The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 Appendix 5: Water well regulation in Canada Groundwater jurisdiction At the federal level, jurisdiction related to water is related primarily to fisheries and navigation. The federal government is also responsible for international and interprovincial works, lands reserved for First Nations, and “peace, order, and good government” nationally. There is no central federal water law, and federal activity currently focuses on research, national programs and international affairs. A number of departments are active in water issues; Environment Canada is the primary federal body active on groundwater quality, Natural Resources Canada takes the lead on groundwater quantity, and Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada is active through the Sustainable Water Well Initiative[1]. Primary legislative responsibility for water resources is held at the provincial level, including the power to make laws governing natural resources and property rights, ownership of public land and jurisdiction over municipalities. The construction of wells is regulated in all provinces to meet standards of construction and the requirements for wells have improved dramatically over the past decades in some parts of Canada. Most provinces provide permits for groundwater use; British Columbia is the only province that does not require a license for groundwater withdrawals, and this is currently being reviewed by the province[1]. Provincial permitting does not apply to First Nation reserves. Many provinces have undertaken reviews of groundwater legislation in the wake of the Walkerton tragedy and amidst greater environmental awareness internationally[1]. All provinces and territories claim government ownership of water, with the exception of Ontario and PEI. Responsibility for groundwater resources is often shared between a number of provincial agencies, for example, in Ontario the Ministry of the Environment has responsibility for the construction, maintenance and decommissioning of private wells, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care has responsibility for a sampling program and providing technical advice concerning water quality for private water systems, and OMAFRA is responsible for promoting water wells best management practices for agriculture and rural residents[2]. In the North West Territories and Nunavut, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC) carries out legislation and policy for water management; licenses are issued through water licensing boards and approved by the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development. In the Yukon, the Yukon Water Board is an independent tribunal that grants water licenses[1]. Local governments require licenses from the province for water use, but are important in their role with land use planning, which is intrinsically linked with water availability and demand. Provincial groundwater regulation Regulations on groundwater use are primarily set at the provincial level. The regulations create very different contexts for well owners. For example in BC a license is not required for constructing and using a well, while PEI, Manitoba, and Ontario have all implemented moratoriums on water permitting either temporarily or permanently in response to water allocations being regarded as exceeding sustainable yield. Also, some provinces have permit terms as short as only 1 or 2 years while others issue licenses in perpetuity (Table 1). Charging for groundwater use in Nova Scotia and the territories provides an incentive for reducing groundwater use that does not exist in other provinces. See Table 2 for a detailed outline of provincial regulations related to water wells. 1 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 Table 1: Water well regulation across Canada Summary (adapted from Nowlan, 2005[1]) Province / Territory Number of wells Number of groundwater permits n/a – permits not required Quantity exemption for permits No GW permits Length of permit Priority of uses BC SK 100,000+ estimate - well records not mandatory 500,000 approx. – approx. 5000 new wells each year Not available n/a n/a Not available – numbers kept by regional offices Agriculture – < 6250 m3/yr First-in-time, first-in-right (FITFIR) No 3,600 approx. Domestic < 5000 m3/yr Historic licenses in perpetuity. New licenses of 1, 2, 10, or 25 yrs From 5 yrs to in perpetuity No priority system Not available 533 as of August 2004 Agriculture < 25 m3/day Irrigation 20 yrs Livestock 10 yrs ON 500,000 approx. 2,800 < 50 m3/dayi From 2 – 10 yrs QC Not available < 75 m3/day 10 yrs NB Estimated 3000 new wells each year 17,000 + More than 600 catchments > 75 m3/day Not available FITFIR – if application falls on same date the following priorities: 1) domestic 2) municipal 3) agricultural 4) industrial 5) irrigation 6) other 1) domestic, farm purposes and fire protection 2) municipal 3) industrial, commercial, irrigation No priority system Industrial - $0 - $12.50 / 1000 m3 Industrial $0.01 - $0.02 / 1000 m3 MB < 50 m3/day In perpetuity Not available None 5 – 10 yrs 100 approx. with withdrawals > 23 m3/day 500 - 800 5 approx. < 23 m3/day Not to exceed 10 yrs PEI YK 97,000 approx.; estimated 3000 new wells each year 21,000 approx. Not available NWT Not available Not available NUN Not available Not available < 4 L/s < 100 m3/day < 100 m3/day < 100 m3/day Open-ended Not to exceed 25 yrs Not to exceed 25 yrs Not to exceed 25 yrs AB NL NS Price charged for groundwater No No No No priority system, though domestic is favoured in practice 1) domestic 2) municipal 3) agricultural 4) commercial, industrial, institutional 5) water and thermal power generation 6) other FITFIR with priority to drinking water No No prioritization FITFIR No $1.50 - $2.00 / 1000 m3 $1.50 - $2.00 / 1000 m3 $1.50 - $2.00 / 1000 m3 FITFIR FITFIR No $117 – 143.77 / 1000 m3 Note: i. There is also a discretionary authority to require a permit for water takings of less than 50 m 3/day where the taking of water interferes with any public or private interest in any water 2 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 Table 2: Water well regulation across Canada (compiled by Harry Rohde, AAFC) Regulatory Requirement (Wells) Statute, Regulation, etc. Section Alberta An inspector or the Director may issue a water management order to the person responsible for a water well where possibility of an adverse effect on the environment or on human health Water Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. W-3 97(1), 136(1) Water Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 483 68-82 Groundwater Protection Regulation, B.C. Reg. 299/2004 (under the Water Act) 7-14 Drinking Water Protection Act, S.B.C. 2001, c. 9 16 British Columbia Regulated aspects of water wells: o o o o o o o o o o o o o restrictions on constructing wells, closing wells and related activities restrictions respecting well pumps and flow tests qualified well drillers and qualified well pump installers well reports -water analyses for new or altered wells well identification closing or deactivating a well well caps or well covers controlling artesian flow well operation prohibition on introducing foreign matter into a well wells on Crown land drilling authorizations ground water advisory board Regulated aspects of water wells: o o o o o o o o surface sealing well identification deactivating or closing a well well caps and well covers flood proofing of wells protection of wellhead temporary wells change of use or purpose Wells must be flood-proofed, if required by regulation 36 Restrictions on well-drilling in certain areas Owner or operator of a well that provides drinking water and identified as at risk of flooding must flood-proof their well Drinking Water Protection Regulation, B.C. Reg. 200/2003 14 Wells must be at least 100 feet from any probable source of contamination, such Sanitary Regulations, B.C. 42 as a privy vault, cesspool, manure heap, stable or pigsty, and at least 20 feet Reg. 142/59 (O.C. 829/17) (made under the Health Act) from any dwelling house, and at least 400 feet from any cemetery or dumping ground (subject to exceptions) Manitoba 3 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report Regulates well-drilling (creates licensing regime) and provides for: o o o o o o access to wells and records surveys and studies control of flow from well pollution of ground waters order re well abandonment or improper seal or cap right of entry Contamination of wells prohibited April 2011 The Ground Water and Water Well Act (Manitoba), C.C.S.M., c. G110 Generally Protection of Water Sources 2(2) Regulation, Man. Reg. 326/88R Wells must be constructed and maintained to prevent contamination of the water, Water Supplies Regulation, and the medical officer of health or inspector may direct what methods of M. Reg. 330/88R construction or materials must be used Well abandonment regulated medical officer of health may order the reconstruction, disinfection, or closing of a well where unsafe 6(1),(2) 6(3) 7(2) 8 Disinfection not required in the absence of erratic or high level coliform contamination or other contaminating factors Newfoundland and Labrador o o o o o o o Part III regulates well drilling, including licensing regime, creating well driller obligations and responsibilities, permitted rate of withdrawal, protection zone around a well Water Resources Act, SNL 2002, W-4.01 53-63 Regulated areas: Well Drilling Regulations, 2003, N.L.R. 63/03 (Water Resources Act) 3-7 licensing regime preventing surface water infiltration; minimum distances from potential contamination sources siting, design and appurtenances requirements water control areas maintenance and abandonment wells prohibition on waste disposal water yield testing 8-11 12-16 17 18 19 20-23 Sewage shall not contaminate a well Minimum setbacks from well for septic tanks, disposal areas Sanitation Regulations, C.N.L.R. 803/96 (under the Public Health Act) 5(5) Clean Water Act, S.N.B., c. C-6.1 11(1) Sch. 1 New Brunswick Well driller's report required when well is dug Owner of well must test water in accordance with regulations supply to consumers of water that poses a significant health risk prohibited (except from a private well) 11(2) 13(2) 13(3)-(8) Minister can take certain steps where water from a well poses a significant health risk 16 4 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 Well drilling requires the appropriate registration, licence, permit or approval in accordance with the regulations Well contractor's permit required for anyone who engages in the business of well- Water Well Regulation, N.B. 4, 6 Reg. 9079 (under the Clean drilling 8 Water Act) Permit renewable 11 Inspector can require modifications 14 Well location requirements 15-21 Construction standards 22-25 Minimum setback distances, other locational requirements 26-27 Where well not in use 30 Pump installation requirements 32 Well yield must be evaluated 35 Well Drilling Advisory Board created 38 Inspector's orders Voucher system: Minister issues voucher to well-driller, who gives it to owner, who then must use voucher to have water tested Potable Water Regulation, 3-6 N.B. Reg. 93-203 (under the 7ff Clean Water Act) Owner must develop a sampling plan for Minister's approval Different zones created throughout province, in which certain activities that may threaten groundwater are restricted or prohibited Wellfield Protected Area Designation Order, N.B. Reg. 2000-47 Generally No well may be constructed without the approval of a district medical health officer unless it has been approved by the Minister General Regulation, N.B. Reg. 88-200 (under the Health Act) 218 A district medical health officer may order the disinfection or closing of a well or spring where it is found to be unsafe for drinking or cooking purposes, or where it is improperly located or constructed or the spring is inadequately protected 219 229 240 Contaminating wells prohibited 256-7 Setbacks from septic tanks 258 Depth requirements Setbacks from sub-surface disposal field Northwest Territories Not referred to specifically, but falls under general sampling and testing requirements Duane Fleming (Chief Environmental Health Officer, Stanton Territorial Health Authority) 1 Nova Scotia 5 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report Well drillers must have Certificate of qualification April 2011 Well Construction Regulations, N.S. Reg. 58/95 (made under the Environment Act) Certificate of qualification requirements 5 6-16 Inspector can require well modification 17 Construction standards, capping, sealing 20-23 Location of wells (incl. minimum distances) 24-33 Abandoned wells 34 Pump installation 38-40 Yield test 41-47 Well Construction Records 48-50 Corrective action to be taken when bacteria found to be present Guidelines for Monitoring Public Drinking Water Supplies 5.4.2 Ontario Water Resources Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.40 35-50 Nunavut No relevant provisions Ontario Subjects: o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o permit required to construct well in designated area issuance of well construction permit grounds for refusal to issue, etc., well construction permit well contractor licence required issuance of well contractor licence grounds for refusal to issue well contractor licence grounds for revocation, etc., of well contractor licence well technician licence required for the construction of wells issuance of well technician licence grounds for refusal to issue well technician licence grounds for refusal to renew, etc., well technician licence review, refusal to issue, etc., well permit or licences interim order, refusal to issue, etc., well permit or licences expiry of well permit or licences transfer of well permit or licences The owner of a drinking-water system that includes a well used as a raw water Non-Residential and Non10 supply shall ensure that no surface water or other foreign materials enter the well Municipal Seasonal Residential Systems that Do Not Serve Designated Facilities, O. Reg. 252/05 (made under the SDWA) Regulated areas: o o o Wells Regulation, R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 903 (made under the OWRA) well contractor licence well technician licence examination Generally 6 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o April 2011 continuing education well technicians assistant well technician construction requirements well clusters location of wells casing annular space disinfection pump installation venting testing of well yield well maintenance abandonment protection of well tag Prince Edward Island Well drilling, construction and operation can only be done in accordance with the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.P.E.I. 1988, c. E-9 regulations 12 Where a municipality is the owner of a public drinking water supply facility, it must develop a well field protection plan Drinking Water and Wastewater Facility Operating Regulations, P.E.I. Reg. EC710/04 (under the EPA) 20 Regulated areas: Water Well Regulations, P.E.I. Reg. EC188/90 Generally o o o o o o o o o o o o well driller's and well contractor's licenses well construction report well permits groundwater exploration permits groundwater extraction permits general provisions re well construction location of wells well design upon well completion abandonment pump installation restricted areas Well construction standards Atlantic Canada Guidelines 2.3.6 for the Supply, Treatment, 2.3.8 Storage, Distribution and Operation of Drinking Water Supply Systems (2004) Wellhead requirements Quebec Wells require municipal approval Groundwater Catchment Regulation, c. Q-2, r. 1.3 3 Contamination must be avoided 4 Minimum setbacks from wastewater, agricultural areas; floodplains, 5-8 Construction and materials standards, sealing, 9-18 7 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 Yield tests, reports, sampling requirements 19-21 Protection areas 24-30 Authorization of the Minister required for high-load systems, systems used to supply bottled water 31 45 Drilling requirements 63 Municipalities responsible for the application of several parts of regulation 64 Minister of the Environment must every 5 years file a report with the Government on the application of this Regulation Saskatchewan Approval of Saskatchewan Watershed Authority required for construction of wells Saskatchewan Watershed Authority Act, 2005, S.S. (except wells used for domestic purposes) 2005, c. S-35.03 No person shall operate a water well drilling machine unless that person or machine is registered with Saskatchewan Watershed Authority (except wells constructed for domestic purposes) 59(1) 74 75 77 No person shall do any of the following, except in accordance with the regulations: (a) undertake a ground water investigation program; (b) drill a water well; (c) use ground water Well drillers and owners of wells must ensure wells are sited, constructed and controlled in accordance with the regulations Regulated areas: o o o o o o o o o o permit for ground water exploration registration of machines for drilling drilling and evaluation (notice of drilling, driller's report, logs, yield test, disinfection) abandonment of test holes and wells use of ground water report completion of well and appurtenant works licencing of existing works, new works meters and observation wells ground water use records inspection Municipal wells connected to a distribution system supplying water for hygienic uses must meet certain disinfection standards Every person who holds an approval pursuant to The Saskatchewan Watershed Authority Act to construct, extend, alter or operate a well must ensure it meets construction standards, and ensure that the water is cleaned and disinfected Generally The Ground Water Regulations, S. Reg. 172/66 (under the Ground Water Conservation Act [repealed] [123].) The Water Regulations, 2002, c. E10.21, M. Reg 1 22 25 No person shall establish, extend, renovate or alter a well or other supply of Health Hazard Regulations, 5 water intended for public use that is not connected to a distribution system unless R.R.S. c. P-37.1, Reg. 10 6, 7 the owner or operator has obtained written approval to do so from the local authority 8 Owner of operator of a well or other supply of water intended for public use that is not connected to a distribution system must ensure water is potable, take steps to prevent contamination, submit samples for testing 8 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada The Sustainable Water Well Initiative Business Case Report April 2011 A local authority can require the owner or operator to provide ongoing treatment if it suspects that a public water supply (incl. a well as above) constitutes a health hazard Yukon No person shall create a condition injurious to health or which is or is likely to become a public nuisance on any well Regulations Respecting Public Health, C.O. 1958/079 (made under the Every incorporated municipality shall provide maintain one or more wells or other Public Health Act) sources of water supply for the use of the inhabitants and shall be responsible for the safety of such supply 6(1) 17 18 19 Every well or other source of water supply for use for human consumption, or in connection with the manufacture for sale of food or drink, including storage, handling, intakes, transmission, and outlets shall be subject to inspection and testing by a Medical Health Officer or Health Officer Minimum setbacks from sources of pollution; protection from surface water; cover and seal Footnotes: 123. These Regulations continue in force under The Saskatchewan Watershed Authority Act, 2005. References: 1. 2. Nowlan, L., Buried Treasure: Groundwater Permitting and Pricing in Canada. 2005, The Walter and Duncan Gordon Foundation. Simpson, H., Promoting the management and protection of private water wells. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part A, 2004. 67: p. 1679-1704. 9 Prepared by GW Solutions Inc. for the Agri-Environmental Services Branch of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada