SUBMISSION ON DRAFT NATIONAL WILDLIFE CORRIDOR PLAN by WESTERN CATCHMENT MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 1) General Comments on Draft The Western Catchment Management Authority (Western CMA) offers the following general comments of the Draft National Wildlife Corridor Plan (DNWCP): A focus of the document is the issue of fragmentation of habitat and re-establishment of connectivity to assist the movement of species especially under a climate change scenario, ostensibly through linking protected areas primarily through native vegetation management. However, habitat fragmentation is not a significant issue across the Western Catchment as approximately 95% of the area consists of intact native vegetation. Likewise, about 80% of mainland Australia is rangeland and is not suffering habitat fragmentation. The draft document recognises this to some degree on page 19 ‘Intact and Natural Landscapes’, but we emphasise that these intact landscapes comprise the major reservoir of biodiversity at a national scale. Within the rangelands, the presence of introduced predators is a far greater influence on wildlife survival compared with the availability of habitat and vegetation condition. The draft Plan provides no clear direction to address this key issue. Again on page 19 of draft under ‘Intact and Natural Landscapes’ we noted that there is no mention of unmanaged goats in reference to feral animals. We consider this a significant omission given the national scale of the feral goat issue. Western CMA recognises that unmanaged goats are the major impact on the management of natural resources in the Western Catchment and is in the process of developing a strategy to direct future responses to this issue. To inform the strategy, we have commissioned reviews of the ecology, legal status, economics and harvest industry implications of feral goats in the Western Rangelands as well as a 20 year population trend analysis. This information in addition to a forthcoming Australian Collaborative Rangelands Information System report demonstrate a burgeoning goat problem across NSW rangelands. Western CMA has invested approximately $10 million into feral goat management over the past six years through groundcover projects using Total Grazing Pressure (TGP) fencing and trapping facilities. However the scale of this investment has yet to result in landscape-scale improvement in groundcover or reduced goat numbers. The strategy will promote a more strategic, collaborative approach to managing the impact of goats more broadly at the landscape scale. On page 21, Figure 5 shows a large amount of red area in the Western Catchment as being held under Private Conservation agreements. Western CMA records do not reflect this level of conservation agreements. On page 45, Map 2 shows a large amount of medium fragmentation throughout the Western Catchment area. Higher levels of fragmentation is more confined to Darling Riverine Plains, Cobar Peneplain and Riverine biogregions were the Channel Country, Mulga Lands, Broken Hill Complex and Murray-Darling Depression bioregions should show low fragmentation due to being more intact landscapes. A key corridor for aquatic species within the Western Catchment is the Barwon-Darling River system. The viability of this national-scale corridor is highly vulnerable to upper catchment water extraction and connectivity is compromised by numerous barriers to fish passage. Further investment in this river system (such as through the Native Fish Strategy) is essential to achieve the objectives of this draft Plan. Office – 142 Brisbane Street, Dubbo – PO Box 1048, DUBBO NSW 2830 Principal Office - 62 Marshall Street, Cobar - PO Box 307 COBAR NSW 2835 Telephone: 02 6841 2740 - Facsimile: 02 6841 2799 - Website: www.western.cma.nsw.gov.au 2 2) National Wildlife Corridor Proposal for Appendix B: Western Rangelands of NSW Western CMA willprovide the following information for consideration for the Western Rangelands of NSW to be considered as a potential National Wildlife Corridor and to be added to Appendix B of the draft. Western Rangelands 2 The Western CMA is the largest in NSW, covering 230,000 km or 29 per cent of the state including 20% of the Murray Darling Basin and has a population of 18,000. The Western Catchment has primarily been used for grazing sheep on native pastures and is characterised by large properties and marginal climatic conditions. Environmental issues in the region include soil erosion, encroachment of Invasive Native Scrub and the decline of pasture and groundcover conditions, largely driven by high total grazing pressure resulting from unmanaged goats. Approximately 5% of the Far West and Central West Slopes Regions are protected within the Public reserve system. Landscape and Biodiversity The Western Rangelands of NSW contain vast tracts of relatively unmodified ecosystems, a wide diversity of native species and a large number of rare and endangered species (approximately 130 species of plant and animal species are listed as threatened). There are both production and biodiversity values that are dependent on the health of these rangelands. It is one of the most diverse rangelands areas in Australia. The Western Rangelands encompass a series of river systems including Barwon/Darling Culgoa, Paroo, Warrego, Narran, Bokhara, Birrie, Bulloo Overflow and part of the Bogan Rivers. The native vegetation includes open woodlands, chenopod shrub lands and native pastures. Whilst the Western Rangelands in NSW are largely intact in terms of native vegetation structure, relative to the extensively cleared temperate areas of the State, there has been a significant and continued decline in rangeland condition, landscape function and hence, biodiversity. The level of decline varies between bioregions, but accurately determining trends is difficult to separate due to climatic and management influence on rangeland condition. Too add, Western CMA has been working with landholders in the catchment on improving conservation on private lands complementing the reserve system through its on ground works including stewardship programs, river rehabilitation, native vegetation management, salinity programs, community education and support. Conservation Areas Approximately 5% of the Western Rangelands in NSW are under conservation reserves and include Paroo/Darling, Lake Mungo (world heritage listed), Gundabooka, Culgoa, Mutawinji National Parks and Yathong, Ledknapper, Kinchega, Nocoleche and Narran Lake nature reserves. The establishment of the reserve system is based on Comprehensive, Adequate and Representative (CAR) being three measures of how well the system samples and offers longterm protection for the range of biodiversity in a region. In the very high priority bioregions are the Darling Riverine Plain, Cobar Peneplain and Broken Hill Complex. The Mulga Lands bioregion is classified as high priority. Under the CAR system the target for extant ecosystems within these bioregions is 80% and currently percentages are approximately 50% and below. 3 The Darling Riverine Plains is the bioregion of most concern, having the lowest level of reservation and possibly the highest level of development pressure. Past and Current Pressures Because of a lack of reliable rainfall required for cropping, and the open structure of arid and semi-arid woodland communities, there has not been widespread clearing of the vegetation in the Western Catchment. However, a small number of plant communities (including myall woodlands, box woodlands and grasslands on black soil plains) along the eastern edge of the Catchment have been reduced in extent due to clearing. Much of the clearing has occurred in the highly fertile Darling Riverine Plains bioregion. However some clearing has also occurred in the Cobar Peneplain and other bioregions. This is the area where cropping is practiced on the margin of the wheat belt, so these plant communities are likely to be less depleted in the Western Catchment than they are further east or south. More pervasive than clearing is the decline in palatable flora across the Catchment due to longterm high total grazing pressure. This has caused serious modifications of some plant communities (including box woodlands, grasslands, shrublands and areas of mulga), lack of regeneration of some perennial species (including rosewood), degradation of the understorey, significant depletion and species loss and ultimately structural decline leading to loss of viable habitat. Unmanaged goat populations are a significant component of total grazing pressure. Recent data indicates that goat populations have doubled in the past decade to three million head. Total grazing pressure management projects funded by Western CMA have demonstrated a dramatic improvement in vegetation condition can be achieved within relatively short timeframes. Activities Currently two programs with implicit biodiversity conservation objectives operate in the Western Catchment, the landscape-scale Enterprise Based Conservation Program (EBC) and the site based High Conservation Value (HCV) program. The primary difference in approach is that for the EBC program is to develop conservation as commercially viable and alternative land-use in the Western Catchment through a long term return to the landholder. The HCV program focuses on the protection of high conservation value areas being more discrete and likely to be smaller in size than EBC sites. These two programs are the basis for achievement of Western Catchment biodiversity targets. In particular, the EBC program has generated a high level of landholder interest. EBC commenced as a conservation land use program in the Western Catchment in 2003 as part of the WEST 2000 Plus structural adjustment program to run for a period of 5 years and was extended for a further 4 years. The Western CMA EBC program continues today and is similar to WEST 2000 Plus program however with three basic changes to the project structure including funding period for 15 years and development of management agreements through statutory Property Vegetation Plans (PVP). The third change was that the area must be destocked completely were as the WEST 2000 Plus program allowed for destocking, but also incorporated grazing opportunities under Western CMA groundcover program. The relatively intact landscapes in the Western Catchment and the low level of reservation, presents an opportunity for bioregional planning. For this planning to be effective it must occur across the landscape and include all tenures to adequately reflect the scale and interconnection of ecosystem function and processes. An integral part of this planning is the implementation of the Western CMA EBC and HCV program. These programs can be targeted to complement and 4 enhance the existing reserve system and create new nodes in the landscape. These nodes should target ecosystems unrepresented or poorly reserved in the public reserves, or contain other high value habitats, particularly freshwater ecosystems and or areas of refuge. However future funding of the EBC program is not secure. The Western CMA has developed a proposal to set up a Rangelands Trust fund for EBC program and the broad scope of the proposal is that landholders sell grazing rights in exchange for conservation trust units from a Rangeland Trust. The Trust runs a commercial investment, generating market returns. This business case is still a proposal and differs from stewardship schemes in that it makes conservation an enterprise alongside agri-business. This business case and background report are availble at http://www.western.cma.nsw.gov.au/pages/Developconservationindustry.html. Governance and Community participants The NSW Biodiversity Strategy 2007 proposed the development of regional conservation initiatives as response to climate change and the continuing effects of past habitat loss and what the significant ongoing threats this poses to biodiversity in NSW. These initiatives will link existing efforts by agencies, CMA’s, NGO’s, volunteer community groups, indigenous groups, private individuals and others so that they contribute to priorities for connectivity within and between regions. Also establish large scale collaborative programs, provide guidance to agencies, industry, CMA’s and others on how to consider large-scale ecological processes and threats in similar landscapes. The Western Rangelands was one of two areas considered as a pilot for the first regional conservation initiative being area of high conservation priority at the State scale and proposal for the Western area is attached. Stephen Wolter Catchment Officer (Biodiversity) Western Catchment Management Authority