Clinical Correlation THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NEUROANATOMY AND NEUROLOGY: PRINCIPLES OF LESION LOCALIZING Dr. Bruce Giffin Monday, April 9, 2007 11:00 am Objectives: The student should Appreciate the close link between basic and clinical neurosciences Describe how in localizing a lesion, the topography of the lesion(s) in the CNS is determined in terms of the level of involvement and the systems affected Discuss how type localization involves identifying whether the lesion is unifocal, multifocal, diffuse, or confined to a system List the typical signs and symptoms of lesions of the nervous system involving various levels and systems and use these in anatomical localization The foundations of clinical neurology include anatomy and physiology, the patient history, the neurologic examination, and the intellectual exercise of identifying where in the nervous system is the site, and what is the nature of the pathology. THE INTERPRETATION OF PHYSICAL SIGNS FOUND UPON CLINICAL EXAMINATION OF A PATIENT WITH NEUROLOGICAL PROBLEMS DEPENDS HEAVILY UPON YOUR PRACTICAL KNOWLEDGE OF NEUROANATOMY! In order to for the physician to come up with a differential diagnosis, a correct diagnosis, and a prognosis for pathology and diseases affecting the nervous system, two questions need to be answered: Where is the lesion? and What is the lesion? The information in this handout is intended as an introduction to clinical thinking to help you in the CASE-BASED PROBLEM SOLVING exercises which are a scheduled activity of the Brain and Behavior I course. SOME DEFINITIONS Lesion-a zone of localized dysfunction within the CNS or PNS and may be anatomic (structural damage) or physiologic (absence of demonstrable anatomic abnormalities). Differential diagnosis-the process of making a diagnosis by comparing and analyzing the similarities and differences between the signs, symptoms, and other findings associated particularly with two or more diseases sharing certain characteristics; similar conditions are systematically eliminated from consideration SOME GENERALIZATIONS Manifestations of neurologic disease by be negative (loss of function) or positive (abnormalities resulting from inappropriate excitation). Some neurological disorders affect primarily gray matter, others affect primarily white matter, and some disorders affect both gray and white matter. Neurologic disease can result in syndromes (a constellation of signs and symptoms frequently associated with each other and suggest a common origin). Many pathologic processes result in lesions that are larger than any single nucleus or tract. In these cases neighborhood signs (combinations of signs and symptoms) may help to localize the lesion. Dysfunction of the nervous system can be due to destruction or compression of neural tissue, or compromise of the cerebrovascular system. PROCESSES CAUSING NEUROLOGIC DISEASE Focal pathology causes signs and symptoms on the basis of a single, geographically contiguous lesion. Multi-focal pathology results in damage to the nervous system at multiple, separate sites. Diffuse dysfunction of the nervous system can result from toxins or metabolic abnormalities. WHERE IS THE LESION? The location of a lesion needs to be determined by (1) rostral-caudal localization (examine the constellation of neurologic signs and symptoms and relating them to appropriate tracts and nuclei; it is often possible to place the lesion at the appropriate level along the rostro-caudal axis) and (2) transverse localization (place the lesion within the cross section of the brain or spinal cord). There are four major anatomical levels at which the lesion can be localized. These levels are defined by the meninges and the bony structures to which they are related. Medial (A) and lateral (B) views of sections though brain and spinal cord illustrating major levels: supratentorial (dark shading), posterior fossa with brainstem (lines) and cerebellum (dots), and spinal (clear area). Peripheral level is not shown. Supratentorial level: the portion of the nervous system located above the tentorium cerebelli (cerebral hemispheres, basal ganglia, thalamus, hypothalamus, cranial nerves I and II) Posterior fossa level: contains structures located within the skull, below the tentorium cerebelli but above the foramen magnum (midbrain, pons, medulla, cerebellum, cranial nerves III-XII) Spinal level: the portion of the nervous system located below the foramen magnum but contained within the vertebral column (spinal cord and nerves contained in the body vertebral column and in the intervertebral foramina) Peripheral level: includes all neuromuscular structures located outside the skull and vertebral column (cranial and peripheral nerves, their branches, and structures innervated by them, autonomic ganglia and nerves) WHAT IS THE LESION? After anatomical localization it is necessary to determine the pathologic features of the lesion. This requires knowledge of the cellular elements of the nervous system and their pathological reactions. Information from the examination and the history such as age, gender, and the general medical context (smoking, hypertension, etc.) is important. The time-course of the illness in many cases can provide invaluable information about the nature of the illness. Transient ischemic attacks: (brief, reversible neurologic dysfunction resulting from reversible ischemia which resolves in about 24 hours) can be predictive of an upcoming stroke. TIME Relapsing-remitting: patient experiences bouts of dysfunction lasting days to weeks followed by functional recovery (e.g. multiple sclerosis) Sudden onset: a fixed deficit comes on suddenly; characteristic of cerebrovascular disease Slowly progressive dysfunction: evolves over years and suggests a neurodegenerative disease (Alzheimer's, Parkinson's) Subacutely progressive dysfunction: advances over weeks to months (e.g. brain tumors) CLINICAL CORRELATIONS Think of the nervous system as you would an electrical circuit (later we will call these wires “line segments”). The longitudinal systems (motor and sensory) lead to and from the cerebral hemispheres and conduct impulses from one segment to another. Segmental “wires” (nerves) come off of these intersegmental “cables”. If there is damage to an intersegmental cable, there will be a loss of function beyond that point. Damage to a segmental wire will result in a loss of function confined to that individual segment. Major nervous system connections. (A), cranial nerves; (B), spinal nerves. Note the long intersegmental pathways leading to and from higher centers and multiple, short segmental pathways (cranial and spinal nerves) to the peripheral level. SEGMENTAL PATHWAYS INTERSEGMENTAL PATHWAYS LOCALIZATION is determined by the level of the nervous system in which the pathway function is interrupted. To aid in localization, the functions of each of the major anatomical levels are summarized below: LEVEL SUPRATENTORIAL POSTERIOR FOSSA SPINAL PERIPHERAL CLINICAL FINDING SIDE OF LESION Loss of sensation and/or weakness on the SAME side of the body and face Contralateral to the deficit Loss of sensation and/or weakness on ONE side of the face and OPPOSITE side of body Ipsilateral to side of the face Cranial nerve deficit Cerebellar deficit Loss of pain and temperature on ONE side and weakness and loss of position sense on OPPOSITE side of the body Loss of sensation to all modalities in distribution of nerve or sensory loss in glove-and-stocking distribution Muscle weakness in distribution of nerve Ipsilateral to cranial nerve Ipsilateral to cerebellar deficit, cerebellar signs (incoordination) Ipsilateral to loss of position sense and weakness Ipsilateral to sensory loss COMMON SEGMENTAL SIGNS OF THE LEVEL Vision Olfaction Cognition Memory Intelligence Behavior Seizures Hearing Tinnitus Vertigo Diplopia Dysarthria Dysphagia Neck/back pain; findings related to specific spinal level Limb pain without back pain; loss of sensation and muscle weakness in distribution of a nerve SOME EXAMPLES OF HOW TO GO ABOUT THE LESION LOCALIZING PROCESS Think of each symptom or abnormal physical finding as a line segment that connects the CNS to a muscle or sensory receptors out in the periphery. If all these line segments intersect at a single point, that point will be where the lesion is localized. In the event that there are two or more points where all the line segments intersect, each potential localization site will need to be evaluated further by determining whether the patient has other symptoms or signs that would be expected with a lesion in that location. EXAMPLE 1: A patient is found to have the following: (1) weakness of abduction of the little finger on the right hand and (2) reduced pinprick sensation on the palmar surface of the little finger of the right hand. Where is the lesion? EXAMPLE 2: A patient is found to have the following: (1) reduced pinprick sensation on the left forehead and (2) reduced pinprick sensation on the palmar surface of the little finger of the right hand. Where is the lesion? EXAMPLE 3: A patient is found to have reduced vibration sense in the left foot and reduced pinprick sensation on the palmar surface of the little finger of the right hand. Where is the lesion? EXAMPLE 4: A patient is found to have reduced vibration sense in the left and right foot and the left and right hand. Where is the lesion? This page and the following page are to help you begin developing a vocabulary for lesion localizing as you work through case-based problems. THE LOCATION OF LESIONS The following is a systematic survey of the nervous system with examples of lesions that can be located in the following anatomic sites. It is by no means all-inclusive. Muscles: weakness, atrophy, depressed deep tendon reflexes (dystrophies, polymyositis) Motor end-plates: weakness, abnormal fatigabililty; may involves limbs or trunk, or muscles involved in chewing, swallowing, eye movement (LEMS, myasthenia gravis) Peripheral nerves: motor and sensory deficits together or separately (peripheral neuropathies) Roots: segmental motor deficit (may be mediated through several nerves if a plexus lesion); sensory difficult due to dermatomal overlap Spinal cord: decussation pattern is staggered for fine touch and pain and temperature-permits localization within the cord; LMN signs and symptoms at the level of injury with UMN signs and symptoms below the level of injury Brainstem: functional deficits of the long tracts and cranial nerve signs and symptoms can localize the lesion to the medulla, pons, or midbrain Cerebellum or its peduncles: impaired motor coordination, decreased muscle tone ipsilateral to the lesion site Diencephalon: hypothalamus-endocrinologic and visual abnormalities; thalamussensory and motor dysfunction; subthalamus-dyskinesias (hemiballism); epithalamus- compression of the cerebral aqueduct (hydroencephalus) Subcortical white matter: abnormal myelin (leukodystrophy); destruction of normal myelin (multiple sclerosis) with abnormal axonal conduction; pathology-diffuse, focal, or multi-focal The basal ganglia (subcortical gray): movement disorders (Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease) Cerebral cortex: focal lesions (disorders of language, neglect syndromes, UMN weakness of contralateral limbs); irritative lesions (focal or generalized seizures) Meninges: hemorrhages into spaces in and around the meninges (subarachnoid, subdural, epidural); infection (meningitis) Skull, vertebral column, and associated structures: intervertebral disks, ligaments, joints THE NEUROPATHOLOGIC CLASSIFICATION OF VARIOUS DISORDERS AFFECTING THE NERVOUS SYSTEM Vascular disorders: usually sudden onset; cerebrovascular disease secondary to hypertension; stenosis or occlusion; embolism from ulcerated plaques; subarachnoid hemorrhage and intraparenchymal hemorrhage; subdural and epidural hemorrhages as a result of trauma Trauma: head injuries; penetrating injuries destroying brain tissue Tumors: primary tumors of brain and spinal cord directly invade and destroy brain tissue; hydroencephalus from compression of the ventricular system; progresses over weeks, months, or years Infections and inflammation: meningitis, abscess, encephalitis, and granulomas; may be accompanied by fever Toxic, deficiency, and metabolic disorders: toxic substances, vitamin deficiencies, enzyme defects Demyelinating diseases: can produce multiple lesions in the CNS white matter Degenerative diseases: spinal, cerebellar, subcortical, and cortical degenerative disorders often characterized by specific functional deficits Congenital malformations and perinatal disorders: exogenous factors, genetic and chromosomal factors that produce abnormalities of the brain and spinal cord Neuromuscular disorders: muscular dystrophies, congenital myopathies, NMJ disorders, nerve lesions or neuropathies SELECTED REFERENCES Adams, R.D., Victor, M., and Ropper, A.H. Principles of Neurology. (6th edition). New York: McGraw-Hill. 1997. Brazin, P.W., Masdeu, J.C., and Biller, J. Localization in Clinical Neurology. (3rd edition). Boston: Little, Brown and Company (Inc), 1996. DeMeyer, W.E. Technique of the Neurologic Examination. (4th edition). New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc. 1994. Fitzgerald, M.J.T. Neuroanatomy: Basic and Clinical. (3rd edition). Philadelphia: Saunders and Company. 1996. Plum, F., and Posner, J.B. The Diagnosis of Stupor and Coma. (3rd edition). Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company. 1982. Ross, R.T. How to Examine the Nervous System. (3rd edition). Connecticut: Appleton and Lange. 1999. Wilkinson, I.M.S. Essential Neurology. (3rd edition). Oxford: Blackwell Science. 1999. Patten, J. Neurological Differential Diagnosis. (2nd edition). New York: Springer-Verlag, 1996.