The Kingdom of Tonga In collaboration with the University of the South Pacific Pacific Centre for Environment and Sustainable Development (USP PACE-SD), DAI facilitated C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise in five Tongatapu Island Group villages—Ahau, Nukuleka, Popua, Sopu and Tatakamotonga— through one-day sessions held between Thursday, January 10th and Friday, January 18th. Through one day sessions in each community, DAI led an introduction to C-CAP, and each village’s C-CAP Community Committee (CCC) participated in climate change risk identification and infrastructure mapping exercises. Following the workshop, communities’ Town Officers and interested CCC members led the C-CAP team on a tour of the village’s social, economic, coastal and water infrastructure. C-CAP geo-referenced and photographed these community assets and uploaded data points mapping software. Each CCC was initiated by the community’s Town Officer (Mayor), with guidance from the USP PACE-SD In-Country Coordinator Lopeti Faka’osi and Co-Chair of their National Project Advisory Committee Simi Silapelu. All CCCs are comprised of 15 village, youth, and women leaders. Background Tongatapu Island is home to 75-percent of the Kingdom of Tonga’s population of 103,036. Between 2006 and 2011, the number of Tongatapu households grew 3.4-percent, while all other Tonga island groups experienced a declining number of households during the same period1. This population trend is expected to increase as residents flock from the outer islands to reside close to Nuku’alofa, the capital city and economic hub of the Kingdom. The population influx is merging with the changing climate to compound stress on the island’s natural resource base. Each of C-CAP’s five communities—situated at various ends of the northern coast of Tongatapu—is increasingly at risk, as outlined in the sections below. Across the communities, CCCs all reported that sea level rise and resulting coastal inundation and erosion is impacting their communities. This is consistent with analysis conducted by the Pacific Climate Change Science Program which reports a 6 mm rise of sea level near Tonga each year since 19932. This exceeds the global average of 2.8 to 3.6 mm per year. Each village also extolled the virtues of sea walls for protecting their coastal zone despite acknowledging the maladaptive nature of this intervention; each CCC was aware that sea walls are expensive, require frequent repair, and redirect and intensify ocean currents towards neighboring villages without sea walls—causing extreme erosion and inundation. Among other climate change risks and impacts experienced in Tongatapu, each CCC cited more intense rains as the cause of village flooding, erosion and sedimentation of near shore marine environments. While freshwater needs varied across the C-CAP communities, each CCC believes that drought is more frequent in Tongatapu and rain falls less often, but in more intense showers. This is corroborated by the Pacific Climate Change Science Program, that reports a trend of decreasing rainfall in Nuku’alofa since 1950. 1 2 http://www.spc.int/prism/tonga/index.php/tonga-documents/doc_download/94-preliminary-count-2011 http://www.cawcr.gov.au/projects/PCCSP/Nov/Vol2_Ch14_Tonga.pdf -2- While there was no clear consensus among the communities on whether there has been a significant change in the frequency and intensity of cyclones and other climate-related natural disasters, each year high wind events do impact livelihoods through damage to food-bearing trees that each village depends on as a food and income source. Breadfruit, mango, coconut and banana trees are particularly vulnerable to high wind events. Coconut tree damage can have far ranging impacts. Coconut cream is used in most Tongan dishes. Coconuts are also used as pig feed. This is important, as most families own and care for pigs to be used primarily for celebrations and family and cultural obligations. Livelihoods are also impacted by an increase in illness and infection following floods and cyclones, both of which can cause freshwater tank contamination. Villages also cited sea spray from cyclones and high-wind events increase corrosion of household and community center roofs, which then contaminates the village’s freshwater supply that is collected from gutter systems and rainwater tanks. Tatakamotonga Tatakamotonga, a community that sits on the coast of the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon in east Tongatapu, has a population of 1,761. Beyond its historic significance as the landing site / docking point of the first missionaries to arrive to Tonga—in 1799—Tatakamotonga is the social and economic hub of the eastern end of Tongatapu Island. Tatakamotonga’s local police outpost and health clinic provide social services to eastern villages, while a local bank branch, cash transfer outpost, convenience stores and informal roadside markets provide an economic and financial foundation for the area. Tatakamotonga Town Officer Hone Felemi and the Tatakamotonga CCC took part in the C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise on Thursday, January 10, 2013 in the Tatakamotonga Town Hall. Risk Identification Before more rigorously assessing impacts against climate projections/GIS-based contour maps, the Tatakamotonga CCC identified observed climate change risks and impacts in the village. After leading a brief overview on climate change and global impacts of climate change, the CCC analyzed and presented the local impacts of global warming, precipitation pattern changes, and natural disasters experienced in Tatakamotonga. -3- Image 18: A member of the Tatakamotonga CCC leads a presentation on climate change impacts and risks in Tatakamotonga. Additional Tatakamotonga photos can be seen here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/90755241@N08/sets/72157632510501404/ Global Warming Impacts The CCC reports that the primary impacts of global warming are being experienced in the coastal zone of the village in the form of rising sea level and increases in average ocean temperature. While average sea level rise encroaches on arable land—Town Officer Felemi and Youth Group President Sifa Latunipulu note that this is compounded by sea swells and king tide events that contribute to erosion, causing more accelerated land loss. A local home that stands meters from the coastline and the Mu’a Government Primary School are the closest village infrastructure to the coastline. Global warming is also causing impacts on local livelihoods. The CCC advised that they are experiencing decreases in near shore fisheries and marine animal products, such as shellfish, which they attribute to rising average ocean temperature; the CCC also notes that overharvesting of coastal mangroves impacts near-shore fisheries. While not suggested by the CCC, it is also likely that overfishing has contributed to losses. Outside of the coastal zone, community plantation sites have also experienced losses which may be attributed to rising air temperatures, as well as increases in intensity/frequency of natural disasters, and drought. In this agrarian society, any decrease in root crops, tuber and vegetable production has far-ranging implications on household subsistence and income-generation capability. Precipitation Pattern Changes The CCC ascribes variations in seasonality and increasing numbers of drought and heavy rain events to climate change-induced precipitation pattern changes. They report an increase in soil erosion and coastal pollution related to flooding that typically occurs after periods of heavy rain. Tatakamotonga is divided into halves by Taufa’ahau Road—the main road on Tongatapu; the north side of the village beyond the road slopes to the lagoon at the southern end of the village. Lacking a proper drainage system, rainwater runoff and floodwaters carry pollution and sediment to the coastline. Points without mangrove forest cover are experiencing erosion. The village -4- reports that runoff of sediment, pollution and chemicals used in agriculture contributes to the death of mangrove forests and fisheries. While precipitation intensity is projected to increase in the Pacific Islands region, the number of rainy days per year is expected to decrease. Resulting periods of drought are also a major concern of the Tatakamotonga CCC. The CCC notes that recent droughts have resulted in lost production and stunted growth of villagers’ vegetable and root crops and tubers. In addition to the impact on agriculture, the village reports that incidence of typhoid increases during periods of drought. Natural Disasters The village did not note a discernible difference over the past decade in the number / frequency of cyclones and other natural disasters but did describe serious impacts on village infrastructure, livelihoods and environment that are caused by extreme weather events. Infrastructure damage stems primarily from high wind events and cyclones, and related flooding. Destroyed roofs were the most common impact according to the CCCs. The CCC also explained that coastal erosion is exacerbated by storm surges and cyclone-related flooding. Economic, Social and Water Infrastructure Mapping Following identification of local climate change impacts, the CCC completed hand-drawn community infrastructure maps, highlighting economic, social and water infrastructure that may be vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and extreme weather events (see Annex 2.3). Image 19: Tatakamotonga Climate Change Risk Map, with geo-referenced economic, social and water and coastal infrastructure points, photographs and risk profiles. Interactive map can be found here: https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=210276136318794746510.0004d2d3fd958bb2d093f&msa=0&ll=-21.18013,175.117908&spn=0.027411,0.052314&iwloc=0004d3260c5ea6433f6de. -5- Economic Infrastructure Table 31: Tatakamotonga Economic Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability Tatakamotonga Community Hall The Community Hall building rents space to a branch of the Tonga Development Bank, a privately-owned convenience store, and two money transfer centers at which villagers collect remittances. Tatakamotonga Youth-Run Coconut Oil Manufacturing Coconut oil is manufactured by youth and sold to restaurants located in Nuku’alofa. This is an important source of income and business education for Tatakamotonga youth. Private-Owned Seedling Nursery Though privately owned, this business supplies villagers with essential inputs for vegetables, cash crops and traditional plants/flowers. 4. Village Plantations Subsistence and semi-subsistence agriculture is the primary livelihood source for Tatakamotonga. 5. Roadside Informal Market Semi-subsistence farmers sell crops to residents of the Hahake District at this roadside market. This is an important source of income for families in the community and a food source for residents of the Hahake District. 1. 2. 3. 6. Mangrove Forests Mangrove forests serve as nurseries for coral reef fish and feeding grounds for fish and other marine life. Mangroves are essential for the sustainability of nearshore fisheries. Flooding (located on northern slope of the village) Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding (located on northern slope of the village) Extreme Weather Event—structural and roof damage Extreme Weather Event—structural and roof damage Drought Drought Flooding Extreme Weather Event—damage to cassava, tree crops (root crops and tubers often survive) The informal market is housed in a local gas station. The primary vulnerability is to damage incurred to crops prior to harvest. Mature Mangroves Pollution Deforestation Young Mangroves Storm Surge Extreme Weather Flooding—sedimentation, pollution Social Infrastructure Table 32: Tatakamotonga Social Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability Sea Level Rise Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding (located on northern slope of the village) Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding Flooding Extreme Weather Event—structural and roof damage 1. Mu’a Government Primary School School for village youth in grades 1-6. 2. Tatakamotonga Town Hall The Community Hall is the center for regularly held village meetings, development program meetings and all discussion of village policy. It is also used for community events and informal social gatherings. 3. Hahake District Health Clinic The Hahake District Health Clinic was recently constructed with funding from China Aid. It serves the health needs of residents of the Hahake District. 4. Hahake District Police Outpost The Hahake District Police Outpost provides security and police services to residents of the Hahake District. 5. Men’s Hall Men’s halls are centers for nightly gatherings and kava drinking-fundraisers for community social issues. Flooding Extreme Weather Event—structural and roof damage 6. Women’s Hall The Women’s hall is a center for regular gatherings and community events. Flooding Extreme Weather Event—roof damage -6- Water and Coastal Infrastructure Table 33: Tatakamotonga Water and Coastal Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Sea Wall 1 / Missionary Landing Site Sea Wall 1 was constructed in front of a memorial to the landing site of the first missionary to arrive in Tonga (1799), and was designed to stem erosion and to provide a coastal barrier against king tides, storm surges and average sea level rise. Erosion Flooding Extreme Weather Event—storm surge Sea Level Rise 2. Sea Wall 2 / Nahafu Point Sea Wall 2 was designed to stem erosion and to provide a coastal barrier against king tides, storm surges and average sea level rise; it was built to stem coastal flooding of Nahafu Point. Erosion Flooding Extreme Weather Event—storm surge Sea Level Rise 3. Tatakamotonga Reservoir / Water Pumps 1, 2 The reservoir / water pump—run by the Tatakamotonga Water Committee—provides piped water, used for cooking, cleaning and hygiene—to homes. Drought Extreme Weather Event—structural damage Tatakamotonga Rainwater Tanks 1, 2, 3 (Concrete) Freshwater reserve tanks were formerly used by community members without a household rainwater catchment tank. All have fallen into disuse and need to be rehabilitated. Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) 4. Nukuleka Nukuleka, a small village with a population of 265 individuals in the Lapaha District, is situated along the mouth of the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon in northeast Tongatapu. It is significant as the site of “the cradle of Polynesia,” where 2,900 year-old pieces of “Lapita” pottery were discovered by Canadian archaeologist Professor David V. Burley in 2007. Lapita pottery is the primary source of the archaeological-defined path and timeline of the peopling of the Pacific Islands from coastal Melanesia, Micronesia, and northeast through Polynesia to Samoa. Professor Burley’s findings indicate that Nukuleka was the launching point of the inhabitation and culture of Polynesia, extending from New Zealand in the south to Hawaii in the north and finally to Easter Island in the east3. This site of historical significance is also one of six eastern Tongatapu villages being targeted by the Ministry of Land, Environment, Climate Change and Natural Resources (MoLECN) — through approximately $576,000 in funding by the Secretariat of the Pacific Community—for coastal zone management support. MoLECN has expressed interest in leveraging these resources with support from C-CAP for a coastal infrastructure rehabilitation / development. Currents moving water from the open ocean into the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon around the peninsular Nukuleka, has formed an inlet of brackish water that is cutting inland behind the village. Vulnerable to sea level rise, flooding/inundation and accelerated coastal erosion, these climate change impacts are combining to consume greater amounts of Nukuleka’s arable land each year. Town Officer Sitiveni Fe’au and the Nukuleka CCC took part in the C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise on Monday, January 14, 2013 in the Nukuleka Catholic Church Hall. 3 "Canadian rewrites Oceania history", Randy Boswell, Calgary Herald, 21 January 2008 -7- Risk Identification Before more rigorously assessing impacts against climate projections/GIS-based contour maps, the Nukuleka CCC identified observed climate change risks and impacts in the village. After leading a brief overview on climate change and global impacts of climate change, the CCC analyzed and presented the local impacts of global warming, precipitation pattern changes, and natural disasters experienced in Nukuleka. Global Warming Impacts Rising sea levels and resulting more extreme tidal movements and sea surges are the most significant risk to Nukuleka from the impact of global warming, according to the Nukuleka CCC. Sea level rise has accelerated coastal erosion in Nukuleka, damaging the village sea wall, and inundating unprotected land on the western end of the village. The Nukuleka CCC postulates that the Nuku’alofa (capital city) sea wall has altered the effects of ocean waves and currents, causing down coast erosion problems in their community. The village representatives expressed concern over the coastal road which serves as the only entry and exit point to the village. The CCC’s initial preferences are to protect the coast—and road—from sea level rise and to develop an alternative entry/exit road from the community that would connect to Tongatapu’s main Taufa’ahau Road. Image 20: Erosion plagues Nukuleka, a peninsula in northeast Tongatapu Island. Additional Tatakamotonga photos can be seen here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/90755241@N08/sets/72157632520198858/ Precipitation Pattern Changes Precipitation patterns no longer follow the typical Tongan wet and dry season, according to the village. The village notes a decrease in frequency, yet increase in intensity, of rainy days— which impacts livelihoods in terms of food and water security. Resulting periods of drought have impacted subsistence and semi-subsistence farming in the community—reducing harvests of root crops and tubers. The village also depends upon regular rainfall to replenish their freshwater supply which is collected in rainwater catchment tanks. -8- Like the other C-CAP priority communities in Tonga, Nukuleka’s roads lack proper drainage; the CCC notes that roads, which are elevated, can cause flooding in the land they dissect during periods of heavy rain. The CCC report an increase in soil erosion related to flooding that typically occurs after periods of heavy rain. Lacking a proper drainage system, rainwater runoff and floodwaters carry sediment to the coastline, causing erosion of roads, land, and the village sea wall while also harming the offshore reef and near shore marine life. Natural Disasters Like its peer CCCs in other Tongatapu villages, the Nukuleka CCC shared the impacts of cyclones and gale-force wind events on food-bearing trees and roofs, and noted that storm surges inundate coastal infrastructure, increase erosion, and damage near-shore fisheries. The CCC’s main concern, however, was that the village lacks a proper disaster warning system. While disaster risk management plans have been drafted for the village, Nukuleka only has one exit road out of their village. This road, as previously noted, runs along the coast and can be flooded by sea surges. While the CCC’s preference is to construct an alternative exit road that cuts through inland mangrove swamp behind the village to Taufa’ahau Road, a warning system that provides ample evacuation notice can also help villages to escape disaster. Economic, Social and Water Infrastructure Mapping Following identification of local climate change impacts, the CCC completed hand-drawn community infrastructure maps, highlighting economic, social and water infrastructure that may be vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and extreme weather events (see Annex 2.3). Image 21: Nukuleka Climate Change Risk Map, with geo-referenced economic, social and water and coastal infrastructure points, photographs and risk profiles. Interactive map can be found here: https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=210276136318794746510.0004d33be568fba98a5f2&msa=0 -9- Economic Infrastructure Table 34: Nukuleka Economic Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Lapita Pottery Excavation Site In 2007, the oldest pieces of Lapita Pottery found to date in Polynesia were excavated from a site in Nukuleka. The village views this as a potential tourism site. Flooding 2. Nukuleka Village Road This road is the only entry and exit point to the community and thus is an important transportation route for villagers traveling to Nuku’alofa for work and for those who sell crops and fish to market. Flooding Erosion Storm Surge 3. Nukuleka Plantation Road This road leads to most villagers’ plantation plots, and is thus essential for food security and the village economy. Heavy rains make this unpaved road impassable. Flooding Erosion 4. 5. Mangroves Mangrove forests serve as nurseries for coral reef fish and feeding grounds for fish and other marine life. Mangroves are essential for the sustainability of nearshore fisheries. Coral Reef Coral reefs are important feeding grounds for a variety of fish, and thus important for local fisher people. Overfishing and sedimentation of reefs have reduced fish catches, pushing fisher people further out to sea to maintain catch levels. Mature Mangroves Pollution Deforestation Young Mangroves Storm Surge Extreme Weather Flooding—sedimentation, pollution Sedimentation Overfishing Rising Sea Temperature Storm Surge Social Infrastructure Table 35: Nukuleka Social Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Government Primary School School for village youth in grades 1-6. Extreme Weather Event—roof damage 2. Town Hall The Community Hall is the center for regularly held village meetings, development program meetings and all discussion of village policy. It is also used for community events and informal social gatherings. Flooding Extreme Weather Event—roof damage 3. Sports Field Center for village play and sporting events. Flooding Cemetery 1, 2 Both village cemeteries are situated on the coastline. While one is protected by a sea wall, the coastline is rapidly eroding towards the second cemetery grounds. Flooding Storm Surge Erosion Sea Level Rise 4. Water and Coastal Infrastructure Table 36: Nukuleka Water and Coastal Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Town Hall Rainwater Tanks (2) (Concrete) Water supply for community events and gatherings. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) - 10 Catholic Church Hall Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. (see above) 3. GPS Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for students and teachers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. (see above) 4. LDS Church Rainwater Tank (Fiberglass) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. Drought—reservoir dries; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) 5. Nukuleka Reservoir / Water Pumps 1, 2 The reservoir / water pump—run by the Nukuleka Water Committee—provides piped water, used for cooking, cleaning and hygiene—to homes. Nukuleka has two 5,000 liter fiberglass reservoir tanks and two water pumps; however, one reservoir tank is cracked, and one machine is no longer working. Drought Extreme Weather Event—structural damage 6. Drainage Drainage channel accommodates sea water flow during tidal changes, and serves as a channel for rainwater runoff. Erosion Sea Wall Sea Wall was designed to stem erosion and to provide a coastal barrier against king tides, storm surges and average sea level rise; it was built to protect the road and to stop coastal erosion. Erosion Flooding Extreme Weather Event—storm surge Sea Level Rise 2. 7. Sopu (Kolomotu’a) Sopu (Kolomotu’a) is Tonga’s second largest village, with a population of 7,870. It is located to the west of capital city Nuku’alofa, serving as a ‘suburb’ for workers. The Nuku’alofa sea wall ends at the far western edge of Sopu, where ocean currents continue to erode the coastline, creating a channel into a swamp that extends into the center of the village. During the rainy season (November – April) and extreme rainy periods during the dry season, homes and other community infrastructure experience near constant flooding. Town Officer (Mayor) Sio Tu’iano, Town Committee Chairperson Drew Havea and the Sopu CCC took part in the C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise on Tuesday, January 15, 2013 in the Kolomotu’a Town Hall. Risk Identification Before more rigorously assessing impacts against climate projections/GIS-based contour maps, the Sopu CCC identified observed climate change risks and impacts in the village. After leading a brief overview on climate change and global impacts of climate change, the CCC analyzed and presented the local impacts of global warming, precipitation pattern changes, and natural disasters experienced in Sopu. Global Warming Impacts Similarly to Nukuleka, rising sea levels and resulting more extreme tidal movements and storm surges are the most significant risk to Sopu from the impact of global warming, according to the Sopu CCC. These issues have increased erosion and flooding in the village center, rather than along the coast, however; impacts are primarily felt on the outskirts of the inland mangrove swamps that extend from the end of the Nuku’alofa / Sopu sea wall through to the center of Sopu. - 11 - Image 22: Inland flooding impacts households / infrastructure on the outskirts of the inland mangrove swamps. Inland flooding is most severe during the rainy season from November through April, but also occurs throughout the year during periods of heavy rain. Also like Nukuleka and Ahau CCCs, the Sopu CCC attributes much of the accelerated coastal erosion and flooding to impacts of the Nuku’alofa sea wall. Rising sea temperatures and sedimentation caused by increased erosion also have impacts on near shore fisheries that are a staple of Sopu community livelihoods. Shellfish gathering is an important semi-subsistence activity for many households in this coastal village. Each day at low tide, Sopu villagers can be seen from the coastal road gathering shellfish, and collecting their catch from fish traps. The CCC expressed concern that rising ocean temperature can impact coral reef health and the health of coral reef fish, shellfish and other near shore marine animals. The CCC also cited the increased risks of vector-borne diseases—such as malaria and dengue fever—carried by mosquitoes which breed in the stagnant flood and swamp waters that envelop Sopu during the rainy/hot season. While malaria is not endemic to Tonga, stagnant water pools increase risks of dengue fever outbreaks. The CCC expressed concern, however, that rising air temperatures could eventually draw Tonga into the malaria zone. Precipitation Pattern Changes The Sopu CCC notes a decrease in frequency, yet increase in intensity, of rainy days—which combines with the impacts of sea level rise to intensify flooding in the village. Flood waters that drain into the Pacific Ocean and the inland mangrove swamps also exacerbate erosion from tidal flows and sea surges. - 12 - Image 23: Homes and infrastructure throughout Sopu experience frequent flooding. Additional Sopu photos can be seen here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/90755241@N08/sets/72157632524253609/ Land use plans and building codes that were referred to during road and home construction are outdated, according to the CCC. Road, homes, and other community infrastructure—particularly those in the center of the village close to the inland mangrove swamp—are left vulnerable to flooding throughout the year. It is worth noting that the number of Kolomotu’a households has increased 11-percent between 2006 and 2011. If urbanization rates continue to rise, poorly planned roads and buildings that are vulnerable to the impacts of climate change can be expected to have an even greater impact on the community. Natural Disasters The CCC explained that while “cyclone season” in Tonga runs from November to April, in the past cyclones fell primarily in February and March. In the past decade, however, the CCC advised that cyclones have been more frequent and no longer predictably occur only in February and March. Like the CCC’s analysis of risks stemming from global warming and precipitation pattern changes, they also linked the primary impacts of natural disasters to flooding and inundation. The intensity of storm surges during cyclones and gale force wind events also increase erosion in coastal areas and the inland mangrove swamps. Natural disasters also levy significant impacts on semi-subsistence shellfish gathering and coral reef fishing in coastal Sopu. Storm surges and waves often damage reefs and the areas inside the coral reefs inhabited by shellfish. Economic, Social and Water Infrastructure Mapping Following identification of local climate change impacts, the CCC completed hand-drawn community infrastructure maps, highlighting economic, social and water infrastructure that may be vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and extreme weather events (see Annex 2.3). - 13 - Image 24: Sopu Climate Change Risk Map, with geo-referenced economic, social and water and coastal infrastructure points, photographs and risk profiles. Interactive map can be found here: https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=210276136318794746510.0004d3502669190cd0353&msa=0 Economic Infrastructure Table 37: Sopu Economic Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Village Park Planned recreation area for future local tourism development. Flooding Erosion Storm Surge Sea Level Rise—inundation 2. Village Roads Village roads are essential for villagers traveling to Nuku’alofa for work and for those who sell crops and fish to market. Flooding Erosion Mangroves Mangrove forests provide important ecosystem services for coastal environments. Mangroves serve as nurseries for coral reef fish and feeding grounds for fish and other marine life. Mangroves are essential for the sustainability of near-shore fisheries. Mangroves also absorb sea swells and help to prevent erosion. Mature Mangroves Pollution Deforestation Coral Reef Coral reefs are important feeding grounds for a variety of fish, and thus important for local fisher people. Overfishing and sedimentation of reefs have reduced fish catches, pushing fisher people further out to sea to maintain catch levels. Sedimentation Overfishing Rising Sea Temperature Storm Surge 5. Sopu Fishing Association This cooperative is mainly staffed by village youth, and led by an official from the Tonga Fisheries Department. The group mainly collects shell fish from near-shore fisheries. They also use fish nets and traditional fish traps. The Association also owns multiple boats, but has not acquired a working motor. The Association enters the coastal area, and transports boats over a ‘boat slick’ that connects the coast to a coastal road. Flooding—sedimentation Overfishing Rising Sea Temperature Extreme Weather—storm surge 6. Boat Ramp Ramp for transporting boats to the coast. Erosion Sea Level Rise Extreme Weather—storm surge 3. 4. Young Mangroves Extreme Weather—Storm Surge Flooding—sedimentation, pollution - 14 - Social Infrastructure Table 38: Sopu Social Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability Hala o Vave Government Primary School (GPS) School for village youth in grades 1-6. Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Kolomotu’a GPS School for village youth in grades 1-6 is located on the coast, but is protected by the Nuku’alofa Sea Wall. Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding Sea Level Rise 3. Town Hall The Community Hall is the center for regularly held village meetings, development program meetings and all discussion of village policy. It is also used for community events and informal social gatherings. Flooding Extreme Weather Event—roof damage 4. Sports Field Center for village play and sporting events. Flooding (semi-permanent) 5. Cemetery 1 Village cemetery is adjacent to inland swamp. Flooding Storm Surge Erosion Sea Level Rise 6. Wesleyan Church Kindergarten Kindergarten program. Flooding. Extreme weather event—roof damage 7. Salvation Army Kindergarten Kindergarten grounds flood during normal rainy periods. Flooding. Extreme weather event—roof damage Health Clinic Situated on the coast, but protected by the Nuku’alofa Sea Wall, village health clinic, staffed by a nurse, provides health and outreach services to GPS students and the community. Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding Sea Level Rise 1. 2. 8. Water and Coastal Infrastructure Table 39: Sopu Water and Coastal Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Town Hall Rainwater Tanks (Concrete) Water supply for community events and gatherings. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. 2. Catholic Church Hall Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. Hala o Vave GPS Rainwater Tank (2) (Concrete) Water supply for students and teachers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. 3. 4. The Lord’s Church of Tonga Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for students and teachers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) - 15 5. Free Church of Tonga Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for students and teachers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. 6. Salvation Army Church 1 Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. Wesleyan Church 1, 2, 3 Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. Wesleyan Church Kindergarten Rainwater Tank (2) (Concrete) Water supply for students, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. LDS Church Rainwater Tank (Fiberglass) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. 7. 8. 9. Drought—reservoir dries; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system 10. Drainage Drainage channel accommodates sea water flow during tidal changes, and serves as a channel for rainwater runoff. Erosion 11. Sea Wall Sea Wall was designed to stem erosion and to provide a coastal barrier against king tides, storm surges and average sea level rise; it was built to protect the road and to stop coastal erosion. Sea Wall has redirected wave energy/tidal flows to the western end of the village that is not protected by sea wall; this has caused extreme erosion. Erosion Flooding Extreme Weather Event—storm surge Popua According to Town Officer (Mayor) Sione Uta, 90-percent of Popua’s 1,894 residents have relocated there from outer islands and villages to be closer to Nuku’alofa, Tonga’s capital city and economic center. While there is no data to substantiate this, evidence of the community’s unplanned housing and road construction on reclaimed land in the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon abound. - 16 - Image 25: Unplanned Roads trap seawater, creating permanent brackish pools. Image 26: Housing developments on reclaimed land extend into the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon. Additional Popua photos can be seen here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/90755241@N08/sets/72157632540496576/ Popua is located to the east of Nuku’alofa, and is surrounded by water on three sides: the Pacific Ocean to the north and the Fana’utu/Fangakakau Lagoon to the east and south. Areas that extend more than one community block to the east, west and south of Popua’s main road are consistently flooded throughout the year. While not approved by the Tonga Ministry of Infrastructure, the community continues road and housing construction further into swampy coastal areas along the west and south coast of the Lagoon. The CCC noted that their greatest concern regarding flooding and inundation was the impact on household septic systems. They note that septic tanks overflow during flooding events, creating extreme health concerns for the community. Adding to the community’s vulnerability, a high percentage of households do not have plantation plots; moreover, remaining land within Popua is not sufficient for farming. In addition to flooding, the land to the north of the village, a mangrove swamp, was the site of the former Tongatapu Island dump. Until the 2007 opening of the Tapuhia Landfill, this section of Popua served as a poorly-tended dumping ground for Tongatapu’s expanding population. While the area has been cleaned, remnants of the dump remain clearly visible on the main road into Popua. Town Committee Chairperson Sione Uta and the Popua CCC took part in the C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise on Wednesday, January 15, 2013 in the Popua Free Church of Tonga Hall. Risk Identification Before more rigorously assessing impacts against climate projections/GIS-based contour maps, the Popua CCC identified observed climate change risks and impacts in the village. After leading a brief overview on climate change and global impacts of climate change, the CCC analyzed and presented the local impacts of global warming, precipitation pattern changes, and natural disasters experienced in Popua. Global Warming Impacts According to the Popua CCC, the greatest impacts from increasing air and sea temperature are rising sea levels and resulting more extreme tidal movements and storm surges. In addition to the impacts of flooded homes and infrastructure, inundation and flooding also cause household septic systems to overflow, raising health concerns in the village. Many homes on the coast - 17 - experience flooding and inundation monthly during high tides, making septic system overflows a regular community concern. Precipitation Pattern Changes The CCC explains that precipitation falls less frequently, more intensely, and occurs less predictably during periods of the year. The participants again cited flooding and resulting coastal erosion as the most serious risk facing the community. While septic tank flooding is contained in coastal areas during high tides, heavy rain often causes septic tank overflows throughout the village. The primary risks of drought on this community is on their drinking water supply, as many homes do not own a rainwater tank, and must rely on rainwater collected in church rainwater tanks. Natural Disasters The CCC again noted that flooding, coastal inundation and erosion were the primary risks associated with natural disasters such as cyclones and gale force wind events, adding that impacts are exacerbated by a lack of road drainage in the community. The community notes that a 1985 cyclone caused severe erosion, permanently inundating coastal Popua with sea water. Inundation has been exacerbated, according to the CCC, by mangrove deforestation carried out by community members. Economic, Social and Water Infrastructure Mapping Following identification of local climate change impacts, the CCC completed hand-drawn community infrastructure maps, highlighting economic, social and water infrastructure that may be vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and extreme weather events (see Annex 2.3). Image 27: Popua Climate Change Risk Map, with geo-referenced economic, social and water and coastal infrastructure points, photographs and risk profiles. Interactive map can be found here: https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=210276136318794746510.0004d3652d91c1d0640ca&msa=0 - 18 - Economic Infrastructure Table 40: Popua Economic Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Village Roads Village roads are essential for villagers traveling to Nuku’alofa for work and for those who sell fish to market. Village expansion and privately-funded road construction has not adhered to engineering principals, however. Roads also lack adjacent drainage systems. This has led to frequent flooding of land adjacent to roads, and in some cases, has caused permanent inundation. Mangroves Mangrove forests provide important ecosystem services for coastal environments. Mangroves serve as nurseries for coral reef fish and feeding grounds for fish and other marine life. Mangroves are essential for the sustainability of near-shore fisheries. Mangroves also absorb sea swells and help to prevent erosion. Mature Mangroves Pollution Deforestation Coral reefs are important feeding grounds for a variety of fish, and thus important for local fisher people. Overfishing and sedimentation of reefs have reduced fish catches, pushing fisher people further out to sea to maintain catch levels. 2. 3. Coral Reef Flooding Erosion Sea Level Rise Extreme Weather—Storm Surge Young Mangroves Extreme Weather—Storm Surge Flooding—sedimentation, pollution Sedimentation Overfishing Rising Sea Temperature Storm Surge Social Infrastructure Table 41: Popua Social Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability Popua Government Primary School (GPS) School for village youth in grades 1-6. Extreme Weather Event—roof damage Flooding Sports Field Center for village play and sporting events. Flooding Sea Level Rise Storm Surge 3. Cemetery 1 Village cemetery sits to the south of a semipermanently flooded area. Village has deposited topsoil to raise the cemetery elevation. Flooding Storm Surge Erosion Sea Level Rise 4. Cemetery 2 Village cemetery. Flooding Erosion Flooding Sea Level Rise Storm Surge Extreme Weather Event—structural and roof damage 1. 2. 5. Men’s Hall Men’s halls are centers for nightly gatherings and kava drinking-fundraisers for community social issues. Water and Coastal Infrastructure Table 42: Popua Water and Coastal Infrastructure Infrastructure Point 1. Popua GPS Rainwater Tank (2) (Concrete) Significance to Community Water supply for students and teachers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. Vulnerability Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination - 19 from rusty roof (sea spray) Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun; too small to collect all available water during intense rain. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Catholic Church Hall Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. 3. Wesleyan Church Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. 4. LDS Church Rainwater Tank (Fiberglass) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for church members without personal rainwater tank. Drought Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system Drainage Drainage channel installed after road construction caused flooding; insufficient to accommodate sea water flow during tidal changes, serve as a channel for rainwater runoff. Erosion Flooding Extreme Weather Event—storm surge 2. 5. Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) Ahau Ahau is a coastal community with a population of 395 in the Kolovai District. Ahau is precariously placed in a coastal zone that sits between sea walls and dense coastal mangrove forest from Nuku’alofa / Sopu extending to Kolovai in the southeast and the Kanokupolu sea wall to the north. The impact of these sea walls on ocean currents in Ahau, according to the Ahau CCC, has intensified erosion in its coastal zone. In 2005, the Ahau Village Committee built a sea wall from its coastal boundary to the south—at the point of a dense mangrove forest in the neighboring village of Kolovai; extending the length of the village to its northern border of Kanokupolu, which has built a sea wall that extends to the northern tip of Tongatapu. Between construction and the current day, the sea wall has eroded in three points, creating everexpanding channels through which tidal flows enter and exit the formerly protected coastal zone. This has left a village sports field—that once served as an international rugby field that hosted Tonga’s first match against Fiji in the 1930s and served as the site of weekly horse racing competitions between Tongatapu villages—permanently inundated with sea water. Ahau village’s current groundwater supply—used for cooking, cleaning and hygienic needs—is from the Hihifo (western) District, which provides piped water to Fo’ui in the south to Ha’atafu to the north. The water supply is insufficient to meet community demand, however. The Ahau CCC indicates that piped water is only available in the early morning and again in the late evening. While a current Australian Agency for International Development / Global Environment Facility-funded project began rehabilitating the current water supply system— repairing water pumps, installing new water pipes, and outfitting homes with water meters—in August 2012, through private financing, the Ahau Village Committee drilled a borehole in the village plantation zone, to the west of all community housing, intended for an Ahau-dedicated piped water system. The village did not have sufficient funding for piping, water pumps, a reservoir tank, or the construction to implement the water delivery system. At this point, the borehole remains covered while the Ahau CCC contemplates financing solutions. The C-CAP Community Committee (CCC) was initiated by Kamoto, the Town Officer (Mayor) and Mātāpule (Talking Chief) of the King of Tonga (Tupou IV, V and VI). Kamoto and the - 20 - Ahau CCC took part in the C-CAP Participatory Risk Mapping Exercise on Friday, January 18, 2013 in the Ahau Wesleyan Church Hall. Risk Identification Before more rigorously assessing impacts against climate projections/GIS-based contour maps, the Ahau CCC identified observed climate change risks and impacts in the village. After leading a brief overview on climate change and global impacts of climate change, the CCC analyzed and presented the local impacts of global warming, precipitation pattern changes, and natural disasters experienced in Ahau. Global Warming Impacts Given Ahau’s proximity to the coast and their eroded sea wall, sea level rise was the CCC’s greatest climate change concern related to global warming. The CCC noted that sea level rise was inundating the coastal zone and contributing to erosion of their sea wall and coastline. During king tides, the water line has reached the village houses that stand closest to the coast. Image 28: A local resident points out that the high tide mark reaches her home. Additional Ahau photos can be seen here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/90755241@N08/sets/72157632520198858/ Regarding increasing sea surface temperature, near shore marine life that the village depends upon for food security is increasingly at risk, according to the CCC. While the CCC has not noted coral bleaching events, they were concerned that if sea surface temperatures continue to increase, the local reef could experience bleaching, further impacting coastal fisheries. Precipitation Pattern Changes The CCC cited changes in the flowering schedule of local flora and food-bearing trees in Ahau. The group noted that flora comes into bloom early in recent years, as compared to past decades. The CCC also explained that over the past decade, rain typically falls in short intense downpours, rather than in previous decades which were marked with frequent steady rain during the November to April rainy season. These heavy rain events result in village flooding that - 21 - typically flows along the village road system to the coast, flooding adjacent homes. In addition to flood damage, this also exacerbates erosion of the coastline and village roads, and increases sedimentation of coastal waters. Reflective of the current rain patterns experience by the village, the CCC explained that droughts are more frequent in Ahau compared to past decades. Drought impacts the village groundwater supply and risks tropical crops that depend upon heavy rainfall. Natural Disasters Many impacts of natural disasters are extreme versions of the risks associated with sea level rise, including storm surges that inundate coastal infrastructure and homes. The Ahau CCC noted that cyclones and gale force wind events can destroy village pig pens, with storm surges sweeping some animals out to sea. In the aftermath of cyclone and gale force wind events, the Ahau CCC also notes that sedimentation from coastal erosion—caused by inland flooding run-off—and storm surges that disrupt near shore marine habitats impact the village’s food security. It often takes time for near shore fisheries to recover following a storm, during which time village members must rely on frozen and processed foods for protein. Economic, Social and Water Infrastructure Mapping Following identification of local climate change impacts, the CCC completed hand-drawn community infrastructure maps, highlighting economic, social and water infrastructure that may be vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and extreme weather events (see Annex 2.3). Image 29: Ahau Climate Change Risk Map, with geo-referenced economic, social and water and coastal infrastructure points, photographs and risk profiles. Interactive map can be found here: https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=210276136318794746510.0004d38c1a484e3af933c&msa=0 Economic Infrastructure Table 43: Ahau Economic Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. This road leads to villagers’ plantation plots, and is Ahau Plantation Flooding - 22 Road 2. 3. 4. Plantations Mangroves Coral Reef thus essential for food security and the village economy. This is also an important road for village women’s cooperative weaving / tapa-making activities; many private plantation lots include mulberry tree orchards used as inputs into tapa. Private plantations are important for food and financial security. Semi-subsistence farmers also sell crops in local markets. Women’s cooperatives use Mulberry Tree bark as primary input into tapa-making. Erosion Extreme Weather—Storm Surge, Fallen Trees (on road) Flooding Extreme Weather—Storm Surge, Uprooted Trees/Bushes (Mulberry, Banana, Plantain, Breadfruit, Mango) Rising Air Temperature Drought Mangrove forests provide important ecosystem services for coastal environments. Mangroves serve as nurseries for coral reef fish and feeding grounds for fish and other marine life. Mangroves are essential for the sustainability of near-shore fisheries. Mangroves also absorb sea swells and help to prevent erosion. Mature Mangroves Pollution Deforestation Coral reefs are important feeding grounds for a variety of fish, and thus important for local fisher people. Overfishing and sedimentation of reefs have reduced fish catches, pushing fisher people further out to sea to maintain catch levels. Young Mangroves Extreme Weather—Storm Surge Flooding—sedimentation, pollution Sedimentation Overfishing Rising Sea Temperature Storm Surge Social Infrastructure Table 44: Ahau Social Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Sports Field Forming sports field used for international rugby competition between Pacific Island countries (19241961), as well as local sports and inter-village horseracing. Has since experienced erosion and is submerged in coastal water. Flooding Sea Level Rise Storm Surge 2. Cemetery 1 Village cemetery. Flooding Erosion Town Hall The Community Hall is the center for regularly held village meetings, development program meetings and all discussion of village policy. It is also used for community events and informal social gatherings. Flooding Extreme Weather Event—roof damage 3. Water and Coastal Infrastructure Table 45: Ahau Water and Coastal Infrastructure Infrastructure Point Significance to Community Vulnerability 1. Wesleyan Church Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for church services, employees and volunteers. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. 2. Town Hall Rainwater Tank (Concrete) Water supply for community meetings and events. Supply for community members without personal rainwater tank. Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) 3. Ahau Sea Wall The Ahau Sea Wall was privately financed by the village and completed in 2005. It has since eroded at three points, creating gaps through which the sea enters Erosion Flooding Drought—reservoir dries; if empty, concrete can be damaged from excessive heat/sun. Extreme Weather Event—contamination; damage to piping, gutter system; contamination from rusty roof (sea spray) - 23 the coastal zone. These gaps have eroded from regular tidal flows and storm surges. This is exacerbated due to Ahau’s location between the Nukua’lofa/Kolomotua sea wall and a sea wall to the north of the village; this results in faster-moving, more extreme tides and regular wave energy. 4. Borehole Ahau village privately financed the drilling of a borehole. The village currently relies on an Eastern District-run water pump that only provides running water in the morning and evening hours. The village does not have financing for a reservoir tank, pipes, or a pump. Extreme Weather Event—storm surge Drought