SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations Deliverable 1.2 SEAP-PLUS recommendations and tools Adding to SEAP – more participants, more content across Europe IEE/11/978/S12.615950 Author: Diputacio de Barcelona Date: October 2012 1 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations Table of Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 4 2 Innovative BEI and SEAP methodologies: Good practices, experiences, methodologies and tools ............................................................................................. 6 2.1 Horizontal methodologies ................................................................................................... 6 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.1.4 2.1.5 2.1.6 2.1.7 2.1.8 2.1.9 2.1.10 2.1.11 2.1.12 2.1.13 2.1.14 2.1.15 2.1.16 2.1.17 2.1.18 2.1.19 2.1.20 2.1.21 2.1.22 2.1.23 2.1.24 2.1.25 2.1.26 2.1.27 2.1.28 2.1.29 2.1.30 2.1.31 2.1.32 2.1.33 2.2 Climate and Energy Model Regions in Austria ........................................................................ 6 Supporting activities ................................................................................................................... 6 e5-Programme in Austria (national programme of the European Energy Award) ............ 7 Best Practice Database at Climate Alliance Austria Website ................................................. 7 CO2-Assessment-Tool for municipalities .................................................................................. 8 KomKlimA-project (2012 - 2014) .............................................................................................. 8 Capacity building and institutionalisation of sustainable energy policies in the municipalities’ operations ........................................................................................................... 9 Results, outcomes and developments of other IEE-projects related to the Covenant of Mayors (Climate Alliance Austria) ............................................................................................. 9 Accessing Local Energy data ................................................................................................... 10 Barcelona’s methodology for drafting SEAP .......................................................................... 10 Barcelona’s guidelines to establish SEAP actions in medium and small villages: ............ 10 Barcelona’s monitoring tools ................................................................................................... 11 Barcelona’s dissemination of the Covenant tools ................................................................. 11 Barcelona’s communication resources for municipalities along the European Sustainable Energy Week .............................................................................................................................. 11 Tools for management of SEAP by a Covenant Coordinator .............................................. 12 ClimactRegions manuals .......................................................................................................... 12 ClimactRegions best practice database.................................................................................. 12 “What If” risk analysis tool – energy, climate and adaptation to climate change in local scale ............................................................................................................................................ 13 SEAP-Catalogue of measures for small and medium-sized municipalities ........................ 13 Energiluppen (“Energy Loupe”) .............................................................................................. 13 ENERGee Watch Network ........................................................................................................ 14 Swedish Climate Municipalities` (“Klimatkommunerna”) tools for developing SEAP and BEI 14 “Hållbarometer” / Sustainable barometer Luleå ................................................................... 14 Environmental solutions home page ...................................................................................... 15 Web tool – daily environmental friendly solutions ............................................................... 15 Calculator for ecological footprint ........................................................................................... 15 Baseline Emission Inventory tools and methodologies for Cyprus .................................... 16 Future emissions modelling for Cyprus .................................................................................. 16 Sustainable Energy Action Plan for Cyprus ........................................................................... 17 Monitoring of Sustainable Energy Action Plan for Cyprus ................................................... 17 Toolbox of Methodologies on Climate and Energy ............................................................... 18 Protocols on local government and community scale GHG emissions .............................. 19 Local Energy Action Plan (LEAP) Wizard................................................................................ 20 Municipal energy consumption ........................................................................................ 20 2.2.1 2.2.2 Barcelona’s energy assessment visits guidelines and report template.............................. 20 Training for municipal officers and staff ................................................................................ 20 2 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5 2.3 Residential and tertiary sectors ....................................................................................... 22 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.4 Sustainable Procurement Resource Centre ........................................................................... 23 SMART SPP LCC-CO2 ................................................................................................................ 24 New SEAP sectors’ additions and enhancements.................................................. 25 3.1 Agriculture, forestry and fishery ...................................................................................... 25 3.1.1 3.1.2 3.2 3.3 eReNet Initiative - Rural Web Energy Learning Network for Action .................................. 25 Agencies and services for rural development ....................................................................... 26 Waste ................................................................................................................................... 26 3.2.1 Waste treatment management ............................................................................................... 26 Water ................................................................................................................................... 27 3.3.1 4 NV-Eko Programm – Norrbottens and Västerbottens energy and climate program ....... 23 Procurement ....................................................................................................................... 23 2.6.1 2.6.2 3 Private households: Environmental cycling awareness raising campaign......................... 23 RES and energy production .............................................................................................. 23 2.5.1 2.6 Latvenergo – Energy efficiency center ................................................................................... 22 Training scheme for SMEs ....................................................................................................... 22 Private households .................................................................................................................... 22 Transportation .................................................................................................................... 23 2.4.1 2.5 Training programs for local decision makers, especially mayors and municipal administration ............................................................................................................................ 21 Local politicians and civil servants within the municipal administration ........................... 21 Monitoring scheme for municipal energy consumption (incl. transport) .......................... 21 Water treatment energy uses ................................................................................................. 27 SEAP and regional Policies; Cooperation with stakeholders ................................ 28 4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4 4.1.5 4.1.6 4.1.7 4.1.8 4.1.9 4.1.10 4.1.11 4.1.12 4.1.13 4.1.14 4.1.15 4.1.16 Covenant capaCITY project – Capacity building of local governments to advance Local Climate and Energy Action – from planning to action to monitoring ................................ 28 The Genoa Smart City Association.......................................................................................... 28 Xarxa de Ciutats i Pobles cap a la Sostenibilitat ................................................................... 29 Norrbottens´s sustainable energy plan and climate strategy............................................. 29 Jokkmokk Winter Conference: an international youth conference on local and regional energy and climate strategies ................................................................................................. 29 Northern Network on Climate Change ................................................................................... 30 Jokkmokk sustainable energy plan and climate strategy SEAP .......................................... 30 Covenant of Mayors Signatories in the Baltic Sea Region ................................................... 30 Local development program .................................................................................................... 31 Energy agencies ........................................................................................................................ 31 National Development Plan 2014 - 2020 ............................................................................... 31 The Climate Change Financial Instrument (CCFI) ................................................................ 31 Students, schools and education sector “Futurize” .............................................................. 32 Cooperation with indigenous people ...................................................................................... 32 Multipliers, stakeholders, media and decision makers ......................................................... 33 Environmental NGO .................................................................................................................. 33 3 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 1 Introduction Transfer of knowledge from experienced to learning local governments and the enhancement of the submitted Baseline Emission Inventories (BEI) and Sustainable Energy Action Plans (SEAP) are among the main objectives of the SEAP-PLUS project. The first objective is accomplished through a close cooperation and collaboration between experienced and learning organizations that participate in SEAP-PLUS. Thus, experienced partners and learning ones share their know-how and their concerns and help each other to improve the services they provide to local governments. From this exchange several suggestions to improve SEAPs and several good practices can be shown in order to disseminate them among other Covenant signatories that might have the same concerns. In order to help more local and regional organizations across Europe have access in methodologies, tools and best practices that can improve the quality and content of their BEI and SEAP, SEAP-PLUS has prepared a document that gathers in a concise way options that will help to improve: - SEAP methodology regarding its scope, integration in regional policies and monitoring process - BEI/SEAP calculations with the aid of specific tools that have been developed - SEAP content by the inclusion of more emissions sectors - the cities’ stakeholders participation in the Covenant of Mayors process All identified input for this document has been organized in order to help local and regional stakeholders with regard to their state of involvement in the Covenant of Mayors: 1. Innovative BEI and SEAP methodologies: good practices, experiences, methodologies and tools – content related to sectors that all BEI/ SEAP submitted until today have included: municipal, residential, tertiary, transportation and RES i. Horizontal methodologies ii. Municipal energy consumption iii. Residential and tertiary sectors iv. Transportation v. RES and energy production vi. Procurement 2. New SEAP sectors’ additions and enhancements – content related to sectors that BEI/SEAP could have included if cities had proper guidance and technical help. i. Agriculture, forestry and fishery ii. Waste treatment 4 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations iii. Water treatment 3. SEAP and regional Policies; cooperation with stake holders – content related to the integration of local SEAP measures to wider regional policies; ways to involve the local and regional stakeholders in the CoM process At the end of each measure/action/tool one can find a link to more detailed and specific information or the organizations that created/implemented it. 5 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2 2.1 Innovative BEI and SEAP methodologies: Good practices, experiences, methodologies and tools Horizontal methodologies 2.1.1 Climate and Energy Model Regions in Austria Developer: Austrian Climate and Energy Fund; Climate Alliance Austria It is an Austrian blueprint for a successful bottom-up approach in the field of climate change and energy especially developed for rural regions. Introduced in 2010, the programme has now developed a great dynamic, and has created 84 Climate and Energy Model Regions with 878 participating communities. In total this regions inhabit over 2 million citizens. The programme “Climate and Energy Model Regions” is divided into three phases: Phase 1: Development of an implementation concept with predefined requirements with involvement of essential stakeholders. Phase 2: A model region manager receives funding and support for the acquisition of know-how for a period of 2 years. The manager is in charge of the implementation of projects and of awareness-raising in the region. The maximum amount of funding for phases 1 and 2 is €100,000/year. Cofinancing by the region is a requirement and also a success factor. The prolongation of the programme is possible, but requires successful evaluation. Phase 3: The Climate and Energy Fund supports the Climate and Energy Model Regions through exclusive investment assistance for projects in the field of renewable energy and energy efficiency. For more information see: www.klimaundenergiemodellregionen.at 2.1.2 Supporting activities Developer: Climate Alliance Austria The programme is funded by the Austrian Climate and Energy Fund whose intention is to develop new and innovative ways of sustainable development against climate change: 1. Networking and training: At least two times per year the Austrian model region managers meet for a two-day training and networking event. The managers are educated in relevant topics, but also focus on disseminating their know-how 2. Energy monitoring: Every region is obliged to undertake monitoring activities of certain key data (consumption and production). This obligation implies great 6 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations awareness of the problem and is necessary to directly illustrate the project’s success For further information see the fact sheet: http://www.klimafonds.gv.at/assets/Uploads/Downloads-Frderungen/KuEModellregionen/Fact-Sheet-Climate-and-Energy-Model-Regions.pdf 2.1.3 e5-Programme in Austria (national programme of the European Energy Award) Developer: Austrian Energy Agency; input by Climate Alliance Austria The European Energy Award consists of two main elements: A quality management system for communal energy-related services and activities Certification and award for energy-related achievements and control of success through regular audits It has the following benefits for participating communities: allows municipalities to identify strengths, weaknesses and potential for improvement helps implementing effectively energy efficiency, and renewable energy measures the success of a municipality's efforts is made visible by an award the standardized assessment allows for a benchmarking between communities allows member cities to share their experiences and expertise 120 Austrian municipalities have been participating in the programme so far. Only a few of them have reached the highest step of an e5-municipality For further details see: http://www.e5-gemeinden.at/ 2.1.4 Best Practice Database at Climate Alliance Austria Website Developer: Climate Alliance Austria A database that contains more than 100 best practices successfully implemented by Austrian municipalities and cities in the fields of energy efficiency, renewable energy, mobility, agriculture and forestry, public relations and awareness building, development aid and cooperation For further details see: www.klimabuendnis.at/bestpractice 7 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.5 CO2-Assessment-Tool for municipalities Developer: Climate Alliance Austria The CO2-Assessment-Tool is a web-based tool for Austrian Climate Alliance municipalities for calculation of their Baseline Emission Inventories. The tool also shows in which fields the biggest possibilities for energy saving are possible. The start of the tool was in 2005. The development was financially supported by the Ministry of Life For further details see: http://co2rechner.klimabuendnis.at/ 2.1.6 KomKlimA-project (2012 - 2014) Developer: KomKlimA-project The CO2-Assessment-Tool was enlarged and updated in the nationally funded KomKlimA-project (Municipal Climate Protection Action Plan for Austria). The starting point was a status quo analysis and a detailed study of state of the art energy and mobility technologies in regard to their positive climate effects and their applicability / adaptability for implementation in municipalities. The status quo was established in regard to: 1. the current use of climate technology 2. the energy demand, emission balances as base for future reduction possibilities 3. budgetary, personnel and institutional framework requirements, socioeconomic and gender aspects The concrete KomKlimA project outcomes will be: - a comprehensive status quo analysis of the energy municipal framework conditions - a set of best practice examples - a technology database and - a concrete action plan for climate technologies, including application-oriented tools for municipalities For further details see: http://www.komklima.at/englishsummary.html 8 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.7 Capacity building and institutionalisation of sustainable energy policies in the municipalities’ operations Developer: Green-Twinning project Green Twinning – Capacity building and lessons to be learned for the institutionalisation of sustainable energy policies in the municipalities’ operations is an Intelligent Energy Europe project which aims at: - strengthening the technical and financial capacity of EU-12 municipalities in sustainable energy policy - and implementation supporting EU-12 municipalities towards joining the Covenant of Mayors initiative and fulfilling the obligations resulting from this commitment and promoting permanent long-term partnerships and networking between experienced and learning municipalities in order to achieve commonly agreed results in joint project implementation process. For further details see: http://green-twinning.eu/ 2.1.8 Results, outcomes and developments of other IEE-projects related to the Covenant of Mayors (Climate Alliance Austria) Come2CoM For further details see: http://regions202020.eu/cms/sec/come2com/ NETCOM For further details see: http://networkingcovenantofmayors.eu/ Towards 100% RES rural communities For further details see: http://eaci-projects.eu/iee/page/Page.jsp?op=project_detail&prid=2550 9 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.9 Accessing Local Energy data Developer: Meshartility project The MESHARTILITY (Measure and share data with utilities for the Covenant of Mayors) project aims at the development of solutions and tools facilitating exchange of energy data between energy utilities and local authorities that are busy assessing local greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and planning action to address this through energy savings, energy efficiency and the use of renewable energy. These solutions and tools will help cities, who are signatories of the Covenant of Mayors, to develop their Sustainable Energy Action Plans (SEAPs). For further details see: http://www.meshartility.eu/mt/ 2.1.10 Barcelona’s methodology for drafting SEAP Developer: Diputació de Barcelona A specific methodology has been developed to draft SEAPs in Barcelona, so all SEAPs coordinated by DIBA can be easily compared. This includes: - Methodology guide - Action’s template (excel sheet) linked to a word template - Guide to calculate emissions inventories (in Catalan language) The methodology is available in Catalan and English. For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/documents/471041/615438fd-8cba-498cb5ea-5d70036a4ef5 2.1.11 Barcelona’s guidelines to establish SEAP actions in medium and small villages: Developer: Diputació de Barcelona Includes an actions Check list, specific action’s template (including how to calculate emissions and energy savings, energy production and estimated costs, actions classified depending on its relative cost (low cost, medium cost or high cost actions). The guidelines are available in Catalan. 10 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/c/document_library/get_file?uuid=1428e547-8edc-4ec0-8d4c9880493104bd&groupId=471041 2.1.12 Barcelona’s monitoring tools Developer: Diputació de Barcelona Diputacio de Barcelona has developed an excel sheet for SEAP monitoring and drafting of the monitoring report. Three workshops have been made on these monitoring tools that have served both for its dissemination and for its improvement. For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 2.1.13 Barcelona’s dissemination of the Covenant tools Developer: Diputació de Barcelona These tools contain a broad collection of brochures and material that can be customized and used by the municipalities. Available in Catalan. For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/mediambient /pactealcaldes/recursos 2.1.14 Barcelona’s communication resources for municipalities along the European Sustainable Energy Week Developer: Diputació de Barcelona Resources that are provided free to the municipalities, helping them to disseminate the Covenant of Mayors and to spread out the world the energy sustainability. For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 11 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.15 Tools for management of SEAP by a Covenant Coordinator Developer: Diputació de Barcelona Diputacio de Barcelona has developed various tools to help Covenant Coordinators to manage the SEAP developed by the local governments that it supports: - Database collecting emission’s baseline inventories data of all municipalities (excel sheet) - Database collecting actions proposal of all SEAPs - Database collecting data on energy assessment visits done in municipal buildings and facilities (consumption and measures proposed to improve them) - Database to collect all monitoring and draft Summary monitoring reports (in several languages) For further details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 2.1.16 ClimactRegions manuals Developer: ClimactRegions Interreg IVc project During the ClimactRegions project a number of manuals were compiled to help regional stakeholders to adopt and implement climate friendly strategies and actions: - Dedicated modes of governance (regional and local) - Regional and local inventory of GHG emissions - Regional and local climate- und sustainable energy strategies Available in English and French, some even in Swedish, German, Romanian, Italian, Spanish and Czech. Link for downloading: www.climactregions.eu/web/guest/reference-manuals 2.1.17 ClimactRegions best practice database Developer: ClimactRegions Interreg IVc project A large database of best practices for climate change mitigation and adaptation measures and actions was compiled during the Climactregions project. Climactregions partners identified more than 140 good practices in 60 regions spanning 23 countries. All best practice examples are available in English and French Link for downloading: www.climactregions.eu/web/guest/best-practices 12 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.18 “What If” risk analysis tool – energy, climate and adaptation to climate change in local scale Developer: Jokkmokk/Whatif AS Whatif is a board game and a web application for risk analysis and table top exercises. The English version of the risk analysis tool is available for a number of target groups e.g. municipalities, SME, students/schools. More versions are available in Swedish and Norwegian. For basic information in English see: www.whatif.as/index.php?p=2_1 For the way the tools is used within the program “Northern Network on Climate Change” NNCC see: www.nncc.eu/index.php/trainings-capacity-building/tools/whatif 2.1.19 SEAP-Catalogue of measures for small and medium-sized municipalities Developer: Jokkmokk It is a tool to become more future-oriented, competitive and environmentally friendly. It can be used as a checklist to become clear about your status-quo and as a database for new ideas. The catalogue is available in English and Swedish. For further details http://www.nncc.eu/index.php/trainings-capacity-building/tools/catalogue-ofmeasures see: 2.1.20 Energiluppen (“Energy Loupe”) Developer Nenet Regional energy agency It’s a new webtool called “Energiluppen” that shows energy use in municipalities in Norrbotten and Västerbotten. The tool can be used to see the energy use historically in all municipalities and it is also possible to construct scenarios for future GHG-emissions, depending on how the energy use is altered. Comparisons between different municipalities or counties can be made and you can see how much of the total energy use comes from renewable energy sources. Available only in Swedish. For further details see: http://stats.nenet.se/ 13 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.21 ENERGee Watch Network Developer ClimactRegions project and FEDARENE ENERGee-Watch was created with the aim to enable regions to efficiently monitor and observe greenhouse gases and to develop regional policies for greenhouse gas mitigation using good governance processes. For further details see: www.energee-watch.eu 2.1.22 Swedish Climate Municipalities` developing SEAP and BEI (“Klimatkommunerna”) tools for Developer: Swedish Climate Municipalities The Swedish Network “Climate Municipalities” has developed a set of tools that should help local authorities to develop SEAP and work out the BEI. The tool consists of 3 parts: 1) How to structure the working process (stakeholder involvement, citizen participation, organizational structure etc.). Link: www.klimatkommunerna.se/?page=page48f5eaee86921 2) How to in practice develop the leading document (SEAP, energy plan and climate strategy) including examples and templates. Link: www.klimatkommunerna.se/?page=page48fda7942da5a 3) Guidelines and examples about how to work with the BEI – national and regional data sources, factors, examples, calculation sheets etc. Link: www.klimatkommunerna.se/?page=page4912ada79a1c2 All tools are only available in Swedish. The Swedish Climate Municipalities are at the moment the only official CoM Supporting Structure in Sweden. 2.1.23 “Hållbarometer” / Sustainable barometer Luleå Developer City of Luleå It’s a very comprehensive observatory easy to access and to understand by the website visitors. Defined indicators are the main tool within the observatory, which are compared with national environmental targets. Partly, more differentiated and more intodepths indicators have been created. The idea has been to follow-up developments more concrete that can be influenced at the local level and that lead to reach (or not reach) the environmental targets. 14 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations For further details see: http://miljobarometer.lulea.se 2.1.24 Environmental solutions home page Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund This website consists of four sections: Water; Air; Earth; Human. Each section provides an overview of the regulatory base, the basic principles of the operation of the systems, a summary of information on the latest technologies, offers solutions to existing problems in the system, as well as features a calculator to define costs solutions and a list of implemented projects. The website is developed in the following languages: Latvian; English and Russian. For further details see: www.videsrisinajumi.lv 2.1.25 Web tool – daily environmental friendly solutions Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund 1) Web tool collecting solutions, how the daily habit change can positively impact environment. Citizens publish those solutions. To motivate persons to change daily habits, famous public recognizable people persons share their ideas from their daily life. The tool is connected with twitter and Facebook accounts. The solutions can be used as a campaigning method. Available in Latvian language. For further details see: www.nacunsac.lv 2) Practical solutions, how to change daily habits in household, transport; consumption; food sector. Available in Latvian language. For further details see: www.homoecos.lv/lv/zalie-paradumi 3) Green guide – Food; transport; electricity goods; energy efficiency; house and garden; closes and Laundry; cosmetic; sexual life and fertility. Available in Latvian language. For further details see: www.zb-zeme.lv/images/viss%20kopaa.pdf 2.1.26 Calculator for ecological footprint Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund & WWF A calculator for the users’ ecological footprint was developed by Latvian Environmental Investment Fund & WWF. Available in Latvian language. For further details see: www.pdf.lv/epeda/epeda.html 15 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.27 Baseline Emission Inventory tools and methodologies for Cyprus Developer: Cyprus Energy Agency Cyprus Energy Agency has developed a number of tools and methodologies for local governments that are preparing their Baseline Emissions Inventory: - Signature of a long term Memorandum of Cooperation with Energy Data Owners (Electricity and gas suppliers, Ministry of Energy/Environment, Oil companies, Statistical services etc.) - Introduction of new more detailed energy sectors. According to the international coding (NACE code 2.2) used for electricity consumers categorization, very accurate and detailed data can given from electricity suppliers. Find below the main subcategories of the NACE coding. More detail categories in the excel file attached. The electricity supplier can provide the electricity consumptions and the number of customers for a selected region. - The use of other energy sources in each category is difficult to be approached but it could be estimated using statistical data, surveys, experiences etc. - Methodology of recording energy data for municipalities (energy consumption of the Municipal Service) For more detail see: http://www.cea.org.cy/Home.html 2.1.28 Future emissions modelling for Cyprus Developer: Cyprus Energy Agency Cyprus Energy Agency has established a methodology/tool for the estimation of future emissions in the municipalities of Cyprus. Previous years energy (and other) data must be collected in order to use annual rates of change in each sector. Different scenarios can be approached (Business as usual, Increase energy efficiency (optimistic) scenario, pessimistic scenario, etc) For more detail see: http://www.cea.org.cy/Home.html 16 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.29 Sustainable Energy Action Plan for Cyprus Developer: Cyprus Energy Agency Cyprus Energy Agency has developed a number of tools and methodologies for local governments that are preparing their Sustainable Energy Action Plan: - Creation of common approaches/methodologies on how we can calculate the CO2 saving for each measure included in SEAP (especially for educational/awareness activities, Landscape planning measures, Improvements in the public transports etc) - New approaches for water and waste management. What is the energy and CO2 benefit? Do we have to take into account other GHG emissions reduction (methane etc)? Do we need to take into consideration the desalination plans? - Measures for the Agriculture or green area development - Implementation of common projects between two (2) or more Covenant of Mayors signatories in the same region, e.g. a street lighting energy efficiency improvement project For more detail see: http://www.cea.org.cy/Home.html 2.1.30 Monitoring of Sustainable Energy Action Plan for Cyprus Developer: Cyprus Energy Agency Cyprus Energy Agency has developed a number of tools and methodologies for local governments that are monitoring their Sustainable Energy Action Plan: - Energy data needed on annual base - Signature of Memorandum of Cooperation with energy data owners - Energy data needed on annual base needed from municipalities as well - Monitoring tool/methodology for recording the energy data, evaluate the progress and show the results (example below) - Introduction of indicators (example below) For more detail see: http://www.cea.org.cy/Home.html 17 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.31 Toolbox of Methodologies on Climate and Energy Developer: ICLEI Europe Local governments across Europe are engaging in sustainable energy planning and action. They are often searching for guidance and advice to develop or further improve their Sustainable Energy Action Plans (SEAPs). Many methodologies and tools are offered by sub-national governments, energy agencies and city networks – many of whom are also active as Supporting Structures of the Covenant of Mayors (CoM) either as Covenant Coordinators of Covenant Supporters. With a simple external structure and search function (by language or alphabetical) it uses icons to present “elements” typically part of a SEAP development process. The Toolbox collection contains many different types of examples, in different languages, of useful methodologies and tools, including: - Documents - Tools - Links - Other guidance material (videos, newsletters, etc) "Climate and energy-relevant" methodologies typically address one or a combination of the following: Topic: Target group / activity: Local leaders, People: Municipal staff, Local stakeholders: citizens, NGOs, business and industry Methodology example: Tools, descriptions Raising awareness among local decision-makers Municipal staff training activity Local Agenda 21 Programme Green business climate campaign Industry energy savings promotion Vision and Strategy (Direction) Policy: Legislation Assessment, Processes: Policy Regulation SWOT analysis on energy (threats, opportunities, ..) Commitment, Baseline Emission Inventory (BEI) Planning, Targets: CO2 reduction, RE targets, energy savings goals, community targets and government 18 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations Implementation, operations targets. Monitoring, Sustainable Energy Action Plan (SEAP) guidance Evaluation SEAP implementation and monitoring Local Energy Action Plan (LEAP) Wizard Green public procurement Integrated management Energy savings Technologies, Energy efficiency Actions Renewable energy Measures: Financing: Options Sectoral activities e.g. transport, waste, … Financing Concepts Public-Private Partnerships Energy Service Companies (ESCOs) etc.. For more detail see: http://toolbox.climate-protection.eu/home/ 2.1.32 Protocols on local government and community scale GHG emissions Developer: ICLEI Europe (and others) Global Protocol for Community Scale GHG Emissions was launched by ICLEI, C40 and WRI on 14 May 2012. It represents a significant step forward in harmonizing emissions measurement and reporting processes for cities of all sizes and geographies for community-scale greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions measurement. GPC is primarily guided by “International Local Government GHG Emissions Analysis Protocol” (IEAP) which was released in 2009 by ICLEI WS. The IEAP sets a global standard for the inventory of greenhouse gas emissions at both government and community level. For more detail see: http://www.iclei.org/fileadmin/user_upload/documents/Global/Progams/GHG/GPC_Pi lotVersion_1.0_May2012_20120514_01.pdf http://www.iclei.org/fileadmin/user_upload/documents/Global/Progams/CCP/Standar ds/IEAP_October2010_color.pdf 19 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.1.33 Local Energy Action Plan (LEAP) Wizard Developer: ICLEI Europe Local Energy Action Plan (LEAP) Wizard was created as an online decision-making support tool to assist municipal action planning Good practice cases in the WIZARD are added by municipal experts. Cases are based on facts and figures, with narrative text supporting these. It makes comparison and finding replicable cases easy. For more detail see: http://wizard.sustainable-now.eu 2.2 Municipal energy consumption 2.2.1 Barcelona’s energy assessment visits guidelines and report template Developer: Diputació de Barcelona In order to have a realistic approach and to develop real specific and concrete actions SEAPs in Barcelona Province include at least 10 energy assessment visits to municipal buildings or facilities. Those assessments have to be done according to those guidelines. Energy assessment visits to municipal buildings and facilities: Specific visits to at least 10 buildings and facilities in order to establish very concrete and specific actions that the Town Council can develop easily. Those visits guarantee “reality” in SEAPs, specificity of each municipality, and real knowledge of the Council situation towards energy management. The templates are available in Catalan and English. For more detail see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 2.2.2 Training for municipal officers and staff Developer: Diputació de Barcelona In order to cope with an identified need, Diputacio de Barcelona has organized specific courses on energy management, energy services, public lighting, etc. The courses are regularly carried out and are free for all municipal workers. For more details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/form#cursos 20 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.2.3 Training programs for local decision makers, especially mayors and municipal administration Developer: Climate Alliance Austria 3 different training programs developed in Austria (3 times 2 days or 2 times 2 days each programme). The Programs are chaired by a university professor. After successful participation the participants get a certificate: 1) Communal climate protection training course 2) Communal soil protection training course 3) Communal mobility training course Very successful programmes for climate protection awareness building, know-how transfer and capacity building for municipal decision makers, especially designed for small and medium cities administration staff. In the season 2012/2013 a new programme for urban climate protection has been started in October 2012. Training programs have been spread to 3 neighbouring countries 2012 – 2014 (Hungary, Slovakia, Slovenia) in a EUfunded CLIPMA-project. For more details see: http://www.clipma.eu/ 2.2.4 Local politicians and civil servants within the municipal administration Developer: Jokkmokk Training program for this target group was developed within NNCC Northern Network on Climate Change project. This target group is maybe most decisive for successful implementing of SEAPs. Their every day behaviour is in addition extremely important regarding giving good examples to citizens and private companies (multiplier effects)! For more details see: www.nncc.eu/index.php/trainings-capacity-building 2.2.5 Monitoring scheme for municipal energy consumption (incl. transport) Developer: Jokkmokk A simple excel-file for monitoring of municipal energy consumption incl. indicators, used as basis for reporting municipal energy demand within the Swedish Energy Agency’s energy efficiency programme for municipalities was prepared. For more details see: 21 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations http://www.energimyndigheten.se/en/Sustainability/The-Sustainable-Municipality/ 2.3 Residential and tertiary sectors 2.3.1 Latvenergo – Energy efficiency center Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund Electricity energy has been provided by one market operator – Latvenergo. Various market operators will come into market after year 2013. The objective of the Energy Efficiency Center opened by Latvenergo is to advise consumers on safer and more efficient usage of various electrical appliances. The Center houses a large display of household electrical appliances. All the appliances are connected to the power network, water supply, and sewerage system and are operated on site. The Center welcomes both individual and group visitors to find solutions for energy efficiency improvement possibilities. Available in Latvian language. For more details see: www.eec.latvenergo.lv/portal/page/portal/Latvian/EEC_Latvenergo/EEC_latvenergo 2.3.2 Training scheme for SMEs Developer: Jokkmokk A training scheme including presentations, good practice examples and working group discussions for SME. For more details see: www.climactregions.eu/web/guest/best-practices 2.3.3 Private households Developer: ClimactRegions Involving citizens and private households is as important as involving (energy) stakeholders, both in the developing and in the implementation phase. ClimactRegions has collected some excellent examples on citizen involvement. For more details see: www.climactregions.eu/web/guest/best-practices 22 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 2.4 Transportation 2.4.1 Private households: Environmental cycling awareness raising campaign Submitter: Jokkmokk An awareness raising activity formed as a cycling event with several stops with information, guessing games and discussions on the environment, incl. Possibility for citizens to make concrete proposals what the municipality could or should do in terms of energy and environment. For more details see: www.climactregions.eu/web/guest/best-practices 2.5 RES and energy production 2.5.1 NV-Eko Programm – Norrbottens and Västerbottens energy and climate program Developer: Nenet It’s a Renewable Energy potential analysis tool used by 29 municipalities in Northern Sweden. Currently is available only in Swedish. For more details see: http://www.nenet.se/ 2.6 Procurement 2.6.1 Sustainable Procurement Resource Centre Developer: ICLEI Europe Bringing all the necessary information together in one place, the Sustainable Procurement Resource Centre is a one-stop access point for procurers, policy makers, researchers and other stakeholders. The Sustainable Procurement Resource Centre contains key knowledge on how to effectively undertake sustainable procurement, saving public authorities money and driving the market towards sustainable solutions. Get the 23 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations latest news and events on sustainable procurement, take advantage of networking opportunities and tap into an extensive searchable database of: Procurement criteria Policies and strategies Tools and guidance Good practice cases Projects and initiatives Studies and reports Ecolabels and other labels Useful links Information on the Resource Centre flows in both directions. As well as benefiting from the wide variety of information already online, you can send us your own information, project results and experiences, and generate attention for your work and raise the profile of your authority. For more details see: http://www.sustainable-procurement.org/ 2.6.2 SMART SPP LCC-CO2 Developer: ICLEI Europe Life Cycle Costing and Emissions Tool has been developed to help you calculate the life cycle costs (LCC) and important emissions (CO2, CO2eq, NOx, SO2, NMHC and PM) of different products, work and services to assist in procurement decision-making. Buying green can save money, particularly when an LCC approach is taken during the procurement process – to account for all of the costs that will be incurred during the lifetime of the product, work or service and its related emissions, not just the purchase price. LCC can save costs by allowing procurers to choose the option which represents best value over its entire life-cycle. For more details see: http://www.smart-spp.eu/ 24 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 3 New SEAP sectors’ additions and enhancements The SEAP –PLUS Consortium agrees that it is essential not only to discuss about new sectors but also to improve the existing ones taking into consideration the lessons learnt by the SEAP PROJECT so far and the “rejected “SEAPs. In addition, the participation and involvement of new target groups could make the difference in the success of the CoM initiative. Most promising sectors to be analyzed so that they can be included in new SEAP: - Agriculture / Forestry / Fishing - Waste management - Water management These categories could be included as a preferred size of cities that need help and support when preparing BEI and SEAP along with the respective methodologies and tools either improving existing ones or developing new ones. In this prospective EU funding opportunities should be developed. 3.1 Agriculture, forestry and fishery Existing SEAP methodologies and texts have overlooked the special characteristics of rural communities, such as Inhabited by a large amount of Europe’s population, while covering 90% of Europe’s land surface, possess a vast potential for the realization of Renewable Energy & Rational Use of Energy (RES/RUE) activities, face particular challenges as regards growth, jobs and sustainability, situation that is being aggravated by the financial and economic crisis), today’s status (e.g. lack of human resources, of technical know-how, of validated energy consumption data) and needs (e.g. development of a customized methodology for rural communities, facilitation of the existing municipality personnel in the development of local SEAPs). Emissions from agriculture and forestry play an important role for the results of the BEI in rural municipalities (sometimes even for bigger cities). Existing SEAP sectors, such as urban transportation and industry, have secondary role in rural communities while agricultural sector (agriculture, forestry, fishery), distinguishes in these communities for its high energy consumptions (up to 25% of total energy consumption in the region) and don’t offer an integrated framework for these Rural communities’ SEAP. 3.1.1 eReNet Initiative - Rural Web Energy Learning Network for Action Developer: eReNet project This Web Tool for Rural Communities’ SEAPs co-funded by an IEE project to improve existing SEAP Methodologies and tools trying to fill in the needs of rural communities. It includes RES/RUE Suggested Actions (Best practices database, including actions in the 25 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations agricultural sector)- Local Production & Final Energy Consumption (Emphasis on Agricultural sector)-Alternative methods for the calculation of final energy consumption also in the agricultural sector and Farming fishery ) and its database information provided ( e.g. Mapping the rural community's characteristics and needs, Climatic characteristics, Priority Projects for the community, Developing Energy and GHG emissions baselines, Provision of instructions regarding each action’s steps). The web aims to be friendly and easy /simple (e.g. guides the user through all SEAP development steps, one by one) and by the end of 2012 will be available in 6 languages in total (En, Gr, Hr, De, Pt, Bg). For more details see: http://erenet-tools.epu.ntua.gr 3.1.2 Agencies and services for rural development Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund a)Regional Development agencies The Agency purpose is to ensure implementation and supervision over plans for development of the region. Its activities contributed to the implementation of many EU funded projects. Agencies have significant role in the data collection process and dissemination; this role can be useful to motivate new municipalities from particular region to sign CoM and to develop SEAP. b)Rural Support Service The Rural Support Service is responsible for the implementation of a unified state and European Union support policy in the sector of agriculture, forestry, fisheries and rural development; it supervises compliance of the sector with the laws and regulations and fulfils other functions connected with agriculture and implementation of rural support policy. Services role into SEAP development can be significant if we need collect information about market operators who have implemented latest technologies and have reached improvements in CO2 emissions. For more details see: http://www.lvif.gov.lv/?object_id=460 3.2 Waste 3.2.1 Waste treatment management Developer: Diputacio de Barcelona We include it since the Town Council has “competences” (is responsible or in charge of) in waste management. Waste intersects in various ways the emissions accountability: - Waste transport: energy consumption directly (included in Municipal fleet) - Waste use as an energy source 26 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations - Waste treatments emit several GHG like CH4 or CO2 directly, especially when waste are driven to a landfill. Composting organic matter or methanizations is greener. We discount emissions due to waste separation: paper, glass or plastic are reused, saving materials. For more details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 3.3 Water 3.3.1 Water treatment energy uses Developer: Diputacio de Barcelona Treatment of water demands energy, both in the purification and the wastewater treatment. We don’t include direct emissions from wastewater. For more details see: http://www.diba.cat/web/mediambient/pactealcaldes 27 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 4 SEAP and regional Policies; Cooperation with stakeholders An important aspect of the Covenant of Mayors initiative is the ambitious Plans it envisages for its signatories. Lack of coordination of the signatories in the different European regions, lack of integration of the ambitious local CoM-oriented policies with the regional policies and inadequate collaboration of the local governments with the local stakeholders are identified as important non-financial obstacles for the implementation of SEAP. This chapter proposes measures, policies and actions that can help in overcoming these obstacles during the whole Covenant of Mayors process. 4.1.1 Covenant capaCITY project – Capacity building of local governments to advance Local Climate and Energy Action – from planning to action to monitoring Developer: ICLEI Europe (consortium leader) Covenant capaCITY is a project led by ICLEI Europe in which an online training programme has been developed for start-up local governments. As a next step modules for more advanced cities and towns will be created – and translated into 11 languages. Further, Local Energy Action Plan (LEAP) Wizard was created as an online decision-making support tool to assist municipal action planning. This will be populated with more good practice cases and can then be valuable for all local governments. For more details see: http://www.covenant-capacity.eu/eu/training-platform 4.1.2 The Genoa Smart City Association Developer: Municipality of Genoa To consolidate and facilitate the process of transformation into a Smart City, in 2010 the Municipality of Genoa has created with Enel Distribution and the University of Genoa, the Genoa Smart City Association, to engage key partners in virtuous cycle: research, enterprises, institutions, and public finance. The Association has more than seventy members, including other institutions (Region, Province, Chamber of Commerce, Port Authority), small and big companies, research institutes, associations, all working together towards the shared goal of turning Genoa into a smart city. The members of AGSC have submitted about 25 projects that fall within one or more of the four proposed platforms (Efficient Buildings, Sustainable mobility, Energy, and Harbour). 28 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations The Municipality has signed with some companies a Memorandum of Understanding that identify specific projects for which companies undertake to carry out, free of charge, a project study or feasibility. For more details see: http://www.urbancenter.comune.genova.it/node/529 4.1.3 Xarxa de Ciutats i Pobles cap a la Sostenibilitat Developer: Diputacio de Barcelona The Network of Towns and Cities Towards Sustainability is promoted by DIBA. There are Local Governments from all Catalonia, not just from the province of Barcelona, and it is a platform that serves to exchange experiences among all members. There is a specific working group on Energy and climate Change, where other energy stakeholders, a part from Local governments, related to the Catalan Government also participate. For more details see: http://www.diba.es/xarxasost 4.1.4 Norrbottens´s sustainable energy plan and climate strategy Developer: Norrbotten Administration Board Climate change is one of the greatest challenges and the highest priority environmental issue. Therefore, the County Administrative Board of Norrbotten County, along with other players in the county, has produced a climate and energy strategy and an action; pointing out how the energy efficiency of the community, an increase in the share of renewable energy and reduced carbon footprint, can become a reality and be a driving force for regional growth. Full version available in Swedish and English. For more details see: www.lansstyrelsen.se/norrbotten/Sv/miljo-och-klimat/klimat-och-energi/klimat-ochenergistrategiskt-arbete/Pages/default.aspx 4.1.5 Jokkmokk Winter Conference: an international youth conference on local and regional energy and climate strategies Developer: Jokkmokk Jokkmokk Winter Conference is a yearly, international four day conference with a strong focus on youth involvement into local and regional energy and climate strategies. It follows a participatory approach with a strong network of partners, and is now an 29 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations established meeting point for decision makers and youth for forming climate policies for the North. For more details see: http://www.nncc.eu/index.php/jokkmokk-winterconference 4.1.6 Northern Network on Climate Change Developer: Jokkmokk The Northern Network on Climate Changed (financed by Interreg Iva Nord) is a network of municipalities and energy stakeholder providing information on energy and climate, developing tools for improving local strategies and actions and a broad range of training and promotion activities for energy stakeholders, municipalities and business. For more details see: http://www.nncc.eu/ 4.1.7 Jokkmokk sustainable energy plan and climate strategy SEAP Developer: Jokkmokk How a small municipality can make a difference – a best practice SEAP for municipalities with less than 15.000 inhabitants. Full version is available in Swedish, summary and BEI even in English. For more details see: www.jokkmokk.se/ext/templates/extPage.aspx?id=11790&epslanguage=SV 4.1.8 Covenant of Mayors Signatories in the Baltic Sea Region Developer: Union of the Baltic Cities The Baltic Sea Region Covenant Club - sharing ideas and inspiration across the region supports cities by: - facilitating exchange of experience through meetings, seminars and discussion - information and support in finding relevant information on the CoM - awareness raising of the CoM in other Union of Baltic Cities events - Cooperation between other CoM clubs and supporting structures For more details see: http://www.networkingcovenantofmayors.eu/ 30 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 4.1.9 Local development program Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund Regional policy document - local development program, has been developed or at the moment is under development process in each municipality of Latvia. The goals of the program are linked to the SEAP goals to improve the environmental quality for citizens. For more details see: http://www.lvif.gov.lv/?object_id=460 4.1.10 Energy agencies Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund Agencies facilitate the improvement on energy efficiency in public and private sectors, as well as to ensure the information availability on these issues for residents. They have developed particular SEAP for Latvian cities, which have signed the CoM. For more details see: http://www.lvif.gov.lv/?object_id=460 4.1.11 National Development Plan 2014 - 2020 Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund The possibility to comment the National Development Plan is ensured electronically and in the public seminars. Energy stakeholders can actively take part in this activity, ensuring positive impact on the national development directions. For more details see: www.nap.lv/kā-es-varu-palīdzēt 4.1.12 The Climate Change Financial Instrument (CCFI) Developer: Republic of Latvia Aim of CCFI is to prevent global climate change, adaptation to the effects of climate change and contribute the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions (for example, implementing activities to improve the energy performance of buildings in both public and private sectors, the development and implementation of technologies that use renewable energy resources, as well as the implementation of the integrated solutions to reduce greenhouse gas emissions). The Latvian Environmental Investment Fund provides supervision of implementation and post-implementation monitoring of projects cofinanced by CCFI – National Implementing Agency (CCFI co-financing – 200 million EUR) Its primary goal is to be achieved by implementing activities in the following climate change mitigation policy areas: 31 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 1) 2) 3) 4) increase the share of renewable energy sources in the energy balance; increase efficient and rational use of energy resources; develop an environmentally friendly transport system; promote the implementation of the best available techniques, environmentally friendly technologies and cleaner production; 5) promote the implementation of environmentally sound agricultural methods that reduce direct GHG emissions; 6) increase CO2 removals in forestry; 7) establish an up-to-date municipal waste management system, ensuring collection of biogas in municipal waste landfills For more details see: http://www.lvif.gov.lv/?object_id=19261 4.1.13 Students, schools and education sector “Futurize” Developer: Jokkmokk in cooperation with Nenet, regional energy agency Norrbotten Youth is a key player in work with Sustainability and SEAPs. The project Futurize tries to involve students aged 12-18 into the local work with these issues. A key instrument of the project is a so called “Future Contract” (Memorandum of Understanding) that is signed by both the regional political leaders (Mayor, City Council) and youth representatives. The contract includes that politicians are obliged to listen to the ideas, concepts and visions students develop in order to build a sustainable regional future. For more details see: http://www.nenet.se/projekt/futurize-energi-framtiden 4.1.14 Cooperation with indigenous people Developer: Jokkmokk, in collaboration with Sajtte “Sajtte” project is a local initiative in Northern Sweden/Jokkmokk which includes activities to involve the regional indigenous peoples (Sami) into the regional sustainability and SEAP work. With help of several tools, among others a vulnerability analysis, the specific situation and the specific knowledge of indigenous peoples are taken into account. For more details see: http://www.jokkmokk.se/Filer/Utvecklingsenheten/Projekt/Sajtte%20folder.pdf 32 SEAP-PLUS (IEE/11/978/SI2.615950) Deliverable 1.2 – SEAP-PLUS recommendations 4.1.15 Multipliers, stakeholders, media and decision makers Developer: Jokkmokk Training program for this target group developed within NNCC Northern Network on Climate Change project. For more details see: www.nncc.eu/index.php/trainingscapacity-building 4.1.16 Environmental NGO Developer: Latvian Environmental Investment Fund Environmental NGO role to educate energy stakeholders: tools for energy data collection, latest methods, approaches. NGO involvement can represent a bridge between energy stakeholders and local municipalities developing SEAP should be increased. Environmental NGOs of Latvia take part in the Environmental Advisory Board of Ministry of Regional Development and Environmental Protection. The advisory board has the possibility to participate in policy documents and decision making process. For more details see: http://www.lvif.gov.lv/?object_id=460 33