20 August 2009 Impact of the financial crisis in Lesotho As many other developing countries, also Lesotho has been affected by the global economic and financial crisis. There are several factors that make Lesotho exceedingly vulnerable to the current global situation. Firstly, Lesotho’s government revenue, as well as country’s foreign reserves, is highly dependent on Southern African Customs Union (SACU) revenue pool, which accounted for about 60 per cent of government revenue in 2008. SACU revenues are a direct result of imports into the sub-region. According to the South African Revenue Service (SARS) the imports in the area diminished 19.8% from March 2009 to April 2009, indicating a decline in these revenues. It has been estimated that the SACU revenues for Lesotho will decline by 37.7 per cent in 2009/2010 (including a repayment to the pool), and further by 11.2 per cent in 2010/2011 due to the decline in imports in the area. Secondly, both the nation and individual households remain highly exposed to the economic changes in developed countries. The South African mining sector has been the third largest employer of Lesotho’s labor force, consisting mainly of rural workers. There have been 53,000-54,000 Basotho people working in South African mines annually and the remittances contributed 28% of the country’s GDP, equaling USD 371 million in 2007. It is estimated that remittances in Sub Saharan Africa will decline by 8.3-11.6% this year, which is more than the global average. The statistics show that the number of Basotho workers employed at the mining sector in South Africa has been declining since Q3 2007, mainly due to the falling gold and platinum prices. In 2009 gold and platinum prices have been moderately increasing again, but the production rates remain lower compared to the previous year. According to the Central Bank of Lesotho, the remittances diminished from M871 million in Q3 2008 to M860 million in Q4 2008, and further to M833 million during the Q1 in 2009 (the average exchange rate has been between 8 and 10 maloti to USD in 2009). In January it was estimated that up to 14,000 employees will face redundancy in the industry. As migrant workers are retrenched, many have to depend on increasingly unpredictable agricultural outputs as sources of income. Thirdly, a slowdown in the developed countries affects Lesotho’s exports. The main export destination in 2007 was North America with a share of 47 per cent. Exports to the European Union totaled 21 per cent and SACU area almost 30 per cent. It is expected that both exports and imports decline in 2009 and start recuperating in 2010 again. (Table 1) Table 1: Economic Indicators1 2007a 2008b 2009c 2010c Real GDP growth (%) 4.8b 6.8 -2 2.8 Exports of goods (fob USD bn) 0.8 1 0.8 0.9 Imports of goods (fob USD bn) 1.6 1.9 1.6 1.7 a Actual, b EIU estimate, c EIU forecast Lesotho’s exports to the U.S. declined by almost USD 69 million from 2007 to 2008 and further decline in 2009 can be expected. Exports from January to June 2009 were USD 39 million less than the year before. (Table 2) 1 Economist Intelligence Unit 20 August 2009 Table 2: Lesotho’s exports to the United States (USD)2 2006 2007 2008 2008* 2009* Textiles and apparel exports 387 242 000 383 568 000 339 757 000 155 202 000 122 265 000 Minerals and metals exports 20 026 000 52 385 000 30 592 000 16 229 000 9 898 000 408 407 000 443 018 000 374 098 000 172 777 000 134 000 000 All sectors exports * January-June The economic slowdown and its impact on Lesotho’s exports have been resulting to retrenching workers in Lesotho, especially in the clothing and textile sector. Previously manufacturing has been contributing about 50 per cent to the total employment, providing jobs to about 48,000 Basotho, of which approximately 45,000 have been female. It has been estimated that the situation endangers indirectly the income of over 200,000 people dependent on the patronage of the people working in the textile sector. In addition, declining global demand of diamonds (Europe being the main market) had an enormous impact on Lesotho’s mining sector and the exports of diamonds fell by 65.5 per cent in the fourth quarter of 2008 forcing mining sector to scale down its operations. In addition to the falling prices access to trade financing is constrained and two mines had to suspend their operations during the second half of 2008 partly due to credit unavailability. As unemployment grows in the country (previously it has been over 40 per cent) it leads to diminishing purchasing power, lower consumption, and lower income tax and VAT collections. As a result of the global economic crisis and its impact on Lesotho, the government has been prepared to increase public spending and cut taxes in the short to medium term. It is planned that a stimulus fund of M600 million is set aside for boosting economic growth during the next two years and in order to protect the vulnerable. Furthermore, the Government has planned to implement structural reforms to creating a conductive and competitive investment climate; restructuring the textile and clothing industry and creating institutional and financial facilities to support export-import businesses and diversifying new export products; providing monetary support for specific new investments, feasibility studies and SME start-ups; protecting workers currently employed, and allocating funds to projects that use the services of the unemployed across all ten districts. These measures would lead to fiscal deficits in the short and medium term and the Government has received push back from the IMF during the Spring sessions as a result of which the budget is being revised downward. Table 3: Key Fiscal Variables (% of GDP)3 2005/06 5006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 Revenue & Grants 51.1 60.7 58.7 59.2 62.2 48.5 53 Total Expenditure 46.6 47.4 47.3 49.9 64.4 62.4 61.1 Overall Balance 4.5 13.3 11.3 9.2 -2.2 -13.9 -8.2 Primary Balance 6.8 16.2 13.7 10.1 -1.2 -13.2 -7.6 At current rates, unless checked, these drivers of vulnerability, coupled with the effects of rising food prices globally, are likely to intensify rural poverty and destitution. These results will arise from the increasing inability of households to generate enough resources to satisfy their basic needs. Given the many and important roles 2 3 United States International Trade Commission CBL Economic Review March 2009 20 August 2009 women and girls play (as de facto household heads, caregivers in HIV-affected households, and bread-winners in the face of increasing HIV death-related orphanhood), the increased poverty and destitution will be more preponderantly borne by females, thus negatively impacting the MDGs. Sources: Central Bank of Lesotho, Quarterly Review September 2008 Central Bank of Lesotho, Economic Review January 2009 Central Bank of Lesotho, Economic Review February 2009 Central Bank of Lesotho, Economic Review March 2009 United States International Trade Commission World Bank Migration and Development Brief, July 13, 2009 IMF, The Implications of the Global Financial Crisis for Low Income Countries South African Revenue Service The Economist Intelligence Unit, Country Report Lesotho 2009 The World Bank, Migration and Remittances Factbook 2008 Goldprice.org Platinumprice.org Chamber of Mines of South Africa South Africa Mining Report Q1 2009, Business Monitor International