History – Stage 4 and 5 Integrating sustainability education in your subject The NSW Department of Education and Communities (DEC) is committed to sustainability education through the: Environmental Education Policy for Schools and the Sustainability and Environment integration (Learning across the Curriuclum) in revised NSW syllabus. Together these aim to outline the understandings, skills and values that develop the capacity to live more sustainably. Schools should provide sustainability education programs and experiences that: are interdisciplinary and systematically programmed, taught and evaluated as part of the curriculum K-12 progressively build knowledge and skills through the stages of schooling that allow students to use the school site and other built and natural environments to investigate, plan and take action for biodiversity and the natural environment allow students to consider a range of viewpoints and to make judgements based on evidence, their personal values and social justice provide students with opportunities to learn about, and from, Aboriginal peoples’ relationship with country, land use, heritage and culture, preferably through engagement with members of their local Aboriginal community allow students to explore their relationship with their community and the environment and to explore, design and where possible implement responses to sustainability solutions promote collaboration and partnerships within the community. Further information and guidance on how education for sustainability may be structured to support a progression of learning from Kindergarten to Year 10 can be found in the Sustainability Curriculum Framework published by the Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts. This document sets out three dimensions to learning for sustainability: Sustainability Action Process, Knowledge of Ecological and Human Systems and Repertoires of Practice. The three above three dimensions can be applied in all curriculum areas. The following pages provide lnks to learning resources that support student development in each of these three dimensions. Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 History, Stage 4 and 5 Sustainability Curriculum Framework Sustainability Action Process Knowledge of Ecological and Human Systems Repertoires of Practice NSW DET Sustainability Education Policy allow students to experience, value and take action to protect biodiversity and the natural environment allow students to use the school site, other built environments and their local area to investigate, plan and take action to improve sustainability promote collaboration and partnerships within the community are systematically programmed, taught and evaluated as part of the curriculum K12 are interdisciplinary; applying, connecting and progressively building knowledge and skills from across learning areas and through the stages of schooling provide students with opportunities to learn about, and from, Aboriginal peoples’ relationship with country, land use, heritage and culture, preferably through engagement with members of their local Aboriginal community allow students to consider a range of viewpoints and to make judgements based on evidence, their personal values and social justice allow students to explore their relationship with the environment and to explore, design and where possible implement responses to sustainability challenges for both natural and built environments include different spatial scales (local to global, home to community). Stage 5 unit of work Saving our Heritage Examine the heritage of Kelly’s Bush and Susannah Place and collect evidence about the places, sites and issues of important heritage value to Australians 2 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 History Sustainability Action Process 1. Making the case for change Outcomes Skills Learning for Sustainability 4.4 Brainstorming Changes for the Good of All Showing Evidence Tool Making Decisions Visual Ranking Talk it Out 4.5 5.5 4.8 5.8 4/5.9 2. Defining the scope 4.6 5.6 4.7 5.7 3. Developing the proposal 4/5.10 Identifies major periods of historical time and sequences people and events within specific periods of time Identifies the meaning, purpose and context of historical sources identifies, comprehends and evaluates historical sources Locates, selects and organises relevant information from a number of sources, including ICT, to conduct basic historical research locates, selects and organises relevant historical information from a number of sources, including ICT, to undertake historical inquiry Uses historical terms and concepts in appropriate contexts Draws conclusions about the usefulness of sources as evidence in an inquiry uses sources appropriately in an historical inquiry Identifies different contexts, perspectives and interpretations of the past explains different contexts, perspectives and interpretations of the past Selects and uses appropriate oral, written and other forms, including ICT, to communicate effectively about the past Oral History project Seeing Reason Tool Using Google Sketch-Up Digital Story Telling Agreement by Consensus Visual Ranking Persuasive Writing Writing a Discussion Create a Laptop Wrap How Do We Use Language to 3 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Persuade? Mind Mapping Writing a Project Brief Seeing Reason Tool Decision Making Techniques Tuning Protocols Communication Checklist Effective Communication Making a Difference Getting Things Done 4. Implementing the proposal 5. Evaluating and reflecting Knowledge of Ecological and Human Systems Living things Major forms of life Biochemistry Ecosystem and ecosystem relationships Evolution of life and the biosphere Biosphere processes Methods of mapping, monitoring and assessing living systems Forces and energy Structure of the Earth Solar system Climate Social systems and culture 4.2 Knowledge and Understanding Learning for Sustainability Describes significant features of Aboriginal and Ancient Observatories Threats to Aboriginal Land Indigenous peoples, 4 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 indigenous cultures, prior to colonisation 4.3 Explains the ways indigenous and non-indigenous peoples of the world have responded to contact with each other The class is divided into expert groups and use historical sources and other references to evaluate Plains Indians the cultural and environmental impact of contact on Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe the indigenous group studied in class. Wounded Knee - The Museum 5.1 Explains social, political and cultural developments and events and evaluates their impact on Australian life Sub systems Methods of assessing ecological sustainability colonisation and contact history - allows an exploration of relationship with country, land use, heritage and culture e.g. Plains Indians 5.5 Identifies, comprehends and evaluates historical sources Individually students identify and justify a feature in their life that is worthy of conservation and preservation for the future. Collectively students negotiate criteria for determining the heritage significance of a site or practice. In the classroom students are provided with three examples of sites from a local, national or global environment to which they need to apply their agreed criteria and justify their choice. Australian Biographies Biggest Family Album Old New Land Koori History Law & Justice in Australia ABC Archives Heritage – investigating the preservation and conservation of the built and natural environment e.g. mandatory site studies Teaching Heritage Aboriginal Sites Sydney Olympic Park Site The Abandoned City 5 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Historical evaluation and processes of historical change 4.1 Describes and explains the nature of history, the main features of past societies and periods and their legacy 4.4 Identifies major periods of historical time and sequences people and events within specific periods of time The river Nile was central to Egyptian society, providing life-giving water, transport and resources. Students use primary and secondary sources to examine key questions: - What natural features and resources enabled Egypt to play a prominent role in the Near East?' - What types of natural resources did Egypt possess? - How did the natural world affect the ancient Egyptians’ beliefs and values? Students collate their answers to the focus questions and: 4.2 - Frame a hypothesis based on the importance of the geography, topography and natural resources of ancient Egypt from the evidence. - Create a graphic overview or plan based on the - importance of the Nile to ancient Egyptian society. - Identify primary & secondary sources that support their argument. - Present the ancient attitude to the natural Past societies, periods and their legacy – evaluating the history and development of human society, technology and their relation to the natural environment, including whether or not present and past societies can be judged to be or have been ecologically sustainable e.g. ancient Egypt Jared Diamond - Collapse How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed Egyptians Learning From Past Societies Ancient China Ancient Egypt Ancient Greece Inside Romans Ancient Cultures The Abandoned City 6 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 4.3 environment by writing hymns to Hapi and Seth Describes significant features of Aboriginal and indigenous cultures, prior to colonisation Explains the ways indigenous and non-indigenous peoples of the world have responded to contact with each other Students design a series of 10 postcards that describe the threats to Aboriginal culture and heritage and outline the way they have responded to them. Students should use the following categories to guide the development of the postcards. • Traditional heritage of local Aboriginal community • European colonisation – Economic and spiritual erosion/dispossession – Changing cultures Aboriginal pre and post contact history – provides students with opportunities to engage with Aboriginal culture and heritage and with members of indigenous communities e.g. changing rights and freedoms of Aboriginal Australians. Frontier Education Online Screen Australia – Contact History Australian Colonisation Indigenous Australia The Crimson Thread of Kinship First Australians Exhibition Aboriginal Timeline Threats to Aboriginal Land • Reclaiming autonomy – Self-determination – Political and social activism Each postcard needs to be A5 size, with a picture/backdrop applicable to the local aboriginal community and an 80-word description of a person, theme or issue related to one or more of the above categories. Civics and citizenship 5.1 Explains social, political and cultural developments Civics and citizenship – 7 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 and events and evaluates their impact on Australian life 5.2 - Brainstorm a definition for the term ‘activist’ and write a list of well-publicised current causes that encompass some form of public protest or activism. For example environmental issues such as global warming, the hunting of whales, destruction of rainforests or the persistent discovery of asbestos in buildings. - Discuss the causes that were important in Australia in the 1960s and 1970s. Explain that this period of history has become viewed as a watershed when social structures and attitudes went through a period of significant change. - Investigate Jack Mundey and the Green Bans and have students research the impact of Green Bans on The Rocks precinct. - Instruct students in groups to construct a newspaper article or blog detailing some of the characters, issues and incidents involved in the fight for the cultural and environmental heritage of The Rocks. Topic for debate: That Green Bans should be stopped See: www.shfa.nsw.gov.au/.../4D6154E2-F54A5C1A-B041D5377E47ECAB.pdf explores, designs and responds to sustainability challenges through civic action e.g. Jack Mundey & BLF Green Bans People and power - Jack Mundey and BLF Green Bans Learning For Sustainability resource links Democracy Federation Gateway Civics and Citizenship education The Franklin Dam Assesses the impact of international events and relationships on Australia’s history 8 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Students investigate Australia’s international commitments through treaties and the United Nations e.g. UNHCR, UN Environment Program, Kyoto Protocol, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, etc. and carry out a cost benefit analysis. Divide the class into groups. Students use a table or mind map to identify and list the social, economic and environmental costs and benefits of the Australian international obligation being studied. Students assess how economic, social and environmental costs and benefits relate to one another? Which are more important and why Ownership and property rights 5.3 Explains the changing rights and freedoms of Aboriginal peoples and other groups in Australia Topic: Land Rights Focus Question: Do people have the power to change situations that are unjust? Investigation - students answer the following: Why did European settlers see the Aborigines as having no ownership of the land? Australia as a global citizen – examining mechanisms for global cooperation e.g. United Nations, Kyoto Protocol. Civics & Citizenship Civics in Practice The United Nations – lesson ideas Cost Benefit Analysis Australia as a Global Citizen Historical personalities, Eddie Mabo – evaluating systems of ownership and property rights that are fundamental to issues of sustainability e.g. Land Rights and Native Title Eddie Mabo & Native Title Frontier Education Online Native Title Mabo From your knowledge of Aboriginal culture explain the view Aborigines have of the land and why this differs from the European settlers' viewpoint? Roleplay: A mining company has proposed the construction 9 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 of a dam at an important Aboriginal site. They may very well get government approval. What is your response to this? a) Teacher divides students into four groups: Aboriginal community representatives; environmentalist lobby group; mining organisation; and Australian Government representatives to role-play about proposed mining on Aboriginal land. b) Each group is given a package of sources to support the point of view of their stakeholder group. Students are given time to analyse the sources and come up with responses. The student response needs to be in line with that of the stakeholder group to which they have been allocated. c) Teacher to act as mediator as the various stakeholders discuss their views on the proposed mining operation. Teacher can then insert a variety of situation changes, e.g. Human remains that could be 30,000 years old have been found at the site – does this change your point of view? d) Students write a response to the following from the points of view of two stakeholders (one must be the Aboriginal community representatives): 'What do you see as a possible solution to this 10 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 issue?' Economic systems and costs Native Title History of Economic Thought Water technologies Materials and production Built environment technologies Archaeology Dictionary of Sydney Canberra- An Ideal City? A Capital Choice Old New Land Build a Pyramid Transport Agriculture and food production Information and communication technologies Old New Land Repertoires of Practice World viewing Outcomes Values and Attitudes Systems thinking 5.4 Futures and design thinking Other Resources Sequences major historical events to show an understanding of continuity, change and causation Mitchell Library Connecting the Continent From Wireless to Web Learning for Sustainability What are My Values? The Dreaming Aboriginal Spirituality The People Rule The Abandoned City Year 7 & 8 Assessment & Work Samples Year 9 & 10 Assessment & Work Samples 11 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Saving our Heritage In 1974 protesting Sydney residents were responsible for delaying in excess of $3 000 million worth of development in the city. Examine the heritage of Kelly’s Bush and Susannah Place and collect evidence about the places, sites and issues of important heritage value to Australians. Susannah Place and Kelly's Bush Focus questions What do Susannah Place and Kelly’s Bush reveal about the influences on life in contemporary Australia? How do the influences revealed by these places contribute to our understanding of: the meanings of citizenship and civic participation in Australia; the role of governments in heritage preservation; past and present values of Australians towards preserving heritage? What is being preserved in these places; who decided what was important and should be kept; and how is it being done? The Green Ban period was a time when community groups mobilised to save parts of Sydney's built and natural environment. Verity Burgmann describes the background to the struggles: [It] is the story of the destruction of Australia’s major cities in the 1960s and early 1970s, when vast amounts of money were poured into property development: giant glass and concrete buildings changed the face of our cities and valuable old buildings were razed in the process. The interests of homebuyers and architectural heritage lost out before often purely speculative construction. At one 12 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 stage there were ten million square feet of office space in Sydney’s business district, while people looking for their first homes or flats could find nothing. Against this backdrop, 42 Green Bans were imposed in Sydney by 1974, holding up well over $3000 million worth of development. The Rocks area and Kelly’s Bush are places where community members acted to save Australia’s heritage from redevelopment. Susannah Place - 58-64 Gloucester Street, The Rocks, Sydney View Larger Map Kelly's Bush - Nelson Parade, Hunters Hill, Sydney View Larger Map 13 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Susannah Place Built in 1844, Susannah Place – located in The Rocks – is an example of the urban consolidation that occurred in Sydney during the 1840s. An early Victorian terrace row of four individual dwellings – including a corner shop – Susannah Place survived the demolitions that followed the outbreak of the plague in 1900. Resident resistance saved the row of terraces from demolition in the early 1970s. Susannah Place was saved from redevelopment when the Builders Labourers’ Federation (BLF) enforced a green-ban on the area. Green Bans were only imposed in areas where union action received community support; the bans represented an alliance between unionists and community activists.Susannah Place shopfront The Green Bans Movement began in 1971 with action to save Kelly’s Bush. Six hundred people attended a public meeting where they voiced opposition to AV Jennings building homes on native bushland on the foreshore of the Parramatta River. The action was spearheaded by a group of thirteen women – known as the ‘Battlers for Kelly’s Bush’ – and the Builders Labourers’ Federation. On 4 September 1983, the Premier of New South Wales announced that Kelly’s Bush would be set aside for full public access on a permanent basis. Acting to save Australia’s heritage protestors in Victoria Street 14 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Houses in Woolloomooloo being demolished in 1968 for the Eastern Suburbs railway. 15 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Memorial to the 25th anniversary of the world’s first Green Ban Investigating Heritage Susannah Place and Kelly’s Bush are linked to investigations focusing on heritage and environmental issues in Australian communities. Examine the images and text information relating to Susannah Place and Kelly’s Bush. What can the buildings, artefacts, landforms and vegetation tell us about the past? Look for evidence of technology, commerce, housing, townships and environment. Consider the recollections of those involved in the Green Bans. What did environmental activism in the 1970s represent to communities threatened by redevelopment? How did people decide what was worth preserving? What attitudes and values Memorial to the 20th anniversary of the world’s first Green Ban come through in the accounts of participants? Do you recognise any attitudes or assumptions that are evident in current heritage and environmental debates? Consider the perspectives presented on the Green Bans – what the movement stood for, the processes involved, the effectiveness of alliances, peoples recollections of the way actions were organised and evolved. What can these oral accounts tell us about the role of memory in reconstructing the past? Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of oral histories and testimonies. What other sources would you access to gain a fuller picture of the green-bans period? What can Kelly’s Bush and Susannah Place tell us about the experience of social change and environmental activism in Australia communities? 16 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Investigating Heritage and Citizenship Examine local newspapers and community newsletters (environmental group, local historical society, National Trust committee) for a current action in your locality aimed at saving part of the natural or built environment. Identify the key players in the discussion/debate and the main arguments being put forward. Access newspaper articles in the local media and local studies collection of your community library. Can you identify any links between the current issue and past discussions and actions in your community? What can you say about the way community members have viewed development in your locality over time? Consider the opposing arguments of key players in the issue under investigation. What are the main arguments for and against development? Invite individuals or group representatives to the school to present their position on the issue. What strategies for advocacy and action are they using? How have they interacted and worked with other community members over the issue? What are their predictions about future discussions and actions? Analyse the way issues are managed and strategic positions are developed in local area politics. Reflect on the opportunities for youth to participate in actions at the local government level. What strategies would you utilise to ensure young people had a voice in community decisions that impact on the environment and/or local heritage? Extension Debate the proposition “That Green Bans should be stopped” See: Sydney Harbour Foreshore ”Battle for the Rocks” Resource Pack 17 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Resources Plan of Kelly’s Bush Environmental Protest timeline Kath Lehany, Battlers for Kelly’s Bush Tracy Ireland, School of Archaeology, University of Sydney Protestors in Victoria Street[image] Demolition in Woolloomooloo [image] Kath Lehany’s perspective on Kelly’s Bush [transcript] Hunter's Hill Council’s perspective on Kelly’s Bush Chronology of the campaign to save Kelly’s Bush Perspective on Sydney’s green ban campaign, 1970-74 Bulldozers and people After the green bans Peter Garrett on crunch time for the harbour-city Robert Hughes on learning to value what is local Tour Susannah Place with Ann Toy Letters to the editor on the Kelly’s Bush issue Excerpts from Susannah Place oral histories Heritage challenges in light of concrete and glass The Sydney experience of conservation and modernity 18 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011 Sustainability Education policy for schools - Support document - History Stage 4 and 5 Extension activity Identify the central figure in this photograph. What was his role in the Battle for The Rocks? Why do you think he looks so relaxed? Why did the Builders Labourers Federation support preservation of the built environment of The Rocks? Write a sentence or two as a caption to this photograph. 19 © State of New South Wales through the NSW Department of Education and Communities, 2011