FOI/2014/119 SCHEDULE OF RECORDS Date From To No. Pages Document Type Decision Release/Partrelease/Refuse Part-release 1 13.10.14 T Palmer Peterson of Dublin via Peter Mathews TD Minister Varadkar 5 Submission, letter and official response 2 08.10.14 Minister Varadkar 11 Submission and letter Release 3 07.10.14 M Chorlins US Chamber of Commerce via Minister for Foreign Affairs & Trade D Drennan NFRN via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 6 Submission and email Release 4 06.10.14 J O’Loughlin Smurfit Kappa Ireland Minister Varadkar 5 Email letter and official response Release 5 02.10.14 T Palmer Peterson of Dublin Minister Varadkar 4 Letter and official response Release 6 01.10.14 Minister Varadkar 8 Submissions, letter and enclosures Release 7 30.09.14 S Mitchell Joint Committee on Jobs Enterprise & Innovation via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation D McGrane James Fox Ltd, also via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 9 Email submissions letter and official response Release 8 23.09.14 A O’Dowd ECMI Ltd via Michelle Mulherin TD Minister Varadkar 4 Submission letter and official response Part-release 9 10.09.14 A Babic Foreign Investors Council in Croatia also via Taoiseach & Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Minister Varadkar 8 Submissions, letters Release Reason for PartRelease or Refusal Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. 1 Innovation 10 27.08.14 W Stacey AmCham Czech Republic via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 2 Submission and letter Release 11 25.08.14 L M Munnigh Dominican Republic via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 5 Submission and letter Release 12 11.08.14 Minister Varadkar 11 Submissions, letters and final response Release 13 29.07.14 O Nicolescu via Taoiseach, Minister for Finance, Minister for Justice & Equality S Carty, Topaz/Daybreak Minister Varadkar 8 Email and final response Part-release 14 29.07.14 S Verheyen MEP via an Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 5 Submission, email letter and final response Release 15 24.07.14 Minister Varadkar 12 Submissions, letters and final response Release 16 24.07.14 H Yasaman, Yasaman Law Firm via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Finance, Taoiseach, D Poturnay, food Chamber of Slovakia via an Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 4 Submission letter and final response Release 17 28.07.14 J Wancer AmCham Poland via an Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 7 Submission, letter and final response Release 18 24.07.14 M Ozgener Aegean Exporters’ Associations via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Finance Minister Varadkar 11 Submissions emails and final response Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record. 2 19 22.07.14 20 18.07.14 21 18.07.14 22 18.07.14 23 18.07.14 24 18.07.14 25 11.07.14 26 11.07.14 R Morgan ASH Ireland, also via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Kathleen Lynch TD, Taoiseach, Minister for Finance, Minister for Environment Community & Local Government J Sweeney via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 29 Letter submissions enclosures and final response Release Minister Varadkar 6 Submission letter and final response Release Firat Izgi Attorney Partnership via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Finance, Taoiseach S Crolla AmCham Italy via Taoiseach Minister Varadkar 9 Submissions letters and final response Release Minister Varadkar 5 Submission letter and final response Release Z Dereli TABA/AmCham Turkey via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Taoiseach, Minister for Justice & Equality, Minister for Finance S Namura Japan Intellectual Property Association via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation E Ryan via Anne Ferris TD, Minister for Finance Minister Varadkar 27 Submissions letters and final response Release Minister Varadkar 7 Submission email and final response Release Minister Varadkar 12 Submissions emails enclosures and final response Part-release Raftery’s Centra Claregalway via Noel Grealish TD Minister Varadkar 6 Submission email and final response Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record. 3 27 07.07.14 M Corbett Suir Vending via Noel Coonan TD Ministers Reilly & Varadkar 12 Submissions letters and final response Part-release 28 04.07.14 P Konstiak Slovak Association of Commerce & Tourism via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Taoiseach T Palmer via Tánaiste Minister Reilly 8 Submissions letters and final response Release 29 02.07.14 Minister Reilly 9 Submission letter enclosure and final response Part-release 30 01.07.14 L Overath via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Justice & Equality T Palmer Peterson of Dublin via Jerry Buttimer TD Minister Reilly 19 Submissions letters and final response Release 31 27.06.14 Minister Reilly 8 Submission letter enclosure and final response Release 32 24.06.14 B Goodlatte via US Ambassador, Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Justice & Equality, Minister for Skills, Research & Innovation G Coughlan Spillanes Mace/Maxol via Minister for Agriculture, Food & the Marine, Minister for Justice & Equality P Farrell Mace via Minister of Children & Youth Affairs Minister Reilly 26 Submissions, letters, enclosures and final response Release 33 24.06.14 Minister Reilly 20 Submission letter enclosure and final response Release 34 25.06.14 Minister Reilly 11 Email letter and final response Release 35 20.06.14 D McGrane James Fox Ltd Minister Reilly 9 Email enclosure and final response Release 36 20.06.14 A O’Dowd ECMI via John O’Mahony TD Ministers Reilly & Varadkar 10 Submissions email letter and final response Part-release Material which falls outside the scope of the FOI request has been redacted. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been 4 redacted from this record. 37 18.06.14 C McElearney Londis Top Shop via Fergus O’Dowd TD Minister Reilly 8 Email letter and final response Release 38 16.06.14 P Byrne Minister Reilly 3 Email and official response Part-release 39 11.06.14 Minister Reilly 5 Emails and official response Release 40 12.06.14 S Carty Topaz/Daybreak via Minister for Transport Tourism & Sport F McGinley ICMOA via Dinny McGinley TD Minister Reilly 6 Emails and final response Part-release 41 11.06.14 Minister Reilly 18 Submissions letters and final response Release 42 10.06.14 J Hardy BASCAP via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation, Minister for Finance, Taoiseach B Higgins via Taoiseach Minister Reilly 5 Emails, final response Release 43 03.06.14 C Dunne Irish Cigarette Machine Operators Association via Minister for Finance Minister Reilly 6 Email and submission Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record. - Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record - Material which falls outside the scope of the FOI request has been redacted. Release 5 44 27.05.14 A Massey Costcutter via Alan Shatter TD Minister Reilly 6 Email submission and official response 45 14.04.14 A Bendall, Apex Cylinders Ltd via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation R O’Callaghan via Kathleen Lynch TD Minister Reilly 11 Letter submission and report Minister Reilly 3 Submission email and official response Release Release 46 14.04.14 47 02.04.14 K Belton, Tara Publishing via Taoiseach Enda Kenny Minister Reilly 8 letter and final reply 48 27.03.14 T Enoch Nude Brand Consulting via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation Minister Reilly 3 Submission 49 28.03.14 M Jaeger Taxpayers Association of Europe Via Taoiseach Enda Kenny Minister Reilly 8 submission and final reply 50 26.03.14 R Von Honenhau Taxpayers Association of Europe via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation Minister Reilly 6 submission and final reply Part-release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record. Release Part-release Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Release Release 51 07.03.14 P Kinsley Neworld Associates Minister Reilly 7 52 06.03.14 A Carney via Minister for Training & Skills Minister Reilly 4 Letter submission and final reply email and final reply Release Part-release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted 6 from this record. 53 05.03.14 M Ridgeway MR Business Services via Alan Shatter TD Minister Reilly 24 Letter, submission, presentation and official response Release 54 05.03.14 Minister Reilly 9 Letter submission petition and final response Release 55 03.03.14 Clare Businesses via Chair of Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs & Trade C Dunne ICMOA via Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation Minister Reilly 9 Letter submission and official response Release 56 03.03.14 Minister Reilly 24 Letter, submission, presentation 57 14.02.14 Minister Reilly 7 58 19.02.14 M Ridgeway 7 UK Packaging MFRS via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation A Hennigan Casey's Centra via Taoiseach L&M O'Connell, Centra via Noel Coonan TD Minister Reilly 8 Letter submission email and final reply email submission and final reply Part-release 59 19.02.14 J Freda JTI Ireland via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation Minister Reilly 10 submission and final reply Release 60 18.02.14 T McLoughlin on behalf of cigarette retailers Minister Reilly 8 Letter submission and final reply Release 61 12.02.14 Minister Reilly 6 06.02.14 Minister Reilly 7 Letter submission and final reply Letter submissions and final reply Release 62 A Saeki Japan Tobacco via Tanaiste A Saeki Japan Tobacco via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation via Department of Foreign Affairs Release Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record. Release 7 63 30.01.14 E Waters, Londis via Minister for Training & Skills Minister Reilly 13 email submission and final reply Release 64 27.01.14 P O'Hanlon, Centra via Peter Fitzpatrick TD Minister Reilly 5 Letter submission and final reply Release 65 20.01.14 P Delap Newsagents via Charlie McConalogue TD Minister Reilly 7 email and final reply Release 66 16.01.14 M Wilson Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters, via Taoiseach, Minister Reilly 9 email enclosures and final reply Release 67 18.12.13 D McGrane via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise & Innovation Minister Reilly 4 email letter & final reply Release 68 18.12.13 Minister Reilly 8 submission and final reply Release 69 12.12.13 N McHale Centra via John O'Mahony Cork Retailers via Ciaran Lynch TD Minister Reilly 6 submission and final reply Release 70 11.12.13 Minister Reilly 7 email, letter and draft material for inclusion in Taoiseach's reply Release 71 09.12.13 Y Browne via Minister of State Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and Taoiseach's Office Y Browne via Minister of State Department of Agriculture Minister Reilly 6 submission and final reply Release 72 03.12.13 A & M O’Neill via Willie O'Dea TD Minister Reilly 4 email and final reply Part-release 73 28.11.13 P Flannery Gala via Minister Lynch Minister Reilly 5 email and final reply Part-release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record - Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or 8 telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record - Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. 74 25.11.13 S Carty via Minister for Transport , Tourism & Sport Minister Reilly 5 email and final reply Release 75 20.11.13 Cavan Retailers via Heather Humphreys TD Minister Reilly 6 email and final reply Release 76 20.11.13 T Enoch via Richard Bruton TD Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Part-release 77 25.11.13 P Young via an Taoiseach Minister Reilly 5 Submission letter final reply Part-release 78 16.12.13 Minister Reilly 9 letter and final reply Release 79 31.10.13 Minister Reilly 10 Submission, letters, email and final reply Release 80 18.11.13 Mayo Retailers via Micheal Ring TD S Aiken British Irish Chamber of Commerce via Michael Noonan TD & Alan Shatter TD J McCormack Emerald Filling Station Ltd via Ciaran Cannon TD Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Part-release 81 15.11.13 N McCormack via Phil Hogan TD Minister Reilly 5 letter and final reply Part-release Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email 9 addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record 82 12.11.13 P Delap CSNA via Charlie McConalogue TD Minister Reilly 3 Letter and official response Release 83 12.11.13 C Thornton Monaghan County Council Minister Reilly 4 letter and final reply Release 84 11.11.13 Anthony Lawlor TD Minister Reilly 5 letter and final reply Release 85 05.11.13 Jan O'Sullivan TD Minister Reilly 4 letter and final reply Release 86 08.11.13 Trim Retailers via Ray Butler TD Minister Reilly 4 email and final reply Release 87 05.11.13 S Dawson via Alan Shatter TD Minister Reilly 5 Release 88 04.11.13 Minister Reilly 3 89 30.10.13 Martin Heydon TD via John Perry TD I Hornshaw via Cllr Maria Bailey Submission, letters and final reply Letter and official response Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Part-release 90 28.10.13 Willie Penrose TD Minister Reilly 4 Letter and final reply Release 91 25.10.13 J Howley via Ciaran Cannon TD Minister Reilly 5 letter and final reply Part-release 92 25.10.13 Cavan Retailers via Sean Conlan TD Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Release Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record 10 93 23.10.13 Cavan Retailers via Joe O'Reilly TD Minister Reilly 4 letter and final reply Release 94 16.10.13 Ian Paisley MP & M Giltrap Techmate Vending Services via Dept of Finance Minister Reilly 6 letters and official response Part-release 95 18.10.13 S Whitaker Ignis via Dept Jobs, Enterprise & Innovation Minister Reilly 5 letter and final reply Release 96 17.10.13 H van Schaik European Carton Makers Association Minister Reilly 10 Letter, position paper and final reply Release 97 14.10.13 Martin Heydon TD Minister Reilly 4 Letter and official response Release 98 01.10.13 economiesuisse Taoiseach Kenny 7 letter and final reply Release 99 26.09.13 Dairyglen Products Ltd via Andrew Doyle TD Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Part-release 100 26.09.13 J Freda JTI Ireland Ltd via Richard Bruton TD Minister Reilly 5 Letter, position paper and final reply Release 101 26.09.13 Ian Paisley MP via Anne Ferris TD Minister Reilly 4 Letter and official response Release 102 24.09.13 Ian Paisley MP via Alan Shatter TD Minister Reilly 4 letter and final reply Release 103 23.09.13 Dairyglen Products Ltd via Anne Ferris TD Minister Reilly 7 letter and final reply Part-release 104 13.09.13 K Kiely Suir Vending Ltd via Tom Hayes TD Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Release 105 13.09.13 M Giltrap Techmate Vending Services Ltd via Taoiseach Kenny Minister Reilly 4 letter and final reply Part-release Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. 11 106 11.09.13 S Whitaker Ignis via Taoiseach, Alan Shatter TD & Michael Noonan TD P Towey Topaz via John O'Mahoney TD M Ridgway via Richard Bruton TD Minister Reilly 10 letters Release 107 27.09.13 Minister Reilly 5 letter and final reply Release 108 19.09.13 Minister Reilly 6 letter and final reply Part-release 109 30.07.13 P Kinsley Neworld Associates via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation Minister Reilly 9 letter submission and final reply Part-release 110 25.07.13 J Sweeney Newscentre Minister Reilly 3 email submission and official response Part-release 111 19.07.13 J Hardy BASCAP via Minister for Enterprise, Jobs and Innovation Minister Reilly 4 submission and official response Release 112 19.07.13 J Maher JTI Ireland Ltd via Minister for Enterprise, Jobs and Innovation Minister Reilly 5 submission and official response Release 113 01.07.13 J Freda, JTI Ireland via Tanaiste's Office Minister Reilly 8 submission and official response Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record Under Section 27 (1) commercially sensitive information has been redacted from this record. Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record 12 114 01.07.13 A Gorby Minister Reilly 2 letter & official response 115 28.03.13 K Belton Retail news via Minister for Small Business and Minister for Jobs Enterprise & Innovation Minister Reilly 8 letters & official response 116 01.02.13 Cllr J Mellett via Taoiseach Minister Reilly 4 letter email enclosure and official response Part-release 117 28.01.13 Minister Reilly 5 Letter Release 118 09.08.12 US Chamber of Commerce via Minister for Jobs, Enterprise & Innovation M Timoney via Dept Taoiseach Minister Reilly 5 Submission and letter Release 119 07.08.14 Minister Varadkar 5 Detailed opinion Refuse Communication from the Commission (Slovakia) Part-release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record Release Under Section 28 (1) personal information, including personal addresses, email addresses and/or telephone numbers, has been redacted from this record Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains 13 120 13.08.14 Communication from the Commission (Bulgaria) Minister Varadkar 4 Detailed opinion Refuse 121 13.08.14 Communication from the Commission (Portugal) Minister Varadkar 6 Detailed opinion Refuse information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, 14 122 08.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Czech Republic) Minister Varadkar 7 Detailed opinion Refuse disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of 15 123 17.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Romania) Minister Varadkar 11 Detailed opinion Refuse 124 17.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Spain) Minister Varadkar 9 Detailed opinion Refuse which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains 16 125 17.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Poland) Minister Varadkar 5 Detailed opinion Refuse 126 23.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Italy) Minister Varadkar 14 Detailed opinion Refuse information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, 17 127 23.09.14 Communication from the Commission (Greece) Minister Varadkar 6 Detailed opinion Refuse disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of which is prohibited by the body. Under Section 26 (1) (a) and (b) this record contains information provided in confidence, disclosure of which would constitute a breach of the duty of confidence. Under Section 24 (2)(II)(e) and (f) this records contains information communicated in confidence from a body of the European Union and contains information the disclosure of 18 which is prohibited by the body. 19