Jennifer Wiley IST 605 Jill Hurst-Wahl 12/2/2010 Pathfinder: Gothic Architecture in Bird Library Gothic Architecture This is a guide for finding information on Gothic architecture in the resources available through Bird Library. Gothic architecture is a medieval style of architecture, most commonly associated with cathedrals, abbeys, and churches. The size and style of these designs were used by architects as a way of conveying the glory of God and ornamental pieces often depicted Biblical imagery. The buildings are known for their scale and the great amount of detail and ornament put into each one. The Gothic architecture movement was very focused on how the building could use it’s physical structure to effect the emotions of the masses. Some terms to keep in mind: Architectural drawings: technical drawings. These include floor plans, cutaways, elevations, etc. Sub-styles: specific trends within the Gothic movement. These can be defined by region, by time period, or by aesthetic trends. Gothic Revival: an architectural movement in the late 1700’s when designers brought back many of the elements of Gothic architecture. General Information Bird Library offers a wealth of resources on the topic of Gothic architecture. Here is a variety of the books and online databases available through Bird that will supply good information for the overall subject of Gothic architecture. Print Resources Bumpus, T. F. (1914). A guide to Gothic architecture. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. This book provides in depth explanations of the relationships between architecture, art, and religion as well as discussing the effects of these relationships on the general public and the development of classification systems. This subject matter would be especially valuable to anyone wishing to understand the cultural significance of the Gothic architecture movement. The author divides the contents by sub-styles of Gothic and provides a glossary of terms in the back, creating an easy method of both searching and understanding of basic terminology. Plates throughout the book also provide good visual aids with photographs as well as a variety of architectural drawings. Lesser, G. (1957). Gothic cathedrals and sacred geometry. London: A. Tiranti. This book studies the symbolism created by the technical designs implemented by the architects of Gothic architecture. It describes how the specific shapes and proportions were believed to be significant to the holiness of the space within the cathedrals. Lesser provides architectural drawings of specific buildings with the proportions and math marked out as well as equations for the geometry being described. He also takes the time to acknowledge arguments that could be made against his conclusions and attempts to respond to them clearly. This would be a good source for anyone interested in understanding how the architects used technical elements to create an emotional effect on the public. Mark, R. (1982). Experiments in Gothic structure. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. This book provides an engineering perspective of architecture instead of the artistic or historical perspective that is more commonly used. Mark analyzes collapses and repairs to explain the development of the style with specific examination of structural elements including buttresses, vaulting, etc. The analysis is accompanied by lots of photographs and illustrations of actual buildings as well as images of models being tested under environmental experiments. Mark also provided a split glossary divided into engineering terms and architectural terms. This would be a good source for anyone looking to better understand the development of the structure of Gothic architecture. Parker, J. H. (1881). An introduction to the study of Gothic architecture (6th ed.). Oxford: Parker. This book provides a focus on how the combination of time and location effected the development of Gothic architecture, dividing the contents by sub-styles including differing countries, differing centuries, and differing aesthetics (Chapter 2 explains these divisions). Parker included detailed illustrations of architectural elements throughout and a glossary in the back. This would be a valuable resource for anyone interested at looking at the scope of Gothic architecture. Roritzer, M., Shelby, L. R., & Schmuttermayer, H. (1977). Gothic design techniques :The fifteenth-century design booklets of mathes roriczer and hanns schmuttermayer. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. This book provides a focus on the architects instead of the architecture, describing what they were doing or what they thought they were doing. In this medium, the authors describe the history of the field of architecture around the middle ages, focusing specifically on the significance of Gothic architecture. Two booklets translated from German are included in the book with the translations running parallel to one another that provide how-to’s for architects, focusing on the importance of geometry and providing lots of illustrations. A glossary of terms (mostly for German) is provided at the back to help understand the technical terminology. This would be a good source for any one curious about the men behind the buildings and about the technical aspects. von Simson, O. G. (1956). The gothic cathedral: Origins of gothic architecture and the medieval concept of order. New York: Pantheon Books. This book looks at the symbolism of Gothic architecture and medieval significance of art and architecture. Chapters are dedicated to specific buildings, elements of Gothic design, and general history with sections divided to emphasize the general design, the beginnings of the movement, and the ultimate end which allows for easy browsing of the subject. Plates are included throughout with photographs of actual buildings, architectural drawings, and images of religious manuscripts that reflect the presence of Gothic style in more than just the architecture of the time. This is a good resource for looking at the Gothic movement as a whole. Databases EbscoHost (n.d.) Avery Index to Architectural Periodicals [electronic]. Ipswich, MA: ebscohost.com. Available through SU library subscription. This database offers a collection of written works concerning Gothic architecture going all the way back to the late 1700’s through today. EbscoHost allows a user to narrow the field by century, specific year, language, and more. It also provides full text articles in many cases, another option that can specified in the advanced search. A user also is also able to save articles to a folder to save while searching for additional works. This is a good source for a variety of users. ARTstor (n.d.) ARTstor [electronic]. New York, NY: artstor.org. Available through SU library subscription. This database offers a variety of images of Gothic architecture buildings. The captions include information such as location, years during which it was built, measurements of the building, and a brief description of the building. Often a link to further information is also provided. This is a good resource for getting introduced to the concept of Gothic architecture and understanding specific examples a little better. Internet Resources Gothic art and architecture. (2010). Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.gothic-architecture.com/ This is an entire website dedicated to Gothic art and architecture. Quick links are provided on the left side including such topics as origins, differing sub-styles, specific buildings, specific regions, and Gothic Revival. There is an additional link for glossary terms on the right side that remains no matter what other link you click. This is a good resource for both general and specific topic browsing. Martindale, A. H. R. (n.d.). Gothic art and architecture. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://history-world.org/gothic_art_and_architecture.htm This website was written by a professor of visual arts in England. Though it does not provide very many images, it does discuss the Gothic movement from start to finish in a concise format that may be more desirable to some users than an entire book. Topics include styles of various regions, a variety of technical elements, classifications of sub-styles, and the men involved in the works. This is a good introductory material. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. (2010). Gothic art. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/mgot/hd_mgot.htm This page is from the Metropolitan Museum of Art and includes a good amount of images. It discusses briefly the history of the movement as well as it’s effects on European culture. Most valuable here is the use of links within the text that bring up specific images to provide a quick reference system. This is a good introductory source. Ornamentation Gothic architecture is known for its elaborate detail, the specifics of which are often very useful in dating buildings and figuring out what masons and architects were associated with them. For information specific to the ornamentation, try these resources. Print Resources Paley, F. A., & Fawcett, W. M. (1902). A manual of Gothic moldings :With directions for copying them and for determining their dates (6th ed.). Cleveland: C. W. Kuehny. This book offers a thorough introduction to the subject of Gothic ornamentation. The authors discuss the methodology used for creating the pieces and include both typical measurements and a variety of drawings throughout, often showing comparisons in style. At the end of the book are also included a collection of plates showing a wide range of comparisons of different types of moldings. The contents are divided by the elements that would have contained the moldings (columns, bases, capitals, etc) and types of moldings (decorative, perpendicular, etc) which makes browsing easy. This is a good source for understanding the importance and differences within these smaller pieces of architecture. Pugin, A., & Pugin, A. W. N. (1916). Gothic ornaments, selected from various ancient buildings in England and France, exhibiting numerous specimens of every description of decorative detail(A new a rev ed.). London: J. Tiranti and company. This book would be best to be used purely as supplement to existing research, but is a valuable supplement. It is comprised entirely of images of the variety of ornaments used in Gothic architecture. Often the images are very large to allow for better examination of the finer details incorporated within these ornaments and captions including location of buildings that offer specific examples could help understand regional differences. Through this medium, the authors give a good idea of the true scope and design of the details that partly define Gothic architecture. Though, again, best for supplemental research, this is a good source for better understanding the visual aspects of Gothic design. By Region Gothic architecture was used across Europe. If you are interested in the architecture by country, here are a few good places to look. Print Resources Arslan, E. (1972). Gothic architecture in Venice [Venezia gotica.English]. London: Phaidon; distributed by Praeger, New York. This book takes on the unusual task of focusing on the Gothic buildings that were secular in nature. It does a very good job, however, of discussing the relationship of the Gothic architecture in Venice to the Gothic architecture in the rest of Europe. There is a great deal of focus on the details of Venetian design accompanied by a many large plates and illustrations. The contents are organized chronologically with discussion of history being present throughout. This is a good source for understanding how Venice contributed to the Gothic movement. Bond, F. (1906). Gothic architecture in England;an analysis of the origin & development of English church architecture from the Norman conquest to the dissolution of the monasteries. London: B. T. Batsford. This book does an exceptional job of explaining the tiny parts that together create the overall Gothic design. It includes definitions of general architecture vs. early Christian architecture vs. Romanesque architecture vs. Gothic architecture and emphasizes the relationship between Romanesque and Gothic (Romanesque being the predecessor to Gothic). There is also a great deal of discussion concerning the skeletal structure of Gothic buildings with lots of pictures and illustrations of details throughout. Finally, Bond included a glossary of terms as well as indexes divided by illustrations, location of buildings, and subject matter. This is a good source for in depth study into English Gothic. Crossley, P. (1985). Gothic architecture in the reign of Kashmir the Great : Church architecture in Lesser Poland, 1320-1380. Kraków: Ministerstwo Kultury i Sztuki, Zarza?d Muzeów i Ochrony Zabytków. This book goes into thorough discussion of how Polish society effected the Gothic movement as well as how the Gothic movement effect Polish and European history. Within the discussions, Crossley also included maps and plates depicting architectural drawings and photographs, focusing both on specific buildings and general architectural designs. This is a good source for understanding the relationship between culture and architecture as a give and take. Jackson, T. G. (1915). Gothic architecture in France, England, and Italy. Cambridge Eng.: University Press. This work divided between two volumes discusses specific buildings in each of the three countries as well as discussing how the countries influenced each other. Greater attention is paid to the relationship between England and France. There are a great deal of illustrations and plates throughout and Jackson included annotations in the margins beside the text to call attention to specific topics. This is a good source for understanding not only the unique qualities of each the French, English, and Italian Gothics, but also the ways in which they related to and effected to one another. Street, G. E., & King, G. G. (1914). Some account of Gothic architecture in Spain. London; Toronto: J.M. Dent & Sons, ltd. This work, also divided between two volumes, describes the important Gothic buildings across Spain through the perspective of a traveler, with the drawings actually being done by the author himself during his own travels. The contents are organized by regions within Spain. In volume two, the author adds a general summary to classify the buildings more generally in terms of history and style instead of region and provides some history about Spanish Gothic architects. This is a good source for understanding Spanish Gothic, a subject often left out of other works. Specific Buildings If you are looking for something a little more specific, here are some good resources concerning only one building at a time. Print Resources Branner, R., & Branner, S. P. (1989). The cathedral of Borges and its place in Gothic architecture. New York, N.Y.: Architectural History Foundation. This book provides a unique perspective as the author himself contributed to hands on excavation work at the site of Borges. Included is a discussion of the building’s historic significance to the Gothic movement and a timeline of the life of the cathedral, including findings of physical evidence. Illustrations throughout include architectural drawings and detail photographs emphasizing Gothic design elements. This is a good source for studying not only the history of the cathedral of Borges but also for understanding the importance of the smaller elements. Internet Resources Cathedrale Notre Dame Paris. (2010). Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/ This is a website dedicated exclusively to the Cathedral of Notre Dame. Links are provided in both French and English and include such topics as building history and architectural elements as well as specific artistic elements including paintings, sculptures, and stain-glass windows. It also provides a variety of views of the cathedral. Finally, a link to a kid friendly site is provided which introduces children to the physical building, the history of the cathedral, and different things that happen at the cathedral. This is a great source for some one interested in very detailed information about Notre Dame. King's College Cambridge. (n.d.) Chapel. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.kings.cam.ac.uk/chapel/index.html This site is part of Cambridge University’s King College website. The chapel is part of the college. The site includes images of the chapel as well as information including it’s history as well as present day information including times the chapel is open and activities available at the chapel. The building of the chapel spanned many decades, being haulted for several wars in between. The history given on this website divides itself over the ruling king at the time and goes on to discuss the masons involved. This is a good source for understanding how the chapel fit into British history and for understanding how individual people were involved in it’s creation. Ready Reference Resources For quick, concise information. Print Resources Curl, J. S., & Sambrook, J. J. (1999). A dictionary of architecture. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press. This dictionary includes entries on Gothic, Gothic Revival, Gothic Survival and Gothick (a style vaguely based on Gothic) as well as many entries covering the specific elements of Gothic design. The entries do a good job of packing a lot of information concisely and some illustrations are included for more detailed elements. Most importantly, this is a dictionary specifically designed to make architectural terminology accessible to students and the general public. This is a good source for anyone studying Gothic architecture, especially if you are new to the subject. Harris, C. M. (1977). Historic architecture sourcebook. New York: McGraw-Hill. This sourcebook includes a great deal of illustrations throughout the entries, including interior and exterior views of typical Gothic style. The illustrations even go so far as to point our specific elements of the designs including the nave, the aisle, the clerestory, the pinnacle, the spire, flying buttresses and many more. There is discussion of the differences between countries, with separate entries for Gothic Revival and Gothic Survival. All the entries are short and to the point, but still provide the vital information. This is a very good source for quickly understanding everything that goes into Gothic design. Internet Resources Vadnal, J. (1997). Glossary of medieval art and architecture. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.pitt.edu/~medart/menuglossary/Index.htm This web page is offered through the University of Pittsburgh. The author has compiled an in depth glossary of terms associated with medieval art and architecture, many of which would apply to the Gothic movement. Provided are links to the first letter of a word you are looking for to make searching easier. Vadnal also provided links within the definitions to related words in her glossary. This is a good source for quickly looking up technical terms. For Scholars These resources would best serve scholars looking for in depth research. Print Resources Arslan, E. (1972). Gothic architecture in Venice [Venezia gotica.English]. London: Phaidon; distributed by Praeger, New York. Bond, F. (1906). Gothic architecture in England;an analysis of the origin & development of English church architecture from the Norman conquest to the dissolution of the monasteries. London: B. T. Batsford. Branner, R., & Branner, S. P. (1989). The cathedral of Borges and its place in Gothic architecture. New York, N.Y.: Architectural History Foundation. Bumpus, T. F. (1914). A guide to Gothic architecture. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. Crossley, P. (1985). Gothic architecture in the reign of Kashmir the Great : Church architecture in Lesser Poland, 1320-1380. Kraków: Ministerstwo Kultury i Sztuki, Zarza?d Muzeów i Ochrony Zabytków. Jackson, T. G. (1915). Gothic architecture in France, England, and Italy. Cambridge Eng.: University Press. Lesser, G. (1957). Gothic cathedrals and sacred geometry. London: A. Tiranti. Mark, R. (1982). Experiments in Gothic structure. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. Paley, F. A., & Fawcett, W. M. (1902). A manual of Gothic moldings :With directions for copying them and for determining their dates (6th ed.). Cleveland: C. W. Kuehny. Parker, J. H. (1881). An introduction to the study of Gothic architecture (6th ed.). Oxford: Parker. Pugin, A., & Pugin, A. W. N. (1916). Gothic ornaments, selected from various ancient buildings in England and France, exhibiting numerous specimens of every description of decorative detail(A new a rev ed.). London: J. Tiranti and company. Roritzer, M., Shelby, L. R., & Schmuttermayer, H. (1977). Gothic design techniques :The fifteenth-century design booklets of mathes roriczer and hanns schmuttermayer. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. Street, G. E., & King, G. G. (1914). Some account of Gothic architecture in Spain. London; Toronto: J.M. Dent & Sons, ltd. von Simson, O. G. (1956). The gothic cathedral: Origins of gothic architecture and the medieval concept of order. New York: Pantheon Books. Databases EbscoHost (n.d.) Avery Index to Architectural Periodicals [electronic]. Ipswich, MA: ebscohost.com. Available through SU library subscription. Internet Resources Cathedrale Notre Dame Paris. (2010). Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/ King's College Cambridge. (n.d.) Chapel. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.kings.cam.ac.uk/chapel/index.html The Metropolitan Museum of Art. (2010). Gothic art. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/mgot/hd_mgot.htm For Casual Users These resources would be of better use to a casual user looking for in depth information. Print Resources Arslan, E. (1972). Gothic architecture in Venice [Venezia gotica.English]. London: Phaidon; distributed by Praeger, New York. Bond, F. (1906). Gothic architecture in England;an analysis of the origin & development of English church architecture from the Norman conquest to the dissolution of the monasteries. London: B. T. Batsford. Bumpus, T. F. (1914). A guide to Gothic architecture. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. Jackson, T. G. (1915). Gothic architecture in France, England, and Italy. Cambridge Eng.: University Press. Lesser, G. (1957). Gothic cathedrals and sacred geometry. London: A. Tiranti. Paley, F. A., & Fawcett, W. M. (1902). A manual of Gothic moldings :With directions for copying them and for determining their dates (6th ed.). Cleveland: C. W. Kuehny. Parker, J. H. (1881). An introduction to the study of Gothic architecture (6th ed.). Oxford: Parker. von Simson, O. G. (1956). The gothic cathedral: Origins of gothic architecture and the medieval concept of order. New York: Pantheon Books. Databases ARTstor (n.d.) ARTstor [electronic]. New York, NY: artstor.org. Available through SU library subscription. Internet Resources Cathedrale Notre Dame Paris. (2010). Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/ Gothic art and architecture. (2010). Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.gothic-architecture.com/ King's College Cambridge. (n.d.) Chapel. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://www.kings.cam.ac.uk/chapel/index.html Martindale, A. H. R. (n.d.). Gothic art and architecture. Retrieved November 12, 2010, from http://history-world.org/gothic_art_and_architecture.htm