Enterprise for Development (EfD) series on models of best practice for socially and environmentally sustainable private enterprise and social enterprise Case study: Jacaranda Health Background Kenya has a large and growing urban population (11 million in 2013 and growing at 4% per year), particularly in Nairobi where the population has grown from 862,000 in 1980 to 3.4 million 2009.1,2 Evidence suggests that the dramatic increase in the slum and peri-urban populations in and around Nairobi has been accompanied by increasing rates of poverty and poor health outcomes.3 Figure 1: Typical peri-urban settlement Public provision of health services to these populations is limited, with the vast majority of providers being private for-profit institutions – the latter are mostly unlicensed clinics and maternity homes, with no working guidelines or standard protocols for services.4 Despite the low quality of services provided, many women choose to deliver in such facilities, due to both a lack of alternative options and the low cost of delivering in these facilities. Jacaranda business model Figure 2: Jacaranda maternity hospital Jacaranda Health (Jacaranda) is a nonprofit social enterprise focused on providing comprehensive, integrated, low cost and high quality maternal and newborn healthcare in Africa. Services are provided through maternity hospitals with 12 to 15 beds, equipped with a laboratory, pharmacy and the essential equipment needed for delivery and postnatal care. Services provided include antenatal care, delivery and postnatal care, newborn care and child wellness care, as well as family planning services. 1 World Bank data. http://www.unicef.org/sowc2012/pdfs/SOWC-2012-Focus-On-Maternal-and-Child-Health.pdf 3 Ibid. 4 Ibid. 2 1 Figure 3: Jacaranda client Jacaranda’s target customers are women that are often the primary breadwinner for their families living on approximately $3-$7 per day. They usually work in the informal sector (e.g. as domestic help, vegetable sellers or shop-owners), or are lower-middle class professionals (e.g. factory workers, security guards or school teachers). They are busy, cost-conscious women, who must carefully balance the demands of pregnancy and visits to clinics with taking care of their families and their businesses. The business model is designed to be highly sustainable and scalable, generating revenue through affordable user fees while continually innovating in the following areas to minimise operating costs and improve efficiency: Human resources: Jacaranda places particular emphasis on training nurses to be strong leaders and managers, from handling obstetric emergencies to running clinical case reviews and quality initiatives. Non-financial incentives for hiring and retention, as well as models for task shifting and task sharing, are also being tested, with a view to disseminating knowledge on the utility of such practical facility-based approaches to improving service delivery efficiency. New technology: Jacaranda is developing, testing and introducing a series of technology interventions to help get to know clients, guide clinical decision-making, and improve efficiency. This includes mobile phone technology, electronic medical records, and mechanisms to improve the financial accessibility of services. Patient-centred care: Jacaranda brings models of best practice for providing maternal health care from around the world into low resource settings, and is instilling a culture of respectful maternity care in its facilities. This includes tailoring clinical safety guidelines to the resources and cultural background of clients, training staff in customer service, engaging men in decision making processes, providing home visits, and exploring new ways to improve education and birth planning, such as group antenatal care education and mobile phone health messaging. Quality improvement: Jacaranda is developing a set of practical and tested tools that healthcare providers in all low-resource settings, including Jacaranda itself, can use to deliver high quality, low cost, patient-centred maternity care. This includes evidence-based protocols and tools, regular clinical case and chart reviews, measuring impact through a mobile phone database and electronic medical records, and building decision support tools into electronic health record systems to help nurses manage care in emergencies and increase adherence to obstetric protocols. 2 Jacaranda past, present and future Jacaranda opened their first maternity hospital for low-income women in 2012. This hospital is in Ruiru, a peri-urban area on the outskirts of Nairobi, and has proven successful in delivering high quality care, receiving one of the highest ratings for care quality of any health facility in Kenya. Jacaranda opened their second facility in 2014 in Kahawa West, a Nairobi suburb. With an established and skilled team, facilities and equipment in place, key partnerships formed, and a very popular service offering (almost 1,000 patients visiting Jacaranda’s facilities each month), Jacaranda are looking at options to further scale and replicate their service offering. Figure 4: Jacaranda staff Firstly, Jacaranda aim to create direct impact at scale by expanding the network of Jacaranda maternity hospitals and developing them as ‘centres of excellence’. There are however some constraints to scaling the business in this manner alone – principally that setting up a new maternity hospital is time and capital intensive. nJacaranda is also considering initiating management partnerships as a mechanism to deliver a defined package of maternal and newborn health services through existing health providers. Such an arrangement would allow Jacaranda to instil its business and clinical practices in a health facility, without owning the facility or the equipment. This would be a much quicker and less capital intensive approach to scaling Jacaranda’s operations, albeit with considerable risks associated with successfully negotiating and initiating such a management partnership. For this reason, Jacaranda is currently pursuing this option with caution and anticipates undertaking groundwork to create the model and undertake a market landscape assessment before entering into such an arrangement. To achieve further impact at scale, Jacaranda aim to influence the practices of other health providers operating in the region by promoting the work of the Jacaranda facilities as centres of excellence. Jacaranda also intend to make available their evidence-based tools and systems for improved efficiency and quality of service delivery in other public and private health facilities. 3