Review Questions for Chapter 10: Mantle Melting and the Generation of Basaltic Magma 1. Name as many sources of mantle samples as you can. 2. Use Figure 2.2c to describe the differences between dunite, harzburgite, and lherzolite. 15 Tholeiitic basalt Wt.% Al2O3 3. What does Fig. 10.1 suggest about the relationship between dunite, harzburgite, and lherzolite samples? 10 a rti Pa ing elt lM 5 um Lherzolite idu s ReHarzburgite 0 Dunite 0.0 T C o 0 1000 2000 3000 Plagioclase Spinel 0.2 0.4 Wt.% TiO2 0.6 Figure 10.1. From Brown and Mussett (1993). Liquid Garnet Lherzolite idus Liqu m ther 10 Depth (km) 200 Geo P (GPa) 5 400 15 Solid High-Pressure Phases us 20 600 Figure 10.2. Phase diagram of aluminous lherzolite with melting interval (gray), sub-solidus reactions, and geothermal gradient. 4. What features in Fig. 10.2 suggest that mantle melting is not a “normal” process in the “typical” Earth? 0.8 5. You described the REE diagrams on the left in the review questions in Chapter 9. Suppose you demonstrated that the two rocks represented primary melts. Using Fig. 10.2, what could you say about the depth of melting for each? Explain. 6. If melting is not a “normal” process, under what circumstances can it be accomplished? Note the principles and limitations for each method. 7. As H2O-undersaturated rocks are heated by burial along the shield geotherm in Fig. 10.6, what should occur at point d? Will any melt be generated? Why? If not, when will melt be generated, and why? 6 4 160 c R gw in g ie Sh ld he ot e g 1 a Oce 0 400 600 100 80 m 2 120 Depth (km) d ol e 140 o eo o d th O er c e m an amp hi b 3 H2O-s aturate P (GPa) us e ite p hlogop 5 d solid 180 r a b 60 rm he eot g n 800 40 1000 1200 1400 T oC Figure 10.6. Phase diagram (partly schematic) for a hydrous mantle system, including the H2O-saturated lherzolite solidus, the dehydration breakdown curves for amphibole and phlogopite, plus the ocean and shield geotherms. 8. As H2O-undersaturated rocks are heated by burial along the ocean geotherm in Fig. 10.6, what occurs at point a? Will any melt be generated? Why? If not, when will melt be generated, and why? 9. In our discussions of partial melting in conjunction with the ternary eutectic phase diagrams in Chapter 7, melting begins at the eutectic point and continues as melt increments are removed until what occurs? What happens as heating continues? How might such a process affect the termination of melting in some source area of the mantle? 10. In what principal ways does a tholeiitic basalt differ from an alkaline basalt? 11. Use Figures 7.27, 9.3 and 10.8 to suggest three plausible ways that might tend to yield an alkaline basalt rather than a tholeiite by partial melting of a chemically homogeneous mantle. (there is more room on the next page, if required) 10 8 Rb 6 4 2 Sr 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 F Figure 9.3. Change in the concentration of Rb and Sr in the melt derived by progressive batch melting of a basaltic rock. Nepheline E 3 GPa Volatile-Free Jadeite E 2 GPa E 1 GPa Albite Figure 7.27. Effect of volatiles on the ternary eutectic point (minimum melt composition) in the system FoNe-SiO2 at 2 GPa. Highly undersaturated (nepheline-bearing) alkaline basalts E 1 atm d ate tur salts a s a r de c b Un leiiti o h t Forsterite Enstatite Oversaturated (quartz-bearing) tholeiitic basalts Silica Figure 10.8. Change in the eutectic (first melt) composition with increasing pressure from 1 to 3 GPa projected onto the base of the basalt tetrahedron. All but the low-T ends of cotectic curves have been omitted to avoid clutter. 12. Although it is possible to derive both tholeiites and alkaline basalts via partial melting of a chemically homogeneous mantle, and “Ockham’s razor” (or the “law of parsimony”) suggests that such a simple explanation is most likely to be correct, what about Fig. 10.13 below suggests that the mantle is not a chemically uniform “fertile” mantle? 1000 a. Rock/Chondrite Rare Earth Elements 100 OIB 10 MORB 1 La Ce Pr Nd PmSm Eu Gd Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu 1000 b. Spider Diagram Rock/Chondrite OIB 100 10 MORB 1 Rb Ba Th U Nb Ta K La Ce Sr NdSm Zr Ti Gd Y Figure 10.13. REE diagram (a) and spider diagram (b) of a typical alkaline ocean island basalt (OIB) and tholeiitic mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB). 13. The “Mantle Array” in Figure 10.15a below shows the common range of isotopic analyses for oceanic island basalts. These basalts represent relatively primitive mantle melts from throughout the ocean basins, where the contaminating effects of thick ancient continental crust is not a factor. What would be the simplest model for the sub-oceanic mantle that could explain the narrow linear array? Explain how such a model could produce the array. You may want to refer to your answers to review questions 9.46, 9.47, and 9.51 on Sr and Nd isotopes. 14. Discuss the relative merits of the whole-mantle vs. two-layer convection models.