RS GCSE EXAM REVISION: PREJUDICE & DISCRIMINATION Key words Prejudice Meaning Thinking badly of someone because of the group he/she belongs to e.g. religion, gender, race, disability, looks, sexuality, lifestyle Discrimination Treating someone badly and unfairly Positive Treating a group of people favourably as they have been discriminated against Discrimination in the past. E.g. people with disabilities. Stereotyping: A simplified negative image of people and applying it to a group Ignorance Lack of education that breeds prejudice Tolerance Respecting the beliefs and practices of others Justice Making something fair Harmony Living peacefully alongside others Racism Treating someone badly because of the colour of their skin or their religious beliefs Apartheid A system of “Apartness” & segregation of black and white citizens in South Africa until 1994 Segregation Two races living in separate communities enforced by law, e.g. in the USA until the mid 1960s. Sexism Unfavourable treatment of a particular gender, mainly women FAMOUS RELIGIOUS LEADERS WHO FOUGHT AGAINST DISCRIMINATION Desmond Tutu: campaigned in South Africa to breakdown the system of apartheid. He put Christian teachings, such as “Love your neighbour” into action. For example, he led peaceful marches and protests. He saved the life of a black policeman by throwing himself over him when a crowd tried to stone him to death. He said South Africa should have a “rainbow people of God”. Apartheid was legal until 1994. Martin Luther King: a Christian who lived in America when black & white people were legally segregated. Black & white children were not allowed to use the same schools, swimming pools or restaurants. Black citizens had to sit in the back of buses and give up their seats for white passengers. MLK used his belief in Christian teachings such as “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” to encourage peaceful protests, for example, the bus boycotts, the student sit-ins and freedom riders (on the national buses) against racist laws. He was a very powerful speaker & 1000s gathered to hear his “I have a dream” speech. As a result segregation was outlawed in the USA. Gandhi: A Hindu who believed in ahimsa (non-violence) and used peaceful methods to fight racism and segregation in South Africa and India. He held marches, demonstrations and processions demanding fairness for all people. He encouraged non-violent mass civil disobedience. He led boycotts. He believed that the only way to treat people is to love them. Although Gandhi came from a rich family he dressed like a poor man to show his belief in equality and peace. QUOTES PAGE CHRISTIAN QUOTES EQUALITY “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” “Love thy neighbour as yourself.” “So there is no difference between .. men and women, you are all one in Jesus.” “I have a dream.. that people will not be judged by the colour of their skin but by the content of their character.” DISCRIMINATION “I do not allow women to teach or have authority over men; they must keep quiet.” “It is a disgraceful thing for a woman to speak in church.” “Women should remain at home, sit still, keep house and bear and bring up children… If a woman grows weary and at least dies from child bearing, it matters not. Let her die from bearing – she is there to do it.” MUSLIM QUOTES: EQUALITY “Women are the twin halves of men." “Men and women are equal but they have different roles to play.” DISCRIMINATION “Men are in charge of women, because Allah has made the one of them stronger than the other.” SIKHISM EQUALITY “Know people by the light that illuminates them.” “All men and women are equal as they are both children of God.” RELIGIONS DISCRIMINATE AGAINST WOMEN YES For 1000s of years religion has shaped the way women have been treated. The Bible has verses that discriminate against women and this has influenced how society has treated them. in the Bible it says: That man was created before woman. Woman was created from man’s rib. This has led people to believe that men are in charge of women. QUOTES: In the Bible it says: “I do not allow women to teach or have authority over men; they must keep quiet.” It also says: “It is a disgraceful thing for a woman to speak in church.” NO At the time of Jesus society had a negative attitude towards women. They were considered: Second class Had to stay in the home Were not allowed to pray in the synagogue Were not spoken to in the street Were not allowed an education It could be argued that Jesus started the women’s rights movement because he: Allowed women to be taught Allowed women to worship Gave women a role in the church QUOTES: Jesus said: “So there is no difference between .. men and women, you are all one in Jesus.” A leading Christian in the 15th Century said: In the New Testament it says: “Mary sat down “Women should remain at home, sit still, keep at the feet of the Lord and listened to his house and bear and bring up children… If a teaching.” woman grows weary and at least dies from child bearing, it matters not. Let her die from In 1994 the Church of England decided that bearing – she is there to do it.” women were allowed to become vicars. Because Jesus and his disciples were men the Roman Catholic church says that women should not be priests. Muslim beliefs Muslims believe that men and women are equal but they have different roles to play. In a Mosque, women and men have to pray separately. In Islam a women cannot become an Imam (leader of prayer). In some Muslim countries women are expected to wear the Burkha. Muslims believe that women are expected to bring up the children. In the Qur’an it says (4:34): “Men are in charge of women, because Allah has made the one of them stronger than the other.” Sikh beliefs Sikhs believe that all men and women are equal as they are both children of God. In the Gurdwara (temple) women can lead prayers and from the Guru Granth Sahib (the holy book). Guru Nanak said women deserve respect as it is through them that the human race continues. The Sikh scriptures says: “Know people by the light that illuminates them.” HAVE RELIGIOUS BELIEVERS DONE ENOUGH TO COMBAT RACISM? YES Martin Luther King, a Christian minister in the 1950s & 1960s, campaigned for Black citizens of the USA to have equal rights to whites. He used peaceful methods, such as speeches, nonviolent marches and boycotts to highlight the inequalities Black citizens faced. Black citizens, at the time, had separate schools, facilities, cafes and were not allowed good jobs or able to vote. They had to give up their seats on buses for white passengers. MLK wanted equality between both races & he was motivated by Jesus’ teachings, such as: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” “Love thy neighbour as yourself.” He gave a famous influential speech which ended with: “I have a dream.. that people will not be judged by the colour of their skin but by the content of their character.” He successfully: Ended segregation on buses, schools, parks and other public places Secured the right for Black people to vote. Made it easier for black people to get jobs in law, education & business Desmond Tutu, an archbishop from South Africa, campaigned for Apartheid to be abolished. He used peaceful protests, marches and speeches to highlight the problems that black citizens faced. He wanted all children to be entitled to an education – not just the white children. He wanted to abolish the ‘homelands’ – areas designated for black people to live. In 1994 after Apartheid he set up the Truth & Reconciliation Commission which asked people who had committed human rights violations to admit their wrong doings and ask for forgiveness. NO Many religious believers have used and interpreted holy scriptures to discriminate against groups of people. Some Christians have been responsible for encouraging racist attitudes for example some supported the slave trade. Here are 2 examples where the Bible has been used to cause racist views: South Africa: Apartheid For many decades the Dutch Reformed Church taught that God created white people superior to other races. They believed that “apartness” was God’s will. (Many years later they have apologised and admitted their ideas were antiChristian). Apartheid may have been abolished but separate worship along racial lines remains the norm in South Africa. USA: The Ku Klux Klan, the white supremacy organisation, uses the Bible to suggest that black people were created inferior to whites. They quote from Genesis a story where a man (called Ham) is given a blemish on his skin for disobeying God. The KKK says that black people are descendants of this man. The KKK has its roots in the Southern states of the USA, where black people used to be slaves. It campaigned to keep the USA segregated. And is still in operation today wanting the separation of whites and blacks. A FEW EXAMPLES OF RACISM REPORTED IN THE UK January 2012: John Terry is stripped of his England football captaincy after allegedly using racist language towards Anton Ferdinand in October 2011. December 2011: Anuj Bidve, 23-year-old Indian man, was shot in the head in Salford, Manchester on Boxing Day. 2 white British men are in police custody. There are reports of racial tension in this community. August 2009: West Ham & Millwall football fans chanted racial abuse at the England striker Carlton Cole, calling him a “monkey”. October 2006: A teenage schoolgirl was arrested by police for racism after refusing to sit with a group of Asian students because some of them did not speak English. April 1993: A black teenager, Stephen Lawrence (17), was attacked by a gang of white racist youths and was murdered. He was stabbed twice in his upper body. This attack followed 9 other racially motivated killings in London that year. None of the gang was originally convicted of his murder. This led people to call the police “institutionally racist”. However, a re-investigation has led to 2 of the gang being convicted of murder in 2011, 18 years after his death. WHY ARE PEOPLE PREJUDICE? Bad experience at the hands of someone in the group they are prejudiced against The way someone has been brought up – family influence Scapegoat – blaming someone or a group for something they haven’t done (e.g. Hitler blaming the Jews) and treating them badly The media (TV, internet, magazines, radio, newspapers) Patriotism – loving ones country and thinking it should only have one race of people Ignorance & lack of education (not understanding other races, cultures & religions) FEAR- e.g. Islamaphobia (fear of Muslims) & Homophobia (fear of homosexuals) Peer group pressure – following what friends say and do Christian teachings about RACISM: The Parable of the Good Samaritan Jesus taught people to “love thy neighbour as you love yourself”. A man in the crowd asked who his neighbou was? Jesus told him the story of the Good Samaritan to teach people that everyone is your neighbour. In the story a Jewish man was beaten and left for dead. A priest and a temple worker, who you would expect to stop and help, both walked passed and did nothing. A despised man from Samaria (A Samaritan) stopped, helped and nursed the man back to health. It was the enemy who helped in the end. Moral of the story: we must love and help each other regardless of our differences such as our skin colour, where we are from, our gender etc EXPLAIN RELIGIOUS VIEWS ABOUT THE VALUE OF THE INDIVIDUAL Religions believe that each individual is created by God. They believe in the Sanctity of Life - that every person has a special value to God. Christians believe that God has a plan and purpose for everyone. In the Bible it says: “Before I formed you I knew you” and “You created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother's womb.” Both quotes say we are special, sacred and have a relationship with God. God created all humans as individuals and equals and we should treat people how we would like to be treated ourselves. “There is no Jew nor Greek, male nor female, we are all one in Christ.” Christians are taught in the story of the Good Samaritan that we should treat everyone equally and with respect, even our enemy. The message of Christ is to “Love your enemy and pray for those who persecute you.” EXPLAIN WHAT RELIGIOUS BELIEVERS MIGHT DO TO CHALLENGE PREJUDICE Religious believers think that prejudice, judging a group of people unfavourably, is wrong. Many religious believers teach/preach equality and some have set up communities to demonstrate that we are all equals. Gandhi, a Hindu preacher (1900s), set up Ashrams (spiritual communities) where everyone lived as equals regardless of their wealth, race, religion or caste (social class) in South Africa and India. He believed people should live in harmony as we are all part of God’s creation. The Christian teaching of the Good Samaritan where the enemy, a Samaritan man, helps a Jewish man who was left for dead has influenced many to challenge prejudice. Martin Luther King used this along with Jesus’ teaching the Sermon on the Mount, “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” to challenge the racial segregation in the USA in the 1960s. His peaceful protests, speeches and acts of civil disobedience (such as the freedom riders or the sit-ins) eventually changed the laws in the USA to allow blacks the same rights as whites (to vote, to own property, interracial marriage). THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH POSITIVE DISCRIMINATION I agree that there is nothing wrong with positive discrimination as it is necessary to protect minority groups, such as those with a disability, someone from an ethnic minority or an older person, from people treating them unfairly. Everyone has the same human rights regardless of their abilities, race, gender or age. Positive discrimination helps to allow equality of opportunity. Examples of positive discrimination are keeping a seat with easy access for a handicapped person on a bus, having ramps instead of steps in public places, monitoring company recruitment processes (ensuring that companies are not stopping people getting jobs because of their skin colour/age). These policies are good because in the past these groups have been treated badly/unfairly and they have not had their views represented. Most religions teach about equality. In Christianity Jesus actively helped those who were weak, vulnerable and treated badly by their community. For example, Jesus healing a leper (someone who had a disease that people feared, hated and didn’t wanted to touch) showed that he had compassion for those who were treated unfairly. Jesus said that God loved everyone regardless of our imperfections. “In my father’s house there are many rooms”. This means that God allows many people into heaven and doesn’t have his favourites. He also said “When a foreigner lives with you in your land, do not ill-treat him.” God created the human race “In his own image” and this means we are all to be treated equally. Gandhi also mixed with people known as the “untouchables” to demonstrate that we all human, we all have imperfections and the no one should be treated unfavourably/unfairly because of disease/lack of wealth and we should all have rights. On the other hand positive discrimination can lead to resentment between groups. For example where an older person is given a job as opposed to a younger person – it may mean that the best talent is overlooked. It can lead to arguments and tensions between racial groups when one thinks the other is getting a better deal. Positive discrimination shows favouritism to one group but in the Bible it says: “For God does not show favouritism.” If, as religious people teach, we are all equals, then treating one group more favourably can be wrong.