Are we living longer: Fact or fiction? Students will conduct a supported investigation into mortality rates within their local historical cemetery and use this information to detect patterns, variations, relationships and trends and explain and communicate to others how these have changed over time. Curriculum links Principles • High expectations • Cultural diversity 1 • Learning to learn • Community engagement • Coherence Key Competencies • Thinking 2 • Using language symbols and text • Managing self • Relating to others • Participating and contributing Levels 3, 4 & 5 Learning Areas Values • Explore with empathy the values of others • Learn to accept different kinds of values – social & cultural • Learn about the values on which NZs cultural & institutional traditions are based. 3 Learning Areas: Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Level Three: Mathematics and Statistics Statistical investigation. Conduct investigations using the statistical enquiry cycle: Students can, Gather, sort and display multivariate category and whole number data and simple time series data to answer questions. Identify patterns and trends in context within and between data sets. Communicate findings using data displays. Statistical literacy Students can evaluate the effectiveness of different displays in representing the findings of a statistical investigation activity undertaken by others. Level Four: Mathematics and Statistics Statistical investigation. Plan and conduct investigations using the statistical enquiry cycle: Students can, Determine appropriate variables and data collection methods. Gather, sort and display multivariate category, measurement, and time-series data to detect patterns variations, relationships and trends. Compare distributions visually. Communicate findings using appropriate displays. Statistical literacy Students can evaluate statements made by others about the findings of statistical investigations. Level Five: Mathematics and Statistics Statistical investigation. Plan and conduct investigations using the statistical enquiry cycle: Students can, Determine appropriate variables and measures. Consider sources of variation. Gather and clean data. Use multiple displays and re-categorise data to find patterns, variations, relationships and trends in multivariate data sets. Compare sample distributions using methods of centre spread and proportion. Present a report on findings. Statistical literacy Students can evaluate statistical investigations undertaken by others including data collection methods, choice of methods and validity of findings. 2 Learning Areas Issue #: [Date] Level Three, Four & Five – Social Sciences Dolor Sit Amet Strand: Identity, Culture and Organisation Students learn about society and community and how they functioned in the past in ways that are both similar and different to today. Level 3 students gain knowledge skills and experience relating to the following concepts Understand how cultural practices may vary but reflect similar purposes. Students can Describe the issues that impacted on health and lifestyle in the Victorian era and explain the extent to which these conditions were different in the past as are reflected in the mortality rates in our heritage cemeteries. Explain that people in the Victorian era lived, worked, and socialised for the same reasons as we do today but explained and expressed things in different ways. Level 4 and 5 students gain knowledge skills and experience relating to the following concepts Understand that events have causes and effects Students can explain that lack of knowledge about health care, causes of disease, lack of social support for the poor, inadequate and overcrowded living conditions and unsafe work practices could impact greatly on the lives of people in the past. Understand that people move between places and that this has consequences for people and the places. Students can Explain that new immigration could and did bring great advantages and also new dangers to new and fragile communities in the colony. Students can describe and comment on some of the actions and reactions Victorian New Zealanders displayed to new immigrants. Settings In this module we investigate mortality within the context of the New Zealand cemetery. A range of activities allow students to research and investigate explore child and young adult mortality and the reasons for it in the initial period of New Zealand’s European settlement, that is about 1850 to about 1920. 3 Introduction to the cemetery Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Learning outcomes Explore students existing knowledge of cemeteries and develop some preliminary understandings from students about why they exist? What do students know about cemeteries? Using the postbox technique place the following questions around the room and have students write their answers on a slip of paper and place in a box at each station. Pre-visit Activities -Activity 1 Activity 1 1 Have you been to a cemetery? Who did you go with and why did you go? 2 2 Write Write down down 4 4 or or 5 5 items you would items you would see see ifif you you visited visited a a cemetery. cemetery. 3 What do you think you might learn about the past from visiting a cemetery? 4 How old do you think some of our cemeteries are? Why do you think we have cemeteries? 6 Why do you think cemeteries are important to people? 5 When students have completed responses to all or most of the stations, regroup students and have them collate the answers and display ideas on poster-sized paper or present as an Inspiration™ graphic. This is an ideal opportunity to discuss the nature and purpose of cemeteries with students and clarify any misunderstandings they may have. Download and show the “Introducing Cemeteries” PowerPoint slide show to support an introductory discussion. 4 Introducing the cemetery: Developing a cemetery vocabulary Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Pre-visit Activities Activity 2 Have students make use of the Glossary and make up a criss-cross puzzle for another class group to solve at Discovery Education’s Puzzlemaker website at http://puzzlemaker.discoveryeducation.com/CrissCrossSetupForm.asp Alternatively you as teacher can select words and set up a criss-cross or other puzzle for students. Teachers unfamiliar with Puzzlemaker may like to use the puzzles provided. A glossary is provided with the activity sheets. Activity 3 Map activities. Introduce students to cemetery maps. Explain the different kinds of maps available and the purpose of schematic maps. Discuss with students why cemetery maps are needed and how the maps work. Have students do some preliminary activities locating various objects, blocks and find approximate location of various plots using these maps. Both aerial and schematic maps are provided. Cemetery maps are available with the teacher and student resources that are part of this unit. Activity 4 Introduce students to the items they will encounter at the cemetery. Download and show students the PowerPoint slideshow called “Introducing the Cemetery”. Some Fact Sheets that introduce students to some of the wide range of memorials they are likely to encounter are available for download. It is suggested that teachers print two or three of each and laminate them for general class use. Activity 5 Discuss with student expected behaviour at the cemetery. An information sheet is provided. Discuss with students the worksheets, and reading of inscriptions and the need to work together to decipher some of the more difficult inscriptions. Encourage them to try and decipher as much as they can. It does get easier with practice. Make sure students take digital cameras, a reliable pen, a clip board or other form of firm writing surface, and a small calculator as they may prefer to work out ages on site. ENJOY YOUR CEMETERY VISIT 5 Preparing for a cemetery visit: Cemetery Maps 1 Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Obtaining cemetery maps. Before you start this activity you may wish to introduce your students to some mapping work. You will need to obtain maps of your local cemetery. These are sometimes available online but you may need to visit your local historical society, museum, information centre or library to obtain what you need. If all else fails the Genealogy Society of New Zealand have produced a series on cemetery headstone transcriptions. These often contain hand-drawn maps and are available from your local library or history society. Online schematic maps are available of many cemeteries. You need to search for these on your local city council or public library website. An alternative is the Kiwi Celts website at http://fhr.kiwicelts.com/Cemeteries/NZ_Cem.html These maps usually provide an overview of the whole cemetery with blocks numbered. Some maps have the individual plots mapped and numbered but not all cemeteries provide this level of detail. If you can Try and locate detailed maps that show individual plots. Satellite maps from Google vary considerably in quality and generally do not allow the user a clear view of individual graves. Dunedin City Council provides an excellent webmap service of the city in which cemeteries are clearly marked and blocks and graves can be seen. Aerial photographs can be obtained from http://www.dunedin.govt.n z/council-online/webmaps And http://www.dunedin.govt.n z/WebMap/viewer.htm?city Overview photograph of Dunedin’s Northern Cemetery provided by the Dunedin City Council. Used with permission. Preparing for a cemetery visit: Cemetery Maps 1 Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Teacher Answer Sheet \ 1 2 Key to Map 3 1 Car park 2 Modern memorial to Thomas Bracken 3 Sexton’s cottage, now an interpretive centre + toilets 5 4 Cemeteries are laid out with sealed roads and grass paths, and in blocks and individual sections called plots in much the same way as a suburb in a town. Each block and plot is numbered. Students can answer these questions using their schematic map. 1. Locate blocks 1,2,3 & 4, on this aerial map. 2. What blocks are inside the circle labeled 4 and triangle 5? Overview photograph of Dunedin’s Northern Cemetery provided by the Dunedin City Council. Used with permission. Preparing for a cemetery visit: Cemetery Maps 2 Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Information sheet: Schematic map of the Northern Cemetery This is a schematic map of the same south west section of Dunedin’s Northern Cemetery as the aerial map. The map shows Block numbers. To find an individual grave or plot within the cemetery you may need to look at the mortuary records. Keeping track of where everyone was buried was one of the jobs of the cemetery sexton. Today we can check where people are buried online using the following databases; the Northern cemetery database at http://www.northerncemetery.org.nz/northerncemetery/application/dynamic/contacts.cfm and the City of Dunedin Cemeteries database at http://www.dunedin.govt.nz/facilities/cemeteries/cemeteries_search Find the following people and mark them with a dot on the map on the left. Find these graves when you visit the cemetery. Robert A Lawson who designed many of Dunedin’s fine old buildings including the Dunedin Town Hall and Otago Boys’ High School, is buried in Block 8 Plot 7. 1 1 Sir Thomas MacKenzie who was a Prime Minister and High Commissioner for New Zealand, is buried in Block 43A Plot 0. 2 4 Alexander Livingston who was drowned in the wreck of the S.S.Tararua is buried in Block 2 Plot 16. 3 3 2 William Cutten arrived in Otago on the John Wickliffe and married a daughter of Captain Cargill. With Julius Vogel he established the Otago Daily Times newspaper in 1861. He is buried in Block 3 Plot 7. 4 Preparing for a cemetery visit: Cemetery safety and etiquette Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Specific learning outcomes Students understand the behaviour that is expected of them when they visit the cemetery. Information sheet: Student do’s and don’ts in a cemetery Dress appropriately for the visit. Solid lace-up footwear for uneven and often steep surfaces is necessary. Warm coats, raincoats and sunhats are advisable. Take a rubbish bag with you. There are no rubbish receptacles at most cemeteries. Make sure that everything you take into the cemetery you also take away with you. Don’t leave litter. Keep with your group. Do not wander off by yourself. Move around the cemetery on the sealed and grass paths. Do not run across what appear to be empty spaces. Many plots do not have headstones or other markers but people are buried there. Never move a gravestone or plot fencing. Do not sit on, lean against, push against, or try to climb headstones. Do not scratch at or try to clean headstones. If you have a water bottle with you, you can wet the headstone to make it easier to read and photograph. No crayon or pencil rubbings of headstones are allowed. You may need to walk over a grave to better read an inscription. Please do this with respect. Be mindful of other visitors in the cemetery. A cemetery is a special place for many visitors who come to pay their respects for deceased relatives. To show respect for the thoughts and feelings of others by behaving quietly is important. IMPORTANT Not all cemeteries are closed to burials. If you arrive to find a burial service in progress you will need to move away to another part of the cemetery until the service is over. At the cemetery : Data collection Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Specific learning outcomes Students conduct a statistical investigation on approximately 20 – 25 headstones using the in-depth study area worksheets and accompanying maps. Students understand the importance of the way they collect and record data for a statistical inquiry and are encouraged to be consistent and methodical in carrying out the steps in the data collection and recording process. General Notes for Teachers Print out the resource packets and student recording sheets for each of the study areas chosen. Provide one set for each study group. You may decide to have more than one study group working each area. If so start a second group at a different starting point to the one suggested. Students need clipboards and pens. If digital cameras are available encourage them to photograph the headstones especially if you wish to extend the inquiry as a result of this part of the investigation. Students record the inscription details on their worksheets. On some graves where there is no detail other than a name some information may have been pre-recorded on the student sheets. It is suggested that students record the name, date of death and age in full. Students can later check the cemeteries databases and fill out any missing details. Ages are often not provided for more recent interments. Sometimes dates are not provided. Some students could be encouraged to write in initials only if they are having difficulty. Including names helps to avoid doubling up or missing information recorded if students are distracted. Reading headstone inscriptions can be tricky. Lettering can be missing or hard to read in certain lights. Forming a shadow with a coat can sometimes be helpful. Inscriptions can often be confusing to comprehend. Generally where there is a death there is a date and age. Make sure your students are aware of the pitfalls. Northern Cemetery Area 1 – Blocks 43, 43A and 44 Area 4 – Blocks 100 and 28 Area 2 – Blocks 42, part 41 and part 196 Area 5 – Blocks 106 and 107 Area 3 – Blocks 2 and 3 Area 6 – Blocks 108, 101, 111 and 112 After the cemetery visit : Data analysis Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Specific learning outcomes Students transfer data collected onto a scatter plot worksheet. Students working at Levels 3, 4 and 5 can make some tentative observations based on the completed scatter graph about changing mortality over time. Students working at level 4 and 5 can find age mean and modes per decade and deepen initial observations. Statistical Analysis Activities Activity 1 Students work in cemetery groups or in pairs and transfer the year of death and age at death data from their recording sheets on the scatter plot graph sheets. Use the worksheet provided for this. Older students might prefer to use an Excel spreadsheet. Activity 2 Students enter the age data by decade. If a person aged 42 died in 1876 that information will be placed in the decade 1870 to 1879. The decade information starts at 1850. Dunedin’s Northern Cemetery opened on the 1st April 1872. The information finishes in 2000. Dunedin’s Northern and Southern cemeteries are now closed for burials except for the interment of ashes in family plots but many smaller cemeteries are still open for burials. Activity 3 It is suggested that students write in the actual age of each person into the decade cell as follows. 29 - 20 26 19 - 10 14 18 / 19/ 18 9-0 71/2 / 5 / 3 1/ 8/ 6/ 5 6/5/8 6wks/ 2mths 1850 – 1859 3 days/ 6 mths/ 1860 – 1869 3 mths/ 0-1 YEAR 1870 – 1879 This method makes it easier to make visual observations from the data in the scatter graph. Encourage students to raise questions about their specific graphs. Activity 4 Students working at levels 4 and 5 can insert their scatter plot information into Excel and develop bar charts to show the numbers of deaths by decade for their particular area. Statistical Analysis Activities Continued… Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Students can also produce bar charts to show mortality within particular age bands over time. Comparative bar charts could be developed for each area for children and teens over the last 150 years and for people reaching old age. Activity 5 Level 4 and 5 students are also encouraged to re-categorise the data. They can calculate mean and mode ages of death for each decade to find or enhance patterns, variations and trends. Encourage these students to consider the social conditions of the times when they are thinking about patterns. Activity 6 Students at all levels can prepare presentations of their data. Students observe and compare data presented by other groups in the class. What are the similarities to their own data? What are the differences to their own data? Activity 7 information will be placed in the decade 1870 to 1879. The decade information starts at 1850. st April 1858. The information finishes in 2000. Southern Cemeterythe opened the 1 AsDunedin’s a class activity combine data.onThis activity is particularly worthwhile if the class Dunedin’s Northern and Southern cemeteries are now closed for burials except for the inurnment has worked over a number of sites. Students can use other mortality records available of ashes in family plots but many smaller cemeteries are still open for burials. the data to see if there are different patterns variations between town and country. It is suggested that students write in the actual age of each person into the decade cell as follows. Notes for teachers. 26 29 - 20 The scatter plot graphs show some interesting changes in mortality over time. 14 18 / 19/ 18 19 - 10 1. Graphs should show a large number of children’s deaths (under the age of 10) especially from the 1860s to the 71/2 / 5 / 3 1/ 8/ 6/ 5 6/5/8 1880s 9 0 2. The number of deaths of children under 10 decrease from the 1890s onwards. 3 days/and young 3 mths/ 3. Graphs should show a greater6wks/ number of teens adults (those in their 20s and 30s) dying in the 2mths 6 mths/ 0 1 1860s to 1900s 1850 numbers – 1860 – 1870 – their 70s and 80s from about 1900 onwards 4. Graphs should also show greater of people living into YEAR 1859 1869 1879 This method makes it easier to make visual observations from the data in the scatter graph. Activity 8 Encourage students to raise questions about their specific graphs. Have students collect the death notices section from the local newspaper over several days and plot the age at death for people today on the scatter graph chart. Have students compare mortality rates today with those of the past. Activity 9 Encourage students to observe changes and suggest from their evidence some possible reasons for changing mortality over time. Discuss with students the central question of the unit , “Are we living longer? Fact or Fiction!” Teachers may wish to complete the unit at this point. However the statistics unit provides an excellent opportunity for teachers to encourage students to further inquire into the reasons for changing mortality rates over time in their local community. Further student explorations into the mortality surveys Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet Factors affecting the life span of early New Zealanders A mortality survey using an historic cemetery as a primary source opens the door for students to follow up on some of the questions that are likely to emerge from their statistical studies. It is suggested that students use an inquiry methodology to ask, develop and refine questions and to follow up on the questions with information gathering from a wide variety of sources, analyse their information and present their findings either online or to a live audience. A challenge for students would be to find which of the changes may have had the most marked affect and at what points of time. Download the file timeline.pdf. This is a good starting point for students to find out what possible reasons for many people living shorter lives were and reference point for individual or group inquiries. No taps! How did people in your town/city get their water? Investigate the changing conditions of the local water supply. Investigate the links with diseases such as typhoid and cholera. Find out about when improvements to the water supply were made. 1 No flush toilets! What did people do? The water closet or flush toilet that we use today was not in common use in Victorian times in New Zealand. Why not? What did people use in the way of toilets? Find out what a privy is? Find out what an earth closet is? Find out what a cesspool is? 2 3 No pulling the bath or the sink plug! Have a look at sewerage and effluent disposal. Investigate the links with diseases such as typhoid, and cholera. Find out about when improvements to the effluent disposal were made. 4 No wheelie bins or “Insinkerators”! Investigate how household and commercial garbage was disposed of in your town. 5 No lights! How did people see at night? The use of candles and kerosene lamps often had consequences for people living in cramped conditions and wooden houses. No heaters or heat pumps! What did poor heating, and poor building-construction, mean? What did people do to keep warm? Investigate the links with diseases resulting from close living in small, damp and cold houses, such as scarlet fever, influenza, colds, asthma, and tuberculosis. 6 7 No Microwaves! and how was food prepared without the flick of a switch to turn on the oven How did families in Victorian times cook food? What did they use? No refrigerators! How did housewives store food? What sort of food-handling methods were used? Find out how butchers handled meat for their customers. Investigate the links with such diseases as diarrhoea, food poisoning, and intestinal parasites, hydatids, and unpasteurised milk. 8 Further student explorations into the mortality surveys Issue #: [Date] Factors affecting the life span of early New Zealanders Dolor Sit Amet 9 No domestic or commercial fire alarms. Investigate the development of the fire brigade in your town and some of the terrible commercial building and house fires that occurred. Investigate some of the reasons for these fires. 10 Poor hospital practices and limited health care! What did people do when they suffered from disease injury or toothache? How were young mothers helped with looking after babies and children. How were the elderly cared for? Students may like to investigate these aspects of the lowering of infant mortality and the increasing number of elderly over time. 11 Limited vaccines and no antibiotics! Diseases caught in other countries and brought into New Zealand by immigrants from many different countries were quite a problem. Investigate the links with small pox, diphtheria and tuberculosis. Students can investigate the various solutions to this problem over time and can even investigate how this problem, which still exists, is handled today! 12 No tar-sealed roads! Find out about the first roads in your local area. Find out about later road conditions and road surfaces. What were the problems caused by unsealed roads? What were the problems caused by horses on unsealed roads. No cars, trucks or bikes! How did people move around! Students might like to have a look 13 at and timeline the invention of new modes of transport and the effect this would have had on bringing horses into the centres of growing cities. How was manure from live animals dealt with? Investigate links with fly-borne diseases such as diarrhoea. No separate bedroom! Houses were much smaller in the Victorian era and 14 families were much larger. Investigate health problems that would be caused by overcrowding and poor living conditions such as tuberculosis, scarlet fever and diphtheria. Note: Each of these themes could be investigated to some considerable depth for there is much to find on each theme. However some themes could be joined into a single theme for example “No toilets!” and “No pulling the bath or sink plug!” Also “No hard roads!” and “No cars, trucks or buses!” also “Limited hospital services!” and “No vaccines, or antibiotics!” could also be merged into a single theme for student exploration. Further student explorations into the mortality Issue #: [Date] surveys Dolor Sit Amet The Old Cromwell Cemetery This clipboard pack provides students with mortality records for three Blocks of the Old Cromwell Cemetery. This includes material on date age and cause of death for about 90 burials. Students can use the mortuary records to complete similar mortality charts to find out whether the charts for a rural township show similar patterns and trends to a larger urban area such as Dunedin. Quarantine Island – Otago Harbour This clipboard pack provides information, newspaper clippings from the times, fact sheets and links to further information about Dunedin’s Quarantine Island, which was used to detain ships and passengers arriving at Port Chalmers that had outbreaks of communicable diseases such as small pox, typhoid fever, scarlet fever, measles and diphtheria during the journey to New Zealand. A list of burials in the Island cemetery is provided as well as information about various memorable ships that arrived in Otago including the Victory in 1863, the Lady Jocelyn, the Charlotte Gladstone, the Mongol and the Cloucester. Evidence of Epidemics This clipboard pack provides information assembled for students about some of the epidemics that are evident if we look carefully at our local cemeteries. The pack contains information about the virulent typhoid epidemic in Cromwell in 1874, three tombstones where children died from scarlet fever that can be found in Dunedin’s Northern cemetery, a case where a family has died of measles in Dunedin’s Southern Cemetery, three family deaths involving consumption at the Waitati Cemetery, situated north of Dunedin, and a look at the 1918 flu epidemic at Dunedin’s Anderson’s Bay Cemetery. Fires! This clipboard pack provides information, newspaper clippings from the times, fact sheets and links to further information about the dangers of living with open fires for heating, colonial ovens for cooking, and candles and kerosene lamps for lighting. Some of Dunedin’s worst fires are relived in the press cuttings, and cemetery trails for this resource pack. Timeline of possible reasons for changes in mortality rates! What were the cases of such high rates of mortality in early New Zealand. This clipboard pack includes a timeline of changes to water supplies, sanitation, food handling practices and more, which may have impacted on the death rates. Further student explorations into the mortality surveys Issue #: [Date] Dolor Sit Amet References - Online Encourage students to find out more about the people who are buried and commemorated here. 1. There are a number of young men in this area killed in action and interred in commonwealth war graves. The following websites are recommended for students i. The Commonwealth War Graves Commission website is searchable at http://www.cwgc.org/debt_of_honour.asp?menuid=14 Students can find out where these men are actually buried and other military details such as rank, and battalion or regiment served. ii. The Auckland Museum Cenotaph Database is also searchable and is at http://muse.aucklandmuseum.com/databases/cenotaph/locations.asp x 2. It is often useful to search your local Cemetery Database if students wish to find out about the occupation and origin of the early settlers on these in depth study areas. These details are not always included but often are, especially for a male. To locate the appropriate databases for your area it is recommended you use the Kiwi Celts website, New Zealand Cemeteries, page at http://fhr.kiwicelts.com/Cemeteries/NZ_Cem.html There is also Christchurch City Council Cemeteries database at http://librarydata.christchurch.org.nz/Cemeteries/ Wellington City Council Cemeteries database at http://www.wellington.govt.nz/services/cemeteries/search/search.php Cemeteries in Auckland are best searched for using either Google or The map locator at Kiwi Celts http://fhr.kiwicelts.com/Cemeteries/NZ_Cem.html as there is no one centralized cemeteries database. 3. The National Library Papers Past website is an excellent primary source to find out about accident deaths. Obituaries are an excellent source of biographical information. Available at http://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/ Papers Past contains more than one million pages of digitised New Zealand newspapers and periodicals. The collection covers the years 1840 to 1915 and includes publications from all regions of New Zealand. 4. The Dictionary of New Zealand Biography http://www.dnzb.govt.nz/dnzb/ This website contains over 3,000 biographies of New Zealanders who have 'made their mark' on New Zealand and includes many local people.