Lab 1: Accuracy and Precision

advertisement
Accuracy & Precision: Making Measurements
in Chemistry
Introduction
The purposes of this lab are many. First of all, this lab handout should give you an idea of the type of lab write-up
that is expected. Also, you should learn how to properly use some common lab equipment. The main purpose of
this lab is to learn how to make and record measurements, determine the precision with which a lab instrument may
be used, keep track of significant figures, and calculate the accuracy and precision of measurements.
Purposes



What is the density of water? (You’ll actually get three values, having used three different pieces of
labware, with varying degrees of precision, to measure the volume of the water.)
How many grams of sugar are in a can of soda.
Any one of the following:
o What is the thickness of the aluminum used to make the walls of the soda can?
o What is the density of solid sodium chloride?
o What is the melting (freezing) point of 2,6-di-t-butyl-4-methylphenol?
Hypotheses
For each item in the purpose above, you need to have a hypothesis. Cite sources properly.
Introduction/Cautions/General Instructions
This lab is really about keeping track of significant figures, using dimensional analysis and scientific notation,
making measurements, writing units, considering error and precision, getting used to handling common chemistry
labware, and writing chemistry lab reports. Any of these should be “easy”, and individual concepts are not supposed
to be so difficult. Ask plenty of questions along the way during this first lab especially. As will be typical, you will
develop your own procedures, then check them with the teacher before you start. Sometimes, however, there will be
specific methods that will be outlined here (in a handout). Never perform your own “experiment”t without the
teacher’s approval! Before completing a potentially dangerous part of any experiment, re-familiarize yourself with
the safety equipment in the lab (fire extinguisher, eyewash, etc.) For this lab, you develop all of your own
procedures, and carefully record them in your lab notebook. Pay attention in lecture for helpful hints.
Important: all information must be entered into your report booklet as you perform the lab!
Suggestions for Research
Other chemistry and science reference books, the internet, and the library are available for you to look up
information related to the experiments. Remember to spend plenty of time before each lab discussing with your
partner the possible results (hypotheses), anticipating sources of error, and looking up related material. Not only
will this research help you develop hypotheses and procedures, but you will likely come across material that you
will want to write about in your discussion. For this particular lab, you may want to look up some of the following
(these are just some ideas):
sodium chloride
solubility
aluminum
use of density, in general
sugar in our diet
the history of aluminum
measuring temperatures through history
supercooling
extrapolation and interpolation
temperature dependence of density, esp. of water
microscale chemistry techniques
cooling curves
Lab 1: Accuracy and Precision
Needs Improvement:
Title Page
Grammar
Usage
Spelling
Mechanics
Organization
Overall Neatness
Purpose
Hypothesis
Materials
Procedure
Data & Observations
Sample Calculations
Results
Discussion













Title, name, partner’s name, and date
Too many spelling errors
Too many grammatical errors
Not organized properly
Messy handwriting
Mistakes not neatly crossed out
Paper hanging out of book
Use pen (not pencil)
Don’t use white-out
Purposes not accurate or complete
Hypotheses lacking insight, or not clear
Sources of information for hypotheses missing
Materials incomplete or lacking















Not enough details
Data and results mixed in unnecessarily
Too many details (too fussy)
Complete sentences should be used throughout
Other information (data, results) included
Data incomplete
Format not well-planned
Line up decimal points
Use a ruler
Units not shown
Results, calculations or other stuff mixed in
Check your significant figures
Not shown
Incomplete
Only show one example of each type of new calculation
encountered in chemistry
(10)

Incomplete
 Density of water (beaker/grad cyl/pipet)
 Sugar Content of Sprite
 Your choice
You should have obtained a bit more accuracy
You should have obtained much more accuracy
Messy/use a ruler
Need percent error
No introduction
Did not reflect on error in the lab
More insight needed when considering possible sources of
error
More insight needed when attempting to place this lab into
context (a) in the class or (b) in the “real world”
Lack of research.
No sources or incorrect format.
Debriefing: Did not reflect (well) on things like “group
dynamics”, or personal insight gained
Late (-5 pts/day)
Safety violation (varies)
(10)











Other
Point
Total
(10)


(10)
(15)
(10)
(25)
Extra
Special!
Title Page: (1st page) your name, your partner’s name, the date turned in, and the experiment’s title.
Purpose, Hypotheses, Materials: The purpose consists of one or two sentences clearly stating the
objectives of the lab. The hypothesis section is simply a list of the probable and expected result(s)
for the lab. You must include sources of information that you used to determine your hypotheses.
The materials section is a list of all substances (elements, compounds, solutions with concentrations)
followed by equipment (beakers, etc.) needed to complete the lab.
Procedure: (one or two pages) A listing of the steps performed in carrying out the lab. You should
write in complete sentences, but be brief and to-the-point. You may write a step-by-step procedure,
or in the form of several paragraphs. Do not include any purposes, data, calculations, results, or
extra commentary here. Someone reading this should be able to obtain your results by following
your procedure, without having to “read between the lines”. Included labeled diagrams, and refer to
them in the text that you create: "Build the set-up as shown in figure 1..."
Data and Observations: (usually one page) Prepare a table of data that neatly shows every
essential measurement you made for each of the steps in the procedure. Make sure each
measurement you record shows the correct number of significant figures. “Neat” means that all
decimals line up and units are shown. Use a ruler. Any graphs should be titled and fully labeled.
Make certain also that your data is absolutely complete, and you don’t leave out any measurement
that you make. Written descriptive observations should use the “correct” terminology found in
chemistry books. All data and observations must be recorded in the lab notebook.
Sample Calculations: (perhaps one page, usually less) Show one example for each new type of
calculation you encountered in the lab. Start with the algebraic expression, and then replace
variables with some of your actual data that you collected, finally showing the result that you
obtained.
Results: (very short, usually) Make a table of results which shows only the final conclusions and
percentage errors. Make sure each of the items mentioned in the purpose section is addressed. The
table is ONLY final results and percent error.
Discussion: (usually the longest section, if you’ve done a decent job) This is perhaps the most
important, and longest, section in the lab write-up.
 Start with a short intro. This should be a paragraph of 2 or 3 sentences.

Evaluate error: Be specific and give examples. For example, if the density of water result was
always too high, state this and relate any errors that could have caused this error. Avoid
generalities. After describing errors, give ways to avoid them for the next chemist doing the lab.
In your opinion, was the amount of error acceptable? If not, think of specific (procedural)
reasons why you ended up with unacceptable amounts of error, and tell how you could do things
differently "next time".

Relate the lab and its ideas to new ideas we have learned in class. This should include some
research.

Debriefing: Comment on the lab (and unit) as a “learning opportunity”, some feedback for the
instructor.
Download