Regional Technical Meeting on Refrigeration Grand Coastal Inn Plantation Le Ressouvenir, East Coast Demerara Guyana National Ozone Action Unit, Hydrometeorological Service Ministry of Agriculture March 30-31, 2011 Meeting objective The meeting was organised around the overarching themes of certification of refrigeration technicians, alternative technologies and management of refrigeration associations. This was to provide a forum for the deliberations at regional level on these pertinent areas as it relates to the refrigeration industry and their role in the assisting countries in maintaining compliance to the Montreal Protocol by achieving phase out targets. Opening Ceremony An official ceremony to observe the opening of the technical meeting on refrigeration was held on March 31, 2011. The ceremony began with welcoming remarks by Mr. Garvin Cummings, Chief Hydrometeorological Officer (ag) who reiterated the importance of these deliberations to all present. Ms. Artie Dubrie, representative of the United Nations Environment Programme, expressed thanks to the Government of Guyana for affording her the opportunity to participate in this meeting on airconditioning and refrigeration. She recognized the eagerness of the participants to standardize their industry. In this regard she urged participants to - keep abreast with new technologies as well as to provide the highest service to clients, in keeping with national and international requirements. Participants were also encouraged to become involved in international issues that are likely to impact their industry. Ms. Dubrie acknowledged the participation of Haiti in air-condition and refrigeration meeting as part of the Caribbean region, pointing to the dedication of the Haitian Government to the protection of the environment and man, even the country focuses its efforts on rebuilding their economy. In the keynote address delivered by Honourable Robert Persaud, Minister of Agriculture, participants were welcomed to the meeting. Minister Persaud confirmed that Guyana has maintained compliance under the Montreal Protocol and pointed that this is an indication that Guyana continues to play its part in the protection of the environment. This he said has given impetus to the success of Guyana’s Low Carbon Development Strategy (LCDS). He highlighted the importance of the meeting and urged technicians to ensure that the refrigeration industry limits their impact on climate change thereby contributing to the safety of our planet. He cautioned that historical neglect of issues related to climate change has resulted in the negative environmental impacts we currently face. To this end, he commended the commitment of regional countries in addressing the challenges of ozone depletion and climate change, which he said was demonstrated through the presence and participation of the various regional representatives. He concluded by wishing participants to the meeting fruitful and productive deliberations. Certification of Refrigeration Technicians 1. Discussions regarding certification of refrigeration technicians were opened with a presentation from CARICOM outlining the major elements of the Caricom Single Market and Economy (CSME), free movement of labour in the CSME, imperatives for workforce development, Technical Vocational and Educational Training (TVET) reform, the establishment of the system of Caribbean Vocational Qualifications (CVQs) and the importance of CVQs to CSME. 2. It was pointed out that CVQs were implemented as a means of facilitating free movement of categories of workers that were not previously covered by the Caricom free movement initiative. Among the new categories of workers targeted under the CVQ programme are refrigeration and air conditioning technicians. On this regard, participants agreed on the importance of CVQ in standardizing the training and certification of refrigeration technicians regionally. 3. It was outlined that only three countries in the region are currently approved to issue CVQs. These are Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados and Jamaica. Countries were therefore encouraged to utilize resources available in these countries that are advanced in the implementation of the CVQ to avoid duplication of efforts and misuse of resources. 4. In the spirit of promoting regional collaboration on this regard, level one standard for refrigeration and air conditioning prepared by Trinidad and Tobago was presented and reviewed by participants present. This standard is slated to be submitted to CARICOM for approval in July, 2011. Following its approval, this standard will be available for use in all Caribbean territories desirous of issuing CVQ for refrigeration and air conditioning. 5. To ensure that adequate emphasis is placed on the environment in regional curricula, the CARICOM representative advised that this should be brought to the attention of CANTA through a formal letter to ensure adequate consideration is given to the incorporation of environmental issues during review of regional standards. Participants were advised that the development of standards is coordinated through local TVET bodies and regionally, through CANTA. Alternative Technologies 6. On the matter of short term alternatives the meeting examined the implications for the current alternatives 410a and 407C to refrigerant HCFC 22 to be phased out under the second schedule of the Montreal Protocol. Among these were, reluctance of equipment owners to retrofit existing equipment to new alternatives especially in cases where the cost for conversion is high. Additionally it was believed that lack of training and tooling of technicians to handle technologies, may create safety concerns, particularly in the case of R410a. 7. Hydrocarbon, Ammonia and Carbon Dioxide were explored by participants as viable longer term alternative refrigerants for the refrigeration industry. These refrigerants were hailed for their low cost as well as low environmental impact. Availability of these refrigerants regionally and training on safe handling and their applications continues to be major challenges for their exclusive adoption by the regional industry. 8. The meeting considered appropriate building designs as a response to ozone depletion and climate change. It was emphasized that appropriate building designs can assist in reducing the demand for mechanical cooling (air conditioning) in contemporary buildings as countries seek to address both ozone depletion and climate change. Primary consideration for the designing of such buildings include siting and orientation of settlements and building, building shape and form, choice of building materials and wall shading. Architects, building owners and policy makers (state) can collectively encourage movement towards more environmentally conscious buildings. Management of Refrigeration Associations 9. With regard to the role of the refrigeration association as representatives of the air conditioning and refrigeration industry, the need for refrigeration associations to be industry driven was underlined. Roles identified for refrigeration associations included, but were not limited to, regularization of the refrigeration industry, promotion of training and certification of refrigeration technicians, sharing of information, provision of technical assistance and organisation of members into collective groups for the purpose of bargaining on behalf of the industry. 10. On the issue of the role of the refrigeration industry in sustainable development, participants agreed that the refrigeration industry is critical to the implementation and compliance of countries that are parties to the Montreal Protocol. With regard to this obligation, participants voiced that the lack of facilities to store and or destroy recovered refrigerants was becoming a growing concern in the industry. This, they added, is often a deterrent to recovery of refrigerants. Participants were advised to make representation on this issue through organised groups or refrigeration associations to their respective Ozone Offices or line Ministry. It was pointed out that information on the volume of stored ODS available for destruction nationally was necessary, before a national or regional strategy can be devised. This responsibility was charged to National Ozone Offices. Notwithstanding, participants were encouraged to make full use of the recovery equipment as this will reduce future volume of stored refrigerants as well as the demand for new refrigerants. 11. Among the challenges identified by refrigeration associations were recruiting and retaining of members. This participants believe is as a result of misunderstanding of the role of associations, as many believe its primary function should be to improve the economic base of its members. Participants considered examples of regional associations which provide training and other incentives / disincentives to attract new members as well as to encourage existing members. Other challenges identified by associations include personality clashes, poor attitudes of some members and lack of respect for line authority. 12. Technicians present were encouraged to seek opportunities through their governments to become involved in the rebuilding process in Haiti, as it was explained that there is a shortage of skills, especially in this sector. This would further assist in training / retraining of technicians and the transfer of current technologies and practices in Haiti. In this regard it was suggested that a regional refrigeration meeting be hosted in Haiti to support this process. Haitian representatives are to follow up on this request. Figure 2: Presenter: Mr. Henry Fredrick, Grenada Figure 3: Site Visit Figure 1: Site Visit - Demerara Distillers Limited, CO2 Plant Figure 4: Site Visit Participant List ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA Winston Steele Technical Manager (Owner) Antigua and Barbuda Refrigeration AirConditioning Association Bathlodge, P.O. Box 2806 St. John’s Antigua 268-720-8083 268-725-8080 abraca1@live.com wrsteele203@hotmail.com BAHAMAS Lyndon Gage Technician & Manager Gage Air-Conditioning & Refrigeration Services All Saints Village, St. John Antigua 268-460-7070 268-464-7070 gages.aircon@hotmail.com William Sturrup Senior Craft Instructor RSES Bahamas Bahamas Technical and Vocational Institute P.O. Box N4934 Old Trail Road, Nassau, Bahamas 242-502-6377 242-393-4005 sturrup@hotmail.com Infobtui@gmail.com BARBADOS Hyrone Boyce Supervisor, Air-Conditioning Department Refrigeration and Air-conditioning Association of Barbados Fonta Belle, St. Michael 246-430-5600 Ext 5648 243-6269 (C) 246-426-0125 hyrone_boyce@amrservice.com BAHAMAS David Ramsey ACR Certification Lecturer Refrigeration Service Engineers Society Bahamas Chapter Ministry of National Security, Nassau, Bahamas 242-392-8996 242-565-0108 242-328-3889 davidramsey549@gmail.com GRENADA John Campbell Air-Condition Technician St. George’s University School of Medicine True Blue Campus, St. George’s, Grenada 473-444-1406 (W) 473-444-1740 (H) 473409-0025 (C) 473-414-5786 (C) 473-444-1770 GRENADA GUYANA Henry Frederick Grenada Airports Authority Point Salines, St. George’s, Grenada 473-415-1198 473-444-4838 fridgedoc@hotmail.com GUYANA Philip Rudland Consultant Engineer Cool Natural 386 Block 8, Mon Repos, East Coast Demerara, Guyana 592-602-8673 coolnatural@live.co.uk GUYANA Jerry Simpson Shurish Baijnauth Senior TVET Officer Council for TVET GTI Compound, 113 Woolford Avenue, Non Pariel Park, Georgetown, Guyana 592-227-8784/9 592-227-8784 council4tvet@yahoo.com Deputy Chief Education Officer (Technical) Ministry of Education 113 Woolford Avenue, Georgetown, Guyana 592-226-4434 592-225-8356 dceotmoe@yahoo.com GUYANA GUYANA Onwuzirike Patrick Chinedu Principal Government Technical Institute Woolford Avenue & Camp Street, Georgetown, Guyana 592-227-1197 Delon Douglas Air-Condition Technician Demerara Distillers Limited Diamond Plantation, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-265-6002 592-653-1427 delon_douglas@yahoo.com GUYANA GUYANA Marven Dublin Senior Refrigeration Technician Demerara Distillers Limited Diamond Plantation, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-265-6022 592-650-3685 sarvin_dublin2006@yahoo.com Shane Adams Demerara Distillers Limited Diamond Plantation, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-265-6022 592-675-5819 shanestorm23@yahoo.com GUYANA GUYANA Imran Khan Air-Condition Technician Demerara Distillers Limited Diamond Plantation, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-265-6022 592-667-7544 sexyboy_2289@yahoo.com Neil George Technician Guyana Telephone & Telegraph Company (GT&T) 79 Brickdam, Georgetown, Guyana 592-225-9033 neilovid2001@yahoo.com GUYANA GUYANA General Manager N. K. Electrical Services 136 Section ‘C’ Enterprise, East Coast Demerara, Guyana 592-270-4595 592-626-2847 zimbo_khan@yahoo.com GUYANA Mahendra Saywack Environmental Officer Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Ganges Street, Sophia Greater Georgetown, Guyana 592-650-1268 mahendrasaywack@gmail.com GUYANA Keino Eastman Antartic Maintenance & Refrigeration 101 Third Street, Albertown, Georgetown, Guyana 592-223-6320 592-223-6330 Orel Rockeliffe Air-Condition Technician Orel Rockeliffe Temporacy Specialist with Steele Refrigeration Airy Hall Mahaicony, East Coast Demerara, GUYANA Guyana 592-628-4144 GUYANA Allan DeJonge Lecturer/General Manager Government Technical Institute/Guyana AirConditioning Refrigeration and Ventilation Association (GARVA) 113 Woolford Avenue, Non Pariel Park, Georgetown Guyana 592-225-0117 592-623-3726 alrefservice@yahoo.com GUYANA Sandra Britton Head, Energy and Energy Statistics Division, Guyana Energy Agency Guyana Energy Agency 295 Quamina Street, Georgetown, Guyana 592-226-6993 592-226-5227 san_britton@yahoo.com Karyl Arthur Lecturer Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Guyana Turkeyen, East Coast Demerara, Guyana Dwarka Singh Supervisor, Maintenance Department Noble House Seafoods Limited Blocx ‘X’ Eccles, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-233-2479-82 592-233-2485 maint@noblesea.com GUYANA GUYANA Khemraj Hariprasad Refrigeration Technician B.E.V. Processors Area ‘K’ Houston, East Bank Demerara, Guyana 592-225-2111 592-647-6667 592-225-0015 khemraj_hariprasad@yahoo.com GUYANA Zainool Rahaman National Consultant - TPMP National Ozone Action Unit Hydrometeorological Service Ministry of Agriculture 18 Brickdam, Stabroek Georgetown Tel: 592 - 225-9303 / 226-0341 Fax: 592 – 226-1460 GUYANA JAMAICA Odessa Shako National Ozone Officer National Ozone Action Unit Hydrometeorological Service Ministry of Agriculture 18 Brickdam, Stabroek Georgetown Tel: 592 - 225-9303 / 226-5403 Fax: 592 – 226-1460 Email: o.shako@hydromet.gov.gy / Michael Heron Director, Air-Conditioning Sales and Service Jamaican Air-Conditioning Refrigeration and Ventilation Association 2 Piccadilly Road, Kingston 5, Jamaica 876-999-3831 876-926-3340/3 876-926-3344 macheron@cwjamaica.com HAITI SURINAME odessas_shako@yahoo.com Stephane Lherisson President Apex Training Center, Miami, Florida Apex Centre Oe Formation Professionvelle Haiti 424 Pointe de Delmas, Port-Au-Prince, Haiti 509-340-1677 stephanewlherisson@yahoo.com TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO Badassee Nanan Director ARIA 13 Fifth St., San Juan Trinidad and Tobago Suite, 20 Centropolis Mall Ramsaran Street Chaguanas 368-671-1648 368-672-6101 temptecltd@hotmail.com SURINAME HSEC Coordinator ARVAS Dr. S. Redmonstraat 217 597-497-7038 597-885-3493 stan.sovan@sr.net stanas@live.NL UNEP / ROLAC Artie Dubrie Policy and Enforcement Officer Panama City, PANAMA Apto. Postal: 0843-03590 507 -305-3161 Fax: (507) 305-3105 artie.dubrie@unep.org Satiesh Sandjoi Teacher Air-Conditioning, Refrigeration and Ventilation Association Suriname (ARVAS) Mr. Y. Hachmonstraat 180 -182 597-875-9259 satieshsardjoe@yahoo.com SURINAME Anjani Ramdjanamsingh Assistant Ozone Officer National Institute for Environment and Development in Suriname Ona fhankelylkheids plein 597-520-043 597-520-042 aramdjanamsingh@nimos.org UNEP Paul Judex Edouarzin Consultant Blvd T. Louverture and Clercine 18, Minustah, Logbase, BP 557, Port-Au-Prince, Haiti 509-377-1910 pauljudex.edouarzin@gmail.com EXPERT Vernon Ramjattan National Training Agency Trinidad and Tobago 868-753-0501 aircon@live.com