LANGUAGE BARRIERS
THE ETHICAL AND LEGAL ISSUES SURROUNDING TRANSLATION
John Sok
Boston College Connell School of Nursing
Keys to Inclusive Leadership in Nursing
PURPOSE STATEMENT & OBJECTIVES
The purpose of this presentation is to inform
and educate fellow nursing peers and faculty
about language barriers and cultural
competency
Objectives:
Identify
current issues regarding language barriers
Evaluate the importance of certified interpretation
Highlight intervention to facilitate communication
JOSEPH M. SMITH COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER
Serves Brighton, Allston,
Waltham
Diverse patient
populations
Offers medical, dental,
counseling, vision, and
pharmacy services
DEMOGRAPHICS –ALLSTON/BRIGHTON
2000 U.S. CENSUS
Total Population
43,887
Caucasian
33,768
75.1%
Black/ African American
1,965
12.3%
Hispanic/Latino
3,260
7.4%
American India/Alaska
Native
91
0.9%
Asian
5,218
3.6%
Native Hawaiian/ Other
Pacific Islander
31
0.1%
Other races
1,485
5.5%
Two or more races
1,329
2.4%
MENTORING EXPERIENCE
June & Olga
Monthly Meetings
Medication
adherence (Merk Tool)
Language Interpreter Service
Nursing Staff Meetings
Every
second Thursday
staffing,
clinical/ethical problems, changes and
implementations, feedback
LANGUAGE BARRIER, A PROBLEM?
Increase number of diverse patient population
Limited English Proficient Patients =
Communication issue
Discrepancy in language translation
Need
for more medically certified interpreter usage
Current practice utilizes family members and/or
other health care personnel
LEGAL AND ETHICAL RESPONSIBILITY
Advocate for patient
autonomy
Accurate translation
Facilitate
communication
Maintain
Confidentiality
Culturally
competent directed
care
LANGUAGE INTERPRETING AS SOCIAL JUSTICE
(MESSIAS ET AL., 2009)
Purpose: Exploring how informal and formal
interpreters conceptualize and implement their
role
Methods: interviewed 27 interpreters (13 formal)
U.S., Puerto Rico, Mexico, Columbia, Brazil, Venezuela,
Panama
Could
you describe your work as an interpreter to me?
Please tell me your relationship and interaction with patients
What is the most difficult part of the job is for you?
LANGUAGE INTERPRETING AS SOCIAL JUSTICE
Results:
Informal: lack of preparation, inadequate cultural
competent care, inconsistent
felt
that it was their personal responsibility to ensure
understanding on the part of the patient and to advocate on
behalf of the patient with the physicians
Formal: supportive, more trusted, confident
“…
professional interpreters viewed their role as one of
information transfer while maintaining professional
boundaries”
Implications:
A need for improve language access and qualified
interpreting service
DO WE REALLY NEED TRANSLATORS?
OPPOSITION
ADVOCATORS
Legal and ethical issues
Certified
Understands medical
concepts/terminology
Reduces biases
24hours/7 days
Available as needed via IPOP
Continuity of care
Convenience
Live Interpreters
Cost effective?
Demoralizing
Difficult to use/ confusing
INTERPRETER PHONE ON A POLE (IPOP)
System similar to speaker
phone system
Providers dial the Language
Line, input authorization code
(specific to floor/unit), ask for
specific language, connected
Reference numbers for
interpreter and event
interaction
CLINICAL CASE EXAMPLE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzOP7Eex7Q
CREATING CHANGE
Increase in IPOP and Language Line usage
Hiring full time certified translators (Thai)
Patients are asking more questions
Increase
in medical adherence
Proactive disease management
Diabetes
Mellitus, Hyperlipidemia, STDs
REFERENCES
02135 - Fact Sheet - American FactFinder. American
FactFinder. Retrieved April 11, 2011, from
http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/SAFFFacts?_ev
ent=Search&geo_id=01000US&_geoContext=0100
0US&_street=&_county=&_cityTown=&_state=&_zip
=02135&_lang=en&_sse=on&ActiveGeoDiv=geoSel
ect&_useEV=&pctxt=fph&pgsl=010&_submenuId=f
actsheet_1&ds_name=ACS_2009_5YR_
lynnekelly2000. YouTube - A Few Minutes In The Life Of A Sign
Language Interpreter. YouTube- Broadcast Yourself. Retrieved
April 11, 2011, from
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzOP7Ee-x7Q
Messias, DeAnne K, Liz McDowell, and Robin D Estrada. "Language
interpreting as social justice work perspective of formal and
informal healthcare
interpreters." Advances in Nursing
Science 32.2 (2009): 128-143.