Chelsea Blair MESC Summer Institution Revised – Teaching the Middle East Unit July 20, 2014 Unit Title: Iran in the Twentieth Century About this unit: - This unit was designed with a High School World History class in mind. I chose to focus this unit solely on Iran because I think it is an extremely important player in today’s current events and yet we do not know very much about it or the role that the U.S. played in its recent history. Being able to draw connections between the past and the present represents one of the most significant skills students should build during history courses. This aim will be one of the driving forces of this unit. - This unit will cover Iran’s history from the turn of the twentieth century to the present. In particular, it will deal with the effects of foreign involvement in Iran. Previously, this class would have theoretically covered a unit on World War I/World War II and Russian history from the Bolshevik Revolution. - This unit’s lessons are designed for 80-90 minute long class periods. Curriculum Framing Questions: - How did foreign interest and imperialism chart a new course for Iran and neighboring countries? - In what ways did the world wars help create a “modern” Iranian state? - How did western involvement contribute to the political revolutions in Iran in the mid-twentieth century? Learning Objectives: - Students will be able to describe the spheres of influence in Iran in the early 1900s. - Be able to discuss why the west was interested in Iran and how they influenced its government. - Be able to summarize the role oil played in foreign interest as well as the changes made to Iran’s government in the twentieth century. - Be able to draw connections between events that occurred in the early/mid-1900s and how the consequences of those events are present in today’s current issues. Standards: - ODE.HS.2: Analyze the complexity and investigate causes and effects of significant events in world, U.S., and Oregon history. - ODE.HS.61: Analyze an event, issue, problem, or phenomenon, identifying characteristics, influences, causes and both short- and long-term effects. - ODE.HS.63: Engage in informed and respectful deliberation and discussion of issues, events, and ideas. - CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.2: determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source; provide an accurate summary of how key events or ideas develop over the course of the text. - - CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.3: Analyze in detail a series of events described in a text; determine whether earlier events caused later ones or simply preceded them. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.6: Compare the point of view of two or more authors for how they treat the same or similar topics, including which details they include and emphasize in their respective accounts. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.8: Assess the extent to which the reasoning and evidence in a text support the author’s claims. Unit Outline: - Lesson 1: The Middle East o In this lesson, we will review what we have covered previously throughout the year about the Middle East. This includes the region’s geography, Mesopotamia and the Fertile Crescent, and the area’s contact with the west through the early 1900s (exploration, trade, and WWI). - Lesson 2: Iran & the Spheres of Influence (Included below) o The purpose of this lesson is to connect Iran’s modern history with the students’ prior knowledge of WWI and WWII. - Lesson 3: The Issue of Oil (Included below) o The purpose of this lesson is to emphasize the effect both world wars had on Iran and to discuss the role oil played in their government on a national and international level. - Lesson 4: The 1979 Revolution, Part I o This lesson will focus on how the 1979 Revolution came about in Iran following the 1953 coup d’état by westerners and what the revolution looked like for the people living in Iran at the time. The story “Persepolis” by Marjane Satrapi will be used as a visual reference here (either the graphic novel or the film). - Lesson 5: The 1979 Revolution, Part II o The second part to this subject will center more on what the consequences of this revolution were, especially in terms of Iran’s relations with foreign countries. This is when the discussion really starts to focus on how Iran is viewed today and how those portrayals came about. The film “Argo” will be used as a visual reference. - Lesson 6: The Iran-Iraq War o This lesson will start moving the unit from the past to the present. In discussing this war, we will be able to draw upon current violence in the Middle East. - Lesson 7: The Nuclear Crisis o The focus here will be to examine the current stereotypes surrounding Iran and why the west considers them a nuclear threat. We will be looking at both sides of each of these subjects in particular what Iran thinks of westerners. - Lesson 8: Iran Today o In the final lesson, we will discuss the current state of Iran’s government and how Iran is seen in the world today. This will be accomplished through the presentation of the students’ summative assessment, the current events assignment. They will also participating in a culminating discussion about how the events that took place in the twentieth century connect back to and affected the present. Summative Assessment: - The summative assessment for this unit is not introduced in the two lesson plans provided here. However, it would most likely have been introduced in the next lesson in the sequence once the content had moved into the last 50 years or so. This will be attached at the end of this document. This assessment will draw on the learning objective that students will be able to draw connections between events that occurred in the early/mid-1900s and how the consequences of those events are present in today’s current issues. - The instructions are as follows: o Find an article about Iran either in the newspaper or online from a newspaper source, Time.com, USA Today, The New York Times, etc., or any other reputable national or local source. Read the article and fill out the statements or answer the questions below. You may not use articles on Entertainment/Gossip or Sports. Because this is a current events assignment you are to choose an article that is no more than a month old from when the assignment is given. Read the Rubric at the end of the worksheet to complete all the requirements for this assignment. Attach the article to the worksheet. Helpful resources for teachers: - Iran Through the Looking Glass: History, Reform, and Revolution (The Choices Program, Brown University) o www.choices.edu/resources/supplemental/_iran.php - “US-Iran Relations: A Brief Guide” (BBC News: The Middle East) o http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-24316661 - The New Middle East (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) o http://carnegieendowment.org/files/new_middle_east_final.pdf - Iran and the First World War: Battleground of the Great Powers by Touraj Atabaki o http://books.google.com/books?id=M3adD9kNH1gC&pg=PA59&lpg=PA59&dq=%22W orld+War+I%22%2B%22Tangistan%22&source=bl&ots=fP73oKNOh7&sig=4pm1Rli8a Yr87ev0T2t9YEAUbnQ&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=1&ct=result#v=onepa ge&q=%22World%20War%20I%22%20%22Tangistan%22&f=false - The Middle East in Transition: Questions for U.S. Policy (The Choices Program, Brown University) o http://www.choices.edu/resources/supplemental_mideast.php - The First World War by Hew Strachan o http://books.google.com/books/about/The_First_World_War.html?id=KZHITOPMf4gC o “The First World War (Jihad 1914 – 1916) – BBC Documentary” (based on the chapter in the book) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cei8dFUzZ3s - “Blood and Oil: The Middle East in World War I” o http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jP0evPEsc30 - Middle East Cartoon History o http://mideastcartoonhistory.com/1941To52/1946.html Unit: Iran in the Twentieth Century Grade Level: 10 Course: World History Lesson Topic: Iran & the Spheres of Influence: Early Iran through WWII Time Allotted: 80-90 min. Unit Essential Question: How did foreign interest and imperialism chart a new course for Iran and neighboring countries? Lesson Question: What are some of the connections between foreign involvement and conflict in Iran? PREPARATION Purpose/Rationale: The purpose for this lesson is to connect Iran’s modern history with the students’ prior knowledge of World War I. By starting with the early 1900s, the students will gain a better understanding of how the west became involved with Iran and begin to see how the seeds of current issues were sown. Prior Knowledge/Background Information: The students in this World History class would have already covered the idea of Persia and the Fertile Crescent when studying ancient civilizations. They would also have completed an in-depth unit on World War I/ World War II. Therefore, with both of these topics, the goal is refresh the students’ memory and bring the Middle East’s role in these wars to the forefront of our discussions. During the previous lesson, we will have ended the class with the following activity: Student’s Actions Teacher’s Actions Students will take out a spare sheet of paper and write down what they think of when they hear Iran or any questions that they have about the country. Ask the students to take out a spare sheet of paper. Instruct them to write down what they think about when they hear Iran or any questions that they have about the country. They will have 5 minutes. Students will share what they wrote with the people sitting next to them. After 5 minutes, they will come back together. Allow the students 5 minutes to share with the people sitting next to them before coming back together as a class. Students will share what they wrote down and what they discussed with their neighbor. Call on students to share some of what they wrote while you write their points up on the board. After you have several points written up there, introduce the following with the students: - What kind of themes are we seeing here? - Which of these topics has to do with the questions you had about Iran? - Does anything surprise you about what the class came up with? You will use these questions as part of a discussion in the following class period. * Slide 1 on the PowerPoint contains a modern map of Iran. It is up to you whether or not to show this at the beginning of this activity as a reference for the students. Materials/Resources Needed: The teacher will need a computer and a projector in order to download and then display the lesson’s PowerPoint. There should also be copies of the Choices Reading: From Cyrus to Reza Shah (p. 2 – 15) and the graphic organizer made for each student. Depending on how quickly the class is able to move through the first lesson of the unit, this reading could be introduced as homework that is due in this class period. That way, you are left with more time for discussion. PROCEDURES AND ASSESSMENT OF STUDENT LEARNING Introduction: Student’s Actions Students will come in and settle down for class. Students will participate in a class discussion about what the class collectively knows and is interested in about Iran. Teacher’s Actions Resources Greet the class and introduce the topic of this upcoming unit. - They will be starting a thematic unit on Iran that covers from 1900 to the present. The primary goal in doing a unit on Iran is to introduce the students to a country that they do not know a lot about even though it is in the news constantly. Time 3 min. Start off the class with a continued discussion of what the information they compiled about Iran at the end of the previous lesson. Call on students to share some of what they wrote while you write their points up on the board. After you have several points written up there, discuss the following with the students: - What kind of themes are we seeing here? - Which of these topics has to do with the questions you had about Iran? - Does anything surprise you about what the class came up with? 15 min. * Slide 1 on the PowerPoint contains a modern map of Iran. It is up to you whether or not to show this at the beginning of this activity as a reference for the students. Body of Lesson: Student’s Actions Teacher’s Actions Resources Time Use the PowerPoint to go over some of the basic background information about Iran. PowerPoint. 15-20 min. - - - Students will consider the images on Slide 4 concerning Persian culture and modern Iran. They will then share with the person sitting next to them what they think these images represent and how they are different. After a couple of minutes, the class will come together and participate in discussion. Students should be ready to share if called on. In groups of 3, students will read a section of the Choices reading. Then they will fill out their graphic organizer for that section. To do this, the students will: - State what the text says - State what they know - And then answer the questions Slide 2: Introduction Slide. This is simply an introduction to the content of today’s lesson. It should be noted though that the Iranian flag shown on this slide is not the current one. This flag was adopted after the Constitutional Revolution of 1906 but was replaced by the one we see today in July 1980 as a result of the Islamic Revolution. Slide 3: Map of the Persian Empire. This slide shows a map of the Persian Empire at its grandest. Persia is a name that was given to this region by its western counterparts and so in 1935, Reza Shah instructed foreign dignitaries to officially use the term Iran. Slide 4: Persian Culture vs. Today’s Perception of Iran. Through images, this slide shows how this area is perceived. Engage in a discussion with the students about what they think these images say about Iran and how important perception is concerning these topics. Why is it so hard to believe they are from the same place? To do this, use a Think-Pair-Share. Introduce the main activity for today: use a graphic organizer to take notes on the history of Iran leading up to WWII. The guidelines for this activity are: - In groups of 3, you will read a portion of the Choices reading and fill out the graphic organizer for that section. - For each section, there are 2 questions that you will have to answer. (These are displayed on Slide 5). - Once you have finished, be prepared to share your findings with the class and take notes on what the other groups present. The graphic organizer that they are using is an It Says-I Say-And So. The teacher should go over how to use the graphic organizer before the activity begins. 10 min. Choices Reading. Graphic Organizer. 20-25 min. Students will report out their findings to the class. As other groups are presenting, they will remain respectful and write down the questions and answers for each of the reading’s sections. Have each group report to the class what they found out from each section. If time is running out or you are worried about the students’ level of engagement, tell the students that they should only worry about writing down the question and the “And So” for each section. However, the reporting group should still explain how they reached that conclusion. 20-25 min. * How you divide the class into groups of 3 is up to you. One way is to have the students form their own groups. Another is to count off each student and then have them find their partners. Closure/Extensions: (Determining progress toward daily objective.) Student’s Actions Teacher’s Actions Resources Time Write down their homework assignment for next time. PowerPoint Slide 6. 2 min. Introduce the homework assignment for next time. Homework: Students will think about the following questions and write down their thoughts/answers on a notecard. They will use this notecard for a discussion at the beginning of the next class period. - What connections are you beginning to see between Iran’s government and Islam? - Between foreign involvement and conflict in Iran? - How might these events relate to what you already knew about Iran? ASSESSMENT Students will be assessed on their class participation. While the students are working in small groups, I will be moving around the room making sure that everyone is on task and working well with others. I will also be checking to make sure that the students are filling out their graphic organizer which will count towards their participation. As their homework for next time, students will need to fill out a notecard that discusses the following questions: What connections are you beginning to see between Iran’s government and Islam? What connections are you beginning to see between foreign involvement and Iran? How might these events relate to what you already knew about Iran? Iran: From Cyrus to Reza Shah Graphic Organizer Question It Says… I Say… And So… Step 1… Write the question (provided) Step 2… Find information from the text that will help answer the question. Step 3… Think about how this information relates to the question. Step 4… Combine what the text says with what you know to come up with the answer. Early Iran (p. 2 – 4) How did the territory’s geographic conditions influence early Iranian society? What did becoming an empire mean for the people of Iran? Islam and the Safavids (p. 4 – 6) What role did Islam play in the creation and rule of the Safavid Dynasty? Shi’ism (p. 5) Describe the origins of Shi’ism. The Qajar Dynasty (p. 6 – 9) In what ways was Iran’s economy unbalanced and what were its effects? Why were Britain and Russia so involved in Iran? The Constitutional Revolution (p. 9 – 12) What were the constitution’s primary aims and why was it unsuccessful? If Iran was neutral in WWI, then how was it affected so negatively? Reza Shah (p. 12 – 15) In what ways did Reza Shah attempt to modernize Iran? How was Iran’s political and economic power affected by WWII? Unit: Iran in the Twentieth Century Grade Level: 10 Course: World History Lesson Topic: The Issue of Oil Time Allotted: 80-90 min. Unit Essential Question: How did foreign interest and imperialism chart a new course for Iran and neighboring countries? Lesson Question: What was the so threatening about nationalized oil? PREPARATION Purpose/Rationale: The purpose of this lesson is to recap what the students read through last class about Iran’s history, to emphasize the effect both world wars had on Iran, and to discuss the role oil played in their government on a national and international level. Prior Knowledge/Background Information: After the previous class’s reading activity, the students should have a basic knowledge of Iranian history. The goal of the first part of this lesson will be to refresh them on what they have learned and emphasize Iran’s role in WWI/WWII, a subject that the students have also studied before. We will also be drawing on the information the students compiled during the brainstorming activity at the end of the previous lesson. Materials/Resources Needed: The teacher will need a computer and a projector in order to download and then display the lesson’s PowerPoint. There should also be copies of the 6 U.S. Documents of the 1953 Coup (TRB p. 22 – 32) and the OPVL chart for each student. Blood and Oil – The Middle East in World War I (Iran Clip): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvjsQw23O68 [2:08 min] Iran and World War 2 Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-VDo97ZTsik#t=363 [starts at 6 min., 6:07 min. remaining] PROCEDURES AND ASSESSMENT OF STUDENT LEARNING. Introduction: Student’s Actions Teacher’s Actions Resources Time Students will come in and settle down for class. Greet the class and introduce the topic for today. (This is summarized in the Rationale.) 2 min. Students will use their notecards to participate in a discussion about what the class as a whole presented about Iran at the end of the last class period. Students will use their notecards (their homework assignment) to participate in a discussion using the following questions: - What connections are you beginning to see between Iran’s government and Islam? - Between foreign involvement and conflict in Iran? - How might these events relate to what you already knew about Iran? 10-15 min. Body of Lesson: Student’s Actions Students will participate in a class discussion about what they learned last time about Iranian history concerning: Islam’s role in Iran, the Constitutional Revolution of 1906, the Spheres of Influence, WWI, and WWII. Teacher’s Actions Resources Time Using the first several slides of the PowerPoint, you will engage the students in a discussion/mini-lecture about the information that was covered in the reading last class period. You will do this by: - Clicking on a slide and asking the students what they remember about that particular topic (if they have their readings from last time then they can have them out). - During these discussions, ask the students questions that probe at deeper issues or the main ideas of each topic. - After the discussion, show the main points of that topic on the slide and move on. The topics that will be covered are Islam’s role in Iran, the Constitutional Revolution of 1906, and the Spheres of Influence. These discussions do not have to be very long, e PowerPoint. 10-15 min. When you get to WWI and WWII, there are clips that go with them. Discuss the topic with the students, summarize the information with them, and then play the designated clips. Blood and Oil. (2 min.) 15 min. Iran and World War 2. (6 min.) *Note: Use the question, “In what ways did WWI help create a “modern” Iranian state?” during your discussion on WWI. **Note: An interesting current event that goes along with the WWII clip is that Iran (as of 2009) is currently seeking reparations from the Allies for damages/expenses done to their country back in the 1940s. Participate in a class discussion. 10 min. As a transition, briefly brainstorm with the class about what types of foreign involvement they have already seen in Iran and what their reasons were for doing so. Present a mini-lecture on the role of oil in Iran. This was clearly one of the primary reasons foreign powers became interested PowerPoint. 15 min. in the control of Iran and is still an important issue today. After WWII, members of the Iranian government fought for the nationalization of the country’s oil so that they could have control of the majority of the profits of this natural resource. Not foreign companies. Iran elected Mossadegh to the presidency under the assumption that he would do so. As a result, the U.S. led a coup d’état against his government in 1953. (However, this information was only declassified by the U.S. government within the last decade.) In groups of 3, students will read through 3 of the U.S. Documents of the 1953 coup and complete rows on the OPVL Chart for them. In groups of 3, students will be working with six documents all of which cover the 1953 coup. One side of the room will work with the odd numbered documents while the other side works with the even numbered documents. In their groups, the students will read each document and complete a row for it on an OPVL chart. If the students finish early, then they should move on to the other set of documents. Closure/Extensions: (Determining progress toward daily objective.) Student’s Actions Teacher’s Actions Write down their homework assignment for next time. Introduce the homework assignment for next time. Homework: Students will continue to fill out their OPVL charts and bring these back to class. We will then recreate the chart and share out as a class. The sheets will be handed in after that activity. Students should also be prepared to discuss the following questions next time: - How does perspective affect interpretation of events? - How else did the U.S. fight against the Soviet threat during the Cold War? 6 U.S. Documents of the 1953 Coup. 20 min. OPVL Chart. Resources Time PowerPoint. 2 min. ASSESSMENT Students will be assessed on their class participation. While the students are working in small groups, I will be moving around the room making sure that everyone is on task and working well with others. I will also be checking to make sure that the students are filling out their OPVL chart which will count towards their participation. Students will turn in their homework from last time, which was to fill out a notecard that discusses the following questions: What connections are you beginning to see between Iran’s government and Islam? What connections are you beginning to see between foreign involvement and Iran? How might these events relate to what you already knew about Iran? Students will complete their OPVL charts from this class period based on the three documents they are working with. They will hand these in next class after a discussion activity with the entire class. Name: _____________________ Period:______ IRAN CURRENT EVENTS WORKSHEET DATE DUE:________ Directions: Find an article about Iran either in the newspaper or online from a newspaper source, Time.com, USA Today, The New York Times, etc., or any other reputable national or local source. Read the article and fill out the statements or answer the questions below. You may not use articles on Entertainment/Gossip or Sports. Because this is a current events assignment you are to choose an article that is no more than a month old from when the assignment is given. Read the Rubric at the end of the worksheet to complete all the requirements for this assignment. Attach the article to the worksheet. Topic of Article: _____________________________________________________________________ Title of Article: ______________________________________________________________________ Source: _____________________________________________________________________________ WHO is this article about? ____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ WHAT is this story about? List four important facts from your article. 1. _________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ 2. _________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ 3. _________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ 4. _________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ WHEN did this story take place? ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ WHY is this story important? ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ CONNECT the article. What does it have to do with you? Based on what you have studied in class, what events in Iran’s history can you trace this back to? Explain your answer. _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________ Grading will be based on the following rubric: A – Entire Current Event assignment displays the following requirements for each question/statement above: a. Demonstrates thoughtfulness, preparation, and accuracy. b. Reflects real understanding of the story and the issues. c. Follows directions. d. Is complete, neat, and includes entire article. e. Asks and answers a provocative (for discussion purposes) question. B – Current Event assignment is complete but lacks 2 of the above requirements. C – Current Event assignment lacks 3 of the requirements. D– Current Event assignment lacks 4 of the requirements. F – Current Event assignment is late (excepting all day absence) or lacks 5 or more of the above requirements. This assignment will be worth 40 points.