Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] CHAPTER V Interpolation and Regression Topics Interpolation Direct Method; Newton’s Divided Difference; Lagrangian Interpolation; Spline Interpolation. Regression Linear and non-linear. 1. What is interpolation? y f x is, often, given only at discrete points such as x0 , y0 , x1 , y1 ,......, xn1 , yn1 , xn , yn . How does one find the value of y at any other value A function of x? Well, a continuous function f x may be used to represent the n+1 data values with f x passing through the n+1 point. Then we can find the value of y at any other value of x. This is called interpolation. Of course, if x falls outside the range of x for which the data is given, it is no longer interpolation, but instead, is called extrapolation. So what kind of function f x should we choose? A polynomial is a common choice for an interpolating function because polynomials are easy to - Evaluate - Differentiate, and - Integrate as opposed to other choices such as a sine or exponential series. Polynomial interpolation involves finding a polynomial of order ‘n’ that passes through the ‘n+1’ points. One of the methods is called the direct method of interpolation. Other methods include Newton’s divided difference polynomial method and Lagrangian interpolation method. y (x3, y3) (x1, y1) f (x) (x2, y2) x (x0, y0) Interpolation & Regression 60 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] 1.2. Direct Method The direct method of interpolation is based on the following principle. If we have 'n+1' data points, fit a polynomial of order 'n' as given below y a 0 a1 x ............... a n x n (1) through the data, where a0, a1, . . ., an are n+1 real constants. Since n+1 values of y are given at n+1 values of x, one can write n+1 equations. Then the 'n+1' constants, a 0, a1, . . ., an, can be found by solving the n+1 simultaneous linear equations (Ahaaa !!! do you remember previous course !!!). To find the value of y at a given value of x, simply substitute the value of x in the polynomial form. But, it is not necessary to use all the data points. How does one then choose the order of the polynomial and what data points to use? This concept and the direct method of interpolation are best illustrated using an example. 1.2.1. Example The upward velocity of a rocket is given as a function of time in Table 1. Table 1. Velocity as a function of time t [s] v(t) [m/s] 0 0 10 227.04 15 362.78 20 517.35 22.5 602.97 30 901.67 1. Determine the value of the velocity at t=16 s using the direct method and a first order polynomial. 2.. Determine the value of the velocity at t=16 s using direct method and a third order polynomial interpolation using direct method. Interpolation & Regression 61 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] 1000 750 v (t) [s] 500 250 0 0 10 20 30 40 t [s] Figure 5.2. Velocity vs. time data for the rocket example. 1.3. Newton’s divided difference interpolation To illustrate this method, we will start with linear and quadratic interpolation, then, the general form of the Newton’s Divided Difference Polynomial method will be presented. 1.3.1. Linear interpolation ( x0 , y0 ), ( x1 , y1 ), fit a linear interpolant through the data. Note taht y 0 f ( x0 ) and y1 f ( x1 ) , assuming a linear interpolant means: Given f1 ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) Since at and at x x0 : x x1 : f1 ( x0 ) f ( x0 ) b0 b1 ( x0 x0 ) b0 , f1 ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) b0 b1 ( x1 x0 ) f ( x0 ) b1 ( x1 x0 ) Then b1 f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x1 x0 so b0 f ( x0 ) b1 f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x1 x0 And the linear interpolant, f1 ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) Interpolation & Regression 62 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] Becomes: f1 ( x ) f ( x0 ) [Lyes KADEM 2007] f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) ( x x0 ) x1 x0 1.3.2. Quadratic interpolation ( x0 , y0 ), ( x1 , y1 ), and ( x2 , y2 ), fit a quadratic interpolant through the data. Note that y f (x), y 0 f ( x0 ), y1 f ( x1 ), and y2 f ( x2 ), assume the quadratic interpolant f 2 ( x) Given given by f 2 ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) b2 ( x x0 )( x x1 ) At x x0 f ( x0 ) f 2 ( x0 ) b0 b1 ( x0 x0 ) b2 ( x0 x0 )( x0 x1 ) b0 b0 f ( x0 ) At x x1 f ( x1 ) f 2 ( x1 ) b0 b1 ( x1 x0 ) b2 ( x1 x0 )( x1 x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) b1 ( x1 x0 ) then b1 At f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x1 x0 x x2 f ( x2 ) f 2 ( x2 ) b0 b1 ( x2 x0 ) b2 ( x2 x0 )( x2 x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) f ( x 2 ) f ( x0 ) ( x2 x0 ) b2 ( x2 x0 )( x2 x1 ) x1 x0 then f ( x 2 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x 2 x1 x1 x0 b2 x 2 x0 Hence the quadratic interpolant is given by f 2 ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) b2 ( x x0 )( x x1 ) f ( x 2 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x 2 x1 x1 x0 f 2 ( x) f ( x0 ) ( x x0 ) ( x x0 )( x x1 ) x1 x0 x 2 x0 Interpolation & Regression 63 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] Figure 5.4. Quadratic interpolation 1.3.3. General Form of Newton’s Divided Difference Polynomial In the two previous cases, we found how linear and quadratic interpolation is derived by Newton’s Divided Difference polynomial method. Let us analyze the quadratic polynomial interpolant formula f 2 ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) b2 ( x x0 )( x x1 ) where b0 f ( x0 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x1 x0 f ( x 2 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x 2 x1 x1 x0 b2 x 2 x0 Note that b0 , b1 , and b2 are finite divided differences. b0 , b1 , and b2 are first, second, and b1 third finite divided differences, respectively. Denoting first divided difference by f [ x0 ] f ( x0 ) the second divided difference by f [ x1 , x0 ] f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x1 x0 and the third divided difference by f [ x2 , x1 ] f [ x1 , x0 ] x 2 x0 f ( x 2 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x 2 x1 x1 x0 x 2 x0 f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ] Interpolation & Regression 64 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] where [Lyes KADEM 2007] f [ x0 ], f [ x1 , x0 ], and f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ] are called bracketed functions of their variables enclosed in square brackets. We can write: f 2 ( x) f [ x0 ] f [ x1 , x0 ]( x x0 ) f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ]( x x0 )( x x1 ) This leads to the general form of the Newton’s divided difference polynomial for ( n 1) data points, x0 , y0 , x1 , y1 ,......, xn1 , yn1 , xn , yn as f n ( x) b0 b1 ( x x0 ) .... bn ( x x0 )( x x1 )...( x xn1 ) where b0 f [ x0 ] b1 f [ x1 , x0 ] b2 f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ] bn1 f [ xn1 , xn2 ,...., x0 ] bn f [ xn , xn1 ,...., x0 ] where the definition of the m th divided difference is bm f [ xm ,........, x0 ] f [ xm ,........, x1 ] f [ xm1 ,........, x0 ] x m x0 From the above definition, it can be seen that the divided differences are calculated recursively. ( x0 , y0 ), ( x1 , y1 ), ( x2 , y2 ), and ( x3 , y3 ), f 3 ( x) f [ x0 ] f [ x1 , x0 ]( x x0 ) f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ]( x x0 )( x x1 ) For an example of a third order polynomial, given f [ x3 , x 2 , x1 , x0 ]( x x0 )( x x1 )( x x 2 ) b0 x0 f ( x0 ) b1 f [ x1 , x0 ] x1 b2 f [ x2 , x1 , x0 ] f ( x1 ) f [ x2 , x1 ] x2 f [ x3 , x2 , x1 ] f ( x2 ) f [ x3 , x 2 ] x3 f ( x3 ) Interpolation & Regression 65 b3 f [ x3 , x2 , x1 , x0 ] Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] Example Use the same previous data of the upward velocity of a rocket, to determine the value of the velocity at t=16 s using third order polynomial interpolation using Newton’s Divided Difference polynomial. 1.4. Lagrangian Interpolation Polynomial interpolation involves finding a polynomial of order ‘n’ that passes through the ‘n+1’ points. One of the methods to find this polynomial is called Lagrangian Interpolation. Lagrangian interpolating polynomial is given by n f n ( x) Li ( x) f ( xi ) i 0 f n (x) stands for the n th order polynomial that approximates the function y f (x) given at (n 1) data points as x0 , y0 , x1 , y1 ,......, xn1 , y n1 , xn , y n , and where ‘ n ’ in n Li ( x) j 0 j i x xj xi x j Li (x) is a weighting function that includes a product of (n 1) terms with terms of j i omitted. Example Use the same previous data of the upward velocity of a rocket, to determine the value of the velocity at t=16 s using third order polynomial interpolation using third order polynomial interpolation using Lagrangian polynomial interpolation. 1.5. Spline Method of Interpolation Spline method was introduced to solve one of the drawbacks of the polynomial interpolation. In fact, when the order (n) becomes large, in many cases, oscillations appear in the resulting polynomial. This was shown by Runge when he interpolated data based on a simple function of y 1 1 25 x 2 on an interval of [-1, 1]. For example, take six equidistantly spaced points in [-1, 1] and find y at these points as given in Table 1. Interpolation & Regression 66 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] Table 1: Six equidistantly spaced points in [-1, 1] y x 1 1 25 x 2 -1.0 0.038461 -0.6 0.1 -0.2 0.5 0.2 0.5 0.6 0.1 1.0 0.038461 Figure.5.5. 5th order polynomial vs. exact function. Now through these six points, we can pass a fifth order polynomial f 5 ( x) 0.56731 1.7308 x 2 1.2019 x 4 , 1 x 1 through the six data points. When plotting the fifth order polynomial and the original function, you can notice that the two do not match well. So maybe you will consider choosing more points in the interval [-1, 1] to get a better match, but it diverges even more (see figure below). In fact, Runge found that as the order of the polynomial becomes infinite, the polynomial diverges in the interval of –1 < x < 0.726 and 0.726 < x < 1. 2 1 f ( x) f1 n2 x f1 n3 x f1 n1 x 0 1 1 0.5 0 0.5 x Figure.5.6. Higher order polynomial interpolation is a bad idea. Interpolation & Regression 67 1 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] 1.5.1. Linear spline interpolation Given x0 , y0 , x1 , y1 ,......, xn1 , yn1 xn , yn , fit linear splines to the data. This simply involves forming the consecutive data through straight lines. So if the above data is given in an ascending order, the linear splines are given by yi f ( xi ) Figure.5.7. Linear splines. f ( x1 ) f ( x0 ) x0 x x1 ( x x0 ), x1 x0 f ( x2 ) f ( x1 ) f ( x1 ) ( x x1 ), x1 x x2 x2 x1 f ( x) f ( x 0 ) . . . f ( xn1 ) f ( xn ) f ( xn1 ) ( x xn1 ), xn1 x xn xn xn1 Note the terms of f ( xi ) f ( xi 1 ) xi xi 1 in the above function are simply slopes between xi 1 and xi . 1.5.2. Quadratic Splines In these splines, a quadratic polynomial approximates the data between two consecutive data points. The splines are given by Interpolation & Regression 68 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] f ( x) a1 x 2 b1 x c1 , x0 x x1 a 2 x b2 x c2 , x1 x x2 2 . . . a n x 2 bn x c n , xn1 x xn Now, how to find the coefficients of these quadratic splines? There are 3n such coefficients a i , i 1, 2, …, n bi , i 1, 2, …, n ci , i 1, 2, …, n To find ‘3n’ unknowns, we need ‘3n’ equations and then simultaneously solve them. These ‘3n’ equations are found by the following. 1) Each quadratic spline goes through two consecutive data points a1 x0 b1 x0 c1 f ( x0 ) 2 a1 x1 b1 x1 c1 f ( x1 ) 2 . . . ai xi 1 bi xi 1 ci f ( xi 1 ) 2 ai xi bi xi ci f ( xi ) 2 . . . an xn1 bn xn1 cn f ( xn1 ) 2 an xn bn xn cn f ( xn ) 2 This condition gives 2n equations as there are ‘n’ quadratic splines going through two consecutive data points. 2) The first derivatives of two quadratic splines are continuous at the interior points. For example, the derivative of the first spline a1 x 2 b1 x c1 is 2a1 x b1 The derivative of the second spline a2 x 2 b2 x c2 is 2a2 x b2 Interpolation & Regression 69 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] and the two are equal at [Lyes KADEM 2007] x x1 giving 2a1 x1 b1 2a2 x1 b2 2a1 x1 b1 2a2 x1 b2 0 Similarly at the other interior points, 2a2 x2 b2 2a3 x2 b3 0 . . . 2ai xi bi 2ai 1 xi bi 1 0 . . . 2an1 xn1 bn1 2an xn1 bn 0 Since there are (n-1) interior points, we have (n-1) such equations. Now, the total number of equations is (2n) (n 1) (3n 1) equations. We still then need one more equation. We can assume that the first spline is linear, that is: a1 0 This gives us ‘3n’ equations and ‘3n’ unknowns. These can be solved by a number of techniques used to solve simultaneous linear equations. Interpolation & Regression 70 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] 2. Regression 2.2. What is regression? Regression analysis gives information on the relationship between a response variable and one or more independent variables to the extent that information is contained in the data. The goal of regression analysis is to express the response variable as a function of the predictor variables. Duality of fit and accuracy of conclusion depend on the data used. Hence non-representative or improperly compiled data result into poor fits and conclusions. Thus, for effective use of regression analysis one must Investigate the data collection process, Discover any limitations in data collected, Restrict conclusions accordingly. Once regression analysis relationship is obtained, it can be used to predict values of the response variable, identify variables that most affect response, or verify hypothesized casual models of the response. The value of each predictor variable can be assessed through statistical tests on the estimated coefficients (multipliers) of the predictor variables. 2.3. Linear regression Linear regression is the most popular regression model. In this model we wish to predict response to n data points (x1,y1), (x2,y2), ....., (xn, yn) data by a regression model given by y a0 a1 x where a0 and a1 are the constants of the regression model. A measure of goodness of fit, that is, how magnitude of the residual, a0 a1 x predicts the response variable y is the i at each of the n data points. i yi (a0 a1 xi ) Ideally, if all the residuals on the model. coefficients. i are zero, one may have found an equation in which all the points lie Thus, minimization of the residual is an objective of obtaining regression The most popular method to minimize the residual is the least squares method, where the estimates of the constants of the models are chosen such that the sum of the squared residuals n is minimized, that is minimize i 1 2 i . Why minimize the sum of the square of the residuals? Why not, for instance, minimize the sum of the residual errors or the sum of the absolute values of the residuals? Alternatively, constants of the model can be chosen such that the average residual is zero without making individual residuals small. For example, let us analyze the following table. x 2.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 y 4.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 To explain this data by a straight line regression model, Interpolation & Regression 71 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] y a0 a1 x n and using minimizing i 1 as a criteria to find ao and a1, we find that for (Figure 5.8) i Y = 4x -4 10 y =4x - 4 8 y 6 4 2 0 0 1 2 3 4 x Figure.5.8. Regression curve y = 4x – 4 for y vs. x data. 4 The sum of the residuals, i 1 i x 2.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 0 as shown in the table below. y 4.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 ypredicted 4.0 8.0 4.0 8.0 ε = y - ypredicted 0.0 -2.0 2.0 0.0 4 i 1 4 So does this give us the smallest error? It does as i 1 i i 0 0 . But it does not give unique values for the parameters of the model. A straight-line of the model: Y = 6. Interpolation & Regression 72 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] 10 8 y 6 4 2 y=6 0 0 1 2 3 4 x Figure.5.9. Regression curve y = 6 for y vs. x data. 4 also makes i 1 0 as shown in the table below. i x 2.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 y 4.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 ypredicted 6.0 6.0 6.0 6.0 ε = y - ypredicted -2.0 0.0 0.0 2.0 4 i 1 i 0 Since this criterion does not give unique regression model, it cannot be used for finding the regression coefficients. Why? Because, we want to minimize n n y i i 1 i 1 i a0 a1 xi Differentiating this equation with respect to a0 and a1, we get n i i 1 a 0 n 1 n i 1 n i i 1 a1 n _ xi n x i 1 Interpolation & Regression 73 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] Putting these equations to zero, give n= 0 but this is impossible. Therefore, unique values of a0 and a1 do not exist. n You may think that the reason the minimization criterion i 1 i does not work is that negative n residuals cancel with positive residuals. So is minimizing i 1 i criterion may be better? Let us look at the data given below for equation y 4 x 4 . It makes 4 i 1 i 4 as shown in the following table. x 2.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 y 4.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 ypredicted 4.0 8.0 4.0 8.0 |ε| = |y - ypredicted| 0.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 4 i 1 4 The value of i 1 4 data has i 1 4 i 4 also exists for the straight line model y = 6. No other straight line for this i 4 . Again, we find the regression coefficients are not unique, and hence this i criterion also cannot be used for finding the regression model. Let us use the least squares criterion where we minimize n n 2 S r i yi a0 a1 xi i 1 2 i 1 Sr is called the sum of the square of the residuals. Interpolation & Regression 74 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] y xi , y i i yi a0 a1 xi x2 , y 2 xn , y n x3 , y 3 y a0 a1 x x1 , y1 x Figure.5.10. Linear regression of y vs. x data showing residuals at a typical point, xi. To find a0 and a1, we minimize Sr with respect to a0 and a1: n Sr 2 yi a0 a1xi 1 0 a0 i 1 n Sr 2 yi a0 a1xi xi 0 a1 i 1 giving n n i 1 i 1 n yi a0 a1 xi 0 i 1 n n n i 1 i 1 i 1 y i x i a 0 x i a1 x i2 0 n Noting that a i 1 0 a 0 a 0 . . . a 0 na 0 n n na 0 a1 xi y i i 1 i 1 n n n i 1 i 1 i 1 a 0 x i a1 x i2 x i y i Solving the above equations gives: Interpolation & Regression 75 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] n n n i 1 i 1 i 1 [Lyes KADEM 2007] n x i y i x i y i a1 n n x x i i 1 i 1 n 2 2 i n a0 n n n x y x x y 2 i i 1 i i 1 i 1 i i i 1 2 i n n n xi2 xi i 1 i 1 Redefining n _ _ S xy x i y i n x y i 1 _2 n S xx xi2 n x i 1 n _ x x i 1 i n n _ y y i 1 i n we can rewrite a1 S xy S xx _ _ a 0 y a1 x 2.4. Nonlinear models using least squares 2.4.1. Exponential model x1 , y1 , x2 , y2 , . . . xn , yn , we can fit y ae bx to the data. The variables a and b are the constants of the exponential model. The residual at each data point xi is Given Ei yi ae bxi The sum of the square of the residuals is n n i 1 i 1 S r Ei2 yi ae bxi 2 To find the constants a and b of the exponential model, we minimize Sr by differentiating with respect to a and b and equating the resulting equations to zero. Interpolation & Regression 76 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] n S r 2 y i ae bxi e bxi 0 a i 1 n S r 2 y i ae bxi axi e bxi 0 b i 1 or n n i 1 i 1 n y i e bxi a e 2bxi 0 n y i xi e bxi i 1 a xi e 2bxi 0 i 1 These equations are nonlinear in a and b and thus not in a closed form to be solved as was the case for the linear regression. In general, iterative methods must be used to find values of a and b. However, in this case, n a yi e i 1 n e a can be written explicitly in terms of b as bxi 2bxi i 1 Substituting gives n n y i xi e bxi i 1 yi e bxi n 2bx i n1 xi e i 0 2bx e i i 1 i 1 This equation is still a nonlinear equation in bisection method or secant method. b and can be solved by numerical methods such as 2.4.2. Growth model Growth models common in scientific fields have been developed and used successfully for specific situations. The growth models are used to describe how something grows with changes in regressor variable (often the time). Examples in this category include growth of population with time. Growth models include y a 1 be c. x where a, b and c are the constants of the model. At x= 0, y The residuals at each data point, xi are Ei y i a 1 be cxi The sum of the square of the residuals is Interpolation & Regression 77 a and as x , y a . 1b Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] n S r Ei2 i 1 a yi cxi 1 be i 1 n 2 To find the constants a, b and c we minimize Sr by differentiating with respect to equating the resulting equations to zero. n 2e cxi ae c xi yi e cxi b S r 2 a i 1 e cxi b S r b S r c a , b and c, and 0 , cx cx n 2ae i byi e i y i a 0, 3 i 1 e cxi b cxi cxi n 2abxi e byi e y i a 0. 3 i 1 e cxi b Then , it is possible to use the Newton-Raphson method to solve the above set of simultaneous nonlinear equations for a, b and c. 2.4.3. Polynomial Models Given n data points (x1, y1), (x2, y2). . , (xn, yn) use least squares method to regress the data to an mth order polynomial. y a0 a1 x a 2 x 2 a m x m , m n The residual at each data point is given by Ei y i a 0 a1 xi . . . a m xim The sum of the square of the residuals is given by n S r Ei2 i 1 n y i a 0 a1 xi . . . a m xim 2 i 1 To find the constants of the polynomial regression model, we put the derivatives with respect to ai to zero, that is, Interpolation & Regression 78 Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] n S r 2. y i a 0 a1 xi . . . a m xim (1) 0 a 0 i 1 n S r 2. y i a 0 a1 xi . . . a m xim ( xi ) 0 a1 i 1 . . . . n S r 2. y i a 0 a1 xi . . . a m xim ( xim ) 0 a m i 1 Writing these equations in matrix form gives n n xi i 1 . . . n m xi i 1 xi i 1 n 2 xi i 1 . . . n . . . . . . n m1 xi . . i 1 n m . xi a i 1 0 n m1 a1 . xi i 1 . . . . . a m n 2m . xi i 1 n yi ni 1 xi yi . i 1 . . . n xim yi i 1 The above system is solved for a0, a1,. . ., am 2.4.4. Logarithmic Functions The form for the log regression models is y 0 1 ln x ln x and the usual least squares method applies in which y is the response variable and ln x is the regressor. This is a linear function between y and 2.4.5. Power Functions The power function equation describes many scientific and engineering phenomena: y ax b The method of least squares is applied to the power function by first linearizing the data (assumption is that b is not known). If the only unknown is a, then a linear relation exists between xb and y . The linearization of the data is as follows: ln y ln a b ln x The resulting equation shows a linear relation between Interpolation & Regression 79 ln y and ln x . Numerical Methods for Eng [ENGR 391] [Lyes KADEM 2007] We can put z ln y w ln( x) a0 ln a then a e ao a1 b we get z a0 a1 w n a1 n n n wi z i wi z i i 1 i 1 i 1 n w wi i 1 i 1 n n 2 2 i n a0 zi i 1 n n a1 w i 1 i n Since a0 and a1 can be found, the original constants of the model are b a1 a e a0 Interpolation & Regression 80