Capitalise on globalisation and market access, those operating in fishing and aquaculture must adapt to market risks, competition and opportunities. Develop appropriate governance and economic models to better support individual and community economic development for the Indigenous sector. Environmental health Seafood production and the health of environmental systems on which it depends are linked. Opportunities: Develop tools and resources to monitor, understand and adapt to fishing and aquaculture’s impacts on fish stocks and ecosystems to ensure sustainable use. Identify new and more efficient methods of producing and harvesting seafood. It is logical that healthier environments are more productive than those that are damaged. It is therefore in the interest of industry and government to make sure all environments are in the best condition possible. Resource access and allocation All fishers need long-term access to aquatic resources to meet their individual and sectoral needs. However, competition is increasing – from within fishing and aquaculture sectors, from external sources such as the oil and gas industry, and from the reduction of fishable area through marine protected areas. Opportunities: Establish and document the aspirations of the sectors in relation to access and allocation of aquatic resources. Establish the appropriate rights-based framework to maximise the economic, environmental and social values from the use of aquatic resources. This will require accurate social and economic data. Resource management The focus within natural resources management has changed from single issues (target stocks or generally isolated environmental concerns) to broader interactions between the environment, economy and communities across all sectors of fishing and aquaculture. This is in line with the current expectations of the Australian public. Formal management of fishing and aquaculture resources has in the past been focused on commercial interests. There is now a growing push for the inclusion of all sectors of fishing and aquaculture in management, including Indigenous and recreational fishing. Opportunities: Develop management practices and processes that better incorporate the needs, actual catch and impact of all sectors and improve resource access and allocation. Acquire sophisticated economic data, accurate catch data and ascertain the impact from all sectors including social impacts. Create a fisheries management ‘standard’ to foster innovative, streamlined and cost-effective natural resource management, with greater emphasis on protocols and data. Page 12 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Aquatic animal health Disease-causing organisms, including exotic, new and emerging pathogens, are an increasing threat to Australian fisheries, aquaculture and their associated ecosystems. The risk is expected to rise with increased globalisation and potential impacts from changing environments. Disease monitoring, prevention and treatment will be especially important to the further development and expansion of aquaculture. Opportunities: Develop the capacity to improve surveillance, monitoring, diagnostics, mitigation of exotic pest risks. Develop disease control responses, including new vaccines, genetic resistance and veterinary chemicals. People development/capacity building There is concern worldwide about the declining number of students enrolling in primary industry courses and pursuing primary industry careers. Australia is not immune from this trend. Many members of the fishing community are older, and as they begin to retire there is a need for new people to step into their positions. There does not seem to be the political will across jurisdictions to manage people development. In addition, there appears to be a lack of knowledge of the training needs for fishing and aquaculture in Australia, and hence an inability to make good investments in this area. Opportunities: Attract, train and retain a skilled workforce, including researchers, fishers, innovators and resource managers at the sector, jurisdictional and national levels. Collect quality data on the training needs of fishing and aquaculture sectors in Australia. Foster leadership, professionalism and entrepreneurship across all sectors of fishing and aquaculture to help build resilience. Bring together the different sectors of fishing and aquaculture to conduct capacity building, thereby building networks to help unify sectors. “I heard four overarching issues raised at this conference – social licence to operate (including resource access), productivity and profitability, market access, and sustainability. Ultimately, the goals and strategies for this industry are industry’s narrative and our role is the science and innovation to help get you there.” – FRDC director Peter O’Brien, summing up the biennial Seafood Directions 2013 conference Page 13 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 SECTOR PROFILES Aquaculture The aquaculture sector typically consists of business-savvy, value-adding ventures. The larger operators process, package and brand their own produce. The outlook for aquaculture in Australia is positive. Increased consumer demand is driving industry growth, and creating opportunities to vertically integrate seafood production all the way through to consumers. This is taking Australian aquaculture on a course to be the major seafood production sector. Aquaculture in Australia is in a position to capitalise on advances in breeding and disease management, and from associated technological advances that can increase productivity while reducing environmental impact. Advanced aquaculture production techniques also have the potential to produce seafood with the smallest use of environmental resources of any primary production sector. As with the wild-catch sector, certification processes are being used in aquaculture to promote environmental and production credentials and build consumer and societal trust. Challenges: Aquatic animal health – Exotic and new virus and disease incursions continue to be a major risk to aquaculture in Australia. There is a continued need for RD&E for adequate viral and disease diagnostic capability, surveillance and treatment in aquaculture. Resource access – A major impediment to the growth of aquaculture is adequate access to suitable production areas (land and water). This is mostly a concern in coastal regions in close proximity to residential areas, where conflict exists with local communities and other recreational users of these waterways. Another key factor impacting on resource access is lack of community support both locally and, more broadly, on a national scale. Page 14 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Commercial fishing The commercial fishing sector has a long and remarkable heritage. Structural adjustment in recent times has led to a more sophisticated and modern industry, characterised by excellent fisheries management, arguably amongst the best in the world. This has achieved a balance between long-term environmental sustainability and economic viability. The wild-catch industry is made up of about 15,000 licence holders, managed by Australian governments and can be generally categorised two ways. There are a small number of operators that take a large portion of the harvest (by value and volume). These are diverse operations that may hold multiple licences. They may operate in a range of fisheries and in some instances they are vertically integrated along the supply chain. The remainder of the wild-catch sector is made up of a large number of small business owner-operators. They are vital to sustaining small coastal communities and are passionate about what they do; supplying Australia with seafood. Challenges: Public perception – There is ongoing need for the sector to demonstrate that its practices are world’s best. In recent times this has been largely centred on obtaining third party certification of fishing practices and management and this will continue. Additionally there are sustainability issues that arise from external factors impacting on the environment, such as pollution, climate variability, disease, biosecurity and destruction of habitat from a variety of means, including coastal development. Resource access – The marine environment is a multi-user environment. There are competing claims for the resource between fishing and aquaculture sectors, and from other users such as the oil and gas industry and stakeholders wanting more areas protected. Productivity and profitability – Economic viability requires efficient harvesting methods, elimination of unnecessarily complex legislation, better use of underutilised species and opportunities to increase yield. Page 15 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Infographic * The commercial sector in Australia comprises about 120 wild-catch fisheries and 70 aquaculture species. * The total quantity of wild-caught fish in 2012–13 was 157,252 tonnes and approximately $1.4 billion. * Total aquaculture production reached 83,786 tonnes in 2012–13, with a value just more than $1 billion. Value and volume are increasing, underpinned by advances in genetic breeding, feeds, animal health and access to new areas. * Historically, the Australian commercial seafood industry has maximised returns through exports and contributes to about 28 per cent of domestic seafood demand. Infographic page 12, Annual Report 2013-14 Infographic: Global context Fishing and aquaculture provide 16 per cent of the world’s animal protein consumption. According to the World Bank, 57 per cent of commercial wild marine fish stocks are exploited to their full potential and another 30 per cent are overexploited and are likely to decline. Globally the wild fish catch has remained constant for more than 10 years. Aquaculture encompasses more than 500 species and is currently the only seafood source able to meet growth in demand. Aquaculture is currently the fastest growing food production system in the world and is forecast to expand by a third. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations predicts that aquaculture will provide 62 per cent of fish for human consumption by 2030. Page 16 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Indigenous sector Indigenous Australians are a distinct group by virtue of their ancient ties to the land and sea, carried on through traditional practices that include fishing. Core values exist around the sharing of fish with communities and families, where there is a culture of ‘no waste’. However, Indigenous Australians also participate in the aquaculture, commercial wild-catch and recreational sectors across Australia. Indigenous fishing is focused around coastal, estuarine, and inland waters with a preference for a mix of species, some of which are also important to other sectors. Marine and freshwater species are an important food source, and a component of many customary, ceremonial and social events. Fishing helps communities and families to retain their independence and connection to country, reinforces social networks through the sharing of gathered food and maintains traditional fishing knowledge. Fish and fishing are important educational tools in many Indigenous communities, with traditional fishing knowledge being passed on to successive generations. Many Indigenous Australians believe their traditional fishing rights have been ignored or are not sufficiently recognised by government across Australia. Several state and territory governments and authorities do explicitly recognise some Indigenous rights, including through legislative provision of Indigenous fishing rights and opportunities, but adoption has been slow. Challenges: Resource access and management – Building two-way understanding and engagement is needed between Indigenous fishers and policy makers, resource managers, other stakeholders and researchers to improve the adoption of completed research. While many agencies are working with Indigenous Australians to improve outcomes, there is still significant work required to create better futures for them through the use, acknowledgement and management of aquatic resources. Economic Opportunities – Australia’s Indigenous communities are increasingly seeking opportunities to develop their fishery resources and related capacity to achieve a number of outcomes, including improving diets, nutrition and health, retaining young people in communities, engagement in local employment, developing local trade and business skills, demonstrating cultural heritage and collaborating in investments. A key area is the development of appropriate governance and economic models to best support individual and community economic development. Page 17 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Recreational sector For recreational fishers, aquatic resources represent opportunities for a hobby, a sport or a vacation. These resources provide an enjoyable activity that allows people to engage with nature, reconnect with friends and family, and provide a source of food. The economic value for the recreational sector comes from the business activities that support it. This includes the bait industry, tackle manufacturers and retailers, fishing tourism and charter or guide operators. Resource managers do not restrict the number of recreational fishers, so there are no regulatory barriers to the growth of this sector. Rather, management focuses on fishing impacts by controlling catch using for example bag limits, method of catching, spatial or seasonal closures and minimum or maximum fish sizes. However, Australia’s recreational fishing community is increasingly being asked to demonstrate greater responsibility for aquatic resources. This will help to maintain the sector’s social licence, and to enhance the quality of fishing opportunities, given that healthy aquatic environments are fundamental to this pastime. The sector also wants to ensure that decision-making is based on sound scientific information that encompasses ecological, social and economic dimensions. Challenges: Management and data – The recreational sector will need to make a greater contribution to funding and collecting quality data on economics, as well as catch and effort, particularly where they are the sole users of a resource. Resource access and allocation – The recreational sector wants to optimise the quality of fishing experiences, which requires an appropriate allocation of aquatic resources. Between fishing and aquaculture sectors and from other users such as, the oil and gas industry and from stakeholders wanting more areas protected. Environmental health – Linked to the desire to improve the experience of recreational fishing, is environmental health. The recreational sector sees that gains can be made by improving the quality of habitats that fish rely on at different life stages, thereby maximising productivity. Funding – Recreational fishers need to establish a long-term and sustainable national funding model to help increase the quality of fishing opportunities available in Australia through investment in RD&E, education, and fisheries enhancement initiatives. Page 18 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 A NEW STRATEGIC FOCUS Following extensive consultation and an evaluation of the drivers and opportunities in the fishing and aquaculture operating environment, the FRDC’s 2015-20 RD&E plan is focused on ensuring maximised impacts by concentrating on three high priority issues: To ensure Australian fishing and aquaculture products are sustainable and acknowledged to be so Improved fisheries productivity and profitability Development of emerging aquaculture opportunities. The FRDC invests in RD&E to create benefit for fishing and aquaculture, and outcomes for Australia more broadly, by investing in knowledge to create change. The FRDCs focus in 1991 was primarily on research for the management of commercial fisheries, which was mainly concerned with target stocks and environmental effects, reflecting the priorities at the time. Investment by the FRDC has evolved to reflect the broader fishing and aquaculture stakeholder base and the increased sophistication of these end users. This has resulted in an increase in RD&E on such things as the economic and social drivers of change across the fishing and aquaculture sectors. (For more information see: Evolution of FRDC: http://frdc.com.au/about_frdc/corporate-documents/Pages/default.aspx) Previous FRDC RD&E plans have included the diverse range of activities relevant to all stakeholders. This has resulted in a range of sector-specific plans including the FRDC’s Industry Partnership Agreements, FRDC subprograms and the RD&E Strategy. This previous work now allows the FRDC to reference and link to these already identified priorities without needing to duplicate them in the 201520 RD&E plan. THE NATIONAL RESEARCH PRIORITIES Australian fishing and aquaculture product are sustainable and acknowledged to be so Aim: By 2020, the community has greater access to, and understanding of, RD&E that underpins fishing and aquaculture sustainability, which informs perceptions of Australian seafood. Strategy: Report and market RD&E that displays the FRDC’s role as an independent, science-based knowledge bank. Continue to prioritise RD&E that ensures sustainability of fishing and aquaculture. Deliverables: An Australian fisheries management and/or technical standard that addresses all fisheries and can be taken up by any management agency in Australia A scheme for responsible fisheries management that can specifically be applied to small-scale, data-poor Australian fisheries Bycatch performance metrics Much increased level of commercial species in the national Status of Key Australian Fish Stocks Reports Reduction in the percentage of species classified as undefined in the national Status of Key Australian Fish Stocks Reports Page 19 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Expanded capacity to connect with seafood consumers and markets in Australia and abroad and use of these channels to understand community perceptions and to tell the Australian fishing and aquaculture story. Targets: Community attitudes to fishing and aquaculture are more positive based on an awareness of Australian seafood’s sustainability credentials. Number of species in the national Status of Key Australian Fish Stocks Reports increases to include 200 species The number of species classified as ‘undefined’ is reduced from the approximately 30 per cent currently down to less than 10 per cent Positive perceptions of the commercial fishing industry increase from 28 per cent to 40 per cent of the Australian public by 2020. Improved productivity and profitability Aim: By 2020, productivity and profitability of fishing and aquaculture are on an upward trajectory while still ensuring environmental sustainability. Strategy: Fund RD&E to understand profitability factors in fishing and aquaculture, link this to business education, and encompass the needs of Indigenous communities. Deliverables: Strategic market intelligence and knowledge to improve market access RD&E on energy efficiency and waste mitigation RD&E that demonstrates how to use underutilised and undervalued species sustainably Case studies to understand barriers and obstacles to measuring productivity and profitability. Targets: Continual increase in the production and profits from Australian fishing and aquaculture products. Industry is more resilient and adaptable. Environmentally sustainable increase in profits and production in fishing and aquaculture: o Volume of aquaculture production rises to more than 100,000 tonnes o The value of Australia’s fishing and aquaculture increases by 20 per cent (from $2.4 billion to $3.2 billion). Development of emerging aquaculture opportunities Aim: By 2020, develop at least two emerging aquaculture opportunities to the point of significant commercialisation, with profitable business operations. Strategy: Identify obstacles to growing the industry – such as potential markets, cost of production, survival, deformities and uniformity of growth – and invest in outcomes that make the commercial activity more competitive. Potential species include Yellowtail Kingfish. Deliverables: Improved hatchery production technologies Improved feeds Page 20 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Removal of barriers to aquaculture development Improved husbandry Improved health systems Targets: There are 2 – 3 emerging aquaculture species that are seeing good productivity and profitability growth. NATIONAL INITIATIVES There are also the following specific national initiatives that the FRDC will lead through preestablished projects, subprograms and coordination programs. Aquatic animal health and biosecurity Aquatic animal health and biosecurity continues to be a focus area for fishing and aquaculture RD&E. The FRDC will continue a subprogram dedicated to this area to ensure that adequate RD&E is occurring to protect fishing and aquaculture from disease and biosecurity related issues within Australia. Deliverables: Improved knowledge of the biology of disease agents, including epizootiology, taxonomy of pathogens, pathophysiology and histology. Key diseases include: o taxonomy of Bonamia species and its relationship to B. exitiosa and B. ostreae o identification of the aetiological agent of oyster oedema disease. Development of highly sensitive/specific and validated diagnostic tests for significant enzootic, exotic, new and emerging diseases of aquatic animals in Australia Specific and sensitive molecular diagnostic tests developed for the newly identified aetiological agent of oyster oedema disease. Recreational fishing FRDC’s recreational fishing subprogram, Recfishing Research, will continue under this RD&E Plan. The priority areas of research for the recreational sector include: community support access sustainable fisheries improvement in the experiential return from recreational fishing safety providing information to fisheries management education, knowledge and adoption health and wellbeing benefits. Deliverables: Better data on recreational fishing is available o The economic value of recreational fishing in Australia is quantified o The social impact of recreational fishing on Australian communities is better understood, including clarification of health and wellbeing benefits Page 21 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 o Catch and effort levels of Australia’s recreational fishing community are quantified on appropriate spatial and temporal scales An increased proportion of Australia’s recreational fishing community are actively engaged in improving the quality of fishing opportunities through fish habitat enhancement The rights and responsibilities of Australia’s recreational fishing community are more clearly defined and strengthened within fisheries legislation A long-term national funding model for recreational fishing RD&E and management in Australia is developed and agreed upon. Indigenous fishing and aquaculture Indigenous Australians have strong customary ties to fishing and aspire to rights, recognition, participation and service provision within, and to, fishing and aquaculture. The FRDC funds research on priority areas of RD&E for Indigenous people through the Indigenous Reference Group (IRG) subprogram. The IRG has examined the aspirations for Indigenous fishing and aquaculture. The key issues are: primacy for Indigenous Australians acknowledgement of Indigenous Customary Practices self-determination of Indigenous rights to use and manage culture assets and resources economic development opportunities arising from Indigenous Australians’ customary assets and associated rights enhanced capacity building opportunities for Indigenous Australians. Deliverables: All FRDC projects consider the relevance to Indigenous Australians and addresses this during the project and in reporting, as appropriate Knowledge and understanding of size, scale and nature of Indigenous fishing improves. People development Having strong leadership capacity will lead to strong fishing and aquaculture communities that are productive and profitable and resilient to change, and people development remains an important focus for RD&E. Long-standing projects include the National Seafood Industry Leadership Program and funding participants to the Australian Rural Leadership program. Within this plan, the FRDC will develop opportunities for industry to collaborate or co-invest in people development projects to ensure continued capacity building for fishing and aquaculture. Deliverable: Continue to invest in leadership capacity building Co-invest with partners in other areas of capacity building Invest with universities in students to study marine-science-specific topics relevant to the FRDC’s stakeholders Collection of data to better understand the training needs for fishing and aquaculture. Page 22 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Social sciences and economics The FRDC initiated the Social Sciences and Economics Coordination Program in 2009 to address the limited understanding around the social aspects of the fishing and aquaculture industry. The response to this program has encouraged its continued funding. The program’s focus includes fisheries management, change management, community perceptions, the adoption of RD&E and the ability of industry to adapt to change. Research generally focuses on how individuals, businesses, groups or sectors interact within the broader community and regional industries. Deliverable: Increased knowledge about how community values align with the value of Australian fishing and aquaculture sectors, with the aim of improving community perceptions Increased involvement of social scientists and economists in fisheries RD&E Improved integration of social and economic research tools and frameworks with biological approaches to support fisheries assessment and decision-making Social and economic components of fisheries are more explicitly accounted for in management objectives for and performance indicators Fishing and aquaculture leaders and organisations are aware of the major research findings and tools available to inform and address the social acceptability of Australian seafood Improved understanding of the social and economic challenges facing fishing and aquaculture in Australia, with the skills available to meet those challenges. Delivery of key services The FRDC has invested in the development of services to support fishing and aquaculture on important issues, from data to facilitate international trade, to the creation of relevant fisheries-based Australian Standards. As part of this RD&E plan the Corporation will continue to provide these services, with new cost-effective operating models being developed that will allow the provision of expanded services. Continuing activities include those related to standards, auditing and trade. Changes to the FRDC’s enabling legislation now make it possible for the Corporation to engage in marketing activities that include promoting Australia’s seafood products, recreational fishing and worldleading management practices. In the future, the FRDC will also focus on a more integrated IT platform that allows for more efficient use of the Corporations stock of electronically held records and data to help streamline program activities, from management and reporting to communications and marketing. Deliverable: The FRDC maintains accreditation to develop Australian Standards Delivery of trade market access data Continuation of the SafeFish program Delivery of fisheries data and statistics. “A key activity for the FRDC is to identify gaps in the industry data and knowledge to inform industry end users. Information and data should be the foundation for all marketing Page 23 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 activities. Without it, stakeholders are flying blind when it comes to their investment in marketing.” – FRDC manager for communications, trade and marketing, Peter Horvat Page 24 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 IMPLEMENTING THE FRDC RD&E PLAN FRDC’s will invest in RD&E using the following three processes. Lead The FRDC will lead RD&E prioritisation and investment in three national priority areas as well as six national initiatives. These priorities/initiatives are designed to deliver RD&E with ‘public good’ aspects and will, therefore, be funded from the Australian Government’s ‘public good component’ of FRDC revenue. Partner Under partnership agreements the FRDC gives autonomy to some sectors and regions to form their own RD&E priorities. Under these agreements, the Corporation will work with sectors and regions to set out the guidelines, timelines and evaluation processes, from funding application to adoption of RD&E outputs. This will help to link the sector-based or regional plans with the FRDC’s RD&E Plan, and ensure they incorporate the objectives of the PIRD Act. Further information on partnership agreements is available in the FRDC’s investment framework policy. Funding for these activities involves the combination from that sector/region coupled with the matching funding from the Australian Government contribution. Collaborate The collaboration element of the RD&E Plan provides a vehicle whereby sectors or regions may leverage funding from the national priorities or national initiatives if there is alignment with the sectors’ own priorities. This encourages sectors to collaborate with each other. In addition, the FRDC encourages sectors and regions to collaborate in specific areas of RD&E such as people development, service functions and social sciences. THE FRDC RD&E PROGRAM AREAS The FRDC has five broad programs of RD&E investment that directly align with its governing legislation, the Primary Industry Research and Development Act 1989: environment industry communities people extension. The FRDC will assess and model its RD&E investments based on these program areas to ensure a balanced portfolio is maintained to meet the long and short-term needs of stakeholders, including the Australian community. Environment Relates to research that provides outputs to underpin natural resource sustainability in managing the fishing and aquaculture activities Commonwealth, state and territory waters. Many components of RD&E undertaken by the FRDC focus on improving the sustainable use of Australia’s aquatic resources. Page 25 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Industry Relates to RD&E outputs that assist the production and the value of seafood. This could come in the form of business profitability, international competitiveness, opportunities for productivity increases, resource access, experience or wellbeing benefits depending on the sector. This program aims to assist all sectors improve their overall performance. Communities Relates to research outputs that maintain the long-term sustainability (triple bottom line) of the fishing industry by understanding the interactions and co-dependence between the community and fishing/aquaculture. This program is underpinned by the knowledge about the social importance of fisheries. People Relates to outputs needed to continue to attract and develop people who will take the industry forward, towards a sustainable and profitable future. The FRDC has taken a strong role in supporting people development, from employing and developing young researchers, through to facilitating access to leadership development for all levels of industry. Extension Relates to the delivery of project outputs in ways that allow easy adoption and support stakeholder decision-making and practices. The FRDC continually works with researchers and end users to determine and implement the most effective way of extending results. In addition, the FRDC is continuing to develop its systems to ensure that its ‘knowledge bank’ is easily accessible. Page 26 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 WHO WILL LEAD The FRDC in conjunction with national bodies and structures takes the lead in this area A sector or region will collaborate with another or bid for additional funding to achieve common priorities Sectors and regions have control over setting their priorities. Proposals then come to the FRDC and are reviewed through the normal process as per the investment framework policy Figure 4 The ’what, how and who’ for the FRDC RD&E Plan 2015–20, including the link to the FRDC program areas. Page 27 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 A BALANCED RESEARCH PORTFOLIO Most FRDC investment in RD&E is driven by stakeholder needs. This RD&E Plan seeks to be more targeted in three major areas, delivering against strategic national priorities. Sector and regions also have autonomy in setting their own RD&E priorities; although these must balance across the FRDC’s program areas. The FRDC also works to balance its RD&E portfolio including: national, regional and sector-focused projects long and short-term project timelines low and high risk projects tactical and strategic initiates blue sky and applied projects domestic and international relevance. APPLYING FOR FUNDING The FRDC investment framework policy details the mechanisms and processes involved in RD&E investment. This includes how to apply for funding and the requirement for Partnership Agreements. More detail can be found in the FRDC investment framework policy and on the FRDC website. EXTENSION AND ADOPTION OF RESEARCH OUTPUTS The FRDC ensures that extension and adoption processes are embedded into all of the research and development which it funds. The process that the FRDC follows to ensure results are extended and adopted is to build in the consideration of extension throughout the entire project process. This includes from the point of deciding on priorities to the end users involved, through the design and proposal phase, as well as execution of the project, and through to the finalisation of reports. This is often easier for short term applied research but does need to be more considered for blue sky longer term research. Within the project management process the FRDC follows it ensures that results are delivered in a timely manner and that extension and adoption processes are conducted within projects. Page 28 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 COLLABORATION WITHIN THE NATIONAL RESEARCH FRAMEWORK Where possible, the FRDC collaborates with other primary industry Research Development Corporations (RDCs) through the National Primary Industries RD&E Framework. The National Framework consists of 14 sector-based strategies and eight cross-sector strategies. FRDC is a member of the Council of Rural Research and Development Corporations and actively engages in this forum. As with many of the other RDCs, the FRDC is continually looking for opportunities to collaborate on RD&E of benefit to multiple primary industries. AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT PRIORITIES Figure 5 shows how the FRDC RD&E Plan national priority areas link to the Australian strategic research priorities and the national rural R&D priorities. Note that the people development priority does not directly align with Australia’s Science and Research Priority areas but there is what is termed a cross-cutting issue in these Science and Research priorities which deals with ensuring a dynamic and skilled research workforce. The FRDC takes great care to ensure the most efficient and effective links are developed across RD&E for fishing and aquaculture. The objectives of the PIRD Act provide the basis of the FRDC’s outcome statement – its reason for being – but there are other key planning documents that also contain relevant research priorities such as: Australian Government Strategic Research Priorities; Rural R&D Priorities; The National Marine Science Plan; The National Primary Industries RD&E Framework – National Fishing and Aquaculture RD&E Strategy; Partnership Agreement Strategic Research Plans (for industry sectors and Fisheries Research Advisory Boards); FRDC subprogram plans; and Department of Agriculture’s AQUAPLAN 2014–2019. Page 29 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 ALIGNED RESEARCH PRIORITIES Structurally, the National Marine Science Plan is the key planning document for marine science in Australia. However, the National Fishing and Aquaculture RD&E Strategy 201520 incorporates research priorities and themes from the National Marine Science Plan and aligns with that plan. In turn, the FRDC’s RD&E Plan aligns with the research priorities and themes of the fishing and aquaculture strategy. The FRDC has been a major contributor to National Fishing and Aquaculture RD&E Strategy. Aligning the FRDC RD&E Plan with the fishing and aquaculture strategy allows the Corporation to minimise duplication. The FRDC can support the delivery of relevant objectives and assess opportunities to provide leadership or address RD&E gaps. The FRDC will link strongly with national initiatives, such as those in the Fishing and Aquaculture Strategy to establish major and supporting research services. The Corporation will draw on international research expertise and outputs where these are relevant, to minimise duplication, and maximise efficiency and develop partnerships with the potential to increase returns for stakeholders. Page 30 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 EVALUATION FRAMEWORK While each measure is summarised here, the FRDC is required to report on its performance annually. These annual reports provide a snapshot for how the corporation is working towards the aims and targets of this RD&E Plan. Table 1 For each of the three national priority areas the FRDC has set targets to track how they are progressing through the life of the RD&E Plan. Aim Target 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 By 2020, the community has greater access to, and understanding of, RD&E that underpins fishing and aquaculture sustainability, which informs perceptions of Australian seafood Number of species in the national status of key fish stocks report increases to include 200 species 114 160 200 The number of species classified as ‘undefined’ is reduced from the approximately 30% currently down to less than 10% ~30% ~20% <10% Perception of the commercial fishing industry increased from 30% to 40% by 2020. 28% 30% 34% 36% 40% By 2020, productivity and profitability of fishing and aquaculture are on an upward trajectory while still ensuring environmental sustainability Volume of aquaculture rises to above 100,000 tonnes. 85,000 90,000 95,000 100,000 110,000 The value of Australia’s fishing and aquaculture increases by 20% ($2.4 billion to $2.8 billion). 2.4 2.5 2.7 2.9 3.2 By 2020, develop at least two aquaculture opportunities to the point of significant commercialisation with profitable business operations There are 2 – 3 new aquaculture species that are seeing good productivity and profitability growth as measured by an increase in tonnage from other species 2,000 2,800 3,200 3,600 4,000 Page 31 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 FUNDING AND EXPENDITURE Table 2 FRDC financial income and expenditure planning 2015 – 2020 2015-16 REVENUE Revenue from Australian Government Contributions Other Total revenue EXPENSES Programs: Environment Industry devleopment People development Communities Extension and adoption Total programs expenditure Management and accountability Total expenses 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 $19,244,243 $20,206,455 $21,216,778 $22,277,617 $23,391,498 $7,850,128 $8,242,634 $8,654,766 $9,087,504 $9,541,880 $1,267,000 $1,330,350 $1,396,868 $1,466,711 $1,540,046 $28,361,371 $29,779,440 $31,268,412 $32,831,832 $34,473,424 $9,715,466 $9,715,466 $2,428,867 $485,773 $2,268,910 $24,288,665 $4,072,706 $28,361,371 $10,164,976 $10,164,976 $2,541,244 $508,249 $2,382,355 $25,412,440 $4,367,000 $29,779,440 $10,641,765 $10,641,765 $2,660,441 $532,088 $2,501,473 $26,604,412 $4,664,000 $31,268,412 $11,165,933 $11,165,933 $2,791,483 $558,297 $2,626,547 $27,914,832 $4,917,000 $32,831,832 $11,708,170 $11,708,170 $2,927,042 $585,408 $2,757,874 $29,270,424 $5,203,000 $34,473,424 Page 32 Fisheries Research Development and Extension Plan 2015–20 Table 3 allocation of funding across the strategic investment areas, strategic priorities, national initiatives and the partnership agreements Activity view of expendituare 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 Existing contracts, plus recommended approvals $ 15,588,665 $ 12,162,440 $ 7,104,412 $ 3,064,832 $ 2,020,424 for 2015 round (using forecast date)* National Priorities $ 1,600,000 $ 1,600,000 $ 2,300,000 $ 3,600,000 $ 5,000,000 National Initiativess $ 1,000,000 $ 1,400,000 $ 2,700,000 $ 3,300,000 $ 3,300,000 Response Fund+ Partnership Agreements (sectors) Partnership Agreements (regions) Total programs expenditure $ 1,500,000 $ 4,500,000 $ 100,000 $ 24,288,665 $ 1,500,000 $ 6,200,000 $ 2,550,000 $ 25,412,440 $ 1,500,000 $ 8,000,000 $ 5,000,000 $ 26,604,412 $ 1,500,000 $ 9,000,000 $ 7,450,000 $ 27,914,832 $ 1,500,000 $ 10,000,000 $ 7,450,000 $ 29,270,424 * note that there are existing contracts for RD&E, this funding is mostly from the sector and region partnership agreement line items. + the response fund is to conduct urgent RD&E needs outside of other funding processes. Page 33