DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 2013 NAPLAN Reading Analysis National Assessment Program Literacy and Numeracy Introduction One of the most crucial elements of supporting reading development is the explicit teaching of reading strategies so readers are able to access their prior knowledge during reading. First Steps Reading Resource Book (Second Edition) The purpose of this document is to encourage teachers to think about the meta-cognitive instructional strategies required to improve the reading comprehension levels of all students. Explicitly teaching students question types, reading strategies and conventions is essential to the development of students’ reading comprehension. Levels of comprehension Literal Inferential Synthesis Evaluative Applied/Creative An understanding of what is explicitly stated in the text Going beyond an author’s literal statements to draw inferences Connecting, comparing, determining importance of information Making a judgement or interpretation of a text Going beyond the text to apply information in new situations, making generalisations and responding emotionally Reading strategies Explicitly teaching a range of reading strategies is vital to ensure students are able to successfully access cues to support reading. When students ask themselves questions before and/or during reading, they read the text in search of answers and are engaged in active comprehension. The reading strategies outlined in First Steps Reading Resource book (2004: 114) are: Predicting Connecting Comparing Inferring Synthesising Creating Images Self-questioning Skimming Scanning Determining Importance Summarising and Paraphrasing Re-reading Reading On Adjusting Reading Rate Sounding Out Chunking Using Analogy Consulting a Reference Reference to the use of reading strategies can be found throughout the Australian Curriculum: English. Conventions Students need to use conventions independently when reading authentic texts. Students need to develop phonological awareness, graphophonic knowledge, vocabulary knowledge and text form knowledge. Exposure to a range of fiction and non-fiction texts is essential for the development of a broad vocabulary. Efficient readers use text knowledge to read and understand texts. It is important for students to develop an understanding of purpose (writing and reading), text organisation, text structure and language features (First Steps Reading Resource book, 2004: 95). Focus Areas The following notes are generalisations based on the 2013 NAPLAN data provided. Understanding the question Carefully reading the question and understanding what it is asking for is essential. Many questions appear to have been answered incorrectly due to a misreading of the question e.g. Year 3 Question 15, Year 7 Question 26 and Year 9 Question 15. Referring to the text It is vital that students learn to justify their answers by referencing the text. A number of questions appear to have been answered using students general or assumed knowledge e.g. Year 3 Question 24, Year 5 Questions 7, Year 7 Question 10 and Year 9 Question 5. Scanning Scanning the text for a key word, acronym or a multiple choice option is the key to locating directly stated information. A number of questions could be answered correctly simply by scanning the text e.g. Year 3 Question 8, Year 5 Question 3 and Year 9 Question 39. Synonymous match (vocabulary) It is important that students are taught about synonyms in context when reading (as well as when trying to improve their writing). Questions at all year levels require students to make a synonymous match e.g. Year 3 Question 4, Year 7 Question 13 and Year 9 Question 24. Reading ‘around’ Having located a key word or phrase in the text, students need to read before as well as after it to locate answers. A number of questions appear to have been answered incorrectly because students have read on but not before the relevant word or phrase in the text e.g. Year 5 Question 29, Year 7 Question 13 and Year 9 Question 39. Referring words (noun-pronoun referencing) An understanding of pronoun referencing is essential in order to comprehend texts. This should be discussed in context during shared reading. Students who answered Year 3 Questions 26 and 32 incorrectly may have had difficulty with this. Connecting information across sentences/paragraphs Students need practice synthesising information purposefully. Questions that required students to connect information across sentences and paragraphs were generally answered poorly by Year 9 students e.g. Questions 14, 15, 16, 39 and 41. Question Analysis Australian Curriculum Links to the Australian Curriculum v5.1 have been provided to show where the skills and knowledge required to answer the question can be located in the English curriculum. Please note that other curriculum areas might include relevant content but have not been referenced here. Content descriptions (and some elaborations) have been copied directly from the curriculum. The selection of questions for analysis One question has been selected for analysis from each text in each test (years 3, 5, 7 and 9). Six questions have been selected for year 3 and 5, eight for year 7 and 9. Some of these questions are link questions so they appear in a test for another year level as well. Questions were selected for two reasons: 1. A large difference (more than 18%) between the percentage of Northern Territory students who answered correctly and the percentage of students across Australia who answered correctly 2. A significant percentage of students (in the Northern Territory) selected one of the incorrect options. Notes on the data The data used for this analysis is the full census item analysis data provided prior to the validation by schools at the end of September 2013. The % NT response and % Aust response columns (see image) do not total 100% because other responses (including the colouring of multiple ‘bubbles’ or missing responses) are not shown here. Class or school percentages can be recorded next to these columns for your reference. Using this document The table colour is the same colour used for the year level test booklets Text title Year level and the order the text appears in the Reading Stimulus Magazine A copy of the text as it appeared in the 2013 NAPLAN Reading test Relevant section of the text with words and phrases that relate directly to the question highlighted Description of the skill the question is intended to test Question as it appeared in the 2013 NAPLAN Reading test Type of question e.g. literal, inferential (see page 1) The shaded option is the correct answer. In this case, this is A. Type of text Percentage of Australian students who selected this option based on initial data (see page 1) Other questions of this type (e.g. inferential) in the 2013 NAPLAN test for this year level Percentage of Northern Territory students who selected this option based on initial data (see page 2) Details about what students need to know and be able to do to answer the question correctly and possible reasons for incorrect answers Multiple choice options Questions that are included in a test for another year level e.g. question 24 in the year 3 test is the same as question 12 in the year 5 test Ideas for teaching students who answered this question or similar questions incorrectly Strategies competent readers might use to answer the question (see First Steps Reading Resource book page 114) Question Types Year 5 Year 3 No. Text 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 Earthworms Earthworms Earthworms Earthworms Earthworms Earthworms Eggs Eggs Eggs Eggs Eggs Eggs The story of Thunder and Lightning The story of Thunder and Lightning The story of Thunder and Lightning The story of Thunder and Lightning The story of Thunder and Lightning The story of Thunder and Lightning An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Adopt-a-Dog Adopt-a-Dog Adopt-a-Dog Adopt-a-Dog Adopt-a-Dog Adopt-a-Dog C A C B B D B D A A D A D D C B B D A D B A B A B C C C D D S C B S D D Question Type Literal Literal Literal Literal Synthesis Evaluative Inferential Literal Literal Literal Literal Synthesis Inferential Applied Inferential Inferential Literal Inferential Literal Inferential Literal Literal Literal Inferential Literal Inferential Inferential Inferential Inferential Evaluative Applied Synthesis Literal Synthesis Applied Inferential No. Text 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 The tree of life The tree of life The tree of life The tree of life The tree of life The tree of life An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths An interview with Andy Griffiths Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Kaiya goes hunting Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Dufken Dufken Dufken Dufken Dufken Dufken Dufken City of the Ancients City of the Ancients City of the Ancients City of the Ancients City of the Ancients City of the Ancients D A B C A C A D B A B A B C C C D D A A B D A D C C B B D C D C A S A B B Question Type Literal Literal Literal Literal Literal Evaluative Literal Inferential Literal Literal Literal Inferential Literal Inferential Inferential Inferential Inferential Evaluative Inferential Literal Inferential Inferential Evaluative Synthesis Literal Inferential Literal Literal Synthesis Inferential Evaluative Evaluative Applied Inferential Inferential Literal Evaluative Year 7 Year 9 No. Text 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Skippy the Bush Kangaroo Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Fishing from the rocks Duyfken Duyfken Duyfken Duyfken Duyfken Duyfken Duyfken Weeds Weeds Weeds Weeds Weeds Weeds Out at Midnight Out at Midnight Out at Midnight Out at Midnight Out at Midnight Out at Midnight RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake The melting Third Pole The melting Third Pole The melting Third Pole The melting Third Pole The melting Third Pole The melting Third Pole B C A D D A A A B D A D C C B B D C D D C D B A C C S D D B C A B D C C B A A C A D C A C D A C B B Question Type Literal Synthesis Inferential Literal Literal Synthesis Inferential Literal Inferential Inferential Evaluative Synthesis Literal Inferential Literal Literal Synthesis Inferential Evaluative Evaluative Evaluative Evaluative Evaluative Applied Evaluative Inferential Inferential Evaluative Evaluative Inferential Applied Synthesis Inferential Inferential Literal Evaluative Evaluative Evaluative Inferential Inferential Inferential Inferential Literal Inferential Synthesis Applied Evaluative Synthesis Inferential Applied No. Text 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 Mind your reflection Mind your reflection Mind your reflection Mind your reflection Mind your reflection Mind your reflection RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA RSPCA Malaria’s ancient mask Malaria’s ancient mask Malaria’s ancient mask Malaria’s ancient mask Malaria’s ancient mask Malaria’s ancient mask Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Encounter in Castle Estondrake Being a vegetarian Being a vegetarian Being a vegetarian Being a vegetarian Being a vegetarian Being a vegetarian In the moment In the moment In the moment In the moment In the moment In the moment The ultimate connection The ultimate connection The ultimate connection The ultimate connection The ultimate connection The ultimate connection Going somewhere Going somewhere Going somewhere Going somewhere Going somewhere Going somewhere D C S D B C A B D C C B D D B D C A A A C A D C A B B C A A C B C D B A A D B C C A B D B S A C B Question Type Synthesis Evaluative Synthesis Synthesis Evaluative Inferential Synthesis Inferential Inferential Literal Evaluative Evaluative Synthesis Synthesis Synthesis Literal Evaluative Inferential Evaluative Inferential Inferential Inferential Inferential Literal Inferential Inferential Synthesis Inferential Evaluative Applied Evaluative Evaluative Inferential Synthesis Inferential Inferential Evaluative Synthesis Literal Literal Literal Applied Evaluative Inferential Evaluative Synthesis Inferential Evaluative Inferential Teaching Test Skills Test knowledge Explain the test structure to students prior to the test. The test consists of a series of texts that get harder. Early questions relate to earlier parts in the text. Sentences and phrases in the test question that are in italics are quoted from the text. The text (reading stimulus magazine) Look at the title, layout and images before reading and predict what you think the text will be about. Read the text through once before reading the questions. Identify the text type, audience and purpose. Number the paragraphs for easy reference later. Underline key words and jot summarising notes next to the text. The question Read the question carefully, including all of the multiple choice options. Underline or highlight key words in the question. Paraphrase the question (i.e. write the question in your own words). Check whether the question directs you to part of the text e.g. (paragraph 2) or in the first two paragraphs Find the relevant part of the text by scanning the text for key words or going to the paragraph mentioned in the question. Re-read this part of the text ensuring you read all of the relevant sentence/s or paragraph. This will usually mean reading both before and after the key words. Ensure you understand what the question is asking by rereading all of it before answering. Cross out any distractors that are incorrect. Ensure you understand the instructions e.g. colour only one bubble. If the question is a short answer question, is it asking you to quote directly from the text or write something in your own words? Earthworms Year 3: Text 1 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 2 Understand how texts are made cohesive through resources, for example word associations, synonyms, and antonyms ACELA1464 Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making connections between the text and students’ own experiences and experiences with other texts, comparing authors’ differing point of view on a topic making connections between information in print and images building on and using prior knowledge and vocabulary making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning See also Year 1 ACELY1660 Item Descriptor Question Makes a synonymous match in a simple information text. Question type Literal Text type Information Similar questions 1, 2, 3, 8, 9, 10, 11, 17, 19, 21, 23, 25, 33 Option % NT response % Aust response A 15 7 B 61 83 Question analysis This question draws on vocabulary knowledge. After scanning the text for the word “hairs”, students must understand the meaning of the words “grip” and “wriggle” in the context in which they have been used. Students need to read beyond “grip” and make a synonymous match between “wriggle” and “move”. Students who chose Option A – eat could have read ahead to the next paragraph or made the assumption that the hairs grip so that the worm can eat. Some of these students will have coloured the first bubble. Reading strategies Scanning, creating images, self-questioning C 9 6 Teaching ideas D 9 4 Link This is not a link question. Build vocabulary through exposure to a range of texts. Teach synonyms in context. Discuss alternative words while reading e.g. What words could the writer have used instead of “grip” and “stiff”? What other words in this paragraph mean ‘earth’? Eggs Year 3: Text 2 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making connections between the text and students’ own experiences and experiences with other texts, comparing authors’ differing point of view on a topic making connections between information in print and images building on and using prior knowledge and vocabulary making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning See also Year 1 ACELY1660, Year 3 ACELY1680 Question Item Descriptor Question type Locates an explicitly stated detail in an information text. Literal Text type Information Similar questions 1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 17, 19, 21, 22, 23, 25, 33 % NT response % Aust response Question analysis Option A 11 3 Options A, B and C (“rice”, “milk” and “butter”) are not used in the text. The question uses basic cultural or world knowledge. Students who selected these may have guessed the answer without referring to the text. B 14 8 Reading strategies This is a literal question that requires students to locate an explicitly stated detail in the first paragraph. This question could be answered correctly by scanning the text for the four options. Scanning Teaching ideas C 12 10 D 56 79 Link This is not a link question. Deconstruct the question – “According to the text” means the answer can be found in the text. The question is not asking for an opinion. Emphasise the importance of referring to the text. Ask students where they found answers and encourage highlighting of the text. Teach scanning – Model the use of this strategy a number of times (i.e. think aloud while demonstrating how to find a name, date or sub-heading) immediately before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Hunt the Text Challenge (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 160-1). The Story of Thunder and Lightning Year 3: Text 3 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 2 Read less predictable texts with phrasing and fluency by combining contextual, semantic, grammatical and phonic knowledge using text processing strategies, for example monitoring meaning, predicting, re-reading and self-correcting ACELY1669 Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making connections between the text and students’ own experiences and experiences with other texts, comparing authors’ differing point of view on a topic making connections between information in print and images building on and using prior knowledge and vocabulary making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning See also Year 2 ACELA1470 Question Item Descriptor Question type Infers how characters are portrayed in a folktale. Inferential Text type Narrative Similar questions 7, 13, 16, 18, 20, 24, 26, 27, 28, 29, 36 Option % NT response % Aust response A 21 13 B 14 13 Question analysis In order to answer this question, students need vocabulary knowledge (i.e. familiarity with the words lazy, violent, powerless, disorganised, fear, told and ordered). Students need to understand that being powerless is synonymous with being helpless (needing help). They need to recognise that the phrase “lived in fear” tells the reader the villagers are scared (rather than lazy) and that “told their king” suggests that the villagers were actually asking for help. Students who answered Option B – violent may not have read the question carefully and therefore linked the behaviour to the sheep instead of the villagers. Reading strategies C 39 56 Inferring, connecting, self-questioning, predicting Teaching ideas D 16 17 Link This is not a link question. Build vocabulary through exposure to a range of texts. Teach students about different question types i.e. literal, inferential and evaluative. Teach inferring and self-questioning. Model the self-questioning strategies e.g. Why didn’t the villagers just tell the sheep to stop? Encourage text to self connections e.g. Have you ever been scared, felt powerless and asked a friend or adult for help? An interview with Andy Griffiths Year 3: Text 4 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 2 Know some features of text organisation including page and screen layouts, alphabetical order, and different types of diagrams, for example timelines ACELA1466 Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning See also Year 2 ACELY1669, Year 3 ACELY 1680 Question Item Descriptor Question type Infers the reason an interviewee introduces a quote in an answer to an interview question. Inferential Text type Interview Similar questions 7, 13, 15, 16, 18, 20, 26, 27, 28, 29, 36 Option % NT response % Aust response A 29 45 B 38 37 C 9 6 Question analysis This question requires vocabulary knowledge and text knowledge; specifically an understanding of structure (question/answer), text organisation (bold questions) and purpose. Students need to understand the quote and/or the question that it was used to answer. The wording of the question (“What do you say to kids who say…”) is asking for advice. To answer this question correctly, students need to know the word advice and the forms advice can take. Students who selected Option B – tell a story (38% of Northern Territory students) may not have referred to the text. They may have used existing knowledge that both Andy Griffiths and Dr Seuss are storytellers to answer the question. Others may have assumed Dr Seuss was a character in a story by Andy Griffiths. Reading strategies Inferring, re-reading, paraphrasing Teaching ideas D 12 10 Link Year 5 Question 12 Share quotes – dissect and discuss Teach Interview structure and purpose Model re-reading and paraphrasing to understand a quote and provide immediate opportunities for practice. Kaiya goes hunting Year 3: Text 5 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 1 Recognise and know how to use morphemes in word families for example ‘play’ in ‘played’ and ‘playing’ ACELA1455 building word families from common morphemes (for example 'play', 'plays', 'playing', 'played', 'playground') using morphemes to read words (for example by recognising the 'stem' in words such as 'walk/ed') Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making connections between the text and students’ own experiences and experiences with other texts, comparing authors’ differing point of view on a topic building on and using prior knowledge and vocabulary making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning See also Year 2 ACELY1669, Year 3 ACELY 1680 Item Descriptor Question Interprets the reason for a character’s reaction in a narrative text. Question type Inferential Text type Narrative Similar questions 7, 13, 15, 16, 18, 20, 24, 27, 28, 29, 36 % NT response % Aust response Question analysis Option A 17 16 B 38 49 Those students who selected Option B – He didn’t want Goolra to wake everyone up have referred to the sentence that follows. Significantly, they have not recognised that “that” in this sentence refers to arguing and not to his little sister. Nor have they understood the connective Besides indicating another point or reason. Those who selected Option A and Option D may not have referred to the text. This question requires students to recognise “sighed” is linked to “sigh” and that the following sentence gives the reason for the sigh. They then need to infer why it was useless to argue – it would make no difference to the outcome. Reading strategies C 16 20 Re-reading, connecting, predicting Teaching ideas D 14 12 Link Year 5 Question 14 Emphasise the importance of referring to the text. Ask students where they found answers and encourage highlighting of the text. Teach referring words (particularly demonstrative pronouns) and discuss in context during shared reading e.g. What does that refer to? Who does he refer to? Who does she/her refer to? Model connecting (self to text) and provide opportunities for guided practice (see First Steps Reading Resource book page 137). Adopt-a-dog Year 3: Text 6 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 2 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to analyse texts by drawing on growing knowledge of context, language and visual features and print and multimodal text structures ACELY1670 making valid inferences using information in a text and students’ own prior knowledge predicting, asking and answering questions as they read, and summarising and reviewing meaning Year 2 Know some features of text organisation including page and screen layouts, alphabetical order, and different types of diagrams, for example timelines ACELA1466 Year 4 Understand how texts are made cohesive through the use of linking devices including pronoun reference and text connectives ACELA1491 Question Item Descriptor Question type Interprets an advertisement to identify authorship. Synthesis Text type Advertisement Similar questions 5, 12, 32, 34 Option % NT response % Aust response A 19 13 B 20 23 C 33 48 Question analysis To answer correctly, students need to understand text structure (problem and solution), purpose (to persuade) and persuasive language features. They need to use clues from the text to infer that Adopt-a-Dog is an organisation and not simply a heading. The logo in the top right hand corner helps to clarify this. Students also require a good understanding of pronoun referencing – “At Adopt-a-Dog we know…”, “We are proud to say that…” Students who selected Option B may recognise that this is an advertisement, but have assumed Candy has a current family who are looking to sell her. Careful reading of the first paragraph may have helped avoid this confusion. Reading strategies Skimming, re-reading, summarising Teaching ideas D 8 9 Link This is not a link question. Discuss audience and purpose during shared reading. Provide a selection of short texts and ask students to suggest the author, purpose and audience. Teach referring words (pronoun referencing) and discuss in context. Teach skimming with a focus on reviewing page layout - see Graphic Overlays (First Steps Reading Resource book page 158). The tree of life Year 5: Text 1 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 3 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to evaluate texts by drawing on a growing knowledge of context, text structures and language features ACELY1680 using text features and search tools to locate information in written and digital texts efficiently determining important ideas, events or details in texts commenting on things learned or questions raised by reading, referring explicitly to the text for verification Year 4 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts ACELY1692 finding specific literal information Question Item Descriptor Question type Locates directly stated information in the second paragraph of an information text. Literal Text type Information Similar questions 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 20, 25, 27, 28, 36 % NT response % Aust response Question analysis Option A 17 6 Options A and C (“coco” and “coir”) are used before “copra”, earlier in the text. Students who selected these may have found the words in the text and not read around them to confirm that they were linked to coconut meat. B 71 89 Reading strategies This is a literal question that requires students to locate an explicitly stated detail in the second paragraph. This question could be answered correctly by scanning the text for words in the question (“coconut meat” and/or the options). Scanning, re-reading and reading on Teaching ideas C 8 5 Link This is not a link question. Encourage students to underline key words in the question. Teach different question types (e.g. literal and inferential) and encourage students to create their own questions for familiar texts. Model and encourage re-reading and reading on to provide sufficient context to determine word meaning. Teach scanning – Model the use of this strategy a number of times (i.e. think aloud while demonstrating how to find a name, date or sub-heading) immediately before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Hunt the Text Challenge (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 160-1). An interview with Andy Griffiths Year 5: Text 2 Australian Curriculum v5.1 Year 3 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning and begin to evaluate texts by drawing on a growing knowledge of context, text structures and language features ACELY1680 Year 4 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts ACELY1692 making connections between the text and students’ own experience and other texts making connections between information in print and images building and using prior knowledge and vocabulary finding specific literal information asking and answering questions creating mental images finding the main idea of a text inferring meaning from the ways communication occurs in digital environments including the interplay between words, images, and sounds bringing subject and technical vocabulary and concept knowledge to new reading tasks Question Item Descriptor Question type Locates directly stated information in an answer in an interview. Literal Text type Interview Similar questions 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 13, 20, 25, 27, 28, 36 Option % NT response % Aust response A 72 93 B 9 2 C 7 1 Question analysis To answer this question correctly, students must understand the use of “then” and “after” as temporal/sequencing conjunctions to indicate the sequence of events. Understanding the concept of drafting would also assist students answering this question. Students who selected Option B – as soon as he gets a new idea may not have referred to the text. Students who selected Option D may have made incorrect links to a later sentence within this paragraph suggesting they were looking for the answer under the correct sub-heading while students who selected Option C may have seen the word “day” in another part of the text. Reading strategies Skimming, scanning, determining importance, paraphrasing Teaching ideas D 7 3 Link Year 3 Question 19 Remind students of the importance of referring to the text. Encourage them to highlight where they found the answer. Teach students about conjunctions and text connectives in context with a particular focus on the purpose and function (e.g. time, addition, contrast). Teach skimming, scanning and determining importance. Model the use of sub-headings and bolded text to locate information. Model and encourage paraphrasing e.g. I write it on paper before typing it up. Kaiya goes hunting Year 5: Text 3 Year 4 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts ACELY1692 making connections between the text and students’ own experience and other texts making connections between information in print and images building and using prior knowledge and vocabulary finding specific literal information asking and answering questions creating mental images finding the main idea of a text inferring meaning from the ways communication occurs in digital environments including the interplay between words, images, and sounds bringing subject and technical vocabulary and concept knowledge to new reading tasks Year 5 Navigate and read texts for specific purposes applying appropriate text processing strategies, for example predicting and confirming, monitoring meaning, skimming and scanning ACELY1702 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies evidence of an emotional state in a narrative text. Inferential Text type Narrative Similar questions 8, 10, 12, 14, 15, 16, 19, 21, 22, 26, 30, 34, 35 Option % NT response % Aust response A 14 10 Question analysis This question requires students to distinguish between an event that frightened a character and the words that describe a behaviour that indicates fear. Some vocabulary knowledge is required as students must know what edged backwards means and associate this behaviour with being frightened. Students who selected Option C – the long grass exploded have identified the event that caused the fear rather than the behaviour that showed the emotion. B 17 13 Reading strategies Creating images, re-reading Teaching ideas C 36 37 D 26 39 Link Year 3 Question 29 Deconstruct the question. Encourage highlighting of key words e.g. second half directs you to part of the text. The question does not ask what caused him to become frightened. It asks which words tell the reader how he felt. Draw students’ attention to the process and participants in each sentence. What is happening and who/what is it happening to? When the long grass exploded, the movement happened to the grass. Model creating an image before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Picture this and Sensory Chart (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 151-2). Provide opportunities for students to act out parts of shared texts. Fishing from the rocks Year 5: Text 4 Year 4 Investigate how quoted (direct) and reported (indirect) speech work in different types of text ACELA1494 Year 4 Recognise how quotation marks are used in texts to signal dialogue, titles and quoted (direct) speech ACELA1492 Year 4 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts ACELY1692 making connections between the text and students’ own experience and other texts making connections between information in print and images building and using prior knowledge and vocabulary finding specific literal information asking and answering questions creating mental images finding the main idea of a text bringing subject and technical vocabulary and concept knowledge to new reading tasks See also Year 5 ACELY1702 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the intended purpose and audience of a statement in a poem. Evaluative Text type Poem Similar questions 6, 18, 31, 32, 37 Option % NT response % Aust response A 54 72 B 9 4 C 21 19 Question analysis This question requires some cultural/world knowledge and text knowledge (language features). Students need to be familiar with rules for different environments and the language of these rules (e.g. “Never” and “stay”). An understanding of quotation marks for speech would help students to recognise this as spoken text. Dad speaks at three other points during the poem and this speech is indicated with the same marks. Students who selected Option C – a warning sign on the beach recognise the language of a rule/warning. These students may not have made reference to the text to see that the previous sentence forms part of the whole. They may have used familiarity with warning signs around water to select this answer. Reading strategies Connecting, creating images, synthesising Teaching ideas D 7 5 Link Year 7 Question 11 Remind students of the importance of referring to the text. Teach the use of quotation marks for direct speech in context when reading a range of texts (including poetry). Focus particularly on examples where the speaker is not directly identified. Discuss who is speaking and to whom. Encourage text to self connections e.g. What rules do they have to follow? Duyfken Year 5: Text 5 Year 4 Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts ACELY1692 making connections between the text and students’ own experience and other texts making connections between information in print and images building and using prior knowledge and vocabulary finding specific literal information asking and answering questions creating mental images finding the main idea of a text inferring meaning from the ways communication occurs in digital environments including the interplay between words, images, and sounds bringing subject and technical vocabulary and concept knowledge to new reading tasks Year 5 Navigate and read texts for specific purposes applying appropriate text processing strategies, for example predicting and confirming, monitoring meaning, skimming and scanning ACELY1702 using word identification, self-monitoring and selfcorrecting strategies to access material on less familiar topics, skimming and scanning to check the pertinence of particular information to students’ topic and task Question Item Descriptor Question type Makes connections across details in different sections in an information text. Synthesis Text type Information Similar questions 24 Option % NT response % Aust response A 16 12 B 33 32 Question analysis This question requires students to locate the words Gulf of Carpentaria and refer to an earlier part of the sentence. Students who selected Option B may not have read the beginning of the sentence containing Gulf of Carpentaria and read on to find mention of the Netherlands. The phrase Twelve months after this trip indicates that sailing to the Netherlands was not part of this journey. Reading strategies Scanning, re-reading Teaching ideas C 11 9 D 29 46 Link Year 7 Question 17 Teach scanning. Model the use of this strategy a number of times (i.e. think aloud while demonstrating how to find a name or date). Mention word features that make scanning easier e.g. capital letters for proper nouns. Provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. Hunt the Text Challenge (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 160-1). Discuss the importance of re-reading from the beginning of a sentence. Provide other examples of similar questions and encourage students to write their own. City of the Ancients Year 5: Text 6 Year 3 Identify the audience and purpose of imaginative, informative and persuasive texts ACELY1678 Year 4 Identify characteristic features used in imaginative, informative and persuasive texts to meet the purpose of the text ACELY1690 See also Year 4 ACELY1692 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the generic main purpose of a movie review. Evaluative Text type Review Similar questions 6, 18, 23, 31, 37 Option % NT response % Aust response A 38 36 B 18 17 Question analysis This question requires text knowledge. Students need to recognise the evaluative language throughout the text and understand that the purpose of a review is to persuade. To answer correctly, they must link persuasion to giving an opinion. Students who selected Option A may have incorrectly interpreted the brief summary of the movie in the first paragraph as retelling a story. Reading strategies Self-questioning Teaching ideas C 27 41 D 6 5 Link This is not a link question. Develop students’ text form knowledge through exposure to a wide range of different texts. Identify audience and purpose when reading shared texts. Ensure explicit teaching of different genres includes purpose. Discuss the difference between the writer’s purpose and the reader’s. Provide groups of students with a selection of short texts of different text forms and challenge them to sort/categorise these according to their purpose (e.g. to persuade, to entertain, to explain). Ask students to provide reasons e.g. The purpose of this text is to explain. We know this because… Read reviews of shared books and films to develop familiarity with the language used to review. Skippy The Bush Kangaroo Year 7: Text 1 Year 8 Understand the use of punctuation conventions, including colons, semicolons, dashes and brackets in formal and informal texts ACELA1544 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 making connections between the text and students’ own experience or other texts making connections between information in print and images finding specific literal information using prior knowledge and textual information to make inferences and predictions asking and answering questions finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text Year 6 Select, navigate and read texts for a range of purposes, applying appropriate text processing strategies and interpreting structural features, for example table of contents, glossary, chapters, headings and subheadings ACELY1712 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the specific purpose of brackets in an information text. Synthesis Text type Information Similar questions 6, 12, 17, 32, 45, 48 Option % NT response % Aust response A 17 12 B 9 4 Question analysis To answer this question correctly, students need to understand the purpose of brackets. Students need to recognise that the names outside the brackets are characters from the show and the actors’ names are inside the brackets. To do this, they need to connect information from other parts of the text, in particular the image, the title and the mention of Sonny in the fourth paragraph. Students who answered Option A – characters in the show may not have carefully read all the options before answering. Students may not be familiar with this convention i.e. character (actor). Reading strategies C 61 79 Scanning, re-reading, synthesising Teaching ideas D 7 4 Link This is not a link question. Emphasise the importance of reading and considering all of the multiple choice options before selecting an answer. Teach the purpose of brackets in context during shared reading. Provide opportunities for students to read a range of texts where brackets are used in this way e.g. read reviews of familiar TV shows and movies. Model synthesising when reading a text. Stop at points during reading to think about and link parts of the text e.g. Sonny must be the boy in the picture. Fishing from the rocks Year 7: Text 2 Year 6 Investigate how vocabulary choices, including evaluative language can express shades of meaning, feeling and opinion ACELA1525 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 making connections between the text and students’ own experience or other texts making connections between information in print and images finding specific literal information using prior knowledge and textual information to make inferences and predictions asking and answering questions finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text See also Year 5 ACELY1702 and Year 7 ACELY1723 Question Item Descriptor Question type Infers reason for an emotional response in a poem. Inferential Text type Poem Similar questions 3, 7, 9, 10, 14, 18, 27, 30, 33, 34, 39, 40, 41, 42, 44, 49 Option % NT response % Aust response A 17 14 B 10 5 C 11 8 Question analysis This question requires some vocabulary and text knowledge. Students need to be familiar with poetry and understand the words “forbidden”, “excited” and “daring”. The question directs students to verse 3. They need to re-read before the quoted text, recognise that this area is forbidden because it is dangerous, understand that going to this area is daring (courageous or brave) and infer that this is the cause of the excitement. Students who selected Option A – They can see the waves may not have referred to the text but assumed that this is a reason to be excited. Alternatively, they may have read on to the words “…the edge of the beach” in the next line or referred to verse 4. Reading strategies Scanning, connecting, inferring Teaching ideas D 53 71 Link Year 5 Question 22 Teach students about the structure of the question e.g. (verse 3) directs you to the part of the text you need to re-read and the words in italics are quoted directly from the text. Emphasise the importance of reading around (including before) the quoted text. Ask students to write their own questions that do this. Model and encourage connecting (self to text) e.g. That’s like when I… Duyfken Year 7: Text 3 Year 5 Navigate and read texts for specific purposes applying appropriate text processing strategies, for example predicting and confirming, monitoring meaning, skimming and scanning ACELY1702 using word identification, self-monitoring and selfcorrecting strategies to access material on less familiar topics, skimming and scanning to check the pertinence of particular information to students’ topic and task Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 finding specific literal information See also Year 7 ACELY1723 Question Item Descriptor Question type Locate the stated detail in an information text. Literal Text type Information Similar questions 1, 4, 5, 8,10,15, 16, 35, 43 Option % NT response % Aust response A 16 5 This question requires students to scan the text for reference to a map and re-read this section. Students who understand that “created” and “made” are synonyms will find this easier to comprehend. However, to answer correctly it is only necessary to locate the word map and re-read from the beginning of the sentence. 1 Students who selected Option A may have selected the first option without reading the text or question. Alternatively, they may have read the question but answered without referring to the text or may have only read the first clause and seen the reference to James Cook. B 3 Question analysis Reading strategies C 68 91 Scanning, determining importance Teaching ideas D 6 3 Link Year 5 Question 25 Determining importance – It is important to determine importance when reading a question. Identify key words in the question stem and the options. Teach synonyms in context during shared reading e.g. What words could the writer use instead of made? Teach scanning – Model the use of this strategy a number of times (i.e. think aloud while demonstrating how to find a name, date or word) immediately before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Hunt the Text Challenge (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 160-1). Weeds Year 7: Text 4 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text Year 6 Analyse strategies authors use to influence readers ACELY1801 Year 6 Understand how authors often innovate on text structures and play with language features to achieve particular aesthetic, humorous and persuasive purposes and effects ACELY1518 See also Year 5 ACELY1701 and Year 7 ACELY1723 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the main purpose of a persuasive text. Evaluative Text type Persuasive Similar questions 11, 19, 21, 22, 23, 25, 28, 29, 36, 37, 38, 47 Option % NT response % Aust response A 14 9 This question requires text knowledge. Students need to recognise the evaluative language and understand the purpose of a persuasive text. They need to recognise that two different perspectives/opinions are presented. Students also need to be aware that not wanting weeds is a common opinion. 25 Students who selected Option B have identified that this is a persuasive text and linked the words to argue. They may not have read all of the multiple choice options or understood the word perspective. Alternatively, they may have seen the word protect in the second paragraph and linked the answer to this. B 27 Question analysis Reading strategies C 7 4 Summarising, paraphrasing Teaching ideas D 42 61 Link This is not a link question. Teach summarising – Model the use of this strategy a number of times (i.e. summarise the main idea in each paragraph when reading a text aloud) immediately before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Oral Summaries, Main Idea Sort, 66 Words (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 166-8). Develop students’ text form knowledge through exposure to a range of persuasive texts. Discuss audience and purpose during shared reading. Out at Midnight Year 7: Text 5 Year 7 Understand how language is used to evaluate texts and how evaluations about a text can be substantiated by reference to the text and other sources ACELA1782 defending points of view in reading circle discussions responding to points of view by developing and elaborating on others’ responses building a knowledge base about words of evaluation, including words to express emotional responses to texts, judgment of characters and their actions, and appreciation of the aesthetic qualities of text See also Year 6 ACELA1525 and ACELY1713 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies a character’s behaviour in an imaginative text. Inferential Text type Imaginative Similar questions 3, 7, 9, 10, 14, 18, 27, 30, 33, 34, 39, 40, 41, 42, 44, 49 Option % NT response % Aust response A 12 7 B 14 11 Question analysis This question requires vocabulary knowledge. To answer this question correctly, students must understand the words “attitude towards” as well as the words in the multiple choice options (“bossy”, “guarded”, “protective” and “aggressive”). They need to refer to evidence of interaction between the characters. Students who selected Option B – guarded may not have understood that the question asked for an attitude rather than an action (i.e. by Shoving Tomas ahead he was guarding him from the wolf). Reading strategies Connecting, re-reading, self-questioning, inferring, creating images C 59 78 Teaching ideas D 7 4 Link This is not a link question. Build vocabulary through exposure to a range of texts. Use faces/toys to build students’ vocabulary around emotion and interaction. Model and encourage connecting (self to text) e.g. This reminds me of… Model self-questioning e.g. Why did Andrej shove Tomas ahead? Provide opportunities to practise creating images e.g. sketch the scene Use activities like Process Sculptures and Frozen Photographs (Using Sophisticated Picture Books & Process Drama to Engage with Grammar by Dr Beryl Exley) to act out a scene and discuss what characters are doing, thinking, saying and feeling at different stages in a text. RSPCA Year 7: Text 6 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text Year 7 Use comprehension strategies to interpret, analyse and synthesise ideas and information, critiquing ideas and issues from a variety of textual sources ACELY1723 Question Item Descriptor Question type Summarises information from a web page. Synthesis Text type Web page Similar questions 2, 6, 12, 17, 32, 45, 48 Option % NT response % Aust response A 54 69 B 15 10 C 12 17 Question analysis This question requires some vocabulary knowledge (“opposed”, “endangered”) and cultural/world knowledge (“safari style”). Students need to recognise words that indicate the RSPCA is against hunting to allow them to dismiss Options B and D. There is no suggestion in the text that crocodiles are endangered. In fact, culling by professionals is mentioned in the third paragraph. The difference in the NT and Australian response to Option C could be explained by topic or cultural knowledge. Students who selected Option B may not have read the option correctly (i.e. read in ‘not’). They may have focused on the phrase safari style hunting. Reading strategies Summarising, paraphrasing Teaching ideas D 10 4 Link Year 9 Question 7 Model summarising (i.e. summarise the main idea in each paragraph when reading a text aloud) immediately before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Oral Summaries, Main Idea Sort, 66 Words (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 166-8). Model paraphrasing a title a number of times before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. RSPCA is against crocodile hunting. Encounter In Castle Estondrake Year 7: Text 7 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 7 Understand how language is used to evaluate texts and how evaluations about a text can be substantiated by reference to the text and other sources ACELA1782 Year 6 Identify and explain how choices in language, for example modality, emphasis, repetition and metaphor, influence personal response to different texts ACELT1615 Year 3 Discuss how language is used to describe the settings in texts, and explore how the settings shape the events and influence the mood of the narrative identifying and discussing the use of descriptive adjectives (‘in the middle of a vast, bare plain’) to establish setting and atmosphere (‘the castle loomed dark and forbidding’) and to draw readers into events that follow Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the purpose of the introductory paragraphs in a narrative. Evaluative Text type Narrative Similar questions 11, 19, 20, 22, 21, 23, 25, 28, 29, 36, 37, 38, 47 Option % NT response % Aust response A 17 21 B 33 36 Question analysis This question requires students to recognise how language is used to build tension and create a sense of anticipation. This requires some vocabulary knowledge (“anticipation”) and text knowledge. Students may have drawn on their knowledge of the narrative genre and assumed the main purpose of the first two paragraphs would have something to do with describing character and/or setting. Students who selected Option B may have focused on the first sentence in the second paragraph. Those who selected Option D may have focused on the word relationship and linked this to parts of the first paragraph. Reading strategies C 18 14 Summarising, predicting, inferring, creating images Teaching ideas D 22 28 Link Year 9 Question 19 Teach students about the link between prediction and anticipation http://moodywriting.blogspot.com.au/2013/02/creating-anticipation.html Explicitly teach students about how authors use language features to build tension (e.g. short simple sentences, repetition). Practice deconstructing questions. This question specifies the first two paragraphs, so both should be considered. Would the answer be different if the question had only mentioned the first paragraph? Model summarising e.g. identify key words, paraphrase. The melting Third Pole Year 7: Text 8 Year 9 Identify how vocabulary choices contribute to specificity, abstraction and stylistic effectiveness ACELA1561 identifying examples of acronyms, abbreviations and proprietary words which are used creatively in texts Year 8 Understand the use of punctuation conventions, including colons, semicolons, dashes and brackets in formal and informal texts ACELA1544 Note: Understanding the use of acronyms is mentioned in Australian Curriculum History in Year 3 ACHHS066. Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies an acronym in a scientific description. Applied Text type Scientific description Similar questions 24, 31, 46, 50 Option % NT response % Aust response A 40 56 B 25 28 Question analysis This question requires knowledge of the terms abbreviation, acronym, figure of speech and quotation. Students who selected Option A may understand that an abbreviation is a shortened version of something but may not be familiar with the term acronym or understand the difference. Reading strategies Scanning Teaching ideas C 13 8 D 10 6 Link This is not a link question. Emphasise the importance of reading all options in a multiple choice question before selecting an answer. Explicitly teach students the difference between abbreviations, acronyms and initialisms. Encourage students to find real life examples and classify them. Outline and discuss conventions associated with acronyms and initialisms e.g. use the full term in the first instance followed by the acronym in brackets, use the article (a/an) determined by the way the acronym is said not how it is spelled (an FBI agent). Teach the punctuation rules around the use of abbreviations, acronyms and initialisms e.g. do not use full stops between the letters in acronyms and initialisms. Mind your reflection Year 9: Text 1 Year 4 Identify characteristic features used in imaginative, informative and persuasive texts to meet the purpose of the text ACELY1690 how textual features such as headings, subheadings, bold type and graphic organisers are used to order and present information Year 7 Understand that the coherence of more complex texts relies on devices that signal text structure and guide readers, for example overviews, initial and concluding paragraphs and topic sentences, indexes or site maps or breadcrumb trails for online texts ACELA1763 analysing the structure of media texts such as television news items and broadcasts and various types of newspaper and magazine articles Year 9 Understand how punctuation is used along with layout and font variations in constructing texts for different audiences and purposes ACELA1556 Question Item Descriptor Question type Explains use of a text feature in a magazine article. Evaluative Text type Magazine article Similar questions 2, 11, 12, 17, 19, 29, 31, 32, 37, 43, 44, 45, 48 Option % NT response % Aust response A 22 18 B 65 76 Question analysis This question requires text form knowledge. Students need to understand that formatting features can be purposeful and are used to convey non-verbal signals. They need to be able to identify the first paragraph. Students who selected Option A may understand that bold words and phrases are often used to draw attention to important information but may not have referred back to the text. Students who selected Option C may not have read the question stem correctly (first paragraph) and referred to the bold writing under the photograph instead. Reading strategies Skimming, re-reading C 3 1 Teaching ideas D 7 5 Link This is not a link question. Encourage underlining of key words in the question. Teach paragraphing and the different ways of showing a paragraph break in context (e.g. compare how a paragraph break is shown in a novel to how a paragraph break is shown in a magazine or newsletter). Encourage students to number paragraphs (i.e. write on the text) when reading the text to make referring back to particular paragraphs easier. Model skimming before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Graphic Overlays, Sneak Preview (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 158-9). RSPCA Year 9: Text 2 Year 8 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and evaluate texts by reflecting on the validity of content and the credibility of sources, including finding evidence in the text for the author’s point of view ACELY1734 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 using prior knowledge and textual information to make inferences and predictions asking and answering questions finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text See also Year 8 ACELY1733 (vocabulary) Question Item Descriptor Question type Connects information across sentences in a web page. Literal Text type Web page Similar questions 16, 24, 39, 40, 41, Option % NT response % Aust response A 3 2 B 4 2 Question analysis Students unfamiliar with the word “culling” need to connect information from the previous sentence (killing animals) in order to provide context. Students need to scan the text for the word cull to locate the word culling or look for the words tourists or professionals. To answer the question, students need to know the word “permitted” and link the two phrases should be permitted and should be firmly in the hands of. Students who selected Option D may have answered the question using their cultural/world knowledge without referring to the text. Reading strategies Scanning, determining importance C 77 90 Teaching ideas D 13 6 Link Year 7 Question 35 Emphasise the importance of referring to the text. The highlighted part of this text is significant as it clarifies the RSPCA’s position. Model determining importance and use guided practice activities like Very Important Points and Main Idea Pyramid (see First Steps Reading Resource book page 165). Model scanning and provide opportunities for guided practice using activities like Hunt the Text Challenge and Interesting Words Chart (see First Steps Reading book pages 160-3). Encourage reading on and re-reading to determine word meaning. Malaria’s ancient mask Year 9: Text 3 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 8 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and evaluate texts by reflecting on the validity of content and the credibility of sources, including finding evidence in the text for the author’s point of view ACELY1734 Item Descriptor Question Connects information across paragraphs in a magazine article. Question type Synthesis Text type Magazine article Similar questions 1, 3, 4, 7, 13, 14, 15, 27, 34, 38, 46 Option % NT response % Aust response A 15 13 B 61 75 C 14 7 Question analysis This question requires some vocabulary knowledge (alters). They need to be aware that an outer membrane’s chemical features are part of its structure. Students need to connect ideas across paragraphs as the idea that creating a vaccine has been difficult is introduced in the third paragraph while the reason for this is explained in the fourth paragraph. Students who selected Option A may have answered using assumed knowledge of the topic without referring to the text. Students who selected Option B may not have carefully read the question (not recognising that the causality conjunction because requires a cause) and answered with the result. Reading strategies Synthesising, paraphrasing Teaching ideas D 5 5 Link This is not a link question. Emphasise the importance of referring to the text. Encourage highlighting of relevant sections. Teach synonyms in context. What words could you use instead of changes, causes? Encourage students to paraphrase sentences to clarify understanding e.g. How else could I say It’s therefore hard to come up with a vaccine that can tell the body what all Plasmodium parasites look like? Encounter in Castle Estondrake Year 9: Text 4 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 7 Compare the ways that language and images are used to create character, and to influence emotions and opinions in different types of texts ACELT1721 Year 8 Apply increasing knowledge of vocabulary, text structures and language features to understand the content of texts ACELY1733 See also Year 9 ACELY1744 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the reasons for a character’s behaviour in a narrative. Literal Text type Narrative Similar questions 10, 16, 39, 40, 41 Option % NT response % Aust response A 6 4 B 13 10 Question analysis This question requires some vocabulary knowledge. Students must link distracted Ayleth and momentarily lose her concentration. They must also link surprise to shock. Students who answered Option D – fear at meeting the enemy and Option B – uncertainty as to whether to fight William may not have referred to the text and instead assumed a correct answer based on their first reading. Students may also have linked shock to fear rather than surprise. Reading strategies Synthesizing, paraphrasing Teaching ideas C 61 73 D 14 12 Link Year 7 Question 43 Deconstruct the question. Encourage students to paraphrase the question e.g. What does distracted mean? Could I replace this with cause her to lose focus? Encourage students to underline key words in the question e.g. fifth paragraph. Teach synonyms in context e.g. What other words could we use instead of shock? Being a vegetarian Year 9: Text 5 Year 8 Understand how coherence is created in complex texts through devices like lexical cohesion, ellipsis, grammatical theme and text connectives ACELA1809 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 8 Apply increasing knowledge of vocabulary, text structures and language features to understand the content of texts ACELY1733 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the reason for points of ellipsis in a sentence in a blog. Inferential Text type Blog Similar questions 6, 8, 9, 18, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 33, 35, 36, 44, 47, 49 Option % NT response % Aust response A 9 5 Question analysis This question requires some text form knowledge. Students need to locate the ellipsis, re-read the sentence to provide context and recognise the purpose of this punctuation. Familiarity with the use of an exclamation mark for emphasis may help students to make this connection. Students who selected Option A or Option D may be familiar with the common use of ellipses to indicate that something has been left out. B 9 6 Reading strategies Re-reading, reading on Teaching ideas C 65 81 D 10 7 Emphasise the importance of referring to the text, particularly where the question directs students to a particular part of the text (paragraph 5). Teach punctuation in context (particularly the ellipsis). Discuss the purpose of punctuation while reading. Select texts for their use of punctuation. Show how the meaning of a sentence can change when the punctuation is changed. Students can investigate how punctuation differs across languages or create their own punctuation mark and explain its unique purpose. General information about use of the ellipsis can be found at http://www.bristol.ac.uk/arts/exercises/grammar/grammar_tutorial/page_25.htm Link This is not a link question. In the moment Year 9: Text 6 Year 7 Reflect on ideas and opinions about characters, settings and events in literary texts, identifying areas of agreement and difference with others and justifying a point of view ACELT1620 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 7 Understand how language is used to evaluate texts and how evaluations about a text can be substantiated by reference to the text and other sources ACELA1782 Year 8 Apply increasing knowledge of vocabulary, text structures and language features to understand the content of texts ACELY1733 See also Year 9 ACELY1744 Question Item Descriptor Question type Infers a characters attitude from details in a narrative text. Inferential Text type Narrative Similar questions 6, 8, 9, 18, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 28, 35, 36, 44, 47, 49 Option % NT response % Aust response A 14 13 B 26 24 Question analysis To answer this question correctly, students need to recognise that Aki is not the narrator but the narrator’s brother. Some vocabulary knowledge is necessary to link highly specific details to tiny, magnifying glass, intricate detail and meticulous. Students who answered Option B may not have referred to the text but assumed a logical response to the question. Those who answered Option A may have confused the characters and assumed Aki was the narrator. Reading strategies Connecting, comparing, synthesizing, summarising and paraphrasing Teaching ideas C D 45 7 56 6 Link This is not a link question. Emphasise the importance of referring to the text. Deconstruct the question/s. Discuss the significance of phrases like From this text. Highlight key words in the stem and options e.g. details. Teach students about different question types e.g. literal, inferential. Teach synonyms in context. Which words in this paragraph refer to details? Model summarising and provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. Summarise this paragraph in one sentence. Model comparing and provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. Venn Diagrams (see First Steps Reading Resource book page 161). Encourage connecting self to text e.g. Do you like details or the big picture? The Ultimate Connection Year 9: Text 7 Year 6 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse information and ideas, comparing content from a variety of textual sources including media and digital texts ACELY1713 making connections between the text and students’ own experience or other texts making connections between information in print and images finding specific literal information using prior knowledge and textual information to make inferences and predictions asking and answering questions finding the main idea of a text summarising a text or part of a text Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 8 Apply increasing knowledge of vocabulary, text structures and language features to understand the content of texts ACELY1733 See also Year 9 ACELY1744 Question Item Descriptor Question type Connects and interprets information across a paragraph in an information text. Literal Text type Information Similar questions 10, 16, 24, 40, 41 Option % NT response % Aust response A 8 6 B 62 77 Question analysis This question requires students to scan the text to locate key words from the question stem. Students need to re-read this sentence to locate the phrase tune into the brain’s electrical signals and recognise that the word using links to purpose. Students who selected Option C may have linked technology to programming or seen the word neuro-technology in the fourth paragraph. Reading strategies Scanning, synthesising, re-reading Teaching ideas C 11 8 D 9 7 Link This is not a link question. Encourage students to highlight key words in the question stem and options. Model scanning numerous times and provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. e.g. Hunt the Text Challenge (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 160-1). Discuss scanning short cuts e.g. Scan for capital letters when looking for a proper noun. In this case, scan for the acronym. Emphasise the importance of re-reading from the beginning of a sentence. Context clues can be found before an item as well as after. Discuss and prepare students for the structure of the test e.g. early questions relate to early parts of the text. Going somewhere Year 9: Text 8 Year 7 Use prior knowledge and text processing strategies to interpret a range of types of texts ACELY1722 Year 7 Compare the ways that language and images are used to create character, and to influence emotions and opinions in different types of texts ACELT1721 Year 9 Use comprehension strategies to interpret and analyse texts, comparing and evaluating representations of an event, issue, situation or character in different texts ACELT1721 evaluating techniques used to construct plot and create emotional responses, for example comparison, contrast, exaggeration, juxtaposition, the changing of chronological order, or the expansion and compression of time See also Year 6 ACELT1615 Question Item Descriptor Question type Identifies the basis of a relationship between characters in an imaginative text. Evaluative Text type Imaginative Similar questions 2, 5, 11, 12, 17, 19, 29, 31, 32, 37, 43, 45, 48 % NT response % Aust response Question analysis Option A 10 6 Students who selected Option B – his sense of style have focused on the physical description (suit, hair, beard and eyes) in this paragraph. B 28 32 This question requires vocabulary knowledge as well as some cultural/world knowledge. Students need to link the words going somewhere (repeated three times in this paragraph and the title) with the idea of a sense of purpose. Reading strategies Summarising and paraphrasing, synthesising, inferring Teaching ideas C 13 11 D 40 49 Link This is not a link question. Explicitly teach students about the use of repetition. Provide examples (such as this) in real texts. Encourage the use of repetition in student writing. Model summarising numerous times before providing opportunities for guided practice e.g. Oral Summaries, Main Idea Sort, 66 Words (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 166-8). Model synthesising and provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. Plot profile (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 149). Model inferring and provide opportunities for guided practice e.g. Developing Dialogue (see First Steps Reading Resource book pages 148). Resources Bristol University, Faculty of Arts http://www.bristol.ac.uk/arts/exercises/grammar/grammar_tutorial/page_25.htm Exley, B. (2013) Using Sophisticated Picture Books & Process Drama to Engage with Grammar Annandale K, Bindon R, Handley K, Johnston A, Lockett L, Lynch P (2004), First Steps Reading Resource book, Rigby: Port Melbourne Assessment and Reporting Teaching, Learning and Inclusion Department of Education http://ed.ntschools.net/ll/assess/naplan/Pages/default.aspx