Running Header: Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities By: Kristen Bromaghim, Molly Cassella, Rachel Gallagher James Madison University – The University of Malta May 2011 Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 2 Abstract This project explores the CINDI dietary guidelines that were set out by the World Health Organization regional office in Europe and to what extent the Maltese elderly population complies with all components. This paper also explores related morbidities that result from any deviations from the recommended diet. To evaluate the degree to which this population follows the guidelines, various means of information extraction took place reword. The majority of information was retrieved from literature reviews authored by medical professionals, as well as specific data sets relevant to the eating habits of the elderly Maltese population. Interviews with various professionals in the health field, as well as information taken from lecture presentations were also a means of data. In addition, a survey conducted by students at several locations in Malta was used to focus on dietary trends of the elderly. It was found that the Maltese elderly population deviates from the CINDI guidelines in many ways such as the inclusion of too many carbohydrates, inadequate types and amounts of protein, unhealthy dairy consumption, lack of fruits and vegetables, and a high intake of sugar. In conclusion, it is evident that if the dietary guidelines set out by the CINDI program were followed correctly, then Malta would have a lower prevalence of morbidities in the elderly population that result from improper nutrition and diet. Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 3 Introduction According to the World Health Organization (WHO), individuals between the ages of 6074 years old are classified as ‘elderly’, 75-89 years are “old”, and 90 years and above are “very old” (Shepherd, 2009). Projections for the European Union’s twenty-seven member states show that by 2060, the mean age of the population will rise to 48 years and 151.5 million individuals, 30% of the total European Union population, are expected to be aged 65 years and over. Additionally, 61.4 million people are predicted to be aged 80 years and over (Gauci, 2008). The increasing size of the aging population can be attributed to numerous factors; however, the shift from families with many children to families with fewer children due largely to financial constraints is a major factor. Increased life expectancy is another key reason why the elderly population is steadily growing. The classification system of the elderly population established by the World Health Organization is upheld in Malta as well. The Maltese elderly population is steadily increasing; this population currently comprises 19.9% of the general population, and by the year 2060 that number is predicted to increase to 24% aged 65 years and over (Gauci, 2008). This aging population is a growing concern worldwide; they carry with them increasing risks of diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, osteoporosis, obesity, and caloric deficiencies (Baker, 2007). Amongst the elderly population in Malta, the leading cause of death is heart disease (Gauci, 2008). The European Health Interview Survey of 2008 reported that 21% of deaths in females and 23% of deaths in males were due to this condition. Also published by the European Health Interview Survey of 2008 were the top reported health conditions in those aged 60 and over: the most common health condition in 2008 was high blood pressure, afflicting 46% of the elderly population. Other common conditions were arthritis, back/neck Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 4 pain, diabetes, and mental health problems (Gauci, 2008). In fact, Malta has the highest diabetes rate in Europe (Mizzi, 1995), and is second only to the United States in obesity rates. In the National Obesity Campaign of 2010, Malta was estimated to have 50% of adults between 35 and 65 years of age were overweight or obese (National Obesity Campaign, 2010). These trends have led health professionals to help create a healthful aging process in which the hallmark diseases are diminished (Baker, 2007). The current healthcare system in most of the world, and particularly in Malta, has been described as reactive (M. Ellul, personal communication, June 6, 2011). A shift towards proactive, preventative healthcare is therefore being encouraged. The CINDI (Countrywide Integrated Noncomunicable Disease Intervention) food pyramid is a dietary guideline devised by the World Health Organization Regional Office in Europe for health promotion and disease prevention (CINDI dietary guide, 2000). This is a nutritional approach to prevent disease by way of changing the food patterns in Europe toward a diet with low saturated fat and high fruits and vegetables (CINDI dietary guide, 2000). The purpose of this paper is to explore the CINDI food pyramid established by the World Health Organization and determine the extent to which the Maltese elderly population deviates from these dietary guidelines. Major deviances are possible causes for Malta’s already high and increasing rates of diet-related morbidities. Promoting a healthier, more balanced diet in Malta could alleviate much of the burden the growing elderly population is placing on the health care system. Background Obesity and its consequences, which include diabetes, hypertension, high blood pressure and cardiovascular disease can be prevented largely by diet modification. In nearly every part of Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 5 the world there is an age-dependent increase in the prevalence of type 2 diabetes (Josse et al., 2008 APA). On a global scale, the prevalence of diabetes in adults aged 65 years and older is expected to increase exponentially to approximately 300 million by 2025, with a lifetime risk of developing type 2 diabetes rising to approximately 20% (Josse et al., 2008). With these numbers, the global burden diabetes and its related complications will have on social structures and health care systems will be enormous (Josse et al., 2008). To battle such burdens, the World Health Organization has created the CINDI dietary guide along with the accompanying food pyramid. The CINDI dietary guide respectively known as the Countrywide Integrated Noncommunicable Disease Intervention was created through the collaboration of the WHO CINDI program and the WHO program for nutrition policy, infant feeding, and food security (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). The WHO program was designed to be a global initiative involved in the improvement of health and lifestyle through health promotion, disease prevention, and reduction of the various mortalities and morbidities resulting from the major identified non-communicable diseases. To reduce and hopefully eliminate the risks of such non-communicable diseases, the WHO intends to identify and diminish the risk factors relevant to them (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). Some of these risk factors that may contribute to an individual’s overall health include alcohol and/or tobacco use or abuse, stress, physical inactivity, and unhealthy nutrition and diet. Malta’s use of this guide is largely due to its low-fat, low salt and low carbohydrate content as well as its heavy inclusion of fruits and vegetables (Denny & Stanner, 2008). The guide provides a reference for healthy eating which is based on foods, rather than nutrients. This essentially is a more practical means of direction simply because we purchase and consume foods and not nutrients (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). The dietary pyramid is Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 6 divided into separate color schemes that help to navigate the structure while demonstrating the variety and proportions of food necessary to comply with healthy standards. The color schemes can be comparable to that of traffic lights and their meanings. The green section identifies foods that are full of nutritional benefits similar to “proceeding” through a green light. The orange/yellow section indentifies foods that an individual should be cautious of. The remaining red section identifies foods that should be thought through and considered before consuming similar to the “stopping” mechanism (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). These illustrations provide a simple means of understanding what and how much to eat. Although, it is important to keep in mind that the more physical activity an individual engages in, the more servings necessary to meet their daily caloric intake needed. The metric form, the joule (kJ) is the most universal unit of measurement of food (1 kcal = 4.2 kJ). As a result, the WHO recommends that a normal adult requires approximately 6,50014,000 kJ each day (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). This recommendation also must take into account the individuals gender, age, body size, and amount of physical activity as mentioned previously. Half of the total energy each day should come from a combination from the two green layers. These layers are found at the base of the pyramid and include fruits, vegetables, and grains. Specifically regarding vegetables which can be found in the upper green layer, the WHO recommends the inclusion of 400 g into daily food intake. In regards to fruits, 5-6 portions daily are recommended with one portion being recognized as equating to one fruit (i.e. an apple) (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). The orange layer implies caution, meaning that only small amounts of this section are needed to maintain a healthy diet. This section includes meats and meat alternatives, and is recommended that only 0.8 g protein per kg is needed per day for an individual (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000). The other half of the orange portion includes dairy Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 7 products, which are necessary to maintain the recommended amount of calcium in the diet. The CINDI pyramid does not identify an exact amount per day but rather implies that amounts differ among individuals due to the varying factors that may have influence (age, body size, gender, etc.). Finally, the top red layer includes foods that supply little nutrients to the diet. Though these foods help supply additional energy, very small amounts are only needed. In addition to the dietary pyramid, the WHO has also incorporated a specific list of 12 dietary guides which explain steps to healthy eating: this could be best presented as a table prnted in color 1. Eat a nutritious diet based on a variety of foods originating mainly from plants, rather than animals 2. Eat bread, grains, pasta, rice or potatoes several times per day 3. Eat a variety of vegetables and fruits, preferably fresh and local, several times per day (at least 400 g per day) 4. Maintain body weight between the recommended limits (a BMI of 20-25) by taking moderate levels of physical activity, preferably daily 5. Control fat intake (not more than 30% of daily energy) and replace most saturated fats with unsaturated vegetable oils or soft margarines 6. Replace fatty meat and meat products with beans, legumes, lentils, fish, poultry or lean meat 7. Use milk and dairy products (kefir, sour milk, yogurt and cheese) that are low in both fat and salt 8. Select foods that are low in sugar, and eat refined sugar sparingly, limiting the frequency of sugary drinks and sweets Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 8 9. Choose a low-salt diet. Total salt intake should not be more than one teaspoon (6 g) per day, including the salt in bread and processed cured and preserved foods. (Salt iodization should be universal where iodine deficiency is endemic.) 10. If alcohol is consumed, limit intake to no more than 2 drinks (each containing 10 g of alcohol) per day 11. Prepare food in a safe and hygienic way. Steam, bake, boil or microwave to help reduce the amount of added fat 12. Promote exclusive breastfeeding and the introduction of safe and adequate complementary foods from the age of about 6 months, but not before 4 months, while breastfeeding continues during the first years of life. (CINDI dietary guidelines, 2000) These steps should be recognized as a whole rather than individually due to the overall context they provide in terms of maintaining a healthy diet and lifestyle. Methods The data obtained for this paper came from a variety of sources. A wide range of literature was reviewed and mostly authored individually ?? or as a collaboration of medical professionals holding various doctorate degrees. In the articles, the nutritional topics most commonly discussed were obesity, malnutrition, and diabetes. In order to further evaluate the nutritional status of the elderly population in Malta, we drew statistical data from a document concerning the changing eating habits of the Maltese written by Mary Bellizzi of the Nutrition Unit of the Department of Health in Floriana, Malta. This information was specific to lifestyle, nutrition choices, and general health status of the population that identified as being 60 years of Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 9 age and older. An additional data set entitled the CINDI dietary guide was obtained from the World Health Organization Europe to illustrate the compilation of the dietary pyramid and lay out the steps for healthy eating. A random, anonymous survey was also conducted by us and our fellow students of 258 individuals that were approached in various locations around Malta. We explained the purpose of our study and the confidentiality in order to guarantee anonymity. The surveys included 49 questions that covered many aspects of lifestyles. We then extracted the data retrieved from the surveys that was relevant to supplement the literature cited. This information was specific to nutrition choices relating to the food pyramid. We also worked closely with several individuals appropriate to our topic of research. Geriatric specialist Dr. Stephen Abela, Dr. Neville Calleja of the Department of Health Information and Disease Prevention, and Public Health Nutritionist, Maria Ellul all provided insight on new data as well as past data already retrieved. Dr. Neville Calleja made available a compilation of the results of the European Health Interview Survey conducted in 2008 that focused entirely on the health status of the elderly. All sessions were documented and incorporated into our results. Results The Nutrition Unit of the Department of Health in Floriana, Malta conducted a study of the eating habits of the Maltese from 1961 to 1988. The results summarized the supply of different foods available and the rates of their consumption during that time period. These results represent the diet decisions made by the current elderly population discussed in this paper, assuming that the dietary habits of a middle-aged individual directly contribute to their health later in life. Thus, the data from 1961 to 1988 about Maltese dietary patterns offer insight into the dietary causes for the morbidities associated with the present aging population, such as, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and obesity. Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 10 The results of the study indicate that the supply of cereals and other wheat products fell steadily from 1961 to 1988, but seem to be stabilizing at the present time. Fruits and vegetables increased in supply and there was a 20% increase in the supply of sugar during the considered period of time do you mean sugar intake??. The supplies of meat, fish, eggs, and dairy products have increased steadily since 1961. Trends in the supply of separated fats and oils in Malta indicate the substitution of butter with margarines and vegetable oils (Bellizzi, 1993). At the time of the study, the largest sources of energy in the Maltese diet were cereals. Cereals include bread, pasta, and other wheat products. The most commonly consumed wheat products were processed bread, followed by pastas. The second largest component of the Maltese diet was meat, specifically, beef and pork. Steadily increasing, yet significantly lower than the percent of red meat consumed, was the percent of fish consumed by the Maltese population. The third greatest source of energy in the Maltese diet was milky and dairy products. These products were often high in fat and salt and the previously noted 20% increase in sugar consumption equates to 21 grams consumption per person daily. The consumption rate of fruits and vegetables by the Maltese was lower than that of Greece, Italy and Spain, with fruits and vegetables constituting only 6% of total energy intake per day (Bellizzi, 1993). In addition, an interview with Dr. Anna McElhatton, a professor of Dietetics at the University of Malta, shed light on the present dietary decisions of the elderly population in Malta. She described decreased protein consumption characterized by an aversion to red meat and increased consumption of refined carbohydrates. These refined carbohydrates are most commonly purchased in the form of qaghaq, a soft bun. Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 11 Also evident is a lack of nutritional education. Student survey results revealed that of the 29 respondents aged 66 years and older, 35% had never heard of the food pyramid. Of the 52% who reported knowing a little about the food pyramid, 28% were not interested in learning more. Findings and Discussion The Maltese population’s deviance from the CINDI nutrition guidelines is apparent through its dietary patterns. The CINDI model recommends a diet high in complex carbohydrates and low in total fats. In contrast, the Maltese diet summarized in the document, The Changing Eating Habits of the Maltese, is one that is low in complex carbohydrates and high in total fats (Bellizzi, 1993). The Maltese population derived 37% of its total energy intake from complex carbohydrates from 1961-1988. Ninety-nine percent of the breads consumed were the local white types of bread, which are high in salt content. Whole-meal and brown bread, the healthier alternative, constituted just 0.1% of bread consumption at the time. Protein consumption contributed to 12% daily energy intake; however, this number represented consumption of fatty meats, such as beef and pork in the form of lunchmeat and bacon. Furthermore, fish consumption constituted only a small portion of protein consumption on the island (Bellizzi, 1993). These numbers deviate from the CINDI dietary guideline suggesting protein be consumed in the form of legumes, lentils, and fish. The CINDI model recommends that fruits, vegetables and whole grains be consumed in nearly equal amounts. However, these three food groups were consumed in dismally low amounts during the period from 1961 to 1988. Already mentioned was the population’s Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 12 preference for white rather than whole wheat bread. Also, the Maltese trailed behind their Mediterranean neighbors in fruit and vegetable consumption by up to 3% (Belizzi, 1993). Recommendations concerning milk and dairy products promote the consumption of low fat and sodium dairy products. However, nearly two-fifths of Maltese dairy consumption was consumed in the form of high-fat cheddar cheese. Though Maltese bread and pasta consumption is consistent with a traditional Mediterranean diet, the Maltese diet is similar to a British diet. This is evidenced by the high consumption of cheddar cheese, sugar, and beef and the low consumption of fruit. Thus, it can be concluded that the British presence from the early 1900s until 1964 greatly influenced Maltese dietary decisions in the following years (Mizzi, 1993). Salt intake, as recommended by the CINDI model, should not exceed 6 grams per day. During the period from 1961-1988, men were consuming 11 grams and women, 9 grams, per day of salt. Also during this period, sugar made up 15% of the population’s total energy intake. This value exceeds what is considered to be the sparingly consumption of sugar recommended by the CINDI plan. The plan urges individuals to limit the frequency of sugar drinks and sweets. However, it is estimated that Malta is second highest per capita consumer of soft drinks. This estimate suggests that soda could have been the source of such a high intake of sugar in the Maltese diet (Bellizzi, 1993). The only aspect in which the Maltese diet followed the CINDI guidelines was in the substitution of saturated fats with unsaturated fats such as vegetable oil and margarine. An interview with Dr. Anna McElhatton, a professor of Dietetics at the University of Malta, shed light on the present dietary decisions of the elderly population in Malta. She described decreased protein consumption and increased consumption of refined carbohydrates. She pointed out that food choices of the elderly are largely influenced by their physical abilities Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 13 or rather, inabilities. For example, elderly individuals may chose to shop at neighborhood corner shops because of their location. These corner shops, though convenient, receive shipments only twice a week. Thus, the fruit and vegetables purchased by an elderly individual are normally of low quality and diminished nutritional value due to inadequate storage. The Health Interview Survey of 2008 revealed that as age increases, reported difficulty with instrumental activities of daily living increases. Instrumental activities of daily living include cooking, shopping, cleaning and other tasks necessary for one to maintain his or her home environment. The Health Interview Survey concluded that 28.7% of elderly males and 19.4% of elderly females have difficulty preparing meals (Gauci, 2008). With such difficulty, meal choices become monotonous over time and a balanced is not achieved. Those elderly individuals limited physically to an extent that requires institutionalization in a nursing home suffer as well. Currently, there are only two dieticians on the island. This scarcity results in the near absence of nutritional assessment in the nursing home environment. The continuing assessment of an elderly patient’s nutritional status is fundamental to a positive health outcome. Without a dietician, an accurate assessment of the patient’s eating patterns and the result to which these patterns affect the patient’s health is nearly impossible to attain (Baker, 2007). Nutritional supplements, which are meant to substitute for protein or other nutrients, are unheard of in nursing homes on the island. Such supplements are often served in the form of a smoothie for patients with mastication problems. Without these supplements, patients with missing teeth or ill-fitting dentures are likely to compromise their nutritional status by choosing foods such as bread and pasta because they are easy to chew (Dr. A McElhatton, personal communication, June 6, 2011). Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 14 In conclusion, the discussed eating patterns represent a need for the reduction of red meat consumption and an increase in the consumption of fish and poultry. Also a concern is the failure to substitute high fat dairy products with low fat alternatives. The consumption of fruits, vegetables, and whole grain products by the Maltese population are also lower than recommended. Recommendations There are numerous ways in which the Maltese population, particularly the government and ministry of health, could work to help combat the rising obesity and morbidity rates. An increase in the extremely low number of dieticians and nutritionists would be beneficial for education and follow up of patients. These health care professionals are able to make personal recommendations and specific diets for patients suffering from all different conditions. For the percentage of the population already in the obese category, dieticians and nutritionists would be able to create a diet to help decrease their health risks and help them lose weight. These professionals are also able to serve an educational purpose by instructing patients how to prevent obesity and its resulting morbidities. Increased education could see a rise in the obesity rates. In the absence of dieticians and nutritionists, Malta could choose to educate and utilize their nursing staff to assess and teach patients about nutrition and obesity. While these groups will not be able to specialize to the extent of a dietician, they can still serve some of the same roles and provide brief education with current patients. Education in general is an area that needs improvement in Malta. Numerous health care professionals could work together to help make the public more aware of the CINDI food pyramid and dietary guide. The results of the survey implied that education may be a key in the fight against obesity; education will help increase the number of people who are fully understand Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 15 the recommended diet. Currently, people reply that they do not know much about the food pyramid and this could be a major reason why they are not following the guidelines. Awareness can be raised using different channels. A simple option is having physicians and other medical professionals educate their patients during office visits and via brochures or posters at their offices. However, due to the fact that the entire population will not be frequenting doctors’ offices, it would be effective to spread the word using mass communication. Television, radio, and the internet are all valid options on which to place advertisements and programs designed to get the public’s attention. Upon increased education, more people will be likely to at least attempt to follow the CINDI food pyramid. The United States has a program by the American Heart Association in which foods that have been certified “heart healthy” are stamped with a common recognizable logo (Food Certification, 2010). This allows the public to quickly and easily learn which foods will help improve or maintain their heart health. Bring a similar program to Malta would be helpful for those already combating obesity as well as those who are trying to maintain their current health status. An idea for a program in Malta is to indicate not only which food are heart healthy, but which foods are overall effective in avoiding diabetes. Word playing the CINDI dietary guide, the symbol would be a young girl named Cindy. When the cartoon is red, representative of heart health, the food is certified heart healthy; when the cartoon is blue, representative of diabetes awareness, the food is low in sugars to prevent diabetes. A last major recommendation for the Maltese is an assessment/screening program that would test the general public on their nutritional status. This is a preventative measure that will show patients where they fall on the overweight/obese scale. If a patient meets criteria for overweight or obesity they will be given a dietary plan and then brought in for continued follow- Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 16 up. This preventative program will aim to help not only the currently obese and overweight population, but mainly the large sector of the population that is at risk of becoming obese. In the Journal of Community Nursing, author Susan Holmes indicated an example of such a program called a Nutritional care pathway. In this example, patients are nutritionally screened then assessed to determine the cause of any medical conditions. If the assessment determines nutrition as the issue the patient is referred to a dietitian and is given a diet plan. After some time, reassessment is done and if the problem still exists the process begins again (Holmes, 2006). Due to the severe rates of obesity and the resulting morbidities in the Maltese population, numerous recommendations can be made to help improve these statistics. The problem needs to be prevented not only reacted to, the population should be educated of dietary guidelines, and a simple way of introducing healthy foods are will all be beneficial actions for this population. Conclusion Considering all the above findings, we have concluded that with proper adherence to a set of standards set out by the World Health Organization through the CINDI program, Malta can aim to reduce the health deficiencies particularly evident in the elderly population that result from nutrition choices high in fat, salt, and carbohydrate content. Through this compliance, Malta should hopefully observe a radical decline in the prevalence of various morbidities faced by the elderly that will put them in better health standing. Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 17 References American Heart Association. (2010). Food Certification. Retrieved from: http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/General/Food-Certification_UCM_309600_Article.jsp Baker, H. (2007) Nutrition in the elderly: nutritional aspects of chronic diseases. Geriatrics, 62(9). 21-25. Bartl, R. (2004). Continuing education: geriatric nutrition. Nutrition and Dietetics, 61(4). 236239. Camilleri, R. (1993). A demographic and social-economic profile of ageing in malta. International Institute on Ageing. Denny, A. & Stanner, S. (2008). The role of nutrition in healthy aging. Practice Nursing, 19(5). 225-230. Gauci, D. (2008). Health status of the elderly. European Health Interview Survey. 9-14. Holmes, S. (2006) Nutrition matters for older adults. Journal of Community Nursing, 20 (2). 2430 Josse, A. R., Panahi, S., Esfahani, A., Leiter, L. A., Jenkins, D. J. A., Kendall, Cyril, W. C. (2008). Nutritional considerations for older adults with type 2 diabetes. Journal of Nutrition for the Elderly, 27(3). 363-375. Koh, G. (2005). Overnutrition among older persons in a maltese nursing home. Malta Medical Journal, 17(1). 28-32. Masters, R. (2010). Tackling undernutrition in older people from a regional perspective. British Journal of Community Nursing, 15(6). 266-270. Dietary Trends of the Maltese Aging Population and the Resulting Morbidities 18 Mizzi, L. (1995). Food and nutrition policy in malta. Food Policy, 20(6). 475-480. Savona-Ventura, C. (2001). Mortality trends from diabetes mellitus in a high prevalence island population. International Journal of Risk & Safety in Medicine, 14. 87-93. Schranz, A.G. The epidemiology of diabetes in malta. Diabetes/Metabolism Reviews, 13(3). 181-199. Shepherd, A. (2009). Nutrition through the life span: part 3; adults aged 65 years and over. British Journal of Nursing, 18(5). 301-307. Tessier, S., Gerber, M. (2004). Comparison between sardinia and malta: the mediterranean diet revisited. Appetite, 45. 121-126. World Health Organization Europe. (2000). CINDI dietary guide [data file]. Retrieved from http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/119926/E70041.pdf