Mission Note November-December, 2014
India Water Resources Management Program - Hydrology Project Phase 3
World Bank Identification Mission
November-December, 2014
I.
Introduction:
1.
On September 2014, the Department of Economic Affairs (DEA), Ministry of Finance,
Government of India has requested World Bank assistance for a follow-on Project (HP-III) to the
recently concluded Hydrology Project Phase II (HP-II). The letter dated September 1, 2014 has
proposed a budget of INR 3000 crores [US$ 370 million Bank assistance and USD 130 Million
GoI i.e. 30% counterpart funding by Ministry of Water Resources, River Development & Ganga
Rejuvenation (MOWR, RD & GR) and/or states]. The proposal shared by DEA is attached for
reference and available relevant material is also posted on the project’s website
(www.indiawrm.org).
2.
HP-II closed on May 31, 2014, and was implemented in 13 states and 8 central agencies,
predominantly in Central and Southern India. The Hydrology Project has been central to efforts
in India to improve the planning, development and management of its water resources, as well as
flood forecasting and reservoir operations in real-time. The project - having completed two
phases (Phase I from 1996 to 2003 and phase II from 2006 to 2014) - has successfully
established the backbone of a comprehensive Hydrological Information System (HIS) in India,
providing scientifically verified, uniformly accepted and widely accessed hydrological records
covering all aspects of the hydrological cycle. More important even than the improvement and
standardization of the country’s hydro-meteorological and geo-hydrological monitoring systems,
the project was instrumental in promoting a paradigm shift from relatively isolated water
resources development towards comprehensive planning, development and management of water
resources in a river basin context. The Hydrology Project has established a platform for water
agencies in India to learn from each other, and has encouraged them to modernize existing
hydro-meteorological monitoring systems, move from manual to Real-Time Data Acquisition
Systems (RTDAS), and develop tools for Integrated Water Resources Planning and
Management, with the objective to enhance the productivity and cost effectiveness of water
related investments. For the first time in the country, in three river basins, climate forecasts have
been integrated with stream flow forecasts and reservoir operations, which has improved
forecasting lead times significantly and thus allows additional time to prepare for flood
management and improve reservoir operations.
3.
Based on the successful outcome of the Phase II project, the Government of India has
now proposed to expand the project to the States in the Ganga and Brahmaputra Basins, The
proposed project would not only strengthen the existing monitoring systems for water
availability, but also include the monitoring of water use and put much emphasis on IWRM and
real-time monitoring and flow forecasting. Details of proposed project HP-III is given in
Annexure 1.
Page 1 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
II.
Implementation Arrangement:
Nodal Implementing
Agency
MoWR, RD & GR
*Project Coordination Secretariat (PCS) to with housed here.
Implementing
Agencies (IAs)
‒
‒
Project Duration
States and UTs across India
10 Central Agencies (including MoWR RD & GR, CWC,
CGWB, NIH, IMD, CPCB, SoI, NRSC, CWPRS, and BBMB).
* IAs are to formulate Project Management Unit (PMU) for
the coordination and execution of the project.
8 Years
Participation in HP-3
‒
Based on the fulfilment of the “ readiness criteria”, the
IAs will be allocated budget in the HP-3.
Allocation of project
budget to IAs
‒
At the start of project, budget will be allocated to IAs
based on their “readiness criteria”.
Thereafter, the budget allocation will be based on their
performance and needs.
The project is designed to be flexible and will be
reviewed and updated on annual basis. Well performing
agencies will be given preference during budget reallocation.
‒
‒
Project
Implementation Plan
(PIP) preparation
‒
‒
III.
It is mandatory to use the PIP template by all IAs and
duly submitted to MoWR, RD & GR in the stipulated
time.
Proposed activities in PIP should be prepared in 2
Phases. The activities under Phase 1 will be taken up first
on priority basis and Phase 2 activities will be considered
based on the performance of the IAs.
Timeline and clearances of project
4.
MoWR RD & GR has already taken clearance from the Planning Commission.
Implementing agencies need not to take any central clearance. The Central Project Management
Unit (CPMU) of MoWR RD & GR shall compile the Project Implementation Plan (PIP) and will
arrange for the EFC clearance at central level. The states do need to comply with their own State
Clearance procedures prior to submitting the final project documents including the PIP.
However, they may share the preliminary draft proposals prior to such clearance to expedite the
project preparation process. Funding arrangements for implementing agencies shall be
shared by MoWR RD & GR. As per DEA communication, the understanding is that out of
Page 2 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
total project budget of INR 3000 crores, 30% (INR 1000 crore) would be funded by participating
agencies including MoWR, RD & GR and participating central and state agencies.
5.
GR:
The following tentative time schedule has been agreed with the States and MoWR, RD &
S. No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Activity
Itemized Cost estimate by
Implementing Agencies (IAs)
First draft of PIP
Finalization of PIP by MoWR RD & GR
Submission for EFC clearance
EFC Clearance
Project Appraisal
Negotiation
Submission to World Bank Board for
clearance
Effectiveness
Due by
November 15, 2104
December 15, 2014
January 15, 2104
February 2015
March 2015
May 2015
July 2015
August 2015
September, 2015
IV.
Readiness
6.
Kindly refer to the DEA recommendations for readiness conditions, according to which
the following major actions would require immediate attention:
a. Project management/implementation unit at each agency should be strengthened in
line with the requirement of project. Please refer to the organization charts of HP-II
agencies as examples for strengthening HP institutions (in particular Maharashtra,
Himachal Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh - Groundwater).
b. 30% of bid documents should be ready to be awarded.
c. Major consultancies for the first two years of the Project should be awarded prior to
effectiveness.
7.
Retroactive financing would be permissible for agreed expenditures incurred during
one year prior to effectiveness of the project, provided that the procurements are made
using World Bank procedures. Therefore, the project agencies are advised to proceed with the
initiation of activities as needed and process requests for budgets within this year in their
systems.
8.
The IAs must immediately formulate their PMU by deputing relevant staff and start
preparing the Project Implementation Plan (PIP) for its submission to MoWR, RD & GR.
Page 3 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
V.
Consultation with the states/implementing agencies:
9.
The World Bank Team1 had extensive discussions with the participating States and
Central agencies during September 18-19, 2014 and November 16-22, 2014, and reviewed
proposals for the follow-on project. Prior to this meeting, during September 15-17, two
workshops were organized wherein international and national agencies and consultants shared
information on the latest available monitoring equipment for hydro-meteorology, as well as
information on available tools and modeling software for flood forecasting and management,
surface-groundwater interaction, water resources planning and management, and the use of
relevant Earth Observation products. Detailed proceedings are available on the project’s website.
10.
In between short visits have been conducted by the World Bank team to several states
including Assam, Bihar, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Maharashtra, Gujarat, West Bengal,
Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka and Uttar Pradesh.
11.
A Regional Consultation Workshop for the states of Ganga-Brahmaputra basins and
North-East India was held in Kolkata during 17-18 November 2014 which was hosted by West
Bengal DWRID. Mission team would like to thank DWRID for their excellent arrangement.
Almost 10 states participated in the workshop.
12.
Regional meeting-cum-working session on HP-3 and PIP preparation for the southern
states was held in Bangalore during 1-3 December 2014 where engineers from Tamil Nadu,
Karnataka, Kerala, Puducherry and Goa participated. The World Bank team would like to thank
the Karnataka Water Resources Department for their excellent arrangement.
13.
Similar regional meeting-cum working session on PIP preparation for the Northern states
was held in Delhi during 4-5 December 2014 which was participated by engineers from
Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana, Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh.
14.
Based on the Bank’s team interaction with the states engineers, it is understood that
the states of Maharashtra, Rajasthan, Bihar, Himachal Pradesh and Goa are in advance
stage of readiness for HP-3 and has already submitted their PIP proposal for review to the
World Bank and MoWR, RD & GR.
VI.
Regional workshop Proceedings:
15.
Dr. Amarjit Singh, Additional Secretary, MoWR RD & GR chaired the Regional
Workshop in Kolkata (during 18 Nov 2014) and provided an overview of the key issues the
Ministry have recognized and would like address during HP-3.
i. Ground water use: 16% blocks in India are over exploited which are equivalent to 1056
blocks. In the North East, the number of tube wells is going down as electrical prices
rise. Need for the hour is to search for alternative sources of energy to sustain and
promote irrigation.
ii. Water demand: the current annual water consumption for India is estimated 730 BCM
which is projected to rise to 1130 BCM. There is a great need to evaluate where the
1
Mission Members Mmes/Messrs: Anju Gaur Sr. Water Resources Specialist and Task Team Leader; William
Young, Lead Water Resources Management Specialist; Satya Priya, Nagaraja Rao Harshadeep, Tapas Paul and,
World Bank Consultants: Johan Grijsen, Chabungbam Rajagopal Singh, Carter Borden, KAS Mani, C.S. Renjit and
Padmakar Kelkar.
Page 4 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
x.
xi.
maximum stress is occurring and will occur in the future for effective planning of the
limited water resources.
Water use efficiency in irrigation: Most irrigation systems in the country have been
estimated to have efficiency ranging between is 16- 38%. Looking into the projected
rapid increase in water demand in the future, large emphasis must be given in
development of more efficient and effective irrigation systems in the country.
Flooding: Due to rapid growth of population, the floodplains of many major rivers of
India are been encroached upon leading to occurrence of devastation flood events on
annual basis. This has called for development of concrete strategies for management
flooding in the country.
Transforms data into decision making: Priority must be given in developing tools and
technologies for converting the hydro-meteorological data collected by various central
and government agencies into information for supporting decision making.
Water Quality: Water quality continues to decline in many river and reservoir systems
(e.g. the arsenic contamination in ground water resources of West Bengal). To better
understand and manage the pollution, proper tools and better laboratory equipment need
to be established.
Capacity building of all stakeholders including setting-up of Centers of Excellence for
Water Resources Management in each state to spread the usefulness of the scientific
knowledge.
Public-private options for management: Many problems can be effectively addressed
by incorporating public entities into the solution. These should be examined.
Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM): It is imperative to involve all
water users for effective and holistic management of the resources. This is inclusive of
women folks.
Enhancing collaboration between Centre & States as well as between states.
Improving access to information in the public-domain.
16.
The key points discussed with the states representatives during the regional
workshops/meetings are:
i.
States recognize the need of river basin management for proper water resources planning
and in particular flood management. Both upper and lower riparian states indicated their
interest to exchange the data for flood management and planning the water distribution.
ii.
The states were keen on developing their PIP but needed some guidance and support
from PCS for securing administrative approvals.
iii.
The states particularly new ones could use guidance in following:
a. Training on the World Bank procurement procedure for new states as they were
not clear even to engage expert to help them.
b. Design of HIS: The states needed guidance in designing the HIS system: optimal
number of stations; site selection and instrument specifications (please do refer
Page 5 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
HP2/1 Manuals). Specifications are also provided in the website. Latest example
bid document will also be shared with the states.
iv.
All participating states were introduced the PIP Cost Table Template prepared by the
World Bank Team in consultation with MoWR, RD & GR during the workshops and
meetings. The states are further advised to revise their HP-3 PIP proposal and
submit (as per template format) to MoWR, RD & GR at the soonest possible for
their comments and finalization.
VII.
Preparation for HP3
17.
In order to be ready for HP3, all agencies will be required to have following:


Submit Project Implementation Plan (PIP) to MoWR, RD & GD
Have institutions ready – set-up Project Management Unit immediately. A sample
of the Organizational Chart of a typical PMU is provided in Annexure 2. It should
be noted that the project allows the IAs to hire individual consultants for technical
help including preparation of bid documents.
18.
The overall Action Plan for the preparation of HP3 along with the role of involved
agencies is given below (Table 1):
VIII. Preparation of project implementation Plan (PIP)
19.
The List of IAs and their overall status of the preparation of PIP documents is enclosed in
Annexure 3.
20.
The PIP shall include following documents:
a. Cost estimate template: it is an excel based template which was last updated on
Dec 4, 2014 and posted on web.
b. Report describing the plan
c. MIS for institutional setup and HIS
21.
World Bank team had a trial run with State of Maharashtra and Rajasthan. These
examples are being shared with all other agencies.
Page 6 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Table 1: Action Plan for HP-3 Operationalization
S.
no
Activities
Action taking
Agency
Deadline
MoWR, RD & GR,
GOI
15-Dec-14
MoWR, RD & GR
30-Mar-15
States and
Central Agencies
MoWR, RD & GR
30-Mar-15
Dec14
Institutional Set-up
1
2
3
4
Letter to all IAs with instructions
about HP-3 including Funding
Pattern
Formulation of PCS/ Central Project
Management Unit (CPMU)
Formulation of Project
Management Unit (PMU)
Procurement of Technical and
Management Consultant (TAMC)
i. Finalization of TAMC TOR
16-Feb-15
ii. Preparation of TAMC Tender
Document
iii. Tendering of TAMC biddocument
iv Award of TAMC contract
5
20-Apr-15
30-Apr-15
30-Sep-15
Project Preparation and Clearances
i. PIP EFC Clearance
MoWR, RD & GR
30-Apr-15
ii. CCEA Approval
MoWR, RD & GR
25-May-15
iii. HP-3 Project Appraisal
MoWR, RD & GR
and World Bank
MoWR, RD & GR
and World Bank
15-Jun-15
iv. HP-3 Project Negotiation
15-Jul-15
Page 7 of 18
Jan15
Feb15
Mar15
Apr15
May15
Jun15
Jul15
Aug15
Sep15
Mission Note November-December, 2014
S.
no
6
Activities
v. Clearance of HP-3 Project by
World Bank Board
Effectiveness of HP-3 Project
Action taking
Agency
Deadline
World Bank
31-Aug-15
ALL
21-Sep-15
Dec14
Preparation of PIP
7
Finalization of overall PIP template
World Bank
22-Dec-14
8
All IAs
15-Dec-14
9
Submission of itemized Cost
Estimation by IAs (PIP cost table)
Submission of 1st Draft of PIP
All IAs
15-Jan-15
10
Finalization of PIP and compilation
MoWR, RD & GR
along with World
Bank & IAs
14-Feb-15
15-Jan-15
Finalization of Equipment
specification
HP-2 states +
some new
states**
HP-2 states +
some new states
Formulation of tender/bid
document
HP-2 states +
some new states
14-Mar-15
Approval of Tender Document and
Procurement Plan
MoWR, RD & GR
and World Bank
29-Jun-15
Tendering of bid-documents for HIS
All IAs
30-Sep-15
Award Tender
MoWR, RD & GR
and IAs
30-Sep-15
Tendering of Major Contracts
11
HIS Tendering*
Identification of sites
14-Feb-15
Page 8 of 18
Jan15
Feb15
Mar15
Apr15
May15
Jun15
Jul15
Aug15
Sep15
Mission Note November-December, 2014
S.
no
Activities
Action taking
Agency
Deadline
Dec14
Jan15
Feb15
Mar15
Apr15
May15
Jun15
Jul15
Aug15
Sep15
Support/ Capacity Building
12
13
14
Finalization of HIS Guideline with
Specifications
Training course on Hydro-met
instrumentation
Training course on WB procurement
procedure
World Bank
30-Jan-15
New IAs
(conducted by
WB)
New IAs
(conducted by
WB)
09-Feb-15
30-Jan-15
* - HIS is the major component, however IAs are welcome to tender other major Consultancies and Goods.
** - New states to take part in early tender includes Bihar, UP, Rajasthan and West Bengal; other new states are welcome to put forward early tenders.
Page 9 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
IX.
Guidance material for preparation of project proposal
22.
The following reports have been posted on the project website (www.indiawrm.org) for
the reference:
a. HP-2 Preparation documents: PIP (Project Implementation Plan), Project Appraisal
Document (PAD) and Project Completion Reports of selected agency. In particular
the new HP agencies may refer to the documents for Goa and Himachal Pradesh who
were well performing new states in HP-2
b. Key procurement documents during HP-2
c. Outline of proposed project
d. HP-3 PIP Cost Table Template
e. Example of cost estimates prepared by selected agencies.
23.
Cross learning: The new HP States were mapped with the existing HP States in order to
enable them to seek guidance in project preparation (Annexure 4). Irrespective of such mapping,
the new states are advised to visit existing HP States and learn from their best practices in
various fields.
Page 10 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Annexure -1
Outline of proposed project
Project Development Objective would be to “improve the scope and accessibility of water
resources data and information and to strengthen water resources planning and management in
selected institutions across India”.
Outcome indicators: Proposed PDO outcome indicators are:
‒ Volume of data stored and accessible online through the National WRIS
‒ Number of states uploading and accessing data through the National WRIS
‒ Number of registered users of National WRIS and volume of data downloads
‒ Number of river sub-basins in which flood risk has been reduced
‒ Number of water management agencies using water resources assessments to guide
water resource planning and/or operations
‒ Number of river sub-basins with water resource assessment reports.
Description of the project: Based on the successes previous phases of project, the GoI wishes to
expand these efforts to cover the entire country including the states of the Indus, Ganga and
Brahmaputra basins2. HP-III will further improve and expand monitoring systems for water
availability and water use. It will emphasize real-time monitoring for operations, flow
forecasting, integrated water resource planning on a river basin basis and strengthening of
community-based groundwater management. HP-III will contribute to the GoI’s Digital India
initiative by integrating across state and central agencies.
Building on the earlier phases, HP-III will include the following:
a. Database standardization: a national information center and center of excellence
will be established to standardize databases and associated procedures and to
integrate hydro- meteorological and water use data of the country.
b. Transparent and reliable water data: real-time and automated monitoring with
online delivery for reliable and transparent data access in support of operational
management.
c. Balanced centralized and decentralized support: the project will provide both
generic national solutions (through central agencies) and specific state-based
solutions.
d. Operational systems: state-level operational systems will be put in place for flood
Page 11 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
management and irrigation distribution.
e. River basin approach: IWRM on a river basin basis will be promoted to devise
appropriate solutions for planning investments and developments.
f. Flexible design: the project will support performance based funding allocations and
flexibility in program to address the needs of states.
g. Cross learning: cross-learning among states will be continued including transferring
knowledge from HP-II state agencies to new HP-III agencies.
Major Components: The project will consist of the following four components:
Component A: Improving In Situ Monitoring System (IMS): USD 300 million.
This component will expand and upgrade water resources monitoring systems, bolster database
population and maintenance, develop community-based data collection and water management,
and conduct site specific surveys to the states in the Indus, Ganges and Brahmaputra Basins and
in North-East India. This will include:





In situ real time/automated monitoring systems (weather, river, reservoir, canal,
groundwater and water quality) ;
Community-based hydrological monitoring and management system;
Implementation of protocols developed by central agencies (CWC, CGWB and CPCB)
for inter-agency data sharing, data validation and analytical quality control procedures
for water quality laboratories;
Establishment of National Water Information Center though upgrading and expansion of
database software on web-based centralized systems for data entry, data storage, data
management and data dissemination, developed under HP-II (including India-WRIS);
and
Targeted surveys such as i) priority reservoir sedimentation surveys, ii) bathymetric
surveys in river stretches with critical flooding issues, iii) groundwater exploration and
aquifer mapping for selected areas, and iv) water quality and waste load surveys, to
assess the load, fate and transport of critical constituents within water quality hotspots.
The output of this component would be a national Water Resources Monitoring System.
Component B: Improving Spatial Information System (SIS): USD 80 million
The component will strengthen and make available remote sensing and spatial information data
to water managers and stakeholders through providing and processing of spatial data sets,
creating tools for tailor-made processing of spatial data, and developing web-based portals for
public access to information. Development of centralized spatial data sets will largely be
produced by ISRO/NRSC, IMD and Survey of India (SOI) with the dissemination of the
information via a publicly accessible, web-based portal for non-classified data. Products to be
developed include:

Digital Elevation Model (DEM) for the entire country for improved flood hazard
mapping and other planning purposes,
Page 12 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014



Local high resolution surveys (such as LIDAR) for flood prone areas to support flood
risk mapping and management action plans,
Satellite based estimates of water balance parameters including climate, land use,
irrigation water requirement, and flood assessment
Publicly accessible, web-based portal for non-classified data.
The output of this component will be centralized Water Resources Information System (WRIS)
customized with respect to various users including public, state agencies and other departments.
Component C: Promoting Water Resources Operation and Management Applications
(WROMA): USD 50 million
This component will ensure the usefulness of the WRMS and WRIS data sets through decision
support systems (DSS) for river basin planning, water balance assessments, climate risk
assessments, water quality management, scenario analysis for investment planning, and tools for
community based groundwater management. It will develop short-term and seasonal flow
forecasts, establish multiple flood/flow forecasting systems important for operation of reservoirs
and flood management, and introduce on pilot basis operation and water distribution systems for
irrigation systems.
Flagship knowledge products will include IWRM plans for selected river basins, a report on the
status of India’s water resources, including water balance assessments, water quality
assessments and support purpose driven studies (PDS) on specific issues for each IA, including
climate risk assessments for present and planned water resources infrastructure.
Component D: Strengthening Water Resources Institutions and Capacity Building (WRICB):
USD 70 million
Component D will strengthen and build capacity in the participating Implementing Agencies
(Water Resources Institutions) through establishing Water Resources Knowledge Centers and
providing infrastructure and ITC equipment, capacity building and extensive training programs,
supporting project management through Technical Assistance and Management Consultancies,
and funding of incremental staff. In particular, the project will support the establishment of
National Water Information Center (upgraded version of India WRIS) and center of excellence at
National and state levels. The National Water Information Center will provide a central platform
for integration and exchange of water data across the country and will ensure the sustainability of
data management. MoWR RD&GR had established India WRIS through their own resources and
they are committed to continue National water information center after the project. In addition,
the project will support strengthening of irrigation training Institutes for improved water
management practices.
Page 13 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Annexure 2:
Organizational Chart of Goa
Chief Engineer
Water Resources Dept
Project Co-coordinator
Superintending
Engineer
Circle I, Panaji
Nodal Officer
Sr Hydro
geologist
G.W. In charge
Hydro-Geologist1
Asst. HydroGeologist-1
SDII, WD I
Porvorim
TA-1, JE-3
Data Manager
Data Center &
Laboratory
In charge
Executive Engineer III
S.W &
Hydrometeorology,
Procurement In
charge
Surface Water
Asst Hydrologist.2
TA-2,
SDIII, WD II
Quepem
TA-1, JE-3
SDI, WDIII
Bicholim
TA-1, JE-3
SD II, WD III
Ponda
TA-1, JE-3
SD III, WD III
Margao
TA-1, JE-3
Page 14 of 18
Technical Cell
ASW-2
Asst.
Hydrogeologist-1
TA-2, JE-2
Ground Water
Asst HydroGeologist.-1
TA-2
Chemist
Lab. Attendant-35
Supervisor-10
Helper-10
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Annexure 3:
Status of IAs PIP Preparation
(as of 12 Dec 2014)
Sl.
Implementing Agencies
Template
1st Round
Discussion
2nd Round
Discussion
States
1
Andhra Pradesh (SW)
YES
YES
2
Andhra Pradesh (GW)
YES
YES
3
Assam
YES
YES
YES
4
Bihar (GW)
YES
YES
YES
5
Bihar (SW)
YES
YES
YES
6
Chhattisgarh
YES
YES
7
Goa
YES
YES
8
Gujarat (GW)
YES
YES
9
Gujarat (SW)
YES
YES
10
Haryana (GW)
YES
YES
11
Haryana (SW)
YES
YES
12
Himachal Pradesh
YES
YES
13
Jharkhand
YES
YES
14
Karnataka (GW)
YES
YES
15
Karnataka (SW)
YES
YES
16
Kerala (GW)
YES
YES
17
Kerala (SW)
YES
YES
18
Madhya Pradesh
YES
YES
19
Maharashtra (GW)
YES
YES
YES
20
Maharashtra (SW)
YES
YES
YES
21
Manipur
NO
NO
22
Meghalaya
YES
YES
23
Mizoram
YES
YES
24
Nagaland
YES
YES
25
Odisha (GW)
YES
YES
26
Odisha (SW)
YES
YES
27
Punjab
YES
NO
28
Rajasthan
YES
YES
29
Sikkim
YES
NO
30
Tamil Nadu
YES
YES
31
Telangana (GW)
YES
YES
Page 15 of 18
YES
YES
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Sl.
Implementing Agencies
Template
1st Round
Discussion
32
Telangana (SW)
YES
YES
33
Tripura
NO
NO
34
Uttar Pradesh (GW)
YES
NO
35
Uttar Pradesh (SW)
YES
NO
36
Uttarkhand
YES
NO
37
West Bengal (GW)
YES
YES
38
West Bengal (SW)
YES
YES
UT
39
Andaman
NO
NO
40
Chandigarh
NO
NO
41
Dadra and Nagar Haveli
NO
NO
42
Daman and Diu
NO
NO
43
Delhi
NO
NO
44
Lakshadeep
NO
NO
45
Puducherry
YES
YES
Central Agencies
46
MoWR
YES
YES
47
CWC
NO
NO
48
CGWB
NO
NO
49
NIH
YES
YES
50
CWPRS
NO
NO
51
BBMB
YES
YES
52
DVC
NO
NO
53
IMD
NO
NO
54
SOI
NO
NO
55
NRSC
NO
YES
Page 16 of 18
2nd Round
Discussion
Mission Note November-December, 2014
Annexure 4:
Summary of proposals and mentors agreed with participating agencies
(Listed below are the agencies who participated in the mission, the remaining agencies are advised to
share their proposal at the earliest)
S. No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
New
State
Mentors**
X
X
X
Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu
Gujarat
Maharashtra, Gujarat
X
X
Himachal Pradesh, Goa
Himachal Pradesh, Goa
C
GW
SW
GW
SW
GW
SW
X
Gujarat, Goa
Meghalaya
C
X
Mizoram
MP
Nagaland
Orissa
Orissa
Pondicherry
Punjab
C
C
C
GW
SW
C
C
X
Goa, Karnataka, Himachal
Pradesh
Goa
X
Goa
Institution
Andhra
Pradesh
Andhra
Pradesh
Assam
Bihar
Bihar
Chhattisgarh
Goa
Gujarat
Haryana
Haryana
Himachal
Pradesh
Jharkhand
Karnataka
Karnataka
Kerala
Kerala
Maharashtra
Maharashtra
Departments
GW
SW
SW
GW
SW
C
C
C
GW
SW
C
Page 17 of 18
Mission Note November-December, 2014
S. No.
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
Institution
Rajasthan
Sikkim
Tamil Nadu
Telangana
Telangana
Uttar
Pradesh
Uttarakhand
West Bengal
West Bengal
CWC
CWPRS
BBMB
NIH
NRSC/ISRO
CPCB
SOI
PCS
CGWB
New
State
Mentors**
X
Himachal Pradesh
GW
X
Maharashtra, AP
SW
X
Maharashtra, AP
C
GW
SW
X
X
X
Himachal Pradesh
Kerala, Maharashtra
Kerala, Maharashtra
Departments
C
C
C
GW
SW
@ SW: Surface Water, GW: Ground water, C: combined
*Mentor state: These are just suggestions, the states are advised to visit several states and
can have more than one mentor and take expert help from each agency.
Page 18 of 18