Chapter 3 1916 ‘More Men Wanted’ ‘The New Year holidays were marked by very severe weather conditions. In the evenings especially the gale was violent, and was accompanied by heavy showers of rain. People returning from the city at night had to face a blizzard of wind and rain, and where they had some distance to go before reaching home they had a most trying experience. The unsettled weather continued throughout the holidays.’ The weather readily reflected the atmosphere in the village and in the country at large at the start of 1916. From the pulpit of the parish church the Rev Anderson felt the need to remind villagers why the war was being fought. “The German wolf has been trying to fix the blame of this war on Great Britain, France, Russia or anyone else who may serve her purpose ... Belgium was neutral, but what is neutrality to the German warlords?” The funeral of a local soldier who died in a London hospital, Robert Boyd of Mossend, took place in the village in late January and the Rev Anderson again used the opportunity to remind local people about their duty. Corporal Boyd had been home on furlough from France during the Christmas that had just gone. On returning to London he took ill and died in hospital from pneumonia. Much organisation went into his funeral on Tuesday, January the 18th. It was an impressive affair, as much for the benefit of villagers as for his relatives. Members of the ‘Hope of West Calder’ Tent of Rechabites, of which Corporal Boyd was a member, walked in front of the hearse. Following the hearse came a party of soldiers from the Highland Light Infantry, his relatives and ‘members of all classes in the community’. Large crowds gathered at the side of the road to watch the funeral procession pass. At the cemetery soldiers carried the coffin shoulder high to the grave. There followed a very moving ceremony, conducted by the Rev Anderson at the graveside. The following Sunday, referring to the sacrifice made by Corporal Boyd, the Rev Anderson said that “One of the most remarkable things about the present war, one of the glories that swim up through all its horrors and atrocities, and for the moment submerges them, is the courage which is manifested not merely by the saint or hero, but by just the average ordinary man.” Corporal Boyd was just such a man. “They have gone out from our shops and offices, from our factories and farms, and mines and they are just the kind of men you and I are accustomed to meet from day to day in our common life and all for the cause of King and Country.” The message was quite clear. It was the duty of all - man, woman and child to work towards the war effort and the defeat of Germany. After the failures of 1915, a great many in the country at large were dissatisfied with the conduct of the war and the editor of the Advertiser was amongst those calling for calm. “Those who have the welfare of their country at heart ought to strive to steady public opinion at this time. We are face to face with a crisis within our own borders which calls for delicate handling. The London Press must not be mistaken for the voice of the nation. This section of the press has been proved to be wrong again and again, but it is constantly embarrassing those who have the responsible task of conducting the war. We want to replace their sensationalism by a calm and sober attitude towards the great questions that are evolving.” “France - usually an emotional nation - is giving us a worthy lead in the manner in which she is sinking all lesser differences and bending all her energies to win the war. If our politicians could only be given a six months holiday, and a firm grip be placed on the London journals, Lord Kitchener and General Joffre would be in a much stronger position to secure a speedy peace. The mixing of politics and war is the surest way to lose. Our men in Flanders and in other fields will read of our squabbling with heavy hearts, and they may well be forgiven if the thought gets uppermost that we are unworthy of the terrible sacrifices they are making” Even as the editor penned this message, the influence of Kitchener was on the wane. Had he not been held up in the press as a national hero and the saviour of the country, it is doubtful that he would have remained in post much longer. The Gallipoli Campaign had been recognised as a costly failure and by January 6th all Empire troops had been removed from that theatre of war in an expertly executed withdrawal. It was March before villagers could read about the evacuation in a detailed letter from Corporal Robert Pratt from the village, which summed up the success and failure of the expedition. “I had lost everything I possessed except what was on my back, but that was a matter of little moment. We had made a wonderful evacuation - the possibility of which at one time we had doubted - and I was alive to tell the tale.” As it was, Douglas Haig was now Commander-in-Chief on the Western Front and it was his decisions that were to lead to a campaign that is still debated amongst historians and one which had a devastating impact on the village and district. Throughout 1916 there was a continual demand for more men for the army. In certain quarters in the village there was an almost pathological concern about the young men who had not yet signed up. Lord Derby’s Scheme was deemed to have been unsuccessful. “From the Police Office, armlets have been issued to the local men who have attested under Lord Derby’s Scheme. The men seem shy to wear them however, as very few have so far been seen.” The answer to this was the Military Service Bill, which would bring in conscription. As the bill made its way through parliament, there was opposition to it in the village. On January 15th, a lecture on ‘Militarism’ had been delivered at the Masonic Hall, the result of which it was reported that those present had taken a vote and agreed to do all in their power to oppose the Bill. They were against ‘compulsion’ of any kind. There was an immediate outcry, with letters to the press accusing the Independent Labour Party, Socialists and members of the trade union movement of being unpatriotic and leading a conspiracy against the good of the country. ‘Sir, In last weeks paper I saw a letter which stated that the working men of West Calder had met in the Masonic Hall and passed a resolution protesting against and resolving to oppose the Military Service Bill. This really is throwing a slur on the workingmen of West Calder. It was only a mere handful of members of the ILP who did so. The bulk of the young workingmen of West Calder are in the trenches or preparing themselves for the fight of liberty. The young men who are not away would be better occupied getting into uniform than passing such resolutions. In any case they have good reason to keep quiet and keep out of sight just now. It is only indispensable men we need at home right now. Patriot.” “Sir. If I take it that this meeting considers itself representative of the working men of West Calder, then it means that West Calder has made its mind up, that come what may in this war, victory or defeat it is determined to oppose the sending or calling up of any further supply of eligible men to the army. It is going to put a premium on the man who refuses what he, being a citizen of Empire, ought to be proud to do, that is to take his share in his country’s battles. It is going to leave undone the work commenced by the village lads who have fallen (and they are not a few).” The writer goes on to accuse the workingmen of West Calder of being crushed by trade unionism, ‘They object not to being forced to join a Union, but refuse to fight for their country.’ The debate raged on with little effect. The Military Service Bill became law on February 10th. The Act stated that all males, aged 18 to 41, who were unmarried or a widower without any dependant children, were deemed to have enlisted for the period of the war and would be transferred to the reserve. ‘If a man considers he should be exempt, he can apply for an exemption certificate.’ Exemption could be granted if his work at home was in the national interest; or he suffered from ill health; his business would suffer through his absence or he was a conscientious objector. Local tribunals were to be set up to hear appeals. “At the Bathgate tribunal, Hugh Currie, City Farm, was granted conditional exemption for his ploughman, but the appeal on behalf of his byreman, John Smith, was refused. Mr Currie stated that he farmed 216 acres and the two men were his only male helpers.” “David Millar, Auchinhard Farm, West Calder, appealed for his son David, who owing to the appellants ill health, was the manager of the farm. A doctor’s certificate was produced, certifying the correctness of the statement regarding illness. The farm extended to 60 acres, and the son was the only one employed on the farm. Appellant had a son serving in the army. Conditional exemption was granted.” “James Philip, photographer, West Calder, appealed on business grounds against the decision of the tribunal, but the appeal was dismissed. The passing of the Military Service Act did not see an end to concerns over young men who were avoiding their duty. In May the Advertiser was of the opinion that “Hundreds of young men are skulking down our pits in order to escape the operations of the Military Service Act, whose previous experience of coal getting was an occasional trip to the domestic cellar to replenish the household fires.” In June two arrests were made in village of young men who had contravened the Military Service Act and not reported for enlistment. In August, Andrew Dowie, of Main St, a conscientious objector, appeared at Edinburgh Sheriff Court. He was charged with having failed to report when called. He was fined 40 shillings or 7 days imprisonment and handed over to the military authorities. By mid August, all young men of 18 and above were being called up, with the pledge that they would not serve abroad until the age of 19, a promise that was later broken. In early September “a circular letter issued by the Local Government board to local and appeal tribunals states that the Army Council are anxious that all outstanding applications or appeals for exemption should be dealt with in the next few weeks. Tribunals are reminded that ‘the immediate need of the army is very great’ and that ‘exemption should not be granted in any case unless it is quite clearly justified.’ Why this constant need for men? There is no doubt that up until July of 1916, despite its losses, the parish had ‘got of’ relatively lightly in terms of dead, missing or wounded. In early February there were rousing scenes at Harwood Church when a lecture was delivered describing ‘Three Months in France with the Boys in Khaki.’ The Advertiser felt able to explain to the Germans why they had cause for worry and also reassure the village that our lads at the front ‘had never had it so good’. “I wonder if the Germans really know how the people of this country are getting themselves down to the war. They know what our soldiers are capable of, they stand in mortal dread of our fleet, they realise we are piling up munitions for ourselves and our allies; but I doubt if they realise the hold the war spirit has on the people here at home from the highest to the lowest.” ‘Some of our boys have recently been home on leave. They tell us that there has been a great improvement in our trenches and supplies reaching the soldiers there. All are well fed and well clothed.’ The first blow to this confidence came with the death of Kitchener. He was drowned on June 5th while on a mission to Russia, when the cruiser HMS Hampshire struck a mine of Orkney. Despite being unpopular amongst his colleagues, Kitchener was popular in the country. His finger-pointing poster, declaring ‘Your country needs YOU’ could be found through out the village. In August, villagers were given the opportunity to help the war effort and obtain a memento of the great man. ‘Messrs Raphael, Tuck and Son are issuing a beautiful facsimile of Lord Kitchener’s memorable letter in which the great soldier called for a further 300 000 men. It will be remembered that the original was sold for £6000. It was his call which brought into being our great army.’ It was this ‘great army’ that was to be sent into battle by General Haig and suffer the worst losses in the history of the British army. Under Haig the full effort of the British Army was to be concentrated on defeating the Germans on the Western Front. In an attempt to break the stalemate of trench warfare, the Germans had launched an attack against the French at Verdun. Verdun had no strategic value, but its loss would have been catastrophic to morale in France. The French knew that despite horrendous casualties they had to hold on to it at all costs. In order to relieve pressure on the French, Haig agreed to launch an attack upon the Germans, on the 1st of July, on the Somme. The Somme offensive or ‘Big Push’ saw the first major use of Kitchener’s volunteer army. On July 1st it suffered over 57 000 casualties. Historians still argue about the Somme and the events surrounding it. Whatever the arguments, from late July onwards the pages of the Advertiser carry long lists of casualties and the impact of the war was for the first time brought home with a vengeance to the people of West Calder. A typical example of losses can be found in the August 18th edition of the Advertiser. ‘The following are the names of local and district soldiers appearing in the official casualty lists this week: Soldiers killed: Segt.-Major Pte Pte Pte Cranston Newton Ross Harkins Bathgate East Calder Shotts Uphall Died of Wounds: Pte Campbell Linlithgow Tonner Eadmonstone Oates McNair Wright Wynne Flaherty Tinley Hall Duffy Pender McCartney Lee Anderson West Calder Whitburn Blackburn Bathgate Harwood Balerno West Calder West Calder Linlithgow West Calder Blackburn Shotts Addiewell Blackburn Wounded: Pte Pte Pte Pte Pte Pte Pte Pte Driver Pte Pte Pte Crprl Pte Pte Pte Pte Pte Blaney Crow Montgomery McFarlane Broxburn Mid Calder Davidson’s Mains Davdson’s Mains There are 22 further names on the list and this one was by no means the longest to appear in the newspaper. Despite the losses, the message from the front and from the Advertiser remained positive and enthusiastic. It is no wonder, that when the ‘truth’ finally made its way into print in the 1920s, many ordinary people lost faith in ‘King and Country’. ‘If ever the German High Command deluded themselves with the thought that our citizen soldiers were unequal to the European armies, they must have had a rude awakening since the offensive opened on July 1st. Our lads are simply splendid. No army in the world could have shown greater dash, courage or tenacity in holding on to the position after it was won. It is the British Empire that is over the parapet, as one writer said last week. Our army is composed of men from all ranks of life and from every country in the Empire.’ Writing home from the front on August 18th a local soldier says, ‘The spirit of our lads is excellent. They are encouraged by the progress of the combined British and French offensive. Though the advance does not look big on the map it has given our men the opportunity that they have so long waited for of showing that they are more than a match for the Hun’. ‘General Haig, it will be noticed, makes the interesting statement that we have since July 1st met and engaged on the Somme front 35 German divisions of which 29 have been defeated and withdrawn for rest and repairs. ... We have had at least 3 million men in front of us and of these at least three quarters have been destructively subjected to the most terrible artillery fire and the unceasing and successful attacks of our infantry. To suppose that Germany is in as good a shape as ever to resist our further attacks is ridiculous.’ One of the ‘fallen’ was Pte Charles Graham of the Royal Scots. He was buried where he was killed. The burial party mistakenly left his personal possessions at the side of the grave and his home address, save for the fact that he was a West Calder man, were lost. The possessions were sent to the Rev Anderson, who displayed them in the parish church. “When the photographs which had been found on the battlefield in France were being shown in the vestibule of the Parish Church, Mr Robert Graham, Front Street, Mossend, recognised one as the photograph of his son Pte Charles Graham of the Royal Scots. Pte Graham was married and had signed up straight away. He wrote home regularly. He had taken part on the big attack on July 1st and no news had been had of him since then.” The anxiety of the family was replaced by grief at the confirmation of their son’s death. The Rev Longden, the army chaplain who had sent the possessions and photographs, later wrote to the Rev Anderson. ‘My Dear Sir, I am glad to hear from you that the belongings I sent home have come into the hands of a relative of one of our brave lads, although I much regret that they should of necessity carry the proof of his death.’ The Rev Langden could offer no explanation to the disposal of the personal possessions at the side of the grave, but gave the reassurance that Pte Graham now rested with his friends and fellow soldiers nearby. “His people would no doubt like to know that he had fallen in the great advance at a point which is beyond the old German first line of trenches, so that before he fell he had succeeded in breaking through the line with the other gallant fellows and had his share in starting the route of our enemies, which will I trust before long end this terrible war.” As casualties mounted, a public meeting was held in the Polytechnic Hall to establish a parish fund to make awards to local soldiers who had won distinction on the battlefield and to discuss the setting up of a memorial for the fallen. The shale miners union met and agreed to set up a fund to help the relatives of those who had fallen and provide support for those who should return wounded. In August a letter was circulated to the local appeal tribunal by the government, stating that ‘the immediate need of the army is great’ and that exemption should not be granted unless it was quite clearly justified. At the same time, there were those who seemed to be working against the war effort! A great deal of distress was caused in the village by the theft of the Roll of Honour from the golf club. The crime had been carefully planned and the thief never apprehended. In the midst of the carnage at the front, the Advertiser published a letter from Sergeant Joseph Foster, of the 26th Brigade Machine Gun Company, whose home was at Gavieside, West Calder. “To the people of West Calder and District. This is an appeal from the trenches to help to keep the boys happy and bright, and to take their thoughts away from the scenes of the battlefield. While out for short rests, we have formed up a choir, or glee party, with some splendid singers. We have 20 just now on the roll, but the difficulty is that we need the music, sacred preferred.” It would take more than sacred music to defeat the Germans and Haig believed that he had a weapon that would make the turning point in the war. ‘September 22nd. Great British Advance. Splendid success against stubborn enemy fighting. Over 2,300 prisoners taken. News of the great success gained by the British on the Somme, in the greatest success since the opening of the big offensive, is contained in the following despatches from Sir Douglas Haig.’ ‘Friday, 12.50pm. Last night, the enemy’s trenches south-east of Thiepval, on a front of about 1000 yards, were captured by our troops.’ ‘This morning we attacked the enemy on a front extending from Bouleaux Wood to north of the Albert-Bapaume Road, a distance of about six miles. Our troops have advanced some 2000 to 3000 yards in places ... large numbers of prisoners taken ...In this attack we employed for the first time a new type of heavy armoured car, which has proved of considerable utility.’ The dispatch described the new secret weapon, the mysterious ‘tanks’ or ‘willies’ as the soldiers called them, that were about to win the war for us. In that first battle some were destroyed, many broke down and their value was mainly psychological. They could not yet be deployed in sufficient numbers to make any great difference. Back in West Calder, villagers were to witness the ‘big advance’ at first hand. ‘The official cinema picture of the Battle of the Somme, taken by permission of the War Office, will be exhibited at the local picture house on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday of next week. The film has occasioned much public interest and the demand for booked seats is phenomenal.’ The film had actually been shown to troops behind the front lines on the Somme and it was the first time that the British public had seen so much ‘live action’ from the Front. In many cinemas people fainted. ‘Picture-goers have been made familiar with the many brilliant battle scenes arranged for the camera for show purposes, and, as they watch the opening scenes of the Somme picture, they may be disposed to think it is not so spectacular as they had anticipated.’ ‘Soon, however, this feeling passes away, and it is recognised that the spectator is dealing with grim reality. It is one thing to read about the Somme enterprise, or to study its features on a map, and quite another to realise the stupendous nature of the undertaking by carefully watching this picture. Seeing it, one understands the imperative cry for munitions, and marvels at the efficiency and terrible destructiveness of modern engines of war.’ ‘One sees the British soldier calm and undaunted in the face of death, and in the brief respites of fighting, finding happiness in little things - cheerful in the most trying circumstances. Again, when the picture shows the wounded being brought in, the quick and considerate attention they receive, and mentally tries to realise the amount of suffering borne with patient heroism, sympathy goes out to those lads at the front in a way which creates the conviction that the nation cannot err on the side of doing too much for them.’ Large crowds queued to see the film in West Calder, although it was noted by those leaving the Picture House that ‘one specially noticeable feature was the absence of Scottish and Irish regiments.’ Did villagers understand the true nature of modern warfare as it was being fought on the Western Front? Despite the fact that news from abroad was censored and the Advertiser was positive even in the face of tremendous loss or defeat, there can be little doubt that there was no hiding from the grim realities of warfare on the home front. Apart from the lists of casualties that appeared in the local newspaper, there were also ‘realistic’ descriptions of fighting conditions. When local soldiers received awards for bravery, it is easy to ‘read between the lines’ and appreciate the nature of the work they were involved in. Lieutenant Rawlinson, a local man, was injured in righting a machine-gun that fouled. It took him a two-month stay in hospital to recover. Captain McVicar helped rescue twelve men who had almost been buried alive in a dugout when a shell exploded near them. In February, Alexander Greenhorn, a transport driver, returned home to tell the village about the destruction of the French countryside and its towns. In May, Private Easton was awarded the DCM for service in the Dardanelles. He was 19 years old and a former miner. His feats of courage included repairing a fouled machine-gun whilst under enemy fire. At one point a number of Turkish bodies lay decomposing close to the trench where he was fighting. They were a health hazard and he volunteered to crawl to them, douse them in petrol and set fire to them, thus eliminating the possibility of disease to our men. In June, Private William Marshall, who lost his right leg in the fighting, returned home to the village for good. His fighting days were effectively over. Wherever you look there are reminders of the war and none more so than in the sense of loss felt by ordinary families. A Bathgate family inserted the following tribute to their son in the ‘In Memoriam’ column of the Advertiser: He little thought when he left home That he would ne’er return Sad was the eve that brought the news Of his untimely fall His well-known form no more we’ll see Nor well-known voice we’ll hear; In life we loved you very dear, In death we do the same If proof were needed that this was a new type of warfare, it could be seen in the threat that was posed by Zeppelins. The perceived threat of such an attack was far greater than the reality, yet a kind of Zeppelin fever gripped the village and no doubt many believed that the local oil works would be high on the Kaiser’s list of targets. ‘Local arrangements have now been made with reference to darkening the village in the event of an air raid by Zeppelins. If the enemy aircraft should visit, the east of Scotland information will be telephoned to the Police Office. The electric lights on the streets will be at once switched off, and the gas supply will be shut off at the gas works. In the event of the gas supply being shut off, householders should at once see that their jets are turned off. The measures which are being taken are purely of a precautionary nature, and need not cause any alarm. At the same time it is important that the instructions be carefully carried out, and all prominent lights should be shaded at night.’ ‘The new lighting regulations may do something to save the people from air raids, but they will not improve the spirit of the people. The conditions in the village at night are positively melancholy. The only consolation we have is that the days are now lengthening and in a few weeks time we will not feel the restrictions so much.’ ‘If anything is calculated to bring the war home to us it is the state of the streets at night. Gross darkness now reigns everywhere. The villagers, in the full glare of the electric light and the well-lit shop windows, used to smile at a description of the darkened towns in England. It is our own turn now, and, needless to say, the experience is not a pleasant one at night. It takes a bit of ‘steering’ to negotiate a crossing when you have only sound to guide you. Matters are made worse if you are half-way across when the ‘toot’ of an approaching car comes out of the darkness, and you are at a loss to know which way it is going. The old German Count who invented ‘Zepps’ has much to answer for. But there is a compensating side to almost everything. The children have now to stop their games when darkness falls, and the streets are quiet an hour early.’ An air attack never happened, although ........ ‘On Tuesday evening several precautionary measures were taken against raids by aircraft. The gas pressure was reduced at the works as an indication to householders that Zeppelins were again visiting the Scottish coast. The special constables were assembled and ready for duty, but fortunately their services were not required, as the Zeppelins were never near the district. A large number of people were in the streets, evidently keen to get a sight of the raiders had they come this way. A passenger train was stopped at the station, and the passengers did not reach their destination until early next morning.’ Along with the lighting restrictions, by early April the ringing of church bells and the chiming of the village clock had fallen under a national ban as well. It is doubtful if anyone at the start of the war could have predicted the impact it would have on civilian life. By the end of 1916, there were very few areas of village life that had not been affected by some restriction or ban. Local farmers were under pressure to maximise the yields from their fields. ‘It said that in Germany last year every available piece of land went under the plough. We must do the same. The shortage of manpower is a problem. Some farmers are taking the plough themselves. All honour to them, they are ‘doing their bit’.’ The public were asked to restrict their use of sugar. By August the military were helping to collect the harvest and in November the government fixed the price of milk and warned that flour should not be hoarded. In May, the Daylight Saving Bill was introduced to increase farm production and villagers were reminded to put their clocks forward by an hour. A week later, on May 25th, the Advertiser was able to report that the daylight savings were more than popular amongst local workers. In October, shop-opening hours were restricted to a 7pm close on weekdays, 8pm on Fridays and 9pm on Saturday. There was an outcry when the local miners threatened strike action unless their wages rose. Some accused them of acting in an unpatriotic manner, but considering inflation their demands seem modest. In March the local collieries and mines passed into government control for the duration of the war. In July in the House of Commons it was reported that the estimated rise in food, clothing and rent over the period of the war was 16%. ‘In other words it would require today a sovereign to purchase what cost 17s 3d in March 1915 or 15s on March 1914.’ Even the Advertiser could not escape the effects of the war. As raw materials became scare it was forced to cut the size of the newspaper and raise its price. It was almost with a sense of shock that the editor advised readers that a charge would have to be made for the delivery of the newspaper and that it could only be supplied if ordered beforehand. Those choosing to escape the gloom of the village to Edinburgh or Glasgow for the day had to endure a restricted train service, partly due to the lack of manpower, and a rise in ticket prices. Some turned to other means of pleasure. ‘Last Saturday night when people were saddened by the news from the front, it was most unseemly to see so many drunk men on the village streets. We made some enquiry and found that a considerable number of those who were in this state come in every Saturday from outlying parts and get drunk. This is not a credit to the district or to the trade at a time such as this.’ It was in June however that it must really have occurred to those in the village that even if the war were to end soon, life would never be quite the same again! ‘A staff of young women were employed this week in West Calder as road makers. The streets were being given a fresh coat of tarmacadam, and the women did good work. In their overalls and dust caps they looked quite smart and business-like. Men could not be got for the work, and the road surveyor invited the services of women, and they responded pluckily. This is the first time we have had women as workers on the streets of the village.’ There was little to celebrate at the end of the year, apart from the fact that a new government was in place, led by Lloyd George. ‘Despite all that has happened during the past fortnight, the new government starts business with the good wishes of the country as a whole. Mr Lloyd George has the courage, energy and imagination to secure better results ... The year is closing with the European war still raging as fiercely as ever. Peace kites are being sent up from Germany.’ If Germany were asking for peace, then surely we must be winning and 1917 would be the last year of war! On reading this many in the village may have hoped that it would be a reality, but it is doubtful if many believed it would actually happen.