Learning Difficulties and Volunteer Training: A Module for Tutor Training Trainer Packet Mary Dunn Siedow and Nancy Frazier with North Carolina Literacy Association Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project Partners North Carolina Literacy Resource Center North Carolina Community College System 2001 Learning Difficulties and Volunteer Tutoring A Module for Tutor Training Mary Dunn Siedow and Nancy Frazier With Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination (LDTD) Project Partners North Carolina Literacy Resource Center, North Carolina Community College System, Fall 2001 This module is intended for use by volunteer literacy organizations, either in basic literacy training or as an in-service workshop. The module is based on Bridges to Practice: A Researchbased Guide for Literacy Practitioners Serving Adults and on the experiences of LDTD Project Partners as they implemented Bridges to Practice in their organizations. Tutor trainers who use this module should be familiar with Bridges to Practice. Ideally, they should attend the orientation session that introduces this module. Tutor trainers should read this module carefully and should prepare overheads, charts, handouts, etc. before using it. Module Packet Included in the Learning Difficulties and Volunteer Training module packet are the following: Training Script Overhead Transparency Masters Handout Masters Literacy organization training teams and staff should determine together the best way to use the module and materials. Handouts referred to in the “Directions and Talking Points” should be duplicated for participants. Objectives By participating in this module, trainers and volunteer tutors should: Gain a basic understanding of learning difficulties and disabilities. Understand and be able to use a “strengths model” to help adults with learning difficulties have successful experiences in tutoring programs. Appreciate the need for effective instruction—including use of strengths, multisensory techniques, and modifications. Materials Needed Flip chart or white board and markers Overhead projector, transparencies and markers Copies of participant packet—handouts, other resources Training Script The following pages provide a script for using the training module. The information in this publication is based upon work supported by the National Institute for Literacy (NIFL) to ProLiteracy America, the U.S. Division of ProLiteracy Worldwide. The information that it contains is based upon work supported by NIFL under Grant No. X257 B70003. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the values of the NIFL. The contents of this document are not official statements of ProLiteracy Worldwide. Legal information is included as examples and must be reviewed by qualified legal counsel for compliance and applicable federal and state laws. -1- One: Introduction to Learning Difficulties and Disabilities Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Map Overhead (OH/HO-1) Show the Map for the module. Explain that this is an overview of the module. The Map begins with a guiding question and then illustrates objectives. 5 min Flip chart or white board Ask this focus question: “What does the term learning disability bring to mind?” 10 min LD quiz Handout and “answers” Overhead (OH/HO-2 Pass out the LD Quiz. Allow a few minutes for participants to match people with learning difficulties. Show answers on the overhead. Discuss the following or related topics: 5 min NIFL LD Handout (HO-3) Allow participants to respond. Make a list of responses on a flip chart or white board. Tutors are likely to get things like: ADD, AD/HD, dyslexia, “most adult learners have LD,” “My brother (sister, child) has a LD (is dyslexic),” references to famous people with LD, learning style, etc. Be accepting and non-judgmental, but do not agree with everything. We sometimes hear that historical figures (DaVinci or Einstein) had LD. We really cannot know this with certainty, and should not make judgements about them. Living people may have been diagnosed—or we may just be repeating “conventional wisdom.” Commonly heard “sound bites” about adults and learning disabilities many times include the following estimates: 50-80% of adults in literacy programs have LD. 25-40% of people on welfare have LD. Statements like these are common, but they are difficult to substantiate. That’s because the statements are rarely accompanied by references. Sound bites are just estimates—they don’t give us the best—or even complete—pictures. Talk about how the participants’ list and the LD quiz show the following: We have varied ideas about learning disabilities. We confuse terms. We over-generalize and probably do far too much labeling. -2- Two: Understanding Learning Difficulties and Disabilities (Optional Activity: Drop it or use it in place of the LD Quiz.) Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Tell participants that that they will be working toward the following in this portion of the training: Flip chart, white board, or blank overhead Understanding that learning disabilities are real. Trying not to over-generalize about learning disabilities. Distinguishing among some of the terms associated with LD (styles, differences, difficulties, and disabilities). Coming to an understanding of how volunteer literacy tutors can assist adults with learning difficulties (disabilities). Draw a line on a piece of flip chart paper, on a white board, or the overhead. On the left side write “easy” and on the right side write “impossible.” Tell participants to think of a continuum of learning, from easy to nearly impossible. Easy— people for whom learning is easy—school is a breeze. These people are intelligent, possibly creative, and experience few, if any, impediments to learning. Impossible—people for whom every learning task presents great, even insurmountable, difficulty. Point out that in between are all manner of barriers to learning. Adults in literacy programs may have experienced these barriers in school and now may hope to overcome them. To assist learners, tutors should understand what learning difficulties and disabilities are and should have a plan for dealing with them as they work with adult learners. Tell participants to keep the following general statements in mind when working with learners: For many individuals, learning is easy, and they have little difficulty in school. For most people with minor learning difficulties, learning needs are still met in school. For most people who have difficulty with learning, school is very hard (or is nearly impossible). These are the individuals who enter literacy programs as adults. -3- Three: Important Definitions—Position Statement Time Materials Directions and Talking Points Tell participants that it is important to have clear definitions of learning difficulties and disabilities. One reason for this is that there are legal ramifications to terms like learning disability. Another reason is that most people are not qualified to judge LD in others. 10 min Styles / differences / disabilities Overhead and Handout Show the accompanying overhead, uncovering the definitions as you talk about them. Use the notes below. Allow participants to comment, and ask questions. (OH/HO-4) Learning Styles—the preferred means of learning. Learning styles may be visual (pictorial, reading, etc.), auditory (listening, speaking, and remembering based on aural input), or kinesthetic (tactile, learning from doing). For most people, the preferred style is a mix of one or more styles. Learning styles develop from what we find easy, interesting, and successful. Learning Difficulties—the things that are hard to learn. Everyone has difficulties learning some things. But these learners have more serious difficulties. That’s why they enroll in literacy programs. The difficulties may have been developed over a long period of time, and there may be considerable baggage attached to them. Tutors will be able to identify some of their learner’s difficulties if they are observant. Tutors can work with staff to find ways to help learners overcome them. Learning Disabilities—a formal term, with legal ramifications, for serious, “hard-wired” difficulties with learning. These difficulties significantly impair efforts at learning. 10 min LD Definitions Overhead and handout (OH/HO-5) Show participants the definition of learning disabilities. Explain that it was made by a joint committee of LD experts who wanted it to include the most critical information possible. Review each part of the definition carefully. Make a clear statement of your local program’s position. The following is a general position statement: Volunteers and staff are not in a position to diagnose learning disabilities. They should refrain from using the term learning disability except in those cases where there is a formal, legal diagnosis. If a tutor has tried many strategies with someone and thinks that a difficulty may be so deep-seated as to truly be a disability, consider getting a formal diagnosis for an adult learner. -4- Time Materials Directions and Talking Points Learning disability is a much overused term. People use it freely, almost jokingly; they label others who possess some characteristics associated with learning disabilities. Point out that dyslexia, Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD), and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) are some of the most overused terms for learning disabilities. 5 min Dyslexia Overhead and Handout (OH/HO-6) Show the dyslexia definition. Say that in its true sense dyslexia refers to a very small percentage of people whose severe reading disabilities are due to central processing problems. These people find it extremely difficult to learn to read but may be able to do many other intellectual tasks. In a popular sense, dyslexia is misused to describe any difficulty with reading. 5 min There is considerable evidence that ADD and ADHD, while debilitating conditions, are not—strictly speaking—learning disabilities. People think they know what dyslexia means, but generally use the term far too loosely. It is particularly of concern when people over-generalize that someone has dyslexia simply because he or she displays one or two characteristics often associated with it. It is also of concern when someone says he or she once had dyslexia but overcame it. In the truest sense of the definition, this is unlikely. It is more likely that the person had a reading difficulty that was remedied. Sum up the definitions section by noting that learning difficulty is the “term of choice.” By selecting it, tutors accomplish the following: Have a definition stated in educational terms Can use what is known about effective instruction to select strategies and to modify instruction Are not overstepping any legal boundaries Are not adding to the misinformation about learning disabilities Are not making light of learning disabilities that they are not qualified to diagnose Remind participants that learning disability is a legal term that requires formal diagnosis by professionals. There is enough misunderstanding about learning disabilities (especially dyslexia). Tutors should avoid adding to the confusion or making light of LD. Tutors should refrain from using the term learning disability in the absence of a formal diagnosis. -5- Four: Assessment Continuum Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Show overhead. Tell participants that another way to look at the differences among definitions is through an assessment continuum. Assessment Overhead and Handout (OH/HO-7) Intake: When a learner enters a program, a staff person interviews him or her and administers assessment tests to determine a good starting place for instruction. Tutors and learners may do additional assessment activities during their work together. Screening: If a tutor or learner suspects that a learner’s difficulties require special kinds of instruction, he or she can speak with program staff about more in-depth assessment. Program staff can administer educational assessments to gain more information about educational difficulties or screening instruments to point to possible clues that recommend the learner be referred for a learning disabilities diagnosis. Diagnosis: Only when learner, tutor, and program staff are in agreement that it is called for should program staff seek formal diagnosis of a learning disability. The decision should be based on the severity of learning difficulties, evidence from screening instruments, availability of appropriate accommodations, and the learner’s desire to undergo the diagnosis. Remind participants that they need to communicate regularly with program staff. They should discuss with learners and staff what is and what isn’t working. Tutors should report any suspicions they and their learners may have to program staff. -6- Five: Working with Learning Strengths and Preferences (Optional Activity) Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 10 min Ask: “What’s your preferred learning style?” Some participants may respond quickly. Tell them that there are many ways to get an idea of adults’ learning styles. One way is to respond to some situations that involve learning. Present tutors with the following situation: Learning Styles Handout (HO-8) Suppose you are faced with a task that requires having a lot of information about a topic. How would you respond to this checklist? Now, suppose you are faced with a task that requires being able to perform a series of physical steps. How would you respond to the checklist? Your preferred learning style is a combination of what you like and what you do well. It probably is more than just one style. In fact, most people use a combination of learning styles depending on the tasks they must accomplish. Most people have also developed learning habits that avoid styles that are difficult. The same is true for adult learners in literacy programs—however these adults are not likely to prefer learning through written language. They may have well-developed auditory or tactile-kinesthetic styles, either alone or in combination. They may use visual information to support these styles. Tutors could use a similar checklist with learners, remembering that the preferred styles are likely to be auditory, kinesthetic, and visual (only when pictorial and not including words). -7- Six: Teaching Adults with Learning Difficulties Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Remind participants that, as tutors, they are likely to encounter adults with many kinds of difficulties that can affect their learning. These difficulties: 10 min Strengths and Difficulties Handout (OH/HO-9) Direct participants to the handout on working with strengths and difficulties. Mention the following: 10 min Modifications Handout and Overhead (OH/HO-10) Can be visual, auditory, tactile-kinesthetic, or a combination. Often mirror strengths—a visual difficulty may be mirrored by a strong auditory preference, or vice versa. An auditory or a visual difficulty may mirror a preference for tactile-kinesthetic learning. A strong preference for tactile-kinesthetic may mirror visual or auditory difficulties. Talk about how the handout helps to show a relationship between strengths and difficulties. Discuss suggestions for capitalizing on strengths and suggestions for instructional interventions in areas of difficulty. Note that in each area there are positives about learner strengths. Also note that suggestions for dealing with difficulties often relate to potential strengths in other areas. Note that some recommendations use basic instructional strategies. It is important to base all instruction on these basic strategies. Tutors should then modify their approach to match learner needs. Direct participants to the handout on Instructional Modifications. Invite them to share the ideas presented with learners. Some tutors and learners may be leery of modifications. This handout helps to explain that modifications are both legitimate and important ways to make instruction work better for adults with learning difficulties. -8- Seven: Effective Tutoring Time Materials 5 min Effective Tutoring Handout and Overhead HO-11 OH-12 OH-13 OH-14 OH-15 Directions and Talking Points Direct participants to the Effective Tutoring handout. Tell participants that the handout summarizes the module and relates it to other information presented about effective tutoring. The handout is organized into clusters to show the importance of the following: Involving the learner Creating an effective learning environment Being well prepared Staying in touch with program staff Discuss effective tutoring, using the overheads that correspond to handout clusters. 5 min Direct Instruction Handout and Overhead (OH/HO-16) Direct participants to the Direct Instruction handout. Point out that direct instruction has been shown to be effective with learners who have difficulty learning. In direct instruction, teachers control the amount and organization of content, provide guided and independent practice, and monitor learner performance. The version of direct instruction presented adds another element. That element involves of learners becoming independently responsible for their learning. -9- Eight: Shared Responsibilities, Resources Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Tell participants that everyone involved in the tutoring process (the learner, tutor, and program staff) has responsibilities in making tutoring as successful as possible. Show the overhead and talk about the following: Shared Responsibilities Overhead and Handout (OH/HO-17) 5 min Resources Overhead (HO/OH-18) Program Responsibilities Tutor Responsibilities Learner Responsibilities Use the Resources overhead to show participants that they and their learners have access to a variety of helpful resources. Present the following: An overview of your program’s specific resources. A list of resources available in your community. The NC Literacy Resource Center (LRC). Tell participants that by visiting the NC LRC website at http://www.nclrc.state.nc.us they can do the following: 1. Locate books in the NC LRC library 2. Use the “Teacher/Tutor Resources” section to find LD resources, including the following: Bibliographies of NC LRC resources and websites Information sheets and overheads Bridges to Practice information Connections to other LD resources through LINCS. - 10 - Nine: Summary Time Materials Directions and Talking Points 5 min Show the Map overhead again. Review the organizing question and objectives. Map Overhead OH/HO-1 Summarize this module by discussing the following points: LD is lifelong. Significant numbers of adults in literacy programs may have LD, beyond what is expected in the general population. An appropriate position for a literacy organization to adopt is as follows: Avoid labels. Teach to strengths. Be prepared for tutoring sessions. Tutors can be effective educators by doing the following: Work with the learner. Together, create an effective learning environment. Know and use effective strategies. Be prepared to adjust instruction and make modifications to meet learner needs. Be observant. If you and the learner believe that difficulties are significantly impeding progress, talk with program staff. Staff may suggest other strategies and materials. Or, staff may want to screen for more information about the difficulties. Be ready to talk to program staff about any difficulties you encounter. Be able to describe the difficulty in terms of the learning activity. Seek resources from staff and be accepting of their ideas. Contact: NC Literacy Resource Center / NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project - 11 - OH/HO-1 How can tutors assist adults who have difficulty learning? Know about LD and available resources Know and use learner strengths and preferences Be an effective tutor Develop strengths Use multisensory techniques Modify as needed NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-2 Can You Name These Famous People with Learning Difficulties? Match these famous people to the descriptions below. A. B. C. D. E. F. Albert Einstein Cher George Patton Bruce Jenner Tom Cruise Agatha Christie 1____ Despite being a success in his chosen field, this entertainer can learn lines only by listening to a tape. He is formally diagnosed with dyslexia. 2____ This individual is well spoken enough to appear as an expert on TV, following his very successful athletic career. His reading problem was severe enough that it almost cost him the chance at any athletic scholarships. 3____ This person had a learning disability called dysgraphia, which prevented any understandable or legible written work. As a result, she had to dictate everything to a typist. 4____ This famous performer has achieved success in two major fields of entertainment. Unfortunately a math learning disability keeps her from remembering telephone numbers or from balancing a checkbook. 5____ When he was twelve years old, this person could not read, and he remained deficient in reading all his life. However, he could memorize entire lectures, which was how he got through school. His reading difficulty never stopped him from marching ahead. Answers: 1 E, 2 D, 3 F, 4 B, 5 C NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-3a Adults with Learning Disabilities Definitions and Issues Summer 1995 It has been estimated that 50-80% of the students in Adult Basic Education and literacy programs are affected by learning disabilities (LD). Unfortunately, there has been little research on adults who have learning disabilities, leaving literacy practitioners with limited information on the unique manifestations of learning disabilities in adults. One of the major goals of the National Adult Literacy and Learning Disabilities Center (National ALLD Center) is to raise awareness among literacy practitioners, policy makers, researchers, and adult learners about the nature of learning disabilities and their impact on the provision of literacy services. This fact sheet provides: a definition of learning disabilities in adults; a list of common elements found in many useful LD definitions; and a list of areas in which LD may affect life situations of adults. Background In 1963, the term "learning disability" was used to describe such disorders as perceptual handicaps, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia. In 1975 the passage of regulations accompanying Public Law 94-142, the Education for All Handicapped Children Act, specifically included a definition of learning disabilities for children that served as a guideline to provide appropriate educational, legislative, and judicial relief. The federal definition was based on the needs of children with learning disabilities, not recognizing how their disability would affect them as adults. It became apparent that learning disabilities persist throughout an individual's life, and it became crucial to develop a definition that describes LD but did not limit the condition to children. Thus, professionals in education, psychology, neurology, biology, and child development have developed definitions that describe learning disabilities as a lifelong condition. Definition Many useful definitions for LD have been accepted by educators, federal agencies, advocacy groups, and/or professional organizations. After reviewing several of these definitions, the National ALLD Center Advisory Board selected the Interagency Committee on Learning Disabilities' definition of learning disabilities for use by the National Adult Literacy Learning Disabilities Center. Advisory Board members selected this definition because it reflects current information and issues associated with LD, allows for the presence of learning disabilities at any age, and has been accepted by a committee with broad representation in the LD community. The Interagency Committee on Learning Disabilities Definition Learning disabilities is a generic term that refers to a heterogeneous group of disorders manifested by significant difficulties in acquisition and use of listening, speaking, reading, writing, reasoning, or mathematical abilities, or of social skills. These disorders are intrinsic to the individual and presumed to be due to central nervous system dysfunction. Even though a learning disability may occur concomitantly with other handicapping conditions (e.g., sensory impairment, mental retardation, social and emotional disturbance), with socioNational Adult Literacy and Learning Disabilities Center A Program of the National Institute for Literacy HO-3b environmental influences (e.g., cultural differences, insufficient or inappropriate instruction, psychogenic factors), and especially attention deficit disorder, all of which may cause learning problems, a learning disability is not the direct result of those conditions or influences. Definition Highlights There are many variations of learning disabilities. Learning disabilities may involve difficulties in any of the following skills: listening, speaking, reading, writing, reasoning, and mathematics. Social skills may be affected by the learning disability. Learning disabilities may be due to a central nervous system disorder. Although a learning disability may be present with other disorders, these conditions are not the cause of the learning disability. Common Elements in LD Definitions The following concepts are important to understanding the similarities and contrasts that exist among the many definitions of learning disabilities. Some definitions suggest that learning disabilities exist when a person has uneven patterns of development. Other definitions suggest that learning disabilities are indicated by aptitude-achievement discrepancies. Most definitions specify that the cause for learning disabilities is the result of a problem in the central nervous system. Some definitions suggest that learning disabilities are caused by interference in the neurological processes that make proficient performance possible. Most definitions imply that learning disabilities can be present at any age. Most definitions specify that problems understanding spoken or written language can be caused by learning disabilities. Some definitions specify that certain types of academic problems (e.g., those involving reading, writing, spelling, or math) can be caused by learning disabilities. Some definitions specify that problems involving social skills, spatial orientation, sensory integration, or motor skills can be manifestations of learning disabilities. Some definitions indicate that learning disabilities can coexist with other kinds of handicaps (e.g., emotional disturbance or sensory impairment). Other definitions are worded to eliminate the coexistence of learning disabilities with other disabling conditions. Impacts of LD in Adults The impacts of learning disabilities may compound with age. While individuals with learning disabilities demonstrate some intellectual strengths, their areas of disability may prevent them from excelling as adults in certain life situations at the same level as their peers. Areas where learning disabilities may affect adults include: Self Esteem—Being criticized, put down, teased, or rejected because of failures in academic, vocational, or social endeavors often leaves adults with learning disabilities with low self-esteem. Adults with low self-esteem tend not to take risks or strive to National Adult Literacy and Learning Disabilities Center A Program of the National Institute for Literacy HO-3c reach their potential. Also, adults with low self-esteem are less likely to advocate for themselves. Education—Learning disabilities that may manifest themselves in difficulties in spoken or written language, arithmetic, reasoning, and organizational skills will affect adults in adult basic education, literacy, postsecondary and vocational training settings. These students may perform at levels other than those expected of them. Adult educators are not always prepared to address the unique needs of learners with learning disabilities. Vocation—Errors are commonly found in filling out employment applications because of poor reading or spelling skills. Job-related problems frequently arise due to learning disabilities that cause difficulties in organization, planning, scheduling, monitoring, language comprehension and expression, social skills, and inattention. Social Interactions—Adults with learning disabilities may demonstrate poor judgment of others' moods and attitudes and appear to be less sensitive to others' thoughts and feelings. In social settings these adults may do or say inappropriate things and have problems comprehending humor, for example. They may have problems discriminating response requirements in social situations. These traits may result in a difficulty finding and keeping a job or developing long-term relationships. Independent Living—Responsibilities such as writing checks, filling out tax forms, or taking phone messages may present problems for adults with learning disabilities. Adults with LD may find themselves without the support systems (parents, schools, social services, etc.) that they relied on as children and have to incorporate their own accommodations when necessary. References Brown, D. (1980). Steps to Independence for People With Learning Disabilities. Washington, DC: Closer Look. Gerber, P., & Reiff, H. [Eds.] (1994). Learning Disabilities in Adulthood: Persisting Problems and Evolving Issues. Boston, MA: Andover Medical Publishers. Hammill, D.D. (1990). On Defining Learning Disabilities: An Emerging Consensus. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23 (2), 74-84. Kavanaugh, J. & Truss, T. [Eds.] (1988). Learning Disabilities: Proceedings of the National Conference. Parkton, MD: York Press. Smith, C. (1991). For You: Adults with Learning Disabilities. Ottawa, Ontario: Learning Disabilities Association of Canada. This material has been prepared under a cooperative agreement between the Academy for Educational Development (AED) and the National Institute for Literacy (NIFL), Grant No.X257B30002. Opinions, findings, conclusions and recommendation expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of AED or NIFL. This information is in the public domain, unless otherwise indicated. Readers are encouraged to copy; please credit the National ALLD Center. National Adult Literacy and Learning Disabilities Center A Program of the National Institute for Literacy OH/HO-84 Definitions • Learning Style—a preferred way of learning (visual, auditory, tactile/ kinesthetic—often a combination). • Learning Difficulty—condition that makes it hard to learn. A learning difficulty may be caused by educational, environmental, cultural, personal or other factors and can be addressed instructionally. • Learning Disability—disorder that is internal to persons of average or above average intelligence and causes significant difficulty with learning. LD must be diagnosed professionally. LD is not mental retardation. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-85 Learning Disabilities National Joint Committee on Learning Disabilities (1990) • Is a general term for a heterogeneous group of disorders. • Are manifested by significant difficulties in listening, speaking, reading, writing, or math. • Are part of the person’s makeup (they will not go away). • Are presumed to be a dysfunction of the central nervous system. • May be discovered across the life span. • May result in problems with behavior, social perceptions, and social interactions (but these are not the disability). • Are not the result of other disabilities such as loss of sight or hearing, lack of intelligence, or lack of schooling. Remember, learning disability is a legal term and requires formal professional diagnosis. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-86 Dyslexia International Dyslexia Association • Dyslexia is a distinct learning disability—a specific language-based disorder of constitutional origin—characterized by difficulties in single word decoding, reflecting insufficient phonological processing. • Single word decoding difficulties are often unexpected in relation to age and other cognitive and academic abilities—not the result of developmental disability or sensory impairment. • Dyslexia is manifest by variable difficulty with different forms of language including problems in acquiring reading, writing, and spelling. Like other learning disabilities, dyslexia requires formal, professional diagnosis. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-87 Assessment Continuum • Intake Assessment—gathering information to begin instruction Program staff, tutors and learners do this assessment. • Screening—informal assessment to discover more about learning difficulties and make suggestions for instruction Program staff do this assessment. • Diagnosis—formal means of identifying a learning disability Only qualified professionals diagnose LD. LD diagnosis has legal ramifications. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-8 Learning Styles Checklist Most people learn in a variety of ways. However, each person may prefer one or a combination of learning styles. Instead of a formal learning-styles inventory, use this checklist to get a rough idea of your learning preferences. Part 1: Place a check mark before any of the learning techniques below that describe ways you learn well. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ movies, television lectures group or panel discussion reading role-playing, acting making things with hands audiotapes, CD’s written reports body movement 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. ____ drawing/painting ____ question/answer sessions ____ graphs, tables, charts ____ recitation by others ____ writing ____ participating in physical games ____ touching objects ____ repeating information aloud ____ visualizing information Part 2: Use the key below to identify the learning style or styles that you prefer. Technique 1, 4, 8, 12, 14, 18 2, 3, 7, 11, 13, 17 5, 6, 9, 10, 15, 16, Style______________ Visual, including print Auditory, Aural Tactile-Kinesthetic Part 3: Now, put yourself in these situations. Think about how your responses to the checklist might be influenced by each situation. 1. New processes being implemented at work demand that you learn a great deal of new and unfamiliar information. 2. You have just purchased a computer or child’s toy that requires assembly. 3. An acquaintance is giving you directions to his house. Based on James and Galbraith. Perceptual Learning Styles: Implications and Techniques for the Practitioner. Lifelong Learning, 1985. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-9a Working From Strengths to Overcome Difficulties Visual Learners Learner Strengths Techniques to Support Learner’s Visual Learning Ability Likes to look at books and pictures Remembers and prefers visual details Prefers to see what needs to be learned Follows written directions easily Likes to look at orderly things— often demands neat surroundings Remembers where he or she has seen things Likes puzzles Probably able to draw balanced pictures Allow the learner to follow words with finger when reading and to touch the first letter of every word. Look for vocabulary words in newspapers, letters, papers and magazines. Use mapping strategy for comprehension, writing. Use KWL strategy for purposeful reading. Use visual aids (drawings, maps, lists). Use clues such as placing a green dot as a place to begin reading and a red dot to stop. Use a mirror to show how the mouth forms letters. Provide brightly colored pens to write with and large spaces upon which to write. Use a color-coding system for categorizing subjects, reading—blue; spelling—yellow; math—green, etc. Use the same system for categorizing and working with vowels, nouns, etc. Choose a work place with as few distractions as possible. Organize lesson materials and keep things in order during tutoring sessions. Encourage learner to keep a calendar for appointments, assignments, etc. Show an example of what the finished product should look like. Use matching games—jigsaw matching of words, prefixes, suffixes, etc. Encourage learner to draw his or her own picture to help understand the concept being taught. Learner Difficulties Techniques That Help Develop Visual Abilities Often has trouble following long explanation Doesn’t hear the sounds of letters in word contexts Has trouble understanding oral directions—needs to be shown Encourage learner to doodle or take notes while listening. Write out explanations with lists of important points. Provide written word lists that demonstrate the letter–sound correspondence in the words of the lesson you’re working on. Give one task at a time. Write out directions and let the learner copy them. Read directions aloud while the learner follows along. Demonstrate tasks. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-9b Working From Strengths to Overcome Difficulties Auditory Learners Learner Strengths Techniques to Support Learner’s Auditory Learning Ability Likes to read aloud Likes to talk about what needs to be learned Often a “chatterer” Can follow long explanations Enjoys music and rhythmic activities Knows lyrics to songs and memorizes easily Encourage learner to read aloud or into a tape recorder and then to play back tape privately for review. Encourage learner to use books on tapes and to follow along with text. Read aloud to the learner, asking him or her to repeat back what you read. Have learner participate in verbal drills. Talk through tasks step by step. Use “Think Aloud” strategy to model your thinking. Encourage thinking out loud. After reading, ask learner to tell the “story” to you. In a group setting speak directly to this person. Tape the lecture or speech for the learner. Dictate spelling words and sentences for learner to write. Create poems, songs, or raps. Play lots of rhyming and blending games. Create mnemonics. Learner Difficulties Techniques That Help Develop Auditory Abilities Easily distracted by noise Has trouble with written directions and maps Needs oral directions Find a quiet place to work. Use earphones to help cut out distractions caused by outside sources. Don’t distract learner when he or she is working. If you need to repeat instructions, use the same words. This person may be able to listen to a radio for background noise while doing work. Give one task at a time using as few words as possible when giving directions. Read directions with learner following along. Encourage learner to rehearse directions to commit them to memory. Tape record assignments. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-9c Working From Strengths to Overcome Difficulties Tactile–Kinesthetic Learners Learner Strengths Techniques to Support Learner’s Tactile–Kinesthetic Learning Ability Enjoys doing things with hands Builds or fixes things Has good motor skills Uses concrete objects as reminders Places objects in order Draws pictures as reminders Touches things as reminders Learner may need to talk to himself or herself in order to understand a concept or may need to see himself or herself saying things in a mirror. Provide stories that are filled with action. Encourage learner to demonstrate processes while explaining them. Encourage writing. Encourage copying of vocabulary words and sentence patterns. Use concrete objects (e.g. playing cards, rulers, measuring spoons, etc.) as learning aids for establishing patterns. Use manipulatives (colored discs, rods, etc.) for math and letter tiles or word cards for word learning. Use mapping for writing and comprehension. Use textured letter forms and manipulatives. Use KWL strategy for comprehension. Use VAKT strategy for helping learners to remember spelling and word parts. Learner Difficulties Techniques That Help Develop Tactile–Kinesthetic Abilities Constantly in motion Wiggles, plays with pencils, etc. Easily distracted, has a short attention span Difficulty with rote counting and sequential materials without aids Difficulty with learning abstract symbols such as letters and numerals Don’t ask learner to sit for too long. Take frequent breaks—about one every 10 minutes. Allow learner space to work and move around, if needed. Set specific deadlines for completion of assignments. Allow use of “tactile enhancers” such as small objects to squeeze, roll, etc., while learner is engaged in learning. Keep a calendar of appointments and activities. Mark calendar with frequent due dates. Suggest assignments be put on a clipboard and done “on the run.” When memorization is necessary, help learner to associate some sort of bodily movement with what needs to be remembered. Use tactile memory aids (colored book marks, calendars, etc.). Alternate written and oral work. Provide sufficient practice time. Structure lessons following a consistent format. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-10 Modifying Instruction • Modifying tasks uses students’ learning strengths to work on difficulties. • Modifications are not cheating—they are ways to make things fair. • Modifications do not mean others are doing the work for the learners. The students are doing their own work in a way that works for them. • Modifications can be as simple as using fingers in math—or as complex as using a voice-activated computer to type what is said. • The key is to match the modification to the learners’ learning strengths and needs. • Sometimes modifications are the only way to complete a task. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 HO-11 Hints for Tutors Assisting Learners Who Have Difficulty Learning Involve the learner in all aspects of instruction. Confer with the learner about what he or she sees as his or her strengths, difficulties, interests, and preferences. Work with the learner to set short-term goals that lead to immediate successes. Teach the skills your learner needs and wants to learn. Determine together how you will evaluate progress toward goals. Discuss techniques that are working for the learner. Create an effective learning environment. Establish a routine to promote order and consistency. Reduce distractions. Work in a private area when possible. Turn off radios, and remove distracting visual items. Use incandescent rather than florescent lights. Give instructions orally (tape record if needed) and in writing. Allow the learner to repeat instructions as often as needed. Emphasize learner strengths, and encourage the learner to use them. Be sure the learner sees the value of practice. Help the learner generalize from tutoring context to life contexts. Reinforce the learner’s efforts and progress. Praise even minor successes. Encourage use of learning aides (calculators, highlighters, tape recorders, computers, maps, charts, fingers, rulers, “squeeze balls,” etc.) Be well prepared. It is easier for the tutor to adjust teaching methods than it is for learners to change the way they learn. Work with fewer skills, and work better by being selective. Teach the skills directly, in meaningful context and with plenty of practice. Relate new concepts to practical applications. Build on what the learner already knows. Model use of skills. Do lots of explaining. Be able to use a variety of solid instructional strategies. Use multisensory strategies so the learner can see, say, hear, touch—and thus develop full mental images that stick and make sense. Be able to modify strategies for the learner or substitute alternative strategies for those that are not working. Vary lessons, reteach and review in a variety of ways. Change an activity when it is not working. Stay in touch with program staff. Talk to program staff about any difficulties you encounter. Be able to describe the difficulty in terms of the learning activity. Be accepting of ideas from the staff. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-12 Involve the Learner • Talk with the learner about what he or she sees as strengths, difficulties, interests, and preferences. • Together, set short-term goals that lead to immediate successes. • Teach the skills the learner needs and wants to learn. • Determine together how to evaluate progress toward goals. • Discuss techniques that are working for the learner. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-13 Create an Effective Learning Environment • Establish an orderly, consistent routine. • Reduce auditory and visual distractions. Work in a private area with incandescent lighting. • Give instructions orally (tape record) and in writing. Allow learner to repeat. • Emphasize learner strengths, and encourage learner to use them. • Be sure learner sees the value of practice. • Help learner generalize from tutoring context to life contexts. • Reinforce learner’s efforts and progress. Praise even minor successes. • Encourage the use of learning aides (calculator, highlighters, tape recorders, computers, maps, charts, fingers, rulers, and “squeeze balls.” NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-14 Be Well Prepared • Work on fewer skills. • Teach the skills directly, in a meaningful context, and with plenty of practice. • Relate new concepts to practical applications. • Build on what the learner already knows. • Model the use of skills, and do lots of explaining. • Be able to use a variety of strategies. • Use multisensory strategies so learner can see, say, hear, touch—and thus develop full mental images that stick and make sense. • Be able to modify or substitute alternative strategies for those that are not working. • Vary lessons, teaching in different ways. • Change an activity when it is not working. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-15 Stay in Touch with Program Staff • Talk with program staff about any difficulties you encounter. • Be able to describe learner difficulty in terms of learning activities. • Be accepting of ideas from program staff. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-16 Direct Instruction— “Quick” version of a familiar format I do • Tutor provides background information, sets the purpose, and demonstrates the skill. We do • Tutor and student accomplish the task, and practice the skill together. You do • Student applies the skill independently in new situations. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-17 Shared Responsibilities • Program Responsibilities Provide a range of services to students and tutors. Train tutors to work with students. • Tutor Responsibilities Work with learners to set goals, plan, and modify instruction. Use many strategies to help students learn. Stay in contact with program staff. • Student Responsibilities Work with tutors. Tell tutors about difficulties. NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-18 Learning Disabilities Resources • Program • Community • NC LRC/NCCCS http://www.nclrc.state.nc.us 800-553-9759 Library materials Bridges to Practice overheads and handouts Bibliographies Gateway to LINCS literacy resources NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001 OH/HO-19 12-04.Learning Difficulties Module PP NC Literacy Resource Center, NC Community College System 800-553-9759, 919-733-7051 Learning Disabilities Training and Dissemination Project, 2001