Review Comment Form

advertisement
Review Form 1.2
Name of Journals:
Journal of Bioscience and Agriculture Research (JBAR)
Journal of Science, Technology & Environment Informatics (JSTEI)
Intl. Journal of Business, Management & Social Research (IJBMSR)
Article ID Number:
Title of the Article:
Type of the Article
Original Research Article, Review Paper, Case Study, Short Communication, Other type
General guideline for Peer Review process:
This journal’s peer review policy states that NO manuscript should be rejected only on the basis of ‘lack of Novelty’, provided the manuscript is
scientifically robust and technically sound. Re-submission of manuscripts suggested after reject.
Peer review guidelines can be found here : http://www.journalbinet.com/reviewer-guide.html
To know the complete guideline for editorial policy, peer review process, reviewers are requested to visit the link below :
http://www.journalbinet.com/editorial-policy.html
Fore more information : http://www.journalbinet.com/
Created by: Executive Editor
Checked by: Chief Editor
Approved by: Editorial Board
Version: 1.0 (16-08-2015)
Review Form 1.2
PART 1: Review Reporting / Recommendation / Comments
Reviewer’s comments
Nature of Recommendations
Author’s comment (if agreed with reviewer,
correct the manuscript. It is mandatory that
authors should write feedbacks here)
Compulsory REVISION comments
Minor REVISION comments
Are there ethical issues or conflicts
of interest in this manuscript?
Accept / Require minor correction / Require major
correction / Reject (re-submission)
Reviewer Decision
PART 2: Reviewer Details:
Name:
Anonymous Reviewer, Reviewer preferred to be anonymous.
Affiliations:
Department, University & Country
Created by: Executive Editor
Checked by: Chief Editor
Approved by: Editorial Board
Version: 1.0 (16-08-2015)
Download