2013JE004386text01

advertisement
Error Analysis
The purpose of this document is to explain the calculation of error and error bars
for orientation and bed thickness measurements presented in the manuscript.
Error of 
Error was calculated for each  according to the following equation, using the error
of strike measurements (listed in ts01):
  1/n 
n
 strike
2
i
(A1)
i1
Error of 
Error was calculated for the average dip measurements according to the following
 the error of individual dip measurements (listed in ts01):
equation, using
  1/n 
n
 
2
i
(A2)
i1
Error of bed thickness, t, measurements
To calculate error bars for each bed thickness measurement, we propagate the

errors of orientation
measurements (, ) as well as the errors in the DTM (DTM
resolution and vertical precision), according to the mathematical operations in the
Eqs. 5 and 6 presented in the main text.
Bed thickness is calculated according to the following equations:
t  h cos  sin   v cos
(5)
t  hcos sin   vcos
(6)
 whether the dip of the beds is in the same or opposite direction as the
Depending on
topographic slope. Thickness error is:

t  (h cos  sin  ) 2  (v cos ) 2
(A3)
The horizontal distance, h, along the measured section line between the upper and
lower bed boundaries is calculated using (x, y) coordinates extracted from the DTM

and the distance formula.
h  (x2  x1)2  (y2  y1)2
The absolute error of h is therefore:

(A4)
h  1/2  h  {[(x 2  x1 ) 2  (y 2  y1 ) 2 ]/[( x 2  x1 ) 2  (y 2  y1 ) 2 ]}
(A5)
Where:


[(x2  x1)2  (y2  y1)2 ]  [(x 2  x1)]2 [(y2  y1)]2
(A6)
[(x 2  x1) 2 ]  2  (x 2  x1)2  (x 2  x1) /(x 2  x1)
(A7)
[(y 2  y1) 2 ]  2  (y 2  y1)2  (y 2  y1) /(y 2  y1)
(A8)

Since DEM horizontal resolution is 1 m:


(x 2  x1)  (DEM) 2  (DEM) 2  12 12  2
(A9)
(y 2  y1)  (DEM) 2  (DEM) 2  12 12  2
(A10)
The elevation difference between the upper and lower boundaries for each bed is
calculated according to the formula:

v  z2  z1
(A11)
The absolute error of v is calculated by propagating the error of the two elevation
values, assumed here to be the expected vertical precision of the DEM, EP:

v  (EP) 2  (EP) 2
(A12)
(v cos )  v cos  (v /v) 2  ((cos  ) /cos  ) 2
(A13)

Where error is approximated in trigonometric functions by the following equations:


(cos  )  cos   cos(   )
(A14)
(sin  )  sin   sin(    )
(A15)
(cos  )  cos  cos(   )
(A16)

By substituting Eqs. A1, A2, and A4-A16 into Eq. A3, the following equation is
derived for the propagated absolute error of each thickness measurement:

t  (h cos sin (1/ 2 

(2 2 (x2  x 1 )) 2  (2 2 (y 2  y 1 )) 2
(x 2  x 1 ) 2  (y 2  y 1 ) 2
)2  (
cos  cos(   )
cos
)2  (
sin  sin(   )
sin
) 2 ) 2  (v cos (
(EP) 2  (EP) 2
v
)2  (
cos  cos(   )
cos
)2 )2
(A17)
For sections where no correction is made for the dip of the beds, bed thickness error is:
t  v  (EP)2  (EP)2
(A18)
where EP is the DTM expected precision.

Error of Total Section Thickness
Since the total section thickness (Table 3) was calculated by adding all individual
bed thickness measurements for a section, the error of total section thickness was
calculated by the formula:
TotalThickness 
n
 t
i 1
(A19)
2
i
Error of Mean Bed Thickness
Mean bed thickness for each section was calculated by adding all individual bed
thickness measurements for a section, then dividing by the number of beds. Error of

mean bed thickness is calculated by the formula:
MeanThickness  1/ n 
n
 t
i 1

i
2
(A20)
Download