Transnational Marketing Journal Article Review Form

advertisement
Transnational Marketing Journal - Please return the completed form to [email protected]
REVIEWER’S REPORT FORM
Manuscript Title:
Review request date:
(please try to return your review within 4 weeks, thank you)
Please indicate your level of satisfaction regarding each criteria:
1 = Poor
2
3
4
5=
Excellent
Importance of the topic
Freshness of content
Originality of contribution to the field
Strength of the argument
References to existing literature
Degree of interest to our readership
Clarity and organisation
Writing and presentation
Overall quality (1 to 5):
Recommendation to the editors (Please place X next to your choice)
A – ACCEPT with minor editorial changes
B – ACCEPT with minor revisions
C – REVISE and RESUBMIT (only if the paper has real promise)
D – REJECT, not publishable
E – REFER to a SPECIALIST (please explain briefly)
F – BETTER SUITED TO ANOTHER JOURNAL (please indicate which, if possible)
COMMENTS TO THE EDITOR(S):
This space is for comments to the Editors which will not be sent to the author(s).
You will enter your comments to the authors on the second page.
Please continue to the next page to insert your comments to author(s).
1
COMMENTS TO THE AUTHOR(S):
These comments may be fully forwarded to the author(s)
Your comments to the author(s) here…
Thank you.
2
Download