SOC ∙ Ms. Wiley ∙ Crime & Punishment—Cross-Cultural Wars, D___



Name:
Culture A fines an individual for stealing bread and milk from a general store
o Has higher crime rates
Culture B cuts off the individual’s hand after stealing bread and milk from a general store
o Has significantly lower crime rates
Which culture takes the wiser approach? Which culture has a “better” sense of morality?
Explain:
The World's Most Barbaric Punishments, BY NEWSWEEK 7/8/10
An Iranian woman was spared being stoned to death for adultery this week, in response to international outcry. But the barbaric
punishment is not the only medieval remedy still meted out by courts around the world.
Blinding
In 2003 an Indian citizen working in Saudi Arabia took part in a brawl, wounding a man's eye. Puthan Veettil Abd ul-Latif Noushad
was eventually sentenced, in 2005, to have his own right eye gouged out as punishment. It was, according to charity Human Rights
Watch, the third eye-gouging sentence handed down within a year. HRW was unable to confirm whether any of the gougings had
actually taken place. In Noushad's case, the Indian government made an appeal for clemency. It is not clear if the appeal was
successful. The State Department, on its website, still lists eye-gouging as a punishment that can be handed down by courts in
Saudia Arabia.
Iran also allows chemical blinding. In 2005 a 27-year-old man named only as Majid had been stalking a woman, Ameneh Bahrami.
When she refused his advances he poured a container of sulphuric acid over her. Bahrami was blinded and disfigured. Majid was
sentenced to have five drops of hydrochloric acid dripped into each open eye, blinding him.
Amputation
Right hands have been cut off at the wrist as punishment for theft in Sharia-controlled areas of Nigeria and in Saudi Arabia. Repeat
offenders in the latter country can lose both hands, and legs are sometimes taken for other offenses. An executioner, Muhammad
Saad al-Beshi, told the Saudi newspaper Arab News in 2003 that "I use a special sharp knife, not a sword. When I cut off a hand I cut
it from the joint. If it is a leg the authorities specify where it is to be taken off, so I follow that."
In Iran, in early 2008, five robbers had their right hands and left feet cut off in one week—a practice known as cross amputation.
According to The New York Times "doctors watched to limit bleeding and infection during the procedure." Hands and feet are also
reportedly cut off as punishment in Yemen, Sudan, and Somalia.
Beheading
Recent figures suggest that about 100 people per year are beheaded in Saudi Arabia. According to unconfirmed reports the
condemned are given tranquilizers, and taken to a public square after midday prayers. They are forced to kneel facing Mecca, over a
blue plastic sheet. "With one stroke of the sword I severed his head. It rolled meters away," said one executioner, al-Beshi.
Shooting
Ronnie Lee Gardner, a convicted murderer who elected to die by firing squad, was strapped to a chair at a prison in Draper, Utah,
and shot with .30 caliber bullets just after midnight on June 18 this year.
According to the Associated Press his head was "secured by a strap across his forehead. Harness-like straps constrained his chest. His
handcuffed arms hung at his sides. A white cloth square affixed to his chest over his heart—maybe 3 inches across—bore a black
target."
Five police officers took aim from 25 feet away—four of the guns were loaded and one contained a blank, so no officer could know
definitively that he had killed Gardner.
It was the first U.S. death by firing squad in 14 years.
Flogging and caning
Singapore administers caning for many offenses—including overstaying a 90-day tourist visa. The punishment is also common in
Malaysia and Brunei. Unconfirmed reports suggest that officials use a thick rattan cane, four feet long and half an inch in diameter,
soaked in water. This picture set and video from Malaysia—which we strenuously do not recommend you click through to—suggests
that offenders are strapped naked to an A-frame and struck repeatedly with the cane, raising blood and welts. Foreign nationals are
not immune—American Michael Fay was flogged in Singapore in 1994, despite pleas from President Clinton, and a Swiss man
received three strokes last month for a similar offense.
Flogging, or lashing with a whip or strap, is widespread. It is used in Iran, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, the United Arab Emirates, and the
Bahamas, among others, for offenses from theft to adultery. In the Swat region of northwestern Pakistan, where the Taliban have de
facto power, a commander was videotaped flogging a woman last year. The New York Times reported that she may have stepped
out of her house without being escorted by a male, or spurned a local Taliban chief's advances. In any case, she was held face down
and beaten with a leather strap, while a large circle of men watched. "Leave me for the moment — you can beat me again later,”
she screamed, according to the Times, "pleading for a reprieve and writhing in pain."
Stoning
Convicted of adultery, 43-year-old Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani narrowly escaped being stoned to death in Iran this
week. According to Amnesty International, the Iranian Penal Code specifies that "stones are large enough to cause pain, but not so
large as to kill the victim immediately." Article 102 of the Penal Code states that men should be buried up to their waists and women
up to their breasts for the purpose of execution by stoning. Article 104 states, with reference to the penalty for adultery, that the
stones used should "not be large enough to kill the person by one or two strikes; nor should they be so small that they could not be
defined as stones." The punishment is also used in Saudi Arabia and Somalia.
A young woman, Aisho Ibrahim Dhuhulow, was buried up to her neck and stoned to death in front of a large crowd in the Somali city
of Kismayo in 2008, according to the BBC. "She was asked several times to review her confession but she stressed that she wanted
Sharia law and the deserved punishment to apply," said a local Islamist leader.
1.
What is your reaction to the punishments described in this article?
2.
Can you see any benefits to living in a society with these punishments? Why or why not?
3.
In America, there are 18 states that have officially abolished the death penalty. For those states where it is still in use, is the
death penalty warranted? How does its use compare/contrast with the punishments described above?