REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA LAW ON AMENDMENT OF THE LAW ON BASES OF PROPERTY AND BUSINESS VALUATION 22 June 2011 No XI-1497 Vilnius (Official Gazette Valstybės Žinios, 1999, No 52-1672; 2003, No 38-1673) Article 1. The new wording of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania The Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation shall be amended to read as follows: “REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA LAW ON BASES OF PROPERTY AND BUSINESS VALUATION CHAPTER ONE GENERAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS Article 1. Purpose of the Law This Law shall establish the principles for measuring the value of property or business, the bases for and cases of measuring the value of property or business, the bases for and regulation of operation of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies, the rights, duties, and responsibilities of property or business appraisers and property and business valuation companies, and the requirements for property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies. Other laws of the Republic of Lithuania shall apply to property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies to the extent their operations are not regulated by this Law. Article 2. Key Terms and Definitions of the Law 1. Replacement value of property is the estimated amount of money required to re-create, reproduce or reconstruct (outfit) subject property of the same physical and operational qualities. 2. Individual valuation of property or business means valuation of property or business, considering its individual attributes on a certain day, following an appropriate property or business valuation approach in the manner established in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology. 3. Movable property (movable item) means property (an item) that can be moved from one place to another without modifying its function and significantly reducing its value, unless the law provides to the contrary. 4. Mass property valuation is simultaneous valuation of homogenous property (items defined by their specific attributes), considering the condition of the property at a certain date, following an appropriate property or business valuation approach in the manner established in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology, and with reference to the legislation that regulates this type of valuation. 5. Immovable property (immovable item) means a land lot and items pertaining to it that cannot be moved from one place to another without modifying their function and significantly reducing their value, as well as property (movable items) that is recognised as immovable by the rule of law. 6. Non-compulsory property or business valuation means valuation of property or business done at the client’s initiative, on the basis of an agreement between the client and a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser. 7. Compulsory property or business valuation means valuation of property or business done in cases provided for in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania in order to secure a public interest. 8. Special-purpose property is property that serves a special function, is of limited demand and therefore sells rarely, or is not marketable and therefore does not sell at all. 9. Property means tangible, intangible and financial assets that may be the subject of market transactions. 10. Market value of property or business is the estimated amount for which an asset should exchange on the date of valuation between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm’s–length transaction after proper marketing wherein the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently, and without compulsion. 11. Value of property or business (the value) means a unit of measure of usefulness of property or business at any given time, established on the basis of an appropriate property or business valuation approach, following the procedure and in the manner identified in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology. 12. Property or business valuation means establishing the value of property and/or business using an appropriate property or business valuation approach, following the procedure and in the manner identified in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology. 13. • Valuation of property or business for internal purposes means valuation of property or business carried out at the sole discretion of a legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, to safeguard performance of the direct functions of the legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, other than valuation of property or business under property or business valuation contracts with clients. 14. Property or business valuation company means a legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or any other Member State, or any branches thereof, engaging in property or business valuations in the manner prescribed by the laws of the Republic of Lithuania. 15. Property and business valuation methodology means legislation adopted by the government of the Republic of Lithuania or any other institution authorised by it, which regulates the procedure and manner of application of property and business valuation approaches embedded in the International Valuation Standards and the European Valuation Standards in the Republic of Lithuania, in cases envisaged in said standards. 16. Client of the property or business valuation service (the client) means a private individual, a legal entity or any other organisation or its branches that, pursuant to their regulations, are entitled to enter into contracts, which have entered into a property or business valuation contract with a property or business valuation company. 17. Property or business appraiser means a citizen of the Republic of Lithuania or any other Member State or any other private individual, who exercises the rights of movement across the Member States vested to them by the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania and engages in valuations of property or business. 18. Qualification certificate of the property or business appraiser is a document issued to a private individual by a state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania that certifies the qualifications of that person as an appraiser of property or business specialising in a particular field. 19. Professional ethics code of property or business appraisers means legislation adopted by the government of the Republic of Lithuania or any other institution authorised by it that establishes the standards of professional conduct that apply to all property or business appraisers. 20. Price of property is the amount of money that has been asked, offered or paid for the property. 21. Property value in use is the estimated amount of money benefits that an asset generates for a specific owner. 22. Member State is a member of the European Union, a state within the European Economic Area, or the Swiss Confederation. 23. Business means activity of a private individual, legal entity or any other organisation or its branches, which is aimed at earning income and profit through using economic resources. Article 3. Objects and Subjects of Property or Business Valuation 1. Objects of property or business valuation shall be property and business of any type. 2. Subjects of property or business valuation shall be: 1) clients; 2) property or business valuation companies; 3) legal entities or any other organisations incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or their branches performing property or business valuation for their internal purposes; 4) property or business appraisers. Article 4. Cases of Property or Business Valuation Property or business shall be valued: 1) in cases provided for in the laws and legislation (compulsory valuation of property or business); 2) for internal purposes; 3) in other cases as per client’s request. Article 5. Principles of Calculating the Value of Property or Business 1. The value of property or business shall be determined as follows: 1) based on the logics and criteria of market economy, the results of market and economic condition research and observation; the application of such results is covered in detail in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology; 2) adhering to the principles of equity, rationality, fairness, immunity of property, freedom of contract, impartiality and independence of valuation, legal explicitness and unacceptability of abuse of law; 3) using the criteria of legitimate, reasonable expectations and interests, prudence and caution, replacement of property or business and alternative use of property or business, which are covered in detail in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology. 2. The basis of property or business valuation shall be the benefit that can be obtained if the property or business is used, developed or operated sensibly. 3. The value of property or business may be determined on the basis of: 1) sales transactions; 2) the cost to create (re-create) property or business; 3) income that the property or business generates; 4) other bases of property or business valuation as established in the International Valuation Standards and the European Valuation Standards. Article 6. Approaches to Property or Business Valuation 1. Valuation of property or business shall be carried out using the approaches established under the European Valuation Standards and in cases identified therein. 2. The procedure of application of approaches established under the International Valuation Standards and the European Valuation Standards in cases of property or business valuation as identified therein shall be thoroughly spelled out in the Property and Business Valuation Methodology. CHAPTER TWO PROPERTY OR BUSINESS APPRAISERS AND PROPERTY OR BUSINESS VALUATION COMPANIES Article 7. Classification of Property or Business Appraisers Property or business appraisers shall be classified as follows: 1) an independent property or business appraiser (an external property or business appraiser), an appraiser of property or business, an employee of a property or business valuation company or the owner of a private property or business valuation company or a real member of a property or business valuation partnership, who appraises property or business on behalf of such company under contracts made between the company and its clients, or in cases envisaged in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania, or who is a holder of a private practice certificateand appraises property or business on the basis of contracts with clients and in cases envisaged in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania; 2) an internal property or business appraiser, an appraiser of property or business, an employee of a legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or branches thereof, or the owner of a private company or a real member of a partnership who appraises property or business for the interior purposes of a legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or branches thereof. Article 8. General Requirements for Property or Business Apparaisers A property or business appraiser may be a private individual who: 1) is deemed to be of immaculate repute for the purposes of Article 9.13 hereof; 2) has a university degree in mathematics, statistics, or informatics in the field of physical sciences, general engineering, civil engineering, manufacturing engineering, engineering and building technology in the field of technological sciences, or economics, business, management, or business and management in the field of social sciences, or spatial planning to qualify as an assistant real estate appraiser (lowest-level qualification), appraiser (higher-level qualification), or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification); mathematics, statistics, and informatics in the field of physical sciences, general engineering, mechanical engineering, electronics and electric engineering, manufacturing engineering, land transport engineering, or engineering in the field of technological sciences, or economics, business, management, or business and management in the field of social sciences to qualifyas an assistant movable property appraiser (lowest-level qualification), appraiser (higher-level qualification), or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification); and economics, business, management, or business and management in the field of social sciences to qualify as an assistant business appraiser (lowestlevel qualification), appraiser (higher-level qualification), or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification); 3) has experience relating to property valuations to qualify as an assistant property appraiser (lowest-level qualification), or experience relating to business valuations to qualify as an assistant business appraiser (lowestlevel qualification); 4) has been qualified, for three years or more, as an assistant real estate or movable property appraiser (lowestlevel qualification) to qualify as an appraiser of real estate or movable property, respectively, or a business appraiser (higher-level qualification), or has been qualified, for seven years or more, as a real estate or movable property or business appraiser (higher-level qualification) to qualify as an expert appraiser of real estate or movable property, or an expert business appraiser (highest-level qualification), and has at least three years of experience in conducting real estate or movable property or business valuations to qualify as an appraiser of real estate of movable property, respectively, or a business appraiser (higher-level qualification), or at least seven years of experience in conducting real estate or movable property or business valuations and has prepared at least 50 property or business reports, respectively, to qualify as an expert appraiser of real estate or movable property, or a business appraiser (highest-level qualification); 5) has passed the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser in the manner prescribed by the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations as approved by the minister of finance. Article 9. Qualification of Property or Business Appraisers 1. A private individual who has passed the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser shall be awarded the qualification of assistant appraiser (lowest-level qualification), appraiser (higher-level qualification), or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification) of real estate, movable property, or a business area (“property or business appraiser’s qualification”) and shall have a qualifying certificate of a property or business appraiser issued, with the exception of the case spelled out in Article 11 of this Law. The property or business appraiser’s qualification shall be awarded and the qualifying certification of a property or business appraiser shall be issued by a state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania (“the Regulator”), following the procedure prescribed in the Rules for the Issuing and Effect of the Qualifying Certificate of Property or Business Appraiser as approved by the minister of finance. The list of property or business appraisers who have a valid qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be published by the Regulator on its website. 2. The qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall bear the following details: 1) the number of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser; 2) the full name of the property or business appraiser; 3) the area of real estate or movable property or business valuation; 4) the qualification of an assistant appraiser (lowest-level qualification) or an appraiser (higher-level qualification) or an expert appraiser (highest-level qualification); 5) the date when property or business appraiser’s qualification was awarded; 6) the state regulator of the property or business appraiser and the issuing institutions. 3. The qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be signed by the manager of the issuing institution and shall be endorsed with the seal of the institution. 4. The qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall also bear an image of the property or business appraiser’s face. 5. Property or business appraisers shall be examined by the qualifying examination panel for property or business appraisers (“the examination panel”). The examination panel shall have 5 members, including its chairperson (three members being proposed by the Regulator and one by the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania (“the Ministry of Finance) and higher schools of the Republic of Lithuania (“higher schools”) each). 6. To have one member of the examination panel appointed by the Ministry of Finance, the Regulator shall approach the Ministry of Finance, which shall provide it with a list of three candidates – state officials – for the examination panel. 7. To have one member of the examination panel appointed by higher schools, the Regulator shall approach umbrella organisations of higher schools to provide a list of three candidates for the examination panel. 8. Representatives nominated by the Regulator may be members of an exclusive umbrella association of property and/or business appraisers, and/or property or business appraisers employed with an exclusive umbrella association of property or business valuation companies, or the owners of private companies – members of this association, or real members or partnerships who have the property or business appraiser’s qualification. Exclusive umbrella associations of property and/or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies shall, by mutual consent, nominate three of their members who have the property or business appraiser’s qualification in each area of property or business valuation as candidates to be nominated by the Regulator, provided written consent from such members. 9. A separate examination panel shall be made up for the qualifying examination of each area of property or business evaluation. The constitution of the examination panel shall be approved and its chairperson appointed by the finance minister from among the individuals specified in the summary list of candidates for the examination panel as provided by the Regulator, observing the proportions spelled out in paragraph 3 of this Article. The same individual may be a member of the examination panel for the qualifying examinations of property or business appraiser in several areas of property or business valuation. Upon resignation, removal or revocation of a member of the examination panel, the Regulator shall update the summary list of candidates for the examination panel in the manner laid down in paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 of this Article. 10. The term of office of a member of the examination panel shall be two years. The term of office of a member of the examination panel shall commence on the effective date of the order regarding the approval of the panel or the appointment of another member from the minister of finance. The same individual may only be appointed member of the examination panel for two consecutive terms of office. A member of the examination panel may resign or be removed for reasons specified in paragraph 14 of this Article, or revoked on the basis of a revocation appeal from the institution that nominated such member of the examination panel, prior to expiry of their term of office. To fill the position of a member of the examination panel who has resigned, been removed or recalled, the minister of finance shall appoint another member from the summary list of candidates for the examination panel, observing the proportions specified in paragraph 5 of this Article. 11. 30 days to the end of the term of office of a member of the examination panel, new candidates to sit on the examination panel for the next term of office shall be proposed in the manner stipulated in paragraphs 5, 6, 7 and 8 of this Article. For the purposes of nominating members of the examination panel for the next term of office, unless the associations spelled out in paragraph 8 of this Article do not propose their candidates to serve as members of the examination panel to the Regulator, shall be nominated by the Regulator from among the members (property or business appraisers) of the most numerous exclusive umbrella associations of property or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies, provided consent from such members. 12. A candidate for the examination panel shall: 1) have a university or an equivalent degree in any of the fields specified in the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations; 2) know this Law, the International Valuation Standards, the European Valuation Standards, the Property and Business Valuation Methodology and other legislation regulating valuations of property or business and the activities of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies; 3) be of immaculate repute; 4) be qualified as an appraiser (higher-level qualification) or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification), when that person is nominated by the Regulator; 5) have more than three years of experience of working as a public official, be engaged or involved in drafting bills regulating property or business valuations, when that person is nominated by the Ministry of Finance; 6) have at least three years of experience of teaching in the fields specified in the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations and be qualified at least as an appraiser (higher-level qualification), when that person is nominated by higher school umbrella associations. 13. A person shall not be deemed to be of immaculate repute if they have been: 1) tried and convicted for a grievous or very grievous offence against property, ownership rights, ownership interests, security of electronic data or information systems, economy, the order of business, the financial system, public office or public interests, regardless of whether the conviction has disappeared, or has been lifted or not, as well as tried and convicted for other offences when the conviction has not yet disappeared; 2) terminated on the grounds of any violation of working discipline or removed from a public office for servicerelated misdemeanour within the past three years. 14. The members of the examination panel shall follow the Working Regulations of the Examination Panel for the Qualifying Examination of Property or Business Appraiser. The members of the examination panel shall adhere to the integrity declaration in the form and content established in the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations. If the integrity declaration presented by a member of the examination panel is found to be misleading, that member shall be removed as a member of the examination panel in the manner prescribed in the Working Regulations of the Examination Panel for the Qualifying Examination of Property or Business Appraiser as approved by the minister of finance. The examination panel shall pass its decision on whether the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser has been passed or not. An appeal against the actions of the examination panel may be filed to the Regulator within five business days of the date of the respective action. This deadline may be extended by decision of the Regulator if, in the Regulator’s reasonable opinion, the deadline for making an appeal against a decision of the examination panel has been missed for material reasons (such as breakdowns in communications due to an epidemic, enemy assault, excessive flooding or any other calamity, an illness of the person appealing against the decision of the examination panel for the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser as diagnosed by a healthcare establishment, the death of their any of their family members or next-of-kin, or an abrupt condition that may threaten their lives). Appeals against decisions of the examination panel shall be processed by the Regulator in the manner prescribed in the Rules for Examining Appeals Against Decisions of the Examination Panel for Qualifying Examination of Property or Business Appraiser. 15. The decision to award the qualification of an assistant appraiser (lowest-level qualification) or appraiser (higher-level qualification) or expert appraiser (highest-level qualification) and to issue a property or business appraiser’s qualifying certificate shall be made by the Regulator within 10 business days of the period of time allowed for appeals against the examination panel’s decisions, and shall be published on the Regulator’s website. Article 10. Validity of the Property or Business Appraiser’s Qualifying Certificate 1. The property or business appraiser’s qualifying certificate shall be issued for an unlimited duration. 2. The qualifications of a property or business appraiser shall be subjected to an audit when the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers imposes a disciplinary sanction as specified in Article 29.4.3 of this Law. The qualifications audit shall involve the holding, in line with the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations, of the examination at the highest level of qualification of property or business appraiser that the property or business appraiser has. 3. The validity of a property or business appraiser’s qualifying certificate shall be suspended: 1) when the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers passes a decision to impose a disciplinary sanction as specified in Article 29.4.3 of this Law – upon the expiry of the period of time allowed for appeals against such a decision, if no appeal was made against the decision of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, or after the court decision ruling towards the enforcement of the decision of Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers to impose a disciplinary sanction as specified in Article 29.4.3 of this Law has entered into effect; 2) if, upon receipt (by registered mail) of a written inquiry from the Regulator, the property or business appraiser refuses or fails, within an established period of time and outside of the existence of any of the material reasons spelled out in paragraph 14 of this Article 9, to issue an explanation regarding a property or business valuation conducted by the property or business appraiser; 3) if, at the end of a calendar year, the property or business appraiser fails to provide the Regulator, within a period of three months and in the manner prescribed in the Rules for the Issuing and Effect of the Qualifying Certificate of Property or Business Appraiser, with a property and/or business valuation activity and qualifications improvement report without there being any of the material reasons laid down in paragraph 14 of this Article 9; 4) if the property or business appraiser has, for the past three years and outside of the existence of any of the material reasons spelled out in paragraph 14 of this Article 9, failed to improve their qualifications in the areas indicated in the Description of Requirements for the Education, Professional Experience, and Qualification Improvement of Property or Business Appraiser and, upon receipt (by registered mail) of a written inquiry from the Regulator, has failed to produce documents to support the fact of qualification improvement; 5) when the property or business appraiser is found, by a valid court judgement, guilty of any of the offences spelled out in Article 9.13.1 of this Law,. In any of these cases, the property or business appraiser’s qualifying certificate shall be suspended until the conviction of the property or business appraiser regarding the offences spelled out in Article 9.13.1 of this Law, with the exception of grievous or very grievous offences against property, ownership rights, ownership interests, security of electronic data or information systems, economy, the order of business, the financial system, public office, or public interests, disappears; 6) when the property or business appraiser files a request to suspend the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser. 4. Suspension of validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall render the property or business appraiser’s right to carry out valuations of property or business void, yet the property or business appraiser shall be bound by any and all duties and obligations of the property or business appraiser as specified in Article 15 of this Law, other than the duties and obligations set forth in Article 15.1.3, Article 15.4.3, and Article 15.4.4. 5. Suspension of validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be reversed if the reasons that caused the suspension of validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser are removed within a period of six months, unless the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser was suspended for reasons set forth in paragraphs 3.1, 3.5, and 3.6 of this Article. For the purposes of paragraphs 3.2, 3.3, and3.4 of this Article, if the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser is suspended, the reason that caused the suspension shall be deemed removed when the property or business appraiser files with the Regulator a document supporting the removal of the cause for the suspension or a copy thereof (accompanied by the original document for comparison purposes), unless this document is issued by the Regulator, and a request to reverse the suspension of the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser. If the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser was suspended for the reason specified in paragraph 3.1 of this Article, the reason that caused the suspension shall be deemed removed when the property or business appraiser passes the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser in the manner stipulated in paragraph 2 of this Article and files a request to reverse the suspension of his qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser. If the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser was suspended for the reason specified in paragraph 3.6 of this Article, the suspension of the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be reversed when the property or business appraiser files a request to reverse the suspension of his qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser. 6. The qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be revoked: 1) upon the death of the property or business appraiser; 2) when the property or business appraiser files a request to revoke his qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser; 3) when the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser is suspended for a second time during a period of consecutive three years for reasons other than those spelled out in paragraph 3.6 of this Article; 4) if the property or business appraiser who has had their qualifying certificate suspended fails, over a period longer than six months, to remove the reasons that caused the suspension of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser, unless the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser was suspended for reasons spelled out in paragraphs 3.1, 3.5, and 3.6 of this Article, or fails,over a period longer than 11 months, to pass the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser at the highest level of qualification of property or business appraiser that the property or business appraiser has, according to the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations; 5) when the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers passes a decision to impose a disciplinary sanction as specified in Article 29.4.4 of this Law – upon the expiry of the period of time allowed for appeals against such a decision, if no appeal was made against the decision of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, or after the court decision ruling towards the enforcement of the decision of Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers to impose a disciplinary sanction as specified in Article 29.4.4 of this Law has entered into effect; 6) when the property or business appraiser is found, by a valid court judgement, guilty of any grievous or very grievous offence against property, ownership rights, ownership interests, security of electronic data or information systems, economy, the order of business, the financial system, public office, or public interests. 7. The decision to suspend the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons other than those specified in paragraphs 3.1 and 3.5 of this Article, to reverse the suspension thereof for reasons other than those specified in paragraph 3.5 of this Article, or to revoke the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons other than those specified in paragraphs 6.5 and 6.6 of this Article shall be made by the Regulator within three business days of the date when the bases spelled out in this Article become evident. 8. The decision to suspend the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons specified in paragraph 3.1 of this Article or to revoke the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons specified in paragraph 6.5 of this Article shall be made by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers. 9. The decision to suspend the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons specified in paragraph 3.5 of this Article or to revoke the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser for reasons specified in paragraph 6.6 of this Article shall be made by the court investigating the case. 10. The decisions spelled out in paragraphs 7, 8, and 9 of this Article shall be published by the Regulator on its website within three business days of the date when the respective decision is made. 11. The qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser shall be deemed suspended, or its suspension reversed, or the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser revoked as of the moment of the respective decision to suspend the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser, reverse the suspension, or revoke the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser being published on the Regulator’s website, or the decisions of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers to impose the disciplinary sanctions specified in Articles 29.4.3 and 29.4.4 of this Law entering into effect, or, in the cases specified in paragraph 3.5 or 6.6 of this Article, the respective court judgement entering into effect, or, in the case of paragraph 3.5 of this Article, the conviction regarding the offences spelled out in paragraph 9.13.1 of this Article, other than grievous or very grievous offence against property, ownership rights, ownership interests, security of electronic data or information systems, economy, the order of business, the financial system, public office, or public interests, disappearing. In the cases above listed, all of the qualifying certificates of property or business appraiser held by the property or business appraiser in question shall be considered suspended or revoked, or their suspension reversed. Article 11. Recognition of Professional Qualifications of Property or Business Appraisers from other Member States 1. The professional qualifications of property or business appraisers from other Member States who intend to engage in valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on incorporated or temporary basis shall be recognised in the manner prescribed by the government of the Republic of Lithuania (“the government”) or any other institution authorised by it. 2. The Regulator shall refuse to recognise the qualifications of a property or business appraiser from another Member State who intends to engage in valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis in the event the property or business appraiser in question has been subjected to the disciplinary sanctions specified in Article 29.4.3 of this Law, until the property or business appraiser undergoes an audit of qualifications and passes the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser at the highest level of qualifications that the property or business appraiser had, following the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations. If the property or business appraiser engaging in valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis who has been subjected to the disciplinary sanctions specified in Article 29.4.3 of this Article fails to pass the qualifying examination of property or business appraiser at the highest level of qualifications that the property or business appraiser had, following the Rules for Holding Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations over a period longer than 11 months, their right to engage in valuations of property or business in Lithuania shall be revoked. The decision to revoke the right to engage in valuations of property or business shall be made by the Regulator. Article 12. Requirements for Persons Intending to Engage in Valuations of Property or Business 1. A legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or an independent property or business appraiser shall be entitled to engage in valuations of property or business provided they satisfy the following requirements: 1) at least one property or business appraiser who is qualified at least as an appraiser (higher-level qualification) is employed, or the owner of a private company or a real member of a partnership is qualified at least as an appraiser (higher-level qualification) for legal entities of other organisations incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or any other Member State, or any branches thereof intending to engage in valuations of property or business, or qualified at least as an appraiser (higher-level qualification) for independent property or business appraisers intending to engage in valuations of property or business; 2) compulsory third-party liability insurance is in place for legal entities or other organisations incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or any other Member State, or branches thereof, or independent property or business appraisers intending to engage in valuations of property or business. 2. A legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or branches thereof, or an independent property or business appraiser that satisfies the requirements laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article shall, in the manner prescribed by the Rules for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business as approved by the minister of finance, be entered in the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business (“the List of External Appraisers”) and shall be deemed to stand in conformity to the requirements laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article on the next day after the date when their entry into the list is published on the Regulator’s website. 3. Legal entities incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or branches thereof, that engages in valuations of property or business for internal purposes shall not be entered into the List of External Appraisers. 4. An independent property or business appraiser of another Member State shall be entitled to engage in valuations of property or business if the Regulator recognises their professional qualification in line with the procedure set by the government or another institution authorised by it, and if they have a compulsory thirdparty liability insurancecover in compliance to the requirements specified in Article 17.2 of this Law. A legal entity or any other organisation incorporated in another Member State, or any branches thereof, shall be considered a property or business valuation company and shall be entitled to engage in valuations of property or business if the Regulator recognises the professional qualifications of the property or business appraiser employed by it in line with the procedure set by the government or another institution authorised by it, and if it has a compulsory third-party liability insurance cover in compliance to the requirements specified in Article 17.2 of this Law. Article 13. The Drawing of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in Valuations of Property or Business 1. Before entering a legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or an independent property or business appraiser in the List of External Appraisers, the Regulator shall have in its possession: 1) anapplication, substantially in the form established in the Rules for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business, from the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser for entry of the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser in the List of External Appraisers; 2) a copy of the compulsory third-party liability insurance policy of the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser presented to it by the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser; 3) a copy of the incorporation certificate of the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof. The Regulator shall approach the Register of Legal Entities over the issue of a copy of this certificate; 4) a written confirmation from the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, regarding the property or business appraiser employed by the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the owner of a private company who is a property or business appraiser, or a real member of a partnership who is a property or business appraiser, who holds a valid qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser, specifying the full name and the qualifying certificate number of the property or business appraiser in question; 5) a copy of a private practice certificate. The Regulator shall approach the State Tax Inspectorate under the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania over the issue of a copy of this certificate. 2. The decision to enter a legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or an independent property or business appraiser in the List of External Appraisers shall be made by the Regulator within 10 business days of the date of receipt of the documents spelled out in paragraph 1 of this Article, and shall be published on the Regulator’s website. 3. When a property or business appraiser valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser is entered in the list of the List of External Appraisers, a notice to the effect shall be given on the website of the Regulator, and an appropriate certificate shall be issued. The mandatory form of the certificate shall be approved and the certificate issued by the Regulator. 4. The Regulator shall deny entry in the List of External Appraisers to a legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or an independent property or business appraiser, and shall notify the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser to the effect by registered mail within 10 business days of the date of receipt of documents of copies thereof, if: 1) not all of the mandatory documents or copies thereof as specified in paragraph 1 of this Article have been received; 2) the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or the independent property or business appraiser fails to conform to the requirements laid down in Article 12.1 and Article 17.2 of this Law. 5. The Regulator shall strike a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser from the List of External Appraisers if: 1) a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser files a request to be struck out of the List of External Appraisers; 2) a legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania is wound up or its branch discontinues operation or the Regulator adopts a decisions for reasons spelled out in Article 10.6.1 of this Law; 3) a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser fails to satisfy the requirements specified in Article 12.1 of this Law; 4) a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser fails to satisfy the requirements specified in Article 17.2 of this Law; 5) a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser fails to present the Regulator with the report indicated in Article 15.2.1 and Article 15.4.5 of this Law when due, or the report presented contains incomplete or misleading information specified in Article 15.2.1 and Article 15.4.5 of this Law, and the Regulator has notified the property or business valuation company or the independent property or business appraiser in writing (by registered mail) to the effect; 6) a property or business valuation company, standing in receipt (by registered mail) of a written inquiry form the Regulator, refuses or, within the established period of time, fails to provide any explanation of documents related to valuations of property or business that the property or business valuation company has conducted, without there being any of the material reasons spelled out in Article 9.14 of this Law; 7) the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser is suspended or revoked. 6. A property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser shall be considered struck out of the List of External Appraisers on the next day after the date of publication of the strikeout on the Regulator’s website. 7. A legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, that has been struck out of the List of External Appraisers may be re-entered in the list if the reasons for the strike-out have been eliminated. 8. The decision to strike a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser out of the List of External Appraisers shall be made by the Regulator in the manner prescribed by the Rules for the for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business within 10 business days of the date when any of the circumstances spelled out in paragraph 5 if this Article became evident, and shall be published on the Regulator’s website. 9. The List of External Appraisers shall be published on the Regulator’s website. Article 14. Rights of Property or Business Valuation Companies and Property or Business Appraisers 1. A property or business valuation company or a property or business appraiser shall, for the purposes of valuations of property or business, have the following rights to: 1) obtain from the client any information and data that may be required for the purposes of conducting a valuation of property or business, and access governmental and corporate information as may be required for the purposes of conducting a valuation of property or business; 2) inspect the subject property or business, its physical condition, rights to the subject property or business, restrictions of ownership rights, and other characteristics of the property or business that are relevant for the purposes of determining the value of the property or business; 3) hire necessary specialists and experts to carry out the valuation, subject to the client’s approval. 2. Based on the qualification level, a property or business appraiser shall have the following rights: 1) assistant appraiser – the right to conduct a valuation under the supervision of a property or business appraiser who is qualified as an appraiser or an expert appraiser 2) appraiser – the right to appraise certain kinds of property or business independently; 3) expert appraiser – the right to appraise property of a certain field or business independentlywhen the client or a property or business valuation company or other persons or entities are in dispute with regard to the determination of the value of property or business and issue opinions on this matter or appraise certain types of property or business independently. 3. The provisions of this Law shall apply to assistant property or business appraisers and expert property or business appraisers to the extent they apply to property or business appraisers, unless it is otherwise provided for on contradicts their rights laid down in paragraph 2 of this Article. Article 15. Duties and Obligations of Property or Business Valuation Companies or Property or Business Appraiser 1. A property or business valuation company or a property or business appraiser shall: 1) keep information obtained in the process of conducting a valuation of property or business, which, unless the legislation regulating cases of property or business valuation provide otherwise, is related to the subject of the property or business contract, the fulfilment of the contract and its outcomes confidential, and refrain from using it for personal gain or that of other persons or entities; 2) disclose the information spelled out in paragraph 1.1 of this Article only in the cases provided for in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania and in the cases specified in paragraph 2.3 and paragraph 4.6 of this Article; 3) when entering into property or business valuation contracts, on the client’s request, present the client with a certificate of proof that the property or business valuation company or the independent property or business appraiser has been entered in the List of External Appraisers; this stipulation shall not apply to independent property or business appraisers or property or business valuation companies of other Member States that are conducting valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis. 2. A property or business valuation company shall: 1) within three months of the end of a calendar year, provide,in the manner prescribed by the Rules for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business as approved by the minister of finance, the Regulator with a report on valuations of property and/or business; this stipulation shall not apply to property or business valuation companies that are conducting valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis; 2) have a property or business appraiser who is qualified at least as an appraiser (higher-level qualification) throughout the duration of the property or business valuation activities of the property or business valuation company; 3) upon receipt (by registered mail) of an inquiry from the Regulator, provide it with explanations and documents pertaining to the valuation of property or business (property or business valuation reports, and so on). 3. The report specified in paragraph 2.1 of this Article shall indicate the name, code number, domicile address, legal status, legal form of the property or business valuation company, and contain details of its property and/or business valuation activity over the reporting year, such as the number of property valuations by field and/or the number of business valuations, income from valuations of property and/or business, a list of property or business appraisers employed who have a qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser (stating their full names and the numbers of their qualifying certificates), and a copy of the third-party liability insurance policy of the property or business valuation company. 4. A property or business appraiser shall: 1) follow the Code of Professional Ethics of Property or Business Appraisers; 2) carry out their duties with honesty; 3) conduct valuations in a professional manner; 4) seek to improve their qualifications; 5) within three months of the end of a calendar year, provide, in the manner prescribed by the Rules for the Issuing and Effect of the Qualifying Certificate of Property or Business Appraiser, the Regulator with a property and/or business valuation activity and qualifications improvement report, stating the full name, contact details of the property or business appraiser, the number of property valuations by field and/or the number of business valuations (in the event the property or business appraiser conducted the property or business valuations on the basis of being employed with a property or business company, or as the owner or real member of a property or business company, the number of property or business valuations shall be given together with the name of the property or business valuation company where such valuations were performed), as well as information about the improvement of their qualifications; this stipulation shall not apply to independent property or business appraisers of another Member State that are conducting valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis; 6) upon receipt (by registered mail) of an inquiry from the Regulator, provide it with explanations pertaining to the valuations of property or business performed by the property or business appraiser, and documents pertaining to the valuation of property or business (property or business valuation reports, and so on). Article 16. Responsibility of Property or Business Valuation Companies or Independent Property or Business Appraisers 1. The responsibility of a property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser in conducting valuations of property or business shall be regulated by this Law and other legislation as well as property or business valuation contracts made between the client and the property or business valuation company. 2. The responsibility of legal entities or other organisations incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, in conducting property or business valuations for internal purposes only shall be regulated by this Law and other legislation. Article 17. Compulsory Third-party Liability Insurance of the Property or Business Valuation Company or Independent Property or Business Appraiser 1. A property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser shall maintain a compulsory third-party liability cover throughout the period of engaging in valuations of property or business. 2. The annual threshold of third-party liability insurance shall be LTL 300,000. 3. The object of the compulsory third-party liability insurance shall be the third-party liability of the property or business valuation company and/or independent property or business appraiser for damages done to the client and/or third parties through neglect in performing obligations. 4. Third-party liability of the property or business valuation company and/or independent property or business appraiser resulting from activity that is not related to valuations of property or business shall not be an object of compulsory third-party liability insurance. 5. The terms and conditions of the compulsory third-party liability insurance contract of the property or business valuation company and/or independent property or business appraiser, the pre-contractual and contractual rights and obligations of the parties to the insurance contract shall be regulated by the Rules for Compulsory Thirdparty Liability Insurance of the Property or Business Valuation Company and Independent Property or Business Appraiser as approved by the Insurance Supervisory Commission of the Republic of Lithuania. Article 18. Restrictions of the Rights of Property or Business Valuation Companies to Conduct Valuations of Property or Business A property or business valuation company may not enter into any contracts over valuation of property or business appraiser if: 1) the client is a member of the property or business valuation company, and/or a member of its managing or supervisory bodies; 2) the property or business valuation company is a member of the client; 3) the spouse (live-in) of the client or of a member of the client’s managing body is a shareholder of a member of the property or business valuation company, or a member of its managing or other bodies, or shareholders of a member of the property or business valuation company, or members of its managing or other bodies are close relatives or in-laws to the client or to members of the client’s managing bodies; 4) the property or business valuation company is the owner (co-owner) of the subject property or business. Article 19. Restrictions of the Rights of Property or Business Appraisers to Conduct Valuations of Property or Business 1. A property or business appraiser may not appraise property or business if: 1) the property or business appraiser is the owner (co-owner) of the subject property or business; 2) the property or business appraiser is the spouse (live-in) of the client or of a member of the client who has 1/10 votes or more at the meeting of the client’s members, or the spouse (live-in) of a member of the client’s managing bodies, or is a close relative to the client or members of the client who have 1/10 votes or more at the meeting of the client’s members, or to members of the client’s managing bodies, or is a member of the client or a member of its managing bodies; 3) the qualifying certificate of the property or business appraiser has been suspended. 2. The property or business appraiser shall only appraise properties that they are entitled to appraise pursuant to their qualification of property or business appraiser. CHAPTER THREE BASES OF PROPERTY OR BUSINESS VALUATION Article 20. Bases for Conducting Property or Business Valuations 1. Valuations of property or business shall be conducted in the manner stipulated in Article 21 of this Law. 2. Non-compulsory valuations of property or business shall be conducted on the basis of property or business valuation contracts as individual valuations of property or business. 3. Compulsory valuations of property or business shall be conducted in accordance with this Law and the legislation regulating such valuations as mass valuations of property and/or individual valuations of property or business. Article 21. Performance of Property or Business Valuations 1. Valuation of property or business shall commence upon receipt of the client’s request to determine the value of property or business and the property or business valuation company or an independent property or business appraiser and the client entering into a written property or business valuation contract, unless it is otherwise provided in the legislation regulating cases of compulsory property or business valuation. By agreement of the parties, the contract may be accompanied by terms of reference. 2. The property or business valuation contract shall specify the following: 1) the details of the property or business valuation company or the independent property or business appraiser (its name, legal form, domicile address, code number, registry that compiles and stores data of the company, or the full name and contact details of the independent property or business appraiser); 2) the number of the certificate specified in Article 13.2 of this Law; this stipulation shall not apply to independent property or business appraisers or property or business valuation companies of other Member States that conduct valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis; 3) the client’s details (its name, legal form, domicile address, code number, registry that compiles and stores data of the client, or the full name and contact details of a private individual); 4) the case and subject of property or business valuation, and location of the subject property or business; 5) the date of determination of the value of the property or business and the timeframe of conducting the valuation of the property or business; 6) the amount of the compensation paid for the valuation of the property or business (the price of the service); 7) the rights, obligations, and responsibility of the property or business valuation company and/or property or business appraiser and the client; 8) the date when the contract was made. 3. The contract for the property or business valuation service may contain other terms and conditions. 4. The property or business appraiser shall prepare a property or business valuation report specified in Article 22 of this Law. 5. No report specified in paragraph 1 of this Article shall be required for valuations of property or business performed for internal purposes of a legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof. In that case, providing terms of reference shall be required. The responsibility for drawing terms of reference shall lie with the person entitled to act on behalf of the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, or another person authorised by them. 6. The terms of reference shall specify the following: 1) the title, date, and venue of the terms of reference; 2) the details of the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, engaging in the valuation of property or business (such as its name, legal form, domicile, code number, registry that compiles and stores data of the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof); 3) the case, subject, and venue of valuation of property or business; 4) the individual characteristics of the subject property or business; 5) the date of establishing the value of the property or business and the timeframe of conducting the valuation of the property or business; 6) the full name and signature of the person entitled to act on behalf of the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, or that of the person authorised by them, and the full name and number of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser (for property or business appraisers that are not based in another Member State) and signature of the property or business appraiser. 7. The terms of reference may specify other technical, design, or other details required for the purposes of calculating the value of property or business. 8. The property or business appraiser shall, on the basis of the property or business valuation contract, unless the legislation regulating cases of compulsory property or business valuation provides otherwise, or on the basis of the terms of reference and the International Valuation Standards, the European Valuation Standards, the Property and Business Valuation Methodology, and in consideration of the case of valuation (the specifics and intended use of the subject property or business), adopt approaches (or combinations of approaches) of valuation of property or business, and methods to apply such approaches. 9. The amount of compensation payable for valuation of property or business shall be fixed in the property or business valuation contract. The contract shall clearly define all of the terms and conditions being established therein. Article 22. Property or Business Valuation Report 1. The property or business valuation report shall be concluded in writing. 2. For non-compulsory or compulsory valuations of property or business, the property or business valuation report shall be signed by the independent property or business appraiser drafting it. When valuation of property or business is conducted by an independent property or business appraiser employed with a property or business valuation company, the property or business valuation report shall also be signed by a person entitled to act on behalf of the property or business valuation company, or a person authorised by them, or a person commissioned tosign the property or business valuation report by the legislation. When the independent property or business appraiser is also the owner of a private company, the property or business valuation report shall be signed once. Property or business valuation reports drafted by a property or business valuation company shall also bear the seal of the property or business valuation company, if the property or business valuation company is required to have one. 3. For valuations of property or business for internal purposes of a legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, the property or business valuation report shall only be signed by the property or business appraiser drafting it. 4. The property or business valuation report shall specify the following: 1) the title of the report; 2) the name and location of the subject property or business; 3) individual characteristics of the subject property or business, unless the valuation of property is being conducted as mass valuation of property; 4) the case of valuation; 5) the client’s details (name, legal form, domicile address, code number, registry that compiles and stores data of the client, or the full name and contact details of a private individual); 6) the tenure and owner of the subject property or business, unless the valuation of property is being conducted as mass valuation of property; 7) the details of the property or business valuation company or independent property or business appraiser (the name, legal form, domicile address, code number, register that compiles and stored data of the property or business valuation company, or the full name, contact details of the independent property or business appraiser and the number of the certificate of proof that the property or business valuation company or independent property or business appraiser has been entered in the list of the List of External Appraisers, unless the independent property or business appraiser and property or business valuation company is engaged in property or business valuation in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis); 8) the full names and signatures of the person entitled to act on behalf of the property or business valuation company, or the person authorised by them, or the person commissioned to sign the property or business valuation report by the legislation, and the property or business appraiser; 9) the dates of inspection of the property or business, unless the valuation of property is being conducted as mass valuation of property, and the drafting of the report; 10) terms and conditions that might affect the value of the property or business that have not been considered, providing the reasons for doing so; 11) approaches (or combinations of approaches) of valuation of property or business and methods of application of such approaches; 12) a description of the subject property or business; 13) validation of the value of the property or business, complete with the calculations used in arriving at the value of the property or business; 14) an opinion on the value of the property or business signed by the property or business appraiser drafting it (bearing the property or business appraiser’s full name and signature), stating if the opinion was drawn as a result of there being a dispute between the client and the property or business valuation company or other persons or entitles regarding the determination of the value of the property or business, and the date of the valuation of the property or business. 5. The contents of the property or business valuation report may be enhanced by agreement between the client and the property or business valuation company or independent property or business appraiser, as well as in cases envisaged in the legislation. 6. Property or business valuation reports shall be registered by the property or business valuation company, or individually registered by the independent property or business appraiser. 7. Counterparts (copies) of property or business valuation reports shall be kept at property or business valuation companies conducting valuations of property or business as prescribed by the law; furthermore, independent property or business appraisers from the List of External Appraisers or independent property or business appraisers of other Member States shall be required to keep counterparts (copies) of property or business valuation reports for a minimum period of five years. Article 23. Legal Status of the Property or Business Valuation Report and Disputes Concerning Valuations of Property or Business 1. A property or business valuation report shall be deemed correct unless the Regulator has identified any deviations from the requirements laid down in Article 22 of this Law and/or unless it is contested in court. 2. Any disputes regarding the value of property or business shall be settled by mutual agreement of the parties or in court, unless other legislation otherwise provides. Article 24. Publicity of the Property or Business Valuation Report and Details 1. The property or business valuation report is the property of the client and may be issued to third parties or publicised at the client’s discretion, considering the valuation case addressed in the report, with the exception of the case specified in Article 23.1 of this Law, when the compliance of the property or business valuation report to the requirements laid down in Article 22 of this Law needs to be established, unless the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania or the contracts made between the property or business valuation company or independent property or business appraiser stipulate otherwise. The property or business valuation company or independent property or business appraiser shall present a copy of the counterpart (copy) of the property or business valuation report to the Regulator in the event specified in Article 15.2.3 or Article 15.4.6 of this Law. 2. For valuations of property or business for internal purposes of a legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, the property or business valuation report shall be the property of the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, and may be issued to third parties or publicised at its owner’s discretion, unless the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania provides otherwise. Upon receipt (by registered mail) of a written inquiry from the Regulator, the legal entity or another organisation incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania or another Member State, or any branches thereof, shall issue the property or business valuation report, accompanied by any explanations from the property or business appraiser and documents pertaining to the valuation of the property or business. 3. When the valuation of property or business is carried out for the purposes of taxation, eminent domain, and in other cases envisaged in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania, which are considered to be in the interests of the state and the public, the publicity of the property or business valuation report and its contents shall be regulated by this Law and the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania governing valuations of property or business for taxation, eminent domain purposes and in other cases as envisaged in the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania, which are considered to be in the interests of the state and the public. CHAPTER FOUR REGULATION OF THE ACTIVITIES OF PROPERTY OR BUSINESS APPRAISERS AND PROPERTY OR BUSINESS VALUATION COMPANIES Article 25. Regulation of the Activities of Property or Business Appraisers and Property or Business Valuation Companies The regulation of the activities of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies shall be done by the Regulator. Article 26. Institution Commissioned by the Government of the Republic of Lithuania to Perform State Regulation of Property or Business Appraisers and Property or Business Valuation Companies 1. The Regulator shall operate in line with the law regulating its legal form, unless this Law provides otherwise, and its Statute. 2. In enforcing the provisions of this Law, the Regulator shall: 1) prepare and submit to the Ministry of Finance: draft Description of the Requirements for the Education, Professional Experience and Improvement of Qualifications of Property or Business Appraiser, draft Description of the Procedure for the Recognition of Professional Qualifications of Property or Business Appraisers from other Member States Intending to Engage in Valuations of Property or Business in the Republic of Lithuania on Incorporated, Temporary, or One-time Basis, draft Working Regulations of the Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examination Panel, draft Code of Professional Ethics of Property or Business Appraisers, draft Methodology of Property and Business Valuation, draft Rules for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business, draft Rules for the Audit of Operations of Property or Business Appraisers and Property or Business Valuation Companies, draft Rules for the Holding of Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examinations, draft Rules for the Handling of Complaints Regarding the Decisions of the Property or Business Appraiser Qualifying Examination Panel, draft Rules for the Issuing and Effect of the Qualifying Certificate of Property or Business Appraiser; 2) carry out audits of property or business operations of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies in line with the Rules for the Audit of Operations of Property or Business Appraisers and Property or Business Valuation Companies; 3) handle inquiries about the compliance of property or business valuation reports to the requirements laid down in Article 22 of this Law; 4) handle applicants’ complaints regarding operations of property or business valuation companies and property or business appraisers, observing the procedure and timeframe established in the Public Administration Law of the Republic of Lithuania; 5) enforce decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers upon expiry of the appeal period; 6) coordinate improvements of property or business appraisers’ qualifications; 7) handle the Computerised Property or Business Appraiser and Property or Business Valuation Company Data Handling and Retrieval System in line with the Rules for Using the Computerised Property or Business Appraiser and Property or Business Valuation Company Data Handling and Retrieval System as approved by the Ministry of Finance and the Regulator; 8) be entitled to obtain from private individuals and legal entities (including property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies) information to be used for the purposes of regulating the operations of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies or to be filed with the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, and copies of documents pertaining to valuations of property or business (such as property or business valuation reports, and so on), access information available in the Computerised Property or Business Appraiser and Property or Business Valuation Company Data Handling and Retrieval System and in registries and databases operated and handled by other legal entities; 9) publish a list of property or business appraisers who are holders of valid qualifying certificates of property or business appraisers, and the List of External Appraisers; 10) exercise other rights and duties established in this Law and other legislation. 3. In performing audits of operations of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies as stipulated in paragraph 2.2 of this Article, the Regulator shall: 1) analyse the conformity between the details laid down in reports on operations and improvements of qualifications of property or business appraisers as envisaged in Article 15.4.5 of this Law and the details provided in operating reports of property or business valuation companies as established in Article 15.2.1 of the Law, and/or the accuracy of such details; 2) examines the conformity of property or business valuation reports for a period of three previous years or less as may be drafted by and registered at property or business valuation companies or drafted by property or business appraisers to the requirements laid down in Article 22 of this Law according to the activities plan approved by the Regulator for that year. 4. In exercising its right stipulated in paragraph 2.8 of this Article, the Regulator shall provide reasonable arguments to support its written inquiry demanding release of information and documents pertaining to valuations of property or business (such as property or business valuation reports, and so on), notify (by registered mail) the private individual or legal entity (including the property or business appraiser and property or business valuation company) that is the subject of the information so demanded to the effect, and set a deadline for the release of the documents and information. 5. The employees and former employees of the Regulator shall keep information they may obtain from private individuals and legal entities (including property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies) confidential and shall refrain from using documents pertaining to valuations of property or business (such as property or business valuation reports, and so on) they may obtain for their own gain or that of other persons or entities. The employees and former employees of the Regulator shall be held liable for inappropriate usage or illegal disclosure of such information in the manner prescribed by the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania. 6. The Regulator shall, within four months of the end of a calendar year, present the Ministry of Finance with reports on operations and regulation of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies, the results of such regulation, and the status of property or business valuations in Lithuania. Article 27. Presentation of Decisions by the State Regulator of Property or Business Appraisers and Property or Business Valuation Companies Commissioned as such by the Government of the Republic of Lithuania Within three days of publication of decisions adopted in the cases spelled out in Article 9.15, Article 10.7, and Article 13.2 and 13.8 (with the exception of the personal ID code number of the property or business appraiser) on its website, the Regulator shall dispatch, by registered mail, endorsed copies of such decisions to property or business appraisers that are the subject of such decisions, and legal entities or organisations, or any branches thereof, or property or business valuation companies, which employ the property or business appraisers that are the subject of such decisions. Article 28. Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers 1. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall have five members: 1) three members qualified at least as appraisers (higher-level qualification) shall be appointed, given their consent, by exclusive umbrella associations of property and/or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies out of the members of such exclusive umbrella associations of property and/or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies that are employed by members of the property or business valuation company associations or are the owners of private companies or real members of partnerships; 2) two members – public officials – who have at least three years of experience of holding a public office or experience of drafting or participating in drafting legislation regulating property or business valuations shall be appointed by the Ministry of Finance. 2. The personal makeup of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be approved and its chairperson and deputy chairperson appointed out of the members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers by the minister of finance. 3. The term of office of the members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be three years from the appointment date. The same person may be appointed for a maximum of two consecutive terms of office. A new member of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be appointed within 30 days of the end of the term of office of a retiring court member. Upon the expiry of the term of office of a member of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, they shall continue to serve as a member of the court until a new court member is appointed for the subsequent term of office. Upon resignation of a member of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, the appointing institution or organisation shall appoint a new member of the court within 10 days. An institution appointing a member to the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers may recall the member prior to the expiry of the respective term of office. Upon the recall of a member of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, the appointing institution or organisation shall appoint a new member of the court within 10 days. In the event the associations laid down in paragraph 1.1 of this Article do not appoint their members to the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers in the cases specified in this paragraph, the Regulator shall appoint such members from among the members (property or business appraisers) of the most numerous exclusive umbrella organisations of property or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies, granted the consent of such members. 4. In its operations, the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall abide by this Law and the Regulations of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers as approved by the minister of finance that stipulate the working principles, organisation of business, procedures of disciplinary hearings of property or business appraisers, and procedures for passing decisions of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers. 5. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall have the duty to: 1) investigate disciplinary cases of property or business appraisers; 2) call property or business appraisers to attend sittings of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers for the purposes of disciplinary hearings; 3) pass decisions to impose disciplinary sanctions onto property or business appraisers or close disciplinary hearings. 6. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall have the following rights: 1) the right to approach the Regulator over information (written explanations from property or business appraisers; written explanations from property or business valuation companies and documents pertaining to valuations of property or business; other information relating to a disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser) that may be required for the purposes of initiating and/or conducting a disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser; 2) other rights fixed in the Regulations of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers that are aligned with this Law and other legislation. 7. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers may conduct a disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser if the sitting is attended by more than one-half of the members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers. Decisions of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be adopted by a majority vote from all members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers. 8. The members and former members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall keep information that they may obtain in the process of conducting disciplinary hearings of property or business appraisers confidential and shall refrain from using it for their own personal gain or that of other persons or entities. The members and former members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be held liable for any violations of this provision in the manner prescribed by the legislation of the Republic of Lithuania. 9. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be represented at other institutions by the chairperson and deputy chairperson of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers. 10. The Regulator shall be in charge of supplying the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers with all the hardware and materials necessary. Article 29. Disciplinary Hearings of Property or Business Appraisers 1. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall subject property or business appraisers to one of the disciplinary sanctions spelled out in paragraph 4 of this Article for failure to adhere to the provisions of this Law, the International Valuation Standards, the European Valuation Standards, the Property and Business Valuation Methodology, the Code of Professional Ethics of Property or Business Appraisers. 2. The Regulator shall draw and file a written motion to initiate a disciplinary hearing towards a property or business appraiser based on the available information (i.e. information submitted by persons in writing or information in possession of the Regulator) about the infringements laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article to the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers within 10 business days of the date when such information was received or became evident. Information about infringements of this Law, the International Valuation Standards, the European Valuation Standards, the Property and Business Valuation Methodology, the Code of Professional Ethics of Property or Business Appraisersmade by property or business appraisers of other Member States shall be forwarded to the competent body of the respective Member State by the Regulator by registered mail. 3. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall pass a decision to initiate a disciplinary hearing towards a property or business appraiser within 10 business days of the date of receipt of a written motion to initiate a disciplinary hearing towards a property or business appraiser from the Regulator. 4. The following disciplinary sanctions shall apply to property or business appraisers for the infringements specified in paragraph 1 of this Article: 1) a caution; 2) a reprimand; 3) suspension of the validity of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser or temporary restriction of the right to engage in property or business valuations and a qualifications audit for a property or business appraiser from another Member State who engages in property or business valuations on temporary or one-time basis; 4) suspension of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser or revocation of the right to engage in property or business valuations of a property or business appraiser from another Member State who engages in property or business valuations on temporary or one-time basis. 5. One infringement shall only entail one disciplinary sanction. One year after the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers passes a decision to impose a disciplinary sanction, the property or business appraiser shall be deemed to have never had any such sanction applied. 6. Unless any of the infringements laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article are found during a disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser, the disciplinary hearing of the property or business appraiser shall be closed. 7. The Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall pass its decision within 60 days from the date when the disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser was initiated. Unless the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers passes a decision within 60 days from the date when the disciplinary hearing of a property or business appraiser was initiated, the disciplinary hearing of the property or business appraiser shall be deemed closed. If the Regulator has adopted a decision to impose the sanctions stipulated in this Law on a property or business appraiser for the infringements laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article, no disciplinary sanction shall be applied to the property or business appraiser, or the disciplinary hearing of the property or business appraiser shall be deemed closed. 8. Decisions of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be binding on property or business appraiser, property or business valuation companies, and the Regulator. 9. Having passed a decision to impose a disciplinary sanction, the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall, within 10 business days of the date of passing its decision, submit the decision to the Regulator, which shall, within three business days of the date of submission of the decision to the Regulator, notify the property or business appraiser of the decision passed in writing (by registered mail), enclosing a copy of the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers endorsed by the Regulator. An endorsed copy of the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall also be dispatched (by registered mail) to the property or business valuation company or the legal entity incorporated in the Republic of Lithuania, or any branches thereof, that employ the property or business appraiser who is the subject of the relevant decision. 10. Extracts from decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall, within three business days of the date of receipt of the relevant decision by the Regulator, be published in the file of the property or business appraiser who is the subject of the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, which file is available in the Computerised Property or Business Appraiser and Property or Business Valuation Company Data Handling and Retrieval System. After the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers enters into effect, its extract shall be published on the website of the Regulator. This publication shall also include details as to the date of commencement of application of the disciplinary sanction to the property or business appraiser. 11. The content of an extract of a decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers as published on the Regulator’s website shall contain the following details: 1) the full name of the property or business appraiser; 2) the number (or numbers) of the qualifying certificate of property or business appraiser, unless the appraiser in question is an independent property or business appraiser of another Member State engaging in valuations of property or business in the Republic of Lithuania on temporary or one-time basis; 3) the date when the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers was passed on the disciplinary hearing of the property or business appraiser was closed; 4) the sanction imposed by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers as per stipulations of paragraph 4 of this Article, or any of the circumstances spelled out in paragraph 6 and 7 of this Article. 12. Extracts from decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be published on the Regulator’s website for the duration of the relevant disciplinary sanctions imposed on property or business appraisers only. 13. Decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall enter into effect upon the expiry of the period of time allowed for appeal, if not such appeal was made. If a decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers has been appealed against, the decision shall enter into effect once the court judgement enforcing the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers becomes effective. Article 30. Procedure of Making Appeals against Decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers 1. Appeals against decisions by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers may be made to the Administrative Court of District of Vilnius within 30 days of dispatch (by registered mail) of the relevant decision to the property or business appraiser and the publication of an extract from the decision in the file of the property or business appraiser who is the subject of the decision by the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, which file is available in the Computerised Property or Business Appraiser and Property or Business Valuation Company Data Handling and Retrieval System. 2. The Regulator’s decisions shall be appealed against to the Administrative Court of District of Vilnius within 30 days of their publication on the Regulator’s website.” Article 2. Effective Date of the Law With the exception of Article 4, this Law shall enter into effect on 1 May 2012. Article 3. Enforcement of the Law 1. In line with the Rules for the Drawing, Handling, and Publication of the List of Persons and Entities Entitled to Engage in External Valuations of Property or Business, the state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania shall, within three months of the effective date of this Law, enter property or business valuation companies that hold valid qualifying certificates of corporate entities issued by the public company Institute for Audit, Accounting, and Property Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania prior to the effective date of this Law, and certificates specified in Article 13.3 of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania, in the List of External Appraisers. Three months after the effective date of this Law, property or business valuation companies that hold valid qualifying certificates of corporate entities issued by the public company Institute for Audit, Accounting, and Property Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania prior to the effective date of this Law shall be entitled to engage in valuations of property and/or business regardless of the provisions of Article 12.2 of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Law, and in the case stipulated in Article 21.2.2 and Article 22.4.7 such companies shall state the numbers of their valid qualifying certificates of corporate entities issued by the public company Institute for Audit, Accounting, and Property Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania prior to the effective date of this Law. 2. Property or business appraisers that hold valid qualifying certificates of property or business appraiser issued by the public company Institute for Audit, Accounting, and Property Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania prior to the effective date of this Lawshall be entitled to engage in valuations of property or business until 1 January 2018 regardless of the provisions of Article 8.2 and Article 8.3 of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Law. Decisions regarding suspension, suspension or reversal of suspension of valid qualifying certificates of property or business appraiser issued by the public company Institute for Audit, Accounting, and Property Valuation of the Republic of Lithuania prior to the effective date of this Lawshall be made by the state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania and the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers in the cases spelled out in the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Law. 3. Unless, within 30 business days of the effective date of this Law: 1) the associations specified in Article 9.8 of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Lawfile with the state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania a list of nominees for the property or business appraiser qualifying examination panel in the case indicated in the paragraph above mentioned, the state regulator of property or business appraisers and property or business valuation companies commissioned as such by the government of the Republic of Lithuania shall nominate such candidates from among the members (property or business appraisers) of the most numerous exclusive umbrella associations of property or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies, granted consent from such members; 2) the associations specified in Article 28.1.1 of the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Lawappoint members to the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers, they shall be appointed by the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania. In the case specified in this paragraph, members of the Honorary Court of Property or Business Appraisers shall be appointed by the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania from among the members (property or business appraisers) of the most numerous exclusive umbrella associations of property or business appraisers and/or property or business valuation companies, granted consent from such members. Article 4. Proposal to the Government and other Bodies of the Republic of Lithuania The government of the Republic of Lithuania, the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania, and the Insurance Supervisory Commission of the Republic of Lithuania shall, prior to this Law entering into effect and within the limits of their individual competences, adopt legislation enforcing this Law, make the necessary decisions, approve legislation assigned to them, and coordinate other items of legislation necessary for the purposes of enforcing this Law and the Law on Bases of Property and Business Valuation of the Republic of Lithuaniaas laid down in Article 1 of this Law. I hereby pronounce this Law adopted by the parliament of the Republic of Lithuania. DALIA GRYBAUSKAITĖ PRESIDENT REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA