A Cohort Observational Study Evaluating The Incidence And

advertisement
A Cohort Observational Study Evaluating Predictors, Incidence And
Immunopathogenesis Of Immune Reconstitution Syndrome (IRIS)
In HIV-1 Infected Patients With CD4 Count <100 Cells/µL Who Are Initiating
Antiretroviral Therapy
NIH Principal Investigator/Protocol Chair:
Irini Sereti, M.D., M.H.S.
KEMRI/WRP Principal Investigator/ Protocol Co-Chair: Frederick Sawe, MBChB, MMED
USAMRU-K Principal Investigator/ Protocol Co-Chair: Douglas Shaffer, M.D., M.H.S.
South East Asia Research Collaboration with Hawaii (SEARCH)
Thai Red Cross AIDS Research Centre Principal Investigator/ Protocol Co-Chair:
Jintanat Ananworanich, MD, PhD
Accountable Investigator:
Lead Associate Investigator:
Irini Sereti, M.D., M.H.S.
Virginia Sheikh, M.D.
Associate Investigators:
JoAnn Mican, M.D.
Alice Pau, Pharm. D.
Stephen Migueles, M.D.
Margo Smith, M.D.
Eunice Obiero, MBChB, MMED
Samoel Khamadi, PhD
Kibet Shikuku, MBChB, MMED
Nittaya Phanuphak, MD
Wisit Prasithsirikul, MD
Somsit Tansuphaswadikul, MD
Alex Schuetz, PhD
Nipat Teeratakulpisarm, MD
Thep Chalermchai
Study Statistician
Dean Follmann, Ph.D.
Study Coordinators
Gregg Roby, R.N.
Alexander Ober, R.N.
Hellen Ngeno, B.S.N.
Z#AI001121-01
Version 5.2
Initial IRB submission 11/7/2005
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
1
RESEARCH FACILITIES WHERE THE CLINICAL INVESTIGATION WILL BE CONDUCTED
National Institutes of Health, Clinical Center
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases- HIV Clinic
Building 10, 8th floor clinic (OP-8) and CRC-5SE North NIAID Ward
10 Center Drive
Bethesda, MD 20892
(FWA00005897)
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical Research Center
Hospital Road
PO Box 1357-20200
Kericho, Kenya
(FWA00002066)
South East Asia Research Collaboration with Hawaii (SEARCH)
The Thai Red Cross AIDS Research Centre (TRCARC)
104 Rajdumri Road
Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
(FWA00008378)
Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute
126 Tiwanon Road, Muang
Nonthaburi 11000, Thailand
(FWA00008374)
CLINICAL LABORATORY FACILITIES TO BE USED IN THE CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
1) Department of Laboratory Medicine
Dr. Thomas Fleisher, Chief
Building 10- Room 2C306
National Institutes of Health
Bethesda, MD 20892
2) NCI- Frederick Cancer Research & Development Center
Fort Detrick
Dr. Michael Baseler- Head Clinical Services Program
Boyles Street, Building 1050
Frederick, MD 21702-1201
3) Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical
Research Center Laboratory
Dr. Kibet Shikuku, Deputy Director
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
2
Hospital Road
PO Box 1357-20200
Kericho, Kenya
4) Kericho District Hospital Laboratory
Lilly Kirui, H. Dip., Director
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200
Kenya
5) Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project Basic Sciences
Laboratory
John Waitumbi, PhD, Director
PO Box 54-40100
Kisumu-Kakamega Road
Kisumu, Kenya
6) Central Reference Tuberculosis Laboratory
National Leprosy and Tuberculosis Program
Joseph Sitenei, MBChB, Director
P.O. Box 20781
Nairobi, Kenya
7) The Thai Red Cross AIDS Research Centre (TRC-ARC)
104 Rajdumri Road
Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
8) Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute (BIDI)
Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute
126 Tiwanon Road, Muang
Nonthaburi 11000, Thailand
9) Armed Forces Research Institute of Medical Sciences (AFRIMS)
U.S. Army Medical Component
Department of Retrovirology
315/6 Rajvithi Road, Bangkok 10400, Thailand
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................... 6
1. SCHEMA/PRECIS........................................................................................................ 9
2. HYPOTHESIS AND STUDY OBJECTIVES .......................................................... 10
2.1 Primary Hypothesis ...................................................................................................................... 10
2.2 Primary Objective ........................................................................................................................ 10
2.3 Secondary Objectives ................................................................................................................... 10
3. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 10
3.1 Background and Study Rationale ................................................................................................. 10
3.2 What is Immune Reconstitution Syndrome (IRIS)? ...................................................................... 11
3.3 Immunopathogenesis of IRIS ........................................................................................................ 12
3.4 Importance of IRIS Studies ........................................................................................................... 14
4. STUDY DESIGN ......................................................................................................... 14
5. SELECTION AND ENROLLMENT OF PATIENTS ............................................ 14
5.1 Inclusion Criteria ......................................................................................................................... 14
5.2 Exclusion Criteria ........................................................................................................................ 16
5.3 Study Enrollment Procedures ....................................................................................................... 16
5.4 Co-enrollment Guidelines ............................................................................................................ 16
6. STUDY TREATMENT............................................................................................... 16
6.1 Anti-retroviral Therapy ................................................................................................................ 16
6.2 Prophylaxis for Opportunistic Infections ..................................................................................... 16
6.3 Treatment of Opportunistic Infections or AIDS-associated Illnesses........................................... 16
6.4 Clinical Manifestations of IRIS Episodes ..................................................................................... 17
7. CLINICAL AND LABORATORY EVALUATIONS ............................................. 18
7.1 Schedule of Events (US) ............................................................................................................... 18
7.2 Definitions for Schedule of Events- timing of Evaluations ........................................................... 20
7.3 Special Instructions and Definitions of Evaluations .................................................................... 24
8. CRITERIA FOR IRIS END POINTS ....................................................................... 28
9. CRITERIA FOR STUDY DISCONTINUATION ................................................... 29
10. STATISTICAL CONSIDERATIONS..................................................................... 29
10.1 General Design-Statistical Considerations ................................................................................ 29
10.2 Secondary Analyses .................................................................................................................... 31
10.3 Interim Analyses ........................................................................................................................ 31
11. DATA COLLECTION AND MONITORING AND ADVERSE EVENT EXPERIENCE
REPORTING ................................................................................................................... 31
11.1 Definitions .................................................................................................................................. 32
11.2 Serious Adverse Event (SAE) Reporting..................................................................................... 33
12. HUMAN SUBJECTS ................................................................................................ 34
12.1 Institutional Review Board (IRB) Review and Informed Consent .............................................. 35
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
4
12.2 Subject Confidentiality ............................................................................................................... 35
12.3 Minority Recruitment (US) ......................................................................................................... 35
12.4 Inclusion of Children and Pregnant Women .............................................................................. 36
12.5 Risks and Benefits Associated with Study Participation ............................................................ 36
12.6 Study Discontinuation ................................................................................................................ 37
12.7 Remuneration ............................................................................................................................. 37
12.8 Illiterate and Foreign-speaking Subjects (US site) .................................................................... 37
13. DATA MANAGEMENT AND RECORD RETENTION ..................................... 37
13.1 Data Management Plan.............................................................................................................. 37
13.2 Record Retention ........................................................................................................................ 38
14. PUBLICATION OF RESEARCH FINDINGS ...................................................... 38
15. BIOHAZARD CONTAINMENT ............................................................................ 38
15. REFERENCES .......................................................................................................... 40
16. APPENDIX A: IRIS CRITERIA* ........................................................................... 43
17. APPENDIX B- DAIDS TOXICITY TABLE .......................................................... 44
18. APPENDIX C- PROTOCOL RELATED RESEARCH USE OF STORED HUMAN SAMPLES,
SPECIMENS AND DATA.............................................................................................. 62
19. APPENDIX D-KERICHO SITE SPECIFIC APPENDIX .................................... 63
20. APPENDIX E-THAILAND SITE SPECIFIC APPENDIX………………………….87
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
5
ABBREVIATIONS
Abbreviation
Text
AB
AE
Ag
ACTG
AFB
AIDS
ALT (SGPT)
ANC
ART
ARV
AST (SGOT)
AZT
BMI
BP
BU
BWs
CAP
CBC
CDC
CLADE
CLIA
CMV
CNS
CRAg
CRC
CRIMSON
CRP
CSF
CSWs
CT
CXR
DAIDS
DIR
DOD
DTH
EBV
ELISA
ESR
FDA
GALT
GCP
GI
Abstinence/Be Faithful
adverse event
antigen
AIDS Clinical Trial Group
Acid Fast Bacilli
acquired immunodeficiency syndrome
alanine transaminase
absolute neutrophil count
antiretroviral therapy
antiretroviral
aspartate transaminase
zidovudine
body mass index
blood pressure
Boston University
barworkers
College of American Pathologists
complete blood count
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Clinic-based ART & Diagnostic Evaluation
Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments
cytomegalovirus
central nervous system
Cryptococcus antigen
Clinical Research Center
Clinical Research Information Management System
C-reactive protein
cerebrospinal fluid
commercial sex workers
computed tomography
chest x-ray
Division of AIDS
Division of Intramural Research
Department of Defence
delayed-type hypersensitivity
Epstein-Barr Virus
enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay
erythrocyte sedimentation rate
Food and Drug Administration
gut-associated lymphocyte tissue
Guidelines for Good Clinical Practices
gastrointestinal
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
6
Abbreviation
Text
HAART
HepBcAb
HepBsAb
HBsAg
HCV
HeAb
HeAg
β-hCG
HDL
HEENT
Hg
HIV
HVTN
IAVI
ICH
IDCRP
IFN
IRB
IRD
IRIS
KDH
KEMRI
LDH
LDL
LLN
LN
MAC
MAI
MCV
MDR
MOH
MVA
NIAID
NIH
NRTI
NNRTI
NSAID
O-GAC
OI
OVC
PAVE
PBMC
PCP
highly active anti-retroviral therapy
antibody to hepatitis B core antigen
antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen
hepatitis B surface antigen
hepatitis C virus
antibody to hepatitis E antigen
hepatitis E antigen
beta-human chorionic gonadotropin
high density lipoprotein
head, eyes, ears, nose, and throat
hemoglobin
human immunodeficiency virus
HIV Vaccine Trials Network
International AIDS Vaccine Initiative
International Conference on Harmonization
Infectious Diseases Clinical Research Program
interferons
institutional review board
immune restoration disease
immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome
Kericho District Hospital
Kenya Medical Research Institute
lactate dehydrogenase
low density lipoprotein
lower limit of normal
Lymph node
Mycobacterium avium complex
Mycobacterium avium intracellulare
mean corpuscular volume
multi-drug resistant
Ministry of Health
Modified Vaccinia Ankara
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases
National Institutes of Health
nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor
non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug
Office of the Global Aids Coordinator
opportunistic infection
Orphans and Vulnerable Children
Partnership for AIDS Vaccine Evaluation
peripheral mononuclear cells
Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
7
Abbreviation
Text
PCR
PD-1
PDCs
PEPFAR
PHE
PI
PLT
PMD
PML
PMTCT
PPD
PT
PTT
RBC
RCHSPB
RNA
RPR
RSC
SAE
STIAs
T4
TB (MTB)
TCR
TDs
TG
Th
Treg
TSH
ULN
USAMRU-K
USMHRP
USUHS
WBC
WHO
Wk
WRAIR
WRP
VCT
VZV
ZN
polymerase chain reaction
programmed death-1
plasmacytoid dendritic cells
President’s Emergency Plan For AIDS Relief
Public Health Evaluation
protease inhibitor
platelet count
Primary medical doctor
progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy
Prevention of Mother To Child Transmission
purified protein derivative
prothrombin time
partial thromboplastin time
red blood cells
Regulatory Compliance and Human Subjects Protection Branch
ribonucleic acid
rapid plasma reagin
Radiation Safety Committee
Serious Adverse Event
sexually transmitted infection clinic attendees
thyroxine
tuberculosis (mycobacterial tuberculosis)
T-cell receptor
truck drivers
triglycerides
Helper T cells
regulatory T cells
Thyrotropin, thyroid-stimulating hormone
Upper limit of normal
United States Army Medical Research Unit-Kenya
United States Military HIV Research Program
Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences
white blood cell count
World Health Organization
week
Walter Reed Army Institute of Research
Walter Reed Project
Voluntary Counseling and Testing
Varicella zoster virus
Ziehl-Neelsen
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
8
1. SCHEMA/PRECIS
A cohort observational study evaluating the predictors, incidence, clinical presentation and
immunopathogenesis of Immune ReconstItution Syndrome (IRIS) in human immunodeficiency virus
(HIV-1) infected patients with CD4 Count <100 cells/µL who are initiating antiretroviral therapy.
Immune reconstitution syndrome (IRIS) is a clinical syndrome that has been described in HIV-infected
patients after initiation of highly active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART), and is characterized by
paradoxical acute worsening of an underlying opportunistic infection or AIDS-defining illness. There is no
widely accepted syndromic definition, the pathogenesis of the syndrome is unclear and there is no specific
therapy. The syndrome is more common in patients with low CD4+ T cell counts (<50 cells/µl) and in
those with certain underlying infections (e.g. mycobacterial or cryptococcal infection) and is typically
observed when there is evidence of response to HAART and while patients are still at risk for other
opportunistic infections (OIs) or AIDS defining illnesses (e.g. pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia or
cytomegalovirus [CMV] retinitis). The incidence of IRIS varies depending on the studied population and is
very frequent in developing countries creating significant diagnostic and therapeutic challenges as well as
utilization of limited health resources.
DESIGN
International observational cohort study. Participants will be evaluated at baseline
and followed according to the protocol follow up schedule after initiation of
antiretroviral therapy for a total of two years. Acute symptoms that may be
representing manifestations of IRIS will also be evaluated at additional acute care
visits if necessary.
DURATION
Enrollment is expected to take 2 years. Each volunteer will be followed for two
years with an optional 2-year extension for US participants only. Total duration of
the study will be approximately 8 years (including the optional extension phase in
US).
SAMPLE SIZE
Approximately 500 patients will be enrolled over a 2- year period 200 in Kenya, 100
in Thailand and approximately 200 in US.(enrollment in US will continue
approximately until the other sites are full). Based on the incidence of IRIS in
patients with low CD4 counts (approximately 20-40%), we anticipate strong power
(~90%) to identify baseline factors predictive of IRIS.
POPULATION
HIV-1-infected men and women, age >18 years, antiretroviral therapy (ART)-naïve
with CD4+ T cell counts <100 cells/mm3. Participants will be recruited and followed
at three sites: the broader Washington DC, Kericho, Kenya and Bangkok, Thailand
areas.
REGIMEN
Participants will be initiated on ART according to the clinical standard of care. If an
OI or other AIDS defining illness is identified prior to or during screening or at any
point during the study, they will also be treated according to standard of care.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
9
2. HYPOTHESIS AND STUDY OBJECTIVES
2.1 PRIMARY HYPOTHESIS
Baseline predictors exist [e.g. CD4 count, presence of OIs, hemoglobin level, body mass index (BMI), and
immunologic parameters] in persons with advanced HIV infection (CD4 <100 cells/mm3) starting highly
active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) that significantly increase the risk of developing immune
reconstitution syndrome (IRIS).
2.2 PRIMARY OBJECTIVE
 To identify baseline predictors of IRIS within 6 months of HAART initiation prospectively in a
group of HIV-1 infected patients with advanced disease who are starting antiretroviral therapy.
 To evaluate the immunopathogenesis of IRIS with the goal to identify more appropriate targets for
future therapeutic interventions.
2.3 SECONDARY OBJECTIVES
1. To evaluate the impact of IRIS on the risk of subsequent death (attributable mortality).
2. To study the incidence and clinical manifestations of IRIS prospectively in a group of HIV-1
infected patients with advanced disease who are initiating antiretroviral therapy.
3. Evaluate the baseline clinical and immunological characteristics of individuals who develop IRIS
and compare them with those who do not.
4. Evaluate the incidence of pre-existing asymptomatic diseases (e.g. cryptococcus) that may lead
to unmasking IRIS.
5. Evaluate the possibility that risk factors for IRIS differ by geographical site (US versus Africa
versus Thailand) evaluating statistically risk factors by site interaction.
6. Evaluate IRIS immunopathogenesis with prospective follow up of lymphocyte subsets including
regulatory T cells (Treg), evaluation of pathogen specific responses (depending on the infectious
agent that gets diagnosed), measurement of markers of inflammation and T-cell turnover and
evaluation of T-cell repertoire and innate immune responses.
7. To help establish an improved definition of IRIS by describing systematically its clinical
presentations, identifying risk factors and understanding its immunopathogenesis.
8. Compare IRIS incidence in participants with CD4+ T cell counts <50 cells/µL versus those with
CD4+ T cell counts between 50-100 cells/µL at baseline (pre-HAART).
9. Evaluate prospectively the immune reconstitution of patients who eventually develop IRIS versus
those who do not.
10. Evaluate prospectively the role of gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) depletion and
reconstitution and its potential association with health and disease in a subset of participants (US
and Thailand sites only).
11. Evaluate the impact of HAART on cytomegalovirus (CMV) and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)
viremia in patients with advanced HIV infection (US site only).
3. INTRODUCTION
3.1 BACKGROUND AND STUDY RATIONALE
Immune reconstitution syndrome (IRIS) is a term used to encompass clinical presentations of
paradoxical worsening of infectious or non-infectious diseases in patients with HIV infection after
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
10
initiation of potent antiretroviral therapy (ART). The exact etiology of IRIS is unclear but the
pathogenesis seems to include an excessive inflammatory response rather than increased susceptibility
to opportunistic pathogens. The lack of understanding of the immunopathogenesis of IRIS significantly
impairs rational design of preventive or therapeutic strategies. IRIS’s clinical presentations and possible
pathogenesis have been reviewed extensively but have not been studied prospectively in an extensive or
systematic way [1-6].
Preliminary evidence suggests that the impact of IRIS, regarding morbidity and even mortality, will be
much higher on HIV-infected patients in developing countries, as anti-retroviral therapy is becoming
more widely available and is typically initiated at a very low CD4+ T cell count with more frequent coexistence of clinically evident or subclinical opportunistic infections such as tuberculosis (TB) [7-11].
3.2 WHAT IS IMMUNE RECONSTITUTION SYNDROME (IRIS)?
Immune reconstitution syndrome or immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome (IRIS) or immune
restoration disease (IRD) was initially described after the introduction of zidovudine (AZT)
monotherapy when some treated patients presented with intense inflammatory lymphadenopathy
secondary to Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC) [12-14]. The phenomenon became more prevalent
after the introduction of combination ART and has now been described in association with several
opportunistic infections, tumors, and auto-immune phenomena [15-24]. Most cases are seen in
association with mycobacterial disease (both tuberculosis and atypical mycobacterial infections) [9, 25],
cryptococcal disease [26], CMV infection, Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia (PCP), chronic hepatitis
B or C but also progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML), Kaposi’s sarcoma, and less
commonly encountered conditions such as Leishmaniasis, Bartonellosis, sarcoidosis, or Grave’s disease
[1].
Similar inflammatory or paradoxical worsening of clinical condition has been described in a smaller
proportion of HIV-seronegative patients treated for tuberculosis [27, 28], in patients with recovering
neutrophils, or in patients that are in steroid-tapering phase of therapy for other diseases.
Most of the evidence regarding IRIS comes from observational retrospective studies and case series,
and as of to date there is no specific definition, but certain characteristics are consistent and generally
accepted as specific for IRIS such as:
1) An intense inflammatory response (clinically and histologically) despite the absence or scant
presence of live organisms in histologic specimens, and the lack of pathogen isolation from the
bloodstream (in the setting of IRIS associated with an OI).
2) A paradoxical response, i.e., worsening of clinical or radiologic parameters despite successful
antimicrobial therapy. This phenomenon is not exclusive to HIV infection and is described in 23% of HIV-seronegative patients who are being treated for tuberculosis.
3) A higher frequency in patients with HIV infection and low CD4+ T cell counts (<50 cells/µL),
which could be related to higher microbial antigen load or more significant immune
dysregulation.
4) An association with virologic response to ART.
5) Typical occurrence within the first few months of initiation of ART with some notable
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
11
exceptions (i.e. Grave’s disease which typically occurs 1-2 years later).
6) Clinical and microbiologic presentation of infectious diseases that is distinct from the new
presentation of an opportunistic infection (for example negative blood cultures in patients with
MAC despite fever and lymphadenopathy; negative cryptococcal blood culture despite presence
of cryptococcal antigenemia; uveitis instead of retinitis with CMV infection).
7) Despite significant morbidity, there is overall low mortality associated with IRIS, and response
is usually observed with either no specific therapy or a combination of medical (nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs [NSAIDS] or steroids) with or without mechanical (drainage of lymph
node [LN]) measures, typically without discontinuation of ART.
8) The term “unmasking” is frequently used to designate unusual or exuberant presentations of OI
or infections or tumors that were not present pre-HAART but occurred soon after antiretroviral
therapy (ARV) introduction. These are thought to represent either pre-existing occult infections
that were asymptomatic due to the immune suppression of HIV and are being unmasked by an
awakened immune system or true new infections that are generating a dysregulated immune
response.
Although some attempts have been made for a more detailed specific definition, as in [1, 2] and
Appendix A, recognition of IRIS remains a clinical judgment decision.
3.3 IMMUNOPATHOGENESIS OF IRIS
The etiology and pathogenesis of IRIS are unclear, but the syndrome is thought to be a manifestation of the
emergence of pathogen-specific immune responses, as suggested by some studies, possibly in the absence
of adequate recovery of regulatory mechanisms and overall imbalance of immune responses after
suppression of HIV viral load and decrease in generalized immune activation.
In some patients, delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses may convert from non-reactive to reactive
at the same time as IRIS presentations, and in others a pathogen-specific immune response (as measured by
cytokine production) may be observed that was not detected prior to ART [13, 29-32]. Although these
findings have not been consistent, it is possible that each disease, that can be associated with IRIS, may
have certain unique immunopathogenesis features.
Serum markers of inflammation such as IL-6 and TNF-α have been described to be elevated in patients
with IRIS and mycobacterial disease, despite overall decreases in other markers of immune activation [3335]. Finally, certain genetic markers may be related and predispose to the development of IRIS [36, 37].
Although the pathogenesis of IRIS remains elusive, certain parameters, specifically presence of a foreign
antigen (Ag) and low CD4 counts and possible genetic factors, have been suggested based on existing data
from retrospective studies [1].
It is thought that IRIS is an exuberant Th1 response in the absence of appropriate or adequate regulatory
mechanisms. There is evidence of increased Th1 responses from one study in TB-IRIS [38], but the role of
inadequate Th2 response, inadequate Treg control, or the possible contribution of Th17 responses or
dendritic cells have not been investigated. Investigating further the hypothesis of an exuberant Th1
response, the immunologic work up of this study will focus on describing the course of T cell activation as
measured by Ki67, programmed death-1 (PD-1), and HLAD-DR with CD38 co-expression, memory and
naïve subset recovery post-HAART, and presence of Tregs before, during and after an IRIS episode. We
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
12
will compare this course of T cell activation with that observed in control patients who do not develop IRIS
and have or do not have similar baseline characteristics including type of OI, baseline CD4 count, and
virologic response to therapy.
The role of recovering plasmacytoid dendritic cells (PDCs) with production of type I interferons (IFNs)
will also be investigated. Ag-specific responses will focus on examination of the multi-functional aspect of
responding T cells with respect to production of cytokines, perforin and granzyme B. We will compare
HIV-specific responses to the responses against the underlying pathogen in patients with infections based
upon Ag availability. Our hypothesis is that IRIS is associated with intense Th1 (and/or Th17) responses in
the absence of appropriate regulatory control (i.e. lack of IL-10, lack of functional Treg, perhaps with a
recovery of DC function in the right genetic host background). An expansion of effector CD4 T cells (as
opposed to central memory or naïve) may be associated with IRIS and T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire
analyses will attempt to also look at possible skewing. The possibility that abrupt reversion of PD-1+ status
of either CD4 or CD8 T cells leading to reversal of functional exhaustion (and thus exuberant Ag-specific
responses) will also be investigated. It is hypothesized that the cytokine environment during IRIS (which
has not been reported to date) will be that of inflammatory cytokines. Finally, the study of markers like Creactive protein (CRP) will also be conducted particularly with respect to their potential predictive value of
impending IRIS either pre-HAART or soon after virologic suppression but before the IRIS events become
fully symptomatic.
Since the manifestations of IRIS suggest an intense inflammatory response in the presence of significant
antigenic burden, most cases have been treated with continuation of the pathogen-specific therapy, with or
without the addition of anti-inflammatory medications (non-steroid or steroid) [27, 39], and occasionally
(mostly in the presence of severe neurologic complications), with temporary discontinuation of ART. The
higher incidence of IRIS observed in retrospective studies of patients who started ARV and OI therapy
almost simultaneously [40] suggests that a decrease of the microbial burden for 4-8 weeks prior to the
initiation of HAART may decrease the incidence of IRIS but at the possible risk of emergence of a new OI
in those patients with CD4+ T cell count <100 cells/µL [41, 42]. There are no randomized, controlled
studies to date addressing the timing of OI therapy in relation to ART.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
13
3.4 IMPORTANCE OF IRIS STUDIES
Despite the early description, the high incidence, and the occasional dramatic clinical presentation of IRIS,
few prospective studies have been done to date and there is still lack of a concrete definition and
understanding of its pathogenesis in an era of significant advances in immunologic research and study of
Ag-specific immune responses.
IRIS is becoming prevalent in the developing world, where ARV therapy is becoming available for patients
with advanced disease (<200 cells/µL with the median usually ~100 cells/µL). The high frequency of IRIS
is thus related to the more advanced stage of disease and also probably to the much higher prevalence of
TB co-infection which is frequently associated with IRIS. The IRIS presentation can pose significant
diagnostic and therapeutic problems in a population with high incidence of other opportunistic infections,
multi-drug resistant (MDR) TB, and limited health care resources. Identification of predictors of high risk
patients are important for clinical purposes but attempts to develop a predictive model based on
retrospective data have failed and are flawed because they’re based on small number of IRIS episodes from
a single center or clinic generating data that are not generalizable [43, 44].A better definition of IRIS is
needed, and the pathogenesis needs to be studied, so that better targets for therapy can be identified and
prevention in high-risk populations can be planned.
4. STUDY DESIGN
This is an international, observational cohort study of ART-naïve patients with CD4+ T cell counts
<100 cells/µL. Participants will be followed at protocol-specified intervals that approximate local standards
of care and treatment for a duration of up to 2 years, with additional unscheduled visits when acute
symptoms develop that could be representing manifestations of IRIS, a new OI or AIDS-defining or associated illness. By having US, Kenyan and Thailand-based enrollment, the resulting cohort will have
more generalizable data.
5. SELECTION AND ENROLLMENT OF PATIENTS
5.1 INCLUSION CRITERIA
1.
For the National Institutes of Health (NIH)/US site: HIV-1 infection, as
documented by OraQuick rapid test using venipuncture whole blood, or
fingerstick whole blood done at screening; or by reactive enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and Western Blot as determined by NIH
Clinical Pathology Laboratory or SAIC-Frederick Inc Monitoring
Laboratory. HIV infection as determined by an outside Clinical
Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA)-approved laboratory
facility will be accepted for enrollment and verified by a standard HIV-1
ELISA with Western Blot at NIH
For the Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical
Research Center (KEMRI/WRP CRC)/Kenya site: HIV-1 infection will
initially be diagnosed based upon two, serial rapid HIV tests according
to Kenya Ministry of Health (MOH) guidelines. Volunteers entering
this study will have HIV infection reconfirmed by two serial rapid HIV
test in accordance with Kenya MOH guidelines and testing algorithm
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
14
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
followed by a confirmation with a Western Blot using FDA approved
kits. Samples from participants with discrepant results (between the
results from other institution and KEMRI/WRP-CRC laboratory) and/or
indeterminate/negative Western Blot will be subjected to a nucleic acid
assay i.e. DNA or RNA PCR. For Thailand, HIV-1 screening and
confirmatory testing will be based on 3, serial rapid HIV tests according
to the Thai Ministry of Public Health guidelines. The subjects will
initially be tested with an ELISA method that detects both HIV antigen
and antibody. Confirmatory testing of HIV reactive samples by two
different antibody detection methods will follow. Positive results by all
three methods confirm HIV diagnosis. Discrepancy between the tests
will require a nucleic acid detection method to confirm HIV diagnosis.
No previous treatment with potent combination anti-retroviral therapy
(ART), defined as any protease inhibitor (PI)-based or non-nucleoside
reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI)-based regimen, or even triple
nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTI)-based regimen,
consisting of at least three antiretroviral drugs (including a boosted PI
with NNRTI combination). Patients with limited use of ART (less than
12 weeks duration) more than 24 weeks before screening will be eligible
for study participation.
Screening CD4+ cell count ≤100 cells/mm3 *.
Residence within the wider Washington D.C. area (approximately
within a 120-mile radius from the NIH Bethesda campus) for the
National Institutes of Health/US site and residents of the Kericho
District Hospital catchment area, an approximate 93-mile (150
kilometers) radius, for the KEMRI/WRP CRC/Kenya site. Residence
within the Bangkok Metropolitan area and nearby provinces are allowed
to participate (approximately 120-mile radius from each of the clinical
site)
Men and women age 18 years.
Ability and willingness of subject or legal guardian/representative to
understand study requirements and give informed consent.
Be willing to allow storage of blood or tissue samples for future research
(For Thailand: storage of blood or tissue samples is an optional
procedure and therefore not an inclusion criteria)
Be willing to have HLA testing (For Thailand: HLA testing is an
optional procedure and therefore not an inclusion criteria)
For the NIH/US site: Participants must have primary care physician or
will need to agree to find one during the first 24 weeks on study.
For the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya site: Participants must be enrolled in the
Kericho District Hospital HIV Clinic. For the two Thailand clinical
sites: participants must be enrolled in the HIV clinic at either of the
sites.
*CD4 <100 cells/µL from an outside or the site’s laboratory within 8 weeks prior to
screening can be accepted as the screening value
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
15
5.2 EXCLUSION CRITERIA
1.
2.
Active drug or alcohol use or dependence that, in the opinion of the
investigator, would interfere with adherence to study requirements.
Pregnancy will be an exclusion criterion for study entry given the intense nature
of the protocol regarding blood draws, diagnostic testing, and follow- up
5.3 STUDY ENROLLMENT PROCEDURES
Prior to implementation of this protocol, the protocol and consent form will need to be approved by the
NIAID institutional review board (IRB) and the IRB of potentially collaborating institutions. In addition,
the protocol and consent form will be approved by the Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI) and the
Uniformed Services University IRB. In Thailand, the protocol and consent forms will be approved by the
Department of Disease Control (DDC) at the Ministry of Public Health and the Chulalongkorn University
IRBs.
Once an eligible candidate for study entry has been identified, details will be carefully discussed with the
subject. The subject will be asked to read and sign the consent form that was approved by the IRB.
5.4 CO-ENROLLMENT GUIDELINES
Co-enrollment to the biopsy protocol (US NIH Site only) for rectal and/or LN biopsies will also be
encouraged if patients elect to have research biopsies.
6. STUDY TREATMENT
6.1 ANTI-RETROVIRAL THERAPY
Potent antiretroviral therapy will follow the published treatment guidelines overall and reflect current
standard of care with Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drugs or drugs available through
expanded access [45] for the NIH/US site and based upon Kenya Ministry of Health (MOH) and World
Health Organization (WHO) guidelines [43, 44] for the KEMRI/ Walter Reed Project (WRP)/Kenya site.
The Thailand sites will follow the HIV treatment guidelines published by the Thai Ministry of Public
Health. The choice of ART will be individualized to some degree, based on specific clinical or laboratory
parameters and personal preferences or adherence issues. The ART regimens will be chosen in consultation
with the participant’s primary care physician. ART will be continued throughout episodes of IRIS, but may
need to be discontinued temporarily in situations where severe inflammatory responses present with lifethreatening or serious neurologic complications (i.e., enlargement of lymph nodes compressing the airways
and/or progression of central nervous system [CNS] lesions with edema).
6.2 PROPHYLAXIS FOR OPPORTUNISTIC INFECTIONS
Opportunistic infection prophylaxis will be administered according to standard of care and established local
practice guidelines and may be discontinued once immune reconstitution has been achieved according to
published treatment guidelines.
6.3 TREATMENT OF OPPORTUNISTIC INFECTIONS OR AIDS-ASSOCIATED ILLNESSES
Participants with an opportunistic infection or with AIDS-associated illness or malignancy will be treated
according to local standard of care and published treatment guidelines where available, in consultation with
the primary care provider.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
16
Observational data have shown that the incidence of IRIS can be higher in the presence of high antigenic
load of opportunistic pathogens. A suggestion has been made to treat certain opportunistic infections such
as tuberculosis, MAC, or cryptococcosis for 4-8 weeks prior to HAART initiation. Randomized studies are
currently trying to address the question of immediate versus deferred ART initiation in HIV-infected
patients with CD4+ T cell counts <200 cells/µL.
In more advanced disease (CD4+ <100 cells/µL), which reflects the study population selected for this
study, observational studies have found increased incidence of new AIDS-defining illness or OIs in patients
whose ART initiation was delayed. Since there is no consensus on the best timing of ART initiation, but
there is evidence that new diagnoses can emerge if ART is delayed in patients with CD4+ T cell count
<100 cells/µL, ART in all participants will be initiated within 4 weeks from screening regardless of the
presence of an OI or another underlying AIDS-defining illness.
6.4 CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS OF IRIS EPISODES
There is no standard of care or specific treatment for IRIS. Participants presenting with a clinical picture
compatible with IRIS will undergo an appropriate work-up for exclusion of other diagnoses. Treatment
may require any one, or any possible combination, of the following procedures:
a. Mechanical intervention: examples include drainage of enlarged lymph nodes, thoracentesis,
paracentesis, or lumbar puncture.
b. Non-steroid anti-inflammatory drugs that may decrease fever or other inflammatory manifestations.
c. Pain or antipyretic medications for symptomatic relief.
d. Corticosteroids for more serious manifestations such as severe lymph node enlargement, impending
respiratory decompensation, and/or neurologic symptoms.
e. Rarely, ART discontinuation for life-threatening situations such as progressive neurologic
complications.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
17
7. CLINICAL AND LABORATORY EVALUATIONS
7.1 SCHEDULE OF EVENTS (US)
Evaluation
Screening
(-28 days)
Documentation of HIV
X
Medical & Medication History
X
Body mass index
(BMI)4
Pre-ART
(-27 to 0
days)
X
ART1
(Wk 0) Wk 23 Wk 43 Wk 83 Wk 123 Wk 243
X
X
X
X
X
Nadir CD4+ Count
X
Clinical Assessment
X
X
X
X
X
Wk 363
Wk 483
Wk 64 and
803
Wk 96 (EOS)6
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Amylase, Lipase
X5
(X)5
Lipid Profile (fasting)
X
Exam2
Physical
Hematology (CBC and differential and
ESR)
Chemistries, CRP
X
As clinically indicated
X
PT/PTT, D-Dimer
X
X
Urinalysis
X
X
Pregnancy Testing
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
(X)
X
X
X
X
X
X
Flow Cytometry (routine and research)
HIV-RNA (optional)
HIV Genotype
X
TSH and Free T4
X
Hepatitis A, B, C Screen
X
Cryptococcal Serum Ag
X
Toxoplasma Serology (IgG)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
As clinically indicated and before research procedures (apheresis, biopsies)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
As clinically indicated
X6
1: An elective hospital admission may be scheduled between screening and ART initiation to facilitate testing and for participant convenience. Testing of pre-ART visit
may be completed in more than one day
2: Weeks 48-80: visits will occur every 16 weeks, research flow cytometry will be optional
3: All visits will require a medical doctor (MD) visit.
4: BMI= weight (kg) divided by [height x height (cm)]
5: Amylase and lipase can be done on either pre-entry or entry visits
6: Optional extended follow up every 16 weeks up to week 192
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
18
Schedule of Events (Cont’d)
Evaluation
PPD
Screening
Pre-ART
ART1
(-28 days) (-27 to 0 days) (Wk 0)
X
RPR
X
Urine GC, Chlamydia PCR
X
Cervical Pap Smear
X5
CMV Blood PCR
X
CMV serology (IgG)
X
EBV PCR (cell)
X
Eye Clinic Evaluation
X6
EKG
X
Chest X-Ray
X
HLA-typing
X
Stored PBMC/plasma
Stored Serum
2-pass
Apheresis7
GI Biopsy8
LN
Biopsy9
(>2 cm)
Photography
10
Wk 2
Wk 4
X2
Wk 8
(X)
Wk 12
Wk 24
Wk 36
X
Wk 48
X3
Wk 64 and 80 Wk 96 (EOS)4
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
(X) optional
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
(X) optional
X
X
(X)
(X)
X
(X)
(X)
(X)
(X)
X
X
As indicated based on changes of observed lesions
1: An elective hospital admission may be scheduled between screening and ART initiation to facilitate testing and for participant convenience.
2, 3: PPD will be repeated at week 4 or 8 only if non-reactive at baseline. If PPD non-reactive at baseline and week 4, it will be repeated yearly (at weeks 48 and 96)
4: Optional extended follow up every 16 weeks up to week 192.
5: Pap smear can be delayed up until week 4 of study and will be repeated as clinically indicated or according to local practices. Results from PMD will be accepted.
6: And every 24 weeks thereafter until CD4 >100 cells/µL for >12 weeks or as clinically indicated.
7: NIH/US and Bangkok (optional) sites only. If adequate venous access and Hg >9g/dl, PLT >50,000 and not pregnant for female participants. It will be repeated every 48
weeks after week 48.
8, 9: Optional under a different protocol, time points shown are approximate. q
10: Skin or mucosal lesions that require close follow up (i.e. Kaposi’s sarcoma [KS] lesions, skin, or genital warts).
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
19
7.2 DEFINITIONS FOR SCHEDULE OF EVENTS- TIMING OF EVALUATIONS
7.2.1 Screening
Screening evaluations to determine eligibility must be completed within 28 days prior to day of ART
initiation. These will include laboratory documentation of HIV status, CD4+ T cell count, complete
blood count (CBC) and HIV RNA, if needed to expedite genotype results (US site) as well as clinical
and medication history. Study participants will sign informed consent before screening or research labs
are collected. CD4 T cell counts from an outside or the site’s laboratory within 8 weeks prior to
screening can be accepted as the screening value. For US site only: standard consent may be signed on
the day of screening if outside CD4 count as above is available or as soon as the CD4 count
determining eligibility becomes available. Pre-ART and ART visits will be combined for the Kenya
and Thailand site but tests may be performed in more than one day (see Appendix D and E). For the
Kenya site, a CXR done during routine care in the HIV clinic will be accepted if done within one
month prior to screening. In addition, chemistries may be done as part of screening and repeated if
necessary and clinically indicated prior to ART initiation (see Appendix D).
7.2.2 Pre-ART
Pre-ART evaluations must be completed within 27 days prior to ART evaluations and may require
more than one visits (days). Pre-ART and ART (week 0) visits may be combined, if it is feasible to
schedule all the required testing and obtain standard informed consent.
1.
2.
History and physical exam (including BMI)
CBC with differential and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR)
Chemistry with CRP (CRP in US only) and for KEMRI/WRP/KENYA and
Thailand Chemistries will routinely include electrolytes, Renal and liver function
tests.
3.
Amylase and lipase
4.
A fasting lipid profile
5.
Prothrombin time (PT)/ partial thromboplastin time (PTT) and D-dimer (US
only)
6.
Flow cytometry: routine (CD4 and CD8 T cell counts) and research as outlined
in immunologic studies)
7.
8.
HIV Viral load
HIV genotype (may be done at baseline/screening visit if it facilitates clinical
care)
9.
Urinalysis (as clinically indicated for the Kenya and Thailand sites)
10.
Thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and free thyroxine (T4) (US)
11.
Hepatitis A, B, C screening (Hepatitis A in US only)
12.
Cryptococcal serum antigen
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
20
13.
14.
Urine Histoplasma antigen if clinically indicated or according to standard of care
(Thai site)
Toxoplasma serology (IgG) (US and Thailand)
15.
Purified protein derivative PPD testing
16.
Rapid plasma reagin (RPR; Syphilis diagnostic)
17.
Urine Neisseria gonorrhoeae (GC) and Chlamydia polymerase chain reaction
(PCR) (US only)
18.
Cervical Pap smear (anal Pap smear in Thailand according to local clinical
practices)
19.
Ophthalmological evaluation (Eye Clinic)
20.
CMV PCR (blood) (US only)
21.
CMV serology (IgG) (US only)
22.
EBV PCR (peripheral mononuclear cells [PBMC]) (US only)
23.
Chest x-ray (CXR)
24.
ECG (US and Thai sites only)
25.
Photography of any skin or other lesions that require follow up over time
26.
Pregnancy test (urine or serum) for women of childbearing potential
27.
Cell/serum and plasma storage
28.
HLA typing
Additional pre-ART research tests in US and Thailand will include:
29.
Apheresis (optional and if venous access is adequate and if Hg is ≥9 gm/dL and
PLT> 50,000 with negative pregnancy test in women)
30.
Rectal biopsy (optional under different protocol at the US NIH site and optional
at the Thailand site).
31.
Genital secretion collection (procedure performed in Thailand only and is
optional)
32.
LN biopsy (optional in US under a separate protocol) if a node is found to be
larger than 2 cm in diameter - the LN will be processed for microbiology,
pathology and research (flow cytometry). LN biopsy may also be required at any
point for clinical diagnostic reasons.
The following tests will be accepted if done at NIH within 8 weeks of screening under a different
NIH protocol or in Kenya at the Kericho District Hospital or another treatment facility: EKG, CXR,
CMV and Toxoplasma serology, hepatitis A, B, C screening, TSH and free T4, RPR, and PPD. At
NIH, eye clinic evaluation will be accepted if done at NIH within the past 3 months. For the Kericho
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
21
and Thai sites, eye clinic evaluation will be accepted if done by a qualified ophthalmologist,
ophthalmology technician, or qualified Medical or Clinical Officer in the past 3 months.
Additionally, HLA typing and HIV testing performed at NIH at any point prior to screening will not
be repeated. An elective hospital admission may be scheduled between screening and ART initiation
to facilitate testing and for participant convenience.
7.2.3 ART (day of ART initiation)
ART evaluations must occur within 27 days after pre-ART evaluations or the pre-ART and ART visits
can be combined. These will include:
1.
Targeted review of history including medication history and targeted physical
exam.
2.
Pregnancy test (urine, but serum will be acceptable if urine was not obtained)
3.
Flow Cytometry
4.
HIV RNA
5.
Safety laboratory testing will be repeated only if clinically indicated and if they
were performed more than 2 weeks prior to entry. Lipase and amylase will be done
once either at pre-ART or ART visits and as clinically indicated thereafter.
6.
CMV and EBV PCR will also be done at ART visit if pre-ART visit was more
than 14 days before (US only).
7.
ESR/ CRP and D-dimer/PT, PTT (US only) will be done at ART visit unless they
were done less than 7 days before (at pre-ART visit).
8. Storage of cells, plasma and serum
7.2.4 Week 2 to Week 80 Visits
Week 2 to week 80 visits will include a medical and medication history as well as clinical assessment
with targeted physical exam (BMI at weeks 12, 24 and 48, full physical exam recommended yearly). A
study medical doctor (MD) visit will be required until week 48, and then yearly and as clinically
indicated. For the Kenya site, study participants will be seen by a Clinical Officer or Medical Doctor
consistent with the standard of care in Kenya. For the Thailand site, study participants will be seen by
a Medical Doctor. Additional testing may include:
1. Flow cytometry (except weeks 64 and 80 for the Thailand site)
2. HIV-RNA
3. CBC (with differential and ESR), D-dimer with PT/PTT (US only), UA (as clinically
indicated for the Kenya and Thailand sites) and chemistries (with CRP in US only).
For KEMRI/WRP/KENYA chemistries will routinely include electrolytes, renal and
liver function tests. For the Thailand site, electrolytes and BUN/Cr will be performed
at weeks 12, 24, 48 and 80, fasting lipid profile will be performed at weeks 24 and
48, liver function test will be performed at every visit except for week 8.
4. CMV blood PCR (US only)
5. EBV PCR (US only)
6. Storage of cells, plasma and serum (no storage at week 80 for the Thailand site)
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
22
Additionally: PPD will be repeated at week 4 or 8 if non-reactive at baseline. Eye evaluation will be
repeated approximately every 24 weeks until CD4 counts are >100 cells/µl for >12 weeks.
At weeks 24 and 48: fasting lipid profile, Pap smear (US and Thailand only, not protocol mandated but
recommended in the US, to be performed at weeks 24 and 48 in Thailand according to local practices).
Apheresis (US and optional in Thailand) will occur at approximately weeks 12 and 48 and then yearly
provided conditions are met: adequate venous access, Hg >9gr/dL, PLT >50,000 and negative
pregnancy test).
Yearly testing (approximately at weeks 48 and 96) will also include:
1. PPD if non-reactive at baseline and week 4
2. RPR
3. Fasting lipid profile
4. Urinalysis (as clinically indicated for the Kenya and Thailand sites)
5. Pap smear will be strongly recommended but is not required by protocol (report will
be acceptable from outside medical doctor)
Study visits may occur within a +/-10-day window period in the first 24 weeks of the study and within
a +/-21-day window period for the rest of the study. Unscheduled visits occurring within the above
accepted windows of a scheduled visit may replace the scheduled per protocol visit. During the optional
extension period at the NIH (week 96 to end of study), the window period for visits may be up to 2
months.
7.2.5 Premature Study Discontinuation Evaluations
If a participant elects to discontinue study participation for whatever reason, evaluations will be done at
the end of study visit which would correspond to those listed below as final evaluations of the end of
study visit.
7.2.6 Final Study Evaluations
Final evaluations are required at the subject’s final visit, Week 96 or at premature study
discontinuation. These will include:
1. Complete history and physical exam (with BMI calculation)
2. Clinical assessment of signs and symptoms
3. HIV viral load and flow cytometry
4. CBC with differential, ESR
5. PT/PTT, D-dimer (for US only)
6. Chemistry panel, CRP (US) and for KEMRI/WRP/KENYA, Chemistries will
routinely include electrolytes, Renal and liver function tests.
7. Urinalysis (as clinically indicated for the Kenya and Thailand sites)
8. Stored PBMC, plasma and serum
7.2.7 Unscheduled Visits
Unscheduled visits due to acute events that necessitate outpatient or inpatient evaluations and that,
according to the medical team, may be representing presentations of IRIS will entail evaluations that
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
23
are clinically indicated including flow cytometry and HIV-RNA. In addition, and if the team suspects
IRIS, cell, serum and plasma storage may be done if blood volume restrictions allow and apheresis (US
only) may be scheduled at the closest possible time point that the subject’s clinical condition and
scheduling limitations would permit. Unscheduled visits occurring within a 14-day window of a
scheduled visit may replace the scheduled per protocol visit.
7.2.8 Optional Study Extension Up to Week 192 (US site only)
US participants may choose to continue their study participation an additional two years up to week
192. Visits will occur approximately every 16 weeks and data collection and evaluations will be the
same as between weeks 48 to 96. If patients have ongoing clinical issues a few additional visits may be
allowed as indicated until care is appropriately transitioned. Selected research labs may also be done (as
in protocol visits betweek week 96 and 192) if the clinical issues are related to IRIS or other HIV
complications.
7.3 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS AND DEFINITIONS OF EVALUATIONS
7.3.1 Documentation of HIV
For the NIH site: HIV-1 infection, can be documented by OraQuick test at screening to assure timely
scheduling of the protocol evaluations prior to ART initiation. HIV testing by ELISA, with Western
blot confirmation will also be done at screening if not done previously at NIH.
For the Kenya Medical Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical Research Center (KEMRI/WRP
CRC)/Kenya site: HIV-1 infection will initially be diagnosed based upon two, serial rapid HIV tests
according to Kenya MOH guidelines. Volunteers entering this study will have HIV infection
reconfirmed by two serial rapid HIV test in accordance with the Kenya MOH guidelines and testing
algorithm followed by a confirmation with a Western Blot.
For Thailand, HIV-1 screening and confirmatory testing will be based on 3, serial rapid HIV tests
according to the Thai Ministry of Public Health guidelines. The subjects will initially be tested with an
ELISA method that detects both HIV antigen and antibody. Confirmatory testing of HIV reactive
samples by two different antibody detection methods will follow. Positive results by all three methods
confirm HIV diagnosis. Discrepancy between the tests will require a nucleic acid detection method to
confirm HIV diagnosis.
7.3.2 Medical History
A medical history must be present in source documents. All diagnoses, related and unrelated to HIV
infection, should be recorded regardless of when they occurred. Any allergies to any medications
and/or their formulations must be present in the Clinical Research Information Management System
(CRIMSON) documents or study source documents/case report forms.
7.3.3 Medication History
A medication history must be present in source documents, including:

Complete HIV treatment history, including start and stop dates of any antiretroviral
medication.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
24




Complete treatment history of any prescription or non-prescription medications taken for the
treatment or prophylaxis of opportunistic infections, including actual or estimated start and
stop dates.
All prescription medications (in addition to those noted above) taken within 90 days prior to
screening, including actual or estimated start and stop dates. Medications for prophylaxis or
treatment of HIV-associated diseases such as TB should be recorded regardless of when
they were taken.
Nonprescription medications, to include analgesics, antipyretics, anti-histamines, and
antacids, taken within 30 days prior to screening. Include actual or estimated start and stop
dates.
Alternative therapies to include acupuncture, homeopathic medicine, herbal medications,
and vitamins, taken within 90 days prior to screening. Include actual or estimated start and
stop dates.
All antiretrovirals, prescription and non-prescription medications, dietary supplements, and herbal
treatments will be recorded.
7.3.4 Nadir CD4+ T Cell Count
The subject’s nadir CD4+ cell count (absolute value and date) will be considered the lowest CD4 T cell
count documented prior to ART initiation (on either screening or pre-ART or ART visits) and should
be documented. Results will be recorded in CRIMSON or study source documents/case report form.
7.3.5 Clinical Assessments
Signs and Symptoms
All signs and symptoms that meet documentation requirements (grade 3 and 4, specific diagnoses)
within 30 days prior to screening must be documented. In addition, after enrollment all signs and
symptoms meeting documentation requirements (grade 3 and 4, suspected IRIS, specific diagnoses)
must be recorded in CRIMSON at the NIH/US Site and on study source documents/case report forms
for the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya and TRCARC Bangkok sites throughout the course of the study.
Toxicity analysis will be based on the criteria outlined in the Division of AIDS (DAIDS) Table for
Grading Severity of Adult Adverse Experiences, December 2004, and is shown in Appendix B.
Diagnoses
All confirmed and probable diagnoses made since the last visit will be recorded in CRIMSON at the
NIH/US Site and on study source documents/case report forms for the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya and
TRCARC Bangkok sites, including current status at the time of study visit.
Vital Signs
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
25
Temperature, pulse, blood pressure (BP), respiratory rate and pulse oximetry (US only) will be
collected at all visits and recorded in CRIMSON at the NIH/US Site and on study source
documents/case report forms for the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya and TRCARC Bangkok sites.
Physical Exam
The physical examination includes the following:












Height, weight, vital signs as above
General appearance
Skin
Head, eyes, ears, nose, and throat (HEENT)
Neck
Respiratory
Chest/breasts
Cardiovascular
Abdominal
Genital/urinary/peri-rectal
Extremities
CNS: Cranial nerves, motor, and sensory
Note: Evaluation of subject’s height is required at entry only. Full exam performed at baseline and
yearly, targeted exam (guided by symptoms) in all other visits .
7.3.6 Laboratory Evaluations (see Appendix D (Kericho Site Schedule of Events) for Kenya
specific laboratory evaluations and appendix E for Thailand sites)
Please refer to Appendix B for toxicity grading which is based on the DAIDS Table for Grading
Severity of Adult Adverse Experiences, dated December 2004.
Hematology: Hemoglobin, hematocrit, red blood cells (RBC), mean corpuscular volume (MCV), white
blood cell count (WBC), differential WBC, absolute neutrophil count (ANC), and platelets. Erythrocyte
sedimentation rate (ESR) will also be performed.
Blood Chemistries: Glucose, creatinine, creatine kinase, electrolytes (sodium, potassium, chloride,
phosphate, and bicarbonate), calcium, magnesium, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), total protein, CRP
(US only) and albumin. At the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya and Thai sites, according to local clinical
standards phosphate, magnesium, calcium, lactate dehydrogenase, and total protein will be performed
only if clinically indicated.
Thyroid Function Tests (US and Thailand only): T4 and TSH.
PT/PTT and D-dimer (US only).
Hepatitis A (US only), B, and C: hepatitis A serology (IgG, IgM), hepatitis B serology (hepatitis B
surface antigen [HBsAg], antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen [anti-HepBsAb], antibody to hepatitis
B core antigen [anti-HepBcAb] and hepatitis E antigen [HeAg]/ antibody to hepatitis E antigen [antiHeAb]), and hepatitis C antibody (ELISA) and hepatitis C virus ( HCV) RNA. At the KEMRI/WRP
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
26
Kenya site, only Hepatitis B and C serology (IgG) will be checked. For Thailand, only Hepatitis B and
C serology will be performed.
Liver Function Tests: Total bilirubin, AST (SGOT), ALT (SGPT), alkaline phosphatase (or GGT), and
direct bilirubin.
Urinalysis: Microscopic analysis
Fasting lipid profile: Total cholesterol, HDL, LDL and triglycerides
Pregnancy Test: For women of childbearing potential: β-hCG test with a sensitivity of 25-50 mIU/mL
using urine. If entry is less than 72 hours after pre-entry, a pregnancy test is not required to be repeated
at entry. If urine is not available, serum will be an acceptable alternative.
7.3.7 ECG (US and Thailand only)
A baseline 12-lead ECG is required at study entry and as clinically indicated after that.
7.3.8 Chest X-ray
A baseline chest x-ray is required at entry. It may be repeated at later time points if clinically indicated.
7.3.9 Virologic Studies (HIV Viral Load)
For NIH: Plasma HIV-1 RNA (Real Time)
The screening test for HIV-1 RNA will be performed at SAIC Frederick, using the bDNA assay.
For Kericho: The screening test for HIV-1 RNA will be performed at the Kenya Medical
Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical Research Center laboratory, using the Roche Amplicor 1.5.
For Thailand: The HIV-1 RNA will be performed at AFRIMS using the Roche Amplicor 1.5.
7.3.10 Stored plasma/PBMC/serum (Appendix C)
Plasma, serum and PBMCs will be stored for HIV-related research at all visits, including unscheduled
visits, for possible IRIS assessments, whenever possible, depending on the subject’s blood volume
restrictions.
7.3.11 Immunologic Studies
For NIH: Flow cytometry
Enumeration and phenotyping of lymphocytes will be performed on samples from all visits at SAIC
Frederick laboratory.
For Kericho: Enumeration and phenotyping of lymphocytes will be performed on samples from all
visits at the Kenya Medical Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical Research Center laboratory.
For Thailand: Enumeration and phenotyping of lymphocytes will be performed on samples from all
visits at the AFRIMS laboratory.
Real time flow cytometry will also follow:
1. Proportion and enumeration of CD4 and CD8 T cells with naïve versus memory phenotype
2. Proportion and enumeration of activated CD4 and CD8 T cells as measured by HLA-DR and
CD38 expression
3. Proportion and enumeration of proliferating CD4 and CD8 T cells as measured by intracellular
Ki67
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
27
4.
5.
6.
7.
Proportion and enumeration of CD4 and CD8 T cells expressing IL-7Ra (CD127)
Proportion and enumeration of CD4 and CD8 T cells expressing PD-1
Proportion and enumeration of Treg cells (CD4+/FoxP3+/CD25+or-)
Proportion of myeloid (CD11c) and plasmacytoid (CD123+) dendritic cells
Stored serum and plasma (~2 mL per visit) will be used to measure the following (by multiplex assays):
1. Levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines
2. Th1/Th2 and Th17 cytokines
3. CRP, D-dimer and chemokines
Stored PBMC (~20 x 106 cells/visit) will be used to test:
1. Ag-specific responses by ICCS and CFSE dilution assays. Stimulation assays will include
negative and positive controls, HIV-gag and CMV peptides (in CMV+ recipients) and Ag
relevant to the underlying pathogen if these are available (i.e. PPD, ESAT-6 or CFP-10 for TB,
MAC, Cryptosporidium, Varicella zoster virus VZV).
2. If sufficient cells are available, the tetramer+ cells for specific peptides will be followed.
3. If sufficient cells are available (probably only in certain patients with apheresis) the TCR
repertoire of sorted CD4 and CD8 T cells will be studied at study time points of interest.
4. If sufficient cells are available (probably only in certain patients with apheresis) the function
(i.e. suppression) of sorted phenotypically Treg cells (CD4+/CD25high/CD127low) will be
studied at study time points of interest.
7.3.12 Discarded Clinical Specimens
Discarded specimens collected for clinical reasons (blood, tissue, lung fluid) may also be used for
research.
8. CRITERIA FOR IRIS END POINTS
The study team will meet regularly to evaluate study progression and presentations of participants
during acute or scheduled visits that may be representing IRIS episodes. Based upon the modified
AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) criteria for IRIS (Appendix A) and according to clinical
presentation, laboratory, radiologic findings and study team discussion, the episodes will be categorized
as:
a)
Consistent with IRIS (meeting all five criteria outlined in Appendix A)
b)
Suspicious for IRIS (meeting four of the criteria listed in Appendix A)
c)
Consistent with alternate diagnosis (new OI, recurrence of previous OI, AIDS-defining
illness, other disease or drug toxicity)
Additional work up and evaluation of the participant or stored specimens may be decided during these
meetings.
An endpoint committee chaired by an internationally recognized IRIS expert (Dr Martyn French) and
two other infectious disease experts as well as representation from the study team will review and
adjudicate all cases considered for IRIS (1 of 3 endpoints as assigned above). The committee will make
final recommendations to the protocol chairs with regard to endpoint assignment and will comment on
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
28
the issue of “unmasking”. The endpoint committee will meet after the first 10 cases are evaluated for
IRIS and at regular intervals thereafter. The endpoint committee may ask for additional clinical or
laboratory data from the study teams. Data independent of any patient identifiers, including additional
laboratory tests on stored specimens, will be provided to the endpoint committee.
For the Kenya site, overall review of subjects having any clinical event that may be consistent with
IRIS (as defined in Appendix A), review of source documents and/or case report forms for
substantiation of IRIS criteria, and end point review/IRIS case adjudication will all be covered in a
standard operating procedure document specific for the Kericho site. Telephone conferences will be
held between the NIH team (lead by the Chair or her designee) and the Kericho team and/or the Thai
team according to the needs as defined by the study Chair and Co-chairs. The following are intended to
be the primary topics for discussion during these team calls: all subjects newly enrolled to the study;
any case suspicious of IRIS; any subject experiencing a protocol defined Serious Adverse Event (SAE)
or any other clinical or adverse event (AE) a team member feels should be discussed; and other study
related topics. A case report form for IRIS definition and end point determination will be completed
for all subjects having clinical events suspicious of IRIS. This case report form will serve as the basis
for discussion during the weekly telephone conferences.
9. CRITERIA FOR STUDY DISCONTINUATION
Reasons for withdrawal from study are:
1. Request by the subject to withdraw.
2. Request for withdrawal by the primary care provider, if she/he thinks the study is no longer
in the best interest of the subject.
3. Subject judged by the investigator to be at significant risk of failing to comply with the
provisions of the protocol and to cause harm to self or seriously interfere with the validity of
the study results (for instance, in case of frequently missed visits).
4. Termination of the study at the discretion of the IRBs, NIAID, KEMRI, WRAIR, Infectious
Diseases Clinical Research Program (IDCRP), Chulalongkorn University IRB, the
Department of Disease Control, Ministry of Public Health IRB, or principal investigator.
Pregnancy during study participation will not mandate study withdrawal provided that the participant is
receiving adequate obstetric care and continued study participation will be permitted if the subject
wishes to remain on study. For NIH and Thailand, all aphereses, research biopsies and blood draws
will be suspended during the gestation and 12 month post-delivery period. For all sites, blood draws
will follow local standard of care in a pregnant woman with HIV infection on ART.
10. STATISTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
10.1 GENERAL DESIGN-STATISTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
This protocol aims to evaluate the role of different baseline factors on the risk of developing IRIS
(Immune Reconstitution Syndrome) within 6 months of ART initiation. The study will be conducted in
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
29
3 sites: US, Kenya and Thailand with a total enrollment of approximately 500. The site in Kenya will
enroll 200 participants, the site in Thailand will enroll 100 and the site in US will enroll approximately
200 as it will remain open to enrollment up until the other sites have completed enrollment so that the
maximum anticipated enrollment will be 500 so that a sample size of 400 will be evaluable for the main
study objectives. Each volunteer will be followed for a minimum of 2 years. Important secondary
objectives are to estimate the incidence of IRIS both overall and stratified by different risk factors, to
assess the risk of death associated with IRIS, and to describe the role of immune markers in the context
of IRIS.
To describe power for this study consider a binary baseline characteristic or covariate (e.g baseline
CD4 count above/below the median, or infection at baseline). The probability of identifying this binary
covariate as a significant risk factor depends on the rate of the binary characteristic and the assumed
IRIS rates for the two values of the binary characteristic. The table below identifies specific scenarios
for which a 400-sample study provides around 90% power. From the 5th row of the table we see that if
the overall IRIS rate is 0.30, 1/3 of the sample have the binary characteristic (e.g. CD4 <median), and
the IRIS rate for those with high CD4 counts is 0.40 then we will have 86% power to detect CD4 count
as a predictor of IRIS. The study is extremely well powered to detect a risk factor that doubles the risk
of IRIS.
Statistical power to detect an important binary covariate on the risk of IRIS under different
scenarios. N=400
OVERALL
IRIS RATE
Rate of Binary IRIS rate with
characteristic
binary
characteristic
.20
1/2
1/3
1/5
1/2
1/3
1/5
.30
0.26
0.30
0.33
0.37
0.40
0.44
IRIS rate
without
binary
characteristic
0.14
0.15
0.17
0.23
0.25
0.27
Rate
ratio
Power
1.86
2.00
1.97
1.61
1.60
1.66
0.85
0.93
0.87
0.87
0.86
0.85
The risk factors of primary interest are CD4 count at baseline (above/below the median) and the
presence of an infection (either active or occult) at baseline. The primary analysis will be conducted
using a Cox regression model stratified by site using time to IRIS as the outcome. In these analyses,
death will be treated as a censoring variable. Separate models will be used for each of the above binary
risk factors. Additional Cox regression models will be used to evaluate other risk factors such as BMI,
hemoglobin, infection type e.g. mycobacterial versus other, or active versus occult. Multivariate Cox
regression will also be performed. Although the primary analysis will be done with all sites combined,
statistical tests of risk factor by site interaction will be conducted to examine the possibility that the risk
factor(s) is site-specific.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
30
10.2 SECONDARY ANALYSES
Each patient will be classified into one of four possible categories 6 months after ART initiation:
A=Alive and experienced IRIS, B=Dead after experiencing IRIS, C=Dead without experiencing IRIS,
D=Alive without IRIS. Incidence will be calculated as (A+B)/(A+B+C+D). IRIS-attributable mortality
during the first 6 months will be calculated as B/A+B+C+D. If censoring is an issue, i.e. drop-out
before the 6 month ART anniversary, cumulative incidence curves will be used to estimate the
proportion of patients in the above 4 states over the first 6 months of follow-up [46]. These analyses
will be conducted both separately and pooled over the three sites. Additionally, cumulative incidence
curves of IRIS will be estimate to describe the time course of IRIS over the entire course of follow up.
To evaluate the impact of IRIS on the risk of subsequent death, a Cox regression model using death as
the outcome will be estimated where IRIS is treated as a time varying covariate which is 0 until IRIS
occurs and 1 thereafter. Similar models e.g. a time varying covariate which is 0 except for the 3
months after IRIS, will be used to assess if IRIS is associated with a transient increase in the risk of
death. Multivariate Cox regression will also be used to account for baseline variables in some of these
analyses.
To evaluate the impact of IRIS on subsequent CD4 counts, multiple linear regression will be used to
predict CD4 counts at 1 year post ART initiation using whether IRIS occurred within the first 6 months
and baseline variables e.g. baseline CD4. Random effects longitudinal models will also be used to
assess how the trajectory of CD4 counts is impacted by IRIS.
Statistical analyses of immunophenotypic, cytokine/chemokines, and immune response parameters will
adopt the approach taken for other baseline variables. Thus these parameters will be used as predictors
of time to IRIS in univariate and multivariate Cox regression models.
10.3 INTERIM ANALYSES
Interim analyses will be completed approximately after 200 study participants have completed a
minimum of 24-week follow-up and all data are available.
10.4 REPLACEMENT OF SUBJECTS
There will be no replacement of subjects, since the sample size is adequate to allow 5-10% losses to
follow-up.
11. DATA COLLECTION AND MONITORING AND ADVERSE EVENT EXPERIENCE
REPORTING
The trial will be conducted in compliance with this protocol, International Conference on
Harmonization (ICH) Guidelines for Good Clinical Practice (GCP), and any applicable national and
international regulatory requirements. The principal and associate investigators will be monitoring all
aspects of the study in accordance with the appropriate regulations and will have regular meetings with
periodic quality control of data documentation and collection. The objectives of the monitoring
meetings will be:
1) To verify the prompt reporting of all data points, including reporting SAEs and
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
31
checking availability of signed informed consent,
2) To compare individual subject records, CRIMSON data pulls and/or the study source
documents/case report forms (supporting data, laboratory specimen records and
medical records to include physician progress notes, nurses’ notes, subjects’ hospital
charts),
3) To ensure protection of study subjects, compliance with the protocol, and accuracy
and completeness of records.
The principal investigator (and/or designee) will make study documents (e.g., consent forms,
CRIMSON data pulls) and pertinent hospital or clinical records readily available for inspection by the
local IRB and the NIAID staff for confirmation of the study data.
11.1 DEFINITIONS
Adverse Event: An adverse event (AE) is any undesirable experience/unwanted effect that occurs in a
patient or to a study participant during the course of a clinical trial (or a reasonable time after trial
termination) whether or not that experience is considered related to the drug/ investigational product.
An AE can therefore be any unfavorable and unintended physical or psychological sign (including an
abnormal laboratory finding), symptom, or disease temporally associated with the use of a
medicinal/investigational product, whether or not considered related to the medicinal/investigational
product. This includes exacerbation of pre-existing conditions and intercurrent illnesses.
Stable chronic conditions which are present prior to clinical trial entry and do not worsen are not
considered AEs and will be accounted for in the subject’s medical history.
Serious Adverse Event: An AE is determined to be "serious" based on study participant/event outcome
or action criteria usually associated with experiences that pose a threat to a patient/participant's life or
functioning. An SAE is any undesirable experience that at any dose results in one of the following
outcomes:






Death
Life-threatening event (the study subject was at risk of death at the time of the event; it does not
refer to an event which hypothetically might have caused death if it were more severe)
Inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization
Persistent or significant disability/incapacity (A substantial disruption of a person's ability to
conduct normal life functions).
Congenital anomaly/birth defect
Important medical event that may not be immediately life-threatening or result in death or
hospitalization but may jeopardize the patient/study participant or may require intervention to
prevent one of the other outcomes listed above
Each AE will be classified by the investigator as “serious” or “non-serious.” An AE needs to meet only
one of the above criteria to be considered serious. A change in vital signs, diagnostic tests (e.g., an
electrocardiogram), or laboratory test results may be determined to be an SAE if the change is of
sufficient magnitude to meet one of the above criteria.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
32
Unanticipated problem that is not an Adverse Event (UPnonAE): An unanticipated problem that does
not fit the definition of an adverse event, but which may, in the opinion of the investigator, involves
risk to the subject, affect others in the research study, or significantly impact the integrity of research
data. For example, report occurrences of breaches of confidentiality, accidental destruction of study
records, or unaccounted-for study drug.
Protocol Violation: Any change, divergence, or departure from the study procedures in an IRBapproved research protocol that has a major impact on the subject’s rights, safety, or well-being and/or
the completeness, accuracy or reliability of the study data.
Protocol Deviation: Any change, divergence, or departure from the IRB approved study procedures in a
research protocol that does not have a major impact on the subject's rights, safety or well-being, or the
completeness, accuracy and reliability of the study data.
Unanticipated Problem: Any incident, experience, or outcome that is
1. unexpected in terms of nature, severity, or frequency in relation to
a. the research risks that are described in the IRB-approved research protocol and informed
consent document; Investigator’s Brochure or other study documents; and
b. the characteristics of the subject population being studied; and
2. related or possibly related to participation in the research; and
3. places subjects or others at a greater risk of harm (including physical, psychological, economic,
or social harm) than was previously known or recognized.
11.2 DOCUMENTATION AND SERIOUS ADVERSE EVENT (SAE) REPORTING
This is an observational cohort study with care of participants that will follow clinical standards and/or
published guidelines. Documentation will focus mostly on diagnoses and medications as well as
unscheduled visits or hospitalizations for acute problems that may be representing IRIS. Laboratory
abnormalities reaching grades 3 and 4 will also be documented. All patients in this protocol will have
diagnoses and medications listed by the clinic staff and entered into a computerized database or case
report forms and source documents in Kenya and Thailand. Reporting will occur from enrollment until
the last study visit. If an event suspicious for IRIS is still ongoing at study completion, additional
clinical follow up until resolution of the event may be arranged by the study team. The AEs will be
graded as per the DAIDS toxicity table, if they fall into a graded category; otherwise they will be
categorized by severity as follows:

Mild (Grade 1): Transient or mild symptoms; no limitation in activity; no intervention required.
Symptoms causing no or minimal interference with usual social and functional activities
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
33

Moderate (Grade 2): Symptoms causing greater than minimal interference with usual social and
functional activities. No or minimal intervention required. It is uncomfortable or an
embarrassment.

Severe (Grade 3): Symptoms causing inability to perform usual social and functional activities.
Medical intervention often required.

Life-threatening (Grade 4): Symptoms causing inability to perform basic self-care functions OR
Medical or operative intervention indicated to prevent permanent impairment, persistent
disability, or death.
Analysis will be performed by queries to the NIH, and Kericho, and TRCARC Bangkok databases. The
data will be reviewed (monitored) on an ongoing basis by the study coordinators and the principal
investigator.
Hospitalizations will be documented in the subsequent clinic notes and events during hospitalization
will be summarized. Reporting and grading of clinical events and laboratory abnormalities will be
based upon the primary diagnosis(es) felt responsible for the hospitalization and supporting data For
prolonged hospitalizations, notes will be needed while the participant is an inpatient to replace and
follow the timeline of missed clinic visits. Unscheduled visits or hospitalizations that are considered
suspicious for IRIS will generate separate clinic notes.
SAE reporting to IRBs (USUHS IRB, KEMRI, Chulalongkorn University, Thai Department of Disease
Control, BIDI, NIAID and WRAIR) will be as follows:
 IRB reporting within 7 days of investigator awareness:
All unanticipated problems that are either AEs or non-AEs, (as defined by Section 11.1
above) and all protocol violations

IRB reporting at the time of Continuing Review (CR):
All unanticipated problems
All protocol deviations which in the opinion of the investigator should be reported.
It will be the responsibility of the investigator to report any occurrence that in his/her clinical judgment
is serious and unexpected during study follow-up.
Additional reporting for the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya Site is outlined in Appendix D, Section 9.
12. HUMAN SUBJECTS
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
34
12.1 INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD (IRB) REVIEW AND INFORMED CONSENT
This protocol, the informed consent document and any subsequent modifications will be reviewed and
approved by the IRB or ethics committees in both the US, Kenya and Thailand responsible for
oversight of the study. A signed consent form will be obtained from the subject (legal guardian, or
person with power of attorney for subjects who cannot consent for themselves). The consent form will
describe the purpose of the study, the procedures to be followed, and the risks and benefits of
participation. A copy of the consent form will be given to the subject, parent, or legal guardian and this
fact will be documented in the subject’s record. Advertisements may be used to assist in enrollment of
study subjects and will be submitted for IRB review when available.
Four IRBs have oversight of this protocol.
1. Uniformed Services University of Health Sciences Infectious Diseases IRB (USUHS ID IRB).
The USUHS ID IRB is the IRB of record for the Infectious Diseases Clinical Research Program
(IDCRP). IDCRP is the sponsor of the Kericho and Thailand sites in this study being executed at NIH,
in Kericho and in Thailand. The USUHS ID IRB will review the protocol in its entirety and will
oversee aspects of the Kericho and Thai study.
2. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) IRB.
The NIAID IRB is the IRB of record for the NIAID. NIAID is the sponsor of the NIH portion of this
protocol and has oversight given the study initially was opened in the NIH clinical center and continues
to be active there. The NIAID IRB will review the protocol in its entirety and will oversee aspects of
the NIH study.
3. Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI) IRB.
The KEMRI IRB is the Kenya IRB of record for all Unites States Army Medical Research Unit-Kenya
(USAMRU-K) studies conducted in Kenya and will be the IRB of record for study execution in Kenya.
The KEMRI will review the protocol in its entirety and will oversee aspects of the Kericho study.
4. Thai IRB
The Chulalongkorn University IRB is the responsible IRB for the TRC-ARC site. The Department of
Disease Control, Ministry of Public Health IRB and the BIDI Ethical Committee are the responsible
IRBs for the BIDI site.
12.2 SUBJECT CONFIDENTIALITY
Stored laboratory specimens will be identified by coded number only, in order to maintain subject
confidentiality. All records will be kept locked. All computer entry and networking programs will be
done with coded numbers only. Clinical information will not be released without written permission of
the subject, except as necessary for monitoring by the IRB, FDA, and NIAID.
12.3 MINORITY RECRUITMENT (US)
Patients will be recruited for participation in this study without bias to gender, racial, economic, or
social status. Patients new to the NIH will be recruited from outside physician referrals. Subjects will
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
35
be recruited from NIH clinics and local public, academic, and private clinics. The study will be
advertised and posted on the NIH web site.
The Division of Intramural Research (DIR) maintains an active outreach program to recruit women and
persons from racial or ethnic minorities to participate in clinical trials. Whenever possible, this study
will take advantage of the DIR program.
12.4 INCLUSION OF CHILDREN AND PREGNANT WOMEN
This study will be confined to HIV-infected adults greater than or equal to 18 years of age. Since there
will be no direct benefit associated with study participation, children will be excluded.
Pregnant women will also be excluded at the time of screening since there is no benefit from
participation and the study (particularly at entry) is intense with frequent blood draws, apheresis and
some optional invasive procedures. Pregnant women will only be allowed to continue participation if
pregnancy occurs during study participation, provided that they have adequate obstetric care and with
the provision that they will not undergo protocol-mandated apheresis (US and Thai sites only) or
research blood draws during the gestation and 12 month post-delivery period.
12.5 RISKS AND BENEFITS ASSOCIATED WITH STUDY PARTICIPATION
Ionizing radiation
In this study a chest x-ray (CXR) will be done at baseline in all participants for research purposes (or
one will be available from the routine care and treatment). The calculated effective dose for the
combination of these tests is 0.029 rem. The study has been reviewed and approved by the Radiation
Safety Committee (RSC) of NIH. The amount of radiation exposure in this study is below the dose
guideline established by the NIH RSC for research subjects. This guideline is an effective dose of 5 rem
(or 5,000 mrem) received per year.
Blood draw and apheresis
The potential risks of the needle stick for blood drawing and the venous catheter placement include
pain, bruising, hematoma, fainting, and, very rarely, infection. Other uncommon side effects of the
apheresis procedure include anxiety, chills, pain, and lightheadedness. There may also be a slightly
increased bleeding tendency for a few hours after the procedure due to the temporary presence of the
anticoagulant. Adverse reactions to leukapheresis procedures are rare. No more then 550 cc of blood
will be drawn for research during a 8-week period in accordance with NIH guidelines.
Discarded specimens collected for clinical reasons (blood, tissue, lung fluid) may also be used for
research.
Potential benefits associated with study participation include a potentially more intense than standard of
care follow up with laboratory and clinical evaluation.
At NIH, anti-retroviral medications and therapy for opportunistic infections will be provided by the
NIAID clinic so that adherence and medication changes can be followed closely. At the end of the
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
36
study (2-4 years), the participants may be provided with a 3-4 month supply until an alternate source of
therapy is identified. The social worker will assist with this transition prior to the end of study.
In Kenya, anti-retroviral medications and therapy for opportunistic infections will be provided free of
charge by the Kericho District Hospital at either the Kericho District Hospital HIV clinic or
KEMRI/WRP CRC satellite. Adherence and medication changes will be followed closely with
counseling by necessary medical staff including medical doctors, clinical officers, nurses, and
pharmacists. A social worker who is part of the research team will offer necessary services.
Regardless of study participation, patients will continue to receive antiretroviral therapy provided by
the Kericho District Hospital both during and after the study under the President’s Emergency Plan for
AIDS Relief.
In Thailand, antiretroviral and opportunistic infections therapy will be provided at no cost under the
Thai government’s universal health care coverage. Adherence counseling at every visit will be
performed by the physicians, study nurses and pharmacists.
12.6 Study Discontinuation
The study may be discontinued at any time by the NIAID IRB or the NIAID, or other government
agencies as part of their duties to ensure that research subjects are protected.
12.7 Remuneration
At the NIH/US site, subjects will receive $20 for each protocol mandated scheduled study visit to
compensate for inconvenience and extra blood drawn for research purposes. Additionally, $100 will be
given for each 2-pass pheresis. Participants may receive partial remuneration (payment) for the
immediate costs associated with their study-related expenses (travel costs, lodging, etc). Participation in
optional biopsies (gastrointestinal and lymph node) will be compensated according to those protocols.
At the KEMRI/WRP/Kenya site, participants will receive 750 KSH (approximately 10 USD) for each
study defined visit and 500 KSH (approximately 7 USD) or less (at the discretion of the study team) for
each unscheduled visit.
In Thailand, participants will receive 1000 Baht (approximately 30 USD) for each study visit to pay for
travel and to compensate for loss of work time.Subjects will receive an additional 1500 (approximately
45 USD) for each visit with apheresis and an additional 1500 Baht (approximately 45 USD) for each
visit with gut biopsy. These procedures will be done at Chulalongkorn University Hospital and will
likely be done on a different day as the main study visit. The reimbursement will cover the costs for
travel and food, and for loss of work time.
12.8 Illiterate, Blind or Foreign-speaking Subjects (US site)
When a subject is illiterate, blind and/or a non-English speaker, the short form consent process will be
carried out according to the NIH CC M-77-2 policy after approval from the NIAID IRB.
13. DATA MANAGEMENT AND RECORD RETENTION
13.1 Data Management Plan
At NIH, study data will be collected at the study site and maintained in an electronic data system
(CRIMSON) which will be completed on an ongoing basis during the study. Data entered into
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
37
electronic data systems shall be performed by authorized individuals. Corrections to electronic data
systems shall be tracked electronically (password protected) with time, date, individual making the
correction, and what was changed. Data from CRIMSON Data System will be collected directly from
subjects during study visits and telephone calls, or will be abstracted from subjects’ diaries, and
medical records.
At NIH and in Kenya and Thailand, the Investigator is responsible for assuring that the data collected is
complete, accurate, and recorded in a timely manner. Source documentation (the point of initial
recording of information) should support the data collected and must be signed and dated by the person
recording and/or reviewing the data. Source documents include all recordings of observations or
notations of clinical activities, and all reports and records necessary for the evaluation and
reconstruction of the clinical trial. Source documents include, but are not limited to, the subject’s
medical records, laboratory reports, ECG tracings, x-rays, radiologist’s reports, subject’s diaries, biopsy
reports, ultrasound photographs, progress notes, pharmacy records, and any other similar reports or
records of procedures performed during the subject’s participation in the study. The subject’s medical
record must record his/her participation in the clinical trial and what medications (with doses and
frequency) or other medical interventions or treatments were administered, as well as any adverse
reactions experienced during the trial.
13.2 Record Retention
Research records for all study subjects including history and physical findings, laboratory data, and
results of consultations are to be maintained by the investigators in a secure storage facility for a
minimum of 3 years following study completion. These records are to be maintained in compliance
with IRB and/or State and Federal requirements, whichever is longest. It is the investigator’s
responsibility to retain copies of source documents until notified in writing by NIAID that they can be
destroyed. NIAID must be notified in writing and acknowledgment must be received by the site prior to
destruction or relocation of research records.
In Kenya, research records will be maintained at the KEMRI/WRP Clinical Research Center in a
double locked, fire protected record archiving section. Records will be maintained for the period of
time following the study that meets necessary NIH, IDCRP, and Kenyan guidelines.
In Thailand, research records will be maintained at the SEARCH/TRC-ARC clinical research center in
a double locked data archiving section. Records will be maintained for the period of time following the
study that meets necessary NIH, IDCRP, Kenyan and Thai guidelines.
14. PUBLICATION OF RESEARCH FINDINGS
Publication of the results of this trial will be governed by the study team (chair and co-chairs). Any
presentation, abstract, or manuscript will be made available to the entire study team prior to submission
and will require approval by the Chair or Co-chairs or their designees.
15. BIOHAZARD CONTAINMENT
As the transmission of HIV-1 and other blood-borne pathogens can occur through contact with
contaminated needles, blood, and blood products appropriate blood and secretion precautions will be
employed by all personnel in the drawing of blood and shipping and handling of all specimens for this
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
38
study, as currently recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the
NIH and KEMRI for the Kenya site.
All infectious specimens will be transported using packaging mandated in the Code of Federal
Regulations, 42 CFR Part 72. Sites should refer to individual carrier guidelines (e.g., Federal Express,
Airborne Express) for specific instructions.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
39
15. REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
French, M.A., P. Price, and S.F. Stone, Immune restoration disease after antiretroviral therapy.
Aids, 2004. 18(12): p. 1615-27.
Shelburne, S.A., 3rd and R.J. Hamill, The immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome. AIDS
Rev, 2003. 5(2): p. 67-79.
Stoll, M. and R.E. Schmidt, Immune Restoration Inflammatory Syndromes: The Dark Side of
Successful Antiretroviral Treatment. Curr Infect Dis Rep, 2003. 5(3): p. 266-276.
French, M. and P. Price, Immune restoration disease in HIV patients: aberrant immune
responses after antiretroviral therapy. J HIV Ther, 2002. 7(2): p. 46-51.
French, M.A., Antiretroviral therapy. Immune restoration disease in HIV-infected patients on
HAART. AIDS Read, 1999. 9(8): p. 548-9, 554-5, 559-62.
Foudraine, N.A., et al., Immunopathology as a result of highly active antiretroviral therapy in
HIV-1-infected patients. Aids, 1999. 13(2): p. 177-84.
Breen, R.A., et al., Does immune reconstitution syndrome promote active tuberculosis in
patients receiving highly active antiretroviral therapy? Aids, 2005. 19(11): p. 1201-6.
Kumarasamy, N., et al., Clinical profile of HIV in India. Indian J Med Res, 2005. 121(4): p.
377-94.
Lawn, S.D., L.G. Bekker, and R.F. Miller, Immune reconstitution disease associated with
mycobacterial infections in HIV-infected individuals receiving antiretrovirals. Lancet Infect
Dis, 2005. 5(6): p. 361-73.
Lawn, S.D., L.G. Bekker, and R. Wood, How effectively does HAART restore immune
responses to Mycobacterium tuberculosis? Implications for tuberculosis control. Aids, 2005.
19(11): p. 1113-24.
Michailidis, C., et al., Clinical characteristics of IRIS syndrome in patients with HIV and
tuberculosis. Antivir Ther, 2005. 10(3): p. 417-22.
Mallal, S.A., I.R. James, and M.A. French, Detection of subclinical Mycobacterium avium
intracellulare complex infection in immunodeficient HIV-infected patients treated with
zidovudine. Aids, 1994. 8(9): p. 1263-9.
French, M.A., et al., Correction of human immunodeficiency virus-associated depression of
delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) after zidovudine therapy: DTH, CD4+ T-cell numbers, and
epidermal Langerhans cell density are independent variables. Clin Immunol Immunopathol,
1990. 55(1): p. 86-96.
Barbaro, D.J., V.L. Orcutt, and B.M. Coldiron, Mycobacterium avium-Mycobacterium
intracellulare infection limited to the skin and lymph nodes in patients with AIDS. Rev Infect
Dis, 1989. 11(4): p. 625-8.
Tangsinmankong, N., et al., Varicella zoster as a manifestation of immune restoration disease
in HIV-infected children. J Allergy Clin Immunol, 2004. 113(4): p. 742-6.
Rouanet, I., et al., Acute clinical hepatitis by immune restoration in a human immunodeficiency
virus/hepatitis B virus co-infected patient receiving antiretroviral therapy. Eur J Gastroenterol
Hepatol, 2003. 15(1): p. 95-7.
Safdar, A., et al., Fatal immune restoration disease in human immunodeficiency virus type 1infected patients with progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy: impact of antiretroviral
therapy-associated immune reconstitution. Clin Infect Dis, 2002. 35(10): p. 1250-7.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
40
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
Jubault, V., et al., Sequential occurrence of thyroid autoantibodies and Graves' disease after
immune restoration in severely immunocompromised human immunodeficiency virus-1-infected
patients. J Clin Endocrinol Metab, 2000. 85(11): p. 4254-7.
Rosenfeld, C.R. and L.H. Calabrese, Progression of autoimmune thyroiditis in an HIV-infected
woman on HAART. AIDS Read, 1999. 9(6): p. 393-4, 397.
Mirmirani, P., et al., Sarcoidosis in a patient with AIDS: a manifestation of immune restoration
syndrome. J Am Acad Dermatol, 1999. 41(2 Pt 2): p. 285-6.
Bartley, P.B., A.M. Allworth, and D.P. Eisen, Mycobacterium avium complex causing
endobronchial disease in AIDS patients after partial immune restoration. Int J Tuberc Lung
Dis, 1999. 3(12): p. 1132-6.
Nussenblatt, R.B. and H.C. Lane, Human immunodeficiency virus disease: changing patterns of
intraocular inflammation. Am J Ophthalmol, 1998. 125(3): p. 374-82.
John, M., J. Flexman, and M.A. French, Hepatitis C virus-associated hepatitis following
treatment of HIV-infected patients with HIV protease inhibitors: an immune restoration
disease? Aids, 1998. 12(17): p. 2289-93.
Chien, J.W. and J.L. Johnson, Paradoxical reactions in HIV and pulmonary TB. Chest, 1998.
114(3): p. 933-6.
de Boer, M.G., et al., Immune restoration disease in HIV-infected individuals receiving highly
active antiretroviral therapy: clinical and immunological characteristics. Neth J Med, 2003.
61(12): p. 408-12.
Shelburne, S.A., 3rd, et al., The role of immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome in AIDSrelated Cryptococcus neoformans disease in the era of highly active antiretroviral therapy. Clin
Infect Dis, 2005. 40(7): p. 1049-52.
Hawkey, C.R., et al., Characterization and management of paradoxical upgrading reactions in
HIV-uninfected patients with lymph node tuberculosis. Clin Infect Dis, 2005. 40(9): p. 1368-71.
Breen, R.A., et al., Paradoxical reactions during tuberculosis treatment in patients with and
without HIV co-infection. Thorax, 2004. 59(8): p. 704-7.
Miller, R.F., et al., Cerebral CD8+ lymphocytosis in HIV-1 infected patients with immune
restoration induced by HAART. Acta Neuropathol (Berl), 2004. 108(1): p. 17-23.
Stone, S.F., et al., Cytomegalovirus (CMV) retinitis immune restoration disease occurs during
highly active antiretroviral therapy-induced restoration of CMV-specific immune responses
within a predominant Th2 cytokine environment. J Infect Dis, 2002. 185(12): p. 1813-7.
Shen, Y., et al., Antiretroviral agents restore Mycobacterium-specific T-cell immune responses
and facilitate controlling a fatal tuberculosis-like disease in Macaques coinfected with simian
immunodeficiency virus and Mycobacterium bovis BCG. J Virol, 2001. 75(18): p. 8690-6.
Komanduri, K.V., et al., Restoration of cytomegalovirus-specific CD4+ T-lymphocyte responses
after ganciclovir and highly active antiretroviral therapy in individuals infected with HIV-1.
Nat Med, 1998. 4(8): p. 953-6.
Stone, S.F., et al., Levels of IL-6 and soluble IL-6 receptor are increased in HIV patients with a
history of immune restoration disease after HAART. HIV Med, 2002. 3(1): p. 21-7.
Stone, S.F., et al., Plasma bioavailable interleukin-6 is elevated in human immunodeficiency
virus-infected patients who experience herpesvirus-associated immune restoration disease after
start of highly active antiretroviral therapy. J Infect Dis, 2001. 184(8): p. 1073-7.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
41
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
Keane, N.M., et al., An evaluation of serum soluble CD30 levels and serum CD26 (DPPIV)
enzyme activity as markers of type 2 and type 1 cytokines in HIV patients receiving highly active
antiretroviral therapy. Clin Exp Immunol, 2001. 126(1): p. 111-6.
Price, P., et al., Polymorphisms in cytokine genes define subpopulations of HIV-1 patients who
experienced immune restoration diseases. Aids, 2002. 16(15): p. 2043-7.
Price, P., et al., MHC haplotypes affect the expression of opportunistic infections in HIV
patients. Hum Immunol, 2001. 62(2): p. 157-64.
Bourgarit, A., et al., Explosion of tuberculin-specific Th1-responses induces immune restoration
syndrome in tuberculosis and HIV co-infected patients. Aids, 2006. 20(2): p. F1-7.
Bukharie, H., Paradoxical response to anti-tuberculous drugs: resolution with corticosteroid
therapy. Scand J Infect Dis, 2000. 32(1): p. 96-7.
Shelburne, S.A., et al., Incidence and risk factors for immune reconstitution inflammatory
syndrome during highly active antiretroviral therapy. Aids, 2005. 19(4): p. 399-406.
Dean, G.L., et al., Treatment of tuberculosis in HIV-infected persons in the era of highly active
antiretroviral therapy. Aids, 2002. 16(1): p. 75-83.
Sungkanuparph, S., et al., Opportunistic infections after the initiation of highly active
antiretroviral therapy in advanced AIDS patients in an area with a high prevalence of
tuberculosis. Aids, 2003. 17(14): p. 2129-31.
Manabe, Y.C., et al., Immune Reconstitution Inflammatory Sydnrome. J Acquir Immune Defic
Syndr, 2007. 46(4): p. 456-462.
Robertson, J., et al., Immune reconstitution syndrome in HIV: validating a case definition and
identifying clinical predictors in persons initiating antiretroviral therapy. Clin Infect Dis, 2006.
42(11): p. 1639-46.
DHHS. Guidelines for the use of antiretroviral agents in HIV-1-infected adults and adolescents
http:// AIDSinfo.nih.gov.
Gooley, T.A., et al., Estimation of failure probabilities in the presence of competing risks: new
representations of old estimators. Stat Med, 1999. 18(6): p. 695-706.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
42
16. APPENDIX A: IRIS CRITERIA*
1. Initiation (reintroduction or change) in antiretroviral therapy/regimen.
AND
2. Evidence of:
a. an increase in CD4+ cell count as defined by ≥50 cells/mm3 or a ≥2- fold rise in CD4+ cell
count, and/or
b. decrease in the HIV-1 viral load of >0.5 log10
AND
3. Symptoms and/or signs consistent with an infectious/inflammatory condition.
AND
4. These symptoms and/or signs cannot be explained by a newly acquired infection, the expected
clinical course of a previously recognized infectious agent, or the side effects of antiretroviral
therapy itself.
AND
5. For purposes of data collection, the infectious/inflammatory condition must be attributable to a
specific pathogen or condition.
* AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) criteria May 24th 2005.
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
43
17. APPENDIX B- DAIDS TOXICITY TABLE
Division of AIDS table for grading the severity of
ADULT AND PEDIATRIC adverse events
Publish Date: December, 2004
Quick Reference
The Division of AIDS Table for Grading the Severity of Adult and Pediatric Adverse Events (“DAIDS
AE grading table”) is a descriptive terminology which can be utilized for Adverse Event (AE)
reporting. A grading (severity) scale is provided for each AE term.
General Instructions
Estimating Severity Grade
If the need arises to grade a clinical AE that is not identified in the DAIDS AE grading table, use the
category “Estimating Severity Grade” located at the top of Page 3. For AEs that are not listed in the
table but will be collected systematically for a study/trial, protocol teams are highly encouraged to
define study-specific severity scales within the protocol or an appendix to the protocol. (Please see
“Template Wording for the Expedited Adverse Event Reporting Section of DAIDS-sponsored
Protocols”.) This is particularly important for laboratory values because the “Estimating Severity
Grade” category only applies to clinical symptoms.
Grading Adult and Pediatric AEs
The DAIDS AE grading table includes parameters for grading both Adult and Pediatric AEs. When a
single set of parameters is not appropriate for grading specific types of AEs for both Adult and
Pediatric populations, separate sets of parameters for Adult and/or Pediatric populations (with specified
respective age ranges) are given in the table. If there is no distinction in the table between Adult and
Pediatric values for a type of AE, then the single set of parameters listed is to be used for grading the
severity of both Adult and Pediatric events of that type.
Determining Severity Grade
If the severity of an AE could fall under either one of two grades (e.g., the severity of an AE could be
either Grade 2 or Grade 3), select the higher of the two grades for the AE.
Definitions
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
44
Basic Self-care Functions
Adult
Activities such as bathing, dressing, toileting, transfer/movement,
continence, and feeding.
Young Children
Activities that are age and culturally appropriate (e.g., feeding self
with culturally appropriate eating implement).
LLN
Lower limit of normal
Medical Intervention
Use of pharmacologic or biologic agent(s) for treatment of an AE.
NA
Not Applicable
Operative Intervention
Surgical OR other invasive mechanical procedures.
ULN
Upper limit of normal
Usual Social & Functional
Activities
Adult
Adaptive tasks and desirable activities, such as going to work,
shopping, cooking, use of transportation, pursuing a hobby, etc.
Young Children
Activities that are age and culturally appropriate (e.g., social
interactions, play activities, learning tasks, etc.).
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
45
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions OR
Medical or operative
intervention indicated to
prevent permanent
impairment, persistent
disability, or death
Acute systemic
allergic reaction
Localized urticaria
(wheals) with no
medical intervention
indicated
Localized urticaria with
medical intervention
indicated OR Mild
angioedema with no
medical intervention
indicated
Generalized urticaria
OR Angioedema with
medical intervention
indicated OR
Symptomatic mild
bronchospasm
Acute anaphylaxis OR
Life-threatening
bronchospasm OR
laryngeal edema
Chills
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
NA
Fatigue
Malaise
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Incapacitating fatigue/
malaise symptoms
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
Fever (nonaxillary)
37.7 – 38.6C
38.7 – 39.3C
39.4 – 40.5C
>40.5C
Pain (indicate body
site)
DO NOT use for pain
due to injection (See
Injection Site
Reactions: Injection
site pain)
See also Headache,
Arthralgia, and
Myalgia
Pain causing no or
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Pain causing greater
than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Pain causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
Disabling pain causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions OR
Hospitalization (other
than emergency room
visit) indicated
Unintentional weight
loss
NA
5 – 9% loss in body
weight from baseline
10 – 19% loss in body
weight from baseline
20% loss in body
weight from baseline OR
Aggressive intervention
indicated [e.g., tube
feeding or total
parenteral nutrition
(TPN)]
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
ESTIMATING SEVERITY GRADE
Clinical adverse event
NOT identified
elsewhere in this
DAIDS AE grading
table
SYSTEMIC
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
46
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
Localized, no
systemic antimicrobial
treatment indicated
AND Symptoms
causing no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Systemic antimicrobial
treatment indicated
OR Symptoms
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Systemic antimicrobial
treatment indicated
AND Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities OR Operative
intervention (other than
simple incision and
drainage) indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
septic shock)
Pain/tenderness
limiting use of limb OR
Pain/tenderness
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Pain/tenderness
causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
Pain/tenderness causing
inability to perform basic
self-care function OR
Hospitalization (other
than emergency room
visit) indicated for
management of
pain/tenderness
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
INFECTION
Infection (any other
than HIV infection)
INJECTION SITE REACTIONS
Injection site pain
(pain without touching)
Or
Tenderness (pain
when area is touched)
Pain/tenderness
causing no or minimal
limitation of use of
limb
Injection site reaction (localized)
Adult >15 years
Erythema OR
Induration
of 5x5 cm – 9x9 cm
(or 25 cm2 – 81cm2)
Erythema OR
Induration OR Edema
>9 cm any diameter
(or >81 cm2)
Ulceration OR
Secondary infection OR
Phlebitis OR Sterile
abscess OR Drainage
Necrosis (involving
dermis and deeper
tissue)
Pediatric 15
years
Erythema OR
Induration OR Edema
present but 2.5 cm
diameter
Erythema OR
Induration OR Edema
>2.5 cm diameter but
<50% surface area of
the extremity segment
(e.g., upper arm/thigh)
Erythema OR Induration
OR Edema involving
50% surface area of
the extremity segment
(e.g., upper arm/thigh)
OR Ulceration OR
Secondary infection OR
Phlebitis OR Sterile
abscess OR Drainage
Necrosis (involving
dermis and deeper
tissue)
Itching localized to
injection site AND
Relieved
spontaneously or with
<48 hours treatment
Itching beyond the
injection site but not
generalized OR Itching
localized to injection
site requiring 48
hours treatment
Generalized itching
causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
NA
Thinning or patchy hair
loss detectable by
health care provider
Complete hair loss
NA
Pruritis associated
with injection
See also Skin: Pruritis
(itching - no skin
lesions)
SKIN – DERMATOLOGICAL
Alopecia
Thinning detectable
by study participant
(or by caregiver for
young children and
disabled adults)
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
47
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
Cutaneous reaction –
rash
Localized macular
rash
Diffuse macular,
maculopapular, or
morbilliform rash OR
Target lesions
Diffuse macular,
maculopapular, or
morbilliform rash with
vesicles or limited
number of bullae OR
Superficial ulcerations
of mucous membrane
limited to one site
Extensive or generalized
bullous lesions OR
Stevens-Johnson
syndrome OR Ulceration
of mucous membrane
involving two or more
distinct mucosal sites
OR Toxic epidermal
necrolysis (TEN)
Hyperpigmentation
Slight or localized
Marked or generalized
NA
NA
Hypopigmentation
Slight or localized
Marked or generalized
NA
NA
Pruritis (itching – no
skin lesions)
(See also Injection
Site Reactions:
Pruritis associated
with injection)
Itching causing no or
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Itching causing greater
than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Itching causing inability
to perform usual social
& functional activities
NA
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
CARDIOVASCULAR
Cardiac arrhythmia
(general)
(By ECG or physical
exam)
Asymptomatic AND
No intervention
indicated
Asymptomatic AND
Non-urgent medical
intervention indicated
Symptomatic, non-lifethreatening AND Nonurgent medical
intervention indicated
Life-threatening
arrhythmia OR Urgent
intervention indicated
Cardiacischemia/infarction
NA
NA
Symptomatic ischemia
(stable angina) OR
Testing consistent with
ischemia
Unstable angina OR
Acute myocardial
infarction
Hemorrhage
(significant acute
blood loss)
NA
Symptomatic AND No
transfusion indicated
Symptomatic AND
Transfusion of 2 units
packed RBCs (for
children 10 cc/kg)
indicated
Life-threatening
hypotension OR
Transfusion of >2 units
packed RBCs (for
children >10 cc/kg)
indicated
(with repeat
testing at same
visit)
>140 – 159 mmHg
systolic
OR
>90 – 99 mmHg
diastolic
>160 – 179 mmHg
systolic
OR
>100 – 109 mmHg
diastolic
>180 mmHg systolic
OR
>110 mmHg diastolic
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
malignant hypertension)
OR Hospitalization
indicated (other than
emergency room visit)
Pediatric 17
years
NA
91st – 94th percentile
adjusted for age,
height, and gender
(systolic and/or
diastolic)
≥95th percentile adjusted
for age, height, and
gender (systolic and/or
diastolic)
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
malignant hypertension)
OR Hospitalization
indicated (other than
emergency room visit)
Hypertension
Adult >17 years
(with repeat
testing at same
visit)
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
48
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
Hypotension
NA
Symptomatic,
corrected with oral
fluid replacement
Symptomatic, IV fluids
indicated
Shock requiring use of
vasopressors or
mechanical assistance
to maintain blood
pressure
Pericardial effusion
Asymptomatic, small
effusion requiring no
intervention
Asymptomatic,
moderate or larger
effusion requiring no
intervention
Effusion with non-life
threatening physiologic
consequences OR
Effusion with non-urgent
intervention indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
tamponade) OR Urgent
intervention indicated
Adult >16 years
PR interval
0.21 – 0.25 sec
PR interval
>0.25 sec
Type II 2nd degree AV
block OR Ventricular
pause >3.0 sec
Complete AV block
Pediatric ≤16
years
1st degree AV block
(PR > normal for age
and rate)
Type I 2nd degree AV
block
Type II 2nd degree AV
block
Complete AV block
Adult >16 years
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.45 – 0.47
sec OR Increase
interval <0.03 sec
above baseline
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.48 – 0.49
sec OR Increase in
interval 0.03 – 0.05
sec above baseline
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.50 sec OR
Increase in interval
0.06 sec above
baseline
Life-threatening
consequences, e.g.
Torsade de pointes or
other associated serious
ventricular dysrhythmia
Pediatric ≤16
years
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.450 –
0.464 sec
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.465 –
0.479 sec
Asymptomatic, QTc
interval 0.480 sec
Life-threatening
consequences, e.g.
Torsade de pointes or
other associated serious
ventricular dysrhythmia
Thrombosis/embolism
NA
Deep vein thrombosis
AND No intervention
indicated (e.g.,
anticoagulation, lysis
filter, invasive
procedure)
Deep vein thrombosis
AND Intervention
indicated (e.g.,
anticoagulation, lysis
filter, invasive
procedure)
Embolic event (e.g.,
pulmonary embolism,
life-threatening
thrombus)
Vasovagal episode
(associated with a
procedure of any kind)
Present without loss
of consciousness
Present with transient
loss of consciousness
NA
NA
Ventricular
dysfunction
(congestive heart
failure)
NA
Asymptomatic
diagnostic finding AND
intervention indicated
New onset with
symptoms OR
Worsening symptomatic
congestive heart failure
Life-threatening
congestive heart failure
Prolonged PR interval
Prolonged QTc
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
49
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
GASTROINTESTINAL
Anorexia
Loss of appetite
without decreased
oral intake
Loss of appetite
associated with
decreased oral intake
without significant
weight loss
Loss of appetite
associated with
significant weight loss
Life-threatening
consequences OR
Aggressive intervention
indicated [e.g., tube
feeding or total
parenteral nutrition
(TPN)]
Ascites
Asymptomatic
Symptomatic AND
Intervention indicated
(e.g., diuretics or
therapeutic
paracentesis)
Symptomatic despite
intervention
Life-threatening
consequences
Cholecystitis
NA
Symptomatic AND
Medical intervention
indicated
Radiologic, endoscopic,
or operative intervention
indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
sepsis or perforation)
Constipation
NA
Persistent constipation
requiring regular use
of dietary
modifications,
laxatives, or enemas
Obstipation with manual
evacuation indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
obstruction)
Adult and
Pediatric 1 year
Transient or
intermittent episodes
of unformed stools
OR Increase of ≤3
stools over baseline
per 24-hour period
Persistent episodes of
unformed to watery
stools OR Increase of
4 – 6 stools over
baseline per 24-hour
period
Bloody diarrhea OR
Increase of ≥7 stools per
24-hour period OR IV
fluid replacement
indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
hypotensive shock)
Pediatric <1 year
Liquid stools (more
unformed than usual)
but usual number of
stools
Liquid stools with
increased number of
stools OR Mild
dehydration
Liquid stools with
moderate dehydration
Liquid stools resulting in
severe dehydration with
aggressive rehydration
indicated OR
Hypotensive shock
DysphagiaOdynophagia
Symptomatic but able
to eat usual diet
Symptoms causing
altered dietary intake
without medical
intervention indicated
Symptoms causing
severely altered dietary
intake with medical
intervention indicated
Life-threatening
reduction in oral intake
Mucositis/stomatitis
(clinical exam)
Indicate site (e.g.,
larynx, oral)
See Genitourinary for
Vulvovaginitis
See also DysphagiaOdynophagia and
Erythema of the
mucosa
Patchy
pseudomembranes or
ulcerations
Confluent
pseudomembranes or
ulcerations OR Mucosal
bleeding with minor
trauma
Tissue necrosis OR
Diffuse spontaneous
mucosal bleeding OR
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
aspiration, choking)
Diarrhea
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
50
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
Nausea
Transient (<24 hours)
or intermittent nausea
with no or minimal
interference with oral
intake
Persistent nausea
resulting in decreased
oral intake for 24 – 48
hours
Persistent nausea
resulting in minimal oral
intake for >48 hours OR
Aggressive rehydration
indicated (e.g., IV fluids)
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
hypotensive shock)
Pancreatitis
NA
Symptomatic AND
Hospitalization not
indicated (other than
emergency room visit)
Symptomatic AND
Hospitalization indicated
(other than emergency
room visit)
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
circulatory failure,
hemorrhage, sepsis)
Proctitis (functionalsymptomatic)
Also see
Mucositis/stomatitis
for clinical exam
Rectal discomfort
AND No intervention
indicated
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities OR Medical
intervention indicated
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities OR Operative
intervention indicated
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
perforation)
Vomiting
Transient or
intermittent vomiting
with no or minimal
interference with oral
intake
Frequent episodes of
vomiting with no or
mild dehydration
Persistent vomiting
resulting in orthostatic
hypotension OR
Aggressive rehydration
indicated (e.g., IV fluids)
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
hypotensive shock)
Alteration in
personality-behavior
or in mood (e.g.,
agitation, anxiety,
depression, mania,
psychosis)
Alteration causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Alteration causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Alteration causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Behavior potentially
harmful to self or others
(e.g., suicidal and
homicidal ideation or
attempt, acute
psychosis) OR Causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions
Altered Mental Status
For Dementia, see
Cognitive and
behavioral/attentional
disturbance (including
dementia and
attention deficit
disorder)
Changes causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Mild lethargy or
somnolence causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Confusion, memory
impairment, lethargy, or
somnolence causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Delirium OR
obtundation, OR coma
Ataxia
Asymptomatic ataxia
detectable on exam
OR Minimal ataxia
causing no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptomatic ataxia
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Symptomatic ataxia
causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
Disabling ataxia causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
Proctitis
NEUROLOGIC
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
51
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
Cognitive and
behavioral/attentional
disturbance (including
dementia and
attention deficit
disorder)
Disability causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
OR Specialized
resources not
indicated
Disability causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities OR
Specialized resources
on part-time basis
indicated
Disability causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities OR
Specialized resources
on a full-time basis
indicated
Disability causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions OR
Institutionalization
indicated
CNS ischemia
(acute)
NA
NA
Transient ischemic
attack
Cerebral vascular
accident (CVA, stroke)
with neurological deficit
Developmental delay
– Pediatric 16 years
Mild developmental
delay, either motor or
cognitive, as
determined by
comparison with a
developmental
screening tool
appropriate for the
setting
Moderate
developmental delay,
either motor or
cognitive, as
determined by
comparison with a
developmental
screening tool
appropriate for the
setting
Severe developmental
delay, either motor or
cognitive, as determined
by comparison with a
developmental
screening tool
appropriate for the
setting
Developmental
regression, either motor
or cognitive, as
determined by
comparison with a
developmental
screening tool
appropriate for the
setting
Headache
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions OR
Hospitalization indicated
(other than emergency
room visit) OR
Headache with
significant impairment of
alertness or other
neurologic function
Insomnia
NA
Difficulty sleeping
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Difficulty sleeping
causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
Disabling insomnia
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
Neuromuscular
weakness
(including myopathy &
neuropathy)
Asymptomatic with
decreased strength
on exam OR Minimal
muscle weakness
causing no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Muscle weakness
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Muscle weakness
causing inability to
perform usual social &
functional activities
Disabling muscle
weakness causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions OR
Respiratory muscle
weakness impairing
ventilation
Neurosensory
alteration (including
paresthesia and
painful neuropathy)
Asymptomatic with
sensory alteration on
exam or minimal
paresthesia causing
no or minimal
interference with
Sensory alteration or
paresthesia causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Sensory alteration or
paresthesia causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Disabling sensory
alteration or paresthesia
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
52
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
usual social &
functional activities
NA
1 seizure
2 – 4 seizures
Seizures of any kind
which are prolonged,
repetitive (e.g., status
epilepticus), or difficult
to control (e.g.,
refractory epilepsy)
NA
Increased frequency of
pre-existing seizures
(non-repetitive) without
change in seizure
character OR
Infrequent breakthrough seizures while
on stable medication
in a previously
controlled seizure
disorder
Change in seizure
character from baseline
either in duration or
quality (e.g., severity or
focality)
Seizures of any kind
which are prolonged,
repetitive (e.g., status
epilepticus), or difficult
to control (e.g.,
refractory epilepsy)
Seizure
– Pediatric <18 years
Seizure, generalized
onset with or without
secondary
generalization, lasting
<5 minutes with <24
hours post ictal state
Seizure, generalized
onset with or without
secondary
generalization, lasting
5 – 20 minutes with
< 24 hours post ictal
state
Seizure, generalized
onset with or without
secondary
generalization, lasting
>20 minutes
Seizure, generalized
onset with or without
secondary
generalization, requiring
intubation and sedation
Syncope (not
associated with a
procedure)
NA
Present
NA
NA
Vertigo
Vertigo causing no or
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Vertigo causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Vertigo causing inability
to perform usual social
& functional activities
Disabling vertigo
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
FEV1 or peak flow
reduced to
70 – 80%
FEV1 or peak flow
50 – 69%
FEV1 or peak flow
25 – 49%
Cyanosis OR FEV1 or
peak flow <25% OR
Intubation
Seizure: (new onset)
– Adult ≥18 years
See also Seizure:
(known pre-existing
seizure disorder)
Seizure: (known preexisting seizure
disorder)
– Adult ≥18 years
For worsening of
existing epilepsy the
grades should be
based on an increase
from previous level of
control to any of these
levels.
RESPIRATORY
Bronchospasm (acute)
Dyspnea or respiratory distress
Adult ≥14 years
Dyspnea on exertion
with no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Dyspnea on exertion
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Dyspnea at rest causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Respiratory failure with
ventilatory support
indicated
Pediatric <14
years
Wheezing OR
minimal increase in
Nasal flaring OR
Intercostal retractions
Dyspnea at rest causing
inability to perform usual
Respiratory failure with
ventilatory support
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
53
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
respiratory rate for
age
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
OR Pulse oximetry 90
– 95%
social & functional
activities OR Pulse
oximetry <90%
indicated
MUSCULOSKELETAL
Arthralgia
See also Arthritis
Joint pain causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Joint pain causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Joint pain causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Disabling joint pain
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
Arthritis
See also Arthralgia
Stiffness or joint
swelling causing no or
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Stiffness or joint
swelling causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Stiffness or joint
swelling causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Disabling joint stiffness
or swelling causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions
Adult ≥21 years
BMD* t-score
-2.5 to -1.0
BMD t-score <-2.5
Pathological fracture
(including loss of
vertebral height)
Pathologic fracture
causing life-threatening
consequences
Pediatric <21
years
BMD z-score
-2.5 to -1.0
BMD z-score <-2.5
Pathological fracture
(including loss of
vertebral height)
Pathologic fracture
causing life-threatening
consequences
Myalgia
(non-injection site)
Muscle pain causing
no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Muscle pain causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Muscle pain causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Disabling muscle pain
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
Osteonecrosis
NA
Asymptomatic with
radiographic findings
AND No operative
intervention indicated
Symptomatic bone pain
with radiographic
findings OR Operative
intervention indicated
Disabling bone pain with
radiographic findings
causing inability to
perform basic self-care
functions
Cervicitis
(symptoms)
(For use in studies
evaluating topical
study agents)
For other cervicitis see
Infection: Infection
(any other than HIV
infection)
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions
Cervicitis
(clinical exam)
Minimal cervical
abnormalities on
examination
Moderate cervical
abnormalities on
examination
Severe cervical
abnormalities on
examination (erythema,
Epithelial disruption
>75% total surface
Bone Mineral Loss
GENITOURINARY
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
54
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
(For use in studies
evaluating topical
study agents)
For other cervicitis see
Infection: Infection
(any other than HIV
infection)
(erythema,
mucopurulent
discharge, or friability)
OR Epithelial
disruption
<25% of total surface
(erythema,
mucopurulent
discharge, or friability)
OR Epithelial
disruption of 25 – 49%
total surface
mucopurulent
discharge, or friability)
OR Epithelial disruption
50 – 75% total surface
Inter-menstrual
bleeding (IMB)
Spotting observed by
participant OR
Minimal blood
observed during
clinical or colposcopic
examination
Inter-menstrual
bleeding not greater in
duration or amount
than usual menstrual
cycle
Inter-menstrual bleeding
greater in duration or
amount than usual
menstrual cycle
Hemorrhage with lifethreatening hypotension
OR Operative
intervention indicated
Urinary tract
obstruction (e.g.,
stone)
NA
Signs or symptoms of
urinary tract
obstruction without
hydronephrosis or
renal dysfunction
Signs or symptoms of
urinary tract obstruction
with hydronephrosis or
renal dysfunction
Obstruction causing lifethreatening
consequences
Vulvovaginitis
(symptoms)
(Use in studies
evaluating topical
study agents)
For other
vulvovaginitis see
Infection: Infection
(any other than HIV
infection)
Symptoms causing no
or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Symptoms causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Symptoms causing
inability to perform basic
self-care functions
Vulvovaginitis
(clinical exam)
(Use in studies
evaluating topical
study agents)
For other
vulvovaginitis see
Infection: Infection
(any other than HIV
infection)
Minimal vaginal
abnormalities on
examination OR
Epithelial disruption
<25% of total surface
Moderate vaginal
abnormalities on
examination OR
Epithelial disruption of
25 - 49% total surface
Severe vaginal
abnormalities on
examination OR
Epithelial disruption
50 - 75% total surface
Vaginal perforation OR
Epithelial disruption
>75% total surface
Uveitis
Asymptomatic but
detectable on exam
Symptomatic anterior
uveitis OR Medical
intervention indicated
Posterior or pan-uveitis
OR Operative
intervention indicated
Disabling visual loss in
affected eye(s)
Visual changes (from
baseline)
Visual changes
causing no or minimal
interference with
usual social &
functional activities
Visual changes
causing greater than
minimal interference
with usual social &
functional activities
Visual changes causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities
Disabling visual loss in
affected eye(s)
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
OCULAR/VISUAL
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
55
CLINICAL
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
ENDOCRINE/METABOLIC
Abnormal fat
accumulation
(e.g., back of neck,
breasts, abdomen)
Detectable by study
participant (or by
caregiver for young
children and disabled
adults)
Detectable on physical
exam by health care
provider
Disfiguring OR Obvious
changes on casual
visual inspection
NA
Diabetes mellitus
NA
New onset without
need to initiate
medication OR
Modification of current
medications to regain
glucose control
New onset with initiation
of medication indicated
OR Diabetes
uncontrolled despite
treatment modification
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
ketoacidosis,
hyperosmolar nonketotic coma)
Gynecomastia
Detectable by study
participant or
caregiver (for young
children and disabled
adults)
Detectable on physical
exam by health care
provider
Disfiguring OR Obvious
on casual visual
inspection
NA
Hyperthyroidism
Asymptomatic
Symptomatic causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities OR Thyroid
suppression therapy
indicated
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities OR
Uncontrolled despite
treatment modification
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
thyroid storm)
Hypothyroidism
Asymptomatic
Symptomatic causing
greater than minimal
interference with usual
social & functional
activities OR Thyroid
replacement therapy
indicated
Symptoms causing
inability to perform usual
social & functional
activities OR
Uncontrolled despite
treatment modification
Life-threatening
consequences (e.g.,
myxedema coma)
Lipoatrophy
(e.g., fat loss from the
face, extremities,
buttocks)
Detectable by study
participant (or by
caregiver for young
children and disabled
adults)
Detectable on physical
exam by health care
provider
Disfiguring OR Obvious
on casual visual
inspection
NA
IRIS Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
56
LABORATORY
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
HEMATOLOGY
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
Standard International Units are listed in italics
Absolute CD4+ count
– Adult and Pediatric
>13 years
(HIV NEGATIVE ONLY)
300 – 400/mm3
300 – 400/µL
200 – 299/mm3
200 – 299/µL
100 – 199/mm3
100 – 199/µL
<100/mm3
<100/µL
Absolute lymphocyte
count
– Adult and Pediatric
>13 years
(HIV NEGATIVE ONLY)
600 – 650/mm3
0.600 x 109 –
0.650 x 109/L
500 – 599/mm3
0.500 x 109 –
0.599 x 109/L
350 – 499/mm3
0.350 x 109 –
0.499 x 109/L
<350/mm3
<0.350 x 109/L
Absolute neutrophil count (ANC)
Adult and Pediatric,
>7 days
1,000 – 1,300/mm3
1.000 x 109 –
1.300 x 109/L
750 – 999/mm3
0.750 x 109 –
0.999 x 109/L
500 – 749/mm3
0.500 x 109 –
0.749 x 109/L
<500/mm3
<0.500 x 109/L
Infant†, 2 – 7 days
1,250 – 1,500/mm3
1.250 x 109 –
1.500 x 109/L
1,000 – 1,249/mm3
1.000 x 109 –
1.249 x 109/L
750 – 999/mm3
0.750 x 109 –
0.999 x 109/L
<750/mm3
<0.750 x 109/L
Infant†, 1 day
4,000 – 5,000/mm3
4.000 x 109 –
5.000 x 109/L
3,000 – 3,999/mm3
3.000 x 109 –
3.999 x109/L
1,500 – 2,999/mm3
1.500 x 109 –
2.999 x 109/L
<1,500/mm3
<1.500 x 109/L
Fibrinogen, decreased
100 – 200 mg/dL
1.00 – 2.00 g/L
OR
0.75 – 0.99 x LLN
75 – 99 mg/dL
0.75 – 0.99 g/L
OR
0.50 – 0.74 x LLN
50 – 74 mg/dL
0.50 – 0.74 g/L
OR
0.25 – 0.49 x LLN
<50 mg/dL
<0.50 g/L
OR
<0.25 x LLN
OR
Associated with gross
bleeding
Adult and Pediatric
 57 days
(HIV POSITIVE
ONLY)
8.5 – 10.0 g/dL
1.32 – 1.55 mmol/L
7.5 – 8.4 g/dL
1.16 – 1.31 mmol/L
6.50 – 7.4 g/dL
1.01 – 1.15 mmol/L
<6.5 g/dL
<1.01 mmol/L
Adult and Pediatric
 57 days
(HIV NEGATIVE
ONLY)
10.0 – 10.9 g/dL
1.55 – 1.69 mmol/L
OR
Any decrease
2.5 – 3.4 g/dL
0.39 – 0.53 mmol/L
9.0 – 9.9 g/dL
1.40 – 1.54 mmol/L
OR
Any decrease
3.5 – 4.4 g/dL
0.54 – 0.68 mmol/L
7.0 – 8.9 g/dL
1.09 – 1.39 mmol/L
OR
Any decrease
 4.5 g/dL
 0.69 mmol/L
<7.0 g/dL
<1.09 mmol/L
Infant†, 36 – 56 days
(HIV POSITIVE OR
NEGATIVE)
8.5 – 9.4 g/dL
1.32 – 1.46 mmol/L
7.0 – 8.4 g/dL
1.09 – 1.31 mmol/L
6.0 – 6.9 g/dL
0.93 – 1.08 mmol/L
<6.00 g/dL
<0.93 mmol/L
Infant†, 22 – 35 days
(HIV POSITIVE OR
NEGATIVE)
9.5 – 10.5 g/dL
1.47 – 1.63 mmol/L
8.0 – 9.4 g/dL
1.24 – 1.46 mmol/L
7.0 – 7.9 g/dL
1.09 – 1.23 mmol/L
<7.00 g/dL
<1.09 mmol/L
Hemoglobin (Hgb)
57
LABORATORY
PARAMETER
Infant†, 1 – 21 days
(HIV POSITIVE OR
NEGATIVE)
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
12.0 – 13.0 g/dL
1.86 – 2.02 mmol/L
10.0 – 11.9 g/dL
1.55 – 1.85 mmol/L
9.0 – 9.9 g/dL
1.40 – 1.54 mmol/L
<9.0 g/dL
<1.40 mmol/L
International Normalized
Ratio of prothrombin time
(INR)
1.1 – 1.5 x ULN
1.6 – 2.0 x ULN
2.1 – 3.0 x ULN
>3.0 x ULN
Methemoglobin
5.0 – 10.0%
10.1 – 15.0%
15.1 – 20.0%
>20.0%
Prothrombin Time (PT)
1.1 – 1.25 x ULN
1.26 – 1.50 x ULN
1.51 – 3.00 x ULN
>3.00 x ULN
Partial Thromboplastin
Time (PTT)
1.1 – 1.66 x ULN
1.67 – 2.33 x ULN
2.34 – 3.00 x ULN
>3.00 x ULN
Platelets, decreased
100,000 –
124,999/mm3
100.000 x 109 –
124.999 x 109/L
50,000 –
99,999/mm3
50.000 x 109 –
99.999 x 109/L
25,000 –
49,999/mm3
25.000 x 109 –
49.999 x 109/L
<25,000/mm3
<25.000 x 109/L
WBC, decreased
2,000 – 2,500/mm3
2.000 x 109 –
2.500 x 109/L
1,500 – 1,999/mm3
1.500 x 109 –
1.999 x 109/L
1,000 – 1,499/mm3
1.000 x 109 –
1.499 x 109/L
<1,000/mm3
<1.000 x 109/L
CHEMISTRIES
Standard International Units are listed in italics
Acidosis
NA
pH <normal, but 7.3
pH <7.3 without lifethreatening
consequences
pH <7.3 with lifethreatening
consequences
Albumin, serum, low
3.0 g/dL – < LLN
30 g/L – < LLN
2.0 – 2.9 g/dL
20 – 29 g/L
< 2.0 g/dL
< 20 g/L
NA
Alkaline Phosphatase
1.25 – 2.5 x ULN†
2.6 – 5.0 x ULN†
5.1 – 10.0 x ULN†
> 10.0 x ULN†
Alkalosis
NA
pH > normal, but  7.5
pH >7.5 without lifethreatening
consequences
pH >7.5 with lifethreatening
consequences
ALT (SGPT)
1.25 – 2.5 x ULN
2.6 – 5.0 x ULN
5.1 – 10.0 x ULN
>10.0 x ULN
AST (SGOT)
1.25 – 2.5 x ULN
2.6 – 5.0 x ULN
5.1 – 10.0 x ULN
>10.0 x ULN
Bicarbonate, serum, low
16.0 mEq/L – < LLN
16.0 mmol/L – < LLN
11.0 – 15.9 mEq/L
11.0 – 15.9 mmol/L
8.0 – 10.9 mEq/L
8.0 – 10.9 mmol/L
<8.0 mEq/L
<8.0 mmol/L
Adult and Pediatric
>14 days
1.1 – 1.5 x ULN
1.6 – 2.5 x ULN
2.6 – 5.0 x ULN
5.0 x ULN
Infant†, ≤14 days
(non-hemolytic)
NA
20.0 – 25.0 mg/dL
342 – 428 µmol/L
25.1 – 30.0 mg/dL
429 – 513 µmol/L
>30.0 mg/dL
>513.0 µmol/L
Infant†, ≤14 days
(hemolytic)
NA
NA
20.0 – 25.0 mg/dL
342 – 428 µmol/L
>25.0 mg/dL
>428 µmol/L
Bilirubin (Total)
Calcium, serum, high (corrected for albumin)
58
LABORATORY
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
Adult and Pediatric
≥7 days
10.6 – 11.5 mg/dL
2.65 – 2.88 mmol/L
11.6 – 12.5 mg/dL
2.89 – 3.13 mmol/L
12.6 – 13.5 mg/dL
3.14 – 3.38 mmol/L
>13.5 mg/dL
>3.38 mmol/L
Infant†, <7 days
11.5 – 12.4 mg/dL
2.88 – 3.10 mmol/L
12.5 – 12.9 mg/dL
3.11 – 3.23 mmol/L
13.0 – 13.5 mg/dL
3.245 – 3.38 mmol/L
>13.5 mg/dL
>3.38 mmol/L
Calcium, serum, low (corrected for albumin)
Adult and Pediatric
≥7 days
7.8 – 8.4 mg/dL
1.95 – 2.10 mmol/L
7.0 – 7.7 mg/dL
1.75 – 1.94 mmol/L
6.1 – 6.9 mg/dL
1.53 – 1.74 mmol/L
<6.1 mg/dL
<1.53 mmol/L
Infant†, <7 days
6.5 – 7.5 mg/dL
1.63 – 1.88 mmol/L
6.0 – 6.4 mg/dL
1.50 – 1.62 mmol/L
5.50 – 5.90 mg/dL
1.38 – 1.51 mmol/L
<5.50 mg/dL
<1.38 mmol/L
Cardiac troponin I (cTnI)
NA
NA
NA
Levels consistent with
myocardial infarction
or unstable angina as
defined by the
manufacturer
Cardiac troponin T (cTnT)
NA
NA
NA
0.20 ng/mL
OR
Levels consistent with
myocardial infarction
or unstable angina as
defined by the
manufacturer
Adult ≥18 years
200 – 239 mg/dL
5.18 – 6.19 mmol/L
240 – 300 mg/dL
6.20 – 7.77 mmol/L
> 300 mg/dL
> 7.77 mmol/L
NA
Pediatric <18 years
170 – 199 mg/dL
4.40 – 5.15 mmol/L
200 – 300 mg/dL
5.16 – 7.77 mmol/L
> 300 mg/dL
> 7.77 mmol/L
NA
Creatine Kinase
3.0 – 5.9 x ULN†
6.0 – 9.9 x ULN†
10.0 – 19.9 x ULN†
20.0 x ULN†
Creatinine
1.1 – 1.3 x ULN†
1.4 – 1.8 x ULN†
1.9 – 3.4 x ULN†
3.5 x ULN†
Nonfasting
116 – 160 mg/dL
6.44 – 8.88 mmol/L
161 – 250 mg/dL
8.89 – 13.88 mmol/L
251 – 500 mg/dL
13.89 – 27.75 mmol/L
>500 mg/dL
>27.75 mmol/L
Fasting
110 – 125 mg/dL
6.11 – 6.94 mmol/L
126 – 250 mg/dL
6.95 – 13.88 mmol/L
251 – 500 mg/dL
13.89 – 27.75 mmol/L
>500 mg/dL
>27.75 mmol/L
Adult and Pediatric
≥1 month
55 – 64 mg/dL
3.05 – 3.55 mmol/L
40 – 54 mg/dL
2.22 – 3.06 mmol/L
30 – 39 mg/dL
1.67 – 2.23 mmol/L
<30 mg/dL
<1.67 mmol/L
Infant†, <1 month
50 – 54 mg/dL
2.78 – 3.00 mmol/L
40 – 49 mg/dL
2.22 – 2.77 mmol/L
30 – 39 mg/dL
1.67 – 2.21 mmol/L
<30 mg/dL
<1.67 mmol/L
<2.0 x ULN without
acidosis
2.0 x ULN without
acidosis
Increased lactate with
pH <7.3 without lifethreatening
Increased lactate with
pH <7.3 with lifethreatening
Cholesterol (fasting)
Glucose, serum, high
Glucose, serum, low
Lactate
59
LABORATORY
PARAMETER
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
GRADE 3
SEVERE
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
consequences
consequences
LDL cholesterol (fasting)
Adult ≥18 years
130 – 159 mg/dL
3.37 – 4.12 mmol/L
160 – 190 mg/dL
4.13 – 4.90 mmol/L
190 mg/dL
4.91 mmol/L
NA
Pediatric >2 - <18
years
110 – 129 mg/dL
2.85 – 3.34 mmol/L
130 – 189 mg/dL
3.35 – 4.90 mmol/L
≥190 mg/dL
≥4.91 mmol/L
NA
Lipase
1.1 – 1.5 x ULN
1.6 – 3.0 x ULN
3.1 – 5.0 x ULN
>5.0 x ULN
Magnesium, serum, low
1.2 – 1.4 mEq/L
0.60 – 0.70 mmol/L
0.9 – 1.1 mEq/L
0.45 – 0.59 mmol/L
0.6 – 0.8 mEq/L
0.30 – 0.44 mmol
/L
<0.60 mEq/L
<0.30 mmol/L
Pancreatic amylase
1.1 – 1.5 x ULN
1.6 – 2.0 x ULN
2.1 – 5.0 x ULN
>5.0 x ULN
Adult and Pediatric
>14 years
2.5 mg/dL – <LLN
0.81 mmol/L – <LLN
2.0 – 2.4 mg/dL
0.65 – 0.80 mmol/L
1.0 – 1.9 mg/dL
0.32 – 0.64 mmol/L
<1.00 mg/dL
<0.32 mmol/L
Pediatric 1 year – 14
years
3.0 – 3.5 mg/dL
0.97 – 1.13 mmol/L
2.5 – 2.9 mg/dL
0.81 – 0.96 mmol/L
1.5 – 2.4 mg/dL
0.48 – 0.80 mmol/L
<1.50 mg/dL
<0.48 mmol/L
Pediatric <1 year
3.5 – 4.5 mg/dL
1.13 – 1.45 mmol/L
2.5 – 3.4 mg/dL
0.81 – 1.12 mmol/L
1.5 – 2.4 mg/dL
0.48 – 0.80 mmol/L
<1.50 mg/dL
<0.48 mmol/L
Potassium, serum, high
5.6 – 6.0 mEq/L
5.6 – 6.0 mmol/L
6.1 – 6.5 mEq/L
6.1 – 6.5 mmol/L
6.6 – 7.0 mEq/L
6.6 – 7.0 mmol/L
>7.0 mEq/L
>7.0 mmol/L
Potassium, serum, low
3.0 – 3.4 mEq/L
3.0 – 3.4 mmol/L
2.5 – 2.9 mEq/L
2.5 – 2.9 mmol/L
2.0 – 2.4 mEq/L
2.0 – 2.4 mmol/L
<2.0 mEq/L
<2.0 mmol/L
Sodium, serum, high
146 – 150 mEq/L
146 – 150 mmol/L
151 – 154 mEq/L
151 – 154 mmol/L
155 – 159 mEq/L
155 – 159 mmol/L
160 mEq/L
160 mmol/L
Sodium, serum, low
130 – 135 mEq/L
130 – 135 mmol/L
125 – 129 mEq/L
125 – 129 mmol/L
121 – 124 mEq/L
121 – 124 mmol/L
120 mEq/L
120 mmol/L
Triglycerides (fasting)
NA
500 – 750 mg/dL
5.65 – 8.48 mmol/L
751 – 1,200 mg/dL
8.49 – 13.56 mmol/L
>1,200 mg/dL
>13.56 mmol/L
Uric acid
7.5 – 10.0 mg/dL
0.45 – 0.59 mmol/L
10.1 – 12.0 mg/dL
0.60 – 0.71 mmol/L
12.1 – 15.0 mg/dL
0.72 – 0.89 mmol/L
>15.0 mg/dL
>0.89 mmol/L
Phosphate, serum, low
URINALYSIS
Standard International Units are listed in italics
Hematuria (microscopic)
6 – 10 RBC/HPF
> 10 RBC/HPF
Gross, with or without
clots OR with RBC
casts
Transfusion indicated
Proteinuria, random
collection
1+
2–3+
4+
NA
1,000 – 1,999 mg/24 h
1.000 – 1.999 g/d
2,000 – 3,500 mg/24 h
2.000 – 3.500 g/d
>3,500 mg/24 h
>3.500 g/d
Proteinuria, 24 hour collection
Adult and Pediatric
10 years
200 – 999 mg/24 h
0.200 – 0.999 g/d
60
LABORATORY
PARAMETER
Pediatric > 3 mo <10 years
GRADE 1
MILD
GRADE 2
MODERATE
201 – 499 mg/m2/24 h
0.201 – 0.499 g/d
500 – 799 mg/m2/24 h
0.500 – 0.799 g/d
GRADE 3
SEVERE
800 – 1,000
mg/m2/24 h
0.800 – 1.000 g/d
GRADE 4
POTENTIALLY
LIFE-THREATENING
>1,000 mg/ m2/24 h
>1.000 g/d
* bone mineral density (BMD)
61
18. APPENDIX C- PROTOCOL RELATED RESEARCH USE OF STORED HUMAN
SAMPLES, SPECIMENS AND DATA
1. INTENDED USE OF THE SAMPLES/SPECIMENS/DATA
Samples and data collected under this protocol will be used to study the
immunopathogenesis of immune reconstitution in immune deficient patients with HIV
infection. HLA genetic testing will be performed.
2. HOW SAMPLES/SPECIMENS/DATA WILL BE STORED
Samples will be stored and tracked utilizing the NCI FCRF REPOSITORY operated by
SAIC FREDERICK.
3. WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO THE SAMPLES/SPECIMENS/DATA AT THE COMPLETION OF
THE PROTOCOL?
In the future, other investigators (both at NIH and outside) may wish to study these
samples and/or data. In that case, IRB approval must be sought prior to any sharing of
samples. Any clinical information shared about the sample with or without patient
identifiers would similarly require prior IRB approval.
At the completion of the protocol (termination), samples and data will either be destroyed,
or after IRB approval, transferred to another existing protocol or a repository.
5. WHAT CIRCUMSTANCES WOULD PROMPT THE PI TO REPORT TO THE IRB LOSS OR
DESTRUCTION OF SAMPLES/SPECIMENS/DATA
The NIH Intramural Protocol Violation definition related to loss of or destruction of samples
(for example, due to freezer malfunction) will be followed in reporting to the IRB: The violation
compromises the scientific integrity of the data collected for the study.
Any loss or unanticipated destruction of samples (for example, due to freezer malfunction) or
data (for example, misplacing a printout of data with identifiers) will be reported to the IRB.
62
19. APPENDIX D-KERICHO SITE SPECIFIC APPENDIX
63
A Cohort Observational Study Evaluating Predictors, Incidence And
Immunopathogenesis Of Immune Reconstitution Syndrome (IRIS)
In HIV-1 Infected Patients With CD4 Count <100 Cells/µL Who Are Initiating
Antiretroviral Therapy
Study Conducted By
U.S. Military HIV Research Program, Rockville, MD, U.S.A.
U.S. Army Medical Research Unit-Kenya / Kenya Medical Research Institute-Walter Reed Project
HIV Program
Study Sponsored By
Infectious Disease Clinical Research Program
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
NIH # 06-I-0086
KEMRI # 1470
IDCRP # 008
64
Kericho Site Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
APPENDIX D: KERICHO SITE SPECIFIC ADDENDUM
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. KERICHO AND U.S. PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATORS / PROTOCOL
CHAIRS & CO-CHAIR ................................................................................................. 66
2. OTHER KERICHO SITE STAFF ........................................................................... 67
3. LOCAL IRB ............................................................................................................... 68
4. KERICHO SITE DESCRIPTION .......................................................................... 69
5. INFORMED CONSENT PROCESS .................................................................................... 74
6. SUBJECT ENROLLMENT AND FOLLOW-UP ............................................................... 74
7. KERICHO SITE SCHEDULE OF EVENTS1,2 ................................................................... 76
8. LABORATORY EVALUATIONS FOR STUDY VOLUNTEERS ................................... 78
9. PROTOCOL MONITORING .............................................................................................. 79
10. DATA MANAGEMENT PLAN .......................................................................................... 80
11. STUDY RISKS AND BENEFITS ........................................................................................ 81
12. REPORTING TO IRBS ........................................................................................... 81
A.
B.
C.
D.
ANNUAL REPORTING ............................................................................................................ 81
UNANTICIPATED ADVERSE EVENTS OR SERIOUS ADVERSE EVENTS .................................. 81
MODIFICATIONS OF THE PROTOCOL .................................................................................... 82
PROTOCOL DEVIATIONS ...................................................................................................... 82
13. CONFIDENTIALITY AND STORAGE OF DOCUMENTS............................... 82
14. POLICY REGARDING RESEARCH-RELATED INJURIES ........................... 83
65
Kericho Site Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
1. KERICHO AND U.S. PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATORS / PROTOCOL CHAIRS
& CO-CHAIR
A.
Site Principal Investigator / Protocol Chair:
Fredrick Sawe, MBChB MMED
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-724-255-623
E-mail: fsawe@wrp-kch.org
Site Principal Investigator / Protocol Co-Chair:
Douglas N. Shaffer, MD, MHS
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-724-255-620
E-mail: dshaffer@wrp-kch.org
B.
United States Principal Investigator / Protocol Chair:
Irini Sereti, MD, MHS
Division of Clinical Research, National Institute of Allergy & Infectious Diseases,
National Institutes of Health
Bldg 10, Rm 11C103 (MSC 1880)
10 Center Drive
Bethesda, MD 20892
Phone: 301-496-5533
66
Kericho Site Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
2. OTHER KERICHO SITE STAFF
A.
Associate Investigators
Kibet Shikuku, MBChB, MMED
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-720-789-843
E-mail: kshikuku@wrp-kch.org
Eunice Obiero, MBChB, MMED
Kericho District Hospital
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200
Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-721-474-804
E-mail: obieroe@africaonline.co.ke
Samoel Khamadi, PhD
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
B.
Nurse Coordinator
Hellen Ngeno, BSN
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-720-250-920
E-mail: hngeno@wrp-kch.org
C.
Local Medical Monitor
Jonah Maswai, MBChB, MPH
Kenya Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project HIV Program
Hospital Road
67
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
P.O. Box 1357
Kericho, 20200; Kenya
Mobile phone: 254-722-672-548
E-mail: jmaswai@wrp-kch.org
3. LOCAL IRB
Kenya Medical Research Institute Ethics Review Committee
FWA #00002066
P.O. Box 54840, 00200
Nairobi, 00200, Kenya
Telephone: 254-20-2722541
Fax: 254-20-2720030
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
68
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
4. KERICHO SITE DESCRIPTION
A. General Overview
Site and Population Description
The US Army Medical Research Unit-Kenya (USAMRU-K) is a Special Foreign Activity of
the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research (WRAIR), Washington, DC. USAMRU-K is
affiliated through a Cooperative Agreement with the Kenya Medical Research Institute
(KEMRI). The unit was activated on a temporary basis in 1969 at the invitation of the
Government of Kenya to study trypanosomiasis. The success of that initial venture led to the
establishment of a permanent activity in 1973. Over the past 32 years, research has been
conducted on
malaria, trypanosomiasis,
leishmaniasis,
entomology, human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV)/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) and
arboviruses, with more than 250 manuscripts published.
The USAMRU-K HIV Program is a component of the US Military HIV Research Program
(USMHRP). In Kenya, the HIV Program field site is located at the KEMRI/WRP Clinical
Research Center [CRC]) about 260 kilometers northwest of Nairobi along the NairobiKisumu highway in the rural Kenyan town of Kericho (1). Kericho’s district population is
approximately 500,000, although the larger catchments area for both HIV research and
treatment is approximately 2.5 million covering the southern portion of the Rift Valley
Province. Kericho is located among the African Highlands in the Rift Valley and well
known for the tea that is grown in this region and the rolling “seas of green” within the tea
plantations. The primary tribe represented in Kericho is Kipsigis, a sub-tribe of the Kalenjin
tribe. Kisii, Luhya, and Luo tribes are also represented in Kericho, and to a lesser extent
Kikuyu. Kiswahili is most often spoken within the town; however and consistent with the
predominant tribe, Kipsigis is more often spoken in the rural villages around Kericho. The
primary industry in this region is tea with two large, international tea companies being
centered in Kericho District: James Finlay, Kenya Ltd. and Unilever Tea Kenya Ltd.
Kericho was ranked as the twentieth richest district in Kenya in the 2005/06 national
integrated household budget survey. Income in Kericho comes mainly from agricultural
activities, with about 40-50% of the population living below the poverty line. The annual
national gross domestic product per capita in 2005 averaged KSh 35,045 (equivalent to USD
565 at current exchange rates of 1 USD = KSh 62 (2). In Kenya, the age of majority (i.e.
legal age of recognized adulthood or independence) is 18 years. The Kenyan national
literacy level according the Kenya Adult Literacy Survey report published in March 2007 by
the Kenya National Bureau of Statistics was 64%. In Kericho, the literacy level is 74.3% in
men and 68.9% in women (3). The healthcare system in the larger Kericho area (southern
Rift Valley) is primarily provided by the government through a network of public hospitals,
health centers, and dispensaries run by the Kenya Ministry of Health. The government health
facilities do not charge for treatment but levy a small fee for facility maintenance, which can
be waived for those not able to pay. In addition to government health care facilities, there are
a few faith based and private health care facilities providing services at a small fee. Acess to
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
69
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
most health care facilities is good given a fairly reliable public transport system exists in the
region.
The KEMRI/WRP CRC is the primary HIV research site. Situated on the grounds of the
Kericho District Hospital (KDH)/Ministry of Health (MOH), the 7100 square feet CRC
supports both HIV vaccine and therapeutics/operational research and care and treatment in
the southern Rift Valley Province. The CRC is composed of a clinical area including a
central pharmacy that provides both vaccine and study drug products as well as additional
non-study medicines for HIV and other non-study related care. The CRC is a designated
satellite HIV clinic under the KDH. The CRC also contains a state-of-the-art research
laboratory and Information Technology (IT) center that support both HIV research and
treatment programs. Both the CRC pharmacy and laboratory are approved by the National
Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases/Division of AIDS (NIAID/DAIDS) to participate
in DAIDS sponsored vaccine (Site # 1502) and therapeutics (Site #12501) studies, the only
research site with such approval in Kenya.
Ongoing and Future Research
The KEMRI/WRP HIV program has a vibrant research portfolio. Completing follow-up in
December 2006, the HIV program is currently in the close-out phase of Kenya’s largest
prospective, observational HIV cohort study: “HIV and Malaria Cohort Study Among
Plantation Workers and Adult Dependents in Kericho, Kenya” (4). A key precursor to
conducting HIV vaccine research, the HIV cohort study opened in June, 2003. After a 6month enrollment period, the study followed an initial, closed cohort of 2801 adult plantation
workers and dependents bi-annually for 36 months. The primary goals of the study were to
describe HIV incidence and prevalence, HIV risk factors and related infections, HIV vaccine
study feasibility and acceptability, and to develop local “normal” laboratory values that can
be used for HIV research in this area. In addition to description of local HIV genotype (1),
key manuscripts have been published regarding HIV prevalence and the relationship between
traditional circumcision and incident HIV (5,6).
Currently, the next cohort study is under protocol review and anticipated to open in 2008 (7).
This “high risk cohort study” aims to ascertain HIV-1 prevalence, incidence, cohort
retention, and host genetics and viral diversity in high risk cohorts in East Africa. This study
is a non-randomized, closed cohort, prospective, serial three-monthly follow-up, 18-month
observational study. In Kenya, the study population will include men and women, aged 1550 years old, who are members of the following high risk groups: Commercial Sex Workers
(CSWs), Barworkers (BWs), Sexually Transmitted Infection Clinic Attendees (STIAs), and
Truck Drivers (TDs).
In April 2006, the first and largest HIV vaccine study to date outside of Nairobi (the third in
Kenya’s history and the first US government-sponsored HIV vaccine study in Kenya) opened
at the KEMRI/WRP CRC (8). Sponsored by the National Institutes of Health (NIH)’s
Vaccine Research Center, this study was a Phase I/II clinical trial evaluating the safety and
immunogenicity of a multiclade HIV-1 DNA plasmid vaccine boosted by a multiclade HIV-1
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
70
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
recombinant adenovirus-5 vector in HIV uninfected adult volunteers in East Africa. The
Kericho program enrolled 120 subjects in total in both phase I and II components, completed
final vaccinations in February 2007, and completed follow-up in August 2007. In follow-up
to this Phase I/II DNA/rAd5 vaccine study, the HIV program has been preparing to
participate in the follow-on Phase IIb “test of concept” vaccine study. Currently under
consideration by NIAID, this study is to be conducted under the “Partnership for AIDS
Vaccine Evaluation” (PAVE) consortium including the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC), HIV Vaccine Trials Network (HVTN), International AIDS Vaccine
Initiative (IAVI), and USMHRP in North and South America as well as Africa. The HIV
Program is scheduled to enroll 700 volunteers in larger Kericho District. Finally with regard
to vaccine research, the HIV program is currently being considered by the Division of
Retrovirology to conduct a Phase I DNA-Modified Vaccinia Ankara (MVA) vaccine study,
using WRAIR MVA product, possibly in 2009.
In addition to conducting HIV vaccine research, the HIV Program also conducts critical
operational research related to understanding best treatments for HIV/AIDS in Africa. In
May 2006, the program opened its first interventional, therapeutics trial, the “Optimal
Combination After Nevirapine Exposure (OCTANE)” study (9). USAMRU-K’s HIV
program is 1 of 10 sites in Africa to conduct this study sponsored by the NIH. This study
looks at optimal HIV treatments for women who have taken single dose nevirapine in the
context of Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT) of HIV. The fact that
USAMRU-K HIV PMTCT program has counseled over 140,000 pregnant women and given
single dose nevirapine to over 5,200 underscores the critical importance of such operational
research. After reaching the site’s initial enrollment quota, the site has been asked to
continuing enrolling in effort to facilitate overall study accrual.
The HIV Program plans to conduct two other NIH/AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG)
studies. The first study (A5190) is titled “Assessment of Safety and Toxicity among Infants
Born To HIV-1-Infected Women Enrolled in Antiretroviral Treatment Protocols in Diverse
Areas of the World” (10). This is a prospective, observational, cohort study of infants born
to HIV-1-infected women while enrolled in NIH-sponsored, international, antiretroviral
treatment protocols. Infants enrolled in the study will be followed prospectively to describe
the safety, toxicity, and potential side effects of in utero and breast milk exposure to the ARV
drugs used in international treatment protocols. Second, the site has been invited by ACTG
to participate in A5221, “A Strategy Study of Immediate Versus Deferred Initiation of
Antiretroviral Therapy for HIV-Infected Persons Treated for Tuberculosis with CD4 <200
cells/mm3” (11). A5221 is a randomized, open-label study to determine whether the strategy
of immediate [within approximately 2 weeks after starting treatment for tuberculosis (TB)]
versus deferred (8-12 weeks after start of TB treatment) initiation of antiretroviral therapy
(ART) reduces mortality and AIDS-defining events in participants being treated for TB.
The HIV program will be conducting qualitative research as well as public health evaluations
as complimentary operational research to ongoing and future HIV research and treatment. In
collaboration with the University of California at San Diego, the HIV Program will conduct a
multi- center, qualitative study to assess the acceptability of amenorrhea secondary to
contraception and desired contraceptive features among HIV-infected women in different
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
71
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
cultural settings (12). With support from the United States Presidents Emergency Plan for
AIDS Relief (PEPFAR), protocol development is underway for a Public Health Evaluation
(PHE) titled “Clinic-based ART & Diagnostic Evaluation (CLADE)” (13). CLADE is a
clinic-based, randomized (1:1), non-blinded, controlled, study aimed at evaluating the
superiority of two Kenya MOH antiretroviral therapy (ART) diagnostic evaluations in
treatment naive patients beginning MOH approved first-line ART: “routine care,” the most
common approach to ART roll-out where CD4 and clinical World Health Organization
(WHO) staging are the primary initial diagnostic and follow-up evaluations; and, “viral load
guided care”, where viral loads are incorporated into evaluations consistent with the most
recent MOH 2007 guidelines.
Finally, the HIV program (KEMRI and WRP) conducts studies in collaboration with the
Boston University School of Public Health (BU). The BU-KEMRI-WRP collaboration has
already successfully completed a study describing the impact of HIV-morbidity on labor
productivity in local tea estates (14). The results of this study were the foundation for the
second, ongoing phase of research. Having demonstrated the impact of HIV morbidity on
labor productivity, this second phase of research now evaluates the impact of antiretroviral
therapy on labor productivity and other quality-of-life determinants. This collaboration is
also conducting two other studies 1) “Economic Outcomes of Antiretroviral Therapy in the
Southern Rift Valley Province”, which evaluates economic outcomes of persons receiving
ART in rural households; and, 2) “Costs and Outcomes of Models for Delivering
Antiretroviral Therapy for HIV/AIDS in Kenya”, which is evaluating cost of providing ART
District Hospital or Health Canters in Southern Rift Valley Province.
B. HIV and Opportunistic Infections
As elsewhere in Kenya, HIV disease is a significant health burden in Kericho. HIV
prevalence estimates for the larger Kericho area of the south Rift Valley Province range from
6% (based upon Demographic and Health Survey estimates for “rural” Kenya) to 14% (based
upon research conducted by the HIV program in Kericho) (5,15). HIV prevalence reaches
nearly 20% in females in some areas (15). Systematically collected and published data
regarding prevalence of opportunistic infections (OIs) in Kenya is limited. Most recent
guidelines published by the MOH broadly note a range of OIs based upon CD4 count and
WHO Stage that has often been used in describing OIs in Western settings (16). These OIs
include the following in order of progressing WHO stage and decreasing CD4 count:
pulmonary tuberculosis, oral thrush and oral hairy leukoplakia, Kaposi’s sarcoma,
Pneumocystis jiroveci pneumonia, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, esophageal candidiasis,
cryptosporidiosis, chronic herpes, cerebral toxoplasmosis, cryptococcus, cytomegalovirus
retinitis, and Mycobacterium avium complex. More specific reference to OIs in Kenya
focuses upon Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Pneumocystis jiroveci pneumonia,
cryptosporidiosis, toxoplasmosis, cytomegalovirus, Mycobacterium avium complex,
Salmonella typhi, and Streptococcus pneumoniae (17). In addition to this list more local to
Kenya, cryptococcal meningitis and Kaposi’s sarcoma are seen with notable prevalence as
well.
C. HIV Prevention, Care, and Treatment
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
72
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
In addition to primary HIV vaccine and drug research, the USMARU-K HIV Program also
supports comprehensive HIV prevention, care, and treatment services as one of the US
Government agencies implementing the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief
through the US Embassy in Nairobi. The US Department of Defense (DOD)/USAMRU-K
HIV Program recognized the importance of bringing comprehensive HIV/AIDS services to
the larger Kericho area of the south Rift Valley Province where research is ongoing.
Twenty-four months prior to the first vaccine clinical trail, the HIV Program brought HIV
treatment to the Kericho District through the Emergency Plan. In close collaboration with
the Kenya MOH and through the US Embassy in Nairobi, the HIV Program has to date
opened 25 ART centers in 8 districts of the south Rift Valley Province with a total population
of 2.5 million people. In addition, 170 PMTCT of HIV clinics and 40 Voluntary Counseling
and Testing (VCT) centers have been opened. One faith based organization in the Kericho
District has been developed to provide Abstinence and “Be faithful” (AB) services. Two
Orphans and Vulnerable Children (OVC) programs have been opened.
The US DOD’s Emergency Plan roll out in Kericho has been recognized for its success as
highlighted by the US Embassy in Nairobi for visits by Ambassadors Bellamy and
Ranneberger, the Assistant to the President on Policy and Strategic Planning (Mr. M.
Gerson), the Ambassador for the Office of the Global Aids Coordinator (O-GAC), the
Institute of Medicine during their evaluation of Emergency Plan programs in Kenya, and
many others. To date in the southern Rift Valley Province, the US DOD has directly aided
the Kenya MOH to enroll almost 20,000 Kenyans in to HIV clinics, start nearly 10,000
Kenyans on life-saving antiretroviral therapy, treat over 1000 persons with HIV/TB coinfection, provide HIV counseling and testing to almost 100,000 Kenyans, offer AB
messages/services to nearly 125,000 Kenyans, provide PMTCT services to over 140,000
Kenyan mothers, and provide care to almost 1200 orphans and vulnerable children.
Among HIV clinics in the southern Rift Valley Province, the KDH is by far the largest and
most successful. It is possibly the largest District Hospital HIV clinic in Kenya (18,19). To
date, the KDH HIV Clinic has enrolled approximately 6000 Kenyans, approximately half
starting on first line antiretroviral therapy. Most recent analyses of data available suggest a
12-month mortality rate of approximately 8%.
D. Roles of Researchers
For the Kericho site, the primary role of the researchers will be study execution as
outlined in the protocol and relevant standard operating procedures. All participants in
this study will be enrolled in the Kericho District Hospital HIV clinic; however, some
out-patient HIV care may be provided at the Kericho Clinical Research Center consistent
with routine practices for all research conducted at the Kericho Clinical Research Center.
As with all HIV studies conducted at the Clinical Research Center, HIV+ participants in
IRIS will have the support of the PEPFAR program for dealing with any HIV-related
incidental findings and various other medical issues that may occur where appropriate as
covered by the Kericho District Hospital.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
73
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
5. INFORMED CONSENT PROCESS
For the Kericho site, the informed consent process follows a Standard Operating Procedure
and begins with the first contact with a potential study participant and continues throughout
the course of study. The initial consent process will be conducted by the designated study
personnel in a dedicated room at the Kericho District Hospital and may proceed with or
without antecedent group education depending upon the potential participant’s preference.
The English informed consent document has been translated into Kiswahili and will be
administered in the either language based upon the potential participant’s preference.
Patients need to understand either Kiswahili or English to participate in the study. In the
event that the subject is illiterate, a witness will be present during the entire consenting
process and will sign the consent document according to study Standard Operating
Procedure. The informed consent process will be accomplished and documented before any
study related procedures begin. The subject will be given a copy of the signed informed
consent form as per Standard Operation Procedure.
6. SUBJECT ENROLLMENT AND FOLLOW-UP
Two hundred volunteers with advanced HIV (CD4 count <100 cells/mm3) will be recruited
over 2 years (100 year-1, and 100 year-2). Volunteers will be recruited primarily from the
KDH HIV clinic, combined HIV/TB clinic, and in-patient wards and followed according to
Kenya MOH guidelines for routine HIV care and treatment at the KEMRI/WRP CRC
satellite clinic (18). Based upon evaluation and at the discretion of the clinician, volunteers
may be recruited from other nearby hospitals if follow-up is not deemed to be troublesome as
is the practice at KDH. Follow-up for the observational study is consistent with routine HIV
care visits as recommended by the Kenya MOH (20).
Recruitment will occur at the Kericho District Hospital primarily at (but not limited to) the
HIV (Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy (HAART)) Clinic, combined TB/HIV Clinic, and
in-patient wards according to a study recruitment Standard Operating Procedures document.
At the discretion of the PI, volunteers may be recruited similarly from nearby hospitals.
Briefly, initial recruitment will occur primarily by word of mouth. Interested individuals will
be provided a study informed consent document (Kiswahili and/or English versions) to take
home and invited to speak further with study staff if interested. Open educational sessions
regarding the study as well as individual informed consent sessions will be offered for
interested persons. Routine clinical and laboratory information (e.g. medical history, CD4
count) available as part of standard medical care may be used in the decision to invite the
clinic patients to learn about the IRIS study. For example, a patient with a CD4 count of
250/mm3 will not be invited to potentially participate in the study. Patients who decide they
are not interested in participating in the study or who do not provide consent will continue
routine HIV care. Patients who express further interest to participate will proceed to formal
consenting process by the study PI or designee. Patients who provide informed consent will
be escorted by a study nurse or designee to the KEMRI/WRP Clinical Research Center in
order to start the study related procedures.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
74
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
75
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
7. KERICHO SITE SCHEDULE OF EVENTS1,2
Evaluation
Documentation of HIV (R)
Medical & Medication History (C)
Nadir CD4 Count (C)
Clinical Assessment (C)
Physical Exam (C)
BMI (C)
Hematology (CBC and differential) (C)
ESR (R)
Chemistries3 (C)
Amylase/Lipase (C)
Lipid Profile (fasting) (C)
Albumin (R)
Urinalysis (C)
Pregnancy Test (C)
Flow Cytometry (C, R)
HIV-RNA (C, R)
HIV genotype ( R )
Hepatitis B, C (C, R)
Cryptococcal Serum Ag (C)
PPD6 (R)
RPR (C)
Cervical Pap Smear (C)
Eye Clinic Evaluation (C, R)
Chest X-Ray (R)
HLA-Typing (R)
Stored PBMC/Plasma (R)
Stored Serum (R)
Photography9 (R)
Screening
(-28 days)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X4
Pre-ART/ART
(-27 to 0 days)
Wk0
Wk 2
Wk 4
Wk 8
Wk 12
Wk 24
Wk 36
Wk 48
Wks 64
& 80
Wk 96
(EOS)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X5
X
X
X
X
X
X
X7
X8
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
as clinically indicated
X
X
X
X
X
X
as clinically indicated and annually
as clinically indicated
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
C only
X
X
X
X
X6
X
X
as clinically indicated
X6
X6
X
X
as clinically indicated
as clinically indicated
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
as indicated
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
76
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
Kericho Site Schedule of Events Key
Evaluation codes: C=data obtained secondarily as part of routine clinical care; R=research related procedure; C, R=both clinical care and research related.
1. All visits are consistent with Kenya Ministry of Health follow-up for routine clinical care. Pre-ART and ART visits will be combined but tests may be performed in more than 1
day. Study participants will be seen by a clinical officer or medical officer at each study visit.
2. Phlebotomy volumes are 48mls for each visit except for the screening (8mLs) and entry (58mLs) visits. Phlebotomy will include only clinical laboratory evaluations when the
Hg is < 7.0 gm/dl. In cases where only clinical laboratory evaluations are used, any remaining discard samples may be used for research evaluations.
3. Chemistries will routinely include electrolytes (Na, K, Cl), urea, creatinine, non-fasting glucose, ALT/AST. Other tests (e.g. Ca) may be ordered at clinician’s discretion.
Chemistries will be completed during screening consistent with the standard of care and may be repeated during pre-ART/ART if clinically indicated.
4. Only CD4 performed at screening.
5. May be repeated once if required by laboratory.
6. PPD will be repeated at week 4 only if non-reactive at baseline. If non-reactive at baseline and week 4, PPD will be repeated at weeks 48 and 96.
7. Pap smears will be conducted at entry (may be delayed up to week 4) and at weeks 48 and 96 but is nnt required per protocol. Results from a local medical doctor will be
accepted.
8. And every 24 weeks thereafter until CD4 >100 cells/mm3 for >12 weeks or as clinically indicated.
9. With documented consent from volunteer.
Unless otherwise noted in the site-specific appendix, the parent protocol will be followed.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
77
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
8. LABORATORY EVALUATIONS FOR STUDY VOLUNTEERS
Laboratory support for patients receiving routine clinical care at the KDH is primarily provided
by the KDH laboratory. The KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory has served as the reference
laboratory for HIV care and treatment clinics in the southern Rift Valley Province from the
outset of the PEPFAR program in April 2004. Support initially focused upon safety labs (basic
chemistries including transaminases, complete blood counts) and CD4s as necessary to
promptly and safely open HIV clinics in response to the Emergency Plan. While initially
conducting all safety labs and CD4 counts for up to 11 treatment facilities in the southern Rift
Valley Province, technology to conduct safety labs has been transferred to 9 of the 11 sites. In
addition to serving as a back-up laboratory, the KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory provides
QA/QC support to HIV clinical laboratories in the region and HIV viral load testing for
persons suspected of antiretroviral therapy failure under the auspices of the MOH. The
KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory is scheduled to receive funding in 2008 under the Emergency
Plan to further develop the capacity to serve as the regional reference laboratory for early
infant diagnoses (HIV polymerase chain reaction [PCR]) as well as evaluation for common
opportunistic infections (e.g. Mycobacterium tuberculosis including culture capabilities,
microscopy for Pneumocystis jiroveci, serology for toxoplasmosis and cytomegalovirus).
The KDH laboratory is a MOH laboratory that has been developed with support from
KEMRI/WRP under the Emergency Plan to serve not only the KDH but also regional MOH
HIV clinical laboratories for safety labs and CD4 counts (technology transfer from the
KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory to KDH). Currently, the KDH laboratory conducts ZiehlNeelsen (ZN) staining for Acid Fast Bacilli (AFB). Specimens are sent to the National Public
Health Laboratory in Nairobi for TB cultures. In addition, the KDH laboratory conducts
routine gram stain, microscopy, culture and sensitivity for non-blood specimens, potassium
hydroxide staining for fungal infections, and examination of stool for ova and parasites.
Currently, the KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory supports HIV diagnostics including enzymelinked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), Western Blot, HIV viral load, and CD4 for both
observational cohort and interventional studies. In addition to HIV diagnostics, CD4, and HIV
viral loads, the laboratory also conducts routine chemistries and complete blood counts,
malaria slides for parasites, urine microscopy, India ink and Cryptococcus antigen testing
(CRAg), rapid plasma reagin (RPR)/serodia for syphilis, and hepatitis B serology. The
KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory is approved by the KEMRI, Kenya Medical Technicians Board,
and NIAID/DAIDS (for both vaccine [Site #1502] and therapeutics [Site #12501]) studies.
The KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory is currently enrolled in several external quality assurance
programs: College of American Pathologists (CAP) – hematology, flow cytometry, HIV
serology, chemistry, pregnancy, RPR, and hepatitis B surface antigen; WRAIR – HIV-1
serology, viral load; UKNEQAS – flow cytometry and hematology; CD Chex (Streck) – flow
cytometry; Canadian QASI – flow cytometry; VQA (Rash Laboratories USA) – HIV-1 RNA
and HIV-1 DNA (Whole Blood); CDC - HIV-1 DNA (DBS); HUQAS (Human Diagnostic) –
chemistry; and, IQAP (Beckmann Coulter) – hematology. The laboratory has also enrolled for
rapid HIV 1 and 2, HIV DNA (whole blood), and prothrombin time (PT)/partial
thromboplastin time (PTT) for 2008. The laboratory anticipates undergoing CAP accreditation
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
78
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
in January 2008. The KEMRI/WRP CRC lab will be the only CAP accredited laboratory in
Kenya and one of 4 in East Africa.
Routine care and treatment under this observational cohort protocol will be supported by the
Emergency Plan consistent with support provided in this region. Additional testing to be
incorporated in to the KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory for support of persons in HIV care and
treatment programs in this region will include ZN staining for AFB. PCR probes will be used
to differentiate M. tuberculosis from M. avium complex (MAC). In addition, silver staining for
P. jiroveci pneumonia will be introduced to the KEMRI/WRP CRC lab. Serological testing for
cytomegalovirus, toxoplasmosis, herpes simplex virus, and hepatitis C will also be conducted
at the KEMRI/WRP CRC laboratory. The USAMRU-K Kisumu sub-location laboratories will
perform routine blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cultures as well as diagnostic testing
(PCR) for both Salmonella typhi and brucella. Other tests available at the Kisumu laboratory
include PCR for rickettsia, leptospira, and influenza. All such testing would be at the
discretion of the clinician as indicated. Finally, the NIH laboratory will be utilized for clinical
diagnostic testing for pathogens not tested in Kenya (e.g. Epstein-Barr virus and
Cytomegalovirus PCR).
9. PROTOCOL MONITORING
Monitoring at the Kericho site will be conducted according to the “NIAID Intramural Clinical
Monitoring Guidelines.” Monitors under contract to the NIAID/Regulatory Compliance and
Human Subjects Protection Branch (RCHSPB) will visit the clinical research site to monitor all
aspects of the study in accordance with the appropriate regulations and the approved protocol.
The objectives of a monitoring visit will be: 1) to verify the existence of signed informed
consent documents for each monitored subject; 2) to verify the prompt and accurate recording
of all monitored data points, and prompt reporting of all SAEs; 3) to compare abstracted
information with individual subject’s records and source documents (subjects’ charts,
laboratory analyses and test results, physicians’ progress notes, nurses’ notes, and any other
relevant original subject information); and 4) to ensure protection of study subjects,
investigators’ compliance with the protocol, and completeness and accuracy of study records.
The monitors also will inspect the clinical site regulatory files to ensure that regulatory
requirements and applicable guidelines (International Conference on Harmonization- Good
Clinical Practices [ICH-GCP]) are being followed. During the monitoring visits, the
investigator (and/or designee) and other study personnel will be available to discuss the study
progress and monitoring visit.
The investigator (and/or designee) will make study documents (e.g. consent forms and
pertinent hospital or clinical records) readily available for inspection by the local institutional
review board (IRB), the site monitors, and the NIAID staff for confirmation of the study data.
A specific monitoring plan will be discussed with the Principal Investigator and study staff
prior to enrollment. The plan will outline the frequency of monitoring visits based on such
factors as study enrollment, data collection status and regulatory obligations.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
79
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
10. DATA MANAGEMENT PLAN
In Kenya, study data will be collected at the study site and maintained on paper case report
forms (CRFs). These forms are to be completed on an ongoing basis during the study. The
CRFs and instructions will be distributed to the site by the monitoring sponsor or printed by the
sites themselves after sponsor approval. Data entries on paper CRFs must be completed
legibly with black ballpoint pen. Corrections must be made by striking through the incorrect
entry with a single line (taking care not to obliterate or render the original entry illegible) and
entering the correct information adjacent to the incorrect entry. Corrections to paper CRFs
must be initialed and dated by the person making the correction. All CRFs should be reviewed
by the Investigator and signed as required. The CRFs will be stored at the Clinical Research
Center archive room (see below).
CRF data will be entered into the Research Support System (RSS) and Global Registry and
Enrollment System (GRES). Both are Oracle® based password, protected data systems
developed by the Henry M. Jackson Foundation in Rockville, Maryland, USA and used
extensively by USMHRP.
Study participant registry and enrollment entry date will be entered into GRES at the Kenya
Medical Research Institute/Walter Reed Project Clinical Research Center Information
Technology Department.
This database will contain identifiers such as Participant
Identification Number (PIN), participant names, and the HIV clinic ID number. These are all
used in coordinating follow-up. Other study data will be double entered into the RSS by two
data clerks. Reconciliation will be performed and any discrepancies will be resolved. Once
data entry is complete and reconciled, the CRFs will be filed in a locked, secured room. All
study data will be maintained in the RSS, with only the PIN serving as the identifier for each
participant.
Data will be stored in an Oracle® relational database. Database backups will occur daily.
Back-up sets will be stored in a secure fireproof cabinet in Kericho and at an offsite location.
A full copy of the cleaned RSS dataset (containing no participant identifiers) will be delivered
at least semi-annually and at study completion to the NIH for analysis.
The Clinical Research Center Information Technology Department is secured with limited
access controlled by an electronic lock. The server room is temperature controlled with
“sensor phones” to alert staff of any pre-set temperature deviations. All research servers are
backed up daily, and a copy of the backup saved securely in a fireproof safe at an offsite
location. The CRC archive room is secured by double locks, the inside lock being an
electronic PIN controlled lock. The Clinical Research Center (CRC) Information Technology
Department is within the larger Clinical Research Center complex, approved by the US
Embassy Regional Security Officer (RSO), guarded 24 hours a day, and protected by a
surrounding concrete fence. The offsite location is within the KEMRI/WRP Office complex is
across the road, approximately 20 meters away from the KEMRI/WRP CRC. The office
complex is approved by the US Embassy Regional Security Officer (RSO), guarded 24 hours a
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
80
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
day, and protected by 2 locked doors (the second being accessible only by entry of assigned
code for each staff).
11. STUDY RISKS AND BENEFITS
Potential study risks are limited in this observational study and include, but are not limited to,
primarily radiation and phlebotomy. Such risks are shared by persons receiving routine HIV
care and treatment. Steps have been taken to mitigate such risks.
The Kenya Radiation Protection Board has inspected and certified the Kericho District
Hospital X-ray Department and provides continued oversight. For all X-ray procedures, the
principle of ALARA (As Low As Reasonably Achievable) is applied to ensure that the
minimum radiation does of diagnostic value is given. As routine, patients are given clear
instructions and positioned appropriately for X-ray procedures, and a lead shield will be used
to protect the patient against scattered radiation. Data recording media are inspected for any
light leakage.
Phlebotomy practices at the KEMRI/WRP CRC are covered by a Standard Operating
Procedure. Briefly, trained and experienced study staff perform phlebotomy in designated and
equipped phlebotomy areas. Subjects with hemoglobin concentrations less than 7 gm/dl will
have blood drawn for tests necessary for the clinical management of the subject only. No
research related tests will be done for the subjects until the hemoglobin concentration is above
7 gm/dl. In cases where only clinical laboratory evaluations are used, any remaining discarded
samples may be used for research evaluations. Quality assurance/quality control procedures
are in place to ensure appropriate phlebotomy practices are observed. Specific procedure is
outlined in Standard Operating Procedure guiding the care for emergency/urgent phlebotomy
procedures (e.g. syncope or near syncope).
Discarded specimens collected for clinical reasons may be used for research evaluations.
12. REPORTING TO IRBS
A. ANNUAL REPORTING
A continuing review report will be submitted to all IRBs having overview of this study
including KEMRI, USUHS, and NIAID before the date determined by the IRB of record, but
not less than once a year. After all study related activities, including data analysis are
completed, a final report may be submitted to the IRBs.
B. UNANTICIPATED ADVERSE EVENTS OR SERIOUS ADVERSE EVENTS
All volunteers participating in this observational study will have adverse event (AE)
information collected by the clinic staff. The AEs will be graded as per the DAIDS Table for
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
81
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
Grading Severity of Adult Adverse Experiences, dated December 2004 (Appendix B). General
AE reporting is described in the main protocol (Section 11.1 and 11.2).
Additional reporting for the Kericho Site
Unanticipated problems involving risk to volunteers or others, serious adverse events (SAEs)
related to participation in the study and all volunteer deaths should be promptly reported to the
local IRB as well as all participating IRBs to include KEMRI, IDCRP, NIAID.
Similarly, unanticipated problems involving risk to subjects or others, SAEs related to
participation in the study and all subject deaths should be promptly reported By to the local and
all participating IRBs to include to KEMRI, USUHS, NIAID.
The medical monitor is also required to review all unanticipated problems involving risk to
subjects or others, SAEs and all subject deaths associated with the protocol and provide an
unbiased written report of the event. At a minimum, the medical monitor should comment on
the outcomes of the event or problem, and in the case of an SAE or death, comment on the
relationship t o participation in the study. The medical monitor should also indicate whether
he/she concurs with the details of the report provided by the study investigator. Reports for
events determined by either the investigator or medical monitor to be possibly or definitively
related to participation and reports of events resulting in death should be promptly forwarded
to all-participating IRBs.
C. MODIFICATIONS OF THE PROTOCOL
All amendments to this protocol will also be submitted to the IRBs having overview of this
study including KEMRI, USUHS, and NIAID. Written approval from all IRBs having
overview and implementation from the WRAIR Commander must be received prior to
implementation of any protocol amendment.
D. PROTOCOL DEVIATIONS
All IRBs having overview of this study including KEMRI, USUHS, and NIAID will all be
notified of any deviations/ departures from the protocol that may have an effect on the safety of
volunteers and integrity of the study. All deviations will be reported to the KEMRI IRB
immediately they occur and in the continuing review reports and the final study report to other
participating IRBs.
13. CONFIDENTIALITY AND STORAGE OF DOCUMENTS
Each study volunteer will be provided an identification number for study purposes. These
identification numbers will be used for all laboratory tests or samples stored for testing in
future studies. The study participants’ medical records and the list of names, addresses, and
identification numbers will be kept locked in file cabinets with access limited to study
personnel only. Any publication of this study will not use the study participant’s name or
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
82
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
identify him/her personally. Efforts will be made to keep the study participants’ personal
information confidential. The personal information may be disclosed if required by law.
Study records may be reviewed by any and/or all IRBs or regulatory bodies having overview
including KEMRI, USUHS, and NIH.
14. POLICY REGARDING RESEARCH-RELATED INJURIES
The study site will provide short-term medical care for any injury resulting from participation
in this research. The NIH or the U.S. Federal Government will not provide long-term medical
care or financial compensation for research-related injuries.
Should a participant be injured as a direct result of taking part in this research study, the
volunteer will be provided emergency medical care only, at no cost, for that injury. The U.S.
Federal Government will not provide long term care (more than 6 months) for any injuries
resulting from study participation. The participant will not receive any compensation for
illness or injury. The participant will be given information on where to get further treatment if
needed. The volunteer will be informed that this is not a waiver or release of your legal rights.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
83
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
12. SITE-SPECIFIC ADDENDUM REFERENCES
1. Kenya Integrated Household Budget Survey (2005/06). Kenya National Bureau of
Statistics, Ministry of Planning and National Development. 2007. (ISBN: 9966-767-08-8).
2. Kenya National Adult Literacy Survey. Kenya National Bureau of Statistics. March 2007.
3. U.S. Military HIV Research Program – Kenya. http://www.hivresearch.org/globalefforts/kenya.html. Accessed November 14, 2007.
4. HIV and Malaria Cohort Study Among Plantation Workers and Adult Dependents in
Kericho, Kenya. v29. RV142, WRAIR #855, KEMRI #590.
5. Foglia G, Sateren W, Renzullo P, et al. High Prevalence of HIV Infection Among Rural
Tea Plantation Residents in Kericho, Kenya. Epidemiol Infect 2007;Jun 29:1-9.
6. Shaffer D, Bautista C, Sateren W, et al. The Protective Effect of Circumcision on Incident
HIV in Rural, Low Risk Men Circumcised Predominately by Traditional Healers in Kenya:
Two-Year Follow-up of the Kericho HIV Cohort Study. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
2007;45(4):371-379.
7. HIV-1 Prevalence, Incidence, Cohort Retention, and Host Genetics and Viral Diversity in
High Risk Cohorts in East Africa. RV217b, WRAIR #1373, KEMRI TBD.
8. A Phase I/II Clinical Trial to Evaluate the Safety and Immunogenicity of a Multiclade
HIV-1 DNA Plasmid Vaccine Boosted by a Multiclade HIV-1 Recombinant Adenovirus-5
Vector Vaccine in HIV Uninfected Adult Volunteers in East Africa.
http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/show/NCT00123968?order=1. Accessed November 14, 2007.
9. Optimal
Combination
Therapy
After
Nevirapine
Exposure
(OCTANE).
http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/show/NCT00089505?order=1. Accessed November 14, 2007.
10. Assessment of Safety and Toxicity among Infants Born To HIV-1-Infected Women
Enrolled in Antiretroviral Treatment Protocols in Diverse Areas of the World
http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/show/NCT00100867?order=1. Accessed November 14, 2007.
11. A Strategy Study of Immediate Versus Deferred Initiation of Antiretroviral Therapy for
HIV-Infected Persons Treated for Tuberculosis with CD4 <200 Cells/mm3.
http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/show/NCT00108862?order=1. Accessed November 14, 2007.
12. Multi- Cultural Qualitative Assessment of Acceptability of amenorrhea Secondary to
Contraception and desired Contraceptive Feature Among HIV-Infected Women. RV221,
WRAIR #1348, KEMRI #1240.
13. CLADE: Clinic-based ART & Diagnostic Evaluation: A Public Health Evaluation of
Routine vs. Viral Load Guided ART in Rural Kenya. In development.
14. Fox M, Rosen S, MacLeod W, et al. The impact of HIV/AIDS on Labour Productivity in
Kenya. Trop Med Int Health 2004;9(3):318-24.
15. National AIDS and STI Control Programme, Ministry of Health, Kenya. AIDS in Kenya.
7th ed. Nairobi, Kenya: NASCOP; 2005.
16. National AIDS and STI Control Programme, Ministry of Health, Kenya. HIV Related
Opportunistic Infections, Diagnosis and Treatment: A Healthcare Workers Guide. 2 nd
Edition. Nairobi, Kenya: NASCOP; 2006.
17. Holmes C, Losina E, Walensky R, et al. Review of Human Immunodeficiency
Virus Type 1–Related Opportunistic Infections in Sub-Saharan Africa. Clinical Infectious
Diseases 2003; 36:652–62.
18. Muttai H, Obiero E, …, and Shaffer D. Integration of HIV and TB Services Within The
District Hospital: Experiences From the Kericho District Hospital in Kenya. Oral Abstract
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
84
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
Session. The President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief Implementers Meeting; Kigali,
Rwanda. June 16-19, 2007.
19. Obiero E, Langat B, Shaffer D, et al. Scaling Up An HIV/AIDS Clinic In Rural Kenya:
Experience From The Kericho District Hospital. Oral Abstract Session. The President’s
Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief Second Annual Field Meeting; Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
May 22-27, 2005.
20. National AIDS and STI Control Programme, Ministry of Health, Kenya. Kenya National
Clinical Manual For ART Providers: A Concise and Practical Guide to ART Provision.
2nd Edition. Nairobi, Kenya: NASCOP; 2007.
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
85
Kericho Site Specific Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
12. SIGNATURE OF PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR/SITE CHAIR
I will perform the foregoing protocol and Kericho specific addendum as written in the abovedescribed Study Protocol.
_______________________________________
Frederick K. Sawe
Site Principal Investigator/Chair, Kericho
__________________
_______________________________________
Douglas N. Shaffer
__________________
Date (dd/mm/yyyy)
SITE PRINCIP INVESTIGATOR/CO-CHAIR, KERICHO
(DD/MM/YYYY)
Version 5.2, June 2, 2011
DATE
86
Kericho Site Addendum
Version 5.2
June 2, 2011
APPENDIX E: THAILAND SITE ADDENDUM
87
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
A Cohort Observational Study Evaluating Predictors, Incidence And
Immunopathogenesis of Immune Reconstitution Syndrome (IRIS)
In HIV-1 Infected Patients with CD4 Count <100 Cells/µL who Are
Initiating Antiretroviral Therapy in Thailand
Study Conducted By
The South East Asia Research Collaboration with Hawaii, Bangkok, Thailand
The Thai Red Cross AIDS Research Centre, Bangkok, Thailand
The Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute, Nonthaburi, Thailand
The National Institute of Allergy & Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of
Health, Maryland, U.S.A.
Study Sponsored By
Infectious Disease Clinical Research Program
88
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
1. THAILAND AND U.S. PRINCIPAL
INVESTIGATORS / PROTOCOL
CHAIRS & CO-CHAIR
A. Site Principal Investigator / Protocol
Chair:
Jintanat Ananworanich, MD, PhD
South East Asia Research Collaboration
with Hawaii (SEARCH)
Thai Red Cross AIDS Research Centre
(TRCARC)
104 Rajdumri Road, Tower 2, 2nd floor
Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
Email: jintanat.a@searchthailand.org
Office phone: +662 254 2566 to 9
Mobile phone: +6681 341 4644
Site Co-Principal Investigators / SiteProtocol Co-Chairs:
Nittaya Phanuphak, MD
TRCARC
104 Rajdumri Road, Pathumwan
Bangkok 10330, Thailand
Email: nittaya.p@trcarc.org
Office phone: +662 253 0996 to 7
Mobile phone: +6681 825 3544
Somsit Tansuphaswadikul, MD
BIDI
126 Tiwanon Road, Muang
Nonthaburi 11000, Thailand
Email: somsittan@gmail.com
Office phone: +662 590 3631-2
Mobile phone: +6689 478 3003
Wisit Prasithsirikul, MD
BIDI
126 Tiwanon Road, Muang
Nonthaburi 11000, Thailand
Email: drwisit_p@yahoo.com
Office phone: +662 590 3631-2
Mobile phone: +6681 811 5610
B. United States Principal Investigator /
Protocol Chair:
Irini Sereti, MD, MHS
Division of Clinical Research, NIAID,
NIH
Bldg 10, Rm 11C103 (MSC 1880)
10 Center Drive
Bethesda, MD 20892
Email: ISereti@niaid.nih.gov
Phone: 301-496-5533
June 2, 2011
2. OTHER THAILAND SITE STAFF
A. Associate Investigators
Nipat Teeratakulpisarn, MD
TRCARC
104 Rajdumri Road, Pathumwan
Bangkok 10330, Thailand
Email: tnipat@trcarc.org
Office phone: +662 253 0996 to 7
Mobile phone: +6681 792 6220
Thep Chalermchai, MD
SEARCH and TRCARC
104 Rajdumri Road, Tower 2, 2nd floor
Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
Email: thep.c@searchthailand.org
Office phone: +662 254 2566 to 9
Mobile phone: +6681 555 2552
Alex Schuetz, PhD
AFRIMS, Retrovirology
315/6 Rajvithi Road, Bangkok 10400,
Thailand
Office phone:
Mobile phone: +6685 980 2464
B. Nurse Coordinator
Nitiya Chomchey, RN
SEARCH and TRCARC
104 Rajdumri Road, Tower 2, 2nd floor
Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
Email: nitiya.c@searchthailand.org
Office phone: +662 254 2566 to 9
Mobile phone: +6686 322 3522
C. Local Medical Monitor
Somchai Sriplienchan, MD, MPH
Department of Retrovirology
USAMC-AFRIMS
315/6 Rajvithi Road Bangkok, 10400, Thailand
Email: SomchaiS@afrims.org
Office phone: +662 644 4888 ext. 3415
3. LOCAL INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW
BOARDS (IRB)
Chulalongkorn University
FWA #00008378
Research Section, Faculty of Medicine
Chulalongkorn University
1873 Rama IV, Pathumwan, Bangkok
10330, Thailand.
Tel +662 256 4455 Ext 14, 15
89
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
Department of Disease Control
(DDC), Ministry of Public Health
FWA # 00013622
Tiwanond Road, Nonthaburi 11000,
Thailand
Tel +662 590 3175
Fax +662 965 9610
90
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
2. THAILAND SITE DESCRIPTION
A. General Overview
Site and Population Description (Figure 1)
The coordinating unit for this study will be the South East Asia Research Collaboration with
Hawaii (SEARCH) in Bangkok, Thailand. SEARCH is a subunit of the Thai Red Cross AIDS
Research Centre (TRCARC) and a collaboration between the US Armed Forces Research
Institute of Medical Sciences (AFRIMS), the University of Hawaii and the TRCARC.
Two clinical sites will be used for this study to recruit and follow subjects. These are 1) the
Thai Red Cross Anonymous Clinic (TRC-AC) which is a subunit of the TRCARC situated in
the same complex as SEARCH. Radiologic or invasive investigations will be done at
Chulalongkorn University Hospital, a sister organization of the TRCARC, which is next door
to the TRCARC. 2) Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute (BIDI) which is the largest
HIV and infectious hospital in Thailand. TRCARC and SEARCH have long term relationship
and track record in collaborating with BIDI for various HIV-related studies.
The laboratories involved in this study will be 1) the HIV Netherlands Australia Thailand
Research Collaboration (HIV-NAT) Laboratory. HIV-NAT is a subunit of the TRCARC and
is located within the same complex as SEARCH and TRC-AC. HIV-NAT will perform all
laboratories for this study and for both clinical sites 2) AFRIMS laboratory which will
perform the advanced flow cytometry and store samples.
Figure 1: Relationship between coordinating unit, clinical sites and laboratories involved
South East Asia Research Collaboration with Hawaii (SEARCH)
SEARCH was established in 2005 and has been the coordinating center for USHMRP’s
research studies on acute HIV infection, HIV sequencing in high risk populations and HIV
vaccine cohort One of the SEARCH studies, RV 254/SEARCH 010 study: “Establish and
characterize an acute HIV infection cohort at the TRC-AC”, is described in more detail here.
91
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
The study will evaluate the clinical, immunological, and virological characteristics of persons
with acute HIV infection and describe demographics and behavioral risk factors for HIV.
Optional study procedures performed in this study include leukopheresis, gut biopsy,
cerebrospinal fluid collection and brain MRI/MRS and anogenital sample collection. As of
December 2009, there are 15 acute HIV infection cases identified with 10 cases enrolled.
This study shows the capability of SEARCH to coordinate a complicated study with its
partners (TRC-AC, HIV-NAT laboratory, AFRIMS laboratory, Chulalongkorn University
Hospital). Dr. Jintanat Ananworanich, the principal investigator of this study, is Chief of
SEARCH and Deputy Director in Scientific Affairs at HIV-NAT and staff physician at the
TRC-AC. Therefore, she is in the position to ensure a smooth collaboration between the 3
subunits within the TRCARC.
Thai Red Cross Anonymous Clinic (TRC-AC)
The TRC-AC was established in 1991 as the first voluntary counseling and testing (VCT)
clinic in Thailand and in the region. Clients with HIV infection can receive services which
include latent and active tuberculosis case finding, CD4 count, HIV RNA, genotypic drug
resistance testing, ARV treatment and monitoring. In 2007, there were 6,125 new clients
(32% women, 54% heterosexual men and 14% men who have sex with men, MSM) and the
overall HIV prevalence rate was 15% (women 14.5%, heterosexual men 11.3%, MSM
30.1%). During 2006-2009, 2,647 clients were diagnosed with HIV infection. Percentage of
these clients who had CD4 cell count < 200 cells/mm3 was 35.3%, 27.6% and 46.9% in
women, men who have sex with men and heterosexual men, respectively.
HIV-NAT laboratory
The HIV-NAT laboratory facility comprises approximately 1,184 square ft of space. The
laboratory has the capacity to perform diagnostic immuno-assays for HIV, HBV, HCV,
syphilis, cell immunophenotyping by flow cytometry, HIV RNA quantitation, HIV DNA
PCR, p24 antigen, PCR for Chlamydia, gonorrhea, haematology, chemistry,
pharmacokinetics, and molecular biology-related techniques. The external quality assurance
programs participated include the UKNEQAS (UK national external quality assurance
scheme), the College of American Pathologists (CAP), the Virology Quality Assessment
Program (VQA) from Rush Presbyterian-St. Lukes Medical Center Chicago, Illinois and the
Walter Reed Army Institute of Research. The Cobas IT 5000 Solution laboratory information
system is used. The laboratory currently employs 7 full-time medical technologists, one part
time medical technologist, three assistant technologists, one scientist and one pharmacologist
in addition to a full-time manager.
Bamrasnaradura Infectious Disease Institute (BIDI)
The BIDI was designated by the Ministry of Public Health in 1987 as country’s premier
hospital for HIV/AIDS patients. With the country’s roll-out of antiretroviral (ARV) treatment
in 2000, the mortality rate for HIV patients in the BIDI has decreased from 33% in 1999 to
around 16% in the recent years. Approximately 50,000 services are currently provided at the
HIV out-patient clinic and approximately 1,500 services are provided at the HIV in-patient
clinic each year. Approximately 6,000 patients are currently receiving ARV at the BIDI with
around 400-500 patients eligible to start ARV each year. For this study, the BIDI will be
responsible for recruiting the participants from its out-patient and in-patient units and
performing study procedures.
B. HIV and Opportunistic Infections in Thailand
92
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
Currently, the prevalence of HIV infection in Thailand is 1.2% of adults with about 550,000
Thais living with HIV. The majority of Thailand’s HIV infections are reported to be through
heterosexual transmission, followed by male homosexual transmission. The five most
common opportunistic infections among HIV/AIDS patients in Thailand are Mycobacterium
tuberculosis (30.3%), Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (20.0%), cryptococcosis (14%),
candidiasis of esophagus, trachea or bronchi (4.9%) and recurrent bacterial pneumonia
(3.4%).
C. HIV Prevention, Care, and Treatment
Targeted prevention campaigns carried out in Thailand have significantly reduced HIV
incidence and prevalence with the number of new HIV infections per year reduced from over
140,000 in the early 1990s to about 14,000 in 2007. In 2000, Thailand started the roll-out of
ARV. In 2007, Thailand’s ARV coverage was about 60% with over 100,000 Thais receiving
ARV. This has led to substantial reductions in the number of HIV-related deaths. All Thai
nationals can access ARV and HIV-related treatments at no cost through the National Health
Security Office (NHSO), the Social Security Office (SSO) or the Civil Servant Medical
Benefit Scheme (CSMBS).
D. Roles of Researchers
The study will be coordinated by SEARCH. All participants in this study will be enrolled
from the TRC-AC and the BIDI. Both sites will provide out-patient HIV care and in-patient
care will be provided mainly at the BIDI. Subjects at the TRC-AC site may also be
hospitalized at Chulalongkorn University Hospital. HIV-NAT and AFRIMS laboratories will
perform all lab tests for this study.
3. INFORMED CONSENT PROCESS
Information sheets for the main protocol and the optional procedures (leukapheresis, gut
biopsy, genital secretion collection and genetic (HLA) testing) along with the consent forms
will firstly be prepared in English and translated into Thai with IRB approval. Interested
subjects will be approached by study staff at the TRC-AC and BIDI sties. No study
procedures will occur prior to the subject giving informed consent.
4.
SUBJECT ENROLLMENT AND FOLLOW-UP One hundred participants with
advanced HIV (CD4 count <100 cells/mm3) will be recruited over 1 year. These patients will
form part of a global cohort of 500 patients across three worldwide sites, created to provide
degrees of power for primary analysis as described in section 10.1 (main protocol). The
patients will be distributed between the US, Kenya and Thailand in a 1:2:1 ratio respectively,
determined for reasons of logistical and recruitment practicality. Thai participants will be
recruited primarily from the TRC-AC and the out-patient and in-patient wards at the BIDI.
Recruitment will occur primarily in the clinics, by poster and flyers and by word of mouth.
They will be followed according to the Thailand National Antiretroviral Treatment
Guidelines for routine HIV care and treatment at both sites, and anti-retroviral therapy
recommended as per those guidelines. The investigators will not be responsible for the cost of
anti-HIV treatment, which will be funded by the nationwide government program for Thai
citizens. Study participants will be considered as "lost to follow-up" if they are not reviewed
as per protocol for a contiguous period of at least six months following their most recent
study visit. Study participants who are lost to follow-up will be discontinued from the study.
Management of any clinical presentations compatible with IRIS will include a full work-up to
93
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
exlude other diagnoses and further investigation and treatment as clinically indicated and
according to local guidelines and practice.
5. TUBERCULOSIS
WHO data estimates the prevalence of all forms of TB in Thailand at 192 per 100,000 in
2007. All Thai study participants, regardless of prior TB status, will undergo a tuberculosis
purified protein deriative (PPD) test (Thai Red Cross Tuberculin PPD Preparation) at study
entry and at weeks 48 and 96. If PPD is negative at baseline, it will also be repeated at either
week 4 or 8. The PPD test will be administered and interpreted by a trained nurse, with a
reading of raised induration greater than 10mm in diameter at 48 hours after administration
considered as positive.
6. SCHEDULE OF EVENTS
The schedule of events is shown in Table 1. Optional procedures which require a separate
consent form include 2-pass apheresis, gut biopsy, genital secretion collection and HLA
testing. The study will complete in 96 weeks. The study visits will be at weeks 2, 4, 8, and 12 after
the baseline visit, every 12 weeks until week 48 and every 16 weeks thereafter until the end of the
study.
7. DESCRIPTION OF OPTIONAL PROCEDURES
i. Gut Biopsy
Gut biopsies will be performed in patients who consent for this procedure at the
Chulalongkorn University Hospital, 500 meters from the TRCARC, by a
gastroenterologist. Biopsy specimens will be cryo-preserved for transcriptional analysis
and immunohistochemistry and collected in RPMI medium 1640 (Invitrogen) for flow
cytometric analysis. Phenotyping of colon lymphocytes using fresh lymphocytes and
multi-parameter flow cytometry may include the following panels: Activation:
CD3/CD4/CD8/HLA-DR/CD38; Memory: CD3/CD4/CD8/CD/27/CD45RO/CCR5 and T
reg: CD3/CD4/CD8/CD25/FoxP3/Ki67. HIV RNA in tissue will be determined by real
time PCR. Other HIV-specific immune responses may also be evaluated.
ii. Leukapheresis
Leukapheresis will be performed to collect PBMCs and plasma storage at study entry and
weeks 12 and 48 at the Chulalongkorn University Hospital by an experienced apheresis
technician using a continuous flow apheresis device. During leukapheresis, whole blood
will be withdrawn from a peripheral vein and channeled into a cell separator where the
cellular factions are separated by centrifugation. The lymphocyte fraction is directed into
a collection bag and the red cells and platelets are returned to the patient. The cell
separator kit is anticoagulated with sodium citrate. Some plasma from leukapheresis will
be stored. The blood volume loss from red blood cell loss and plasma storage wil be
about 50ml. The procedure takes about 2-3 hours and requires one or two needle access
sites. Leukapheresis will allow the collection of between 5 x 109 to 10 x 109 PMBCs
while minimizing the total blood volume taken from participants. Each leukopac (bag of
white cells) will be sent to the TRCARC for PMBC isolation. PBMCs will be divided
into aliquots and cryopreserved (-135°C or lower) within 8 hours. Subjects who wish to
not have leukapheresis will have phlebotomy of 64ml instead for each of the
leukapheresis visits.
iii. Genital Secretion Collection
In volunteers who consent for this procedure, the following genital secretion(s) will be
collected at the TRCARC by the study investigator or study nurse: semen (in men), anal
94
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
iv.
June 2, 2011
wash and swab (in MSM), cervicovaginal wash and vaginal swab (in women). Collection
of genital secretions allows direct study of the cellular and cytokine immune response to
HIV infection in the genital compartment and allows assessment of response to treatment
in this compartment also. This will permit correlation of genital compartment
immunopathogenesis and disease progression with possible newly or increasingly
symptomatic underlying sexually transmitted infections compatible with IRIS.
HLA testing
The goal of HLA testing is to study what types of genetic coding are associated with better or
worse HIV disease, response to HIV drugs and the occurrence of IRIS There is no extra blood
draw from volunteers who consent for this procedure. The testing will be done at a later time and
will be done using stored PBMC, which are already drawn as part of the main study.
8. LABORATORY EVALUATIONS FOR STUDY PARTICIPANTS
The HIV-NAT laboratory will perform all laboratory investigations for this study and for
both TRC-AC and BIDI clinical sites. The AFRIMS laboratory will perform the advanced
flow cytometry and will store samples. Some samples will be sent to NIH for additional
testing which may include, but may not be limited to, immunohistochemistry of gut tissue to
assess lymphocyte subsets, and full-length, single genome analysis of viral sequences and
host factors from peripheral blood and genital compartments and colon.
9. DATA MANAGEMENT PLAN
Case report forms (CRF) will be provided for each participant and used in accordance with
Good Clinical Practices. Data from CRF will be double-data entered and compiled in an
electronic database at SEARCH. Data from this protocol will be retained for at least 5 years
after study completion. The data manager will be responsible for data storage.
10. ANALYSIS OF DATA
This study is designed to investigate the predictors, incidence, clinical presentation and
immunopathogenesis of infective IRIS occuring within the first six months of antiretroviral
therapy. Section 10 (main protocol) describes the primary and secondary statistical analyses
that wil be used to evaluate the data obtained. The use of multivariate Cox regression
analyses will minimize the influence of confounding variables, such as gender, age and risk
behaviours (including intravenous drug use).
11. RETENTION OF STUDY SAMPLES
Biological samples will be stored for a period not exceeding five years from the date of
patient enrollment. If samples are required beyond this date, approval for renewal of sample
storage will be sought, Samples will be kept at the TRCARC in Bangkok and/or the National
Institutes for Health storage facilities in the United States.
12. STUDY RISKS AND BENEFITS
Potential risks associated with the main study procedures include risks from phlebotomy,
namely: pain, bruising, (pre)syncope and the small chance of infection. There are risks
associated with the optional study procedures. These risks mainly include hypocalcemia
related to apheresis; gas pain, slight bleeding and intestinal perforation and infection from gut
biopsy, an uncomfortable feeling or irritation related to genital secretion collection, and a
very small risk that the information from genetic testing becomes known to others. The
screening visit chest x-ray involves exposure to a radiation dose of approximately 0.029rem
(or approximately equal to 10 days background radiation exposure). The benefits of this
observational study are primarily the accumulation of knowledge about IRIS that may inform
95
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
future management of this condition. Study participants may also benefit from more frequent
contact with and review by healthcare providers, which may result in patient worries being
addressed earlier than is usual for non-study participants.
13. PREGNANCY
Male study participants will be offered free condoms. Female study participants of child
bearing potential will be offered free condoms and hormonal contraception. Females who are
pregnant at the time of screening will be excluded from the study; those who become
pregnant during the course of the study will not be excluded and the investigators will
coordinate with their doctors to ensure that they receive appropriate obstetric and prevention
of mother to child transmission care. Pregnant study participants will not be offered the
following optional procedures: gut biopsy, leukapheresis and collection of genital secretions,
during the gestation and 12 month post-delivery period.
14. STUDY MONITORING
The study will be monitored by a designated research nurse to ensure correct completion,
compliance and accuracy of informed consents and serious adverse event reports. Monitoring
will take place on a regular basis at intervals of not more than three months starting from
enrollment of the first two patients. The investigators will assist study monitoring by making
available all relevant documentation (including, but not limited to: informed consent forms,
clinical records and results of laboratory, radiological or other clinical investigations). The
monitor will issue a report following the completion of each monitoring visit.
15. REPORTING TO IRBs
A continuing review report, a final report, serious adverse event (SAE) report, any report on
protocol modifications and report on protocol deviations will be submitted to the IRBs
overseeing this study according to standard requirements and regulations.
16. CONFIDENTIALITY AND STORAGE OF DOCUMENTS
Each study participant will be provided a study identification number to be used for all
laboratory tests or samples stored for testing in future studies. Personal identification
information will be kept locked with access limited to study personnel only. Study records
may be reviewed by IRBs or regulatory bodies having overview or as required by law.
17. POLICY REGARDING RESEARCH-RELATED INJURIES
In the event of an injury resulting directly from participation within this study, the study site
will provide access to immediate treatment. The costs of short-term treatment (of a duration
not exceeding six months) for injuries deemed to be directly related to study participation will
be borne entirely by the study site. Advice regarding access to any necessary longer-term care
will be given to the patient. No compensation is offered for illness or injury. It will be
explained to the volunteer that in taking advantage of this policy, he/she does not give up or
waive his/her statutory rights. In the event of a presumptive research-related injury, subjects
should in the first instance contact the responsible study nurse.
96
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
Table 1: Schedule of Events
Evaluation
Screening
ART1
(-28 days) (Week 0)
Documentation of HIV
X
Medical & Medication History
X
Nadir CD4 Count
X
Clinical Assessment
X
Exam3
CBC and Differential (2ml)
Week 36
Week 48
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Week
80
X
X
X
Week 96
(EOS)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Weeks 64
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
TSH and free T4 (3ml)
Hepatitis B, C Antibody
Screen (3ml)
Cryptococcal Serum Ag and
Toxoplasma Serology (3ml)
Histoplasma Urine Ag
PPD4
X
X
X
X
X
Anal Pap
Week 24
X
ALT, GGT , T/d Bili (2ml)
Glucose, TG, Chol, LDL, HDL
(fasting) (2ml)
CD4 % and Count (2ml)
Advanced flow cytometry
(2ml)
HIV-RNA (5ml)
Smear5
Week 12
X
X
Cervical Pap
Week 8
X
Bun/Cr, Electrolytes (2ml)
Smear5
Week 4
X
Body Mass Index (BMI)2
Physical
X
Week 2
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
1: An elective hospital admission may be scheduled for the entry visit to facilitate testing and for participant’s convenience. Testing of the entry visit may be
completed in more than one day.
2: BMI= weight (kg) divided by [height x height (cm)]
3: All visits will require a medical doctor (MD) visit.
4: PPD will be repeated at week 4 or 8 only if negative at baseline. If PPD negative at baseline and week 4, it will be repeated yearly (at weeks 48 and 96).
5: Cervical Pap smear will be performed in women. Anal Pap smear will be performed in participants with history of receptive anal sex as per standard clinical
practice in the clinic. The first Pap smear can be delayed up until week 4 of study and will be repeated as clinically indicated or at weeks 24, 48 and then yearly
according to local practices.
97
Thailand Site Specific Addendum
June 2, 2011
Schedule of Events (continued)
Evaluation
Screening
(-28 days)
Study Entry1
(-27 to 0
days)
Week 2
Week 4
Week 8
Mycobacterial Blood Cx (5ml)
Week 12 Week 24 Week 36 Week 48 Week 64
As clinically indicated
Week 80
RPR, FTA-ABS (2ml)
X
ECG
X
Chest X-Ray
X
HLA-typing (Optional)
X
Stored PBMC/Plasma6 (52ml)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Stored
Serum6
(12ml)
X
Week 96
(EOS)
(Optional)7
X
X
GI Biopsy (Optional)
Genital Secretion Collection
(Optional)
Amylase or Lipase (2ml)
X
X
X
As clinically indicated
Urinalysis
X
As clinically indicated
Pregnancy Test
X
As clinically indicated
Genotyping (6ml)
X
As clinically indicated
Examination8
X
As clinically indicated
2-pass Apheresis
Eye
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
For skin or mucosal lesions that require close follow up
Photography9
Total Blood Volume
X
As clinically indicated
(ml)10
4
36+64
13+64
13+64
11+64
15+64
17+64
17+64
19+64
11+64
13+0
19+64
6: 64ml of blood will be drawn for storage of PBMCs and serum, except at weeks 0, 12 and 48 where this will be replaced by apheresis for patients who have
elected to and are permitted to undergo this procedure.
7: If adequate venous access and Hg >9g/dl, PLT >50,000 and not pregnant for female participants.
8: And every 24 weeks thereafter until CD4 >100 cells/µL for >12 weeks or as clinically indicated.
9: Skin or mucosal lesions that require close follow up (i.e. Kaposi’s sarcoma [KS] lesions, skin, or genital warts).
10: Calculated as the sum total of blood drawn for non-optional procedures at each study visit. Expressed as the volume of blood required from all patients (first
figure) plus any extra required from patients who elect not to undergo apheresis (second figure).
98
Download