1 Forest Wildlife (0403) & Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement (0404) Program Review 2011-12 OVERVIEW: A. Introduction to the Department and Discipline The Department of Natural Sciences offers Bachelor of Arts and Sciences degrees as preparation for a range of professional careers. Majors are offered in Biology, Botany, Cell & Molecular Biology, Chemistry, Forest/Wildlife, Forest/Wildlife Law Enforcement, General Science, Medical Technology, Science Education, and Zoology. Minors are offered in Biology, Botany, Cell & Molecular Biology, Chemistry, Geology, and Zoology. Pre-professional programs are offered for students interested in careers in dentistry, engineering, forestry, medicine, or pharmacy. Additionally, the Department offers courses that fulfill the general education lab science requirements for all other majors on campus. The faculty of the Department of Natural Sciences includes 5 biologists, 2 chemists and 1 geologist. Staff support includes a lab director in Biology, a lab director in Physical Science, and an administrative secretary. The Forest Wildlife Major requires no additional faculty, administrative time, library resources, clerical staff, space or equipment over and above those required by other major and minor programs in the department. As such, it is a no-cost program alternative for students wishing to become Forest Wildlife Majors. The Biology Discipline offers students at WNMU six alternative majors depending on the students’ professional and career goals. The Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement majors are suitable for students wishing to pursue careers working with agencies, state and federal, that focus on land resource management, administration of public lands, wildlife biology, and conservation officers. The Forest Wildlife Major also prepares students for post-graduate Master’s and PhD programs focusing on management of natural resources. B. History of Programs The Forest Wildlife Major (BA or BS) got its start during the 1993-94 academic year. During that same year, dedicated Botany and Zoology degrees were initiated. Prior to AY 1993-94 biology students could major only in Biology with minors in Botany and Zoology. While the Forest Wildlife Major was most similar to the Biology Major in that it offered a balance of zoology and botany courses, while minimizing the number of suborganismal courses (Cell and Molecular Biology) found in the Biology Major. The Forest Wildlife Major quickly attracted several new students, primarily those wishing to pursue careers with natural resource agencies. Overall, new degree programs initiated during AY 1993-94 provided students with greater latitude in academic studies within biology. The Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement version of the Forest Wildlife Major began during the 2004-05 academic year. The Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement, a Bachelor's of Applied Science, sprang from the success of the Forest Wildlife Major, but incorporated the Police Academy in 2 the place of a minor. Students taking this option completed the Police Academy as part of their degree and graduated as certifiable law enforcement officers for certain state law enforcement agencies. Many students wishing to pursue careers as Conservation or Wildlife Law Enforcement Officers choose this degree. Graduates could accept law enforcement positions with the New Mexico Department of Game and Fish or New Mexico State Parks without attending additional law enforcement certification training. The numbers of students taking advantage of the Forest Wildlife Program has remained robust since its inception even though new programs, Cellular & Molecular Biology (2006), have been introduced to biology students. C. Recommendations from Previous Reviews The 2007-08 Forest Wildlife Program Review identified no deficiencies and included no recommendations for Program improvement based on the vitality of the Forest Wildlife Program and the ability of its graduates to obtain employment within their field. ETS Biology Field Test for all majors within the Biology Discipline, Practicum evaluation, and feedback from graduates were used to evaluate the efficacy of the Forest Wildlife Program. D. Procedures and Participants in the Review Information for this program review was gathered from available files in the Department of Natural Sciences, and the WNMU catalogs. Paul Landrum provided the data, via data mart, on enrollment and degrees awarded. Dr. Gilda BaezaOrtego, University Librarian provided information on library holdings. Randy D. Jennings prepared the program review. Jeff Hill reviewed the document. Other faculty members in the Department of Natural Sciences participated in discussions and reflections on the programs. CRITERION A: PROGRAM CENTRALITY A. Educational Goal and Objectives of the Program The goal of the Forest Wildlife Program is to provide graduates with the broad overview of the diversity, evolutionary history, structure, and function of plants and animals, as well as to understand their ecological roles. In that Forest Wildlife curriculum is a subset of biology, basic biological concepts and processes constitute a core of the knowledge base, especially as related to fisheries, wildlife, and forest management of graduates of this program. B. Relationship of the Program to the Institutional Mission According to the WNMU Mission statement “…teaching and learning are preeminent at WNMU.” and WNMU “ …develops the knowledge and skills necessary to prepare our students for the challenges of a changing world.” The Forest Wildlife Program offers the students of WNMU the opportunity to specialize in an important area of biology that allows them to pursue a variety of careers and post-graduate academic endeavors. 3 CRITERION B: PROGRAM CURRICULUM AND STRUCTURE A. Admission, Retention, Graduation Requirements The Forest Wildlife Program has no admission, retention, or graduation requirements beyond those of the University. The Forest Wildlife Program tracks the progress of its majors from the entry-level course, Biology for Majors II: Animal Form, Function, & Diversity, through graduation in order to better understand challenges to retention of its majors. B. Program Structure 1. Degree Options and Objectives Students that major in Forest Wildlife can earn either a BA or BS degree. Those opting for the Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement degree earn a BAS. 2. Description of Required Courses Courses that constitute the Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement degrees (see Fig. 1, Fig. 2, and Appendix 1) are designed to give students a broad background in biological processes and concepts (BIOL 202/203, BIOL 204/205, and BIOL 206/207) including genetics (BIOL 366/368), and ecology (BIOL 301/303). After developing a strong background in basic biology students experience a number of taxon specific courses (BIOL310/312, BIOL311/313, BIOL 322/324, BIOL 351/353, BIOL 425/427, BIOL 442/443, BIOL 448/449, BIOL 451/453, and BIOL 457/459) that will prepare the student for work on the ground in applied biological careers. These courses include a mix of courses that familiarize students with the ecologies, diversity, and evolution of different groups of plants and animals. Principles of Wildlife Biology (BIOL 375/377) knits the curriculum together by presenting students with applied techniques for population estimation, land management practices, harvesting strategies, wildlife law, and other important wildlife concepts that are important to land resource managers. The Practicum (BIOL 481) gives students the opportunity to interact with agency biologist and managers to experience the application of practices learned in coursework. 4. Typical Program of Study The typical program of study is provided below (Fig.s 1 & 2). Students are encouraged to take BIOL 202/203, BIOL 204/205, and BIOL 206/207 early in their academic tenure since those typically are prerequisites for 300 and 400 level coursework. Students work with an advisor (Jennings and Hill are typical advisor.) in the Department of Natural Sciences to navigate through the program of study. 4 3. Summary of Course Requirements Figure 1. Life Sciences and major requirements of the Forest Wildlife degree. Figure 2. Life Sciences and major requirements of the Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement degree. 5 5. History of Courses Taught as Program Requirements Courses relevant to the Forest Wildlife degrees are offered on a two year rotation (Table 1). Foundation courses are typically offered annually. Other courses are offered every other year. Table 1. Course rotation for those courses relevant to the Forest Wildlife degree from Fall2008 to Spring 2010. Fall 2008 Plant FFD (202/204) Intro Cell Molec (206/207) Spring 2009 Animal FFD (204/205) Intro Cell Molec (206/207) Fall 2009 Plant FFD (202/204) Spring 2010 Animal FFD (204/205) Intro Cell Molec (206/207) Intro Cell Molec (206/207) Vert Zoology (311/313) Dendrology (322/324) Invertebrate (310/312) Ecology (301/303) Vert Zoology (311/313) Herpetology (448/449) Ecology (301/303) Ornithology (442/443) Plant Tax (351/353) Mammology (351/353) Princ. Wildlife (375/377) Plant Tax (351/353) Range Veg (425/427) Entomology (457/459) C. Articulation The following courses are included in the state-wide articulation matrix for General Education: BIOL202/203, BIOL 204/205, BIOL 206/207, CHEM 151/153, and CHEM 152/154. There are no state articulation agreements for upper level courses in the sciences, nor is there a biology articulation module. D. Planning Processes The planning process within the Forest Wildlife Program is based on the assessment critieria described in section E (below). Based on evaluation of students derived from the Major Field Test (ETS) scores broken down by topic, evaluation of the Practicum, success in post-graduate education and employment, and feedback from students after graduation, course content and alternate coursework is incorporated into requirements for the major. E. Assessment Major Field Test in Biology (ETS) Scores Competency in biology-related fields involve the gestation of lots of information, and understanding important biological concepts and processes. Success in biology is dependent on the mastery of this broad-based body of information. Student cannot develop questions nor conduct relevant studies without this basic understanding. In order to assess how well students are grasping basic biological information, we have been using the Major Field Test in Biology (ETS) Scores. This is a nationally-normed test covering Biology. Tests are administered each academic year to students about to graduate. Scores are used to identify weaknesses within the Program and to evaluate how WNMU’s Forest Wildlife Major graduates compare to their peers at a national level. Evaluation of Practicum The Practicum (BIOL 481) is required of all Forest Wildlife majors. This is a course where the rubber meets the road for these majors in that it requires students to work with agency wildlife and land management specialists. Students experience what it is like to work in 6 fields that they may soon pursue for a career. Evaluation of the Practicum is conducted by departmental faculty and supervisory agency professionals. During student evaluations agency supervisors often indicate how the Forest Wildlife Program could be improved. Post-Graduate/Job Placement Ultimately, a graduates ability to obtain a position in a related biological field, whether after post-graduate education or not, is the test of our undergraduate program. By tracking students after graduation we can assess how well our program prepares students to deal with challenges obtaining a job and the execution of their new job. CRITERION C: PROGRAM RESOURCES A. Finances (Budget) The Forest Wildlife Program has no single faculty member that teaches all the courses within the major. Similarly, the Forest Wildlife Program does not possess a separate budget within the Biology Discipline. Faculty and budget are spread across all of the programs within the Biology Discipline including Biology, Botany, Cell & Molecular Biology, Forest Wildlife, Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement, and Zoology. Required courses or required electives integral to the Forest Wildlife Program are taught by five faculty within the Biology Discipline; Camacho (1 course, 4 ch), Hill (1 course, 4 ch), Jennings (3 courses, 12 ch), Jost (2 courses, 8 ch), and Norris (6 courses, 24 ch). Courses taught by all faculty in the Biology Discipline can be used as electives for more than one major. The Biology Discipline budget for AY2011-12 is: Biology Supplies & Expenses Graduate Asst. Work Study Lab Fees $7690.00 $5440.00 $2850.00 $19,715.00 B. Facilities and Capital Equipment The Natural Sciences Department is located in Harlan Hall. An addition to Harlan Hall was completed in 2007 that increased space and improved the infrastructure of the building. Classrooms: There are four classrooms in Harlan Hall: 111, 211, 219, and 222. Rooms 111, 211 and 219 are tiered lecture halls. Room 111 and 211 can seat approximately 40 students. The chairs in rooms 111 and 211 were replaced when the addition to Harlan Hall was completed. Room 219 is a large lecture hall and can seat approximately 80 students. Some of the chairs in Room 219 were replaced during the construction of the addition. More classroom furniture was replaced in 2011 with Departmental funds. Room 222 is a flexible classroom with tables and chairs that can seat approximately 25 students. All of these classrooms are equipped with computers and projectors. In addition there is a seminar room (143) that seats approximately 12 people around a large conference table. Teaching/Research Laboratories and facilities: The department maintains 10 teaching labs. The biology program supports a total of 5 labs. These include two general labs, one used for biology for general education and anatomy and physiology, and the other used for biology for majors, botany, and zoology courses. Additional labs include a mammalogy/ornithology lab, microbiology lab and herbarium with lab space. The chemistry program has a general chemistry lab, organic lab, analytical lab and an instrumental lab. The chemistry program also maintains a 7 small NMR research lab. The physics and geology programs share a large lab. The department also maintains a greenhouse for teaching and research. The greenhouse was replaced in 2009. Offices: There are a total of 13 offices in the department including 8 faculty offices, 2 offices for the lab directors, the main office that houses the secretary, an office for use by the emeritus faculty and an office of the Gila Center for Natural History for management of the collections. Faculty offices vary in size and in some cases have attached storage, work, or research space. All of the offices are adequately furnished and all faculty and staff members have a computer. All faculty are connected to two high-speed printers located in the seminar room. Storage: The department requires large amounts of space to adequately store teaching and research collections. The Gila Natural History Collections are stored in several places including cabinets in the mammalogy/ornithology lab, the morgue, and in the herbarium. There is a physics storage room and a geology storage room attached to the geology/physics lab. The Chemistry program has a recently enlarged storeroom with special storage for hazardous substances. There is some additional storage scattered throughout the department as well as storage in the greenhouse. C. Library Part. I: Resources Held in Miller Library The Miller Library has consistently maintained a collection and provided services to support the Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement program. As indicated in the 2010 program review of the Biology program, the Miller Library has more than 3400 individually cataloged items in a wide array of biological topics. The strength of the book (Appendix 2) and media collection lies in ornithology and in natural history of plants and animals. Additionally, the Miller Library has titles that specifically pertain to the biology of forests, woodlands, and rain forests. The collection, however, can be improved by the elimination of dated materials in rapidly changing fields. The Miller Library is a partial depository for Federal Government Documents and enjoys full status as a depository for New Mexico State Government Documents. Government Documents may be checked out and are included in GilaCat, the online catalog for holdings. The Miller Library regularly receives print or electronic versions of important items such as governmentsponsored studies, transcripts of congressional hearings, and findings of reports presented to governmental agencies or Congressional committees. Journal literature is essential to the study and teaching of Forest Wildlife (Appendix 3). To that end, the Miller Library subscribes to approximately seventy journals that support the program. The Interlibrary Loan Department is responsible for requesting books, articles, and other library items not held at the Miller Library. Typically, students and faculty are not accessed charges to request items from other libraries. The Miller Library is a member of several consortia that are committed to resource-sharing. These consortia include AMIGOS Library Services, Inc., (membership includes libraries in New Mexico, Arizona, Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana), the New Mexico Consortium of Academic Libraries, and the National Network of Libraries in Medicine. 8 D. Other Academic Support Resources and Services Computer Laboratory: The Natural Sciences Department maintains a computer lab for use by science majors. Currently the lab houses 8PCs, 2 MACs and a laser printer. Gila Center for Natural History: The Department is the home of the Gila Center for Natural History and maintains the Gila Natural History Collections for research and teaching. Two major projects of the Gila Center for Natural History have been the computerization of the collections and the presentation of a biannual symposium on the Natural History of the Gila. Study Spaces in Harlan Hall: Study tables are located in the hallways on the first floor of Harlan Hall and a group of tables is grouped in the atrium on the second floor. In addition a small lab on the first floor is used as a study space for lab exams and make ups. Students also may use the ‘seminar’ room on the first floor to study. The Academic Support Center in Juan Chacon, provides personal counseling to students as well as academic advising to students who have not yet declared a major. The Special Needs Office is also located in Juan Chacon to assist students with special needs. The Writing Center, housed in Miller Library, provides support and tutoring for writing in all classes. CRITERION D: PROGRAM PRODUCTIVITY AND EFFICIENCY A. Major Headcount Enrollment Class sizes within the Forest Wildlife Program have remained relatively stable, if not increased slightly, during the past five years for 300- and 400-level courses that are required within the major program of study (Criterion B.B.3 above) plus the three Majors Biology courses (BIOL 202/203, BIOL 204/205, and BIOL 206/207). Average class size was 14.5 student per class (s=7.66 students). Student Credit Hour (SCH) production for those same classes averaged 779.0 credits per academic year, and also remained high. Remember that students with other majors besides Forest Wildlife were also enrolled in these classes. Likewise faculty associated with these courses are not restricted to a single major either. Two classes represent unique requirements of the Forest Wildlife majors, Principles of Wildlife (BIOL 375/377) and the Practicum (BIOL 481). Enrollments in these classes demonstrate a consistent pattern of enrollment within the Program. During the past five academic years the number of Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement majors has remained rather consistent and averaged 16.4 students (range 15-20 students, see Table 3). Student credit hour production, enrollment in major specific courses, and numbers of majors all indicated a sustained high level of interest in the Forest Wildlife Program. 9 Table 2. Average class sizes and student credit hour production by academic year for courses that are relevant to the Forest Wildlife majors. YEAR Average Class Sizes SCH Production 2010-11 16.2 904 2009-10 12.9 649 2008-09 13.5 678 2007-08 16.1 916 2006-07 13.1 747 Enrollment: Principles of Wildlife (BIOL 375) Number of Students 26 22 18 14 10 6 04-05 06-07 08-09 10-11 Academic Year Figure 3. Enrollments in one of two courses, Principles of Wildlife (BIOL 375/377) that are specific to the Forest Wildlife majors for its past four offerings. This course is offered biannually. B. Degrees Conferred Table 3 shows the Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement degrees conferred since AY 2006-07. Table 3. Numbers of Forest Wildlife and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement majors and graduates during the past five academic years. ACADEMIC Majors Degrees Conferred YEAR 2010-11 15 4 2009-10 20 7 2008-09 15 6 2007-08 15 4 2006-07 17 4 10 Enrollment: Practicum (BIOL 481) Number of Students 5 4 3 2 06-07 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 Academic Year Figure 4. Enrollments in one of two courses, Practicum (BIOL 481), that are specific to the Forest Wildlife majors for the past five academic years. This course is offered as needed. C. Credit Hour Production: It is difficult to parse the credit hour production of just Forest Wildlife majors from those of the Biology Discipline as a whole. As stated earlier (see section D.A above), there are two courses that are required just for the Forest Wildlife majors. I have documented stabile trends in enrollments in those courses above (Fig.s 3 and 4). That stated, even those course could be taken as an elective by students with other majors within the Biology Discipline. All other courses required for the Forest Wildlife majors are requirements or electives in the Botany, Biology, Forest/Wildlife, and Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement majors. Courses within the Biology Discipline, in general, produce more or almost as many SCHs as any discipline on campus (see Table 2). D. Average Class Size See Criterion D.A above. F. Number of Courses Offered and Time of Offering See Criterion B.B.5 for the courses offered and rotation. 11 CRITERION E: PROGRAM QUALITY A. Other Program Evaluations ETS Major Field Test The Department acquired the ETS Major Field Test in Biology during the Spring 2004 and has administered the test to graduating seniors at the end of each semester since except for AY200607. This is a nationally-normed test that evaluates mastery of basic biological concepts and information. The scores of those Forest Wildlife majors that took the test (Taking the test has not been mandatory) are reported in Table 4. Table 4. Forest Wildlife majors scores (total and subscores) on the ETS Major Field Test in Biology. Test was administered in 2007-08, 2008-09, 2009-10, and 2010-11. Test results from 2010-11 not yet available. Total scores were out of 200 points; subscores were out of 100 points. Student * Total Score 2006-07 test not 2007-08 A B 2008-09 A B C 2009-10 A B C D 2010-11 Cell Biology Molecular Biology &Genetics Organismal Biology Population Biology/Evolution/ Ecology administered 140 157 x=148.5 s=12.02 42 45 x=43.5 s=2.12 40 40 x=40 s=0 37 58 x=47.5 s=14.85 47 74 x=60.5 s=19.09 144 162 142 x=149.3 11.02 32 60 51 x=47. 7 14.29 27 51 43 x=40.3 12.22 48 64 48 x=53.3 9.24 68 67 34 x=56.3 19.35 145 162 152 145 x=151 s=8.04 39 35 48 32 x=38.5 s=6.95 48 56 43 45 x=48 s=5.72 46 72 60 46 x=56 s=12.54 51 70 55 57 x=58.25 s=8.22 tests not processed * student order randomized Institutional total scores across years placed Forest Wildlife graduates from WNMU about the 40th percentile when compared with other institutions at a national level. A non-significant trend of higher scores was observed from AY 2007-08 (32nd percentile) to AY 2009-10 (41st percentile). When individual total scores were evaluated at the national level, scores from students at WNMU ranged from the 16th to the 73rd percentile. Subscores exhibited similar ranges. Individual Cell Biology scores ranked from the 5th to the 71st percentiles. Molecular 12 Biology & Genetics scores ranged from the 3rd to 59th percentile. Organismal Biology scores ranged from the 10th to the 89th percentiles. Population Biology, Evolution & Ecology scores ranged from the 10th to 96th percentiles. Organismal Biology and Population Biology, Evolution, Ecology subscores were higher than scores in the two suborganismal categories, and averaged ranks near the nation's 50th percentile and the 62nd percentiles, respectively. The Forest Wildlife program focuses on applied ecology and organismal biology, so higher scores in these two subdisciplines should be expected. While some scores of Forest Wildlife graduates leave much room for improvement, some students scored above the 90th percentile (and even higher). These results suggest that it is possible for students in our programs to obtain a high quality education (when compared to students on a national scale) at WNMU. Evaluation of Practicum Seventeen Forest Wildlife majors completed their Practicum during the preceding five years (Some graduates had extensive experience working with land management agencies and substituted other coursework for the Practicum.). Grades for the Practicum are determined in conjunction with the agency supervisor. Ten students received As, five received Bs, and two received Ps (passing under a now obsolete pass/fail option). Students that received As, scored above average on their work ethic (punctuality, productivity, professionalism, etc.), understanding of background information/preparation, contribution to agency projects, and their written report of the practicum. Students receiving Bs received above average scores in most categories, while those receiving lower grades received a combination of average and below average scores. Post-Graduate/Job Placement Of the 26 Forest Wildlife graduates spanning the past five years, 20 (76.9 %) have obtained gainful employment (This number may be higher. We have lost touch with some graduates.). Nineteen (73.1%) obtained employment in a career relevant to their Forest Wildlife degree. Most of these (69.2% of total) were employed by state or federal natural resource management agencies including the US Forest Service, NM State Park Service, NM Department of Game and Fish, NM Environment Department, and similar agencies outside New Mexico. One (3.8%) was accepted to and is attending graduate school in Arizona. Forest Wildlife graduates have a great track record in obtaining employment within their field. Gary Ortiz, Director of Law Enforcement for NM State Parks, has called me several times trying to recruit our Forest Wildlife Law Enforcement graduates into careers as rangers in NM State Park Service. He has been impressed with the preparation of our graduates and has hired several as Law Enforcement Rangers. Other Feedback From Forest Wildlife Graduates: Isolated comments from Forest Wildlife graduates are listed below. Incorporate Hydrogeology/Watershed course into degree. Several potential employers asked for that coursework. More job openings to candidates with that experience. “Now that we’re in the field as well as looking for new opportunities, we realize how important data analysis and GIS are. We lost out on quite a few cool gigs because we were lacking in both areas. I know you would like to implement more scientific writing and data analysis courses, but 13 not many showed interest. …. It really needs to be emphasized how important these skills are, and without them you are not going to be very competitive in the job market.” B. Quality of Faculty The Department of Natural Sciences has 8 faculty members, 5 in biology, 2 in chemistry and 1 in geology. All of the faculty have doctorates in their disciplines. The Department occasionally hires adjunct faculty to teach some courses, particularly on-line. The faculty teaching on-line courses at present also hold appropriate terminal degrees. In addition, the department has two lab directors, one in physical science and one in life science who teach some labs. C. Research Activity within the Program Faculty within the Forest Wildlife Program and within the Biology Discipline maintain research programs within their specific areas of interest. Dr. Jennings maintains active research projects on the conservation of Chiricahua Leopard Frogs, Narrow-headed Gartersnakes, and the herpetofauna of the Gila River. Dr. Norris works on regional flora and the taxonomy of Carex spp., as well as the birds of the Gila River in New Mexico. Several students within the Biology Discipline have worked on these projects with Department faculty. D. Community Service Activity within the Program Students in the program routinely participate in outreach activities of the Department of Natural Sciences. Students work in many capacities, including event directors, with the Science Olympiad and with the Expanding Your Horizons conference held annually on campus. Numerous school groups also come to campus for tours and presentations and science students participate in those events as well. E. External Review Process (may be the same as A) See A CRITERION F: PROGRAM DEMAND/NEED A. Student Demand for the Program Enrollments within the Forest Wildlife Program and in 300 and 400-level, program-relevant courses have maintained high levels and are projected to increase in enrollment in the near future (Fig. 5). Student credit hour (SCH) production and enrollments in courses specific to the Forest Wildlife Program (BIOL 375/377 and BIOL 481) exhibit a similar pattern of increase. Increasing enrollments in the face of the implementation of new programs in biology, speak to the health of the Forest Wildlife Program. 14 Fundable SCH: Actual & Forecast 1,000 800 600 400 200 06-07 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 11-12 12-13 13-14 14-15 Academic Year Figure 5. Fundable student credit hour production (SCH, old formula) by academic year. SCH for 2011-12 and after are projections (Landrum). B. Employment Needs and Job Opportunities According to the Occupational Outlook Handbook (http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos069.htm) “Science technicians held about 270,800 jobs in 2008. As indicated by the following tabulation, chemical and biological technicians accounted for 54 percent of all jobs: Biological technicians Chemical technicians Environmental science and protection technicians, including health Forest and conservation technicians Agricultural and food science technicians Geological and petroleum technicians Forensic science technicians Nuclear technicians 79,500 66,100 35,000 34,000 21,900 15,200 12,800 6,400 About 30 percent of biological technicians worked in professional, scientific, or technical services firms; most other biological technicians worked in educational services, government, or pharmaceutical and medicine manufacturing. …. Most environmental science and protection technicians worked for professional, scientific, and technical services firms and for State and local governments. Employment of science technicians is projected to grow about as fast as the average for all occupations, although employment change will vary by specialty. Job opportunities are expected to be best for graduates of applied science technology programs who are well trained on equipment used in laboratories or production facilities.” 15 Demands for Forest Wildlife majors, as biological technicians, natural resource managers, wildlife biologists, zoo keepers, and for those students wishing to use their degrees as preparation for graduate school, remains at least as strong as it has been in the recent past and should exhibit average growth within the job market. C. Societal Needs for the Program Forest Wildlife majors and biologists in general are needed as human populations around the world continue to grow and expand the interface between centers of human population and natural areas. More and more expanding human populations put pressure on valuable natural resources (water, land, forests, grasslands, etc.) and come into conflict with wild populations of organisms that also require those resources. Concomitant with the expanding human presence comes the increase of non-native or novel pathogens and invasive species brought by and associated with humans that will compete with, prey upon, or infect the nearby native flora and fauna. The sixth mass extinction has been proposed as rates of extinction exceed background rates associated with the natural longevity of species on planet earth. Indeed society needs welltrained zoologists, botanists, and biologists that can help us mitigate the dire consequences of extinction, loss of genetic diversity, and altered community and ecosystem function. CRITERION G: PROGRAM DUPLICATIONS WNMU is the only four-year, state institution in New Mexico that offers its students Forest Wildlife degrees that offer a balance of zoological and botanical courses. NMSU and ENMU offer Wildlife and Wildlife & Fisheries Science degrees, respectively, with emphases on wildlife biology and zoology, while NMHU offers a Forestry degree that possesses no emphasis on zoology. The Forest Wildlife degree at WNMU offers New Mexico's students background to identify and understan a mix of regional flora and fauna. SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS A. Strengths The strength of the Forest Wildlife Program at Western New Mexico University is that it provides students with a strong applied, hands-on background in plants and animals. Faculty in the Department is committed to facilitating the undergraduate education of Forest Wildlife majors to allow their desired career choices. In upper division courses within the major students experience extended field trips and lab exercises in the field during which they are exposed to a variety of field sampling techniques and trained in taxon-based identification. WNMU’s Forest Wildlife students tend to score well on organismal portions of standardized tests, and many have reported that field experiences have improved their chances of securing post-graduate positions. The Department of Natural Science also provides opportunities for students to get some experience before they graduate. Many of the work study students in the department work as classroom aides or in collections where they learn the techniques associated with the preservation and curation of scientific specimens. Some students also take advantage of research projects conducted by Department faculty to obtain hands-on experience in field research. It also reinforces their understanding and knowledge of concepts learned in labs and classrooms. 16 B. Concerns The Forest Wildlife degree is a traditional, whole-organism curriculum. In order to enhance student’s exposure to regional flora and fauna, we have resisted the tendency to dilute that traditional curriculum with courses in cell biology or molecular biology, which students could need to interpret phylogenies based on molecular data sets. Organismal courses included in the Forest Wildlife majors include discussions of the importance of such molecular-based phylogenies and the ramifications that new phylogenies bring. C. Recommendations for Action Incorporate more data analysis into existing courses, and develop additional data analysis courses (i.e., a GIS course). Enhance field experiences of Forest Wildlife majors. Consider inclusion of Hydrogeology in Forest Wildlife curriculum. Develop an effective assessment program that includes tracking alumni and follow-up interviews. Five Year Goals for the Program Continue monitoring student feedback to better tailor the Forest Wildlife Program to fill the needs of students. Understand and incorporate Hydrogeology into the Forest Wildlife curriculum. Increase the scores on ETS Field test in biology across areas. Facilitate/Improve student ability to collect and analyze data using statistics and GIS. Forest Wildlife majors need the opportunity to collect and analyze data sets. Since this major does not complete the Senior Project, graduates have not been pushed in that direction. Students obtain some experience in this area in Ecology (BIOL 301/303), but more experience would increase post-graduate opportunities. Similarly, GIS expertise needs to be incorporated into the program. Most resource and land management agencies expect new hires to have some experience with this valuable management tool. 17 Appendix 1. Course descriptions of required and elective courses that constitute the Forest Wildlife degree. Biology Courses BIOL 202/203. Majors I: Plant Form, Function and Diversity & lab. Introduction to plant biology: summarizes the major disciplines of botany and includes study of the more important plant groups: three lectures and one laboratory period per week. This course, BIOL 204, and BIOL 206 constitute the prerequisite for all biology related majors and minors. BIOL 202, 204 and 206 can be taken in any order. (NMCCN BIOL 1213/1211) (Area III). (4) BIOL 204/205. Majors II: Animal Form, Function and Diversity & lab. Introductory biology covering biological macromolecules, ecology, evolution, systematics, phylogeny, developmental biology, and a survey of major animal groups; three lectures and one two-hour laboratory a week. This course, BIOL 202, and BIOL 206 constitute the prerequisite for all biology related majors and minors. BIOL 202, 204, and 206 can be taken in any order. (NMCCN BIOL 1223/1221)(Area III). (4) BIOL 206/207. Majors III: Intro to Cell Biology & lab. Introductory biology for majors covering biological molecules, eukaryotic and prokaryotic cell form and function, cellular metabolism and mechanisms of heredity; three lectures and one two-hour laboratory a week. This course, BIOL 202 and 204 constitute the prerequisites for all biology related majors and minors. BIOL 202, 204, and 206 can be taken in any order. (4) BIOL 301/303. Ecology & lab. The study of the interactions between organisms, their abiotic environment, and other biotic components of natural systems; the structure and function of biotic communities and ecosystems; three lectures and one laboratory or field period per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, and ENGL 102. Offered every Spring. (4) BIOL 310/312. Invertebrate Zoology & lab. Systematic study of invertebrate groups including taxonomy, ecology, anatomy reproduction and natural history of invertebrates; three lectures and one laboratory period per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 204/205 and ENGL 102. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 311/313. Vertebrate Zoology & lab. Study of vertebrate animals, their evolu- tion, morphology, and ecology: three lectures and one laboratory period per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 204/205 and ENGL 102. Offered every Fall. (4) BIOL 322/324. Dendrology & lab. Identification and natural history of North American trees, shrubs, and vines, with emphasis on species native to the Southwest. Considerable time spent in field study. Three major projects involving analysis and interpretation of field data collected by the class in lab.Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, 206/207, and ENGL 102. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 351/353. Plant Taxonomy & lab. Flowering plants and their classification, with emphasis on flora of the Southwest: three lectures and one laboratory per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203 and ENGL 102. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 366/368. Genetics & lab. Methods and results of the transmission of hereditary characteristics; three lectures and one laboratory per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, 206/207, and ENGL 102. (4) BIOL 375/377. Principles of Wildlife Biology & lab. This course studies the appli- cation of wildlife principles to various animal species. Topics will include population dynamics, species introduction, predator-prey interactions, hunting and manage- ment techniques; three lectures and one laboratory per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, 301/303, and ENGL 102. Offered alternate years, even years spring. (4) BIOL 422. Evolution. The study of changes in natural populations of organisms and the dynamics underlying those changes. Evolutionary processes including mutation, genetic recombination, natural selection, migration, and genetic drift are reviewed, as well as their microevolutionary and macroevolutionary consequences; three lectures or discussion periods per week. Prerequisites: ENGL 102 and 15 credit hours of biology including BIOL 366. 18 Offered alternate years. (3) BIOL 425/427 Range Vegetation & lab. Focuses on plants of rangelands of the southwest, with emphasis on identification of range plants and ecology of rangeland plant communities. Prerequisites: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, and ENGL 102. (4) BIOL 442/443. Ornithology & lab. Introductory scientific study of birds, with emphasis on North American species; three lectures and one laboratory period per week; two Saturday field trips required. Prerequisites: BIOL 202, BIOL 204, BIOL 311, and ENGL 102, or permission of the instructor. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 448/449. Herpetology & lab. The study of amphibians and reptiles will review the evolutionary history, phylogenetic relationships, global diversity, life history, and general biology of these important groups. Laboratory will focus on the identification of the regional herpetofauna; three lectures and one laboratory per week with at least one required weekend field trip. Prerequisites: BIOL 202, BIOL 204, BIOL 311, and ENGL 102, or permission of the instructor. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 451/453. Mammalogy & lab. The study of fur-bearing animals, including their structure, behavior, life histories, and taxonomic relationship; three lectures and one laboratory period per week; one weekend field trip required. Prerequisite: BIOL 202/203, 204/205, 311/313, ENGL 102, or permission of the instructor. Offered alternate years. (4) BIOL 457/459. Entomology & lab. An introduction to the biology, classification, ecology, and evolution of insects, with emphasis on the roles insects play in global ecosystems and human affairs. Entomology has applications in fields of ecology, medicine, agriculture, forestry, and conservation, and is a suitable course for students pursuing careers in those areas. Offered alternate years. Writing Intensive. Prerequisites: BIOL 204/205, 206/207, and ENGL 102. (4) BIOL 472. Readings in Science. An interdisciplinary introduction to the explora- tion and understanding of primary, scientific literature. Two scientific papers will be read and discussed each week. Outlines of scientific papers and participation in discussions are focal activities. Designed for the upper level undergraduate. Offered alternate years. Prerequisite: ENGL 102. (3) BIOL 475. Field Biology. Will develop the upper undergraduates ability to design, execute, and report biological field studies. Overnight camping required four nights per week. Prerequisites: BIOL 111, BIOL 204; BIOL 301/303 recommended, and ENGL 102. Summers only. (6) BIOL 481. Practicum. For Forest/Wildlife and Forest/Wildlife Law Enforcement majors only. This course involves 150 hours of volunteer work in the field with professional biologists that gives students practical educational experiences to help prepare them for their professional career. All students must take an appropriate biology exit exam by the eight week of the semester to receive a grade. Students must apply to the Advisor of the Forest/Wildlife Program 4 months prior to the begin- ning of this course. Writing Intensive. Prerequisite: ENGL 102. (3) Chemistry Courses CHEM 151/153. General Chemistry I & lab. Introductory course in chemistry; three lectures and one lab per week.Prerequisite: MATH 131 or equivalent (may be taken concurrently). (NMCCN CHEM 1213/1211)(Area III). (4) CHEM 152/154. General Chemistry II & lab. Second introductory course in chemistry; three lectures and one lab per week.Prerequisite: CHEM 151/153. (NMCCN CHEM 1223/1221)(Area III). (4) 19 Appendix 2. Miller Library book holdings relevant to the Forest Wildlife Program. Forest Wildlife: Publication Information Call number Representative Book Holdings American Forests Charlottesville, Va. :University of Virginia Library ;Boulder, Colo. :NetLibrary,1995. SD356.5.M89 (E-book) America's forests health update. Washington, DC :USDA Forest Service, Forest Health Protection A 1.75:757 (Microform cabinets) Washington, D.C. :Island Press,c1990. SD387.O43/N67 1990 [Washington, D.C.] :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service,[2007] A 13.2:L 22/13 (Gov Docs) Ancient forests of the Pacific Northwest/Norse, Elliott A. Assessment of the status and trends of natural resources from U.S. forest and range land :15 key findings. At home in the rain forest/Willow, Diane QH112.W55 1991 Balancing act :environmental issues in forestry/Kimmins, J. P. Vancouver :UBC Press,c1992 SD387.E58K55 1992 Bulletin, no. 2, report on the forest conditions of the Rocky Mountains, and other papers. Washington :Govt. Print. Off.,1888. SD144.A14 (Microform cabinets Conservation of the northern spotted owl: Hearing before the Subcommittee on Environmental Protection of the Committee on Environment and Public Works, United States Senate, One Hundred Second Congress, second session, May 13, 1992. Washington :U.S. Government Printing Office, 1992 Y4.P96/10:S.hrg.102 (Microform Cabinets) Crisis on the national forests :containing the threat of wildland fire to the environment and communities : oversight field hearing before the Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health of the Committee on Resources, U.S. House of Representatives, One Hundred Eighth Congress, first session, Friday, March 7, 2003, in Flagstaff, Arizona. Washington :U.S. Government Printing Office, 2003 Y 4.R 31/3:108-5 Desired future conditions for Piñon-juniper ecosystems, August 8-12, 1994, Flagstaff, Arizona Fort Collins, Colo. :Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, U.S. Dept. of A13.88:RM-258 Agriculture,[1995] Effects of all-terrain vehicles on forested lands and grasslands Washington, D.C. :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service, National Technology & Development Program, Recreation A 13.2:AL 5/4 Gov Doc Management :U.S. Dept. of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration,2008. FIBER 3.0an ecological growth model for Northeastern forest types / Solomon, Dale S. Radnor, PA (5 Radnor Corp CTR STE 200, P.O. Box 6775, Radnor 19087-8775) :USDA A13.88:NE-204 Microform Cabinets Forest Service, Northeastern Forest Experiment Station,[1995] Field sampling and data analysis methods for development of ecological land classifications an application on the Manistee National Forest St. Paul, MN :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station,1993. Fire management and invasive plants :a handbook [Arlington, Va.] :U.S. Dept. of the Interior, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service,[2009] I 49.6/2:F 51/2 Gov Docs 20 Fire policy and related forest health issues :joint oversight hearing before the Committee on Natural Resources, and the Committee on Agriculture, House of Representatives, One Hundred Third Congress, second session ... October 4, 1994--Washington, DC. Y4.R31/3:103-119 Microform Cabinets The forest by Peter Farb New York : Time, inc., 1961. QK938.F6 F34 Functional ecology of woodlands and forests London ;New York :Chapman & Hall,1992 QK938.F6F86 1992 Functional ecology of woodlands and forests London ;New York :Chapman & Hall,1992. QK938.F6F86 1992 Gestión forestal municipal en América Latina. English. Municipal forest management in Latin America Bogor, Indonesia :Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) ;Ottawa :International Development Research Centre (IDRC),2003. SB435.6.L29G4713 2003eb Management of pinyon-juniper woodlands/Evans, Raymond A. Ogden, UT :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service, Intermountain Research A13.88:INT-249 Microform Cabinets Station,[1988] Mangrove management and conservation present and future Tokyo ;New York :United Nations University Press,c2004 SD397.M25M373 2004eb National fire plan Implementation :oversight hearing before the Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health of the Committee on Resources, U.S. House of Representatives, One Hundred Seventh Congress, first session, March 8, 2001. Washington :U.S. Government Printing Office, 2001 Y 4.R 31/3:107-3 Old-growth forests in the Southwest and Rocky Mountain regions proceedings of a workshop, March 9-13, 1992, Portal, Arizona. Fort Collins, Colo. :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain A13.88:RM-213 Microform Cabinets Forest and Range Experiment Station,[1992] Pine plantations and wildlife in the southeastern United States an assessment of impacts and opportunities /Allen, Arthur W. Washington, D.C. :U.S. Dept. of the Interior, National Biological Service,[1996] I73.11:3 Microform Cabinets Rainforest by Sara Oldfield Cambridge, Mass. :MIT Press,c2002 Oversized QH86.O43 2002 Report on the forests of North America (exclusive of Mexico)/Sargent, Charles Sprague, Washington :Govt. Print. Off.,1884. SD143.S2 Microform Cabinets Saving our ancient forests/Zuckerman, Seth. Venice, Calif. :Living Planet Press,c1991. SD387.O43Z83 1991 Sea-level rise and coastal forests on the Gulf of Mexico St. Petersburg, Fla. :U.S. Geological Survey, Center for Coastal Geology,[1999] I 19.76:99-441 Microform Cabinets Shelter Covedraft environmental impact statement Silviculture and ecology of western U.S. forests/Tappeiner, J. C.(John C.) United States. Forest Service. Alaska Region A13.92/2:K49/2/ Microform Cabinets Corvallis :Oregon State University Press,2007 SD391.T37 2007 State Forest resource plan :executive summary / prepared by David D. Brown. New Mexico. Forestry and Resources Conservation Division. NMX221.7:R43 New Mexico Gov Doc The Congo Basin Forest Partnership hearing before the Subcommittee on African Affairs of the Committee on Foreign Relations, United States Senate, One Hundred Eighth Congress, first session, July 24, 2003. Washington :U.S. G.P.O Y 4.F 76/2:S.HRG.108-246 (Microform Cabinets) The dying of the trees :the pandemic in America's forests/Little, Charles E. New York, N.Y. :Viking,1995. SB762.L58 1995 The Last rain forests :a world conservation atlas New York :Oxford University Press,1990 QH541.5.R27L38 1990 The life of the forest Savannah, GA :International Paper,2000 SD428.I58 The United States forest policy/Ise, John, New Haven :Yale University Press,1920. SD565I8 21 Timeless heritage :a history of the Forest Service in the Southwest / [Washington, D.C.?] :U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Forest Service,1988. SD144.A165T5 1988 Tropical rainforest :a world survey of our most valuable and endangered habitat with a blueprint for its survival New York :Facts on File,c1990 Oversized QH541.5.R27N49 1990 Wildfires on the national forests :an update on the 2002 wildland fire season : hearing before the Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health of the Committee on Resources, U.S. House of Representatives, One Hundred Seventh Congress, second session, July 11, 2002 Washington :Govt. Print. Off., 2002 Y 4.R 31/3:107-138 22 Appendix 3. Miller Library journal holdings relevant to the Forest Wildlife Program. Journal Title Publisher Dates Covered Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research Taylor & Francis Ltd 05/01/1999 to present with a 12-month delay Acta Herpetologica Firenze University Press 06/01/2009 to present Acta Zoologica Wiley-Blackwell 01/01/1920 to present with a 12-month delay Acta Zoológica Mexicana Instituto de Ecologia A.C. 04/01/2001 to present Advances in Ecological Research Academic Press Inc. 07/01/2003 to present (citations only) African Journal of Herpetology Taylor & Francis Ltd 03/01/2009 to present (citations only) African Zoology Zoological Society of South Africa 01/01/1994 to present Agricultural & Forest Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 02/01/1999 to present with a 12-month delay al & Forest Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 02/01/1999 to present with a 12-month delay Amphibia-Reptilia VSP International Science Publishers 02/01/1999 to present Animal Conservation Wiley-Blackwell 02/01/2003 to present Annual Review of Entomology Annual Reviews Inc. 01/01/1997 to 2005 Anthrozoos 03/01/2005 to present Arthropod Structure & Development Elsevier Science 02/01/2002 to present (citations only) Audubon National Audubon Society 01/01/1984 to present Canadian Journal of Forest Research Canadian Science Publishing 01/01/2001 to present Canadian Journal of Zoology Canadian Science Publishing 01/01/2001 to present Canadian Wildlife (Canadian Wildlife Federation) Canadian Wildlife Federation 01/01/2001 to present Ciência Rural Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, Brazil 10/01/2008 to present Conservation Biology Wiley-Blackwell 02/01/1998 to present Contributions to Zoology National Centre for Biodiversity > NCB Naturalis 12/01/2007 to present Current Zoology Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences 02/01/2010 to present Ecological Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 02/01/1998 to present Entomological Science Wiley-Blackwell 03/01/2003 to present European Journal of Entomology c/o Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre, Czech Academy of Sciences 07/01/2007 to present European Journal of Forest Pathology Wiley-Blackwell 06/01/1971 to present Human Dimensions of Wildlife Taylor & Francis Ltd 01/01/2001 to present Insect Systematics & Evolution Brill Academic Publishers 10/01/2009 to present 23 Integrative Zoology Wiley-Blackwell International Journal of Zoology Hindawi Publishing Corporation 01/01/2009 to present International Wildlife National Wildlife Federation 07/01/1990 to 01/01/2002 International Wildlife National Wildlife Federation 01/01/1984 to 01/01/2002 Italian Journal of Zoology Taylor & Francis Ltd 03/01/2006 to present with a 12-month delay IUCN Otter Specialist Group Bulletin Otter Specialist Group Bulletin 10/01/2008 to present Journal of Animal Science American Society of Animal Science 07/01/1996 to present Journal of Applied Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 01/01/1998 to present Journal of Biology & Life Science (JBLS) Macrothink Institute, Inc, Toronto 08/01/2010 to present Journal of Herpetology Society for the Study of Amphibians & Reptiles 06/01/2003 to present Journal of Mammalogy Allen Press Publishing Services Inc. 02/01/2004 to present with a 12-month delay Journal of Wildlife Management Wiley-Blackwell 07/01/1990 to present, citations only Journal of Wildlife Rehabilitation International Wildlife Rehabilitation Council 12/01/2008 to present Journal of Zoological Systematics & Evolutionary Research Wiley-Blackwell 03/01/1998 to present Journal of Zoology Wiley-Blackwell 04/01/2003 to present with a 12-month delay Lynx, series nova National Museum, Czech Republic 06/01/2008 to present Mammal Review Wiley-Blackwell 03/01/1998 to present Medical & Veterinary Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 01/01/1998 to present National Wildlife National Wildlife Federation 02/01/1984 to present Natural History Natural History Magazine, Inc. 01/01/1974 to present Nature Canada Canadian Nature Federation 06/01/1990 to 06/01/2006, citations only Netherlands Journal of Zoology VSP International Science Publishers 02/01/1999 to present Northeastern Naturalist Humboldt Field Research Institute 03/01/2000 to present Oryx Cambridge University Press 01/01/1998 to present Pacific Conservation Biology Surrey Beatty & Sons, Australia 03/01/2011 to present Physiological Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 03/01/1998 to present Psyche: A Journal of Entomology Hindawi Publishing Corporation, New York 01/01/2009 to present Society & Animals Brill Academic Publishers 02/01/1999 to present with a 12-month delay South African Journal of Wildlife Research South African Wildlife Management Association 06/01/1994 to present 24 South African Journal of Zoology Zoological Society of South Africa 01/01/1994 to present Southeastern Naturalist Humboldt Field Research Institute 03/01/2002 to present Systematic Entomology Wiley-Blackwell 01/01/1998 to present Ursus International Association for Bear Research & Management 06/01/2007 to present with a 12-month delay Wilderness Wilderness Society 06/01/1990 to 12/01/1995 Wildlife Biology Wildlife Biology, Hornslet, Denmark 03/01/2010 to present Wildlife Conservation Wildlife Conservation Society 01/01/1992 to 05/01/2009 Wildlife Monographs Wiley-Blackwell 07/01/1990 to present, citations only Wildlife Society Bulletin Allen Press Publishing Services Inc. 06/01/1996 to 12/01/2006 Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society Wiley-Blackwell 01/01/2003 to present Zoological Science VSP International Science Publishers 01/01/2000 to 11/01/2003