Big Idea: Food Webs Food Webs show the feeding relationships between organisms and are used to show the energy transfer or energy flow in an ecosystem by indicating specifically who eats who. The interconnecting relationships, illustrated by a food web, give an ecosystem its resilience. The concept of Food Webs fits into the VCE Study design for Biology under Unit 2, Organisms and their environment, Area of Study 2, Dynamic Ecosystems (VCAA, 2009). What you intend the students to learn about this idea. Food webs show all the feeding relationships, and how individual organisms can be part of several food chains at the same time. All these cross connecting relationships give an ecosystem its resilience. The feeding relationships between organisms can be shown as food chains. The system of ‘who eats who’ in an ecosystem is a food chain and shows the transfer of energy between organisms. An organism that is part of a number of food chains in a food web is less likely to be affected by the loss of one source of food. Each feeding level in a food web is called a trophic level. An organism may function at more than one trophic level in a food web. 1st trophic level includes producers (autotrophs) – source of energy (food) is energy from sunlight captured during photosynthesis. All other organisms are consumers (heterotrophs), which are dependent on producers for their source of energy, which is provided in the form of food. 2nd trophic level includes primary consumers (herbivores) - source of chemical energy (food) is from eating plants or other producers. 3rd trophic level includes secondary consumers (carnivores) - source of chemical energy (food) is from eating plant-eaters. 4th trophic level includes tertiary consumers (top carnivore) - source of chemical energy (food) is from eating predators. There are several categories of consumers; herbivores, carnivores, parasites (which feed on living organisms without killing them) and omnivores. Scavengers, detritivores and decomposers all consume dead organisms or organic material. There are different types of food chains called predator-prey, parasite-host, detritivore and decomposer food chains, depending on the relationships between organisms. Why it is important for student to know this. To develop student knowledge and understanding that: A food web is a complex network of many interconnected feeding relationships. Flow of energy along a food chain is a fundamental process in an ecosystem. Sustainable ecosystems rely on a continued supply and exchange of energy from the sun. Animals cannot make their own food, so they must eat other plants and/or animals. Chemical energy from one trophic level passes to organisms at a higher trophic level. The loss of an organism within the food web can have an impact on other organisms at all trophic levels. Relationships in ecosystems can be complex and finely balanced. Human activities can have an impact on the relationships and interactions within ecosystems. What else you know about this idea (that you do not intend student to know yet). Impact of bioaccumulation within a food web. Implication of resource availability on populations. Information about numbers of organisms at each trophic level can be shown for an ecosystem through ecological pyramids. Ecosystems differ in productivity because of factors that limit photosynthesis, including temperature, sunlight, nutrients and water. Impact of human activity and environmental issues on ecosystems such as deforestation, oil spills, global change in CO2, greenhouse effect. Implications of biogeochemical cycles including carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus and water) on ecological systems. Knowledge about students’ thinking/difficulties connected with teaching this idea. Requires prior knowledge and understanding of concepts such as autotrophs, heterotrophs and photosynthesis. Concepts presented in textbooks are often simplistic; therefore students may find it difficult to grasp the intricacies of a food web. Students may find it difficult to understand that an organism can change its trophic level. Students may believe the simpler the organism, the simpler the food it eats. Therefore, they may believe as organisms increase in complexity the more complex the food it eats. Students may believe a population located higher on a given food chain within a food web is predator of all populations located below it in the chain. Detritivores, decomposers and scavengers are often left out of food chains even though they are essential for nutrient cycling Students may not know the food chains and webs in their local area Students may think that varying the population will only affect the organisms that are directly connected through the food web. Students may think that food chains only involve predator and prey, no producers, detritivores, decomposers . Student may have difficulty in understanding that a smaller organism can feed on a larger organism, as in parasite-host interactions or decomposers. The life cycle of many parasites is complex. Students need to understand that at different stages of development a parasite may feed on a separate host species, and as such may be linked to a number of food chains. Teaching procedures (and particular reasons for using these to engage with this idea). Speed date activity: Each student is given an ‘identity’. Each identity is a concept that is to be understood as part of this topic. ‘Identities’ could include; trophic levels, producer organisms, primary consumer, secondary consumer, tertiary consumer, ecosystem, food web, etc. Students are given time to research their own ‘identity’ and then participate in a speed date with the rest of the class. Each student has two minutes to talk about themselves (ie. their ‘identity’), discuss what you like, what you do for a living, where you like to hang out, etc. Time is also given for the students’ date to ask questions. After the allocated time each student swaps to a new date. This activity gives students the opportunity to research and discuss one of the concepts from this topic, it also allows them to listen and get involved in concepts being described by other students. Practical activity: Provide student with a list of organisms that live in a pond community, with details each organism’s food source. Ask student to construct a food web and identify the organisms in various trophic levels. Specific questions would also be provided. Have students then remove one of the organisms from the food web. What are the implications? This activity gives students the opportunity to consider trophic levels and the impact of relationships within a food web. Slowmation: Students create a stop-motion animation to explain a food web. Slowmation is a simplified way of making an animation with learners moving models whilst taking digital still photos and playing them at 2 photos/ second to create a slow moving image. The explanation or story can be enhanced by adding narration, text or music. This activity gives students the opportunity to use ICT to illustrate their understanding of the concept. Specific ways of ascertaining students’ understanding or confusion around this idea (including likely range of responses). Asking directed questions to students in the class and having class discussions on the topic. Through construction of a food web, the teacher is looking to see if students can put knowledge of food webs into practice. Concept maps – students can make connections using key words and phrases from this topic. Apply understanding by giving examples of organisms in an ecosystem that, for example, occupy different trophic levels. The teacher is looking for demonstrated understanding of the concepts covered. Resources: Binghampton University (2007), Common Ecological Misconceptions, Retrieved 3 August 2010, from http://ecomisconceptions.binghamton.edu/foodwebs.htm Biozone (2010). Biozone Biolinks. Retrieved on 2 August, 2010, from http://www.biozone.com.au/biolinks/ECOLOGY.html#E5 Evans, B., Ladiges, P., McKenzie, J., Sanders, Y. (2007). Heinemann Biology 1, 4th Edition, Harcort Education, Port Melbourne Victoria Food Chains (2010), Food Chains, Retrieved 4 August, 2010, from http://users.rcn.com/jkimball.ma.ultranet/BiologyPages/F/FoodChains.html#Food_Webs Kinnear, J., Martin, M. (2006). Nature of Biology Book 1, 3rd Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Australia University of Wollongong (2010), Slowmation, Retrieved on 4 August, 2010 from http://www.slowmation.com.au/ University of Maine (2008), Energy Transfer and Food Webs Background, Retrieved 3 August, 2010 from http://misclab.umeoce.maine.edu/boss/classes/SMS_491_2008/week6/foodweb_bckgrnd.pdf Victorian Curriculum Assessment Authority (VCAA), 2009. Biology, Victorian Certificate of Education Study Design, retrieved on 28 June 2010 from http://www.vcaa.vic.edu.au/vce/studies/biology/biologyindex.html Wikipedia (2010). Food Chain. Retrieved 4 August, 2010, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_web