UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS BOSTON GREEN CHEMISTRY NEWSLETTER Issue 3 June 2015 The Green Chemistry Track in the Chemistry Ph.D. Program at UMass Boston was established in 2002. It is the first such program in the world. Students obtaining a degree from this program will be prepared for conventional chemistry jobs in industry, government and academia. Green chemistry involves an ecologically sustainable view of chemical research, development, and manufacture. Toxicological understanding and environmental fate are necessary components to understanding the entire "molecular life cycle" of any commercial endeavor. The unique complement of the chemistry and biology department as well as the school for the environment faculty has allowed the University of Massachusetts Boston to create such a program. http://www.umb.edu/greenchemistry News UMass Boston’s ACS Student Chapter has earned the Green Chemistry Chapter Award for the second year in a row. Jonathan Rochford has been invited to present at “CO2 reduction and utilization symposium” 250th ACS National Meeting, Boston, MA, August 16th – 20th, 2015. “ Dr. Berkeley Cue and Prof. Wei Zhang are serving on the international advisory board of 2015 Drug Discovery & Therapy World Congress in Boston. Jonathan Rochford gave talk on “Metal ligand cooperativity in solar energy conversion and catalytic CO2 reduction” at Bridgewater State University, MA, Feb. 20th 2015 PhD student Shuai Liu received the travel scholarship to attend 2015 Green Chemistry Symposium organized by Green Chemistry Initiative at the University of Toronto in May Graduate students, Meaghan McKinnon and Sabrina Akhter was accepted to and will attend the ACS Summer School on Green Chemistry & Sustainable Energy at the Colorado School of Mines in Golden, Colorado in July. Dr. Berkeley W. Cue will give the opening keynote talk at the 19th Green Chemistry and Engineering Conference in North Bethesda, MD on July 15th titled, "The ACS Green Chemistry Institute Pharmaceutical Roundtable: A perspective from one of its founders." Check out this video! UMass Boston will host the 3rd Workshop of the Global Green Chemistry Centres (G2C2) on Aug. 20-21, 2015. This event is coorganized by the University of York, ACS Green Chemistry Institute, and UMass Boston Recent Publications As part of a series of Earth Day events in April organized by the Office for Sustainability at Harvard University, Prof. Zhang was invited to give a talk on green chemistry at the Chemistry and Chemical Biology Department at Harvard (Apr. 2015). Pham, K.; Huang, X.; Zhang, W. “One-Pot Fluorination and Mannich Reactions of 1,3-Dicarbonyl Compounds” Tetrahedron Lett. 2015, 56, 1998-2000. Undergraduate students Anthony P. Tran and Jeremy H. Hyatt (Prof. Zhang’s lab) presented two posters on recyclable organocatalysts for asymmetric synthesis at the 21st Annual Massachusetts Statewide Undergraduate Research Conference at UMass Amherst (Apr. 2015). Qian, J.; Yi, W.; Huang, X.; Miao, Y.; Zhang, J.; Cai, C.; Zhang, W. “One-Pot Synthesis of 3,5-Disubstituted and Polysubstituted Phenols from Acyclic Precursors” Org. Lett. 2015, 17, 1090-1093. Graduate students Xin Huang and Shuai Liu (Prof. Zhang’s lab) presented two posters on green organocatalysis and medicinal chemistry at 2015 Northeastern Student Chemistry Research Conference and Career Symposium at Tufts University (Apr. 2015). Ngo, K.T.; Rochford, J.*; Hao, F.; Batarseh, A.; Chitre, K.; Rangan, S.; Bartynski, R.A.; Galoppini, E.* “Photoelectrochemical Properties of Porphyrin Dyes with a Molecular Dipole in the Linker” Faraday Discuss. 2015, accepted. Javier Reinoso of Hannah Sevian’s group presented a poster on the use of green indicators for undergraduate chemistry laboratories. This work was presented at SACNAS regional meeting at Boston College " Lee, N.A.; Frenzel, B.A.; Rochford, J.*; “Dye-sensitized solar cell performance of a cobalt(III/II) redox mediator with the 2,6-bis(8-quinolinyl)pyridine ligand” Hightower S.E.* Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. 2015, accepted. Felix Nampanya of Hannah Sevian’s group presented a poster on a design of greener kinetics reaction for undergraduate chemistry laboratories. This work was presented at NSCRC at Tufts University in April. ” Zhou, Y.; Lee, N.A.; Ngo, K.T.; Peng, X.; Feng, Y.*; Rochford, J.* “Rigid triarylamine donor–π–acceptor porphyrin dyes and their application in dye-sensitized solar cells” RSC Advances 2015, 5, 41193-41202. UMB GreenChemistry 1 Green Chemistry Symposium at the 250th ACS Conference UMass Boston graduate students Ray Borg and Maria Kipreos have collaborated with Wasiu Lawal from the National Presence Younger Chemists Committee to organize a green chemistry symposium for the 250th ACS conference to be held in Boston, MA this August. The symposium titled Careers for Young Professionals in Green Chemistry: Breaking Bad Chemistry Habits, is designed to attract and introduce young chemists to the field of green chemistry. The program will present younger chemists with various career paths in academia, industry, government, and business that utilize green chemistry principles. The symposium also aims to help attendees break bad chemistry habits by introducing them to online tools, resources, and opportunities to get active within the GC community. The following speakers will be presenting at the symposium: Dr. Martin J. Mulvihill, Executive Director, Berkeley Center for Green Chemistry Dr. David J. Constable, Director, ACS Green Chemistry Institute Dr. Sherine O. Obare, Professor, Western Michigan University Dr. Emily A Peterson, Senior Scientist, Amgen Dr. John C. Warner, President and CEO, Warner Babcock Institute Dr. Nicholas D. Anastas, Green Chemist, US EPA Ms. Savannah Sullivan, Strategy Development Officer, NESSE The Symposium will be held in the Boston Convention & Exhibition Center (room number TBD) on Monday, August 17th from 8:30 am to noon. For more information please email Ray Borg at: Raymond.borg001@umb.edu Become a Green Chemist Undergraduate Opportunity Are you an undergraduate student of chemistry or biochemistry who is looking to get more involved on campus and network with colleagues and faculty? Enrich your academic career by becoming a member of UMass Boston American Chemical Society Student Chapter. For more information visit: http://www.umb.edu/academics/csm/chemistry/beyo nd_the_classroom/acs Graduate Opportunity If you are interested in an innovative and exciting career in science, then the Green Chemistry Track in the Chemistry PhD program is a perfect opportunity for you. As the world moves to focus on sustainability in both an environmental and lab setting more job opportunities arise within industry, government and academia. For more information visit: http://www.umb.edu/academics/csm/chemistry UMB GreenChemistry 2 People in Green Chemistry Emily Peterson Q: Can you tell us a little bit of your background and training that has brought you to the position you now hold? A: I completed my Ph.D. at the University of California, Irvine under the direction of Prof. Larry E. Overman where I completed the total synthesis of alkaloid natural products. I then went on to do postdoctoral studies with Prof. Eric N. Jacobsen at Harvard where I studied the enantioselective intermolecular addition of indoles to N-acyliminium ions. In 2007, I started working at Amgen doing Medicinal Chemistry. In addition to my work doing Medicinal Chemistry, I was asked to build a Green Chemistry team at the Amgen Massachusetts site in 2009. Q: Could you give a brief synopsis of your current work and its direction? A: My current work is focused on the discovery of new drugs to treat grievous illness. I am currently working on projects in both the neuroscience and cardiovascular areas. Q: What inspired you to become a chemist? In particular, what directed you towards developing green methods for your area of research? A: I actually started out as an Environmental Studies major in my undergraduate at Western Washington University. I ended up taking organic chemistry for “chemistry majors” because I thought it would improve my marketability as an environmental scientist. It turns out that I really excelled in that class and enjoyed it, so I ended up switching to chemistry. I am excited by the concept of being able to design and build biologically active molecules and this inspired me to become a synthetic organic chemist. It is nice that I can now come full circle to incorporating more sustainable practices in organic chemistry and drug discovery. Q: Amgen is a member company of the ACS Green Chemistry Institute Pharmaceutical Roundtable. Can you tell us what efforts Amgen is making concerning green chemistry with this organization? A: Amgen is heavily involved with the ACS GCI PR. John Tucker, a Process Chemist at Amgen in Thousand Oaks is one of the co-chairs of the ACS GCI PR and I am involved as a member of the Medicinal Chemistry Subgroup of the ACS GCI PR. Scientists at Amgen have contributed to a Green Reagent Guide that will be rolled out soon from the Roundtable. I co-authored the Round Table publications “Sustainable Practices in Medicinal Chemistry: Current State and Future Directions” J. Med. Chem. 2013, 56, 6007 and “Sustainable Chromatography (an oxymoron?)” Green Chem. 2014, 16, 4060. Q: What is your role as Amgen’s “Green Team Lead”? A: I am the Green Chemistry Team lead for Medicinal Chemistry. John Tucker is the lead for Green Chemistry within our Process Organization. My role is to partner with others on our team to conceive of practical initiatives that can help the Medicinal Chemists in our organization reduce the environmental impact of their activities without slowing down the speed of their science. I work to coordinate the collection of metrics on solvent consumption as well as educating our chemists on Green Chemistry methods. Q: Due to the nature of the research, the pharmaceutical industry is notoriously not green. Currently, what do you see as the largest hurdles in greening medicinal chemistry research? A: The largest hurdles are the widespread use of organic solvents for chromatography and the lack of precedent for greener synthetic methods applied to heterocycles. At Amgen, we have been successful at significantly reducing chlorinated solvent use in chromatography and that has been an important change to make our medicinal chemistry efforts more sustainable. The use of silica gel chromatography is still the largest source of organic solvent waste and until alternate methods are available that can provide the same ease of use, broad utility and speed, this will remain a significant challenge. With regard to the incorporation of greener reactions, it is also difficult to change people’s habits and get them to try new methods that have limited precedent using heterocyclic substrates. For reactions where a greener precedent does exist, sometimes convincing chemists to change from methods they are comfortable with can be difficult. I encourage any academic researcher looking to publish a green chemistry method to include several heterocyclic substrates as examples in their paper to increase the utility and impact of their work. Q: You’ve already worked on alternatives for solvents for general use and chromatography, do you have another target in mind? A: Right now I am heavily focused on waste reduction and diversion. Reclaiming precious metals from our waste stream as well as finding a way to repurpose our borosilicate glass waste are important endeavors that we are investigating. We are also currently pursuing ways to reduce wasteful ordering and disposal practices in our industry. This includes encouraging chemists to order the smallest size possible and to resist buying more of a chemical because it is cheaper per gram in larger sizes. Often the cost of disposal rivals the cost of purchasing a chemical and making chemists aware of that can help to reduce ordering of excess chemicals. Q: We’ve heard Amgen has been organizing some community outreach programs to educate on and promote green chemistry. How do you think the undergraduates (and graduates) are receiving this message? What has been their response to these programs? What else do you have in store along this line? A: John Tucker has presented on Green Chemistry in our industry at several universities and my understanding is that his efforts have been very well received. We plan to continue this outreach and it is likely that I will join him for some of the upcoming presentations. Q: What benefit do you see in having green chemistry teams for departments and research groups in both industry and academia? A: There is a huge benefit to having a Green Chemistry team in an organization, academic or industrial. For example, chemists serving in this role that are imbedded within Medicinal Chemistry departments are able to evaluate new green chemistry methods before advertising them to their colleagues. This action often results in chemists having a more open mind to trying greener techniques because they have already been vetted by their colleagues. This goes back to the importance of good precedent. In a broader sense, Green Chemistry is safer chemistry and cleaner chemistry. Furthermore, often Green Chemistry is more efficient chemistry. For example, skipping flash column chromatography by telescoping a reaction not only saves a significant amount of organic solvent, but saves the chemist time, if performed appropriately. From a business justification perspective, less waste generated means less money spent on disposal and a safer working environment benefits everyone. Q: Finally, do you have any hobbies that you like to do in your free time? A: Yes, I am an avid sailor. I have been racing sailboats since college. When I was 22, I was part of a crew of 5 that sailed a 35 ft. sailboat across the Pacific from Hawaii to Washington State. I still race in and around Boston Harbor when time allows. UMB GreenChemistry 3 This interview was conducted by Meaghan McKinnon Bringing science to policy: New paths to support sustainable development By Maria Ivanova, PhD (*) Interactions between science and policy are at the core of global environmental governance. Biology, chemistry, and environmental science inform the policy process by identifying the scale, scope, and nature of problems that need to be addressed. Social sciences often identify obstacles to and opportunities for addressing these problems. The science-policy interface is an important concept that has gained traction within academic and policy circles. In 2012, the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development Rio+20 recognized the “contribution of the scientific and technological community to sustainable development” and called for renewed collaboration between academic, scientific and technological communities, to foster research on sustainable development and to strengthen the science policy interface (United Nations, 2012). Furthermore, as the international community finalizes the new Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to take effect in September 2015, science is expected to make a contribution in the definition of targets and indicators and the mechanisms to monitor and measure progress. The United Nations is working to bring rigorous scientific analysis to these discussions to ensure that the new set of goals and other policy decisions incorporate a range of environmental, social, and economic concerns. In 2013, the UN Secretary-General created a UN Scientific Advisory Board on science, technology and innovation for sustainable development to provide advice to the UN Secretary-General and heads of UN agencies. Bringing together 26 experts from 25 different countries and a variety of disciplines, the Scientific Advisory Board has deliberated on the role of science in the articulation, measurement, monitoring, and reevaluation of the Sustainable Development Goals, on big data, climate change, and means of implementation, among others. During the latest meeting, held in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia on May 24-26, 2015, Board members responded to an invitation from UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to present to him scientific concerns about the future of people and planet that require a global response. Through a Delphi process run over a few months, members suggested different strategies in areas such as ocean management, biodiversity conservation, investment in fundamental research, and prevention of natural disasters. Involving scientists in direct discussions with policymakers is challenging and rewarding. As a member of the Board, I have had the privilege to engage in these discussions and help articulate proposals for global action. A set of policy briefs will outline recommendations to improve the science-policy interface, to develop scientific assessments, to reduce the data divide, and to develop mechanisms that allow the communication of the risks of climate change. Creating a network of scholars interested in bringing scientific rigor to international policy processes is a possible first step toward more effectively integrating science into global decision-making. Green chemistry could be the pioneering field in this regard when scholars suggest solutions that merit global attention and action. (*) Maria Ivanova is Associate Professor in the Department of Conflict Resolution, Human Security and Global Governance, and Co-Director of the Center for Governance and Sustainability. In 2013, she was appointed to the UN SecretaryGeneral’s Scientific Advisory Board. Bibliography : United Nations. (2012). A/RES/66/288 The Future We Want - Outcome Document from Rio+20 United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development. Rio de Janeiro. This Issue of UMB Green Chemistry Newsletter was brought to you by: Ray Borg Meg McKinnon Caitlin Pollock Rachel Sadok If you are interested in joining our mailing list please contact Ray Borg at: GreenChemNewsletter@umb.edu UMB GreenChemistry 4