Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 1.0 INTRODUCTION Architectural acoustics is the science of controlling sound within buildings. The acoustical environment in and around buildings is influenced by numerous interrelated and independent factors associated with the building planning design construction process. The architect, the engineer, the building technologist, and the constructor all play a part in the control of acoustical problem. A particular advantage of sound intensity measurement to manufacturers is that production test bays may serve to double as sound power check facilities. Other application of sound intensity measurement which are at present less well developed than sound power determination are the in-situ evaluation of acoustic impedance and sound absorption properties of materials; the detection and evaluation flanking transmission in buildings; and the in-situ determination, under operational conditions, of the sound power generated by fans together with the performance associated with in-duct attenuators. The advent practical sound intensity measurement may be seen as one of the most developments in acoustic technology since the introduction of digital signal processing systems. It is of great value to equipment designer, manufacturer, supplier and user, and, in particular, to the specialist acoustical engineer concerned with the control and reduction of noise. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 1 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 2.0 SOUND INTENSITY The sound intensity, I, (acoustic intensity) is defined as the sound power Pac per unit area A. The usual context is the noise measurement of sound intensity in the air at a listener's location. For instantaneous acoustic pressure pinst(t) and particle velocity v(t) the average acoustic intensity during time T is given by Both v(t) and I are vectors, which means that both have a direction as well as a magnitude. The direction of the intensity is the average direction in which the energy is flowing. The SI units of intensity are W/m2 (watts per square metre). FIG 1: Decrease in sound intensity for an omnidirectional point source. For a spherical sound source, the intensity in the radial direction as a function of distance r from the centre of the source is: OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 2 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics Here Pac (upper case) is the sound power and A the surface area of a sphere of radius r. Thus the sound intensity decreases with 1/r2 the distance from an acoustic point source, while the sound pressure decreases only with 1/r from the distance from an acoustic point source after the 1/r-distance law. Where p (lower case) is the RMS sound pressure (acoustic pressure). Hence The sound intensity I in W/m2 of a plane progressive wave is: Where: Sound intensity level, LI, is the magnitude of sound intensity, expressed in logarithmic units (decibels). (dB-SIL), where Io is the reference intensity, 10-12 W/m2 OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 3 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics The term "intensity" is used exclusively for the measurement of sound in watts per unit area. To describe the strength of sound in terms, other than strict intensity, one can use "magnitude" "strength", "amplitude", or "level" instead. Sound intensity is not the same physical quantity as sound pressure. Hearing is directly sensitive to sound pressure which is related to sound intensity. In stereo the level differences have been called "intensity" differences, but sound intensity is a specifically defined quantity and cannot be sensed by a simple microphone, nor would it be valuable in music recording if it could. {wikipedia} FIG 2: Chart showing different intensities OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 4 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 2.1 USES OF SOUND INTENSITY IN ARCHITECTURAL ACOUSTICS {J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Volume 84, Issue S1, pp. S32-S33 (November 1988) Issue Date: November 1988} Sound intensity has received significant attention over the past five years in the fields of noise control and product noise analysis. Yet, at this date, it is an infrequently used technique in consulting acoustics in general. Standards have been slow in developing and thus have not increased its use, and the most fundamental reason for its use is still the utility of its results rather than any existing standard. The benefit of intensity measurement in architecture is principally in its ability to indicate source direction, and this benefit is particularly important in a number of fields now being studied. The first of these is the open plan office, and the current work in intensity is based on an interest in the performance of acoustical dividers and absorbers. The second field, for which intensity seems to be the only measurement technique that is easily used, is the analysis of compound element building facades. This analysis is aimed at developing field transmission loss values for facade elements, such as windows, doors, and wall section. 2.2 MEASUREMENT OF SOUND INTENSITY The measurements of sound intensity are carried out over a close, imaginary box (of any shape, e. g. a cuboid or rectangular parallelepiped, as in the diagram on the next page) surrounding a piece of equipment operating in situ. Based on these measurements, the sound power level of the piece of equipment is determined by the sophisticated analyser. It is carried out using sound intensity measurements with Brüel & Kjær (B&K) Modular Precision RealTime Sound Analyzers type 2260 with Sound Intensity Probe type 3595 (state- OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 5 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics of-the-art hand-held sound intensity system). Using this system, the sound power level may be determined according to ISO 9614-2 or ANSI S12.12. Fig3: Equipment used for sound intensity measurement 2.2.1 APPLICATION OF SOUND INTENSITY MEASUREMENT The application of sound intensity measurement may be broadly classified as follows: 1. Determination of the sound power sources. 2. Measurement of sound energy transmission through partitions {transmission loss} 3. Measurement of the sound absorption properties of materials and structures. 4. Identification and rank ordering of source regions {source location and identification} 5. Measurement of sound energy flow in fluid transport ducts. A factor which is common to all these applications is the determination of the sound power passing through some selected surface within a fluid. Even in the process of source location, it is essentially the sound power OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 6 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics of source regions, and not the sound intensity {sound power flux density} which is of significance. For example, a small leak in a partition may produce local intensities far in excess of the average over the remainder of the partition surface, but the area of leak may be so small as to render negligible its contribution to the total transmitted power. An implication of considerable practical importance is that, in cases where the normal sound intensity on a surface varies widely with position, errors incurred in estimating local intensity must be considered in relation to the associated area-weighted surface. It is therefore just as important to minimize errors in the measurement of low intensities distributed over relatively small areas. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 7 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 3.0 SOUND POWER Sound power or acoustic power Pac is a measure of sonic energy E per time t unit. The symbol for sound power is W and its unit is the watt. (Named after the Scottish mechanical engineer James Watt, 1736-1819, of steam engine fame.) A source that emits power equally in all directions is called an omnidirectional source. Any other source is called a directional source. For an omnidirectional point source, the sound wave spreads out from the source in all directions. The sound power, W, of the source is hence spread over the surface of a sphere. SoS=4 r2 And It is measured in watts, or sound intensity I times area A: The measure of a ratio of two sound powers is where P1, P0 are the sound powers. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 8 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 3.1 THE SOUND POWER LEVEL Sound power level or acoustic power level is a logarithmic measure of the sound power in comparison to a specified reference level. The sound power level of a signal with sound power W is [1] [2] Where W0 is the 0 dB SWL reference level: The sound power level is given the symbol LW or SWL. This is not to be confused with dBW, which uses 1W as a reference level. In the case of a free field sound source in air at ambient temperature, the sound power level is approximately related to sound pressure level (SPL) at distance r of the source by the equation Where S0 = 1m2. This is only valid assuming the acoustic impedance of the medium equals 400 Pa*s/m. The sound power level PWL, LW, or LPac of a source is expressed in decibels (dB) and is equal to 10 times the logarithm to the base 10 of the ratio of the sound power of the source to a reference sound power. It is thus a logarithmic OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 9 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics measure. The reference sound power in air is normally taken to be 10−12 watt = 0 dB SWL. Sound power is neither room dependent nor distance dependent. Sound power belongs strictly to the sound source. Table 1: Sound power and sound power level of some sound sources Situation sound power sound power and Pac level Lw sound source watts dB re 10−12 W Rocket engine 1,000,000 W 180 dB 10,000 W 160 dB 1,000 W 150 dB 100 W 140 dB Machine gun 10 W 130 dB Jackhammer 1W 120 dB Excavator, trumpet 0.3 W 115 dB Chain saw 0.1 W 110 dB Helicopter 0.01 W 100 dB 0.001 W 90 dB 10−5 W 70 dB Refrigerator 10−7 W 50 dB (Auditory threshold at 2.8 m) 10-10 W 20 dB (Auditory threshold at 28 cm) 10-12 W 0 dB Turbojet engine Siren Heavy truck engine or loudspeaker rock concert Loud speech, vivid children Usual talking, Typewriter OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 10 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics Usable music sound (trumpet) and noise sound (excavator) both have the same sound power of 0.3 watts, but will be judged psycho acoustically to be different levels. 3.2 SOUND POWER WITH PLAIN SOUND WAVES Between sound power and other important acoustic values there is the following relationship: Where: Table 2: List of some symbols, units and their meanings Symbol Units Meaning p Pa sound pressure f Hz frequency Ξ m particle displacement c m/s speed of sound v m/s particle velocity ω = 2πf rad/s angular frequency ρ kg/m3 density of air Z=c·ρ N·s/m³ acoustic impedance a m/s² particle acceleration I W/m² sound intensity E W·s/m³ sound energy density OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 11 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 3.3 SOUND POWER MEASUREMENT Noise emission values are increasingly becoming the subject of regulations for a safer and healthier working place and for the protection of the environment. Moreover, awareness among consumers regarding noise issues has substantially increased and voluntary awards for companies who meet acoustical criteria are becoming a product differentiator. In cases where the noise emissions of products have been significantly reduced (e.g., within the information technology industry) customer acceptability of the product is mostly related to absence/minimal presence of tonal components. Two quantities which complement each other can be used to describe noise emissions. One is the sound power which has become the preferred quantity as it is independent of the particular circumstances of the measuring environment. The other is the emission sound pressure at specified positions in the vicinity of the machinery (e.g., operator's position). Measuring Sound Power Sound Power can be determined according to three main methods: 1. Measure the sound pressure due to the source in a free (or essentially free) sound field, and then determine its sound power from the sound pressure measurements. 2. As 1, but in a diffuse sound field. 3. Direct measurements of sound intensity in any sound field to determine the sound power of the source. The pressure-based methods are most often used for production audits and high-volume testing (with specific standards for information technology equipment), while the intensity-based methods are generally used for engineering and in-situ measurements. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 12 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 3.3.1 PULSE SOUND POWER TYPE 7799 It is a software application for determining noise emission quantities of machinery, equipment and their sub-assemblies. It includes the determination of sound power levels as described in international standards, as well as the measurement of emission sound pressure levels at specified positions in the vicinity of a machine. Moreover, to evaluate the annoyance of tonal components in noise emissions, the calculation of two complementary parameters, Tone-to-Noise Ratio and Prominence Ratio, is seamlessly integrated in the solution. Uses To determine whether a product complies with noise specifications (legislation, voluntary awards) To compare the noise emissions of machinery and equipment of the same and different types (for example, when benchmarking, or in engineering work, when developing quieter products) To analyze product sound in terms of identification and evaluation of prominent discrete tones and impulsive noise 3.4 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SOUND INTENSITY AND SOUND POWER As most measurements of sound are in terms of sound power (p), it is useful to know the relationship between sound intensity and sound Power: Where: I = P2 C I is the sound intensity in watts/m2 p is the sound pressure in Pa OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 13 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics Is the density of medium in kg/m3 C is the speed of sound in m/s For air at 21°C , = 1.2 kg/m3 and following the equation above: c = 344 m/s Therefore, I = = 0.0024 p2 Strictly speaking, this equation is for plane waves (i.e. waves propagating with parallel wave fronts). However, away from a point source, the spherical waves approximate plane waves. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 14 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics 4.0 CONCLUSION The rapid acceleration of our technological age has given us the ability to make increasingly detailed analyses of our architectural acoustic environment. In turn it is providing the tools for modelling building designs in order to predict the greater accuracy than in the recent past their acoustic performance in advance of any construction. There is this prospect that these tools will continue to be improved and, thereby, permit better and more economic processes for use in architectural acoustics design. The architectural profession should keep abreast of this increasing ability of the architectural acoustics profession to provide significant service in the process of building design and it to contribute to an excellent creative effort. OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 15 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200 Sound intensity and sound power in architectural acoustics REFERENCES Acoustical Society of America Digital Library. Bruel & Kjaer (2008) Sound Power Egan .D. (1998}. Architectural Acoustics. New York: (MC Graw-Hill). F.J. Fahy sound intensity Georgia State University. Physics Department- Tutorial on Sound intensity. Metha, M. , Et al. (1999) Architectural Acoustics: Principle and Design. Upple saddle River, MJ: Prentice Hall. Ogunsote, O.O. Lecture note on Acoustic and Noise Control. {Department of architecture, Federal University of Technology Akure, Ondo State} Stein, B & Reynolds, J. (2000). Mechanical & Electrical Equipment for buildings, 9th edition. New York: John Willey & Sons. Williams, J. Cavanaugh Joseph, A. Wilkes Principles and practice of architectural acoustic www.engineeringtoolbox.com OLOYEDE O.K ARC-04-3216 16 KOLAWOLE M.D ARC-04-3200