Values, Uses and Community Views A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat October 2015 © The State of Victoria Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning 2015 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence. You are free to re-use the work under that licence, on the condition that you credit the State of Victoria as author. The licence does not apply to any images, photographs or branding, including the Victorian Coat of Arms, the Victorian Government logo and the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) logo. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ ISBN 978-1-74146-857-1 (pdf) Disclaimer This publication may be of assistance to you but the State of Victoria and its employees do not guarantee that the publication is without flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purposes and therefore disclaims all liability for any error, loss or other consequence which may arise from you relying on any information in this publication. Accessibility If you would like to receive this publication in an alternative format, please telephone DELWP Customer Service Centre 136 186, email customer.service@delwp.vic.gov.au, via the National Relay Service on 133 677 www.relayservice.com.au. This document is also available on the internet at www.delwp.vic.gov.au Summary A new park of up to 641 hectares is to be established near Ballarat. The park will comprise of the existing Canadian State Forest and other Crown land including the former Victorian Plantation Corporation plantation land. The park is being created to meet the Government’s 2014 election commitment to establish a State Park, in response the community-based group Friends of the Canadian Corridor’s proposal to establish a “Canadian Multi Use Forest Park”. The Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning has consulted key stakeholders and the broader community. An estimated 170 community members participated in the Canadian Park Community Open House and 238 online submissions were received during the consultation period. Additional submissions were also received from several individuals and stakeholders. There has been strong support for the creation of the park from both the community and key stakeholders. Community feedback and submissions are overwhelmingly supportive of the creation of a park that supports a wide range of recreation uses including bush walking, mountain bike riding, picnicking, nature observation, orienteering, dog walking, horse riding, prospecting and environmental education. As a result of the stakeholder and community consultation it has been decided to create the park as a regional park, rather than the state park that had been initially proposed. A regional park will accommodate the community’s wishes to access the park for a wide variety of uses, as highlighted through the consultation process. The new park will enhance the landscape by increasing green space in Ballarat, create a north-south wildlife corridor and protect natural and cultural values. The park will ensure the former plantation land is rehabilitated and brought back to public use and provide for a range of recreational opportunities including walking, mountain bike trails and picnic facilities. The new park will also create opportunities for naturebased tourism. Once the park is created, it is recommended that the park manager commence the preparation of a park establishment plan, supported by further community and stakeholder engagement, to ensure community aspirations for access to and use of the park are realised. Contents Summary Contents 1. Introduction 1 1.1 Purpose 1.2 Overview of the proposed park 1 2 2. Biodiversity and Environmental Values 4 2.1 Forest types 2.2 Species conservation 2.3 Catchments and aquatic ecosystems 2.4 Landscape values 4 4 6 7 3. Recreational and Community Values 8 3.1 Community links to the park 3.2 Local communities 3.3 Recreational activities 3.4 Educational values 3.5 Tourism 3.6 Neighbouring areas 8 8 8 9 9 9 4. Cultural Heritage Values 10 4.1 Aboriginal social values 4.2 Aboriginal cultural heritage 4.3 Other historic legacy and values 10 10 10 5. Economic and Social Values 12 5.1 Planning scheme interfaces 5.2 Mineral resources 5.3 Utilities and infrastructure 12 12 13 6. Risks 14 6.1 Visitor behaviours 6.2 Fire 6.3 Climate change 6.4 Weeds, pests and diseases 6.5 Public safety 14 14 14 14 15 7. Consultation Process and Outcomes 16 7.1 Basis for consultation 7.2 The consultation process 7.3 Sumary of key stakeholder discussions 7.4 Summary of submissions received 7.5 Results of the stakeholder and community consultation 7.5.1 Results of the online survey 7.5.2 Results of the community open house event 7.6 Summary of consultation results 7.7 Conclusion 16 16 17 18 18 18 23 27 29 References 29 Appendix 1. Stakeholder list 30 Appendix 2. Transcript of community comments (log sheets, graffiti wall and submissions) 32 1. Introduction 1.1 Purpose A new park, of up to 641 hectares, comprising the existing Canadian State Forest and other Crown land including the former Victorian Plantation Corporation (VPC) plantation land is to be established in Ballarat (see figure 1). The park is being created to meet the Government’s 2014 election commitment to establish a ‘State Park’, using the former plantation land and adjoining state forest in response to the communitybased group Friends of the Canadian Corridor’s proposal to establish a “Canadian Multi Use Forest Park”. This report provides a summary of the values, uses and community consultation process undertaken by the Grampians Region of the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) to the Minister for Environment, Climate Change and Water to enable the establishment of the proposed park (figures 1 & 2). Establishment will require the definition of: (1) the land to be included in the park and its boundaries; (2) the appropriate uses to be allowed in the park; (3) the type of park to be created; and (4) the proposed land manager. The park will then be declared pursuant to the appropriate legislation. This report will also inform the planning process for the future management of the proposed park by providing a summary of the values, uses and community views. Figure 1. Outline of proposed park in relation to surrounding areas Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 1 1.2 Overview of the proposed park The area proposed for the park is located 4 km southeast of the centre of Ballarat on low hills of Ordovician geology. It is roughly rectangular in shape and is oriented north to south. The southern, western and northern boundaries are convoluted and adjoin urban areas. The eastern boundary adjoins a combination of rural and bushland areas. Much of the land in the immediate vicinity of the park boundary supports native vegetation. Figure 2. Outline of proposed park including aerial imagery from 2015. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 2 The land is made up of a total of 32 existing Crown parcels, comprising the Canadian State Forest, large areas of unreserved Crown land formerly managed by the Victorian Plantations Corporation (VPC) for softwood and hardwood production, and a handful of smaller reserves and unreserved parcels of Crown land totalling approximately 641 hectares. There are also a number of unused government road reserves running through the area, as well as council managed roads. Several tenures including one grazing licence, a communications licence and two mineral exploration licences are also within the proposed park. The remnant bushland in the proposed park is primarily classified as Heathy Dry Forest. This forest type is classed as common in Victoria, with a relatively high proportion remaining due to the relatively low suitability of the soils for agriculture. The former plantation areas harbour a range of native and introduced species which have established since harvest operations concluded. The proposed park will form an important component of the forested corridor extending north to the Creswick Regional Park, southwest to the Enfield State Park, and southeast through the Lal Lal State Forest to the Brisbane Ranges National Park. The corridor represents an avenue for the movement of wildlife, providing habitat continuity and consequently maintaining population health for a range of species. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 3 2. Biodiversity and Environmental Values 2.1 Forest types The native vegetation within the proposed park is predominantly Heathy Dry Forest, with a small area of Valley Grassy Forest (Goldfields bioregion, Ecological Vegetation Classes (EVC) 20 and 47 respectively). The structure and composition of the forest reflects a history of gold mining, firewood collection and timber production among other uses. Parts of the forest contain mature, well-developed tree cover, however there are also areas dominated by coppice regrowth and dense regeneration. Larger trees are typically found along road reserves or buffers on the perimeter of the former plantation, and in the intact forest in the north of the proposed park. The condition of the understorey of the Heathy Dry Forest ranges from excellent to moderate. The northern section of native bushland is in particularly good condition with extensive stands of Grass-trees being a locally significant feature. A small tongue of Valley Grassy Forest adjacent to Katy Ryan’s Road is also locally significant, but is in a degraded condition and is heavily infested with gorse. The former plantation within the proposed park is located centrally in two distinct blocks. At present these blocks hold little native vegetation. Some small patches of forest were retained as islands or buffers, and much of the cleared area is undergoing revegetation by natural and artificial processes. The smaller northern plantation was artificially reseeded with indigenous species after last being harvested, while in the main plantation much of the cleared area has been steadily colonised from surrounding areas by native and introduced species. Both blocks were treated mechanically and with fire to remove harvesting residues. Table 1. Forest types by Ecological Vegetation Class (EVC) represented in the proposed park. Description/Ecological Vegetation Class EVC no. Conservation Status Area in park Percentage of total area Condition of forest type known to be in the park Heathy Dry Forest 20 Least Concern 370 ha 57% Ranging from wellestablished forest to coppice regrowth Valley Grassy Forest 47 Vulnerable 11 ha 2% Poor condition, reduced extent Former Plantation N/A N/A 269 ha 41% Some natives, widespread invasion of gorse and broom. 2.2 Species conservation The proposed park supports a range of common and widespread flora and fauna species. Its value to some fauna species is limited by the shortage of large old trees and associated large tree hollows and fallen logs. In some sections the biodiversity of the understorey on the native bushland has been reduced by past land uses and also possibly by outbreaks of Phytophthora. There are locally significant populations of Austral Grass-tree (Xanthorrhoea australis), particularly in the north. These are a very attractive visual component of the understorey and contribute to the habitat value of the area habitat for native fauna. Stands of Brown Stringybark (Eucalyptus baxteri) are considered locally significant as this species is uncommon around Ballarat. There are also locally significant records of Rough Tree-ferns (Cyathea australis) in several creek-lines in the proposed park. Native mammals recorded within the proposed park include the Agile Antechinus (Antechinus agilis) and the Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus). A regional Koala management plan has been developed by the City of Ballarat to ensure the local viability of the species in the long term (BCC 2006) While the proposed park is Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 4 important for Koala habitat at the landscape scale, it contains minimal suitable habitat due to a lack of preferred diet trees such as Manna Gum (Eucalyptus viminalis) and Swamp Gum (Eucalyptus ovata). Figure 3. Forest types within and adjacent to the proposed park. Two threatened flora species have been recorded within the proposed park. These are the Yarra Gum (Eucalyptus yarraensis), and the Penny-leaf Flat-pea (Platylobium rotundum). Table 2. Rare and threatened species recorded within the proposed park (DELWP 2015). Common name Scientific name Status in Victoria Occurrence in park Yarra Gum Eucalyptus yarraensis Rare Scattered records in park. Suitable habitat for establishment may exist along drainage lines and near small dams. Penny-leaf Flat-pea Platylobium rotundifolium Vulnerable One record from the park. Likely to be more extensive in the proposed park as suitable habitat exists. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 5 In addition to the rare and threatened species known to be within the proposed park, there are a number of species which have been recorded nearby, and whose likelihood of occurrence is high in the proposed park. However, the proposed park is not assessed as having high quality habitat for any of these species. Table 3. Other species recorded in the vicinity, which may occur within the proposed park (DELWP 2015). Common name Scientific name Status in Victoria Possible occurrence in park Wavy Swamp Wallaby-grass Amphibromus sinuatus Vulnerable Highly unlikely Swift Parrot Lathamus discolor Endangered May occasionally fly over Hardhead Aythya australis Vulnerable May occasionally visit small dams. Musk Duck Biziura lobata Vulnerable Unlikely to be present. Requires aquatic habitat. Royal Spoonbill Platalea regia Near threatened Unlikely to be present. Requires aquatic habitat Powerful Owl Ninox strenua Vulnerable May occasionally visit park. Breeding unlikely due to lack of large hollows. Barking Owl Ninox connivens Endangered May occasionally visit park. Breeding unlikely due to lack of large hollows Brush-tail Phascogale Phascogale tapoatafa Vulnerable Suitable habitat exists although hollows are limited. Brown Tree-creeper Climacteris picumnis victoriae Near Threatened Unlikely to be present. Spotted Quail-thrush Cinclosoma punctatum Near Threatened Suitable habitat exists. White-throated Needletail Hirundapus caudacutus Vulnerable Uncertain. Growling Grass Frog Litoria raniformis Endangered Small dams are unlikely to presently form suitable habitat. Brown Toadlet Pseudophryne bibronii Endangered Small dams may presently provide suitable habitat. Tussock Skink Pseudemoia pagenstecheri Vulnerable Unlikely. 2.3 Catchments and aquatic ecosystems The proposed park is within the area overseen by the Corangamite Catchment Management Authority (CCMA). Its proximity to the Great Dividing Range means that there are few major water courses in the vicinity, although rainfall is relatively high with an annual mean of 776.8mm (BoM 2015). A number of small, intermittent streams drain the area, including the Grasstree, Pennyweight and Canadian creek-lines. The Canadian catchment drains into the Yarrowee or Leigh River before joining the Barwon River at Inverleigh and finally flowing into the Bass Strait at Barwon Heads. As a forested catchment in an otherwise largely cleared landscape, the area of the proposed park plays an important role in downstream Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 6 water quality and local hydrology. The CCMA has undertaken a number of joint projects in the Yarrowee catchment in partnership with the City of Ballarat and local community groups, including delivery of works under the current “Breathing the Life into the Yarrowee” project; as well as flood studies along the Canadian Creek tributaries to enhance biodiversity values and native vegetation to aid in protecting downstream water quality and the hydrological processes within the broader Barwon Basin. Creeks and small dams throughout the proposed park may support a range of aquatic life such as the threatened Growling Grass Frog (Litoria raniformis) and Brown Toadlet (Pseudophryne bibronii). However, the presence of these species is highly dependent on the quality of the habitat and its proximity to other habitat areas in the vicinity. 2.4 Landscape values The proposed park is an attractive backdrop to the Ballarat urban area, and a natural setting for those suburbs immediately adjacent to the area. The 2013 report prepared for the City of Ballarat, Mapping Ballarat’s Historic Urban Landscape, identified the Canadian forest as one of the 12 key character areas in the municipality. The former plantation areas within the proposed park are currently open spaces and largely devoid of native forest cover. As they sit relatively high in the landscape, some sections currently provide extensive views over Ballarat, especially near the eastern edge of the proposed park where the land is particularly elevated. In addition to the natural forested landscapes, the historic landscape left behind by early goldmining activities is known to be significant. This is enhanced by the presence nearby of the Sovereign Hill tourist park, which provides historic context to gold mining heritage across the area. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 7 3. Recreational and Community Values 3.1 Community links to the park The Ballarat community has a strong connection to the corridor of land that contains the proposed park. The Wadawurrung people are the Traditional Owners of the land proposed for inclusion in the park. They have a long history in the area, both before European settlement and in more recent times. During the gold rush the forest provided an important source of firewood, and of timber for the construction of mine shafts and other purposes, and this use continued over subsequent decades with the establishment of a pine plantation in the 1950s. Since the final harvest of the plantation in 2012 and divestment of the land back to the State government, the community-based group Friends of the Canadian Corridor (the Friends) developed a proposal to establish a “Canadian Multi Use Forest Park” for the former plantation areas and the Canadian State Forest. Since 2013 the Friends have been lobbying widely in support of their proposal, including in the lead up to the 2014 State election. The Friends obtained wide support for their proposal and featured in the local media. 3.2 Local communities Communities located in close proximity to the proposed park include the inner Ballarat suburbs of Golden Point, Brown Hill and Canadian, the outlying suburbs of Mount Clear and Mount Helen, and the rural communities of Warrenheip and Navigators. People living in these communities value the area for recreational purposes, ecological services, as a commuter route, and for a wide range of other reasons. More broadly, the area is important as a natural setting within the Ballarat region and creates a forested edge to urban growth on the eastern edge of Ballarat. 3.3 Recreational activities The area is currently used by a range of individuals and groups for various recreational uses. During the stakeholder and community consultation process participants were asked how they currently use the land within the proposed park (see table 4 and section 7.7). The proposed park is popular for passive recreation including bush walking/short walks, cycling/mountain bike riding, environmental education, orienteering, prospecting, general exercise and nature observation. Currently there are no formalised recreational facilities, camping or picnicking areas within the park. Table 4. A summary of recreational activities currently undertaken in the park A summary of recreational activities currently undertaken in the park Bushwalking Short walks Cycling, mountain bike riding Environmental education Nature observation Picnicking Research Orienteering and rogaining Visiting historic features Jogging/exercise Scenic drives Horse riding Dog walking Prospecting, fossicking, panning Camping Visiting historic features Bird watching 4WD/Car touring Hunting Meditation Model cars Photography Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 8 3.4 Educational values The proposed park has been used on an informal basis for environmental education purposes. There are a number of schools and institutions located nearby, including the Mount Clear Secondary and Primary Schools, Damascus College, Ballarat Secondary College Eastern Campus, St. Francis Xavier Primary, and Federation University. 3.5 Tourism Currently there are no licensed tour operators within the proposed park. Information received during the community consultation indicates that horse riding tours and prospecting tours are currently operating with the proposed park. 3.6 Neighbouring areas The Pax Hill Activity Centre is located in a Crown reserve, adjoining the proposed park on the north-western boundary. The reserve is vegetated along the adjoining north-western boundary with the activity centre located to north the of the Crown reserve. The centre is used primarily by Scouts Australia and local scout groups for camps and associated activities. Scouts from the activity centre use the proposed park for bush walking and orienteering. The former Commonwealth Rifle Range is surrounded by the proposed park and is one of two large inliers into the park on the western boundary. It is now privately owned, and in 2013 was subject to an application for a planning scheme amendment for the purposes of residential development. The City of Ballarat rejected that application primarily on the basis of fire hazard. This site has historic values and also supports native vegetation. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 9 4. Cultural Heritage Values 4.1 Aboriginal social values The Wadawurrung people are the Traditional Owners of the land on which the park will be created. They have a long history in the area, both before European settlement and in more recent times. In the past, the forest would have been used by the Wadawurrung for shelter and everyday life when conditions on the surrounding volcanic plains became less favourable than in the warmer months. During winter, people would have spent less time finding food, instead preferring to stay in shelter and working on tool production, possum skin cloaks and other such items. While in the forest, in addition to their daily rituals and ceremonies, the Wadawurrung would have met with neighbouring peoples, such as the Dja Dja Wurrung living to the north of the area. The Traditional Owners continue to use the Canadian State Forest today for a variety of purposes, including as a source of materials for ceremonies and other activities. In addition to its practical value, the area continues to be of social significance to the Wadawurrung people. The creation of the park represents an opportunity for local Aboriginal people to maintain a spiritual connection with the land, much of which was impacted by European settlement. The area of the proposed park is also a backdrop for the passing of cultural knowledge between local Aboriginal people, and a landscape in which principles of caring for country can be practised by all. 4.2 Aboriginal cultural heritage The Pennyweight and Grasstree creek-lines north of the proposed park are the formally recognised areas of cultural sensitivity. This suggests these features and the adjoining land were favoured during traditional use by the Wadawurrung people. It is also important to note that other streams and wetland depressions would also have been significant despite not having formal recognition. Due to a large number of significant Aboriginal places within close proximity to the proposed park, it is likely more places of Aboriginal cultural sensitivity are yet to be identified. There are no registered Aboriginal places within the proposed park. 4.3 Other historic legacy and values European settlement was followed rapidly by gold mining, which resulted in a significant population influx during the 1850s and in subsequent decades. The nearby Canadian Lead was among the richest in the Ballarat area and was mined intensively for gold at a relatively early time. During this period the forest provided an important source of firewood, and of timber for the construction of mine shafts and other purposes, and this use continued over subsequent decades. Over-utilisation of the timber resources during this time resulted in the present lack of old-growth vegetation within the remnant bushland. The Canadian Lead, the Ballarat suburb of Canadian, the Canadian Creek and the Canadian State Forest are thought to be named after gold miner “Captain” Henry Ross, who emigrated from Canada during the gold rush. Ross became a successful miner and also played a key role in the Eureka rebellion of 1854. Plantation forestry was established in the area during the 1950s-1960s, with large tracts of native forest cleared and planted. This was initially for softwood production, with several rotations of Radiata Pine (Pinus radiata) being harvested before the plantations were transferred from the government to the Victorian Plantation Corporation (VPC) in the 1990s. In 2002 the plantations were converted to Blue Gum (Eucalyptus globulus) for hardwood production. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 10 The final harvest of the plantation was conducted in 2012, after which time the land was divested to the State government. The northern block of the former plantation was aerial seeded with a mixture of indigenous tree and shrub species after harvesting. This treatment was partially successful, however the larger portion of the former plantation areas have not been revegetated. There is no listed heritage or historic sites within the proposed park. Despite this, the area is historically significant as part of the Ballarat goldfield, particularly due to its proximity to the important Canadian lead. It also retains links to other aspects of the long history of settlement in the Ballarat area including the adjoining former Commonwealth Rifle Range and a nearby railway line that ran from Ballarat to Buninyong. Historic features likely to be within the proposed park include remnants of mining activities such as shafts and tailings, especially in proximity to the numerous creek-lines and gullies. There are also thought to be remnants of early timber harvesting and milling activities. Sawmills located at Yankee Flat and near Buninyong in the second half of the 19th century would have utilised timber from the Canadian forest, which was then likely to have been transported to Mount Clear via a tram line traversing the forest from east to west. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 11 5. Economic and Social Values 5.1 Planning scheme interfaces The proposed park is surrounded by urban, rural and farming land uses of various population densities. Land use and development is regulated by local government planning schemes. The most densely populated areas in the vicinity of the proposed park are located along the northwest boundary in the City of Ballarat. Along the eastern boundary population density is lower and is governed by the Moorabool Shire Council planning scheme. Future development in these interface areas may affect the proposed park, and will need to be considered in bush-fire risk planning. Table 5. Interface areas and planning schemes in proximity to the proposed park. Municipality Interface area Current planning scheme Future intentions of council Ballarat City Council Privately owned inliers to the park area Rural Conservation Zone (RCZ) Low development potential due to prevalence of native vegetation, compatible with park Ballarat City Council Northern boundary interfaces General Residential Zone (GRZ1); Urban expansion in this area not envisaged, may be parts suitable to be zoned for Rural Conservation (RCZ) Ballarat City Council Western boundary interface Neighbourhood Residential Zone (NRZ1) Urban expansion in this area not envisaged, may be parts suitable to be zoned as RCZ Ballarat City Council Olympic Avenue interface to the south of proposed park area Farming Zone (FZ) Proposed to be rezoned as RCZ under the draft Greenhill Road Conceptual Development Framework Plan Moorabool Shire Council Eastern boundary interface Farming Zone (FZ); No proposals to changes to the planning scheme in the near future Rural Living Zone (RLZ) Rural Living Zone (RLZ) 5.2 Mineral resources The area to be included in the proposed park is subject to two current exploration licences, which together cover the majority of Ballarat and its outlying suburbs. These exploration licences allow activities ranging from drilling to bulk sampling, the primary means of oversight for which is the landowner consent process, which cannot unreasonably be withheld under the Mineral Resources (Sustainable Development) Act 1990. The park is also in close proximity to an active licence for underground gold mining, with continuous operations having been undertaken by Castlemaine Goldfields Ltd (CGT) since 2011. These activities have primarily been located west of Canadian creek, from Mount Helen north to Golden Point. In addition to the commercial mining activities in the proposed area, small-scale prospecting including detecting, fossicking and panning for gold continue to occur, especially in areas where gold mining has taken place historically. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 12 5.3 Utilities and infrastructure Electrical infrastructure in the area of the proposed park includes the transmission lines running through the former plantation south of Recreation Road, as well as the distribution line along the Wilson Street corridor in the north of the state forest area and along Recreation Road in the southern end of the state forest area. A mobile communications tower operated by Telstra is also located in the state forest south of Recreation Road and is supplied with power by the distribution line running along Recreation Road. There are two large water tanks managed by Central Highlands Water, one in the north of the proposed park on the Wilson Street extension, and one in the south near Recreation Road. Both tanks lie within water supply reserves. In addition to the tanks, there is a major water pipe running along the Wilson Street easement from the reservoir located to the east in the vicinity of Warrenheip. Table 6. Summary of major infrastructure located within the proposed park. Infrastructure type Name Description Manager Water supply Mains water pipelines Large pipeline running east to west along Wilson Street corridor in north of proposed park. Central Highlands Water Associated power & pipelines to connect the adjoining water supply reserves (Water storage tanks) in the north (Wilson St) and south (Recreation Rd) of proposed park. Electricity supply Transmission lines Multiple 220kV lines running through former plantation area south of Recreation Road. AusNet Services Electricity supply Distribution lines Major 415V distribution line running along Wilson Street corridor in north of area and along Recreation Road to supply the Telstra tower. Powercor Telecommunications Mobile communications tower Single mobile phone tower located in state forest south of Recreation Road. Telstra In addition to infrastructure related to the provision of utilities, the proposed park contains numerous roads and tracks which are employed for a variety of uses. Though there are no sealed roads within the area, Recreation Road is a major unsealed route linking Main Road at Mount Clear with Yankee Flat Road near Navigators. This is a locally important commuter corridor, which experiences a relatively high volume of traffic on a daily basis and is earmarked for future upgrade (BCC 2015). Other significant routes through the park area include Boundary Road, Olympic Avenue, Wilson Street, Clayton Street, Bakers Road and Katy Ryan’s Road which are used as municipal roads and to access private property. There are also numerous smaller roads, fire access and former logging tracks, mountain bike trails and unmarked paths within the area. These are used primarily for management activities and by the local community for recreation. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 13 6. Risks 6.1 Visitor behaviours Associated with its proximity to populated areas, a number of damaging activities are currently taking place within the proposed park. Off-road motor-biking and four wheel driving are causing erosion problems in certain areas. Illegal rubbish dumping is widespread, including the dumping of hazardous materials such as asbestos. It is also understood that unauthorized firewood collection is common. 6.2 Fire There is no known history of bushfire in the Canadian forest although it is assumed that there was regular fire in the area prior to European settlement. While minor bushfires may have occurred in subsequent years, there have been no major events of historic or environmental significance. There are a number of risks associated with fire, including risk to life and property, both within and adjacent to the proposed park, as well as various risks to biodiversity and other ecological values as detailed above. Residential areas in close proximity to the park are exposed to risk to life and property, particularly along the northern, eastern and southern boundaries. For many years government agencies have conducted planned burning in the area, most recently in April 2015, chiefly to reduce fuels in order to mitigate bushfire risk. Planned burning operations have taken place to reduce fire risk in close proximity to nearby residential areas, the former plantations and the Mt Clear Secondary College. Former plantation areas were also burnt immediately after harvesting in 2012 to remove harvesting residue. 6.3 Climate change Climate change has implications for the current and future maintenance of the values identified in this report. Changing patterns of rainfall and temperature variation will directly affect the physiology of many plants, potentially resulting in heightened vulnerability of ecosystems to threats such as pests and disease. For example, changes to rainfall patterns may increase the rate of spread of pathogens such as Phytophthora, which is already present in certain parts of the proposed park. 6.4 Weeds, pests and diseases Weed species are widespread and common in many parts of the proposed park, particularly across the former plantation areas, and in creeks and drainage lines. Regionally Controlled Weeds that have been recorded in the proposed park include Gorse (Ulex europeaus), Blackberry (Rubus fruticosus), Spear Thistle (Cirsium vulgare), Hemlock (Conium maculatum), English Broom (Cytisus scoparius), Sweet Briar (Rosa rubiginosa), and Bulbil Watsonia (Watsonia meriana). Within the park, these weeds are well established in a variety of ecological niches. Of the many introduced species recorded from the proposed park, those that currently pose the most threat to biodiversity values are Gorse and Blackberry. Gorse is widespread in former plantation areas where it is able to out-compete almost all native vegetation. Dense stands can be found near the southern boundary. It can also be found in bushland, however does not thrive under an established canopy. Blackberries are more typically found in gullies within the proposed park, especially in the areas known as the Cascades in the southern block of existing forest. These weeds contribute to fire risk by elevating fuel loads, and have a negative impact on many ecosystems by out-competing indigenous species. In this way, some weeds can potentially contribute to risks to Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 14 biodiversity conservation. It must be noted that these weeds can at times also work to reduce other risks such as erosion, and can potentially provide valuable habitat for certain fauna. New and emerging weed species in the proposed park include Bluebell creeper (Sollya heterophylla), which is spreading near the northern boundary, and Radiata Pine (Pinus radiata), which has become increasingly common in bushland surrounding former plantations. Phytophthora (Phytophthora cinnamomi), or Cinnamon Fungus, is a microscopic, soil-borne plant pathogen that is currently having a serious impact on the biodiversity values of the proposed park. This pathogen is actively spreading and killing Grass-trees within the proposed park. Movement of soil and water via foot traffic and on vehicles spreads the disease into new areas, and the large number of roads and tracks in the Canadian forest and throughout the former plantation areas increases the risk. The proposed park is presumed to harbour a range of pests, including rabbits, foxes, cats and dogs. These pests pose a direct risk to native fauna, through predation and competition for habitat. They can also impact on ecological functions and landscapes, for example by destabilising the ground and elevating the risk of erosion in the instance of rabbits. 6.5 Public safety In addition to risks to the public common to most parks and reserves, such as road traffic and bushfire, the proposed park includes a range of less common risks. One of the most prominent of these risks is the large number of old mine shafts without caps or with decaying capping present in the area. Such shafts are known to be present in the north of the proposed park, and are also likely to be found elsewhere. Informal tracks in these areas suggest that bicycle and motor-bike activity takes place very close to such mine shafts. Other activities such as walking and orienteering which take place off-track expose visitors to an elevated risk. The informal nature of many of the tracks in the area also poses a risk to both pedestrians and vehicles. The southern portion of the proposed park contains a very steep gully which is crossed by a heavily eroded track thought to be used regularly by 4WD enthusiasts. There is a heightened risk of vehicles rollovers on this track, and the gully may be prone to flash-flooding in extreme weather conditions. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 15 7. Consultation Process and Outcomes 7.1 Basis for consultation The purpose of the stakeholder and community consultation process was to establish a clear understanding of community views regarding the proposed park’s values and uses to inform the creation of the park. DELWP undertook a collaborative approach to the stakeholder and community consultation process by first partnering with key stakeholders, i.e. the Friends of Canadian Corridor, the City of Ballarat, Parks Victoria, the Country Fire Authority, and the Wathaurung Aboriginal Corporation, and Geoff Howard MP, Member for Buninyong. The collaborative approach allowed the key stakeholders to participate in the design of the community consultation process and gave them a greater ability to share information and provide feedback to the wider community. The key objectives for the stakeholder and community consultation process were to: share information on park values (social, historic, environmental and indigenous) and issues and options to guide the creation of the park; ensure individuals, community and organisations with an interest in the creation of the proposed park have the opportunity to participate in that process; ensure participation techniques are suitable to meet the requirements and expectations of the variety of individuals, community and organisations; ensure the views, opinions and aspirations of interested individuals, community and organisations are given due consideration in the creation of the park. 7.2 The consultation process The consultation process included a higher level of engagement with stakeholders who had a higher interest in the proposed park and a broader level of engagement for the wider community. The consultation process began in March 2015 with key stakeholders (collaborating partners) to explain the project objectives, timing and to ask for their input on future use of the park and community engagement processes and principles. This was followed by a collaborative group meeting of key stakeholders on the 17 March 2015 in which a consultation process for the wider community was designed. The findings of the consultation process were shared with the key stakeholder group at a facilitated meeting on the 14 May 2015. The consultation process is summarised as follows: The consultation targeted stakeholders, neighbouring residents, user groups and the general community over the period 26 March to 13 May 2015. A letter was sent to 2915 nearby residents and user groups to advise them of the proposed park and to invite them to make comment, either through an online survey, by attending the community open house or written submission. Targeted meetings held with stakeholders and user groups on an as needs basis (see Appendix 1). Stakeholders and user groups also invited to make submissions. Consultation Open House event 17 - 18 April 2015. Designed to allow the community and stakeholders to get information and participate in the consultation process at their discretion. Community online submission process 30 March-30 April 2015. An online survey was available for one month to enable the community to provide their feedback through the following questions: o Question 1. How do you currently use Canadian State Forest? o Question 2. Which activities do you think should be available? o Question 3. What is important to you? o Question 4. What other aspects of the new park would you value? o Question 5. What concerns do you have about the new park? Receipt of written submissions from stakeholder interest groups and individuals. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 16 7.3 Summary of key stakeholder discussions Consultation with key stakeholders (collaborating partners) was undertaken on an individual basis and in a group meeting on 17 March 2015, in which a consultation process for the wider community was also designed. The key stakeholders engaged were the Friends of Canadian Corridor, the Wathaurung Aboriginal Corporation, the City of Ballarat, the Country Fire Authority, Parks Victoria and DELWP Fire and Land. Values and Uses The key stakeholders agreed that the proposed park should protect and enhance native forest values and provide for natural values conservation through the creation of a north-south bio link (Creswick to Mt Buninyong). There was clear agreement that there should be a balance of passive recreation activities, including walking, dog walking, orienteering, rogaining and similar activities, nature observation, mountain biking, horse riding, on-road recreational vehicles, tourism, open space arts and community events, environmental education, environmental research. Differing views were expressed in regards to camping. The group agreed that productive uses such as apiary and managed firewood collection could also occur within the proposed park. Park Boundaries Park boundaries were also discussed with the key stakeholders. The unreserved Crown land boundary of the former plantation land in the vicinity of Mt Clear is irregular, and presents enhanced risks and constraints on land management activities close to residential development (see Figure 2). A number of stakeholders expressed views that private land within the proposed park as inliers (but not part of the park) break-up the forest corridor and could be purchased or used in a land swap. While no clear view emerged on a preferred boundary, key stakeholders agreed that boundary changes could be made to exclude land where that was in the interests of good park management. Stakeholders also agreed that boundary considerations were complex and not suitable for community consultation. There was however agreement on criteria to be used to guide any boundary decisions to determine a suitable boundary once the current Crown land parcel boundaries has been surveyed. The agreed criteria to be applied are as follows: Only plantation land (unreserved Crown land) under consideration Maximise land to be included in the park Reduce risk from within and without Facilitate efficient land management Facilitate ease of public access Do not preclude future land acquisition Park Name While it was not considered in detail during the consultation process, the name of the proposed park was raised with key stakeholders, and was in turn raised by some community members during the consultation period. There were suggestions that an alternative Wadawurrung name may be appropriate, although no name was formally suggested at that time. Key stakeholders including the Wathaurung Aboriginal Corporation, the Friends of Canadian Corridor, the City of Ballarat, Parks Victoria, Victorian National Parks Association and have since offered strong support for an alternative Wadawurrung name for the proposed park. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 17 7.4 Summary of submissions received A total of 238 submissions were received through the online survey. Telephone, email and written submissions were also received from community members. Written submissions were also received from stakeholders including the Friends of Canadian Corridor, Corangamite Catchment Management Authority, Leigh Catchment Group, Victorian National Parks Association, and the Prospectors and Miners Association of Victoria Inc. At the community open house event, attended by approximately 170 people, participants were also able to make comment via logbooks at the themed tables, the park uses activity, and on a graffiti wall. In total the stakeholder and community consultation process generated 575 ‘comments’ on the creation of the proposed park (table 6). Table 6. Source of comments received during the community consultation process Source of comments Online survey Event logbook Park uses activity Graffiti wall Email submissions Phone submissions Written submissions (individuals and stakeholders) Total Count 238 177 129 16 5 3 7 575 7.5 Results of the stakeholder and community consultation 7.5.1 Results of the online survey During the community consultation process an online survey was available for participants to provide information on how they currently use the land and have their say on the future use of the proposed park. The online survey was open from the 30 March to 30 April 2015. Meta data was collected during the online survey to provide information on the demographics of the participants. The following information was collected: 81% of participants were local residents 49.5% of participants were from a local group 68% of participants were male 38.4% of participants were between the ages of 24-44, and 44.3% of participants were between the ages of 45-64. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 18 Question 1. How do you currently use Canadian State Forest? This question gave participants the opportunity to comment on how they currently use the Canadian State Forest. Participants were asked how frequently they used the forest (daily, weekly, monthly, 6 monthly, rarely). The responses are presented in figure 4. A weighted average has been used on the x-axis. From the responses it can be seen that most popular activities frequently undertaken within the state forest are passive recreation activities including bushwalking, short walks, cycling and mountain biking, dog walking and nature observation. Participants also said that they use the proposed park for camping, hunting, apiculture, firewood collection and car rallies. However, these activities are not currently authorised within the Canadian State Forest or the former plantation land. Participants were also able to provide comments on this question. Comments provided advised that the forest is also used for general exercise (including running), meditation, scenic drives and photography. Figure 4. Current uses of the state forest from the online survey. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 19 Question 2. Which activities do you think should be available? This question gave participants the opportunity to comment on activities that they think should be available in the proposed park. Participants were asked to respond to this question based on preference (strongly prefer, prefer, no preference, prefer not, strongly prefer not, I don’t know). The responses are presented in figure 5. A weighted average has been used on the x-axis. From the responses it can be seen that there is a strong preference for passive recreation activities including bushwalking, short walks, cycling and mountain biking, environmental education, nature observation, picnicking, research, orienteering activities and dog walking. Participants strongly preferred to not see hunting, car rallies and car touring, firewood collection, horse riding off tracks and grazing available in the proposed park. Participants were also able to provide comments on this question. Comments provided indicate that the proposed park should also be used for off lead dog walking in designated areas, remote control cars and arts activities such as outdoor movie screenings. Figure 5. Activities that should be available in the proposed park from the online survey. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 20 Question 3. What is important to you? This question gave participants the opportunity to comment on the values that they felt were important to them regarding the proposed park. Participants were asked to respond to this question based on importance (extremely important, very important, moderately important, slightly important, not at all important, I don’t know). The responses are presented in figure 6. A weighted average has been used on the x-axis. From the responses it can be seen that participants ranked all of the values as important to them, with the highest scores recorded for enjoyment of the natural environment, open space and recreation and habitat for wildlife. Figure 6. Values of importance regarding the proposed park from the online survey. Question 4. What other aspects of the new park would you value? This question gave participants the opportunity to add additional values regarding the proposed park that were not options in question 3. Comments provided indicate that biodiversity, flora and fauna and better access for mountain bikes were highly valued. A summary of question 4 responses: Biodiversity, flora and fauna and other related values (15) Infrastructure for recreation, such as tracks, signs, BBQ and toilet facilities, playgrounds among others (16) Better and more numerous mountain bike tracks (19) Open spaces such as a stage for cultural events and other activities, areas for remote control car use (7) Recognition of heritage values across the area (4) Access for prospectors (4) General comments valuing the area for its landscape, forested setting, and proximity to Ballarat (7). Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 21 Question 5. What concerns do you have about the new park? This question asked participants what concerned them about the new park. The question offered three issues to rank (very concerned, moderately concerned, unconcerned, I don’t know). The responses are presented in figure 7. A weighted average has been used on the x-axis. Participants were mostly concerned about vandalism followed by weeds/pest animals and then fire. Participants were also able to provide comments on this question. Comments provided indicate that participants are also concerned about other issues. Over 40 comments noted rubbish dumping as a prominent issue including industrial waste, asbestos, dumped vehicles and household and green waste. Other concerns that were mentioned included: Dangerous drivers and traffic conditions (1) Spread of Phytophthora fungus (3) Exclusion of recreational uses due to new park status, including horse riding and dog walking (3) Informal tracks made by motorbikes, and associated erosion (5) Illegal firewood collection (1) Excessive planned burning activities (1) Climate change (1) Public safety (1) Poor park management (4). Figure 7. Concerns about the proposed park. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 22 Question 6. Additional comments? This question provided participants with the opportunity to make additional comments. The comments provided can be summarised as: Great amenity for Ballarat with a balance of recreation (20 comments) Support for the proposed park (Regional park/State park) (18 comments) Many comments supporting expansion and improvement of mountain bike trails and associated infrastructure (15 comments) Support for permitting prospecting in the park (8 comments). The most common comments supported the creation of the park and the provision of recreation opportunities. One objection to the creation of the park was made in this section. 7.5.2 Results of the community open house event A community open house event was hosted on the 17-18 April 2015 to give residents, user groups and interested members of the public the opportunity to speak with agency staff and interest groups, offer views and ask questions. An estimated 170 community members participated in the open house event across both days. Feedback from participants indicated that the open house was a successful event with many participants welcoming the opportunity to be heard. A number of engagement methods were employed to gather participant views and ideas. The ‘Canadian Park Uses Activity’ engagement tool was used to gauge positive and negative responses to a range of recreation, productive and educational activities within the proposed park. The activity was presented in poster format with public participants provided the opportunity to place three green stickers on most favoured activities and three red stickers on least favoured activities - 129 people responded to preferred activities and 124 people recorded responses to least favoured activities. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 23 From the responses in figure 8, it can be seen that there is a strong preference for passive recreation activities including bushwalking, mountain bike riding, nature observation, dog walking, picnicking, environmental education, horse riding, prospecting and camping. Figure 8. Favoured activities for the proposed park % of respondents favored these activities in the Canadian park Hunting, 1.2% Bushwalking, 14.4% Bushwalking Approved research, 2% Mountain biking on roads and tracks Mountain biking on roads and tracks, 14.1% Apiculture , 2.5% Nature Observation Dog walking Firewood collection areas, 3% Picnics and barbeques Visiting historic features, 3.3% Environmental education Horse riding Other*, 3.1% Prospecting, fossicking, panning Nature Observation , 11% Orienteering and rogaining, 4.6% Camping Orienteering and rogaining Camping, 4.6% Other* Visiting historic features Firewood collection areas Dog walking, 8.5% Prospecting, fossicking, panning , 6% Apiculture Approved research Picnics and barbeques, 7.5% Horse riding, 6.6% Hunting Environmental education, 7.5% * Other: Cars and motorbikes on road touring, 1%; 4WD tracks, 0.7%; Car rallies on formed roads, 0.2%; Minor timber such as poles and posts, 0.5%, and; Water production, 0.7%. Nil response was recorded for Grazing, Mineral exploration, Mining, Stone extraction, and Sawlog production. From the responses in figure 9, it can be seen that participants were strongly opposed to hunting, 4WD, cars and motorbikes, mining, grazing, mineral exploration and sawlog production. Figure 9 Activities not favoured in the proposed park % of respondents did not favor these activities in the Canadian park Other*, 3% Hunting, 16.6% Hunting Horse riding, 1.6% 4WD tracks Minor timber such as poles and posts, 1.6% Cars and motorbikes on road touring 4WD tracks, 14.5% Prospecting, fossicking, panning , 2.2% Mining Grazing Stone extraction, 3.2% Mineral exploration Sawlog production Firewood collection areas, 4% Car rallies on formed roads Car rallies on formed roads, 4.5% Firewood collection areas Cars and motorbikes on road touring, 14.2% Sawlog production, 5.9% Stone extraction Prospecting, fossicking, panning Minor timber such as poles and posts Horse riding Mineral exploration, 6.7% Other* Grazing , 8.3% Mining, 13.7% * Other: Mountain biking on roads and tracks, 1%; Camping, 0.8%; Dog walking, 0.2%; Bushwalking, 0.2%; Nature observation, 0.2%, and; Visiting historic features, 0.2%. Nil response was recorded for Apiculture, Approved research, Environmental education, Orienteering and rogaining, and Water production. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 24 Discussion themes at the open house During the community consultation event, a variety of views were recorded in logbooks located at each table. The log books picked up many detailed comments ranging from elements of the proposed area which were particularly valued, to people’s aspirations for the establishment and future management of the park. These comments and the comments from the graffiti wall map have been transcribed as a record of community views on the establishment of the proposed park. Each comment or submission was allocated a theme and grouped in turn into three categories; Environmental, Recreation and Other. The results of this analysis have been summarised in figure 10. In relation to recreational themes the two most popular discussions were walking and roads. This reflects the dominant recreational use of the park area at the current time, being walking and other passive recreational activities, as well as the primary concern held by local residents, being traffic hazards and the safety of roads throughout the area. In relation to environmental themes, the results suggest that the community mostly values the area in general terms, as a forested landscape. There were also concerns about rubbish dumping, fire, weeds and pests. However, these were not expressed as commonly as concern over roads and traffic. Aside from the popularity of walking, with and without dogs, the community favoured a wide range of recreational activities. These included mountain biking, camping and horse riding. There were also a large number of people who were concerned that prospecting might be excluded from the park. In addition to recreational and environmental themes, there were a number of additional themes which could not be categorised. These included strong support for use of the park for educational purposes, concern about access points into the area being maintained, and a number of comments hoping that suitable information and facilities will be provided after the park is established. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 25 Figure 10. Discussion themes at the open house Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 26 7.6 Summary of consultation results The results of the consultation indicate strong support for the creation of the park. There is also a strong correlation in the aspirations and values for the proposed park from across the different methods used and in the views and comments from stakeholders and the community. From the on-line survey and the community open house ‘uses activity’, it can be seen that the proposed park is currently used for bike riding (including MTB), bushwalking, dog walking, nature observation, prospecting, 4WD and trail biking. In terms of future uses, community feedback and submissions were overwhelming supportive of the creation of a park that supports a wide range of uses including bush walking, mountain bike riding, picnicking, nature observation, orienteering, dog walking, horse riding, prospecting and environmental education. The most preferred future recreational uses were bush walking, bike riding (including MTB), nature/historic feature observation, picnicking, education and research (Table 7). Feedback at the open house event showed there was moderate support for horse riding and prospecting. Responses from the on-line survey and the community open house indicated that car touring, 4WD & trail bikes, hunting, car rallies, grazing are not preferred uses for the proposed park. In regards to productive uses there was a low preference for firewood, apiculture and water production and a moderate opposition to mining and mineral exploration. Table 7. Comparison of recreational uses in order of preference from the online survey and the open house Rank 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 On-line survey results Bushwalking Short walks Cycling, mountain bike riding Environmental education Nature observation Picnicking Research Orienteering and rogaining Visiting historic features Dog walking on a lead Camping Horse riding on tracks Apiculture Prospecting, fossicking, panning Dog walking off lead Park uses activity (open house) Bushwalking Cycling, mountain bike riding Nature observation Dog walking Picnicking Environmental education Horse riding Prospecting, fossicking, panning Camping Orienteering and rogaining Visiting historic features Firewood collection Apiculture Research Hunting All of the five stakeholder submissions were generally supportive of the park, with the Friends of Canadian Corridor, the Leigh Catchment Group, the Prospectors and Miners Association of Victoria and the Victorian National Parks Association advocating for the classification of regional park as the park type that most closely matches the multiple types of recreation and environmental uses preferred for the proposed park. As a result of consultation with Central Highlands Water, it is not proposed to include the two water supply tanks located on Crown Land Water Supply Reserves within the proposed park. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 27 7.7 Conclusion Community and stakeholder feedback and submissions were overwhelmingly supportive of the creation of a park that supports a wide range of recreation uses, enhances the landscape by creating a north-south wildlife corridor and protects natural and cultural values. As a result of the stakeholder and community consultation it has been decided to create the park as a regional park, rather than the state park that had been initially proposed. A regional park will accommodate the community’s wishes to access the park for a wide variety of uses, such as bushwalking, bike riding, nature observation, dog walking, horse riding and prospecting. The recommended recreational activities and other uses to be provided for in the proposed Canadian Park as a reflection of community and stakeholder aspirations are presented in Table 8. Table 8. Recreational activities and other uses recommended for the proposed park. Note: Some uses may depend on whether the legislation provides for the use in a particular park (e.g. firewood collection in a regional park), the use of powers to set aside land where the use is permitted or excluded, or the issuing of a permit to allow the use. 1 May be permitted if area is subject to a pre-existing exploration licence. 2 Two exploration licences exist over the proposed park area. 3 Unauthorised. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 28 References BCC 2006, Ballarat City Council Comprehensive Koala Plan of Management, Ballarat City Council. BCC 2013, Mapping Ballarat’s Historic Urban Landscape, Ballarat City Council. BCC 2015, Draft Ballarat Strategy, Ballarat City Council. BoM 2015, Climate Data Online - Scotsburn (Mount Buninyong) weather station, Bureau of Meteorology, viewed 27 May 2015, < http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/data/> DELWP 2015, Victorian Biodiversity Atlas, Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning, Melbourne. Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 29 Appendix 1. Stakeholder list Stakeholder Stakeholder type Key Partner Stakeholders Friends of the Canadian Corridor Community interest group City of Ballarat CFA Parks Victoria Wathaurung Aboriginal Corporation Geoff Howard MLA Member for Buninyong Local stakeholder/Interest groups Ballarat East Network Field Naturalists Club of Ballarat Pax Hill Scout Group Friends of Sparrow Ground Leigh Catchment Landcare Group Lal Lal Catchment Landcare Group Wattle Flat Pootilla Landcare Group Ballarat Bicycle User Group University of the Third Age (U3A) walking group Ballarat Sebastopol Cycling Club / Ballarat Mountain Bike Club Ballarat and District Outdoor Club Buninyong & District Community Association Birdlife Ballarat Federation University Federation University School of Outdoor Sciences Outdoor Ed Damascus College Mt Clear Primary School Mt Clear Emmaus Catholic Primary School Eureka Orienteers Inc. Prospectors and Miners Association of Victoria Ballarat Field & Game Australia Ballarat District Four Wheel Drive Club Mt Clear Secondary College Mountain View Riding Club Ballarat Pony Club Ballarat Adult Riding Club Ballarat Rovers Motor Cycle Club Ballarat Renewable Energy And Zero Emissions Ballarat Environment Network Ballarat Observatory Sovereign Hill First Mount Clear Scout Group Ballarat Historical Society Municipal council, planning authority Fire management emergency response agency Potential land manager, park management expertise Traditional owner Local member of parliament Community interest group Conservation interest group Adjacent land manager/user group Community interest group Community interest group Community interest group Community interest group Recreational users Recreational users Recreation users Recreational users Nearby community group Recreational user Education organisation/neighbour Education organisation/neighbour Education organisation/neighbour Education organisation/neighbour Education organisation/neighbour Recreational user group Recreational user group Peak body Recreational user group Neighbour Recreational user group Recreational user group Recreational user group Recreational user group Conservation interest group Conservation interest group Interest group Tourism Community group Historical/community groups Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 30 Stakeholder Stakeholder type Friends of Pryor Park Australian Koala Foundation Great Dividing Trail Association Ballarat South Landcare group Corangamite CMA Powercor (licence holder) Telstra (licence holder) Central Highlands Water Victorian Apiarists' Association Conservation interest group Conservation interest group Recreational user group Conservation interest group Catchment manager Power provider Communications provider Water corporation Peak body General Community Midvale traders Adjacent residents Local community in Ballarat area Local businesses Neighbours Local interest Media – local Ballarat Courier ABC Radio Ballarat WIN TV News Power FM radio Regional newspaper: Local radio Regional TV Local commercial radio State bodies Victorian Environment Assessment Council (VEAC) Victorian National Parks Association Biosecurity Group - Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources Sport and Recreation - Department of Health and Human Services Victoria Police Land use body Conservation group (NGO) Government department Government department Law enforcement and emergency response agency Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 31 Appendix 2. Transcript of community comments (log sheets, graffiti wall and submissions) Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Community comment Poor condition of many roads in the area, not graded often enough Traffic and dangerous drivers on local roads Recreation road too narrow and unsafe at speeds currently allowed Horse trail riding operators concerned that business will be lost if riding not permitted Walking tracks suitable for different levels of disability could be incorporated into the park Source Theme Host Table Host Table Roads Roads Host Table Roads Host Table Horses Host Table Neighbouring landowner not informed of park proposal Existing roads are not suitable for the increased traffic likely with the new park Unregistered motorbikes, riders without helmets poses safety risk Walking tracks connecting Bell Avenue, Olympic Avenue and York St could be implemented Host Table Walking Community consultation Host Table Roads Host Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Motorbikes Prospecting in the park should be allowed to continue EDEN project in Cornwall, England is a good example to work by 20 Park is a good idea as it will help keep the area clean Material such as maps and fact sheets would be good for the area Firewood collection might reduce the need for planned burning in the area Recreational activities such as walking, orienteering, running, mountain bikes are important Recreational activities such as walking, orienteering, running, mountain bikes are important Recreational activities such as walking, orienteering, running, mountain bikes are important Recreational activities such as walking, orienteering, running, mountain bikes are important Public education to inform people of importance as wildlife corridor Park should not restrict access to anyone, including prospectors 21 Mountain bikes need established trails 22 Landscape of forested skyline is important Intensive recreation preferred to be confined to close to residential areas 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 23 Walking Prospecting Park management Park management Information Firewood Recreation Recreation Recreation Recreation Education Access Mountain bikes Landscape Recreation Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 32 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. Community comment 24 26 Habitat and biodiversity areas further from residential areas Climate change adaptation for habitat to be considered in management Fire management to be designed to minimise negative impacts 27 Connecting trails to the Canadian creek path 28 29 Interpretive information on history, including Wadawurrung Domestic pests and weeds to be mitigate in park management 30 Support licensed tourism operators 31 Specified off leash dog parks Walking tracks in the park to link up with existing paths and trails in the Ballarat area 25 32 33 34 Weed control should be a priority Accessibility for people with disabilities or impairments so they can participate 35 Balance between recreation and biodiversity conservation 36 Connectivity of north-south forested corridor is important Intensive activities such as thinning or clearing are acceptable in western parts near housing Need to engage uni, schools etc. in discussion on using area for educational purposes Tourism infrastructure such as a small information bay with facilities would be valuable Prospecting including detection, sluicing and panning are important for tour business Access points to park to be designed to allow more intensive use in some areas Wasps have been a big problem around the park area in recent times Boundary road used by trail and mountain bike riders, causing erosion and damage to road Pine regrowth and other invasive species is becoming wide spread in some areas Dangerous drivers are a big problem Dumping of stolen cars will hopefully be reduced with a new park Area is too small for hunting to take place safely Archery may be a suitable activity in the park, if a designated range is provided Flying of model planes has been popular on the south side of the back block 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 Source Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Park Creation Table Theme Community Table Access Community Table Pests Community Table Roads Community Table Community Table Weeds Roads Community Table Community Table Dumping Hunting Community Table Recreation Community Table Recreation Biodiversity Climate change Fire Walking Information Weeds Tourism Dog walking Walking Weeds Access Recreation Landscape Park management Education Tourism Prospecting Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 33 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 Community comment Maintenance of boundary road has not been regular enough Recent planned burning has included unnecessary removal of trees Recent planned burning has included unnecessary removal of trees Rubbish dumping a big problem in the area around pax hill camp Rubbish dumping a big problem in the area around pax hill camp Picnic grounds or facilities in the area would be good Dams or wetlands in the area provided for water birds Old mine shafts near corner of York and Long streets are unsafe Generally satisfied that park is to be created Source Community Table Theme Roads Community Table Fire Community Table Fire Community Table Dumping Community Table Community Table Community Table Dumping Facilities Water Community Table Community Table Generally satisfied with consultation process Community hub or facility including signage and information would be a good way to start Community hub or facility including signage and information would be a good way to start Rangers and patrolling may reduce dumping and other antisocial activities such as fire lighting Walking in the area with students, area is used for education purposed by local teachers Walking tracks of varying difficulty including signposts and distances etc. Walking tracks of varying difficulty including signposts and distances etc. Community Table Public safety Park creation Community involvement Community Table Information Community Table Information Community Table Dumping Community Table Education Community Table Walking Community Table Beekeepers should be allowed, and encouraged in the park Facilitator/coordinator for community and Landcare groups for the area would be beneficial Open spaces should be incorporated into the park, don't just want forest over the whole area Biodiversity information sessions to help with public education and awareness of the park Multiple use park is appropriate, as area is large enough to include a variety of uses Any replanting should be carefully planned, and avoid lots of black plastic to become rubbish Photographic record of changes occurring as part of park establishment and management Nest boxes to encourage birdlife and participation by community groups Wadawurrung to be more deeply involved, and continue involvement in future Park may be an opportunity to revive the LINCS program, which has been "let go" in Ballarat Support habitat for fauna such as Koalas, Wallabies and Echidnas Community Table Community Table Walking Productive use Community involvement Community Table Spaces Community Table Biodiversity Community Table Recreation Community Table Biodiversity Park management Community Table Community Table Community Table Wildlife Cultural connections Community Table Biodiversity Community Table Wildlife Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 34 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 Community comment Recent burning near York St removed too many trees Link up Ballarat walking tracks through the park, including Pennyweight and Sparrow Ground tracks Planning to link in with local business, i.e. Cafes etc. located near ends of walking tracks Access to south end of Richards St and the old rifle range, any existing plans? Generally concerned over illegal activities such as dumping in the area Access to prospectors allowed in the future No large scale mining or exploration licences Firewood collection but no sawlog harvesting Camping to be permitted Would like access to definitions of each park type and allowed uses Firewood collection to be allowed Don't want roads to be sealed Don't want camping in the area Interested in rifle range subdivision and process for CFA approval Question about weed control and treatments at end of Richards St Recreational uses to be allowed, but internal tracks to be consolidated appropriately Dog walking to be allowed Revegetation would be beneficial Weeds and rubbish are key issues of concern Concern about maintaining (?) plots of vegetation in former plantation land Need to follow up weed control and burn treatment around boundaries of park area Happy with current burning regime and management generally Want to continue dog walking and horse riding across entire area Revegetation of former plantation land is important Passive uses would reduce amount of antisocial rubbish dumping etc. Enjoy horse riding in the area Source Community Table Theme Fire Municipal Table Walking Municipal Table Facilities Municipal Table Access Municipal Table Land and Fire Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Dumping Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Park creation Firewood Roads Camping Environment Table Adjoining use Environment Table Weeds Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Recreation Dog walking Forest Weeds Environment Table Forest Environment Table Weeds Environment Table Fire Environment Table Environment Table Horses Forest Environment Table Environment Table Dumping Horses Mountain bikes Landscape Recreation Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table 106 Walking and cycling favoured over motorbikes on trails Value importance of area as a wildlife corridor Kids like to run, play, ride bikes in the area Value area of forest close to the end of Richards St near the old rifle range (good quality) 107 Innovative approaches should be encouraged in park Environment Table Environment Table Prospecting Mining Firewood Camping Biodiversity Park management Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 35 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 Community comment Need disinfectant stations to prevent further spread of Phytophthora by motorbikes etc. Gullies full of tree ferns existed prior to area being turned into plantation Better signage required on roads, boundary road currently incorrectly named Davison rd. in places Enjoy walking and seeing animals in the forest Value Yarra Gums Want an off-lead area for dog-walking Want an off-lead area for dog-walking Need better identification of pest species Tree ferns may be found in the gorge/cascades area Plantation areas were originally cleared in the mid to late 70s Grass trees observed to be dying back along Davison rd. Too many roads in the area encourage rubbish dumping Dangerous drivers on recreation road, McCarthy's road are a big problem Want to see the forest returned to what was in the past Infectious diseases hospital was located off Greenhill road Some areas east of boundary road were entirely cleared in the 1940s but have since grown back Protection from degradation and restoration of indigenous species is important Rubbish dumping, weeds, foxes and dogs are the big problems Happy to see dog walking on lead only, as well as walkers, horses, bikes, dirt bikes Value landscape and skyline Value landscape and skyline Value landscape and skyline Value koalas and other wildlife Value koalas and other wildlife Motor vehicles increase noise pollution in and around the park Think the park will be something to be proud of Wants to see revegetation with indigenous species across former plantations, including wildflowers Motorbikes and other vehicles increase erosion Want to continue fossicking and digging sensitively in the area Dirt bikes, dumping, invasive species, feral animals are the big problems Want intensive activities confined to particular areas Climate change adaptation including pioneer species should be considered Zonings for natural conservation and other uses should be implemented Source Theme Environment Table Pests Environment Table Forest Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Roads Walking Forest Dog walking Dog walking Pests Biodiversity Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Historical Forest Dumping Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Roads Forest Historical Environment Table Landscape Environment Table Forest Environment Table Dumping Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Horses Landscape Landscape Landscape Wildlife Wildlife Environment Table Environment Table Roads Park Creation Environment Table Environment Table Forest Roads Environment Table Prospecting Environment Table Environment Table Motorbikes Recreation Climate change Park Management Environment Table Environment Table Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 36 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. Community comment Need an area designated for grass tree conservation, with restricted access to prevent fungus Revegetation of former plantation as a project for university or other group Area is invaluable for education purposes Need to address "nature deficit syndrome" Source Theme Environment Table Park part of Ballarat: "Eco Town" Use of area for gold prospecting tour business, in a sensitive manner Prospecting business will increase international profile of the park Prospecting is a good activity for older people (55+) No hunting, mining, or other activities which have a negative impact Recreation only appropriate to zoning and conservation objectives Green space for passive recreation, disturbed areas for more intensive activities Don't duplicate services available elsewhere, link to these instead (e.g. Picnic areas) Environment Table Biodiversity Community involvement Education Education Park management Environment Table Prospecting Environment Table Environment Table Prospecting Prospecting Environment Table Hunting Environment Table Recreation Environment Table Recreation Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Education 156 157 158 159 Community involvement is critical to success Need an appropriate fire/burning regime established Research opportunities including for regeneration after disturbance (plantations) Walking tracks featuring multiple vegetation types and landforms Want to see the rifle range site included in the park area Don't want to see prospecting shut out of the area Fenced area for dogs off lead, around 5 acres Facilities Community involvement Fire Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table 160 161 162 163 Use the green army for revegetation of cleared areas Engage walking clubs in weed removal activities Carpark to facilitate walking circuits around the area Don't want to see grazing or rubbish dumping Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table 164 165 Retention of vegetation important to reduce light pollution Need to provide nest boxes and logs for fauna habitat Camping area with toilet in southern part of park away from pax hill Want to see upgrade of McCarthy's and recreation road More information about plant species and weeds Weed control is important Need small unburnt patches when conducting burning, to allow for habitat Pine seedlings moving into bushland is an issue, as are cats and foxes Environment Table Environment Table Walking Adjoining use Prospecting Dog walking Park management Weeds Walking Dumping Park management Wildlife Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Camping Roads Information Weeds Environment Table Fire Environment Table Weeds 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 166 167 168 169 170 171 Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 37 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 Community comment Want better connectivity along the length of the park, linking of remnants Mountain biking and other recreational activities are a chance to showcase natural values Continuous walking track from one end to the other Criterion track for mountain biking, competition, additional tourism Incorporate wetlands to manage water runoff Phytophthora also identified along Greenhill road in the south of the area Wondering if the dirt road behind Greenhaven court will be staying, intends to use the road Park could do with a good clean up of the forest floor to reduce fire risk Uses the park for walking with and without dogs Supportive of the park, frequently walks in the park and immediate neighbour Would like to see an indigenous name for the park Management should address plant removal, rubbish dumping, noxious weeds, fire Management should address habitat preservation, events and uses, improvements Rehabilitation of former plantation should be consistent with existing cultural landscape values Uses the park for walking with family and dogs, lives near the park Concerned about illegal hooning, car use and antisocial behaviour Walks with two bushwalking groups in the forest, and also knows of orienteering and rogaining Field naturalist, also concerned that many people will not be consulted before the deadline North–south walking and cycling trail along Boundary Road connecting to Creswick Southern VPP parcel favoured for MTB/bike riding and dog walking, tourism for MTB activities Source Theme Environment Table Environment Table Environment Table Landscape Mountain bikes Walking Mountain bikes Water Environment Table Pests Email submission Roads Phone submission Phone submission Fire Dog walking Email submission Email submission Written submission Written submission Written submission Walking Park creation Phone submission Walking Phone submission Roads Email submission Walking Email submission Park creation Graffiti wall MTB trail head just off Recreation Road Is resident access between Canadian Lake Blvd/Davies Road and the park possible? Provide a connecting bridge on north-south track over gully between Olympic Ave and Greenhill Rd Develop walks suitable for people with different levels of ability Provide link to Canadian Creek Track from Olympic Ave Gully line running east of Rifle Range formerly full of tree ferns & large trees before plantation Best view of the city near the intersection of Bakers Road and Boundary Road, cleared land Graffiti wall Walking Mountain bikes Mountain bikes Graffiti wall Access Graffiti wall Access Graffiti wall Graffiti wall Walking Walking Graffiti wall Forest Graffiti wall Landscape Environment Table Environment Table Graffiti wall Fire Recreation Landscape Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 38 Canadian Park Open House – Transcript of comments from Log Sheets, Graffiti Wall and Submissions No. 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 Community comment Eucalyptus yarraensis within the rectangular freehold/private parcel near western edge of park Platylobium noted within remnant vegetation patch near Greenhaven court Woody weed control requested west of Katy Ryans Road and in other areas Tracks and trail in area between Olympic Ave and Greenhill set aside for nature walks What about the kangaroos and koalas? Cascades and waterfalls within park boundary in south eastern most corner of park Erosion an issue in southern most former VPP parcel at gully Source Theme Graffiti wall Forest Graffiti wall Biodiversity Graffiti wall Weeds Graffiti wall Graffiti wall Walking Wildlife Graffiti wall Graffiti wall Landscape Management Values, Uses and Community Views: A final report on stakeholder and community consultation for the creation of a new park in Ballarat 39