TheChemistry of Soap Final Project What makes a good soap? How does its properties make it an effective cleaning agent? Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 1/24 Name ______________________ Period _____________________ Project Objectives: Students will understand what it means to “clean” something. Students will understand the relationships among the chemical structure and chemical properties of soap and its ability to clean. Students will demonstrate an understanding of atoms; molecules; compounds; matter; bonding: ionic bonds, covalent bonds; the periodic table; polarity; acids; bases; pH; and basic chemical bonding. Students will also understand how and why soap changes when you change the base and the fat molecule used in the chemical reaction. Students will also demonstrate a basic understanding of marketing design and their working knowledge of chemistry, in a professional presentation. Performance Tasks: The project is a three-part project that will require students to make predictions, collect and analyze their data, draw conclusions and present their findings. Part 1: Making Soap • Students will conduct research and use at least five different sources to write a background for the project. This background should answer the guiding questions included in the background section. • Students will create a soap that fits their definition of a good soap and that works as an effective cleaning agent. Part 2: Testing the Effectiveness • Students will use the soap that they made from part 1 to test different properties of their soap and compare their results to that of a popular moisturizing (Caress) and antimicrobial soap (Dial). - Test 1: Lathering Ability – Students will test to see how well their soap lathers when compared to a good antimicrobial soap and moisturizing soap. - Test 2: Durability Test – Students will determine how durable their soap is when compared to a good antimicrobial soap and moisturizing soap. - Test 3: Surfactant Test – Students will test to see how well their soap dissolves oil when compared to a good antimicrobial soap and moisturizing soap. - Test 4: Stain Removal – Students will test to see how well their soap cleans a series of four stains; dirt, hot sauce, charcoal, and oil when compared to a good antimicrobial soap and moisturizing soap. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 2/23 • • • • - Test 5: pH – Students will measure the Ph of all three soaps to see if the Ph played a role in their performance. Based upon their understanding of an emulsifier and how it cleans dirt molecules, students will create a hypothesis to explain how and why their soap should effectively clean the stains. Students will write individual procedures and execute their experiment Students will collect data that will serve as evidence to “prove” that their soap is effective. Evidence includes: color change; smell of cloth; texture of cloth, etc... Students will then analyze their data, compare it to the data of other co-lab groups and draw a conclusion based upon their findings. Part 3: Roundtable Students will use their understanding of chemistry concepts to present their findings in an entertaining marketing presentation. Students will consider the following questions when making their presentation: What makes an exciting and interesting presentation? What characteristics should a good product have? How will I explain my findings using scientific language while linking different scientific concepts. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 3/24 Part 1. Making Our Soap Aim: The aim of part 1 is to make a good soap Instructions (the procedure can be altered to fit the specifications of your group): A good soap is… An effective soap is… Materials: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Lard or some sort of fat (135ml). 53ml Sodium Hydroxide (NaOH) 250ml Glass and Plastic Beakers Glass stirring rod. Hot plate. Mold for making soap bars. 98ml of H2O Safety: Gloves, lab coat and appropriate eyewear should be worn when handling the 6N NaOH. It should be used in a well-ventilated area, preferably in a fume hood. DO NOT BREATHE THE FUMES. Wash with vinegar should you get some on your skin (have some vinegar handy before starting the experiment) - DO NOT wash with water! Procedure: 1. Clean your work space. 2. Put goggles on. 3. In a glass beaker, place 53ml of NaOH into 97.5ml of H2O. Stir the mixture with a glass stirring rod until it completely dissolves. 4. Place 135 ml of (or any other fat, such as oil or butter) into the glass beaker. 5. SLOWLY AND CAREFULLY sir the mixture. ***What happens when the NaOH is added to the fat? Record your results. 7. Add any additional ingredients to your soap once it has the consistency of pudding (Trace Period). 12. Poor your soap mixture into the soap mold. The solid cake that forms is the soap (what’s left, is glycerol). Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 4/23 Observations: What is fat? What happens when NaOH is added to the fat? How does the fat molecule change to create a soap molecule? Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 5/24 Substance Reason Added (explain what each added substance does from a chemical perspective and an aesthetic perspective) Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 6/23 Part 2. Testing its Effectiveness Aim: The aim of this experiment is to test the effectiveness of your soap and explain how its properties contribute to its abilities to clean, lather, last and…. Background: 1. What is Chemistry? 2. What do soap molecules look like? a. How are the atoms inside of the soap arranged? 3. What ingredients do you need to add to soap in order to make it a good cleaning soap? Why do these ingredients make it clean well? Explain how each ingredient helps soap clean. a. What happens to soap’s molecules when you put soap in water? Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 7/24 b. Draw what happens below. 4. What ingredients do you need to add to soap in order to make it a good moisturizer? Why do these ingredients make it moisturize well? Explain how each ingredient helps soap moisturize. 5. What ingredients do you need to add to soap to make it durable? Why do these ingredients make it durable? Explain how each ingredient helps soap’s durability. 6. What is an emulsifier? 7. How does soap’s property as an emulsifier help it clean? 8. What is pH? Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 8/23 a. What do soap manufacturers do in order to make sure that the pH of soap isn’t too high? 9. How does the pH of soap affect its cleaning ability? 10. How does the pH of soap affect its ability to moisturize? Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 9/24 Hypothesis: ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________ Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 10/23 Test 1: Lathering Ability Materials: Variables: Constants: Controls: Independent: Dependent: Relationship between Independent and Dependent: Procedure: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 11/24 Test 2: Durability Test Materials: Variables: Constants: Controls: Independent: Dependent: Relationship between Independent and Dependent: Procedure: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 12/23 Test 3: Surfactant Test Materials: Variables: Constants: Controls: Independent: Dependent: Relationship between Independent and Dependent: Procedure: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 13/24 Test 4: Stain Removal Materials: Variables: Constants: Controls: Independent: Dependent: Relationship between Independent and Dependent: Procedure: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 14/23 Test 5: pH Materials: Variables: Constants: Controls: Independent: Dependent: Relationship between Independent and Dependent: Procedure: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 15/24 Data: Test 1: Lathering Ability (mL of bubbles) Trial Soap 1 Soap 2 Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3 Test 2: Durability (mass before being added to water and after being added to water) Trial Soap 1 Mass before Mass after Soap 2 Mass before Mass after Mass before Mass after Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3 Test 3: Surfactant Test (Dissolving of oil- drops of oil in soapy water) Trial Soap 1 Soap 2 Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3 Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 16/23 Test 4: Stain Removal (% removed) Stain Soap 1 Soap 2 Dirt Oil Hot Sauce Charcoal Draw what each of your stains looked like before treatment and after treatment Stain Soap 1 Soap 2 Before After Before After Dirt Oil Hot Sauce Charcoal Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 17/24 Before After Test 5: pH (acidic or basic 0-14) Soap 1 Soap 2 Homemade Soap Additional Observations: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 18/23 Analysis: Answer the following questions- using evidence from your calculations, sketches and tables to support your answers. 1) How did the performance of your soap compare to that of the popular moisturizing and antimicrobial soap in lathering ability? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 19/23 2) How did the performance of your soap compare to that of the popular moisturizing and antimicrobial soap in durability? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. 3) How did the performance of your soap compare to that of the popular moisturizing and antimicrobial soap in its ability to be a surfactant? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 20/24 4) How did the performance of your soap compare to that of the popular moisturizing and antimicrobial soap in its ability to clean a dirty stain? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. 5) What was the final pH of each of the soaps (Soap 2, Soap 1 and your soap)? 6) Was the pH of any of the soaps out of the acceptable range of 7-8? 7) Explain how the pH might be connected to the durability, lathering ability, and cleaning ability of the soap. Use evidence from your charts and graphs to explain. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 21/23 8) Which commercial soap did your soap compare more closely to? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. Why do you think this happened? 9) Looking at your results, would you consider your soap a good moisturizing soap or a good cleaning soap? Why? Use evidence from your charts and graphs to support. Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 22/24 Conclusion: ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________ Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 23/23 Sources of Error: Sources of information: Final Project. Soap Chemistry. 24/24