Sampling of 12 Information Literacy Process Models Model 5-As The 8Ws of Information Inquiry Expert/Orga nization Ian Jukes Annette Lamb Overview - Promotes informational, technological and media fluency - Goal is to create and apply this knowledge within the context of real time, real life tasks - Developed to bring together perspectives in library media, technology, and traditional content areas - Focuses on unique way students expresses themselves - Alliteration was used to capture the students’ perspective and foster interest Process Asking - key questions to be answered Accessing - relevant information Analyzing - the acquired information to turn it into knowledge Applying - the information to a task Assessing - the end result and the process Watching (Exploring) Wondering (Questioning) Webbing (Searching) Wiggling (Evaluating) Weaving (Synthesizing) Wrapping (Creating) Waving (Communicating) Wishing (Assessing) Appropriate Setting All Elementary References Information Age Inquiry. (2006a). 5As. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/as.htm Premiere Speakers Bureau. (2008). Ian Jukes Speech Topics. Retrieved from http://premierespeakers.com /ian_jukes/speech_topics Information Age Inquiry. (2006b). 8Ws of information inquiry. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/ws.htm Johnson, L., & Lamb, A. (2007). Approaches to information and communication literacy. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://eduscapes.com/tap/top ic72.htm AGOPPE Big 6 Montgomery - Adopted throughout many County Public school clusters within MCPS Schools - Not a linear sequence, but spiraling - New questions arise as students find info--this requires more resources - Must continually assess info gathered to determine if it meets the informational need Michael B. - The most widely known & Eisenberg & used model Robert E. - Each step has two sub-stages Berkowitz which defines exactly what is expected of the student - Not necessary to complete stages in linear order or spend a lot of time on each Ask Questions Gather Information Organize Information Prepare and Produce Present Evaluate, Assess, and Reflect All Montgomery County Public Schools. (2007). Information literacy: A shared responsibility. The Information Literacy Guide, 25-26. 1. Task Definition - Define the information problem - Identify information needed 2. Information Seeking Strategies - Determine all possible sources - Select the best sources 3. Location and Access - Locate sources (intellectually and physically) - Find information within sources 4. Use of Information - Engage (e.g., read, hear, view, touch) - Extract relevant information Upper Elementary through High Eisenberg, M. B, & Berkowitz, R. E. (2008). What is the Big6? Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.big6.com/ Building Blocks of Research FINDS Debbie Abilock & NoodleTools The Florida Department of Education, Library Media Services - Includes a description of information literacy, student skills and strategies, student outcomes, and curriculum and teaching design for each of the steps - Focuses on core thinkingand problem-solving metaskills across different disciplines - Based on the literacy skills that are in the Florida standards - Provides a framework for the application of these 5. Synthesis - Organize from multiple sources - Present the information 6. Evaluation - Judge the product (effectiveness) - Judge the process (efficiency) Engaging Defining Initiating Locating Examining, Selecting, Comprehending, Assessing Recording, Sorting, Organizing, Interpreting Communicating, Synthesizing Evaluating Focus on the information need Investigate resources to look for an answer Note and evaluate facts Middle and High NoodleTools. (2007). Information Literacy. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.noodletools.com /debbie/literacies/informatio n/1over/infolit1.html Information Age Inquiry. (2006c). Noodle tools: Building blocks of research. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/noodletools.htm All Florida Department of Education. (2006). Introduction to FINDS; Florida research model. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from Information Search Process (ISP) Office & the Florida Sunlink Project standards through a sequential Develop information into research process knowledge for a - Used statewide presentation - Common Score presentation and search language - Transferable Carol Kuhlthau - Based on extensive observations of students - Model of user’s holistic experience of research process - Focuses on attitudinal and emotional aspects of the inquiry process - Central idea: uncertainty increases and decreases during the process of information seeking Middle and Initiating a Research High Assignment apprehension, uncertainty Selecting a Topic confusion, sometimes anxiety, brief elation, anticipation Exploring Information confusion, uncertainty, doubt, sometimes threat Formulating a Focus optimism, confidence in ability to complete task Collecting Information realization of extensive work to be done, confidence in ability to complete task, increased interest Preparing to Present sense of relief, sometimes http://www.sunlink.ucf.edu/ finds/intro.html Space Coast Media Center. (2008). Implementing FINDS [PowerPoint slides]. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from www.spacecoast.brevardsch ools.org/media/IMPLEME NTING%20FINDS.ppt Kuhlthau, C. (2008). Carol Collier Kuhlthau. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.scils.rutgers.edu /~kuhlthau/information_sear ch_process.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006d). Information search process (ISP). Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/ips.htm I-Search Ken Macrorie; Marilyn Joyce & Julie Tallman - Students select topics of personal interest to build an understanding of research process - The key is to work on meaningful projects - Stresses metacognitive thinking - Students keep logs and reflect on the experience Pathways to Knowledge Majorie Pappas & Anne Tepe - Non-linear process - continuously explore and reassess at each step - Stresses the importance of questioning authentic learning, reflection and nonlinearity -Tied to constructivist (student centered) learning satisfaction, sometimes disappointment Assessing the Process sense of accomplishment or sense of disappointment Selecting a topic - exploring interests, discussing ideas, browsing resources Finding information generating questions, exploring resources Using information - taking notes, analyzing materials Developing a final product developing communications, sharing experiences Appreciation and Enjoyment -examine the world Presearch - develop an overview; explore relationships Search - identify information providers; select information resources; seek relevant information Interpretation - interpret information Middle and High Information Age Inquiry. (2006e). I-Search. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/isearch.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006f). Pathways to knowledge. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/pathways.htm Library and Literary Miscellany. (2008). Pathways to knowledge. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://laurabaas.com/inform ation-literacy/information- The REACTS Taxonomy Barbara Stripling & Judy Pitts - Different from previous methods because asks students to reflect on each step - Focuses on: - Critical thinking in the research process - High level thinking that results in quality products - Also designed a 10 step research process for developing papers Communication - apply information; share new knowledge Evaluation - evaluate process and product Recall Explain Analyze Challenge Transform Synthesize Ten Step Research Process 1. Choose a broad topic 2. Get an overview of the topic 3. Narrow the topic 4. Develop a thesis or statement of purpose 5. Formulate questions to guide research 6. Plan for research and production 7. Find / Analyze / Evaluate sources 8. Evaluate evidence / Take notes / Compile bibliography 9. Establish conclusions 10. Create and present final product literacy-models/pathwaysto-knowledge/ Middle and High CSU School of Library and Information Science. (1997). Brainstorm and blueprints: Teaching library research as a thinking process. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://witloof.sjsu.edu/courses /250.loertscher/modelstrip.ht ml Information Age Inquiry. (2006g). REACTS. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inqu iry/stripling.htm Research Cycle Super 3 Jamie McKenzie Michael B. Eisenberg and Robert E. Berkowitz - Focuses on questioning - Requires students to make decisions, create answers, and show independent judgment - Students are information producers, not information gatherers - Requires students to revise and rethink research questions throughout the process - Forced to cycle back through model - More skill = a less linear process - Based upon the Big6 - But simplified - Fewer steps are less overwhelming for younger learners Questioning Planning Gathering Sorting & Sifting Synthesizing Evaluating Reporting High Plan Do Review Lower Elementary McKenzie, J. (2000). Research cycle 2000. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.fno.org/dec99/rc ycle.html Information Age Inquiry. (2006h). Research cycle. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/researchcycle.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006i). Big 6 and super 3. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inq uiry/big6.htm The Chosen 3 Models Model School Setting Chosen For AGOPPE Elementary The REACTS Taxonomy Middle Research Cycle High Why This Model Was Chosen - Provides: a methodical sequence for research in all curricular areas A framework with a common language A format that can be used repeatedly; over time it becomes intuitive - Can be used as a linear process when first teaching young students the research process step-by-step Later introduce the idea of using it in a non-linear manor - Steps are concrete and simple enough for young learners to understand and manage - 10 detailed steps walk student through the complex research process Structure helpful for middle school students Can be modified to use for research projects other than papers - Focus on critical thinking high level thinking quality products If only collect facts, produce recall-type work Need to integrate, conclude, and conceptualize so product will be a synthesis of info - Reflection points ask students to evaluate step just completed Revise step until reflection question can be answered This keeps the student on the right track and focused - A more complex model - Non-linear process encourages higher level thinking More skill=less linear - Prepares students for college and real world a more accurate and realistic representation of research process Student produces info NOT consumes info - Emphasis on questioning Have to reassess and rethink the research question throughout the process Leads to cycling through model before reporting Comparing the 3 Models: The Steps Phase AGOPPE Model REACTS Research Cycle Identifying Locating Information Evaluating & Synthesizing Presentation/ Communication of Information & Assessment of Process Ask Questions Gather Information Organize Information Prepare and Produce Present Evaluate, Assess, and Reflect Choose a broad topic Get an overview of the topic Narrow the topic Develop a thesis or statement of purpose Formulate questions to guide research Plan for research and production Find/ analyze/ evaluate sources Questioning Planning Gathering Evaluate evidence/ evaluate sources Establish conclusions Sorting & Sifting Synthesizing Evaluating Create and present the final product Reporting Comparing the 3 Models: Essential Characteristics Commonalities of All 3 Models Involves high level thinking Model AGOPPE Can be used in all curricular areas Over time students will learn to use the models intuitively REACTS Learner centered (constructivist) Include an aspect of ongoing assessment Aligns with VSC and IL standards Research Cycle What Sets These Models Apart? Problem based Emphasis on finding information Non-linear process 6 steps Student is information consumer Students continually assess the information gathered Inquiry based Emphasis on identifying information need Linear process 10 steps designed to help develop a research paper Student is information producer Students reflect after each step Inquiry based Emphasis on questioning Non-linear process 7 steps that are repeatedly cycled through Students is information producer Students rethink and revise research question throughout the process Curriculum Alignment Alignment of Standard 5.0 History of the Maryland Voluntary State Curriculum with AGOPPE Topic 3rd Grade A. Individuals and Societies Change Over Time A. Individuals and Societies Change Over Time 5th Grade B. Emergence, Expansion, and Changes in Nations and Empires Indicator 1. Examine differences between past and present time 2. Investigate how people lived in the past using a variety of primary and secondary sources 1. Analyze the chronology and significance of key historical events during the age of European exploration 2. Analyze the chronology and the significance of key historical events leading to early settlements in Colonial America 2. Analyze the growth and development of colonial America Prepare and Produce Ask Questions Gather Information Organize Information Present Evaluate Topic 8th Grade Indicator 1. Analyze the causes of C. Conflict the American Revolution Between Ideas and 2. Analyze the effects of Institutions the American Revolution 1. Investigate the evolution of the U.S. political system as expressed in the United States Constitution 2. Analyze the impact of historic documents and A. The practices that became the Foundations and foundations of the Function of the American political system Government during the early national period 3. Evaluate roles and policies of the United States government regarding public policy and issues 1. Analyze the influence of B. Individual and individuals and groups on Group shaping public policy Participation in 2. Defend the importance the Political of civic participation as a System citizen of the United States Ask Questions Gather Information Organize Information Prepare and Produce Present Evaluate Topic Indicator C. Protecting Rights and Maintaining Order 1. Examine the impact of governmental decisions on individual rights and responsibilities in the United States 2. Explain how the United States government protected or failed to protect the rights of individuals and groups 3. Examine the principle of due process Ask Questions Gather Information Organize Information Prepare and Produce Present Evaluate Alignment of AGOPPE with Information Power’s Information Literacy Standards Ask Questions Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. o Indicator 1. Recognizes the need for information o Indicator 3. Formulates questions based on information needs Gather Information Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. o Indicator 2. Recognizes that accurate and comprehensive information is the basis for intelligent decision making o Indicator 4. Identifies a variety of potential sources of information o Indicator 5. Develops and uses successful strategies for locating information Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently o Indicator 4. Selects information appropriate to the problem at hand Organize Information Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively o Indicator 1: Organizes information for practical application Prepare and Produce Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively o Indicator 3: Applies information in critical thinking and problem solving Present Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively o Indicator 4: Produces and communicates information and ideas in appropriate formats Standard 9: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. o Indicator 1. Shares knowledge and information with others Evaluate Standard 6: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and strives for excellence in information seeking and knowledge generation o Indicator 1. Assesses the quality of the process and products of personal information seeking o Indicator 2. Devises strategies for revising, improving, and updating self-generated knowledge Aligninment Standard 5.0 History of the Maryland Voluntary State Curriculum with REACTS Topic 3rd Grade A. Individuals and Societies Change Over Time A. Individuals and Societies Change Over Time 5th Grade B. Emergence, Expansion, and Changes in Nations and Empires C. Conflict Between Ideas and Institutions Indicator 1. Examine differences between past and present time 2. Investigate how people lived in the past using a variety of primary and secondary sources 1. Analyze the chronology and significance of key historical events during the age of European exploration 2. Analyze the chronology and the significance of key historical events leading to early settlements in Colonial America 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 2. Analyze the growth and development of colonial America 1. Analyze the causes of the American Revolution 10 8th Grade 2. Analyze the effects of the American Revolution 1. Investigate the evolution of the U.S. political system as expressed in the United States Constitution 2. Analyze the impact of historic documents and A. The practices that became Foundations the foundations of the and Function of American political the Government system during the early national period 3. Evaluate roles and policies of the United States government regarding public policy and issues 1. Analyze the influence of individuals and B. Individual groups on shaping and Group public policy Participation in 2. Defend the the Political importance of civic System participation as a citizen of the United States C. Protecting Rights and Maintaining Order 1. Examine the impact of governmental decisions on individual rights and responsibilities in the United States 2. Explain how the United States government protected or failed to protect the rights of individuals and groups 3. Examine the principle of due process Alignment of REACTS with Information Power’s Information Literacy Standards 1. Choose a broad topic Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. o Indicator 1. Recognizes the need for information 2. Get an overview of the topic Standard 1 o Indicator 1 3. Narrow the topic Standard 1 o Indicator 1 4. Develop a thesis or statement of purpose Standard 1 o Indicator 1 5. Formulate questions to guide research Standard 1 o Indicator 3. Formulates questions based on information needs 6. Plan for research and production Standard 1 o Indicator 4. Identifies a variety of potential sources of information 7. Find / Analyze / Evaluate sources Standard 1 o Indicator 5. Develops and uses successful strategies for locating information Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently o Indicator 1. Determines accuracy, relevance, an comprehensiveness o Indicator 2. Distinguishes among fact, point of view, and opinion o Indicator 3. Identifies inaccurate and misleading information o Indicator 4.Selects information appropriate to the problem or question at hand 8. Evaluate evidence / Take notes / Compile bibliography Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively o Indicator 1. Organizes information for practical application 9. Establish conclusions Standard 3 o Indicator 3. Applies information in critical thinking and problem solving 10. Create and present final product Standard 3 o Indicator 4. Produces and communicates information and ideas in appropriate formats Standard 9: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. o Indicator 1. Shares knowledge and information with others Alignment of Standard 5.0 History of the Maryland Voluntary State Curriculum with the Research Cycle Topic 3rd Grade 5th Grade Indicator 1. Examine differences between past and A. Individuals present time and Societies 2. Investigate Change Over how people lived Time in the past using a variety of primary and secondary sources 1. Analyze the chronology and significance of key historical events during the age of European A. Individuals exploration and Societies 2. Analyze the Change Over chronology and Time the significance of key historical events leading to early settlements in Colonial America Questioning Planning Gathering Sorting and Sifting Synthesizing Evaluating Reporting Topic B. Emergence, Expansion, and Changes in Nations and Empires C. Conflict Between Ideas and Institutions 8th Grade A. The Foundations and Function of the Government Indicator Questioning Planning Gathering Sorting and Sifting Synthesizing Evaluating 2. Analyze the growth and development of colonial America 1. Analyze the causes of the American Revolution 2. Analyze the effects of the American Revolution 1. Investigate the evolution of the U.S. political system as expressed in the United States Constitution Reporting B. Individual and Group Participation in the Political System 2. Analyze the impact of historic documents and practices that became the foundations of the American political system during the early national period 3. Evaluate roles and policies of the United States government regarding public policy and issues 1. Analyze the influence of individuals and groups on shaping public policy 2. Defend the importance of civic participation as a citizen of the United States C. Protecting Rights and Maintaining Order 1. Examine the impact of governmental decisions on individual rights and responsibilities in the United States 2. Explain how the United States government protected or failed to protect the rights of individuals and groups 3. Examine the principle of due process Alignment of the Research Cycle with Information Power’s Information Literacy Standards Questioning Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. o Indicator 1. Recognizes the need for information o Indicator 3. Formulates questions based on information needs Planning Standard 1 o Indicator 3. Formulates questions based on information needs Standard 1 o Indicator 4. Identifies a variety of potential sources of information Gathering Standard 1 o Indicator 2. Recognizes that accurate and comprehensive information is the basis for intelligent decision making o Indicator 4. Identifies a variety of potential sources of information o Indicator 5. Develops and uses successful strategies for locating information Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently o Indicator 4. Selects information appropriate to the problem at hand Sorting & Sifting Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively. o Indicator 1. Organizes information for practical application Synthesizing Standard 3 o Indicator 2. Integrates new information into one’s own knowledge o Indicator 3: Applies information in critical thinking and problem solving Evaluating Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently o Indicator 1. Determines accuracy, relevance, an comprehensiveness o Indicator 2. Distinguishes among fact, point of view, and opinion o Indicator 3. Identifies inaccurate and misleading information o Indicator 4.Selects information appropriate to the problem or question at hand Reporting Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively o Indicator 4: Produces and communicates information and ideas in appropriate formats Standard 9: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. o Indicator 1. Shares knowledge and information with others Scaffolding AGOPPE REACTS Research Cycle Elementary Middle High - Simple, straightforward steps are a good to initially teach the research process As students develop more skill… - The process becomes less linear and students start to reassess info gathered - Students need less support from teachers - Leads to increased metacognition as students become more aware that they are performing these steps - Provides a foundation for later models to build on - Builds on skills learned in AGOPPE - As research topics become more complex, this model walks students through the process - Metacognition: reflection points encourage reevaluation of process and information gathered - Can be used beyond middle school to help write scholarly papers - Students don’t need as much structure now that they understand and appreciate the research process - This model prepares students for college and beyond - Represents the higher level thinking involved in complex research assignments - Metacognition: students are asked to continuously reassess the research question and cycle back through the process Audience Analysis AGOPPE Appropriate for all grade levels (elementary through high school) o Process eventually becomes intuitive Model be adapted to meet needs of diverse learners o Teachers can guide students more or less according to individual needs o Process can lead to different final products depending on student capabilities o Rubrics can be created to cater to different student needs and lessons Can expect varying requirements and detail, scope, number of sources, etc. The REACTS Taxonomy Appropriate to use in high school, college, and beyond Helpful for students that need clear expectations of what is being asked of them Clear, concrete steps help students understand the process that have trouble grasping abstract concepts Depending on the individual need, steps can be modified of taken out entirely of the process o For example, the thought of 10 steps could be overwhelming for some, so the first three steps (1. choose a broad topic 2. get an overview of the topic 3. narrow the topic) could be combined to one step of “selecting a topic” Research Cycle Appropriate for middle school and beyond Best for students who have a high need for cognition (sorting & synthesizing steps) If the model is too complex, it can be used in a more linear fashion to accommodate for those with lower level thinking skills o As the student becomes more skilled, the process becomes more non-linear References American Association of School Librarians & Association for Educational Communications and Technology. (1998). Information Power: Building partnerships for learning. Chicago: American Library Association. CSU School of Library and Information Science. (1997). Brainstorm and blueprints: Teaching library research as a thinking process. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://witloof.sjsu.edu/courses/250.loertscher/modelstrip.html Eisenberg, M. B, & Berkowitz, R. E. (2008). What is the Big6? Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.big6.com/ Florida Department of Education. (2006). Introduction to FINDS; Florida research model. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.sunlink.ucf.edu/finds/intro.html Information Age Inquiry. (2006a). 5As. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/as.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006b). 8Ws of information inquiry. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/ws.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006c). Noodle tools: Building blocks of research. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/noodletools.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006d). Information search process (ISP). Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/ips.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006e). I-Search. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/isearch.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006f). Pathways to knowledge. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/pathways.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006g). REACTS. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/stripling.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006h). Research cycle. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/researchcycle.htm Information Age Inquiry. (2006i). Big 6 and super 3. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://virtualinquiry.com/inquiry/big6.htm Johnson, L., & Lamb, A. (2007). Approaches to information and communication literacy. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://eduscapes.com/tap/topic72.htm Kuhlthau, C. (2008). Carol Collier Kuhlthau. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.scils.rutgers.edu/~kuhlthau/information_search_process.htm Library and Literary Miscellany. (2008). Pathways to knowledge. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://laurabaas.com/information-literacy/information-literacy-models/pathways-to-knowledge/ McKenzie, J. (2000). Research cycle 2000. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.fno.org/dec99/rcycle.html Maryland State Department of Education. (2008). Teaching and learning: Social studies. Retrieved December 14, 2008 from http://mdk12.org/instruction/curriculum/social_studies/index.html Montgomery County Public Schools. (2007). Information literacy: A shared responsibility. The Information Literacy Guide, 25-26. NoodleTools. (2007). Information Literacy. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from http://www.noodletools.com/debbie/literacies/information/1over/infolit1.html Premiere Speakers Bureau. (2008). Ian Jukes Speech Topics. Retrieved from http://premierespeakers.com/ian_jukes/speech_topics Space Coast Media Center. (2008). Implementing FINDS [PowerPoint slides]. Retrieved December 13, 2008 from www.spacecoast.brevardschools.org/media/IMPLEMENTING%20FINDS.ppt