Aboriginal Affairs Victoria1 PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To recognise, protect and conserve Aboriginal cultural heritage in Victoria in ways that are based on respect for Aboriginal knowledge and cultural and traditional practices. To recognise Aboriginal people as the primary guardians, keepers and knowledge holders of Aboriginal cultural heritage. To accord appropriate status to Aboriginal people with traditional or familial links with Aboriginal cultural heritage in protecting that heritage. To promote the management of Aboriginal cultural heritage as an integral part of land and natural resource management. To promote public awareness and understanding of Aboriginal cultural heritage in Victoria. To establish an Aboriginal cultural heritage register to record Aboriginal cultural heritage. To establish processes for the timely and efficient assessment of activities that have the potential to harm Aboriginal cultural heritage. To promote the use of agreements that provide for the management and protection of Aboriginal cultural heritage. To establish mechanisms that enable the resolution of disputes relating to the protection of Aboriginal cultural heritage. To provide appropriate sanctions and penalties to prevent harm to Aboriginal cultural heritage. Enabling Acts and Regulations Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006 Aboriginal Heritage Regulations 2007 Aboriginal Lands Act 19702 Aboriginal Lands Act 19913 Total number of Acts 3 Total number of Regulations 1 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 0 Number Form Many Hardcopy and Electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation No Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting Annual External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) No ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS VICTORIA 35 Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Not applicable Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published No Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Permit to disturb or excavate land to uncover or discover Aboriginal cultural heritage No 40-50 days Approximately 50 days 40-50 days Permit to carry out scientific research on Aboriginal cultural heritage No 40-50 days Approximately 30 days 40-50 days Permit to harm Aboriginal cultural heritage No 40-50 days Approximately 60 days 40-50 days Permit to buy or sell an Aboriginal object No 40-50 days Approximately 60 days 40-50 days Permit to remove an Aboriginal object from Victoria No 40-50 days None 40-50 days Secretary to evaluate a Cultural Heritage Management Plan 30 days 30 days 27 days 30 days Type of activity Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 36 Not applicable VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency No Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Business unit of Department of Premier and Cabinet (DPC) Method of appointment By delegation from Secretary, DPC Number of members of governing body Not applicable Responsible Minister Minister for Aboriginal Affairs Department supporting Minister DPC Composition Composition of governing body legislated No Not applicable Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 0 0 0 27 22 26 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 1 0 0 Penalties imposed 1 1 0 Investigations Other operational information No. of staff (EFT)4 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Total expenditure ($ million) ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS VICTORIA 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 91 89 80 9 9 9 Not applicable 19.8 Not applicable 22.9 Not applicable 24.9 37 Permit’s, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically (%) Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Fees set by Permit to disturb or excavate land to uncover or discover Aboriginal cultural heritage Per excavation Regulations 8 fee units 2 Not available Permit to carry out scientific research on Aboriginal cultural heritage Per research Regulations 8 fee units 2 Not available Permit to harm Aboriginal cultural heritage Per activity Regulations 46 fee units 16 Not available Permit to buy or sell an Aboriginal object Per purchase or sale Regulations 13 fee units 0 Not available Permit to remove an Aboriginal object from Victoria Per removal Regulations 13 fee units 0 Not available Per Plan Act 0 Type of activity Secretary to evaluate a Cultural Heritage Management Plan Registered Aboriginal Party evaluate a Cultural Heritage Management Plan Per Plan Act Total 269 Various regulated fees go directly to the Registered Aboriginal Party 175 100 Not available 464 Contact details: Office of Aboriginal Affairs Victoria GPO Box 2392 MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Phone: 9208 3290 Email: aboriginal.affairs@dpc.vic.gov.au Internet: www.dpcd.vic.gov.au/aav 38 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 1 Regulatory activity mainly relates to the heritage responsibilities of the work conducted by the Office of Aboriginal Affairs Victoria (OAAV). A significant portion of this involves evaluating ‘cultural heritage management plans’ (when there is no relevant registered Aboriginal party) and ‘Cultural Heritage Permits’. OAAV's work also involves developing and delivering policy, programs and services that address Indigenous aspirations for land and cultural resources, increase understanding and respect for Indigenous culture within the broader community and promote Indigenous community control of the protection and management of Indigenous heritage and cultural property. When OAAV does undertake regulatory enforcement activities, work often involves negotiating agreements so that enforcement activity is not required. 2 This Act is administered by OAAV, however there are no regulatory activities derived from this legislation. 3 This Act is administered by OAAV, however there are no regulatory activities derived from this legislation. 4 The staff and budget information relates to the whole of OAAV operations and programs. About 35 staff operate in the regulatory framework around Aboriginal cultural heritage. ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS VICTORIA 39 Animal, Plant and Chemical Operations Branch PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To minimise the impact of plant pests and diseases on Victorian plant industries, with the aim of maintaining and expanding domestic and overseas markets. Enabling Acts and Regulations Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances (Industrial Hemp) Regulations 2008 Plant Biosecurity Act 2010 Plant Biosecurity Regulations 2012 Total number of Acts 2 Total number of Regulations 2 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 2 Number 16 Form Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation No Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting No External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes Yes1 Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes2 Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No 40 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published Yes3 Timeliness of regulatory process Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business No Less than 1 day Less than 1 day Less than 1 day Co-regulation/ accreditation facilitating movement of plants and plant products No Less than 2 weeks Less than 2 weeks Less than 2 weeks Permits to move specified plants and plant products into or out of control areas, into Restricted Areas, or into Victoria No No 1 day 1 day Permit to cultivate, possess and process low THC cannabis No No Not Applicable Not Applicable Type of activity Legally binding time limit Plant health certificates On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals No Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency No Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Yes4 Section 3 Structure Governance structure Governing body Internal Unit of the Department of Environment and Primary Industries (DEPI) Method of appointment Not applicable Number of members of governing body Not applicable Responsible Minister Minister for Agriculture and Food Security Department supporting Minister DEPI ANIMAL, PLANT AND CHEMICAL OPERATIONS BRANCH 41 Composition Composition of governing body legislated No Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Not Applicable Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations Yes Date of agreement 27 October 2011 Most recent review/revision 27 October 2011 Link www.dpi.vic.gov.au/aboutus/legislation/ministerial-statements-ofexpectations/soe-for-biosecurity-victoria Public reporting of performance against statement of expectations Yes Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 40 58 90 Investigations 38 57 89 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 30 14 57 4 9 8 Penalties imposed Other operational information 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 49 49 25 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable No. of staff (EFT) Total expenditure ($ million) 42 5.6 5.4 4.1 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Fees set by Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Act/ Regulations/ Orders Order >10 000 Not available 1 year Act Order 2935 Not available Permits to move specified plants and plant products into or out of control areas, into Restricted Areas, or into Victoria 1 year or per consignment Act/Order Not applicable >1200 Not available Permit to cultivate, possess and process low THC cannabis Up to 3 years Act Regulations 0 Not available Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Per consignment Co-regulation/ accreditation facilitating movement of plants and plant products Type of activity Plant health certificates Total Proportion lodged electronically >14 000 Contact details: Animal, Plant and Chemical Operations Branch PO Box 2500 BENDIGO DC VIC 3554 Phone: 136 186 Email: customer.service@dpi.vic.gov.au Internet: www.dpi.vic.gov.au 1 Response within 24 hours to pest and disease incidents. 2 Plant pest/disease control plans maintained to assist industry. 3 Refer to the Department of Environment and Primary Industries’ overall enforcement policy. See www.dpi.vic.gov.au 4 Memorandum of understanding on animal and plant quarantine measures; Commonwealth and all States and Territories (21 December 1995), Memorandum of understanding on Interstate Certification Assurance; Commonwealth and all States and Territories (6 August 1999). ANIMAL, PLANT AND CHEMICAL OPERATIONS BRANCH 43 Architects Registration Board of Victoria PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To register architects. To approve architectural companies and partnerships. To regulate the professional conduct of architects. To provide a procedure for handling complaints against architects. To control the title ‘architect’ and the phrases 'architectural services', 'architectural design services' or 'architectural design' in relation to the design of buildings or parts of buildings or the preparation of plans, drawings or specifications for buildings or parts of buildings. Enabling Acts and Regulations Architects Act 1991 Architects Regulations 2004 Total number of Acts 1 Total number of Regulations 1 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 11 Not legislated 12 Number Many Form Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting Annual External data sources/audit Yes Timeliness of regulatory processes Yes Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes Allocation of resources across regulatory functions Yes Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No 44 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes3 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published Yes Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Architect Registration No 30 days Not reported No Registration of an Architectural Partnership or Company No 30 days Not reported No Type of activity On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address Yes On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency No Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Board Method of appointment 2 by election of architects, 1 by nomination of schools of architecture, 1 by nomination of the Australian Institute of Architecture, 2 by nomination of the building industry, 2 by nomination of the Minister of Consumer Affairs, 1 by nomination of the allied professions, and 1 by nomination of the Senior Government Architect. Number of members of governing body 10 Responsible Minister Minister for Planning Department supporting Minister Department of Transport, Planning and Local Infrastructure Composition Composition of governing body legislated Yes Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Yes ARCHITECTS REGISTRATION BOARD OF VICTORIA 45 Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 5 13 10 24 29 31 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 3 3 0 Penalties imposed 2 3 0 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Investigations Other operational information 2009-10 No. of staff (EFT) 2010-11 3.8 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end 2011-12 3.6 4185 3.6 4309 4513 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) 0.74 1.10 1.27 Total expenditure ($ million) 1.12 1.27 1.24 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Fees set by Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Act/ Regulations Regulations 316 Not available Act/ Regulations Regulations 58 Not available Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Architect registration Annual Registration of an Architectural Partnership or Company Annual Type of activity Total Proportion lodged electronically 374 Contact details: Architects Registration Board of Victoria Level 7, 372 Albert Street EAST MELBOURNE VIC 3002 Phone: 9417 4444 Email: registrar@arbv.vic.gov.au Internet: www.arbv.vic.gov.au 1 Professional Conduct Regulations 2 The Australian Institute of Architects has a Code of Practice that governs members only. 3 Magistrates Court 46 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Automotive Alternative Fuels Registration Board PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To register businesses and accredit individuals to carryout Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG), Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) and Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) conversions on motor vehicles in Victoria and to ensure that they (the conversions) are carried out in accordance with the relevant Australian Standards. Enabling Acts and Regulations Road Safety Act 1986 Road Safety (Vehicles) Regulations 2009 Total number of Acts 1 Total number of Regulations 1 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 3 Number 31 Form Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation No Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes No Frequency of public reporting No External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) No Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities Yes Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No AUTOMOTIVE ALTERNATIVE FUELS REGISTRATION BOARD 47 Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies No Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published Yes Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business LPG Business Application No No Up to 14 days 30 days CNG Business Application No No Up to 14 days 30 days CNG Accreditation No No Up to 14 days 30 days LNR Registered Business No No Up to 14 days 30 days LNA Accreditation No No Up to 14 days 30 days On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. Yes On-line payment Yes On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes2 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Automotive Alternative Fuels Registration Board (AAFRB) Method of appointment Established under the Vehicles Standards Information Sheet No. 27 Number of members of governing body 6 Responsible Minister Minister for Transport and Roads Department supporting Minister Department of Transport (VicRoads) Composition Composition of governing body legislated No Stakeholder representatives present on governing body No 48 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 107 65 35 Investigations 107 65 35 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 3 2 0 Penalties imposed 3 2 0 Other operational information 2009-10 No. of staff (EFT) No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end 2010-11 2011-12 4 4 4 2460 2619 2546 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) 1.012 0.886 0.556 Total expenditure ($ million) 1.115 1.192 0.814 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Fees set by LPG Business Registration Annual AAFRB AAFRB 592 2% CNG Business Registration Annual AAFRB AAFRB 8 2% CNG Accreditation Annual AAFRB AAFRB 3 2% LPG Accreditation Annual AAFRB AAFRB 1893 2% LNR Registered Business Annual AAFRB AAFRB 24 2% LNA Registered Business Annual AAFRB AAFRB 26 2% Type of activity Total AUTOMOTIVE ALTERNATIVE FUELS REGISTRATION BOARD 2546 49 Contact details: Automotive Alternative Fuels Registration Board 5th Floor 464 St Kilda Road MELBOURNE VIC 3004 Phone: 9862 6700 Email: aafrb@aafrb.com.au Internet: www.aafrb.com.au 1 Australian Standards AS/NZS 1426-2007, AS/NZS2739-2003, AS2746-2008 2 Road Safety Act: VicRoads 50 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Building Commission PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To regulate for a safe, liveable and sustainable built environment Enabling Acts and Regulations Building Act 1993 Building Regulations 2006 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Regulations 2003 Total number of Acts 2 Total number of Regulations 2 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 2 Number Form 95 Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes1 Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting Annual External data sources/audit Yes Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes2 Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities Yes3 Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No BUILDING COMMISSION 51 Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes4 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes5 Enforcement strategy is published Yes6 Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Certificate of consent Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business 28 days 21days Not recorded No Commercial builder No 28 days Not recorded No Demolition builder No 28 days Not recorded No Domestic builder No 56 days Not recorded No Building inspector No 28 days Not recorded No Building surveyor No 28 days Not recorded No Draftsperson No 28 days Not recorded No Engineer No 28 days Not recorded No Quantity surveyor No 28 days Not recorded No Temporary structures erector No 28 days Not recorded No Building product No No Not applicable No On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address Yes Yes licences No permits On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. On-line payment Yes On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes7 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator Yes8 Not applicable Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Commission9 Method of appointment Ministerial appointment Number of members of governing body 1 (Commissioner) Responsible Minister Minister for Planning Department supporting Minister Department of Planning and Community Development 52 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Composition Composition of governing body legislated Not applicable Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Not applicable Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 629 652 619 Investigations 586 652 619 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 49 24 40 Penalties imposed 35 85 99 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 115 125 120 Other operational information No. of staff (EFT) No. of licensed/registered parties (at financial year end) 24 199 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Total expenditure ($ million) Not supplied Not supplied 2.2 2.3 2.4 26.6 28.4 29.6 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Certificate of consent 3 years Act/ Regulations Building Regulations 2006 8041 Not applicable Commercial builder Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 4461 Not applicable Demolition builder Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 289 Not applicable Domestic builder Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 14 837 Not applicable Building inspector Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 562 Not applicable Building surveyor Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 568 Not applicable Type of activity BUILDING COMMISSION Fees set by 53 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Fees set by Draftsperson Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 2346 Not applicable Engineer Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 2026 Not applicable Quantity surveyor Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 123 Not applicable Temporary structures erector Annual Act/ Regulations Ministers Guidelines 126 Not applicable Variable Act/ Regulations Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Type of activity Building product Total 33 379 Contact details: Building Commission PO Box 536 MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Phone: 1300 815 127 Internet: www.buildingcommission.com.au 1 Practitioner conduct inquiries, prosecutions, resolution of disputes. 2 Building permits, disputes and appeals, practitioner and levy collection. 3 Registered building practitioner awareness among consumers and non-registered practitioners and annual domestic consumer survey. 4 CAV, WorkCover, Victoria Police. 5 Enforcement strategy is primarily reactive/complaints based, practitioner performance audits are proactive and risk based. 6 www.buildingcommission.com.au 7 Major Domestic Building Contract Act: administered by Consumer Affairs Victoria- the Building Commission provides assistance. 8 Memorandum of Understanding: Department of Innovation, Industry and Regional Development (2008) 9 The governing body of the Building Commission consists of only one member, the Commissioner. However, the Building Regulations Advisory Council has stakeholder representation. 54 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Bureau of Animal Welfare1 PART A Section 1 Legislative Framework Objectives To regulate the use of animals in research and testing. To develop legislation, standards and codes of practice to prevent cruelty to animals. To develop legislation and codes of practice to protect the community from feral and nuisance dogs and cats, identify owners of dogs and cats, regulate dangerous dog ownership and to regulate domestic animal businesses. To regulate the microchip industry and data records of cats, dogs and horses. To regulate the management and care of cats and dogs by Council pounds and animal shelters. To develop legislation to regulate the impounding of livestock and the agistment of horses. Enabling Acts and Regulations Domestic Animals Act 1994 Domestic Animals Regulations 2005 Impounding of Livestock Act 1994 Impounding of Livestock Regulations 2008 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Regulations 2008 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Domestic Fowl) Regulations 2006 Total number of Acts 3 Total number of Regulations 4 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 342 Not legislated 73 Number Form 304 Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting Annual5 External data sources/audit Yes Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) No Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No BUREAU OF ANIMAL WELFARE 55 Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes6 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published No Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Scientific procedures premises licence No No 15 days 30 days Scientific procedures field work licence No No 15 days 30 days Specified animals breeding licence No No 15 days 30 days Licensed Microchip Registries No No 21 days 30 days Registered Council Businesses No No 21 days 30 days Type of activity On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator Yes7 Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No 56 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Internal unit of the Department of Environment and Primary Industries (DEPI) Method of appointment Not applicable Number of members of governing body Not applicable Responsible Minister Minister of Agriculture and Food Security Department supporting Minister DEPI Composition Composition of governing body legislated No Not applicable Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations Yes Date of agreement 27 October 2011 Most recent review/revision 27 October 2011 Link www.dpi.vic.gov.au/aboutus/legislation/ministerial-statements-ofexpectations/soe-for-biosecurity-victoria Public reporting of performance against statement of expectations Yes Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 0 1 1 1 35 45 1 24 12 3 40 57 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 0 1 1 Penalties imposed 0 0 1 Investigations Audits of scientific licences Audits of microchip registries, implanters, pounds and domestic animal Other operational information 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 3.1 3.1 2.2 No. of staff (EFT) General BUREAU OF ANIMAL WELFARE 57 Other operational information 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 Component relating Part 3 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (POCTAA) 2.4 2.5 2.4 Domestic Feral and Nuisance Animals Act 7.1 8.0 8.7 Impounding of Livestock Act 0.2 0.2 0.2 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end General 187 188 194 Component relating Part 3 of the POCTAA 163 183 189 Revenue from licences / registration ($ million) General 0.10 0.15 0.11 Component relating to Part 3 of the POCTAA 0.10 0.14 0.10 Total expenditure ($ million) 3.0 3.1 3.6 Bureau total budget ($ million) 3.4 3.4 3.7 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Fees set by Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Act/ Regulations Regulations 42 Not available 1 -3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations 24 Not available Specified Animal Breeding licence 1-3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations 2 Not available Licensed Microchip Registries 1-3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations 0 Not available Registered Council Businesses 1 year Act/ Regulations Regulations 1 Not available Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Scientific procedures premises licence 1-3 years Scientific procedures field work licence Type of activity Total Proportion lodged electronically 69 Contact details: Bureau of Animal Welfare 475 Mickleham Road ATTWOOD VIC 3049 Phone: 9217 4200 Email: animal.welfare@depi.vic.gov.au Internet: www.dpi.vic.gov.au/animalwelfare 58 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 1 The Bureau of Animal Welfare is a part of Biosecurity Victoria in the Department of Environment and Primary Industries (DEPI). 2 There are 34 codes of practice - 28 under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986 (POCTAA) (3 codes mandatory under Part 2, 3 codes mandatory under Part 3), and 6 mandatory under the Domestic (Feral and Nuisance) Animals Act 1994 (DFNAA). Livestock Management Regulated welfare Standards and Guidelines now replace livestock transport codes and the pig code. 3 There are six quality assurance programs in major livestock sectors — dairy, poultry broilers, poultry layers, pigs, livestock transport drivers and abattoirs. There is one quality assurance program for pet shops that are members of Pet Industry Association. All are voluntary to join and most producers are not members. 4 Advisory notes are usually developed along with the legislation and then circulated to all primary stakeholders. They are reviewed periodically often in response to practical experience in their implementation. Examples include the Restricted Breed Dog Guidelines booklet, instructions for appeals, guidelines for councils to implement cat and dog control legislation, liens in horses, rodeo requirements and instructions to vets, stock contractors and permit holders. 5 As part of Biosecurity Victoria’s annual reporting processes. The results of which are included in the DEPI Annual Report. 6 Enforcement of Part 2 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act is delegated to the DEPI Bio-security Division Animal Plant and Chemicals Operations Branch, the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA), local government and Victoria Police. Enforcement of the DFNAA is delegated to local government Councils except for the Licensing of Registries and Council’s own44Domestic Animal Businesses which is administered by DEPI Bureau of Animal Welfare. 7 Memorandum of Understanding with the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals BUREAU OF ANIMAL WELFARE 59 Business Licensing Authority PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To ensure that only eligible individuals and businesses enter the relevant industries. To screen entrants into these industries on a range of grounds aimed primarily at promoting consumer protection. To provide access to accurate public registers and information on licensing. Enabling Acts and Regulations Business Licensing Authority Act 1998 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 (permission applications re debt collectors and introduction agents) Conveyancers Act 2006 Conveyancers (Professional Conduct and Trust Account and General) Regulations 2008 Conveyancers (Qualifications, Experience and Fees) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents Act 1980 Estate Agents (Contracts) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Education) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Exemption) Regulations 2005 Estate Agents (Fees) Regulations 2007 Estate Agents (General, Accounts and Audit) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Professional Conduct) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Retirement Villages) Regulations 2006 Motor Car Traders Act 1986 Motor Car Traders Regulations 2008 Owners Corporations Act 2006 Owners Corporations Regulations 2007 Sex Work Act 1994 Sex Work Regulations 2006 Sex Work (Fees) Regulations 2004 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 1989 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Regulations 2008 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers (Exemption) Regulations 2006 Travel Agents Act 1986 Travel Agents Regulations 2007 Total number of Acts Total number of Regulations 60 9 16 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 0 Number 14 Form Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes1 Frequency of public reporting Annual External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes Yes Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities Yes Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes2 Risk based enforcement strategy Not applicable Enforcement strategy is published Not applicable Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Conveyancers Not applicable 35 days 27 days 4 to 6 weeks Estate agents Not applicable 35 days 22 days 4 to 6 weeks Estate agents representatives Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Motor car traders Not applicable 56 days 97 days 6 weeks Owners Corporation Managers Not applicable 7 days 8 days 7 days Sex work service providers Not applicable 175 days 180 days 6 months BUSINESS LICENSING AUTHORITY 61 Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Brothel Managers Not applicable 35 days 38 days 4 to 6 weeks Second-Hand dealers and Pawnbroker endorsement Not applicable 30 days 37.5 days 4 to 6 weeks Travel agents Not applicable 56 days 57 days 8 weeks On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address Yes On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. Yes On-line payment Yes On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes3 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator Yes4 Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Yes5 Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Authority is governed by a Chairperson and Deputy Chairperson Method of appointment Governor-in-Council appoints Chairperson, and Deputy Chairperson Number of members of governing body 2 Responsible Minister Minister for Consumer Affairs Department supporting Minister Department of Justice Composition Composition of governing body legislated Yes Stakeholder representatives present on governing body No Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations 62 No VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Part B Section 4 – Operational data Other operational information No. of staff 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 4.6 4.6 4.6 (EFT)6 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end 19 976 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Total expenditure ($ million)7 19 885 7.6 Not applicable 7.9 Not applicable 20 156 8.4 Not applicable Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Fees set by Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Act/ Regulations Regulations 69/603 Not available Estate agents Perpetual (annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Regulations 1104/9025 Not available Motor car traders Perpetual (annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Regulations 168/1454 Not available Sex work service providers Perpetual (annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Regulations 18/129 Not available Brothel Managers To be renewed every 3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations 187/921 Not available Exempt Providers Perpetual Act/ Regulations No Fee 243/189 Not available Second-hand dealers Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 354/3009 Not available Pawnbroker endorsement Perpetual (Annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Act Travel agents Perpetual (annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Regulations 59/556 Not available Owners Corporation Managers Perpetual (PI insurance, annual statement and fee) Act/ Regulations Regulations 55/475 Not available Type of activity Duration/ frequency Conveyancers Perpetual (annual statement) Total BUSINESS LICENSING AUTHORITY Requirements set by 1 Proportion lodged electronically Not available 2258/16 361 63 Contact details: Business Licensing Authority GPO Box 322B MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Phone: 1300 135 452 Internet: www.bla.vic.gov.au 1 Jointly with Consumer Affairs Victoria (CAV). 2 Consumer complaint and compliance and enforcement functions for each of the schemes are undertaken by other bodies. The Business Licensing Authority (BLA) mainly refers complaints to CAV and Victoria Police, depending on the scheme. While the BLA has the power to impose conditions or restrictions, it does not have any of its own enforcement powers nor can it initiate disciplinary proceedings before Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). 3 CAV: Conveyancers Act 2006, Estate Agents Act 1980, Motor Car Traders Act 1986, Owners Corporations Act 2006, Sex Work Act 1994, Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 1989, Travel Agents Act 1986. Victoria Police: Sex Work Act 1994, Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 1989. 4 Service agreement: Consumer Affairs Victoria (June 2010); Memorandum of Understanding: Legal Services Board (December 2007) 5 Contract for provision of criminal history information: CrimTrac (July 2009) 6 This figure includes the BLA Registrar and executive support. Staffing within Licensing Branch of CAV, which provides support to BLA are set out in CAV entry. 7 Expenditure across business licensing and registration schemes falls within CAV budget responsibility, and is set out in CAV entry. 64 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Children’s Services1 PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives To provide for the licensing and regulation of children’s services under the Children’s Services Act 1996 (Vic) and to approve and regulate education and care services that operate under the Education and Care Services National Law (Vic) 2010 2. To regulate the licensing, approval and operation of children’s services and education and care services, to ensure that children being cared for or educated by children’s services are safe, children’s developmental needs are met and their health and wellbeing is supported. Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Education and Care Services National Law Act 2010 Education and Care Services National Regulations Children’s Services Act 1996 Children’s Services Regulations 2009 Total number of Acts 2 Total number of Regulations 2 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 4 Number Form Many3 Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation No Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes No Frequency of public reporting Some information reported annually through Australian Children’s Education and Care Quality Authority (ACECQA) External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) No Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No CHILDREN’S SERVICES 65 Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies Yes Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes4 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published No5 Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Victorian Law – application for Approval of Premises (to operate a children’s service) 30 days6 Yes Not reported Yes Victorian Law – application for licence (to operate a children’s service) 30 days7 Yes Not reported Yes Commonwealth Law – Provider approval 60 days8 Yes Not reported Yes Commonwealth Law – Service approval for an education and care service 90 days9 Yes Not reported Yes Commonwealth Law – application for supervisor certificate 60 days10 Yes Not reported Yes Type of activity On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No11 On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment Yes12 On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes13 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Yes 66 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Department of Education and Early Childhood Development (DEECD) Method of appointment Not applicable Number of members of governing body Not applicable Responsible Minister Minister for Children and Early Childhood Development Department supporting Minister DEECD Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No14 Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 355 555 669 2442 2543 2858 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 3 4 2 Penalties imposed 0 4 2 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Investigations Other operational information No. of staff (EFT) 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 70 70 113 2394 2405 50 452 428 423 1189 Not available 3532 No. of licensed/approved parties at financial year end Standard (Vic law only) Limited Hours (Vic law only) Centre-based Outside school hours care Not available 899 School holidays care 94 Not available Family day care 21 106 123 Integrated (Vic law only) Not available 275 1 Short term (Vic law only) Not available 3 3 0.415 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) 0.8 0.8 Total expenditure ($ million) 5.7 6.5 CHILDREN’S SERVICES Not available 2 11.1 67 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Standard Service Licence Up to 5 years Act/ Regulation Regulation 106 Not available Limited Hours Licences (changed to limited hours licences on 25 May 2009) Up to 5 years Act/ Regulation Regulation 207 Not available Short Term Service Licences Up to 1 year Act/ Regulation Regulation 4 Not available School Holidays Care Licences Up to 5 years Act/ Regulation Regulation 0 Not available Integrated Licences Up to 5 years Act/ Regulation Regulation 38 Not available Family Day Care Service Approvals No specified end date (Annual Fee applicable) Act/ Regulation Regulation 21 Not available Centre-Based Service Approvals No specified end date (Annual Fee applicable) Act/ Regulation Regulation 60 Not available Provider Approvals No specified end date Act/ Regulation Regulation 38 Not available Supervisor Certificate No specified end date Act/ Regulation 2306 Not available Type of activity Fees set by Regulation Total 2780 Contact details: Children’s Services GPO Box 4367 MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Phone: 9637 2000 Email: edline@edumail.vic.gov.au Internet: www.education.vic.gov.au/earlychildhood 1 Since the implementation of the National Quality Framework (NQF) on 1 January 2012 the term Children’s Services includes education and care services administered under National Law and children’s services administered under Victorian law. The majority of children’s services in Victoria are now regulated under National Law (i.e. Education and Care Services National Law Act 2010 and Education and Care Services National Regulations). Children’s Services is located within the Early Childhood and School Education Group in the DEECD. 2 The Australian Children’s Education and Care Quality Authority (ACECQA) guides the implementation of the National Quality Framework for Early Childhood Education and Care nationally and promotes consistency in delivery. 3 Guidelines for Imposing Administrative Actions and Statutory Sanctions; Monitoring and Compliance Framework 2010; Prosecution Guidelines; ACECQA Operational Policy Manual for Regulatory Authorities 68 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 4 Victoria Police 5 Victorian Monitoring and Compliance Framework 2010 is not published however ACECQA Operational Policy Manual for Regulatory Authorities in relation to education and care services is available on the ACECQA website. 6 Additional 30 days if more information is required 7 Additional 30 days if more information is required 8 May be extended by up to 30 days with the agreement of the applicant 9 May be extended with the agreement of the applicant. 10 May be extended by up to 30 days with the agreement of the applicant 11 Under Victorian law, Children’s Services cannot change their address on-line. Providers of NQF education and care services are able to submit application forms to change address details on-line. 12 Online payment is available only to providers and certified supervisors that are prescribed under the National Law. 13 National Law only administered with the other jurisdictions. Victorian Law administered by Victoria. 14 ACECQA’s statement of expectations is publicly available on the ACECQA website: www.acecqa.gov.au 15 Under National Law, providers are charged annual fees for their services payable on or before 1 July each year. For 2011-2012 only, annual fees were not collected until August 2012 i.e. 2012-2013. CHILDREN’S SERVICES 69 Consumer Affairs Victoria PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives Consumer Affairs Victoria (CAV) is the State’s general consumer protection agency with the vision of informed and responsible consumers and traders. CAV’s four main goals in pursuing this vision are: Empowered consumers A competitive, fair and safe trading environment Protected vulnerable and disadvantaged consumers Optimised organisational capability Enabling Acts and Regulations Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Regulations 2012 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Associations Incorporation Reform Act 2012 Associations Incorporation Reform Regulations 2012 Business Licensing Authority Act 1998 Business Licensing Authority Regulations 2013 Business Names (Commonwealth Powers) Act 2011 Chattel Securities Act 19871 Chattel Securities (Purchase Price) Regulations 2008 Company Titles (Home Units) Act 2013 Consumer Credit Act 1995 (Vic) Consumer Credit (Administration) Regulations 2006 (Vic) Conveyancers Act 2006 Conveyancers (Professional Conduct and Trust Account and General) Regulations 2008 Conveyancers (Qualifications, Experience and Fees) Regulations 2008 Co-operatives Act 1996 Co-operatives Regulations 2008 Credit Act 1984 Credit Regulations 2004 Credit (Administration) Act 1984 Credit (Administration) Regulations 2004 Credit (Administration) (Committee) Regulations 2006 Credit (Commonwealth Powers) Act 2010 Domestic Building Contracts Act 19952 Domestic Building Contracts Regulations 2007 Estate Agents Act 1980 Estate Agents (Professional Conduct) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (General, Accounts and Audit) Regulations 2008 70 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Estate Agents (Contracts) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Education) Regulations 2008 Estate Agents (Exemption) Regulations 2005 Estate Agents (Retirement Villages) Regulations 2006 Estate Agents (Fees) Regulations 2007 Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012 Fundraising Act 1998 Fundraising Regulations 2009 Funerals Act 2006 Funerals (Infringements) Regulations 2011 Goods Act 1958 Goods (Revocation) Regulations 2004 Motor Car Traders Act 1986 Motor Car Traders Regulations 2008 Owners Corporations Act 2006 Owners Corporations Regulations 2007 Partnership Act 1958 Partnership (Limited Partnerships) Regulations 2003 Residential Tenancies Act 19973 Residential Tenancies Regulations 2008 Residential Tenancies (Rooming House Standards) Regulations 2012 4 Retirement Villages Act 1986 Retirement Villages (Contractual Arrangements) Regulations 2006 Retirement Villages (Records and Notices) Regulations 2005 Sale of Land Act 1962 Sale of Land Regulations 2005 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 1989 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Regulations 2008 Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers (Exemption) Regulations 2008 Sex Work Act 1994 Sex Work Regulations 2006 Sex Work (Fees) Regulations 2004 Subdivision Act 19885 Travel Agents Act 1986 Travel Agents Regulations 2007 Veterans Act 20056 Veterans (Patriotic Funds) Regulations 2008 Warehousemen’s Liens Act 1958 Total number of Acts 30 Total number of Regulations 36 CONSUMER AFFAIRS VICTORIA 71 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 1 Not legislated 0 Number 226 Form Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes Frequency of public reporting Annual External data sources/audit Yes Timeliness of regulatory processes Yes Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) Yes Client satisfaction with regulator activities Yes Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects Yes Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes7 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published Yes Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Business names8 No 95% within 3 weeks Not applicable Not applicable Incorporated associations9 No 90% within 1 month 92% within 4 weeks No Incorporated cooperatives10 No 90% within 4 weeks 90% within 4 weeks 21 days 21 days 21 days 21 days 21 days No 21 days Not reported 21 days No 21 days Not reported 21 days No 14 days Not reported 14 days No 14 days Not reported 14 days Fundraisers Patriotic Limited Funds11 partnerships12 Retirement Funeral 72 Villages13 Providers14 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address Yes15 On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. Yes16 On-line payment No17 On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes18 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator 19 Yes20 Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Yes Section 3 Structure Governance structure Governing body Director21 Method of appointment Appointed pursuant to the Public Administration Act 2004 Number of members of governing body 1 Responsible Minister Minister for Consumer Affairs Department supporting Minister Department of Justice Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations Yes Date of agreement 16 March 2013 Most recent review/revision May 2013 Link www.consumer.vic.gov.au/about-us/statementof-expectations-reducing-red-tape Public reporting of performance against statement of expectations Yes Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals22 Investigations23 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced25 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 19 897 19 528 17 405 8482 5415 80 89 81 643124 Penalties imposed Criminal proceedings 77 32 31 Infringement Notices 130 50 29 CONSUMER AFFAIRS VICTORIA 73 Other operational information No. of staff (EFT) 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 438.9 452.5 421.8 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end 428 737 436 132 Business names27 389 667 395 952 0 35 991 36 756 37 605 707 698 685 1415 1777 1805 Limited partnerships 167 174 199 Retirement villages 400 397 404 Funeral service providers 380 378 385 Incorporated association Incorporated cooperatives Fundraisers Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) to consolidated funds 15.3 To trust funds28 Total expenditure ($ million) 41 08326 14.2 14.5 7.10 7.3 8.0 92.829 97.9 105.5 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Type of activity Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Business names30 3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations 60 408 Not available Incorporated associations Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 1608 Not available Incorporated cooperatives Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 28 Not available 3 years Act/ Regulations Regulations Patriotic funds Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 0 Not available Limited partnerships Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 32 Not available Retirement villages Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 8 Not available Funeral service providers Perpetual Act/ Regulations Regulations 7 Not available Fundraisers Total Fees set by 657/270 Not available 62,748/63,018 Contact details: Consumer Affairs Victoria GPO Box 123A MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Phone: 1300 558 181 Email: consumer@justice.vic.gov.au. Internet: www.consumer.vic.gov.au 74 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 1 Part 3 of the Chattel Securities Act 1987 is administered by the Minister for Roads. 2 Part 5 of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 is administered by the Attorney-General. 3 Sections 23A-25, 27, 32, 33, 45–48, 74–77, 82, 90, 91A, 102, 102A, 103, 104(1),104(4), 104(5), 105(2A), 105(3), 124, 128, 130–134, 141–142B, 142D-212, 213AA,-215, 230, 232–234, 241, 277, 289A, 291–327, 329333, 335–339, 341, 343–366, 373–376, 385, 388, 388A, 390, 390A, 395–398, 399A-439M, 486–499, 501–504, 505A-510C and 511. Section 66(1) is jointly administered with the Minister for Housing .This Act is otherwise administered by the Attorney-General, the Minister for Housing and the Minister for Planning. 4 Made by the Minister for Housing. 5 Part 5 s 43 only. This Act is otherwise administered by the Minister for the Environment and Climate Change and the Minister for Planning. 6 Part 4 only. This Act is otherwise administered by the Minister for Veterans’ Affairs. 7 Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Australian Securities and Investment Commission, State and Territory Consumer Protection agencies, Victoria Police and local councils 8 Business names transactions have been transferred to Commonwealth effective 28 May 2012. 9 Includes transactions related to registrations, updates, and annual returns Actual figures are based on Financial Year 2011-12. 10 Includes transactions related to updates and annual returns Actual figures are based on financial year 2011-12. 11 Due to the low volume of applications and wide variability in processing times, a grade of service measure is not reported. 12 Due to the low volume of applications and wide variability in processing times, a grade of service measure is not reported 13 Same as above. 14 Same as above. 15 Business names, incorporated associations. 16 Business names 17 It is anticipated that incorporated associations online lodgement capability will be operational towards the end of 2013 18 Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Australian Securities and Investment Commission, State and Territory Consumer Regulators: Australian Consumer Law; Department of Treasury and Finance; Trustee Companies Act 1984 and Trustee Companies Regulations 2006. 19 Agreements listed include Memoranda of Understanding and major agreements with other regulatory agencies. List does not include agreements with funded agencies (both casework and policy advocacy), grant recipients or non-regulatory agencies or agreements still under development. 20 Victoria Police (2008), Municipal Association of Victoria (2008), Sustainability Victoria (2008), Legal Services Board (Victoria) (2008), Business Licensing Authority (2008), Building Commission (Victoria) (2007), Essential Services Commission (2010), Office for the Registration of Aboriginal Corporations (2006), Aboriginal Affairs Victoria (2006) 21 Under the Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) s98 there is to be a Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria who is employed under Part 3 of the Public Administration Act 2004. The Director is supported by Consumer Affairs Victoria; a division of the Department of Justice. 22 The figures represent the number of cases registered under dispute resolution stage from the date they were received or entered into the system. 23 The figures reported under this heading includes the number of ‘inspections and investigations’ held during the financial year, as per the Victorian Budget,2011-12 Budget Paper Number 3. 24 Includes total inspections and investigations including estate agents, premises inspected for unsafe/banned products and rooming houses, as published in the Consumer Affairs Victoria Annual Report 2011-12. 25 The figures reported under this heading includes prosecutions and civil actions finalised, as published in the Consumer Affairs Victoria Annual Report. 26 From 28 May 2012, business names registration was administered by the Commonwealth (through ASIC). CONSUMER AFFAIRS VICTORIA 75 27 As above. 28 Does not include transfers, penalties, recoveries or interest. 29 The Promoting and Protecting Consumers total output cost for 2009-10 was $159m, which includes $70.1 million for grants, and $16.2m for Responsible Alcohol Victoria. 30 Registration of business names has now gone to a national regime as part of Council Of Australian Governments reforms. 76 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Council of Legal Education PART A Section 1 – Legislative Framework Objectives The Council of Legal Education and the Board of Examiners jointly regulate entry into the legal profession in Victoria. Enabling Acts and Regulations Legal Profession Act 2004 Legal Profession (Admission ) Rules 2008 Public Notaries Act 2001 Total number of Acts 2 Total number of Regulations 1 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 0 Not legislated 0 Number Form 17 Not supplied Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation No Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes No Frequency of public reporting External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies No Risk based enforcement strategy No Enforcement strategy is published No COUNCIL OF LEGAL EDUCATION 77 Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to applicants Approval of academic law providers/courses None None variable 6 months Approval of practical legal training providers/courses None None variable 6 months Assessment of qualified overseas applicant None 6 weeks 6-8 weeks 6 weeks Skills assessment for qualified overseas practitioners None 6 weeks 6-8 weeks 6 weeks Type of activity On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Not applicable Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator No Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Board Method of appointment Governor in Council Number of members of governing body 14 Responsible Minister The Attorney-General Department supporting Minister Department of Justice Composition Composition of governing body legislated Yes Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Yes Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations 78 No VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Investigations Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Penalties imposed Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Other operational information 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 No. of staff (EFT) 8 8 8 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end 9 9 9 Revenue from licences/registration ($ millions) - 0.0024 0.0030 Not supplied Not supplied Not supplied Total expenditure ($ million) Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed 2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Approval of academic law providers/ courses Not supplied Admission Rules No fees 6 Not available Approval of practical legal training providers/ courses Not supplied Admission Rules No fees 2 Not available Assessment of qualified overseas applicant Not supplied Admission Rules The Council 37 Not available Skills assessment for qualified overseas practitioners Not supplied Admission Rules The Council 87 Not available Type of activity Total COUNCIL OF LEGAL EDUCATION Fees set by 132 79 Contact Details: Council of Legal Education 451 Little Bourke St MELBOURNE VIC 3000 Phone: 9604 2408 Email: colevic@justice.vic.gov.au Internet: www.lawadmissions.vic.gov.au 80 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Country Fire Authority PART A Section 1 Legislative Framework Objectives To prevent and suppress fires and protect life and property (Section 20 Country Fire Authority Act 1958 (Vic)). Enabling Acts and Regulations Country Fire Authority Act 1958 Country Fire Authority Regulations 2004 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Building Act 1993 Building Regulations 2006 Planning & Environment Act 1987 Dangerous Goods Act 1985 Dangerous Good (Storage and Handling) Regulations 2000 Occupational Health & Safety (Major Hazard Facilities) Regulations 2000 Residential Tenancies (Caravan Parks and Movable Dwellings Registration and Standards) Regulations 2010 Liquor Control Reform Act 1998 Total number of Acts 5 Total number of Regulations 5 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 1 Not legislated 1 Number Form Many Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Outcome measures for regulation Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Frequency of public reporting Reported No Yes Annual External data sources/audit No Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) No Allocation of resources across regulatory functions No Unit costs of key regulatory process No Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities No COUNTRY FIRE AUTHORITY 81 Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No1 Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies Yes2 Risk based enforcement strategy Yes3 Enforcement strategy is published No Timeliness of regulatory process Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Permit to light a fire for miscellaneous purposes No No Not supplied Not supplied Registration of a fire brigade No No Not supplied Not supplied Fire safe inspections No No Not supplied Not supplied Type of activity On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. No On-line payment No On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals No Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes4 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator Yes5 Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator No Section 3 Structure Governance structure Governing body Board Method of appointment Ministerial Appointment Number of members of governing body 10 Responsible Minister Minister for Police and Emergency Services Department supporting Minister Department of Justice 82 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Composition Composition of governing body legislated Yes Stakeholder representatives present on governing body Yes Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations No Part B Section 4 – Operational data Other operational information 2009-10 No. of staff (EFT) 1636 2010-11 1754 2011-12 1885 No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Total expenditure ($ million) 378.0 396.8 460.1 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Proportion lodged electronically Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Permit to light a fire for miscellaneous purposes Per fire Regulations Not Applicable 1413 Not available Registration of a fire brigade Ongoing Act/ Regulations Not Applicable 28 Not available Fire safe inspections Ongoing Building Code of Australia Regulations 745 Not applicable Fire Safety Inspections Ongoing Dangerous Goods Regulations Agreement with WorkSafe Victoria 78 Not applicable Caravan Fire Safety Inspections Ongoing Moveable dwelling Regulations Regulations 192 Not applicable Type of activity Total Fees set by 2456 Contact details: Country Fire Authority PO Box 701 MT WAVERLEY VIC 3149 Phone: 9262 8444 Internet: www.cfa.vic.gov.au COUNTRY FIRE AUTHORITY 83 1 However, benchmarking of Country Fire Authority (CFA) is currently undertaken by the Productivity Commission. There are similar fire services in other States and Territories that operate in rural areas with a volunteer base, but none that have the significant volunteer component that CFA does. 2 Fire prevention enforcement functions and permits for fires during the declared fire danger period under CFA legislation, as well as planning permit requirements are mostly carried out by local government. Additionally, the municipal building surveyor is responsible for enforcement of fire safety regulations relating to buildings and structures, although CFA might provide technical expertise. 3 The enforcement strategy consists of proactive inspections as capacity allows and CFA Officers supporting local government and fire prevention officers in the discharge of their duties. There is however no documented strategy. 4 CFA undertakes activities under various pieces of legislation, fire prevention officers administer s. 40F of the Country Fire Authority Act 1958 and Victorian Police prosecute breaches of the Act. 5 Memorandum of Understanding with WorkSafe regarding Dangerous Goods 84 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Dairy Food Safety Victoria PART A Section 1 Legislative Framework Objectives To ensure that standards which safeguard public health are maintained in the Victorian dairy industry. To ensure that the dairy industry performs its functions and exercises its powers efficiently and effectively. Enabling Acts and Regulations Dairy Act 2000 Additional Administered Acts and Regulations Food Act 19841 Total number of Acts 2 Total number of Regulations 0 Other regulatory instruments and guidance materials Codes of Practice Guidance publications available to stakeholders Legislated 1 Not legislated 0 Number Form 402 Hardcopy and electronic Section 2 – Operational information Public reporting of key performance indicators Reported Outcome measures for regulation Yes Outcome measures integrated into internal planning processes Yes3 Frequency of public reporting Annual, website4 External data sources/audit Yes5 Timeliness of regulatory processes No Number of key activities (e.g. returns processed, appeals considered etc.) Yes Allocation of resources across regulatory functions Yes6 Unit costs of key regulatory process Yes Measures of administrative burden on regulated entities (e.g. firms, professionals etc.) No Client satisfaction with regulator activities Yes7 Indicators compared with interstate or similar Victorian bodies No Quantitative evaluation reported for regulatory initiatives/projects No DAIRY FOOD SAFETY VICTORIA 85 Enforcement strategy Related administration or enforcement functions undertaken by other bodies No Risk based enforcement strategy Yes Enforcement strategy is published Yes Timeliness of regulatory process Type of activity Legally binding time limit Target time period for processing applications Actual time to process applications Expected processing time advised to business Dairy distributors licence No No No No Dairy farm licence No No No No Dairy food carrier licence No No No No Dairy manufacturers licence No No No No Milk broker licence No No No No On-line public access to information On-line access to licensing and/or registration information Yes On-line change of address No On-line renewal of licences/permits etc. Partial8 On-line payment Yes On-line access to information on lodging complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Yes Relationship with other agencies/regulators Acts/Regulations administered jointly with another agency Yes9 Formal agreement with other Victorian agency/regulator Yes10 Formal agreement with Commonwealth agency/regulator Yes11,12 Section 3 – Structure Governance structure Governing body Board Method of appointment Minister (Chair and Departmental Representative) Minister on Selection Committee recommendation Number of members of governing body 7 Responsible Minister Minister for Agriculture and Food Security Department supporting Minister Department of Environment and Primary Industries Composition Composition of governing body legislated Yes Stakeholder representatives present on governing body No13 86 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 Ministerial Statement of Expectations Publicly available ministerial statement of expectations Yes Date of agreement 6 Dec 201114 Most recent review/revision Not Applicable Link www.dpi.vic.gov.au/aboutus/legislation/ministerial-statements-ofexpectations/soe-for-dairy-food-safety Public reporting of performance against statement of expectations Yes Part B Section 4 – Operational data Enforcement activities Operational activity Complaints about regulated firms/ professionals Investigations 2009-10 0 44 Disciplinary actions/prosecutions commenced 0 Penalties imposed 0 2010-11 2011-12 51 4115 4 416 0 14/217 0 218 Other operational information 2009-10 No. of staff (EFT) No. of licensed/registered parties at financial year end Dairy farms Manufacturers (including milk brokers) Carriers Distributors 22 2010-11 2011-12 21.8 22.4 5205 150 4603 164 4575 167 38 135 37 130 39 125 Revenue from licences/registration ($ million) Revenue from fee for service activity 3.58 0.66 3.78 0.69 4.07 0.77 Total expenditure ($ million) 4.32 4.37 4.71 DAIRY FOOD SAFETY VICTORIA 87 Permits, licences, approvals, certification and registration activity Type of activity Duration/ frequency Requirements set by Fees set by Number issued/ renewed (2011-12) Board 128 Not reported individually Proportion lodged electronically Dairy distributors licence 12 months Act/Code of Practice for Dairy Food Safety Dairy farm licence 12 months – Sheep/ Goat, Direct payment farmers 24 months – all others Act/Code of Practice for Dairy Food Safety Board 27819 Not reported individually 12 months Act/Code of Practice for Dairy Food Safety Board 39 Not reported individually 12 months Act/Code of Practice for Dairy Food Safety Board 172 Not reported individually 12 months Act/Code of Practice for Dairy Food Safety Board 3 Not reported individually 62020 14.2% Dairy food carrier licence Dairy manufacturers licence Milk broker licence Total Contact details: Dairy Food Safety Victoria PO Box 840 HAWTHORN VIC 3122 Phone: 9810 5900 Email: info@dairysafe.vic.gov.au Internet: www.dairysafe.vic.gov.au 1 The Food Act 1984 (Vic) (Food Act) applies to non-dairy aspects of mixed businesses licensed with Dairy Food Safety Victoria (DFSV), administered by DFSV as authorised officers under the Food Act 2 Includes 6 documents (guidelines, manuals) published under the Dairy Authorities Technical Advisory Committee, Australian New Zealand Dairy Authorities’ Committee, or its predecessor Australian Dairy Authorities’ Standards Committee 3 Publicly reported as from financial year 2012-13 4 Includes reporting to relevant industry forums 5 Independently certified to ISO 9001:2008 6 Publicly reported as from financial year 2012-13 7 Publicly reported as from financial year 2012-13 8 Farms are renewed by electronic transfer of information from the manufacturers that they supply. All other renewals are paper based 88 VICTORIAN REGULATORY SYSTEM 2013 9 Australian Quarantine Inspection Service: Export Control (Milk and Milk Products) Orders 2005 (Commonwealth ). 10 Memoranda of Understanding: PrimeSafe, Department of Health, Municipal Association of Victoria, Environmental Health Australia (Victorian Division) (In place since Oct 2004); Department of Environment and Primary Industry (Biosecurity Victoria Division) (in place since January 2007); Environment Protection Authority (2010). 11 Memorandum of Understanding with Department of Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry, Tasmania Dairy Industry Authority, Dairy Authority of South Australia (2012) 12 Other Memoranda of Understanding – Tasmanian Dairy Industry Authority and Dairy Authority of South Australia; New Zealand Food Safety Authority 13 Skill set required is specified, (e.g. expertise in on farm milk production, dairy food manufacture) but does not dictate that members are from the actual stakeholder base. 14 Date of DFSV response to the Statement of Expectations 15 Until 2010 complaints were categorised as investigations 16 Investigations into unlicensed activities 17 Until financial year 2010-11 this was measured as prosecutions only. Current figure includes Orders placed to stop production or halt movement of product, and enforcement audit regimes imposed 18 Two $5,000 penalties were imposed. 19 Bovine farms are on a fixed 2 year licence period. This year was the second year of this cycle 20 Number issued = new licenses + transferred licensees + annual renewals. There were an additional 165 licence cancellations DAIRY FOOD SAFETY VICTORIA 89