Aggravated phosphorus limitation on biomass production
under increasing nitrogen loading: a meta-analysis
Yong Li, Shuli Niu*, Guirui Yu
The following Supporting Information is available for this article:
Fig. S1 Response of leaf N concentration to P addition.
Table S1 Papers included in this study for establishing the database.
(a)
(b)
Mean
Tropical forest
Grassland
Tundra
Wetland
0.97(104)
0.97(71)
0.96(50)
1.04(13)
0.97(17)
1.03(18)
0.94(13)
0.90(19)
1.02(17)
0.99(20)
NaH2PO4
Ca(H2PO4)2
1.03(5)
1.01(5)
0.97(72)
0.92(37)
<5 g m-2
5-10 g m-2
10-15 g m-2
>15 g m-2
0.96(30)
0.97(39)
1.02(10)
0.98(25)
0.93(29)
1.03(23)
0.92(6)
1.00(13)
≤ 3 yr
>3 yr
0.98(83)
1.00(55)
0.95(21)
0.87(15)
Herbaceous
Woody
0.96(38)
0.98(43)
0.92(34)
1.03(16)
.4
.6
.8
1.0
Response ratio
1.2
1.4
.4
.6
.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Response ratio
Fig. S1 Responses of leaf N concentration to P addition. (a) only P addition, and (b) P
plus N addition (N addition was considered as control and P+N addition as P treatment).
The dot with error bars indicates the mean effect size with the 95% CI.
Table S1 Papers included in this study for establishing the database.
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
References
Aerts R, Berendse F (1988) The effect of increased nutrient availability on vegetation
dynamics in wet heathlands. Vegetatio, 76, 63-69.
Anisfeld S, Hill T (2012) Fertilization Effects on Elevation Change and Belowground Carbon
Balance in a Long Island Sound Tidal Marsh. Estuaries and Coasts, 35, 201-211.
Barger N, D'antonio C, Ghneim T, Cuevas E (2003) Constraints to colonization and growth of
the African grass, Melinis minutiflora, in a Venezuelan savanna. Plant Ecology, 167, 31-43.
Barger NN, D'antonio CM, Ghneim T, Brink K, Cuevas E (2002) Nutrient Limitation to Primary
Productivity in a Secondary Savanna in Venezuela1. Biotropica, 34, 493-501
Bennett LT, Adams MA (2001) Response of a perennial grassland to nitrogen and
phosphorus additions in sub-tropical, semi-arid Australia. Journal of Arid Environments, 48,
289-308.
Blair BC, Perfecto I (2008) Root proliferation and nutrient limitations in a Nicaraguan rain
forest. Caribbean Journal of Science, 44, 36-42
Boelman NT, Stieglitz M, Rueth HM, Sommerkorn M, Griffin KL, Shaver GR, Gamon JA
(2003) Response of NDVI, biomass, and ecosystem gas exchange to long-term warming and
fertilization in wet sedge tundra. Oecologia, 135, 414-421.
Bowman WD, Theodose TA, Schardt JC, Conant RT (1993) Constraints of Nutrient
Availability on Primary Production in Two Alpine Tundra Communities. Ecology, 74, 20852097.
Bret-Harte MS, Garc a EA, Sacr VM, Whorley JR, Wagner JL, Lippert SC, Chapin FS (2004)
Plant and soil responses to neighbour removal and fertilization in Alaskan tussock tundra.
Journal of Ecology, 92, 635-647.
Chalmers A, Mcintyre S, Whalley RDB, Reid N (2005) Grassland species response to soil
disturbance and nutrient enrichment on the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales.
Australian Journal of Botany, 53, 485-499.
Cleveland CC, Townsend AR (2006) Nutrient additions to a tropical rain forest drive
substantial soil carbon dioxide losses to the atmosphere. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 103, 10316-10321.
Corbin J, Avis P, Wilbur R (2003) The role of phosphorus availability in the response of soil
nitrogen cycling, understory vegetation and arbuscular mycorrhizal inoculum potential to
elevated nitrogen inputs. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 147, 141-162.
Craine JM, Morrow C, Stock WD (2008) Nutrient concentration ratios and co-limitation in
South African grasslands. New Phytologist, 179, 829-836
D'antonio CM, Mack MC (2006) Nutrient Limitation in a Fire-derived, Nitrogen-rich Hawaiian
Grassland1. Biotropica, 38, 458-467.
Davidson EA, Carvalho CJRD, Vieira ICG et al. (2004) Nitrogen and phosphorus limitation of
biomass growth in a tropical secondary forest. Ecological Applications, 14, S150-S163.
Feller I, Mckee K, Whigham D, O'neill J (2003) Nitrogen vs. phosphorus limitation across an
ecotonal gradient in a mangrove forest. Biogeochemistry, 62, 145-175.
Feller IC (1995) Effects of Nutrient Enrichment on Growth and Herbivory of Dwarf Red
Mangrove (Rhizophora Mangle). Ecological Monographs, 65, 477-505.
Fynn RWS, O'connor TG (2005) Determinants of community organization of a South African
mesic grassland. Journal of Vegetation Science, 16, 93-102.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
Güsewell S, Koerselman W, Verhoeven JTA (2002) Time-dependent effects of fertilization on
plant biomass in floating fens. Journal of Vegetation Science, 13, 705-718.
Güsewell S, Koerselman W, Verhoeven JTA (2003) Biomass N:P ratios as indicators of
nutrients limitation for plant populations in wetlands. Ecological Applications, 13, 372-384
Gleeson SK, Good RE (2003) Root allocation and multiple nutrient limitation in the New
Jersey Pinelands. Ecology Letters, 6, 220-227
Gleeson SK, Good RE (2010) Root growth response to water and nutrients in the New Jersey
Pinelands. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 40, 167-172
Gordon C, Wynn JM, Woodin SJ (2001) Impacts of increased nitrogen supply on high Arctic
heath: the importance of bryophytes and phosphorus availability. New Phytologist, 149, 461471
Gower S, Vitousek P (1989) Effects of nutrient amendments on fine root biomass in a primary
successional forest in Hawai'i. Oecologia, 81, 566-568
Grogan P, Chapin FS, Iii (2000) Nitrogen limitation of production in a Californianannual
grassland: The contribution of arbuscularmycorrhizae. Biogeochemistry, 49, 37-51
Haag RW (1974) Nutrient limitations to plant production in two tundra communities. Canadian
Journal of Botany, 52, 103-116
Harcombe PA (1977) The Influence of Fertilization on Some Aspects of Succession in a
Humid Tropical Forest. Ecology, 58, 1375-1383
Helmisaari H-S, Hallbäcken L (1999) Fine-root biomass and necromass in limed and fertilized
Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) stands. Forest Ecology and Management, 119, 99110
Herbert D, Fownes J (1995) Phosphorus limitation of forest leaf area and net primary
production on a highly weathered soil. Biogeochemistry, 29, 223-235
Herbert DA, Fownes JH, Vitousek PM (1999) Hurricane Damage to a Hawaiian Forest:
Nutrient Supply Rate Affects Resistance and Resilience. Ecology, 80, 908-920
Hobbs RJ, Gulmon SL, Hobbs VJ, Mooney HA (1988) Effects of fertiliser addition and
subsequent gopher disturbance on a serpentine annual grassland community. Oecologia, 75,
291-295
Huenneke LF, Hamburg SP, Koide R, Mooney HA, Vitousek PM (1990) Effects of Soil
Resources on Plant Invasion and Community Structure in Californian Serpentine Grassland.
Ecology, 71, 478-491
Jefferies RL, Perkins N (1977) The Effects on the Vegetation of the Additions of Inorganic
Nutrients to Salt Marsh Soils at Stiffkey, Norfolk. Journal of Ecology, 65, 867-882
Kiehl K, Esselink P, Bakker JP (1997) Nutrient limitation and plant species composition in
temperate salt marshes. Oecologia, 111, 325-330
Kirkham FW, Mountford JO, Wilkins RJ (1996) The Effects of Nitrogen, Potassium and
Phosphorus Addition on the Vegetation of a Somerset Peat Moor Under Cutting
Management. Journal of Applied Ecology, 33, 1013-1029
Koide RT, Huenneke LF, Hamburg SP, Mooney HA (1988) Effects of Applications of
Fungicide, Phosphorus and Nitrogen on the Structure and Productivity of an Annual
Serpentine Plant Community. Functional Ecology, 2, 335-344
Lawrence D (2001) Nitrogen and phosphorus enhance growth and luxury consumption of four
secondary forest tree species in Borneo. Journal of Tropical Ecology, 17, 859-869
Mcgroddy ME, Silver WL, De Oliveira RC, De Mello WZ, Keller M (2008) Retention of
phosphorus in highly weathered soils under a lowland Amazonian forest ecosystem. Journal
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences, 113, G04012
Mckell CM, Goodin C, Perrier E (1959) Annual range fertilization in relation to soil moisture
depletion. Journal of Range Management Archives, 12, 189-193
Mirmanto E, Proctor J, Green J, Nagy L, Suriantata (1999) Effects of Nitrogen and
Phosphorus Fertilization in a Lowland Evergreen Rainforest. Philosophical Transactions:
Biological Sciences, 354, 1825-1829
Newbery DM, Chuyong GB, Green JJ, Songwe NC, Tchuenteu F, Zimmermann L (2002)
Does low phosphorus supply limit seedling establishment and tree growth in groves of
ectomycorrhizal trees in a central African rainforest? New Phytologist, 156, 297-311
Ngai JT, Jefferies RL (2004) Nutrient limitation of plant growth and forage quality in Arctic
coastal marshes. Journal of Ecology, 92, 1001-1010
Niinemets , Kull K (2005) Co-limitation of plant primary productivity by nitrogen and
phosphorus in a species-rich wooded meadow on calcareous soils. Acta Oecologica, 28, 345356
Øien D-I (2004) Nutrient limitation in boreal rich-fen vegetation: A fertilization experiment.
Applied Vegetation Science, 7, 119-132
Olde Venterink H, Van Der Vliet RE, Wassen MJ (2001) Nutrient limitation along a
productivity gradient in wet meadows. Plant and Soil, 234, 171-179
Ostertag R (2001) Effects of Nitrogen and Phosphorus Availability on Fine-Root Dynamics in
Hawaiian Montane Forests. Ecology, 82, 485-499
Pauli D, Peintinger M, Schmid B (2002) Nutrient enrichment in calcareous fens: effects on
plant species and community structure. Basic and Applied Ecology, 3, 255-266
Pietikäinen A, Kytöviita MM, Vuoti U (2005) Mycorrhiza and seedling establishment in a
subarctic meadow: Effects of fertilization and defoliation. Journal of Vegetation Science, 16,
175-182
Raich J, Russell A, Crews T, Farrington H, Vitousek P (1996) Both nitrogen and phosphorus
limit plant production on young Hawaiian lava flows. Biogeochemistry, 32, 1-14
Rejmánková E (2001) Effect of experimental phosphorus enrichment on oligotrophic tropical
marshes in Belize, Central America. Plant and Soil, 236, 33-53
Sarmiento G, Da Silva MP, Naranjo ME, Pinillos M (2006) Nitrogen and phosphorus as
limiting factors for growth and primary production in a flooded savanna in the Venezuelan
Llanos. Journal of Tropical Ecology, 22, 203-212
Scowcroft PG, Silva JA (2005) Effects of phosphorus fertilization, seed source, and soil type
on growth of Acacia koa. Journal of Plant Nutrition, 28, 1581-1603
Shaver GR, Bret-Harte MS, Jones MH, Johnstone J, Gough L, Laundre J, Chapin FS, Iii
(2001) Species Composition Interacts with Fertilizer to Control Long-Term Change in Tundra
Productivity. Ecology, 82, 3163-3181
Soudzilovskaia NA, Onipchenko VG, Cornelissen JHC, Aerts R (2005) Biomass production,
N:P ratio and nutrient limitation in a Caucasian alpine tundra plant community. Journal of
Vegetation Science, 16, 399-406
Stark S, Grellmann D (2002) Soil Microbial Responses to Herbivory in an Arctic Tundra Heath
at Two Levels of Nutrient Availability. Ecology, 83, 2736-2744
Stevens GN, Jones RH (2006) Patterns in soil fertility and root herbivory interact to influence
fine-root dynamics. Ecology, 87, 616-624
Tanner EVJ, Kapos V, Franco W (1992) Nitorgen and Phosphorus Fertilization Effects on
Venezuelan Montane Forest Trunk Growth and Litterfall. Ecology, 73, 78-86
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
Tanner EVJ, Kapos V, Freskos S, Healey JR, Theobald AM (1990) Nitrogen and Phosphorus
Fertilization of Jamaican Montane Forest Trees. Journal of Tropical Ecology, 6, 231-238
Turitzin SN (1982) Nutrient Limitations to Plant Growth in a California Serpentine Grassland.
American Midland Naturalist, 107, 95-99
Van Der Hoek D, Van Mierlo Anita JEM, Van Groenendael JM (2004) Nutrient limitation and
nutrient-driven shifts in plant species composition in a species-rich fen meadow. Journal of
Vegetation Science, 15, 389-396
Van Wijnen HJ, Bakker JP (1999) Nitrogen and phosphorus limitation in a coastal barrier salt
marsh: the implications for vegetation succession. Journal of Ecology, 87, 265-272
Verhoeven JTA, Schmitz MB (1991) Control of Plant Growth by Nitrogen and Phosphorus in
Mesotrophic Fens. Biogeochemistry, 12, 135-148
Vitousek P, Farrington H (1997) Nutrient limitation and soil development: Experimental test of
a biogeochemical theory. Biogeochemistry, 37, 63-75
Vitousek P, Walker L, Whiteaker L, Matson P (1993) Nutrient limitations to plant growth
during primary succession in Hawaii Volcanoes National Park. Biogeochemistry, 23, 197-215
Willems JH, Peet RK, Bik L (1993) Changes in chalk-grassland structure and species
richness resulting from selective nutrient additions. Journal of Vegetation Science, 4, 203-212