NPQH Final Assessment Guidance for Trainee Headteachers Contents Page Overview of the Final Assessment Process 2 NPQH competency framework 3 Award of NPQH 5 Task 1 Leading a School Improvement Priority 5 Task 2 Leading school improvement working in partnership with the Placement School 12 Task 3 Practical knowledge and expertise demonstrated in test environments: case study and presentation/interview Appendix 1 NPQH Competency Framework © 2012 National College for School Leadership 19 25 1 Overview of the Final Assessment Process Graduation from NPQH will demonstrate your ability to be an effective headteacher and that you are ready to take up your first headship. The NPQH Final Assessment process has therefore been designed to provide opportunities for you to demonstrate your leadership in practice through the successful completion of school improvement work undertaken your own and in other schools, as well as your capacity to perform well in presenting, at interview and in making decisions in test environments. As for the Gateway Assessment, NPQH Final Assessment is competency based, testing the key competencies that are required for successful headship. The assessment process will therefore enable you to demonstrate the progress you have made since the Gateway stage. Full details of the competencies tested are given below. The Final Assessment comprises three tasks: Task 1 You will undertake a task in your school (or agreed school setting if not based in school) in which you lead for an extended period on an actual school improvement priority. Task 2 You will undertake a task working in partnership with your placement school in which you lead for a short period on an actual school improvement priority working closely with placement school staff and the school leadership. You will also, over the whole period of the placement, develop a relationship with the placement school to enable you to extend your own learning about school leadership and to improve your leadership. Task 3 This task comprises two elements in test environments: Firstly, you will undertake a case study assessment that will cover: Leading school financial management Leading teacher appraisal You will need to demonstrate you are able to manage these key aspects of a school that you may not have been able to take full leadership of while on NPQH and show you are able to make appropriate decisions and justify your actions. Secondly, you will attend a presentation/interview. You will make a presentation to a panel and answer questions put by the panel on the content of your presentation and your progress towards successful headship through NPQH. You will need to be able to show you have developed the competence to present in a credible way as a headteacher. You should also be prepared to demonstrate how you have used your NPQH experiences to reflect upon and improve your own leadership competencies to a level that shows your readiness to take up your first headship. The school-based work undertaken in Tasks 1 and 2 will need to be achievable within a 12 month period, to relate to the schools’ improvement priorities and must produce demonstrable positive impact and sustainable change. For all aspects of the assessment you will be expected to draw upon your practical experience, research and school evidence to inform your leadership decision making. You will also be expected to apply your learning from the essential and elective © 2012 National College for School Leadership 2 modules you have completed and to draw upon your knowledge and expertise in key national policy priorities, for example, leading and improving the quality of teaching and pupils’ behaviour, teacher appraisal and financial management. The assessment tasks can also be used towards CATS points if required. NPQH competency framework NPQH is underpinned by a competency framework of 16 competencies. These competencies define the characteristics that are needed to be ready for headship. In preparing for your development and Final assessment it is important that you read and understand the competencies in the NPQH Competency framework – there is a description of each competency and a statement as to ‘Why it matters’ for each of them in Appendix 1. The competencies include characteristics that are needed to be ready for headship, including knowledge (including specific technical knowledge), skills, motives and ability which are expressed in actions or behaviours: Knowledge is what a person knows about a particular area, for example, strategies for improving teaching and learning, ways of managing financial and human resources, and project management for planning and implementing change, performance management and legal issues relating to employment or child protection. Skills are things a person knows how to do well to achieve a goal, for example, collecting and analysing data, monitoring progress, using new technologies, planning, communicating, getting community feedback and carrying out accurate self-assessment. Motives may be expressed in a person’s values such as what he/she believes in or what he/she believes it is important to do (for example, commitment to the pursuit of excellence, working in a collaborative way, insisting on a safe and healthy working environment or through preferences (such as achievement or affiliation), for example, a person with a strong achievement motive will continuously want to achieve and make things better. Ability covers both a person’s ability to think and act rationally and to use their emotional intelligence, for example, identifying trends in performance, using school self-review to make sound decisions, and the ability to build effective teams. Ability can be affected through the working of the emotions and changed through self-awareness and self-management of these. The 16 competencies in the framework are grouped into three areas that reflect key dimensions of highly effective leadership, as demonstrated through research evidence: Strategic leadership: highly effective school leaders have a strong sense of direction: they have a vision for the school and a clear sense of how to achieve their vision. They can lead successfully in a highly autonomous and accountable system. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 3 Educational excellence: highly effective school leaders have the leadership of teaching at the heart of their work: they can lead effectively in a self-improving system to deliver high-quality outcomes for all pupils and students. Operational management: highly effective heads have very effective systems and processes that are consistently applied by all staff: they manage the school to ensure efficient and effective use of all resources and achieve a fit-for-purpose organisation. Figure 1: Three areas of competency Strategic leadership Educational excellence Self-awareness and selfmanagement Delivering continuous improvement Efficient and effective Personal drive and accountability Modelling excellence in teaching Analytical thinking Resilience and emotional maturity Learning focus Conceptual thinking Future focus Impact and influence Partnership and collaboration Organisational and community understanding Operational management Relationship management Holding others to account Developing others Not all of the 16 competencies will be directly tested in the Final Assessment process; there will be a focus upon assessing the following nine leadership competencies. Figure 2: Competencies tested at Final Assessment Strategic leadership Personal drive and accountability Strategic leadership Resilience and emotional maturity Strategic leadership Impact and Influence Educational excellence Delivering continuous improvement Educational excellence Modelling excellence in teaching Educational excellence Learning focus Educational excellence Partnership and collaboration Operational management Efficient and Effective Operational management Holding others to account © 2012 National College for School Leadership 4 The descriptions of these nine leadership competencies can be found in Appendix 1 but there will be further guidance in the sections that follow on the three tasks on the specific competencies that will be tested and how you will be able to develop these and then demonstrate them when presenting for Final Assessment. Award of NPQH The award of NPQH will depend upon reaching a high standard in all of the eight leadership competencies tested. Each of the tasks will contribute to a single judgement on your readiness for headship and the award of NPQH and therefore you will not receive individual test results and feedback. You will receive some overall feedback at the end of the process. However, if in any task you not reach the required standard you will be advised of this and given the opportunity to take the task again and if you do not reach the highest possible standard in any of the competencies you will be advised of this to enable you to plan further development and to prepare for the presentation/interview element of Task 3. Task 1 Leading a School Improvement Priority in own (or agreed) school This element of the final assessment will enable you to demonstrate that you can deliver successful and sustainable school improvement in your school setting (or agreed school setting if not based in school) and that you can use the experience to reflect upon and improve your own leadership competencies. This task will test six leadership competencies: Figure 3: competencies tested in Task 1 Strategic leadership Personal drive and accountability Strategic leadership Resilience and emotional maturity Educational excellence Delivering continuous improvement Educational excellence Modelling excellence in teaching Educational excellence Learning focus Operational management Holding others to account The descriptions of the six leadership competencies tested can be found in Appendix 1. Key elements of the task: You are required to lead for an extended period (a minimum of two terms) on an actual whole school improvement priority © 2012 National College for School Leadership 5 The school improvement priority selected should be in the school improvement plan or similar whole school plan. The task should be strategic and positively impact on the whole school The school improvement priority selected should be one that is sufficiently challenging to firstly enable you to develop and secondly to provide evidence of the competencies relating to Educational excellence and Strategic leadership being tested in this task(see below for further specific guidance) The task should enable you to develop and implement a strategic plan, taking actions which involve leading and holding to account other school leaders and staff, and being accountable to stakeholders, including governors or equivalent The task needs to be completed within a twelve month period and must be sufficiently advanced by the time of submission for you to demonstrate sustainable improvement – you will need to evaluate the outcomes from your leadership and provide quantified evidence of your personal impact including the positive difference your work has had in the school and on meeting its goals and of systems/structures in place to sustain the change and/or of specific proposals for further action to be include in the school improvement plan or equivalent You will need to show how you used: o research and school evidence o learning from the essential and elective modules o knowledge and expertise in key national policy priorities to inform your leadership decision making, and provide evidence of your development as a school leader (see below for further specific guidance). Specific guidance on providing competency-based evidence on leading a school improvement priority and developing as a school leader You should begin by reading the descriptions of the six leadership competencies to be tested in Appendix 1. Undertaking the task should enable your further development in Educational excellence and you should be able to demonstrate in your submission for assessment: o Delivering continuous improvement including involving and inspiring governors and stakeholders to support the school vision for the school improvement priority and in strategically planning for its delivery, determining and evaluating innovative strategies for action to improve teaching and learning and/or the curriculum in the context of the school’s performance using relevant data and information (including research, learning from essential and elective modules and expertise in key national policy areas), setting suitably ambitious targets and success criteria, and working with leaders, staff, governors (or equivalent) and other stakeholders on delivery © 2012 National College for School Leadership 6 o o o Modelling excellence in teaching, including your understanding of the characteristics of excellent/outstanding teaching and the theories and research on effecting teaching and learning, your capacity to articulate your expectations of teaching and learning and to identify strategies to improve these that are critical to the success of the task, your ability to recognise and use good leadership in teaching and learning in delivering your strategies and to share your knowledge and expertise in teaching and learning to embed good practice, systematically monitoring the impact of your work throughout the task and evaluating its impact on teaching Learning focus, including sharing your passion for improving learning and your capacity to develop staff and to embed a culture of learning for all members of the school community through your leadership of professional development in relation to the task, addressing diversity issues or barriers to learning which are critical to the success of the task such as high standards of attendance, punctuality and behaviour and/or issues faced by pupils and parents in and outside of the school, and systematically monitoring the impact of your work throughout the task and evaluating its impact on learning of individuals and groups of pupils Holding others to account including creating levels of accountability within the school and ensuring all understand their roles and responsibilities, standards required and accountabilities, distributing leadership and delegating effectively, demanding high performance through making expectations clear and spelling out the consequences of non-compliance, using the performance management (teacher appraisal) systems effectively to set objectives and targets to deliver school priorities, systematically monitoring performance and progress against objectives and targets, praising success and giving constructive feedback but also taking swift action when performance levels drop Undertaking the task should enable your development in Strategic leadership and you should be able to demonstrate in your submission for assessment: o Personal drive and accountability, including being results orientated through setting goals on what you want to achieve for yourself and the school in relation to the task, being self-motivated, energetic and decisive in taking responsibility for achieving these goals and adopting a high personal profile while leading on the task, using the experience of leading the task to enhance your own and others’ effectiveness and motivating others to achieve results, regularly measuring progress towards both personal and school goals and evaluating the outcomes and impact of your work, accounting for your own and school performance to governors or equivalent, and to other stakeholders on the successful delivery of sustainable change o Resilience and emotional maturity, including being resilient and tenacious to achieve the task and secure sustainable improvement within the time allowed, remaining optimistic and focused upon the task when under pressure or when faced with resistance to change, addressing difficult situations and resolving any conflict in a restrained way, responding positively and with resolve if faced with personal criticism or setbacks, speaking and acting in accordance with school values when it is © 2012 National College for School Leadership 7 necessary to implement decisions that others find challenging and being able to bring the task to a conclusion even in changing situations Undertaking the task should enable your development in Operational management and you should be able to demonstrate in your submission for assessment: Specific guidance on the submission of evidence The submission to the Assessment Panel will be in two parts: Your submission to the Assessment Panel Your sponsor’s submission to the Assessment Panel – based on both observation of your leadership of the school improvement priority and your submission to the Assessment Panel. Your submission to the Assessment Panel You are able to choose what you submit and the form your submission takes, subject to the limitations set out below. Your submission should comprise actual school documents but unless these documents are comprehensive and self-explanatory you will also need to include a short commentary to explain how you demonstrated the leadership competencies being tested through your leadership of the priority for school improvement. You should ensure that your documentation covers: The nature of the school improvement priority Your leadership of the strategic planning process and setting of personal and school goals and targets Your leadership to implement the strategic plan, including actions taken and how you led and held to account other school leaders and staff and overcame challenges and difficulties Your monitoring and evaluation of the school improvement priority and of progress towards meeting your personal goals Your accountability to stakeholders for the outcomes of your leadership of the priority Your evaluation of outcomes for the school: quantified evidence of your personal impact in the school and on meeting its goals and of systems/structures in place to sustain the change and/or of specific proposals for further action to be include in the school improvement plan or equivalent Your evaluation of personal outcomes: development of your leadership competencies and of ability to apply learning from the essential and elective modules and expertise in key national policy areas Reflects the guidance given above on the ’Key elements of the task’ and ‘Providing competency-based evidence on leading a school improvement priority and developing as a school leader’. Documentation When submitting the actual school documents that provide competency-based evidence of your leadership and leadership development and the explanatory © 2012 National College for School Leadership 8 commentary, if you wish to include this, you must not exceed 12 pages of A4 in font size 12 and these must be capable of being read and understood within 30 minutes reading time. Actual school documents could include, for example: Extract from school improvement plan or equivalent for the priority Outline of staff development led by you Extract from policy document(s) produced under your leadership Extract from reports to SLT and/or governing body or equivalent Quantified analysis of outcomes /positive impact prepared for use in school. The sponsor’s submission to the Assessment Panel will be an evaluation of your leadership of the school improvement priority and this will be based upon both their observation of your leadership of the strategy in the school and their reading of your submission for the Assessment Panel. A form (to be presented in landscape for ease of completion) with accompanying guidance will be provided to make this process as straightforward as possible for the sponsor. Sponsors will be asked to verify the evidence you submit and give their own assessment of your leadership of the school improvement priority and the outcomes for the school, and of your leadership development. Sponsors will be provided with descriptions of the competencies being tested and the guidance you have been given on undertaking the task. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 9 Figure 4: NPQH Task 1 Leading a School improvement Priority Sponsor’s submission to the Assessment Panel Name of trainee headteacher………………………………….. As Sponsor, you are asked to verify the evidence provided by the trainee headteacher and to give your own assessment of their leadership of the school improvement priority. Please read the descriptions of the competencies supplied as well as the statements set out below and comment on key aspects of their development in the six leadership competencies. Please also provide quantified evidence of the outcomes and the positive impact of their leadership in the school, where possible (column 2). Then award the most appropriate grade (column 3) from the scale set out below to reflect the extent to which they have used the opportunity of leading the school improvement priority to consolidate their learning from the essential and elective NPQH modules, from research and school evidence, and from knowledge and expertise in key national policy priorities and the degree of progress they have made in developing the leadership competency: Very good: trainee headteacher made full use of the opportunities for development and made outstanding progress in leadership development Good: trainee headteacher made use of many opportunities for development and made significant progress in leadership development Moderate: trainee headteacher made some use of the opportunities for development and made some progress in leadership development Poor: trainee headteacher made limited use of the opportunities for development and limited progress Leadership competency Verification and additional Grade evidence Awarded: Very good, good, moderate, poor Delivering continuous improvement including involving and inspiring governors and stakeholders to support the school vision for the school improvement priority and in strategically planning for its delivery, determining and evaluating innovative strategies for action to improve teaching and learning and/or the curriculum in the context of the school’s performance using relevant data and information (including research, learning from essential and elective modules and expertise in key national policy areas), setting suitably ambitious targets and success criteria, and working with leaders, staff, governors (or equivalent) and other stakeholders on delivery Modelling excellence in teaching, including your understanding of the characteristics of excellent/outstanding teaching and the theories and research on effecting teaching and learning, your capacity to articulate your expectations of teaching and learning and to identify strategies to improve these that are critical to the success of the task, your ability to recognise and use good leadership in teaching and learning in delivering your strategies and to share your knowledge and expertise in teaching and learning to embed good practice, systematically monitoring the impact of your work throughout the task and evaluating its impact on teaching Learning focus, including sharing your passion for improving learning and your capacity to develop staff and to embed a culture of learning for all members of the school community © 2012 National College for School Leadership 10 through your leadership of professional development in relation to the task, addressing diversity issues or barriers to learning which are critical to the success of the task such as high standards of attendance, punctuality and behaviour and/or issues faced by pupils and parents in and outside of the school, and systematically monitoring the impact of your work throughout the task and evaluating its impact on learning of individuals and groups of pupils Personal drive and accountability, including being results orientated through setting goals on what you want to achieve for yourself and the school in relation to the task, being selfmotivated, energetic and decisive in taking responsibility for achieving these goals and adopting a high personal profile while leading on the task, using the experience of leading the task to enhance your own and others’ effectiveness and motivating others to achieve results, regularly measuring progress towards both personal and school goals and evaluating the outcomes and impact of your work, accounting for your own and school performance to governors or equivalent, and to other stakeholders on the successful delivery of sustainable change Resilience and emotional maturity, including being resilient and tenacious to achieve the task and secure sustainable improvement within the time allowed, remaining optimistic and focused upon the task when under pressure or when faced with resistance to change, addressing difficult situations and resolving any conflict in a restrained way, responding positively and with resolve if faced with personal criticism or setbacks, speaking and acting in accordance with school values when it is necessary to implement decisions that others find challenging and being able to bring the task to a conclusion even in changing situations Holding others to account including creating levels of accountability within the school and ensuring all understand their roles and responsibilities, standards required and accountabilities, distributing leadership and delegating effectively, demanding high performance through making expectations clear and spelling out the consequences of noncompliance, using the performance management (teacher appraisal) systems effectively to set objectives and targets to deliver school priorities, systematically monitoring performance and progress against objectives and targets, praising success and giving constructive feedback but also taking swift action when performance levels drop Sponsor’s signature……………………………… Date………………………….. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 11 Task 2 Leading school improvement working in partnership with the Placement School This element of the final assessment will enable you to demonstrate that you can deliver successful and sustainable school improvement in other school settings and can use the experience to reflect upon and improve your own leadership competencies. This task will test three leadership competencies: Figure 5: competencies tested in Task 2 Strategic leadership Impact and Influence Educational excellence Delivering continuous improvement Educational excellence Partnership and collaboration The descriptions of the three leadership competencies tested can be found in Appendix 1. Key elements of the task: You are required to lead for a short period (a minimum of four days of your placement) in your placement school on an actual school improvement priority working closely with placement school staff and the school leadership (SLT and governing body or equivalent). The school improvement priority selected should be in the school improvement plan or similar whole school plan. The task should be strategic and positively impact on the whole school The task should be self-contained and achievable within the timescale but should be sufficient challenging to firstly enable you to develop and secondly to provide evidence of the competencies relating to Educational excellence and Strategic leadership being tested in this task(see below for further specific guidance) The task should enable you to: o Negotiate the placement task with the placement school headteacher, including the expected outcomes, the timescale needed to undertake and evaluate it and the support needed from the placement school o Review the context of the placement school and how the chosen priority relates to the school’s overall plans for school improvement o Lead and involve others to secure agreement on objectives, the approach to delivering the priority, and in the actual delivery of the task © 2012 National College for School Leadership 12 o o Engage effectively and work in partnership with pupils/students, staff, school leaders, governors and other relevant stakeholders in delivering the priority Report on the task outcomes and gain support for the arrangements and accountabilities you create for ensuring sustainable improvement to SLT and governing body or equivalent; using these presentation(s) as an opportunity to develop leadership competencies in the placement school context You will also, over the whole period of the placement: o evaluate your leadership of the school improvement priority within the placement school(including taking account of feedback from the placement school headteacher) o extend your knowledge of school leadership in a different context through developing an on-going relationship with the placement school and improve your leadership in your own school or context (using the remaining days – up to five) The task must be sufficiently advanced by the time of submission for you to demonstrate sustainable improvement – you will need to evaluate the outcomes from your leadership and provide quantified evidence (where possible)of your personal impact including the positive difference your work has had in the school and on meeting its goals and of arrangements and accountabilities in place to sustain the change and to be taken forward by placement school staff You will need to show how you used: o research and school evidence o learning from the essential and elective modules o knowledge and expertise in key national policy priorities to inform your leadership decision making, and evidence of your development as a school leader will also be required (see below for further specific guidance). Specific guidance on providing competency-based evidence on leading a school improvement priority and developing as a school leader You should begin by reading the descriptions of the three leadership competencies tested in the Task in Appendix 1. Undertaking the task should enable your further development in Educational excellence and you should be able to demonstrate in your submission for assessment: o Delivering continuous improvement including involving and inspiring governors and stakeholders to support the school vision for the school improvement priority and in strategically planning for its delivery, determining and evaluating innovative strategies for action to improve teaching and learning and/or the curriculum in the context of the school’s performance using relevant data and information (including research, learning from essential and elective modules and expertise in key national © 2012 National College for School Leadership 13 o policy areas), setting suitably ambitious targets and success criteria, and working with leaders, staff, governors (or equivalent) and other stakeholders on delivery Partnership and collaboration including building positive relationships with a wide range of people, being aware of different agendas and perspectives and taking these into account in building consensus , creating opportunities for informing and working collaboratively with a wide range of stakeholders including parents/carers and the wider community, using mechanisms such as networking and creating structures and processes for cooperation, collaboration and sharing expertise between institutions so that priorities for partnership working are identified and the stakeholders of all institutions benefit Undertaking the task should enable your further development in Strategic leadership and you should be able to demonstrate in your submission for assessment: o Impact and influence including having good negotiation and communication skills, making a positive impact through the ability to unite others around the school’s vision and through presenting information and proposals in a way that increases understanding, holds attention and inspires and engages others , listening to others views and being able to tailor their communication to suit the audience, when agreement needs to be reached able to influence others directly or through third parties, so that they are sure of sufficient support before difficult decisions have to be taken and presenting their arguments and proposals clearly and logically so that others are persuaded of their efficacy and agreement can be reached on a way forward during negotiations Specific guidance on the submission of evidence The submission to the Assessment Panel will be in two parts: Your submission to the Assessment Panel Your placement headteacher’s submission to the Assessment Panel – based on observation of your leadership of the school improvement priority, your on-going relationship with the school to extend your knowledge of school leadership and improve your own leadership, and your submission to the Assessment Panel. Your submission to the Assessment Panel You are able to choose what you submit and the form your submission takes, subject to the limitations set out below. Your submission should comprise actual school documents and documents prepared for the placement task but unless these documents are comprehensive and self-explanatory you will also need to include a short commentary to explain how you demonstrated the leadership competencies being tested through your leadership of the priority for school improvement, your ongoing relationship with the school and how you improved your own leadership as a result. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 14 You should ensure that your documentation covers: Your preparation for the task, relationship with the placement school over the period of the placement and the nature of the school improvement priority Your leadership of the priority, including actions taken and how you involved, led and worked in partnership with leaders, staff, pupils/students, governors (or equivalent) and other stakeholders to secure agreement on objectives, the approach to delivering the priority, and in the actual delivery of the task Your evaluation of outcomes for the school: including quantified evidence (where possible) of your personal impact including the positive difference your work has had in the school and on meeting its goals and the arrangements and accountabilities you created to secure sustainable improvement Your reporting to stakeholders and accountability for the outcomes of your leadership of the priority Your evaluation of personal outcomes: the development of your leadership competencies and of the changes you have made to your leadership in your own school/setting Reflects the guidance given above on the ‘Key elements of the task’ and ‘Providing competency-based evidence on leading a school improvement priority and developing as a school leader’. Documentation When submitting the actual school documents and documents prepared for the placement task that provide competency-based evidence of your leadership and leadership development and the explanatory commentary, if you wish to include this, you must not exceed 12 pages of A4 in font size 12 and these must be capable of being read and understood within 30 minutes reading time. Actual school documents and documents prepared for the placement task could include, for example: Objectives and plan for the Placement task, agreed with the placement headteacher Extract from action plan or equivalent produced for the priority Outline of staff development led by you Extract from policy document(s) produced under your leadership Extract from reports to SLT and/or governing body or equivalent Quantified analysis of outcomes /positive impact prepared for use in placement school. Account of on-going relationship with the placement school and own leadership development taken from reports to own school/setting SLT and/or governing body or equivalent The Placement Headteacher’s submission to the Assessment Panel will be an evaluation of your leadership of the school improvement priority and leadership development and this will be based upon their observation of your leadership of the priority, their observation of your leadership development from the on-going relationship with the school and their reading of your submission for the Assessment Panel. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 15 A form (to be presented in landscape for ease of completion) with accompanying guidance will be provided to make this process as straightforward as possible for the Placement Headteacher. Placement Headteachers will be asked to verify the evidence you submit and give their own assessment of your leadership of the school improvement priority and the outcomes for the school, including arrangements and accountabilities created for sustainable improvement, and of your leadership development. Placement Headteachers will be provided with descriptions of the competencies being tested and the guidance you have been given on undertaking the task. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 16 Figure 6: NPQH Task 2 Leading school improvement working in partnership with the Placement School Placement Headteacher’s submission to the Assessment Panel Name of trainee headteacher………………………………………………………. As Placement Headteacher, you are asked to verify the evidence provided by the trainee headteacher and to give your own assessment of their leadership of the school improvement priority and leadership development while on placement. Please read the descriptions of the competencies supplied as well as the statements set out below and comment on key aspects of their development in the three specific leadership competencies and on their leadership development overall. Please also provide quantified evidence of the outcomes and the positive impact of their leadership in the school, where possible (column 2). Then award the most appropriate grade (column 3) from the scale set out below to reflect the extent to which they have used the opportunity of leading the school improvement priority and developing an ongoing relationship with your school to gain a broader understanding of school leadership and the degree of progress they have made in improving their leadership and developing the specific leadership competencies tested: Very good: trainee headteacher made full use of the opportunities for development and made outstanding progress in leadership development Good: trainee headteacher made use of many opportunities for development and made significant progress in leadership development Moderate: trainee headteacher made some use of the opportunities for development and made some progress in leadership development Poor: trainee headteacher made limited use of the opportunities for development and limited progress Leadership competency Verification and additional Grade evidence Awarded: Very good, good, moderate, poor Delivering continuous improvement including involving and inspiring governors and stakeholders to support the school vision for the school improvement priority and in strategically planning for its delivery, determining and evaluating innovative strategies for action to improve teaching and learning and/or the curriculum in the context of the school’s performance using relevant data and information (including research, learning from essential and elective modules and expertise in key national policy areas), setting suitably ambitious targets and success criteria, and working with leaders, staff, governors (or equivalent) and other stakeholders on delivery Partnership and collaboration including building positive relationships with a wide range of people, being aware of different agendas and perspectives and taking these into account in building consensus , creating opportunities for informing and working collaboratively with a wide range of stakeholders including parents/carers and the wider community, using mechanisms such as networking and creating structures and processes for cooperation, collaboration and sharing expertise between institutions so that priorities for partnership working are identified and the stakeholders of all institutions benefit © 2012 National College for School Leadership 17 Impact and influence including having good negotiation and communication skills, making a positive impact through the ability to unite others around the school’s vision and through presenting information and proposals in a way that increases understanding, holds attention and inspires and engages others , listening to others views and being able to tailor their communication to suit the audience, when agreement needs to be reached able to influence others directly or through third parties, so that they are sure of sufficient support before difficult decisions have to be taken and presenting their arguments and proposals clearly and logically so that others are persuaded of their efficacy and agreement can be reached on a way forward during negotiations Understanding of leadership in the placement school including the development of an on-going relationship with the placement school and an understanding of its context Using the placement to evaluate and develop their leadership, including how they sought and responded to feedback and improved their leadership, and the impact of changes made in the placement setting Placement Headteacher’s signature……………………………… Date………………………….. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 18 Task 3 Practical knowledge and expertise demonstrated in test environments This task comprises two elements in test environments: o Firstly, you will undertake a case study assessment that will enable you to use your practical experience of school leadership, learning from the essential and elective modules and knowledge and expertise in key national policy areas. The case studies will cover: Leading school financial management Leading teacher appraisal You will need to demonstrate you are able to manage these key aspects of a school that you may not have been able to take full leadership of while on NPQH and show you are able to make appropriate decisions and justify your actions. o Secondly, you will attend a presentation/interview. You will make a presentation to a panel and answer questions put by the panel both on the content of your presentation and your progress towards successful headship through NPQH. You will need to be able to show you have developed the competence to present in a credible way as a headteacher. You should also be prepared to demonstrate how you have used your NPQH experiences to reflect upon and improved your own leadership competencies to a level that shows your readiness to take up your first headship. The case study element of task 3 will test two leadership competencies: Figure 7: competencies tested in case study element of Task 3 Operational Management Operational Management Efficient and effective Holding others to account The descriptions of the two leadership competencies tested in the case study element of the Task can be found in Appendix 1. Key elements of the task: The task will be timed and will be taken in a controlled setting The task will comprise two case study tests which will require you to consider a situation, make decisions about what to do and justify your actions. One test will focus on the leading school financial management aspects of the leadership competency Efficient and effective and the other the leading teacher appraisal aspects of the leadership competencies Efficient and effective and Holding others to account In your responses you will need to provide evidence of the aspects of the Operational management competences tested in this task (leading © 2012 National College for School Leadership 19 school financial management and teacher appraisal - see below for specific guidance) You will need to use: o research and school evidence o learning from the essential and elective modules o knowledge and expertise in key national policy priorities to inform you leadership decision making. Specific guidance on providing competency-based evidence in case study element of Task 3 The case study will to require you to demonstrate a full understanding of how to lead school financial management, including how to use financial resources efficiently and effectively to achieve the school’s goals and in a way that maximises performance and secures value for money; how undertake both strategic financial planning and operational budget management and to set school capital and revenue budgets with the governing body, or equivalent; how to seek sources of finance to widen the resource base of the school; how to make sound judgements about financial systems and to review and improve these as required, including employing robust audit processes to ensure outcomes are achieved and devolving budgetary responsibilities wisely and with appropriate safeguards; how to regularly monitor spending against both the budget and appropriate benchmarks, manage within the parameter of the budget and take corrective action when required; and how to report and be accountable to the governing body, or equivalent, on school finance. The case study will to require you to demonstrate a full understanding of how to lead teacher appraisal, including how to secure effective teacher performance through a consistent and efficient staff performance management system (teacher appraisal) that complies with legislative and other national or legal requirements; how to distribute leadership for performance management to the most appropriate level; how to create levels of accountability within the school and clearly communicate expectations and standards required; how to use performance management to achieve school priorities and monitor staff performance against objectives and targets; how to support staff development to help ensure objectives and targets are met; how to give constructive and specific feedback on performance; how to monitor progress against objectives and targets, recognise and praise success and quickly tackle staff underperformance and address capability and misconduct; how to regularly monitor the operation of and make sound judgements about HR systems and to review and improve these as required; and how to report and be accountable to the governing body, or equivalent, on teacher appraisal. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 20 Proceeding to the presentation/interview element of Task 3 In order to proceed to the presentation/interview element of Task 3 you will need to have reached the required standard in Tasks 1, Task 2 and Task 3 (case study). If in one or more of these Tasks you do not reach the required standard you will be notified and given an opportunity to take the Task again within a defined time period. The presentation/interview element of Task 3 will test nine leadership competencies Figure 8: Competencies tested in presentation/interview element of Task 3 Strategic leadership Personal drive and accountability Strategic leadership Resilience and emotional maturity Strategic leadership Impact and Influence Educational excellence Delivering continuous improvement Educational excellence Modelling excellence in teaching Educational excellence Learning focus Educational excellence Partnership and collaboration Operational management Efficient and Effective Operational management Holding others to account The descriptions of the nine leadership competencies tested in the presentation/interview element of the Task can be found in Appendix 1. Key elements of the task The presentation/interview will last an hour, before a panel (with at least one serving head) The process will begin with you delivering a fifteen minute oral presentation on becoming a successful headteacher. You can choose how to make your presentation and how you use the time available but you should cover: o the progress you have made towards becoming a successful headteacher while on NPQH, with particular reference to the nine leadership competencies tested in the final assessment process, with examples of how you used the competencies when in leading in schools o the key development experiences for you (for example, your practical experience in school, the placement, learning from the essential and elective modules) © 2012 National College for School Leadership 21 o your personal impact (quantified where possible) and the positive difference your leadership has had in the schools you have worked with, using specific competency-related examples. You may use PowerPoint or other presentation suites that you would use in a school setting (the number of slides etc. must be compatible with a 15 minute presentation to a panel) and/or a handout (the length and format of this must be compatible with a 15 minute presentation to a panel). The panel will time the presentation and you will be asked to stop after fifteen minutes if you have not finished. You will be responsible for ensuring any specialist equipment is available and ready to use. A full copy of your presentation will need to be provided in advance to both your sponsor for verification and to the Final Assessment Panel. The manner in which you present as well as the content of your presentation will be assessed by the panel having regard to the leadership competence Impact and influence. Following your presentation there will be fifteen minutes of questioning on your presentation by members of the panel. The panel will time the questioning and you will be asked to stop after fifteen minutes if you have not finished. The manner in which you respond to questioning as well as the content of your responses will be assessed by the panel having regard to the leadership competence Impact and influence. In the remainder of the interview the panel will be able to question you on any of the nine leadership competencies being tested in the final assessment, but should there be any of the competencies where you have not reached the highest possible standard in Tasks 1, 2 or 3 (case study element) they will include questions on these to give you the opportunity to demonstrate you have reached the required standard by provide stronger evidence of your leadership experience and practice. In deciding what competencies to test the panel will be informed by the assessments of Tasks 1, 2 and 3 (case study element), the final assessment from your sponsor on your progress towards successful headship and the evidence of the progress you have made since the Gateway assessments. With regard to the results of the tasks, you will be advised following each task of any competencies where you have not reached the highest possible standard and will therefore be able to take account of this in your further development and in preparing for the presentation/interview. Sponsor’s final assessment of the trainee headteacher’s progress towards successful headship Sponsors will be asked to assess your progress towards successful headship based upon their observation of your leadership and to verify your presentation for the Assessment Panel. A form with accompanying guidance will be provided to make this process as straightforward as possible for the sponsor. Sponsors will be asked to verify the evidence you submit as part of your presentation and give their own assessment of © 2012 National College for School Leadership 22 your leadership development and provide quantified evidence (where possible) of your personal impact including the positive difference your leadership has had in the school and on meeting its goals. Sponsors will be provided with descriptions of the leadership competencies being tested and the guidance you have been given on undertaking the Final Assessment tasks. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 23 Figure 9: NPQH Task 3 Presentation/Interview Sponsor’s Statement of trainee headteacher’s progress towards successful headship Name of trainee headteacher…………………………………………. Leadership competencies: Presentation Sponsor: please verify the trainee headteacher’s presentation on their progress towards successful headship. Please evaluate the trainee headteacher’s progress towards successful headship in relation to the specific leadership competencies based upon your observation of their leadership and provide quantified evidence (where possible) of their personal impact, including the positive difference their leadership has had in the school and on meeting its goals. Verification: Personal drive and accountability Resilience and emotional maturity Impact and Influence Delivering continuous improvement Modelling excellence in teaching Learning focus Partnership and collaboration Efficient and Effective Holding others to account Sponsor’s signature…………………………… Date …………………………… © 2012 National College for School Leadership 24 Appendix 1 NPQH Competency Framework Strategic Leadership Self awareness and self management Someone who is ready for headship is aware of their personal strengths, weaknesses and areas for future development and understands how their own leadership behaviour impacts on others and manages this effectively. They have knowledge of their own emotional triggers, ways to manage them effectively and behave consistently in line with professional and personal values and vision. Why it matters Headteachers need to understand their own strengths, weaknesses and areas for development and how their leadership behaviours impact on others so that they can maximise their impact as a leader. Personal drive and accountability Someone who is ready for headship is driven and focused on improvement. They are results orientated and seek to achieve the highest standards within their role through setting and striving to achieve their goals. They are self motivated, energetic and willing to take on new challenges to improve their performance. They are decisive, work for the best interests of pupils and account for their performance to the governing body and other stakeholders. Why it matters Headteachers need to be motivated to reach the highest possible professional standards, to deliver tough objectives and take on challenges in order to achieve and be accountable for high performance throughout the school. Resilience and emotional maturity Someone who is ready for headship is resilient, focused and tenacious when faced with the demands of the job and continually challenging circumstances. They are able to respond positively when managing uncertainty and adversity. They remain focussed on personal and organisational values, and adhere to these, even in difficult, long-term situations. Why it matters Headteachers work in a challenging, highly autonomous and pressurised environment. They will be faced with adversity and will have to manage and recover from setbacks. They also need to be honest and transparent in their interactions and communications with all key stakeholders to reflect a high trust culture. Conceptual thinking Someone who is ready for headship is able to identify patterns between potentially unrelated concepts and draw on past experience to make sense of underlying issues and understand a situation. They take a broader view and utilise additional information to create new ways of and approaches to doing things, and to come up with highly innovative ways of solving problems. They are able to simplify complex issues for others. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 25 Why it matters Headteachers are required to use their previous work and life experiences to make sense of the issues they face as the leader of the school. They will need to identify creative strategic solutions to educational and organisational challenges and to explain these to others. Future focus Someone who is ready for headship continually looks ahead and identifies/ capitalises on opportunities that are likely to arise, as well as managing day to day challenges, and takes action to resolve these. They embrace the opportunities for change and are well able to engage others, including the governing body, to successfully bring change about and to evaluate its impact. Why it matters It is important that Headteachers recognise the positive opportunities for change. In their leadership they must also be able to address both immediate issues quickly and take action over the long term to ensure that changes needed to improve the school are embraced and implemented with minimum disruption. Impact and Influence Someone who is ready for headship has a positive impact on pupils, colleagues and the wider community through inspiration and persuasion to their perspective. They know when they need to negotiate to a solution. They communicate effectively, understand others’ perspectives and priorities and tailor their communication to suit their audience. They lead others and bring their governing body and communities on board by articulating a compelling vision and uniting them around shared goals and objectives. Why it matters Headteachers must be able to inspire and influence pupils, colleagues, governors and the community in an appropriate and considered manner, articulating a compelling vision in order to create an energising learning environment for all. To do this they must understand the needs and motivations of others, adapting their leadership approach to create the desired impact and outcomes. Educational Excellence Delivering continuous improvement Someone who is ready for headship will have a clear vision of the central importance of leading teaching and learning in terms of driving and sustaining school improvement and creating improved life chances for pupils, their families and their community. They use their skills to quickly gain a full understanding of the overall performance of the school and make a judgment about what requires improvement. They work with the governing body and other stakeholders to successfully identify, strategically plan for and lead delivery of the necessary and appropriate improvement strategies. Why it matters Headteachers need to be able to develop vision and to identify the priorities which lead to improvements in teaching and learning and to implement these to achieve a high quality education to improve outcomes for all pupils. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 26 Modelling excellence in teaching Someone who is ready for headship will have a deep understanding of the characteristics of excellent/outstanding teaching, informed by current research and be able to articulate this effectively to others. They will have a systematic approach to monitoring, make sound judgements about the quality of the teaching and learning across the school, and develop and deliver a wide range of improvement strategies. Why it matters Headteachers need to be able to recognise excellence in teaching and be able to demonstrate how teaching can be improved and improvement sustained so that the learning and achievement of all pupils is maximised. Learning focus Someone who is ready for headship will be passionate about learning and will embed a culture of learning for all members of the school community and foster equality of access. They have an unswerving belief that schools have a crucial role to play in changing lives and improving life chances and will monitor learning systematically to ensure progress. Why it matters Headteachers must have the desire and passion to want to help others to improve themselves and those around them. They must be committed to improving the life chances of all pupils and work with others to ensure that every pupil has the opportunity to succeed. Partnership and collaboration Someone who is ready for headship is able to work collaboratively with a range of people in schools, governing bodies and the wider community, to build a culture of cooperation and raise achievement through partnership working. They are open to different perspectives and viewpoints as well as being able to achieve agreement on common goals and objectives and the contribution to be made across the education system. Why it matters Headteachers need to build partnerships, collaborate with others and share expertise in a powerful and effective way to achieve common goals and objectives and improve outcomes for all pupils and the education system. Organisational and community understanding Someone who is ready for headship has a good understanding of the power relationships in their own organisation, including the governing body, other organisations and the wider community with which they work. They are able to identify and engage with the major influencers and decision makers within the community. They can predict how new events or situations will affect individuals or groups within the community. Why it matters Headteachers must work with people within and beyond their own school to improve outcomes for all pupils and the education system. It is critical therefore that they know who the key players are and understand both spoken and unspoken factors that impact on decisions and actions. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 27 Operational Management Efficient and effective Someone who is ready for headship will ensure that all systems and resources, including financial, human and environmental resources, are used efficiently and effectively to achieve the school’s goals and in a way that maximises performance and secures value for money. They are attuned to opportunities that increase the resources available to the school and improve the way the school functions. They monitor the implementation of plans and the effectiveness of organisational structures. They take corrective action where necessary to secure required outcomes and account to the governing body and others for the school’s performance. They have a broad understanding of the legal, political and technical knowledge that affect the running of a school and keep up to date with major changes. Why it matters Headteachers need to ensure that the school’s goals are achieved through deploying resources in the best way and within the planned timeline. They also need to ensure that the school is a ‘fit for purpose’ organisation with the best systems and processes to achieve the school’s goals and that these are kept under review and up-to-date. Headteachers have to take responsibility for the performance of the school and be able to account for this to the governing body and others. Analytical thinking Someone who is ready for headship collects information and data systematically from a wide variety of sources. They confidently analyse complex information and data and understand the connections between issues through breaking down opportunities and challenges into their constituent parts. They are able to break down a problem in a systematic way and establish causal relationships between issues that may or may not be obviously related, to better enable a solution to be found. Their analytical skills enable them to prioritise issues and to plan how to implement the actions necessary to achieve change and improvement. Why it matters It is important that Headteachers can break down opportunities and challenges and link the related issues using a broad range of information. This helps them to understand the implications of situations, employ sound judgement in their decision making and identify the best ways to proceed in managing the organisation. Relationship management Someone who is ready for headship is able to develop and sustain appropriate internal and external relationships, manage individuals and lead effective teams. They know about the impact of behaviour and emotions of relationships, use this knowledge to understand why others behave the way they do and take this into account when communicating and working with others. Why it matters The school is best managed and its goals and objectives achieved by involving relevant stakeholders and the effective leadership of individuals and teams: therefore it is critical to develop effective relationships in order to gain a deep understanding of others’ motivations and perspectives. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 28 Holding others to account Someone who is ready for headship holds others to account by clearly communicating expectations, and gives constructive and specific feedback. They ensure goals or objectives are achieved by getting others to do what is asked of them even if it involves tough or unpopular decisions. These choices or actions will always be instigated with the best interests of pupils/students and the school in mind. Why it matters Headteachers need to ensure educational standards are raised. They will have to make interventions where required in managing the organisation. This is critical in order that schools and the education sector deliver what is expected in sustained school improvement. Developing others Someone who is ready for headship develops others so that they develop leadership potential where possible. They ensure succession planning is in place and learning and development needs are addressed. This involves continually seeking out opportunities to support and develop colleagues so they perform at their best. Why it matters Headteachers need to demonstrate a genuine commitment to developing others. They need to support and empower others to reach their full potential and to create an environment where others are more confident and better motivated to achieve results and the school’s goals and to work efficiently and effectively. © 2012 National College for School Leadership 29