Chem IV - Symmetry and Group Theory Chapter 7 Part 1 - Introduction to symmetry elements, symmetry operations and point groups Symmetry in Nature The Platonic Solids Christian Art Islamic Art Art Deco Architecture Photography Ndebele Zulu Symmetry analysis • A symmetry operation is an action that leaves a molecule apparently unchanged • Each symmetry operation is associated with a symmetry element H2 O Point, line, or plane Symmetry element: axis of rotation Symmetry operation: rotation A symmetry operation leaves at least one point in the molecule unmoved – they are operations of point group symmetry The identity operation, E – do nothing. All molecules have at least E, and some have only the symmetry element E An n-fold rotation is a symmetry operation that leaves a molecule apparently unchanged after rotation by 360o/n. The symmetry element is an n-fold axis of rotation, Cn BH3 Note that C33 = E BrF5 Note that C42 = C2 Associated with the symmetry element C4 we have the symmetry operations C4 C42 ( = C2) C43 C44 ( = E) XeF4 The axis with the highest order, here the C4 axis, is called the principal axis The principal axis defines the z axis Identify the axes of rotation of this snowflake. List the symmetry operations associated with each of these symmetry elements Symmetry operation reflection through the symmetry element mirror plane, σ z The mirror planes contain the principal C2 axis. They are therefore vertical mirror planes (subscript “v”). This mirror plane is perpendicular to the principal C4 axis. It is therefore a horizontal mirror (subscript “h”) This mirror plane is parallel to (contains) the principal C4 axis and bisects the two C2' axes. It is a dihedral mirror (subscript “d”) Mirror planes in molecules σh(horizontal): plane perpendicular to principal axis σd(dihedral), σv(vertical): plane colinear with principal axis σd: σ parallel to Cn and bisecting two C2' axes σv: σ parallel to Cn Identify the mirror planes (σh, σd,σv) in the following examples acetylene Identify the mirror planes (σh, σd,σv) in the following examples (Don’t forget the double bonds are delocalised) Identify the mirror planes (σh, σd,σv) in the following examples Os(cp)2 The symmetry operation inversion, i, involves projecting each atom through a point, the centre of inversion i, that is located at the centre of the molecule i Staggered form of ethane Do these molecules have a centre of inversion? The symmetry operations i and C2 should not be confused The symmetry operation improper rotation occurs about the symmetry element Improper Axis, Sn This is a compound operation combining a rotation (Cn) with a reflection through a plane perpendicular to the Cn axis σh: Read: Do Cn followed by σh Cn followed by σh or σhCn = Sn Neither the 90o rotation nor the reflection is itself a symmetry operation for a tetrahedral molecule, but their combined effect is the symmetry operation S4 Do you see that S1 = σ and that S2 = i? Use a CH4 molecule to verify that 2S4 = C2 Identify a S3 symmetry operation in BF3. What is it equal to in this molecule? Identify all the symmetry elements in the (i) eclipsed (ii) staggered conformation of ethane E, C3, C2, σh, σv, S3 E, C3, C2, σd, i, S6 Sketch the S4 axis of NH4+. Is there a C4 axis? How many S4 axes are there in the ion? The Point Groups of Molecules The set of symmetry elements of a molecule constitute a group. Since all symmetry operations leave at least one point in the molecule unchanged, the group is called a point group The point group is identified by it Schoenflies symbol The process used to assign a molecule to a point group is straightforward with a few exceptions. Use this schematic to guide you. CO2 OCS SiIBrClF Linear – No 2 of Cn, n>2 – No Cn – No σh – No i - No So… Determine the point groups of the following molecules CH2CBrCl C2H2Cl2Br2 H2O2 H2O S8 1,3,5,7-tetrafluorocyclooctatetrane [Ni(en)3]2+ naphthalene XeF4 Convention for orientation of a molecule in a coordinate system 1. Centre of mass (or centre of symmetry) at origin. 2. z axis = highest order axis and principal axis. If several axes of highest order, the z axis is the one that passes through most atoms. 3. Then assign x axis. If molecule is planar and z axis in plane, then the x axis is plane. If a non-planar molecule contains a plane which contains more atoms than any other plane, this is treated as it if where the molecular plane. 4. If molecule planar and z axis plane, then x axis will be in the plane and chosen to pass through greatest number of atoms. 5. The y axis is to other two axes. Place the following in a cartesian coordinate system: NH3 H2O cis-[Pt(NH3)2Cl2] trans-C2H2Cl2 Determine the point groups of the following molecules CCl4 Chloroform Dichloromethane SF6 BF5 (sq pyramidal) 1,2-dichloronaphthalene 1,5-dichloronapthalene Ethane (staggered) Ethane (eclipsed) Os(cp)2 (staggered) Os(cp)2 (eclipsed) PPh3 Part 2 - Group Theory and Character Tables Groups and Group Theory Group: a collection of elements that obey the following rules: • Any combination of two elements must be equivalent to another element in the group (the group shows closure) Show that σv(xz)C2 = σv’(yz) in the C2v point group using H2O as a representation of that point group • There must exist an element that commutes with all other elements and leaves them unchanged For molecules this is the identity E since EX = XE = X • The associative law must hold X(YZ) = (XY)Z Use the symmetry elements C2, σv and σv’ of the water molecule to show that the associative law holds true • Each X must have a reciprocal X-1 such that XX-1 = X-1X = E Find the reciprocals of C2 and σv’ of the water molecule Note the absence of the general requirement that the commutative law holds (XY = YX). If it holds, the group is an Abelian group The set of symmetry operations constitute a group, called a point group because at least one point is unchanged. Once we identify the point group → can look up all the symmetry elements in character tables (see below). The number of elements in a group: order of group, h. Elements A, B, C, ..., M belong to the same class if, and only if X-1AX X-1BX X-1CX ▪ ▪ ▪ X1-MX = A, B, C, ..., or M Show that all the symmetry elements of NH3 belong to three classes As will be seen, need only consider properties associated with one representative from each class rather than all operations. So, for NH3, where we have operations E, C3, C32, σv, σv’, σv” we can write as E, 2C3, 3σv The symmetry of orbitals Central importance for chemists: effect of symmetry on properties of orbitals Example: The effect of the symmetry elements of the C2v point group (E, C2, σv, σv’) on the valence orbitals of O (2s, 2p) z y x C2 σv (xz) σv’ (yz) 2s 2px 2py 2pz Operators either • change sign of wavefunction • leave sign of wavefunction unchanged (≡ ×(-1)) (≡ ×(+1)) For example: (C2)(2px) = (-1)×(2px) Here a 1 × 1 matrix The operation C2 on the wavefunction 2px may be represented by multiplying the wavefunction by a matrix Such a matrix is called a transformation matrix So Ψ´ = R(Ψ) = [M]×Ψ Final wavefunction Initial wavefunction Symmetry operator Initial wavefunction Transformation matrix An aside Multiplying two matrices P = MN 1 2 5 6 1 5 2 7 1 6 2 8 19 22 3 4 7 8 3 5 4 7 3 6 4 8 43 50 In linear algebra, the trace of an n-by-n square matrix is defined to be the sum of the elements on the main diagonal (the diagonal from the upper left to the lower right) 1 0 0 x 0 1 0 y 0 0 1 z = Let a suitable set of functions exist that are the basis set of a point group. There exists a collection of matrices that represents the operation of the symmetry operators. If AB(Ψ) = C(Ψ) (there must exist) [MA], [MB] and [MC] such that [MA][MB](Ψ) = [MC](Ψ) A collection of matrices that obeys the multiplication laws of the symmetry operators of a point group is a representation of that group, symbol Γ (Gk., Gamma). Let’s return to this: Then Γ = (1, -1, 1, -1) is a representation of the C2v point group Take the 2px wavefunction as a basis set for the C2v point group z y x C2 2px What if our basis set is the set of valence orbitals on O (2s, 2p)? Then we need a set of 4 × 4 matrices. s 1 0 0 px 0 1 0 C2 p 0 0 1 y 0 0 0 p z 0 s 0 p x 0 p y 1 p z s 1 0 0 px 0 1 0 v ( xz) py 0 0 1 0 0 0 p z 0 s 0 p x 0 p y 1 p z Write down the matrices corresponding to the symmetry operators E and σv’(yz) Use the two H 1s orbitals in H2O as basis set and show that the transformation matrices are 1 0 E 0 1 0 1 C2 1 0 0 1 v ( xz) 1 0 1 0 v ' ( yz) 0 1 In general, for n basis functions of a point group we will need a set of n × n matrices to represent the point group For a point group with a symmetry operator greater than two-fold a complication arises – the rotation will “mix” elements of the basis set. x´ = x cos θ – y sin θ y´ = x sin θ + y cos θ x cos Cn y sin sin x cos y Example. Take the valence orbitals of N in ammonia as the basis set for the C3v point group. Then the transformation matrix for the C3 operation is s 1 p x 0 p y 0 p z 0 0 1 3 0 2 2 0 3 1 0 2 2 0 0 0 1 Write down the transformation matrices for all other symmetry operators of the C3v point group If X, A and B of a group G: ... then X-1 G (why?) Suppose X-1AX = B We say - A is converted to B by a similarity transformation - B is the similarity transform of A by X - A and B are conjugate Reducing matrices For symmetry operators A, B and C square transformation matrices [A], [B] and [C]. Suppose AB = C; then [A][B] = [C] Let [A]´ and [B]´ be similarity transforms of [A] and [B] So [A]´ = [X]-1[A][X] [B]´ = [X]´[B][X] Now [A]´[B]´ = [X]-1[A][X][X]-1[B][X] = [X]-1[A][B][X] = [X]-1[C][X] = [C]´ So [A]´, [B]´ and [C]´ are true representations of G Suppose as the result of suitable transformations we end up with matrices of the form | a1 | | 0 | | 0 | [ A] | 0 | | a 2 | | 0 | | 0 | | 0 | | a | 3 | b1 | | 0 | | 0 | [ B] | 0 | | b2 | | 0 | | 0 | | 0 | | b | 3 where |0| is a region of the matrix where all elements are 0. These are said to be reduced matrices. Submatrices |an| and |bn| have the same order. It can be shown that if [A]´[B]´ = [C]´ then |an||bn| = |cn| The submatrices are also true representations of G Thus smaller representations can be found within larger ones. If this is impossible, then the original matrix is irreducible. The character of a matrix Character χ = sum diagonal elements χ is unaltered by similarity transforms Larger matrices may be reduced to irreducible components by similarity transforms alone. So n R ai i ( R ) i 1 - χR is the character of a reducible matrix for the Rth operation of the point group - χi(R) is the character of the ith irreducible representation of the Rth operation - ai is the number of times χi(R) is contained in χR. Character Tables This is a typical character table Character table: tabulation of χi(R) i irreducible representations of G. Symmetry elements of the same class related by a similarity transform matrices have the same character. This is a 1-dimensional representation (1×1 matrix) This is a 2-dimensional representation (2×2 matrix) Mulliken symbols give information about symmetry elements of the irreducible representations One dimensional representations symmetric w.r.t. rotation about the principal axis (+1 under Cn) are designated A; those that are antisymmetric (-1 under Cn) are designated B. If the one dimensional representation is symmetric w.r.t. C2 Cn subscript “1” is added to A or B. If C2 is absent then the symmetry w.r.t. a vertical plane is used instead. Two dimensional representations are designated E and three dimensional ones are designated T Primes and double primes indicate representations that are respectively symmetric and antisymmeric w.r.t. σh If i G then subscript “g” (Ger., gerade, even) is added if the representation is symmetric w.r.t. inversion; otherwise “u” (Ger., ungerade, odd) is used Direct products As we shall see, it is often necessary to multiply together representations of two sets of functions. This is a direct product of the two representations. Example: B1 × B2 in C2v B1 × B2 = (1×1 = (1 = A2 -1×-1 1 1×-1 -1 -1×1) -1) Reduction of matrices using character tables It can be shown that the number of times, aj, which is the irreducible representation j, occurs in a reducible representation is given by: 1 a j n R ( R) j ( R) h g • h = order of group (= number of elements in group = sum of squares of characters entered under E in the character table; • g = number of classes; • nR = number of elements in a class (number in front of class symbol) • χ(R) = character of reducible representation; • χj(R) = character of the irreducible representation. How do the metal d orbitals transform in trans-tetraammineaquachlorocobalt(III)? Show that the valence orbitals of nitrogen in ammonia transform as 2a1 + e Usually not necessary to write out a full transformation matrix for each symmetry operator – merely the character. Diagonal elements describes to what extent a function remains in its original position after a symmetry operation: 0 – moves completely away; 1 – remains unchanged; -1 – changes sign; and so on. Example: The p orbitals of C in the carbonate anion. How to they transform in the D3h point group? (So we use the 2p orbitals as a basis set.) Operator Effect E Nothing C3 z→z x → x cos 120o – y sin 120o y → x in 120o + y cos 120o C2’ Contribution to χ χ 3 1 -1/2 -1/2 0 z → -z x→x y→ -y -1 1 -1 -1 σh z → -z x,y unchanged -1 2 1 S3 z → -z x → x cos 120o – y sin 120o y → x in 120o + y cos 120o -1 -1/2 -1/2 -2 σv z→z x→x y→ -y 1 1 -1 1 on diagonal off diagonal Hence Γ2p = (3, 0, -1, 1, -2, 1) is a reducible representation of the C3v point group. Let’s reduce this representation and express this in terms of the irreducible representations of the point group. aj 1 n R ( R) j ( R) h g Γ2p = (3 0 -1 1 -2 1) a(a1’) = 1/12[1.3.1 + 2.0.1 + 3.-1.1 + 1.1.1 + 2.-2.1 + 3.1.1] = 1/12[3 + 0 + -3 + 1 + -4 + 3] =0 a(a2’) = 1/12[1.3.1 + 2.0.1 + 3.-1.-1 + 1.1.1 + 2.-2.1 + 3.1.-1] = 1/12[ 3 + 0 + 3 + 1 - 4 - 3 ] =0 a(e’) = 1/12[1.3.2 + 2.0.-1 + 3.-1.0 + 1.1.2 + 2.-2.-1 + 3.1.0] = 1/12[ 6 + 0 + 0 + 2 + 4 + 0 ] = 1/12[12] =1 a(a1”) = 1/12[1.3.1 + 2.0.1 + 3.-1.1 + 1.1.-1 + 2.-2.-1 + 3.1.-1] = 1/12[ 3 + 0 - 3 - 1 + 4 - 3 ] =0 This means that a1’ does not appear at all in Γ2p aj 1 n R ( R) j ( R) h g Γ2p = (3 0 -1 1 -2 1) a(a2”) = 1/12[1.3.1 + 2.0.1 + 3.-1.-1 + 1.1.-1 + 2.-2.-1 + 3.1.1] = 1/12[ 3 + 0 + 3 - 1 + 4 + 3 ] = 1/12[12] =1 a(e”) = 1/12[1.3.2 + 2.0.-1 + 3.-1.0 + 1.1.-2 + 2.-2.1 + 3.1.0] = 1/12[ 6 + 0 + 0 - 2 - 4 + 0 ] =0 Hence Γ2p = a2” + e’. Two of the p orbitals (2px and 2py are degenerate) and the other (2pz) has a different energy. We could have told this straight away by consulting the 2nd last column of the character table, where we see the functions (x,y) are degenerate and transform as e’ whilst the function (z) transforms as a2”. Recall that ψ2px = n1(x).f(r) ψ2py = n2(y).f(r) ψ2pz = n3(z).f(r) Hence ψ2px has the same symmetry properties as (x), and so on. Notice this typo in Atkins: should be (xz, yz) How do the d orbitals transform under the D3h point group? And the 4s orbital? Part 3 - Some Applications of Group Theory in Chemistry Polarity of molecules Polar molecule: permanent electric dipole moment δ- δ+ Cannot be polar if molecule posses as centre of inversion i Dipole moment cannot be to a mirror plane Dipole moment cannot be to a Cn axis A polar molecule cannot belong to a group that includes i, any of the groups D and their derivatives, the cubic groups (Oh,, Td, Ih) and their modifications Are these molecules polar? Chirality of molecules A polar molecule cannot be chiral if it possesses an improper axis of rotation, Sn. These are groups such as Dnd, Dnh, Td, Oh, etc A mirror plane σ ≡ S1 A centre of inversion i ≡ S2 So molecules with σ and i are not chiral Are these chiral molecules (assume locked in these conformations)? Symmetry adapted linear combination of atomic orbitals Molecular orbitals are built up from the combination of atomic orbitals of the correct symmetry. This is a symmetry adapted linear combination (SALC) of atomic orbitals. Example. The diagram shows a molecular orbital made up of a linear combination of H 1s orbitals in ammonia. To what symmetry species does φ belong? φ1 = ψA1s + ψB1s + ψC1s Example. Identify the symmetry label of the orbital φ = ψ0 – ψ0’ in the C2v molecule NO2 where ψ0 is an O2px orbital on one oxygen atom and ψ0’ is an O2px orbital on the other O atom. The construction of molecular orbitals Now that we know something about group theory let’s return to a topic in Chem III Inorganic: the MO description of the bonding in transition metal complexes Consider a metal from the first row of the d block in an Oh complex such as high-spin [Fe(H2O)6]2+. Available orbitals: 4s: a1g 4p: t1u 3d: eg, t2g Γmetal = a1g + t1u + eg + t2g 3d, 4s, 4p Now the ligands. Assume for the moment σ bonding only (appropriate for H2O as ligands). Exact nature of ligand orbital use unimportant – only the symmetry of the orbitals is important. + + + Six ligand-based orbitals to be combined + + + + + + + + + Now apply the symmetry operations of the Oh point group to these 6 orbitals E 8C3 6C2 6C4 3C2 i 6S4 8S6 3σh 6σd 6 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 4 2 and we find that Γσ(ligand)= (6 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 4 2) which is a reducible representation of the Oh point group. Apply the methods we have learned to express as the sum of irreducible representations and find Γσ(ligand) = a1g + eg + t1u Γmetal = a1g + t1u + eg + t2g Γσ(ligand) = a1g + eg + t1u and notice that there are no ligand orbitals with symmetry t2g. Therefore the t2g orbitals (xy, xz, yz) will be non-bonding. The MO diagram is therefore the familiar one we met in Chem III – but hopefully you will now have a deeper understanding of its origins. What if we include π bonding? This will involve overlap of ligand orbitals which are to the M–L σ bond. σ π π The p orbitals have the same symmetry properties as a vector orthogonal to the main σ bond framework. E 8C3 6C2 6C4 3C2 i 6S4 8S6 3σh 6σd 12 0 0 0 -4 0 0 0 0 0 and reducing this into irreducible representations we find Γπ(ligand) = t1g + t2g + t1u + t2u Γπ(ligand) = t1g + t2g + t1u + t2u t1g and t2u – non bonding because no metal orbitals with this symmetry t1u – largely non-bonding because metal t1u orbitals (4p) already involved in σ bonding t2g orbitals can overlap with non-bonding metal t2g orbitals (xy, xz, yz) to form M–L π bonds If the ligands are π donors such as Cl– the ligand π orbitals with be lower in energy that the metal t2g orbitals. The ligand field splitting is now between t2g* and eg*. This splitting has decreased relative to the σonly case. Ligand such as Cl– that act as π donors are low down in the spectrochemical series. If the ligands are π acceptors such as CO the ligand π orbitals with be higher in energy that the metal t2g orbitals. The ligand field splitting between t2g and eg*. has increased relative to the σ-only case. Ligand such as CO that act as π acceptors are high up in the spectrochemical series and produce low-spin complexes. Molecular vibrations – Infrared and Raman spectroscopy IR absorption occurs when a vibration results in change in electric dipole moment of a molecule. Raman transition occurs when the polarisability of a molecule changes during a vibration Exclusion rule If a molecule has a centre of inversion none of its normal vibrational modes are both IR and Raman active Molecular vibrations – Infrared and Raman spectroscopy No. of atoms degrees of freedom Translational modes Rotational modes Vibrational modes N (linear) 3N 3 2 3N-5 Example 3 (HCN) 9 3 2 4 N (nonlinear) 3N 3 3 3N-6 Example 3 (H2O) 9 3 3 3 Example H3N Cl Pt H3N Cl C2v H3N Cl Pt Cl NH3 D2h Pd-Cl stretching occurs between 200 and 400 cm-1. Trans isomer: modes cannot be both IR and Raman active A molecular vibration is IR active only if it results in a change in the dipole moment of the molecule A molecular vibration is Raman active only if it results in a change in the polarisability of the molecule In group theory terms: A vibrational motion is IR active if it corresponds to an irreducible representation with the same symmetry as an x, y, z coordinate (or function) and it is Raman active if the symmetry is the same as x2, y2, z2, xy, etc or one of the rotational functions Rx, Ry, Rz The vibration will have the same symmetry properties as these vectors. The two vectors together constitute the molecular vibration. symmetric stretch Γ = (1 1 1 1) A1 Both IR and Raman active Both IR and Raman active anti-symmetric stretch Γ = (1 -1 -1 1) B2 y z x symmetric stretch Γ = (1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1) Ag Raman active IR active anti-symmetric stretch Γ = (1 -1 1 -1 -1 1 1 -1 ) B2u In H2O, how many vibrational modes belong to each irreducible representation? You need the point group and the character table • Centre of mass (or centre of symmetry) at origin. • z axis = highest order axis and principal axis. If several axes of highest order, the z axis is the one that passes through most atoms. • Then assign x axis. If molecule is planar and z axis in plane, then the x axis is plane In H2O, how many vibrational modes belong to each irreducible representation? You need the point group and the character table degrees of freedom Use the translation vectors of the atoms as the basis of a reducible representation. Since you only need the trace recognise that only the vectors that are either unchanged or have become the negatives of themselves by a symmetry operation contribute to the character. Note that a vector will either be unchanged or the negative of itself if the atom does not move. Now consider only the atoms that don’t move A reflection can either leave the vector unchanged (multiply by +1) or change direction (multiply by -1) A rotation can either invert the direction of the vector (multiply by -1) or leave it unchanged (multiply by +1) Nothing x -1 Γ moves y -1 z1 9 -1 x1 y -1 z1 1 x -1,-1,-1 y 1,1,1, z 1,1,1 3 Now express the reducible representation as the sum of the irreducible representations of the point group. You should find that Γ = 3A1 + A2 + 2B1 + 3B2 Three are translations (t): A1, B1, B2. Three are rotations (r): A2, B1, B2 The remaining three are vibrations (v): 2A1 + B2 Three are translations (t): A1, B1, B2. Three are rotations (r): A2, B1, B2 Which of these vibrations with A1 or B2 symmetry are IR and/or Raman active? Vibrational modes of water Raman active IR active Suppose we were only interested in the stretching modes and not all the vibrational modes. Then a reasonable basis set would be the following two vectors: O H H It should be easy to see that Γ = (2 0 0 2) = A1 + B2 Don’t confuse with the following: To what symmetry species* does the following vibration belong? Is it IRor Raman-active or both? N O *or O “how does the following vibration transform” “what us the symmetry of” etc. Note that this is one single vibration not two vectors representing the motion of the molecule as in the previous example. Review question a) Draw a Lewis structure of XeF3+ and use VSEPR theory to predict two plausible structures. b) Use group theory to explain how vibrational spectroscopy could be used to determine the actual structure