The Research Experience for Teachers Program http://www.cs.appstate.edu/ret Activity Title: Introduction to Projectile Motion Introduction/Motivation: The equations used to describe projectile motion are generally derived from the basic dvat equations for horizontal and vertical motion. More advanced equations using basic right triangle trigonometry and vectors provide a further analysis of projectile motion. Generally, students complete one word problem at a time, only using one small group of equations. Students rarely, if ever have any understanding of how objects undergoing projectile motion can be described in terms of changing velocity, mass, kinetic energy, gravitational potential energy, total mechanical energy and momentum during and objects motion. In this activity, you will be able to create basic formulas and analyze the meaning of graphs that have been previously prepared as part of the spreadsheet. Learning Objectives: You will be able to: Correctly input equations into Excel using constants, basic algebra and trigonometry functions Analyze graphs of projectile motion with concept of angle, range and altitude Analyze velocity and energy motion diagrams for projectile motion over a range of initial angles Materials List: You will need one computer per student with Microsoft Excel program Background: You should have your noted and basic equations regarding projectile motion with you during this practice. Pre-Assessment: 1. What happens to the kinetic energy in terms of horizontal velocity of projectiles in motion as the initial angle increases? 2. What happens to the kinetic energy in terms of the initial vertical velocity of projectiles in motion as the initial angle increases? 3. At what angle would a projectile have the maximum range? 4. At what angle would a projectile have the maximum height? 5. What relationship exists between the kinetic energy, gravitational energy, and total mechanical energy of a projectile at any angle? Lab Activity: Day 1 (1 – 1.5 hours) Projectile Motion: Basic 1. Open the spreadsheet labeled “ Projectile Motion.xlsx” in Excel. Start on the page that says Projectile Motion Basic at the bottom of the page. 2. Notice that all the cells are empty except for the angles in degrees and a section on the far right in the color blue. Do NOT change anything in the color blue. Projectile Motion Page 1 3. You will also notice that the graphs below the spreadsheet are blank. As you complete calculations in the spreadsheet, they will slowly fill in. 4. Make sure that you are beginning on the spreadsheet that is labeled “Projectile Motion – Basic” at the bottom. You will also notice that cell C5 should already have the number 0 for initial height, therefore the initial height of each of these projectiles is 0 meters. 5. In cell C9 type the number 10, therefore all of these projectiles will have an initial velocity of 6. 10 m/s. You will be able to change the initial velocity later. 7. In cell C12, change the mass of the projectile to 5, therefor the mass of this projectile is 5 kg. You will be able to change the mass of the projectile later 8. Goto cell F11, you must convert all of your degrees data into radians. The functions cosine and sine in Excel are specific to units of radians, and will not give the correct answer if you attempt to take the cosine and sine of an a number in units of degrees. 9. The equation written in cell F10 is rad=(deg*2pi)/360. You are calculating for an angle in radians, type the equation going from degrees into radians in cell F. ***Remember that Excel already has pi as a constant, simply type pi() in the multiplication part of the formula. 10. Copy your equation and results from cell F11, then paste down the column F until cell F101, just before the graphs, when the angle is 90o. (90o should convert to 1.5708 radians) 11. Goto cell G11, calculate the horizontal velocity. The equation written in cell G10 is Vx = Vrcos(), ***Remember that Vr, the initial or resultant velocity is a constant, and must be written as $C$9 in your Excel formula.) 12. Copy your equation and results from cell G11, then paste down the column G until cell G101, just before the graphs, when the angle is 90o. (Vx at 90o should be 0.000) (Answer questions 1 and 2 below) The top of your spreadsheet should look like this” initial height m 0 Initial or Resultant Velocity m/s 10 Angle Angle Degrees Radians theta mass of projectile kg 5 horizontal velocity m/s Vx rad=(deg*2pi)/360 Vx = Vrcos() 0 0.0000 10.0000 1 0.0175 9.9985 2 0.0349 9.9939 3 0.0524 9.9863 4 0.0698 9.9756 5 0.0873 9.9619 13. Goto cell H11, calculate the horizontal momentum (px). The equation written in cell H10 is Px = m*Vx ***Remember that m, the mass, is constant, and must be written as $C$12 in your Excel formula.) Projectile Motion Page 2 14. Goto cell G11, calculate the horizontal kinetic energy(Ex). The equation written in cell G10 is Ex = (1/2)*m*Vx^2 ***Remember that m, the mass, is constant. 15. Copy your equation and results from cells H11 and I 11, then paste down the column H and I until cells H101, and I101. (Answer question 3 below) 16. Goto cell J11, calculate the initial vertical velocity from the equation Voy=-Vrsin(), copy and paste down column J. All of your answers should come out as negative velocities. (Answer question 4 below.) 17. Determine the initial vertical momentum and kinetic energy in columns K and L. Copy and paste the formulas and calculations down column K and L until the graphs start. ***Remember that m, the mass, is constant You will see the formulas for momentum and kinetic energy on the spreadsheet. (Answer question 5 below.) The top of your spreadsheet should appear as: initial initial horizontal momentum horizontal energy vertical velocity vertical momentum kg*m/s Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 m/s kg*m/s Px Ex Voy Poy Px = m*Vx 50.0000 49.9924 49.9695 49.9315 49.8782 49.8097 Ex = (1/2)*m*Vx^2 Voy=-Vrsin() 250.0000 0.0000 249.9239 -0.1745 249.6955 -0.3490 249.3152 -0.5234 248.7835 -0.6976 248.1010 -0.8716 Poy = m*Voy 0.0000 -0.8726 -1.7450 -2.6168 -3.4878 -4.3578 initial vertical kinetic energy Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Ex Ex = (1/2)*m*Voy^2 0.0000 0.0761 0.3045 0.6848 1.2165 1.8990 18. Goto cell M11, calculate the final vertical velocity of the projectile, copy and paste down column M to M101, just before the graphs. (Answer question 6 below) 19. Determine the final vertical momentum and kinetic energy in columns K and L. Copy and paste the formulas and calculations down column N and O until the graphs start. ***Remember that m, the mass, is constant You will see the formulas for momentum and kinetic energy on the spreadsheet. (Answer question 5 below.) 20. Goto cell P11, you will the the equation for the resultant momentum Pr in terms of the Pythagorean theorem, Pr^2 = Px^2 + Pfy^2 , therefore you will have to take the square root of both sides of the equation to solve for Pr. Reminder, to take the square root in excel, you must take the power of your whole function to .5. Copy and paste down column P. The value of Pr at 90o should be 70.7107 21. Determine the final kinetic energy in column Q. Copy and paste the formulas and calculations down column Q. (Answer questions 8 and 9 below.) The top of your cells should appear as: Projectile Motion Page 3 final vertical velocity m/s Vfy Vfy=-Voy 0.0000 0.1745 0.3490 0.5234 0.6976 0.8716 final final vertical momentum vertical kinetic energy kg*m/s Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Pfy Efy Pfy = m*Vfy 0.0000 0.8726 1.7450 2.6168 3.4878 4.3578 Efy = (1/2)*m*Vfy^2 0.0000 0.0761 0.3045 0.6848 1.2165 1.8990 resultant momentum kg*m/s Pr resultant kinetic energy Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Er Pr^2 = Px^2 + Pfy^2 50.0000 50.0000 50.0000 50.0000 50.0000 50.0000 Er = Ex + Eoy 250.0000 250.0000 250.0000 250.0000 250.0000 250.0000 22. In columns R and S you will calculate the maximum height of the projectiles using two different equations. In column R, you will calculate the height based on the final vertical velocity h= (Vfy^2)/(2*g), while in column S, you will calculate the height from the intitial thrust or resultant velocity and the angle, h= ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2)/(2*g). As a check, both columns must have the same result or something is wrong. The value for g, the acceleration of gravity is found in cell R3, and is a constant so, it will be written as $R$3 in your equation, and the value for Vr in the second equation will also be a constant, $C$9. Use this cell in the equation because you will be able to change the acceleration of gravity to other planets later. 23. Goto cell T11 and calculate the gravitational potential energy at the maximum height. Copy and past down column T. You may use either column for height in your calculation. Both mass and the acceleration of gravity will be constants in this equation. 24. Goto cell U11, you will calculate the range of the projectile when given the initial thrust or resultant velocity and the acceleration of gravity, both constants, with an increasing angle as in the equation R = (Vr^2)(sin(2*)/g. Note that in the equation, it is the sin(2*), NOT the sine squared. (Answer questions 10, 11 and 12 below.) 25. In columns V and W, you will calculate the total time in the air using two different equations based on different given information. To check, both columns will calculate the same result or something is wrong. 26. Finally, you will determine the maximum range in column X using the horizontal velocity and either column of time you just calculated. As a check, column X and column U must give the same results. 27. Look at the Energies of Projectile vs. Angle and the Trajectory Motion for Initial Thrust Vr graphs and answer questions 13 – 16 below. Projectile Motion Page 4 max height m h max height m h potential energy at max height Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 GPE Maximum Range m R Total time t s Total time t s Maximum Range R m h= (Vfy^2)/(2*g) 0.0000 0.0016 0.0062 0.0140 0.0248 0.0388 h= ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2)/(2*g) 0.0000 0.0016 0.0062 0.0140 0.0248 0.0388 GPE = mgh 0.0000 0.0761 0.3045 0.6848 1.2165 1.8990 R = (Vr^2)(sin2*)/g 0.0000 0.3561 0.7118 1.0666 1.4201 1.7719 t = (2Vfy)/g) 0.0000 0.0356 0.0712 0.1068 0.1424 0.1779 t = 2(2h/g)^.5 0.0000 0.0356 0.0712 0.1068 0.1424 0.1779 R = Vx*t 0.0000 0.3561 0.7118 1.0666 1.4201 1.7719 Lab Activity: Day 2 (1 – 1.5 hours) Projectile Motion – Advanced 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Open the spreadsheet labeled “ Projectile Motion.xlsx” in Excel. Start on the page that says Projectile Motion-Advanced at the bottom of the page. Notice that all the cells are empty except for the angles in degrees and a section on the far right in the color blue. Do NOT change anything in the color blue. You will also notice that the graphs below the spreadsheet are blank. As you complete calculations in the spreadsheet, they will slowly fill in. Make sure that you are beginning on the spreadsheet that is labeled “Projectile Motion – Advanced” at the bottom. Unlike the original projectile motion page where projectiles are shot from the surface of flat ground, on the advanced page, the projectiles are shot from a known height, such a cliff. Start with a height of 35 in cell C5, an initial velocity of 20 in cell C9, and a mass of 15 in cell C12. Notice the units for each is in the cell above the number. Each of these will be constants in the upcoming equations. Cells should look like this: initial height (h2) m 10 Initial or Resultant Velocity m/s 10 mass of projectile kg 0.15 Angle Angle Degrees Radians theta 0 1 2 3 4 5 rad=(deg*2pi)/360 0.0000 0.0175 0.0349 0.0524 0.0698 0.0873 horizontal velocity horizontal momentum m/s kg*m/s Vx Px Vx = Vrcos() 10.0000 9.9985 9.9939 9.9863 9.9756 9.9619 Px = m*Vx 1.5000 1.4998 1.4991 1.4979 1.4963 1.4943 6. Columns F through N follow the same directions as the Projectile Motion- Basic table, so convert the angle from degrees to radians, and compute all the way through the initial total vertical mechanical energy. Copy and paste data/calculations for columns F through N. Answer question 17 below. Cells should look like this: Projectile Motion Page 5 initial initial horizontal energy vertical velocity vertical momentum Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 m/s kg*m/s Ex Voy Poy Ex = (1/2)*m*Vx^2 Voy=-Vrsin() 7.5000 0.0000 7.4977 -0.1745 7.4909 -0.3490 7.4795 -0.5234 7.4635 -0.6976 7.4430 -0.8716 Poy = m*Voy 0.0000 -0.0262 -0.0523 -0.0785 -0.1046 -0.1307 initial initial vertical initial total vertical kinetic energy gravitational potential energy vertical mechanical energy Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Ey PE Etoty Ey = (1/2)*m*Voy^2 0.0000 0.0023 0.0091 0.0205 0.0365 0.0570 PE= mgh (use h2) 14.7000 14.7000 14.7000 14.7000 14.7000 14.7000 Etoty = Ey + PE 14.7000 14.7023 14.7091 14.7205 14.7365 14.7570 7. In cell O11, you will now calculate the final vertical velocity of the projectile using the equation Vfy = ((-Voy)^2 + 2gh)^.5 Both g and h are constants in this equation. Answer question 18 below. Copy and paste down for column O. 8. Columns P through S follow the same directions as the Projectile Motion- Basic table, so calculate the final vertical momentum, and compute all the way through the resultant kinetic energy. Copy and paste data/calculations for columns P through S. Answer question 19 below. Cells should look like this: final vertical velocity m/s Vfy (use h2) Vfy = ((-Voy)^2 + 2gh)^.5 14.0000 14.0011 14.0043 14.0098 14.0174 14.0271 final final vertical momentum vertical kinetic energy kg*m/s Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Pfy Efy Pfy = m*Vfy 2.1000 2.1002 2.1007 2.1015 2.1026 2.1041 Efy = (1/2)*m*Vfy^2 14.7000 14.7023 14.7091 14.7205 14.7365 14.7570 vector resultant momentum kg*m/s Pr scalar resultant kinetic energy Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 Er Pr^2 = Px^2 + Pfy^2 2.5807 2.5807 2.5807 2.5807 2.5807 2.5807 Er = Ex + Eoy 22.2000 22.2000 22.2000 22.2000 22.2000 22.2000 9. In cell T11, you will calculate the maximum height to the new apex. You will use the equation htot = h1 + h2 = ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2)/(2*g) +h2, where h1 = ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2)/(2*g). htot stands for the total height. h1 is the altitude from the top of h2 to the apex. Vr, h2 and g are all constants. Copy and paste down column T. 10. In cell U11, calculate the total mechanical energy at the maximum altitude. Remember, htot = h1+h2. This htot was calculated in column T. Copy and paste down column U. 11. In cells V and W, use the given equations to calculate the time to the sapex, and the time from the apex to the ground. In column X you will calculate the range. In column Y calculate the impact velocity Vri with the ground, and in column Z, you will determine the angle (in radians) upon impact. Finally, in column AA convert radians back to degrees. Answer question 20 below: Cells should look like: Assessment: Projectile Motion Page 6 g on earth 9.8 maximum height at new apex m h1 = ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2) htot = h1 + h2 total potential energy at max height Joule = kg*m^2/s^2 GPE htot= ((Vr^2)*(sin)^2)/(2*g) +h2 10.0000 10.0016 10.0062 10.0140 10.0248 10.0388 GPE = mg(h1+h2) 14.7000 14.7023 14.7091 14.7205 14.7365 14.7570 Time to apex t1 s Time from apex to ground t2 s t1 = ((2*Vr^2*sin2)/g^2) t2 = 2(2htot/g)^.5 0.0000 2.8571 0.0727 2.8574 0.1453 2.8580 0.2177 2.8591 0.2898 2.8607 0.3616 2.8627 Maximum Range R m R = Vx*(t1+t2) 28.5714 29.2960 30.0147 30.7260 31.4284 32.1202 Final Resultant Impact Velocity Vri m/s on excel, arctan is = atan Impact Angle radians Impact Angle degrees Vri=(Vx^2 + Vfy^2)^.5 =tan-1(Vfy/Vx) deg=(360xrad)/(2pi) 17.2047 0.9505 54.4623 17.2047 0.9507 54.4686 17.2047 0.9510 54.4872 17.2047 0.9515 54.5184 17.2047 0.9523 54.5620 17.2047 0.9533 54.6179 Questions: Projectile Motion Basic: Give all responses in terms of physics principles. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. As the angle increases from 0o to 90o, what occurs to the horizontal component of the velocity? How is the relationship shown in the first graph of Horizontal Velocity vs. Angle? Why is both the momentum and kinetic energy for horizontal velocity equal to zero at 90o? Why are all the initial vertical velocities negative? While the initial vertical momentum is negative, why will the initial kinetic energy never be negative? What relationship exists between the horizontal velocity and the final vertical velocity of the projectile, and at what angle are they equal to each other? What relationships exist between the initial and final vertical momentum and kinetic energies for a projectile? What is significant about the answers for the final total kinetic energy of the projectile? Energy is a scalar, while momentum is a vector, what is the difference between a scalar and a vector and why do we find the total of each one using a different equation? At what angle does the range have the largest value? What occurs to the values of the range before and after the largest value? According to the graph below, when is it possible to have a maximum height greater than the range for a projectile? Why? What relationship exists between the final vertical kinetic energy and the gravitational potential energy of the projectile? Write a mathematical expression that shows the relationship between the total kinetic energy, the horizontal kinetic energy, and the final vertical kinetic energy. How does this describe a scalar? Write a mathematical expression that shows the relationship between the total kinetic energy, the horizontal kinetic energy, and the gravitational potential energy. How does this describe a scalar? Fill in the blanks in regards to a projectile: Projectiles shot from angles that have complementary angles will have the same __________________, but not the same ____________________ except at the angle of _____ degrees. Questions: Projectile Motion Advanced: Give all responses in terms of physics principles. 17. Which values have the same value for all angles and why? Projectile Motion Page 7 18. Why do the values of the final vertical velocity continue to remain greater than the magnitude of the initial vertical velocity and/or the initial horizontal velocity. (Remember in the Projectile Motion Basic sheet the initial and final vertical velocities are of equal magnitude but opposite direction.) 19. Why does the resultant momentum remain the same? 20. How do the two trajectory graphs contrast and compare? References: Spreadsheet for work is here: My Module Work\Projectile Motion.xlsx Projectile Motion Page 8