PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith THE MULTIWAVELENGTH UNIVERSE AND EXOPLANETS School of Physical Sciences Convenor Prof. Michael Smith Taught in Term 2 Teaching Provision: Prerequisites: 1 PH507 ECTS Credits 7.5 Kent Credits 15 at Level I 30 lectures + 4 workshops + 2 class tests PH300, PH301, PH304 Aims: To provide a basic but rigorous grounding in observational, computational and theoretical aspects of astrophysics to build on the descriptive course in Part I, and to consider evidence for the existence of exoplanets in other Solar Systems. Learning Outcomes: 1. An understanding of the fundamentals of making astronomical observations across the whole electromagnetic spectrum, including discussion of photometry and spectroscopy, and the physics of the astrophysical radiation mechanisms. 2. An understanding of the motions of objects in extrasolar systems and the basic techniques required to solve the 2-body problem to measure their properties. 3. An understanding of observational characteristics of stars, and how their physical structures are derived from observation and using simple physical models. 4. To be able to discuss coherently the origin and evolution of Solar Systems and be able to evaluate claims for evidence of Solar Systems other than our own. SYLLABUS: • • • • • • Part 1: measurements Part 2: radiation Part 3: dynamics Part 4: star and planet formation Part 5: telescopes/instruments Part 6: stars and stellar structure Assessment Methods:Examination 70%, Homework 10%, 1st class test 10%, 2nd cla 7 assignments. Class Test 1: end of week 6. Class Test 2: end of week 12 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 2 Recommended Texts: Carroll & Ostlie, An Introduction to Modern Astrophysics, Addison-Wesley, second edition if possible THESE LECTURE NOTES, posted at the end of each week on my webpage [Note: Changes may occur to the syllabus during the year] Convenor: Prof. Michael Smith: 101 Ingram, x7654, m.d.smith@kent.ac.uk Office hours: 10-12am Wed ?? Bad weather Numbers, names Locations, times of lectures: SPS110 Lecturers: Drs Price & Miao PART 1: Measurement LECTURE 1: DISTANCE Distance: Distance is an easy concept to understand: it is just a length in some units such as in feet, km, light years, parsecs etc. It has been excrutiatingly difficult to measure astronomical distances until this century. Unfortunately most stars are so far away that it is impossible to directly measure the distance using the classic technique of triangulation. Trignometric parallax: based on triangulation – need three parameters to fully define any triangle e.g. two angles and one PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 3 baseline. To triangulate to even the closest stars we would need to use a very large baseline. In fact we do have a long baseline, because every 6 months the earth is on opposite sides of the sun. So we can use as a baseline the major axis of the earth's orbit around the sun. BASELINE: 2 x earth-sun distance = 2 Astronomical Units (AU) (The average distance from the earth to the sun is called the Astronomical Unit.) Note: size of earth: 6,000 km Sun 700,000 km 1 AU 150,000,000 km (1.49 x 1011 m) 360 degree = 2 radians 57 degrees = 1 radian Therefore solar disk subtends an angle of 2 x 700,000/150,000,000 radians = 0.01 radians i.e. about half a degree angular size: The parallactic displacement of a star on the sky as a result of the Earth’s orbital motion permits us to determine the distance from the Sun to the star by the method of trigonometric (heliocentric) parallax. We define the trigonometric parallax of the star as the angle p subtended, as seen from the star, by the Earth’s orbit of radius 1 AU. If the star is at rest with respect to the Sun, the parallax is half the maximum apparent annual angular displacement of the star as seen from the Earth. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 4 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 5 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 6 1 radian is defined as: 1 radian = 360 57.3 degrees = 206265 arc seconds, approximately. There are 2 2 rad in a circle (360˚), so that 1 radian equals 57˚17´44.81” (206, 264.81”). Independent distance unit is the light year: c t ( year ) 9.47 1015 m The light year is not used much by professional astronomers, who work instead with the unit of similar size called the parsec, where 1 parsec = 1 pc = 206265 AU = 3.086 x 1016 m = 3.26 light years. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 7 The measurement and interpretation of stellar parallaxes are a branch of astrometry, and the work is exacting and timeconsuming. Consider that the nearest star, Proxima/Alpha Centauri (Rigil Kent), at a distance of 1.29 pc, has a parallax of only 0.772”; all other stars have smaller parallaxes. Formula: 1AU tan p d or 1 d AU p where p is in radians for small angles. To convert to arcseconds: 2.063 105 d AU p '' or d 1 pc . p" Defines the parsec – parallax second abbreviation! Technique: The ground-based trigonometric parallax of a star is determined by photographing a given star field from a number (about 20) of selected points in the Earth’s orbit. The comparison stars selected are distant background stars of nearly the same PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 8 apparent brightness as the star whose parallax is being measured. Corrections are made for atmospheric refraction and dispersion and for detectable motions of the background stars; any motion of the star relative to the Sun is then extracted. What remains is the smaller annual parallactic motion; it is recognised because it cycles annually. Because a seeing resolution of 0.25” is considered exceptional (more typical it is 1”), it may seem strange that a stellar position can be determined to ±0.01” in one measurement; this accuracy is possible because we are determining the centre of the fuzzy stellar image. Astrometry: Technological advances (including the Hubble Space Telescope) have improved parallax accuracy to 0.001” within a few years. Before 1990, fewer than 10,000 stellar parallaxes had been measured (and only 500 known well), but there are about 10 12 stars in our Galaxy. Space observations made by the European Space Agency with the Hipparcos mission (1989-1993) accurately determined the parallaxes of many more stars. Though a poor orbit limited its usefulness, Hipparcos was expected to achieve a precision of about 0.002”. It actually achieved 0.001” for 118,000 stars. The method of trigonometric parallax is important because it is our only direct distance technique for stars. In 2011 – 2013, Gaia will be set into orbit with a Soyuz rocket. Limiting magnitude V=16 ; 100 million stars, over a 5-yr mission lifetime (and SIM Space Interferometric Mission from the US –pointed deep, to V=20). It will be able to measure parallaxes of 10 microarcseconds. It consists of a rotating frame holding three telescopes. Some aims: …….Accurate distances even to the Galactic centre, 8000 parsecs away. ……..Photometry: accurate magnitudes. ……..Planet quest ……..Reference frame from distant quasars (3C273 is 800 Mpc away) PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 9 Parallax remains limited to nearby objects. In the meantime, to go further, we construct the COSMIC LADDER. If we can estimate the luminosity of a star from other properties, they can be used as STANDARD CANDLES. Example: Sirius A (Class A1, V= -1.44) has an observed parallax of 0.3792 arcsec.. Distance? 2.64 parsecs. 2 LUMINOSITY. We can actually only measure the radiant flux of a flame and need to make a few assumptions to find the true luminosity. Luminosity depends on the distance and extinction (as well as relativistic effects). The measured flux f is in units of W/m2 , the flow of energy per unit area. The radiated power L, ignoring extinction, is given by an inverse square law: f d2 L 4d 2 L 4f ’ showing that a standard candle can yield the distance. The Stellar Magnitude Scale PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 10 The first stellar brightness scale - the magnitude scale - was defined by Hipparchus of Nicea and refined by Ptolemy almost 2000 years ago. In this qualitative scheme, nakedeye stars fall into six categories: the brightest are of first magnitude, and the faintest of sixth magnitude. Note that the brighter the star, the smaller the value of the magnitude. (Sun: (minus) -26.72 (1st); Sirius -1.46; Deneb 1.25, 21st) In 1856, N. R. Pogson verified William Herschel’s finding that a first-magnitude star is 100 times brighter than a sixthmagnitude star and the scale was quantified. Because an interval of five magnitudes corresponds to a factor of 100 in brightness, a one-magnitude difference corresponds to a factor of 1001/5 = 2.512. This definition reflects the operation of human vision, which converts equal ratios of actual intensity to equal intervals of perceived intensity. In other words, the eye is a logarithmic detector). The magnitude scale has been extended to positive magnitudes larger than +6.0 to include faint stars (the 5-m telescope on Mount Palomar can reach to magnitude +23.5) and to negative magnitudes for very bright objects (the star Sirius is magnitude -1.4). The limiting magnitude of the Hubble Space Telescope is about +30. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 11 Astronomers find it convenient to work with logarithms to base 10 rather than with exponents in making the conversions from brightness ratios to magnitudes and vice versa. Consider two stars of magnitude m and n with respective apparent brightnesses (fluxes) lm and ln. The ratio of their fluxes fn / fm corresponds to the magnitude difference m n. Because a one-magnitude difference means a brightness ratio of 1001/5= 2.51189, (m - n) magnitudes refer to a ratio of (1001/5)m-n = 100(m-n)/5, or fn / fm = 100(m-n)/5 Taking the log10 of both sides (because log xa = a log x and log 10a = a log 10 = a), log (fn / fm) = [(m - n)/5] log 100 = 0.4(m - n) or m - n = 2.5 log (fn / fm) PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 12 This last equation defines the apparent magnitude; note that m > n when fn > fm, that is: brighter objects have numerically smaller magnitudes. Also note that when the brightnesses are those observed at the Earth, physically they are fluxes. Apparent magnitude is the astronomically peculiar way of talking about fluxes. Here are a few worked examples: (a) The apparent magnitude of the variable star RR Lyrae ranges from 7.1 to 7.8 - a magnitude amplitude of 0.7. To find the relative increase in brightness from minimum to maximum, we use log (fmax / fmin) = 0.4 x 0.7 = 0.28 so that fmax / fmin = 100.28 = 1.91 This star is almost twice as bright at maximum light than at minimum. (b) A binary system consists of two stars a and b, with a brightness ratio of 2; however, we see them unresolved as a point of magnitude +5.0. We would like to find the magnitude of each star. The magnitude difference is mb - ma = 2.5 log (fa / fb) = 2.5 log 2 = 0.75 Since we are dealing with brightness ratios, it is not right to put ma + mb = +5.0. The sum of the luminosities (fa + fb) corresponds to a fifth-magnitude star. Compare this to a 100-fold brighter star, of magnitude 0.0 and luminosity l0: PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 13 ma+ b - m0 = 2.5 log [l0 / (fa + fb)] or 5.0 - 0.0 = 2.5 log 100 = 5. But fa = 2 fb, so that fb = (fa + fb)/3. Therefore (mb - m0) = 2.5 log (f0 / fb) = 2.5 log 300 = 2.5 x 2.477 = 6.19. The magnitude of the fainter star is 6.19, and from our earlier result on the magnitude difference, that of the brighter star is 5.44. What units are used in astronomical photometry? The well-known magnitude scale of course, which has been calibrated using standard stars which (hopefully) do not vary in brightness. But how does the astronomical magnitude scale relate to other photometric units? Here we assume V magnitudes, unless otherwise noted, which are at least approximately convertible to lumes, candelas, and lux'es. ************************************************************** 1 mv=0 star outside Earth's atmosphere = 2.54 10-6 lux = 2.54 10-10 phot Luminance: ( 1 nit =1 candela per square metre) 1 mv= 0 star per square degree outside Earth's atmosphere PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 14 = 0.84 10-2 nit = 8.4 10-7 stilb 1 mv = 0 star per square degree inside clear unit airmass = 0.69 10-2 nit = 6.9 10-7 stilb One star, Mv=0 outside Earth's atmosphere = 2.451029 cd 3 Attenuation in the earth’s atmosphere Light incident on the Earth's atmosphere from an extraterrestrial source is diminished by passage through the Earth's atmosphere. Thus, sources will always appear less bright below the Earth's atmosphere than above it. 1 clear unit airmass transmits 82% in the visual, i.e. it dims 0.2 magnitudes). to a good approximation from The path length that light from a celestial object takes through Earth’s atmosphere relative to the length at the zenith. Airmass is 1 at the zenith and roughly 2 at an altitude of 60°. It can be calculated to a good approximation from the formula A = 1.0 / [ cos(Z) + 0.50572 A = 1.0 / [ cos(Z) + 0.50572 x (96.07995 - Z)-1.6364] x (96.07995 - Z)-1.6364] Note that a unit airmass at Mauna Kea (with a mean barometric pressure of 605 millibars) is equivalent to 0.60 airmass at sea level. From a practical standpoint, you can see that, for example: At z=60 degrees you look through 2 airmasses PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 15 (obtainable from plane parallel approximation). At z=71 degrees you look through 3 airmass. At limit of z=90degrees you look through 38 airmasses. Atmospheric extinction at optical wavelengths is due primarily to two phenomena: 1 Absorption: ◦ On UV side primary absorption is ozone O3 On IR side water vapor, CO2. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 16 Atmospheric extinction across the electromagnetic spectrum. Figure from Observational Astronomy by Lena, Lebrun and Mignard. As may be seen, most EM radiation is blocked by the Earth, and only a few atmospheric windows allow certain wavelengths through: ▪ Optical ▪ Various near and mid-infrared ranges ▪ Millimeter and radio wavelengths ◦ As may be seen, increasing elevations open up new atmospheric windows: ▪ On high mountains and Antarctic plateau (where atmosphere is compressed -- equivalent to higher altitude at warmer latitudes): More mid- and far- infrared wavelengths accessible. 2 Scattering: Two mechanisms depending on size of scatterer: Molecular scattering: scattering radius a << wavelength ▪ Mainly Rayleigh scattering (elastic -- energies of scattered photons preserved), which has a scattering cross-section as function of wavelength. Aerosol scattering: scattering radius a >~ /10 wavelength ▪ Mie scattering is light scattered by "large" [relative to wavelength of light] spheres), and the strict theory accounts for Maxwells equations in the context of all kinds of reflections (external and internal) and surface waves on the scatterer, polarization, etc. Full theory PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 17 requires computer. The sky seems more/deeper blue when you look at greater angles from the Sun because that is mostly Rayleigh scattering, while close to the Sun the sky appears "whiter" because this is primarily Mie scattering. ▪ Aerosols highly variable from night to night. ▪ air pollution ▪ dust = "haze" ▪ volcanic ash (can be horrible) ▪ dust storms Apparent magnitude is an irradiance or illuminance, i.e. incident flux per unit area, from all directions. Of course a star is a point light source, and the incident light is only from one direction. Apparent magnitude per square degree is a radiance, luminance, intensity, or "specific intensity". This is sometimes also called "surface brightness". Still another unit for intensity is magnitudes per square arcsec, which is the magnitude at which each square arcsec of an extended light source shines. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 18 Only visual magnitudes can be converted to photometric units. U, B, R or I magnitudes are not easily convertible to luxes, lumens and friends, because of the different wavelengths intervals used. The conversion factors would be strongly dependent on e.g. the temperature of the blackbody radiation or, more generally, the spectral distribution of the radiation. The conversion factors between V magnitudes and photometric units are only slightly dependent on the spectral distribution of the radiation. Here we're not interested in the photometric response of some detector with a well-known passband (e.g. the human eye, or some astronomical photometer). Instead we want to know the strength of the radiation in absolute units: watts etc. Thus we have: Radiance, intensity or specific intensity: W m-2 ster-1 [Å-1] SI unit -2 -1 -1 -1 erg cm s ster [Å ] CGS unit -2 -1 -1 -1 photons cm s ster [Å ] Photon flux, CGS units Irradiance/emittance, or flux: W m-2 [Å-1] SI unit -1 erg cm-2 s-1 [Å ] CGS unit -1 photons cm-2 s-1 ster-1 [Å ] Photon flux, CGS units Note the [A-1] within brackets. Fluxes and intensities can be total (summed over all wavelengths) or monochromatic ("per Angstrom Å" or "per nanometer"). PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 19 In Radio/Infrared Astronomy, the unit Jansky is often used as a measure of irradiance at a specific wavelength, and is the radio astronomer's equivalence to stellar magnitudes. The Jansky is defined as: 1 Jansky = 10-26 W m-2 Hz-1 4. Absolute magnitude represents a total flux. Absolute Magnitude and Distance Modulus So far we have dealt with stars as we see them, that is, their fluxes or apparent magnitudes, but we want to know the luminosity of a star. A very luminous star will appear dim if it is far enough away, and a low-luminosity star may look bright if it is close enough. Our Sun is a case in point: if it were at the distance of the closest star (Alpha Centauri), the Sun would appear slightly fainter to us than Alpha Centauri does. Hence, distance links fluxes and luminosities. (Sun’s apparent magnitude is –26.83) PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 20 The solar irradiance is the amount of incoming solar radiation per unit area, measured on the outer surface of the Earth's atmosphere, in a plane perpendicular to the rays. The solar constant includes all types of solar radiation, not just the visible light. It is measured by satellite to be roughly 1366 watts per square meter,[ The luminosity of a star relates to its absolute magnitude, which is the magnitude that would be observed if the star were placed at a distance of 10 pc from the Sun, in the absence of interstellar extinction. By convention, absolute magnitude is capitalised (M) and apparent magnitude is written lowercase (m). The inversesquare law of radiative flux links the flux f of a star at a distance d to the flux, F, it would have if it were at a distance d = 10 pc: F / f = (d / D)2 = (d / 10) 2. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 21 If M corresponds to F and m corresponds to the flux f, then m - M = 2.5 log (F / f ) = 2.5 log (d/10)2 = 5 log (d / 10) Expanding this expression, we have useful alternative forms. Since m1 – m2 = 5 log d1 - 5 log d2 defining the absolute magnitude m2 = M at d2 = 10 pc, so m1 = m and d2 = d , m - M = 5 log d - 5 M = m + 5 - 5 log d In terms of the parallax, M = m + 5 + 5 log p” Here d is in parsecs and p” is the parallax angle in arc seconds. The quantity m - M is called the distance modulus, for it is directly related to the star’s distance. In many applications, we refer only to the distance moduli of different objects rather than converting back to distances in parsecs or lightyears. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 22 EXAMPLE: Luminosity – Absolute magnitude? 22 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 23 Absolute magnitudes for stars generally range from -10 to +17. The absolute magnitude for galaxies can be much lower (brighter). For example, the giant elliptical galaxy M87 has an absolute magnitude of –22. Many stars visible to the naked eye have an absolute magnitude which is capable of casting shadows from a distance of 10 parsecs; Rigel (-7.0), Deneb (-7.2), Naos (-6.0), and Betelgeuse (-5.6). Magnitudes at Different Wavelengths The kind of magnitude that we measure depends on how the light is filtered anywhere along the path of the detector and on the response function of the detector itself. So the problem comes down to how to define standard magnitude systems. Magnitude Systems Detectors of electromagnetic radiation (such as the photographic plate, the photoelectric photometer, and the human eye) are sensitive only over given wavelength bands. So a given measurement samples but part of the radiation arriving from a star. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 24 Multiwavelength Astronomy: Four images of the Sun, made using (a) visible light, (b) ultraviolet light, (c) X rays, and (d) radio waves. By studying the similarities and differences among these views of the same object, important clues to its structure and composition can be found. Photographic magnitude Because the flux of starlight varies with wavelength, the magnitude of a star depends upon the wavelength at which we observe. Originally, photographic plates were sensitive only to blue light, and the term photographic magnitude (mpg) still refers to magnitudes centred around 420 nm (in the blue region of the spectrum). Visual magnitude Similarly, because the human eye is most sensitive to green and yellow, visual magnitude (mv) or the photographic equivalent photo visual magnitude (mpv) pertains to the wave-length region around 540 nm. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 25 Filters Today we can measure magnitudes in the infrared, as well as in the ultraviolet, by using filters in conjunction with the wide spectral sensitivity of photoelectric photometers. In general, a photometric system requires a detector, filters, and a calibration (in energy units). The properties of the filters are typified by their effective wavelength, 0, and bandpass, ∆ which is defined as the full width at half maximum (FWHM) in the transmission profile. The three main filter types are wide (∆≈ 100 nm), intermediate (∆≈ 10 nm), and narrow (∆≈1 nm). There is a trade-off for the bandwidth choice: a smaller ∆ provides more spectral information but admits less flux into the detector, resulting in longer integration times. For a given range of the spectrum, the design of the filters makes the greatest difference in photometric magnitude systems. A commonly used wide-band magnitude system is the UBV system: a combination of ultraviolet (U), blue (B), and visual (V) magnitudes, developed by H. L. Johnson. These three bands are centred at 365, 440, and 550 nm; each wavelength band is roughly 100 nm wide. In this system, apparent magnitudes are denoted by U, B or V and the corresponding absolute magnitudes are sub-scripted: MU, MB or MV. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 26 To be useful in measuring fluxes, the photometric system must be calibrated in energy units for each of its bandpasses. This calibration turns out to be the hardest part of the job. In general, it relies first on a set of standard stars that define the magnitudes, for a particular filter set and detector; that is, these stars define the standard magnitudes for the photometric system to the precision with which they can be measured. Infrared Windows The UBV system has been extended into the red and infrared (in part because of the development of new detectors, such as CCDs, sensitive to this region of the spectrum). The extensions are not as well standardised as that for the Johnson UBV system, but they tend to include R and I in the far red and J, H, K, L, and M in the infrared. As well as measuring the properties of individual stars at different wavelengths, observing at loner wavelengths, PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 27 particularly in the infrared, allows us to probe through clouds of small solid dust particles, as seen below A visible-light (left) vs. 2MASS infrared-light (right) view of the central regions of the Milky Way galaxy graphically illustrating the ability of infrared light to penetrate the obscuring dust. The field-of-view is 10x10 degrees Infrared passbands absorption): J Band: 1.3 microns H Band: 1.6 microns K band: 2.2 microns L band 3.4 microns M band 5 microns N band 10.2 microns Q band 21 microns which allow transmission (low Bolometric magnitudes can be converted to total radiant energy flux: One star of Mbol = 0 radiates 2.97 1028 Watts. System is defined by Vega at 7.76 parsecs from the Sun with an apparent magnitude defined as zero. With Lbol = 50.1 Lsolar and Mbol = 0.58. Sun: mbol = -26.8 Full moon: -12.6 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 28 Venus: -4.4 Sirius: -1.55 Brightest quasar: 12.8 For Vega: mb = mv = 0. mk = +0.02 Sun: Mb = 5.48, Mv = 4.83, Mk = 3.28 Colour Index: B-V, J-H, H-K are differences in magnitude….flux ratios. But cooler, redder objects possess higher values. It is independent of the star’s distance. Extinction Interstellar Medium modifies the radiation. Dust particles with size of order of the wavelength of the radiation. Blue radiation is strongly scattered compared to red: blue reflection nebulae and reddened stars. Hence a colour excess is produced. Colour Excess: E(B-V) = B-V - (B-V)o measures the reddening. Modified distance modulus: m() = M() + 5 log d – 5 + A() PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 29 where A () is the extinction due to both scattering and absorption, along the entire line of sight. It is strongly wavelength dependent. The optical depth is given by I exp( ) . Io Therefore A() = 1.086 The optical depth is where N is the total column density of dust (m-2) between the star and the observer and is the scattering/absorption cross-section (m2). ISM empirical Law related extinction to reddening: Av / E(B-V) = 3.2 + - 0.2 OK, so an objects emission is modified/attenuated by the interstellar medium and the atmosphere. But these effects can be estimated. END OF WEEK 1