The ENVISION Advantage CMOS Digital X-ray An Introduction to Envision’s CMOS Technology and Products For more info please call : 907-563-1141 or e-mail to johnc@cmosxray.com Presentation prepared by Tom Dilliner This presentation and all information contained within is copyright protected Any technical data and specifications presented herein are subject to change. Next The following slides form an overview of the Envision CMOS Digital X-ray Imaging products and their related technology. This overview is intended to serve as an introduction to the methodologies behind the Envision CMOS technology and a platform to share the various products offered by Envision. Please check back often or call us as product information sometimes changes or new products are introduced. Use the buttons at the bottom of each slide to advance, go back or return to either the Main Menu or the Products Menu (when you are in the products section). Please let us know if you have any suggestions or have questions about the information presented. Sincerely, John Pursley President, Envision Product Design LLC e-mail: johnp@cmosxray.com Phone: 907-563-1141 Main Menu MAIN MENU A. Who is Envision Product Design? B. An Introduction to Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology Listing Key Attributes C. The Three Main Modalities of CMOS Line Array Utilization Envision’s History Envision Today First: Second: Third: D. EnvisionScan EnSync EnMotion Products Menu Envision’s Line up of Digital Imaging Products E. CR (Computed Radiography) vs. DR (Digital Radiography) Envision's History... Founded in 1993 by John and Sandi Pursley, Envision Product Design has created industry-leading innovations in gamma and X-ray imaging systems along with intelligent robotic crawlers and manipulators. In the oil industry in Alaska, hundreds of miles of pipeline have been inspected using our robotic imaging systems, operating year-around in one of the most difficult environments on earth. The use of Envision’s corrosion inspection equipment has resulted in savings of millions of dollars to the petroleum industry, and significant protection for Alaska’s arctic environment. In January 2000, Envision announced the first in a series of x-ray imaging products based on CMOS (Complementary Metal Oxide Semiconductor) sensors. Main Menu Envision Today... Today, Envision's product line ranges from a breakthrough hand-held X-ray video system, to a sophisticated high-energy large format system for rocket inspection. Envision's CMOS X-ray equipment is used to search for bombs; inspect wings and fuel tanks on space shuttles, missiles and other defense ordinance, commercial aircraft parts, medical products, electronic components, composite structures, agricultural product, automotive castings, tires, railroad tankers, pipelines, turbine blades, and numerous other applications where manufactures and researchers are taking advantage of the cost savings of implementing CMOS imaging technologies. Since it’s inception, Envision has continuously progressed as a leader in the development of digital X-ray systems and has been credited for exceptional commitment and rapid response to it’s customers' needs. Envision's mission statement: We will strive to design and produce high performance and long lasting products that exceed the customer's expectations. Main Menu An Introduction to Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology In this section we will look at the primary attributes of the Envision CMOS line array technology as an industrial digital x-ray imaging detector. We will also look at the benefits and design features of the Envision CMOS detector and learn why Envision may be the best solution for your digital x-ray imaging needs. Main Menu Key Attributes of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. High Spatial Resolution Broad Range of Format Sizes NO BAD PIXELS or Pixel Lines Durability Temperature Range Large Fill Factor High Sensitivity Off-Axis Detection Useful Life - Rated 20,000 Hours and ... Main Menu more ... Key Attributes of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. Main Menu High Energy Use (High MeV) High Signal-to-Noise Ratio Minimum or NO Parallax No Image Blooming No Latent Images Lower Cost (3) THREE-YEAR Warranty Key Attributes of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology Let’s take a closer look at each attribute listed ... Main Menu Key Attributes of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 1. High Spatial Resolution Spatial Resolution is the size of the smallest detail that can be seen with an imaging system and is primarily defined by the size of the pixels in the detector. The Envision CMOS line array detector has a pixel size of only 80 microns (0.0031"). For example: this is approximately 30% better spatial resolution than amorphous silicon, which has a pixel size of 127 microns. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 2. Format Size Envision CMOS detector arrays offer a wide range of format sizes. Standard EnvisionScan panel sizes include 3”x6”, 6”x8”, 12”x14”, 18”x18”, and 24”x24”. Custom sizes are also available. Standard Sizes Custom Sizes Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 3. NO Bad Pixels or Pixel Lines The Envision CMOS array detector is delivered with NO dead or bad pixels, not one. Envision has the best warranty in the industry protecting the customer against this. This is important to note because some detectors, for example Amorphous silicon detectors, are manufactured in a way that, because of their design, yields a certain percentage of bad or "dead" pixels throughout the full area of the detector. These detectors are usually sold in different "grades" as to the yield of actual "good" pixels. So, "out of the box", the amorphous silicon panel is riddled with already "dead" pixels and will continue to degrade over its use and succumb to an increase in dead pixels and dead pixel lines. Dead pixel “lines” are a result of the way the amorphous silicon pixels are "wired together" or amplified causing an entire pixel row to go "dead". Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 4. Durability The Envision CMOS detector utilizes an extremely robust metal oxide design. The CMOS detectors are "hardened" designed to withstand the everyday rigors of handling and to tolerate shock. The design of the CMOS detector’s active pixel sensor allows all the electronic control and amplifier circuitry to be located directly at each pixel instead of being delicately wired to circuitry at the edge of the detector array (as with amorphous silicon detectors). Also, amorphous silicon detectors have the substrate deposited directly on glass making them relatively fragile as compared to the Envision CMOS array. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 5. Temperature Range All digital detectors are subject to increases in electronic noise when the ambient temperature increases, but CMOS has far less of this characteristic as compared to amorphous silicon. Amorphous silicon panels may require recalibration with as little as 10 degree F temperature change. CMOS detectors require little or no recalibration across a broad operating range of 32º to 110º F. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 6. Fill Factor The "fill factor" of a detector is the percentage of the surface area that is actually active, that is, capable of detecting photons. For example, where Envision's CMOS detector arrays have a fill factor in excess of 90%, the amorphous silicon detectors have a fill factor of only about 63%. The higher the fill factor, the more sensitive the detector is. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 7. Sensitivity As shown in the previous slide, the fill factor determines the sensitivity of the detector. The Envision CMOS array is able to capture an image in as little as 1 milli-second. Pixel for pixel, this is a fraction of the time required by the amorphous silicon elements. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 8. Off-Axis Detection This describes the design of the Envision CMOS detector, which means the CMOS pixel sensors are protected from the direct xray radiation. This is a main reason that the Envision CMOS detectors are suitable for the higher energies (including the upper MeV range) while maintaining sensitivity even at a low 20kV. This design feature also significantly increases the useful life of the detector over virtually all other detectors on the market. The Envision CMOS line array detector is also shielded from radiation by a sufficient thickness of lead and tungsten. A built-in slot collimator directs the radiation to the ends of micro fiber optic couplers, which are coated with a scintillating material. The fiber optic couplers then direct the light photons (created by the scintillator) to the detector pixels that are "off-axis" (perpendicular) to the radiation beam. This feature is a very important attribute of the Envision CMOS array. Main Menu CMOS Line Array Off-Axis Design Collimated Slot Radiation Shielding Tungsten Housing CMOS Active Pixel Sensor array (“OffAxis” to Slot) Coupled to Scintillator via fiber optics This simple illustration is intended to reveal only the general design principle of the off-axis feature.. Main Menu Scintillator at Base of Slot converts x-ray photons to light X-ray Source Collimated Fan or Cone X-ray Beam (depending on application or configuration of detector system) Radiation passes down through the collimated slot in the detector housing and strikes the scintillation material; the pixel elements are shielded against radiation. When using a collimated fan beam, minimum radiation shielding is required Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 9. Useful Life The useful life of the Envision CMOS array is rated at over 20,000 hours! This is mainly due to the Off-Axis design as previously discussed. All digital imaging detectors have a useful life (or RAD life) where during the course of being exposed to radiation eventually reach a point where they are unusable. SO ... For example: If the CMOS detector is exposed continuously to radiation for 8 hours per day for 5 days per week, one would expect to get a minimum of 10 years useful life from the detector. Nothing else comes close! Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 10. High Energy The inherent architecture of the CMOS Line Array detector with the "off-axis" design chiefly contributes to the detectors long life and performance characteristics even in the high MeV range. There simply is no other digital x-ray imaging technology on the market today that can offer the performance that the Envision CMOS Linear detector technology offers. “Highest Energy”, “Largest Format”, “Longest Life”, “Highest Resolution” ... are all hallmark features of the Envision High Energy Detectors. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 11. High-Signal-to-Noise Because the CMOS line array detector incorporates a collimated slot and tungsten construction, any scatter radiation to the detector elements is minimized or eliminated. Any scatter radiation, at higher energies, can be further reduced by highly collimating the x-ray beam (as opposed to a cone beam used in conventional radiography and with amorphous silicon area detectors) This attribute contributes significantly to maximizing image quality, especially when your inspection technique requires those higher energies. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 12. Less Radiographic Parallax Cone beam techniques introduce parallax in all directions, where as with the CMOS line array, it is only introduced along the length of the detector. The EnMotion™, EnSync™ and EnvisionScan NP ™ products from Envision utilize this imaging methodology and will be explained in detail later on. Main Menu EnMotion™, EnSync ™ or EnvisionScan NP ™ Digital X-Ray Imaging ... EXAMPLE: No Parallax Part size: 4” diameter x 28” long NO PARALLAX Main Menu Note: All radiographic images have been compressed for download speed and therefore image quality may be reduced. Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 13. No Image Blooming A common occurrence with most other detectors, including amorphous silicon detectors, is image blooming. This occurs when individual pixels in the detector are over-driven (or saturated) by direct radiation (to the pixels). This happens in Amorphous Silicon detectors because the pixels deliver their signals to the electronic amplifiers in a "bucket brigade" along each row and column. When one or more pixels are over-driven, the signal from all other pixels in that row and column can be affected causing "blooming" or streaks in the observed image. This is also called "edge burn-out" where blooming occurs at the edge of the part where radiation saturates the pixel elements of the amorphous silicon detector and prevents the edges from being seen. CMOS detectors eliminate this problem because each pixel is amplified independently (at each pixel) and thereby pixel signals do not affect adjoining pixel signals. Again, NO edge "burn-out". This is another major attribute of the CMOS array. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 14. No Latent Images A historic issue with amorphous silicon panels is the problem with latent images. This is where, to the operator, you may see image data "leftover" from a previous exposure showing up in your new image. This usually requires time-consuming re-calibration measures to correct for this problem. The Envision CMOS detector NEVER experiences this problem. Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 15. Cost The initial investment of the Envision CMOS detector is usually less than virtually all competing digital technologies. Its robust design ensures years of trouble free service and in the unlikely event of failure or damage, the CMOS array can be repaired relatively quickly and easily at a truly nominal cost, making "cost of ownership" significantly lower than any other digital imaging technology. Also, a lease purchase may be the easiest way to move into “digital xray” by simply switching your current operating costs of your film based operation over to the digital equipment lease. Once the lease agreement is fulfilled, it’s money $$$ to the bottom-line! We can show you how! Main Menu Key Advantages of Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology 16. Warranty Envision now offers an unprecedented (3) THREE - YEAR Warranty on its Envision CMOS Line Array detector products. This extension of the warranty period was prompted because of the remarkable success and performance from the numerous installations over the previous six years. This is unmatched by any other digital detector manufacturer in the industry! Main Menu The Three Main Modalities of CMOS Line Array Utilization First: Using a fixed x-ray source, producing a cone beam, the line array is put into motion similar to a flat bed scanner. This modality is used in the EnvisionScan™ Panel system. See next slide for animated illustration EnvisionScan™ Digital Imaging Panel Main Menu Illustration showing the basic operation of the EnvisionScan™ Panel detector EnvisionScan™ Panel Main Menu Animation may take a moment to start The Three Main Modalities of CMOS Line Array Utilization Second: Using a motion system, the detector array is moved in-synchronous with the x-ray source along the length of the part. This methodology is incorporated in Envision’s EnSync™ system. See next slide for animated illustration Main Menu EnSync™ Methodology X-ray tube and detector move “in-synchronized” motion while test part remains stationary No Parallax in the scan direction! Main Menu Click to start scanning The Three Main Modalities of CMOS Line Array Utilization Third. The detector array and x-ray source are fixed while the test sample is conveyed through the x-ray beam. This methodology is used in the EnMotion™ Systems ... And now in the EnvisionScan-NP. See next slide for animated illustration Main Menu EnMotion™ Methodology X-Ray tube and detector remain stationary while test part is conveyed thru collimated x-ray beam. Click to start scanning No Parallax in the scan direction! Main Menu Products Menu Envision’s Lineup of X-ray Imaging Products Envision Movement Systems Integrated Motion Control EnvisionScan™ Detector Panels EnvisionScan-NP™ Integrated Conveyorized Panel EnMotion™ Complete Turn-key Inspection Systems EnSync™ Radiographic Inspection Systems EnXtreme™ - High Energy CMOS Envision 4x4™ Portable Ultra-High Resolution System EnvisionScan GW-2™ Weld Scanning System ScanTrack PL – Pipeline Gamma-ray Scanner SegmentedArray™ - Line Array Detector Tire Inspection System OpenVision LT™ Portable Hand-Held X-Ray System Security Inspection Systems EnStereo™ – 3-D Stereo-Scopic Scanning System EnSpect™ and iX-Pect™ Image Acquisition and Processing Software Main Menu Envision Movement Systems In over thirteen years, Envision has developed and refined a broad range of application-specific movement systems from simple conveyors to five-axis manipulators and autonomous robotic vehicles for mobilizing digital X-ray systems. CMOS imaging technology can also be readily adapted to any existing movement system where Envision provides the motor controllers, feedback encoders, and software adaptation. Any number of axes of motion can be controlled with load requirements of a few ounces to thousands of pounds. Envision designs and builds its own intelligent motion controllers, or if there is already a commercial motion control system is place, an interface can readily be provided in software. Precise and robust closed-loop control with pulsewidth-modulation is easily adapted to motion stages of all sizes. Because the imaging software has been developed with motion control already fully integrated, the cost to add control to existing motion systems or to provide control of a new set of motion stages is minimal. Main Menu Product Menu EnvisionScan™ CMOS Panels Sizable Panels with standard sizes of 3”x6”, 6”x8”, 12”x14”, 18”x18”, and 24”x24”. Custom sizes are available. 80 Micron High Resolution Comprehensive and intuitive iX-pect image acquisition and full feature image processing software. Packaged with fully equipped computer workstation and highresolution flat panel monitor. Energies from 40kV up to 15meV Robust Design Versatility: whether in the production lab or in the field. 3 Year Warranty Envision CMOS Line Array Technology Inside Main Menu Product Menu EnvisionScan™ CMOS Panels Can be placed in virtually any existing cabinet or vault or ... Let Envision design a complete system for you! In the lab or in the field ... ... EnvisionScan stands up to the rigors of any environment! ESP-24 Fully Battery Operated Main Menu Product Menu EnvisionScan NP™ Conveyorized Panel Detector System 3”, 6”, 12”, 18” or 24” Wide Panel integrated with conveyor movement system and Envision’s CMOS Line Array Technology. Available in a range of sizes from 3” to 24” wide. Conveyor can be any length up to 10 feet. X-ray beam can be collimated (fan) for minimized radiation shielding. Truly innovative design! Take advantage of NO parallax imaging. Incremental or continuous imaging Realtime Scrolling Adaptable to most radiographic cabinets or let Envision build you a turnkey system. Envision CMOS Line Array Technology Inside Main Menu Product Menu Envision EnMotion™ Digital X-Ray Imaging EnMotion™ ● Real-Time Scrolling ● Automatic Image Acquisition ● Automated Data Management ● Parts 2” or 200” Long: NO Parallax! Automated Conveyorized Digital X-Ray Inspection Envision CMOS Line Array Technology Inside Main Menu Product Menu ● Automatic Defect Recognition (ADR) Available ● Available with 160, 225, 320 or 450kV x-ray sources including a wide range of microfocus x-ray sources ● Conforms to Lean Manufacturing Methodologies ● Custom Built to Any Size for Your Application ● Can be adapted with Envision’s EnStereo™ Stereoscopic 3-D imaging package ● Fast Return on Investment EnMotion™ Digital X-Ray Imaging Lean Manufacturing Methodology High-resolution High-production Main Menu Product Menu Custom Designed Specifically for Your Needs! Envision EnSync™ System This system utilizes the in-synchronous (EnSync™) methodology as explained in an earlier slide. Scan parts 2” long to over 200” long in one just one image: Image Size Format = Length of CMOS Detector x Length of Part (or scan). No Parallax in the scan direction. Real-time Scrolling Fully custom designed. If you can imagine it, we can design it! For large parts or assemblies where space is limited or part cannot be moved. Great for honeycomb core assemblies. Can be used with fractional focus or microfocus x-ray. Size format is up to you. Automatic Defect Recognition Available Fully integrated for control of all motions, x-ray system parameters, image acquisition and image archival. Main Menu Product Menu Envision CMOS Line Array Technology Inside Example of an EnSync™ System Taking advantage of NO Parallax imaging along length of scan System shown used for the inspection of honeycomb core closeout along periphery edge and splices on fuel tank panels for Boeing’s 777 aircraft. Main Menu Product Menu Envision EnXtreme™ High Energy CMOS MeV Energy Range Energy range: 1 to 15MeV Tungsten + Off-axis detector design Special scintillation design Lengths from 3 inches to 6 feet For integration into any line array based Envision Product! Main Menu Product Menu EnSync™ High Energy Application Main Menu Product Menu High Energy Large Assembly Application using EnMotion™ 15” Diameter x 60” Long Object 3” to 5” carbon steel shot at 6 MeV Note: Example shows image format size for large objects. All radiographic images have been compressed for download speed and therefore image quality may be reduced. Main Menu Product Menu Envision 4x4™ Portable CMOS Ultra-High Resolution X-Ray Imaging System Envision’s small lightweight ultra-high resolution CMOS panel system. Fully Battery or AC operated. 4”x4” image area 48 Micron Pixel Size USB for Ultimate Portability using small Laptop Computer Images can be acquired using any number of x-ray sources including the pulsed XR200 battery operated x-ray tube, microfocus x-ray and conventional x-ray systems up to 160kV. Optional Wireless Control Envision’s EnSpect™ software included; a complete image acquisition and image processing software that is loaded with features. Main Menu Product Menu Envision 4x4™ Portable CMOS Ultra-high Resolution X-Ray Imaging System Mini Laptop computer with EnSpect™ Software Also available in a very small profile 2x2 for specialized & limited access applications Main Menu Stows away in compact case (Shown with XR200 pulsed x-ray source) Product Menu EnvisionScan™ GW-2 Pipeline Girth Weld Scanner Using the latest CMOS X-ray imaging technology, the GW-2 can complete a 3-inch wide, high-resolution scan of a 24-inch pipeline in one to two minutes depending on pipe wall thickness. The GW-2 is an automated digital X-ray scanner for inspecting pipeline welds during new construction. It has also be used in a variety of other applications including railroad tank car inspection. The system is sturdy, compact and lightweight, easily deployed on the pipeline by one person. Using a unique flexible track system, the GW-2 can be mounted to the pipeline, ready to scan, in less than 30 seconds. The GW-2's small rugged computer handles the scanning tasks, while the operator's portable workstation captures the inspection allowing instant analysis and digital storage of the inspected weld. Main Menu Product Menu ScanTrack PL™ Pipeline Gamma-ray Scanner The ScanTrack PL™ is an automated digital Gamma-ray scanner for inspecting in-service pipelines for internal and external corrosion under insulation. Using the latest CMOS X-ray imaging technology, the ScanTrack PL™ can conduct a survey of just the bottom of a pipeline, or provide 100% circumferential coverage. The system is robust, compact, and automatic. Using a unique auto-steering track system, the ScanTrack PL™ can be mounted to the pipeline by one man and ready for operation in a couple minutes. A small rugged computer handles the scanning tasks, while the operator's workstation captures the digital Gamma-ray image in real-time, allowing instant analysis and storage of the inspected area images. Main Menu Product Menu SegmentedArray™ Adaptable Detector Technology In addition to the modalities already shown, the line array is also adaptable to a variety of possible unique applications including inserting the array into a cylindrical object and rotating the object about the fixed array ... single wall with consistent density. The line array can also be shaped while providing a continuous image along its entire length. This 5segment configuration is used in Envision’s Tire Inspection system as shown in the next slide. A special panoramic x-ray tube is used in this case. Line Array “Envision what you can do!” Main Menu Product Menu Tire Inspection System High-production Tire Inspection system used by world leading tire manufacturers including Michelin and Dunlop. Robust and Reliable Uses special panoramic x-ray tube. Uses 5 individual line array segments shaped as a horseshoe. Call for more information. Main Menu Product Menu Envision CMOS Line Array Technology Inside Envision OpenVision LT™ Hand-Held Real-Time X-Ray Imaging System A light-weight C-arm system for portable xray inspection including Corrosion Under Insulation (CUI). Includes a highly sensitive X-ray imager and battery-operated 70Kv Xray tube designed for portable field operation. This unit’s 4” x 6” imaging area allows the operator to safely inspect large sections of insulated pipe much more quickly than any previously available system. Images are presented on a High-Resolution, military grade, heads-up display mounted to standard safety glasses. Optional viewing monitors and recording devices available. This unit is ideal for looking for corrosion in aircraft wing sections and a host of other applications! “Envision what you can do!!” Main Menu Product Menu Features at-a-glance: ○ State-of-the-art x-ray imaging ○ Light-weight hand-held C-arm ○ NO isotopes to deal with ○ NO need to stop work in surrounding area ○ 250 micron resolution ○ Full Dynamic Real-time Imaging (30 frames/sec) ○ Includes two lithium-ion batteries and a 1-hour battery charger ○ Custom sizes and energies available! Envision OpenVision LT™ Hand-Held Real-Time X-Ray Imaging System Rugged Simplistic Effective Easily stows away in a Pelican Field Case Entire C-arm weighs only 15 lbs! Main Menu Product Menu EnStereo™ - Stereo-Scopic Scanning System Presents 3-D Stereo-Scopic Images on a special monitor that the operator can view without the use of special glasses or headgear. Utilizes Dual CMOS Line Arrays for Enhanced Perspective Imagery Aides the operator in providing a fast relative perspective of internal features within the part being x-rayed. Two separate images having two different perspectives are recorded for 2-D viewing and or 3-D viewing. Immediately determine relative depth of defects and the order of features within the test part (e.g., two linear features crossing each other can be readily distinguished as to which is closest to the surface and the relative distance between the two). Can be used with any EnMotion™ system or EnSync ™ system configuration. Consists of Envision’s EnStereo ™ software and hardware along with the CMOS line array adaptation. Phenomenal 3-D Perspective Images! Main Menu Product Menu Security EnvisionScan ESP-24™ Large Format. Battery Operated OpenVision LT™ Handheld. Full Dynamic Video. Battery Operated. OpenVision LT™ Ultra-Resolution. Ultra-Portable. Ultra-Fast. Battery Operated Robotic Crawlers Remote Controlled. Rugged and Dependable. Mobile Scan Cargo Scanning System. Large Format. High-Resolution. Main Menu Product Menu Envision’s Dynamic Imaging Software iX-Pect™ Software for all Envision CMOS Line Array detector systems. User friendly and has all the features you want and more. Adaptable to meet your specific requirements EnSpect™ Software for the Envision 4x4 detector system Feature packed and easy to use Everything you want in an imaging software package ADR (Automatic Defect Recognition) Software from Envision Optional Software for production applications Reduces or eliminates the subjectivity of operator Main Menu Product Menu Characteristics of Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) The Procedure Portability Resolution Format Sizes Speed High-Production Use Cost Pros of each Method Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) The Procedure CR Like film radiography, CR requires exposing the cassette. Typically a cassette (rigid or vinyl) is loaded with the CR phosphor plate and then used in the same manner as film. The cassette is then transported from the inspection site to the reader/processor location. The CR plate is loaded into a processor unit, much like a film processor, and the plate is scanned with a laser optic method. A digital image is subsequently produced, and the image is evaluated on a PC. The plate is then erased. If a “re-shot” is required, the cassette is returned to the inspection site for another exposure and the process is repeated. DR DR is much like going from film based photography to a using digital camera. An image is captured by simply exposing the digital panel. The images are immediately available for review and evaluation on the display monitor. Like the digital camera, if a re-shot is necessary, a new exposure can be taken right away. In the case of the Envision scanning array detector, images can be presented and viewed in realtime as the detector is scanning. Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Portability CR CR cassettes are very portable. The technology excels when the technician must access difficult locations where a DR cable would be impractical to manage; there is very limited access behind the inspection object; or where it is necessary to conform the imaging plate to a curved surface. The CR reader/eraser is not typically portable; smaller portable CR readers are now available but lack the performance typically associated with the requirements of most NDT operations. DR The DR panel can be field portable, depending on the panel size. The DR workstation can also be a laptop PC. The Envision EnvisionScan panels are extremely robust and designed for even adverse conditions in the field. These panels are now available in a completely battery operated (ESP-24) version. The Envision 4x4 portable, ultra-high resolution CMOS panel, is extremely versatile, lightweight, and portable and is operated off a mini laptop computer; fully battery operated. Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Resolution CR The resolution at which the cassette is read is selectable; with the highest currently available being 100 microns. Higher resolution systems may become available in the future. The trade-off with higher resolution capabilities is that the technique will require more exposure time and read time. At 100 microns, the time required to read/digitize a CR plate is 1 to 5 minutes, depending on model/brand. DR The resolution at which the DR panel captures images is selectable, the highest available with DR is the Envision 4x4™ panel at only 48 microns. The large format Envision line array detectors are just 80 microns. Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Format Size CR The sizes available for CR plates are typically limited to that of film with the largest at 14” x 17”. Portable CR systems are typically limited to 8” x 10”. DR The Envision line array detector system is available in a wide range of sizes. The EnvisionScan panels are available in standard sizes of 3” x 6”, 6” x 8”, 12” x 14”, 18” x 18”, or 24” x 24”. Custom larger sizes are also available. The image scan area is user selectable with any EnvisionScan panel. For example: If you have a 24” x 24” EnvisionScan panel and only want to image an area of 4” wide, then you can select only that area of interest to be scanned. The Envision line array detectors can be adapted to a variety of system configurations with lengths from 3” up to 72”! For example: With the Envision EnSync™ or EnMotion™ system, a part 54” in diameter and 60 feet long could be radiographed in just one image! Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Speed CR Like film, CR requires the secondary step of processing an image plate in a remote processor unit. Actual exposure time is typically close to that of film. Reading an image varies from one model/brand to another. Turn around time can typically be anywhere from 2 minutes to 10 minutes. DR DR can provide images within just a few seconds. With Envision’s CMOS line array images can be presented in realtime as scanning is taking place; with Envision’s 4x4™ detector, 6-7 frames per second can be achieved (LVDS Model). Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) High-Production Use CR Because CR is much like traditional film, it requires the same multiple steps before an image can be displayed. For high-production use, several CR imaging plates are required. These are typically handled like film and must be managed in the same way. If re-shots are required, it may be several minutes before it is known. CR requires sometimes multiple personnel to carry out the production operation and does not readily lend itself to any type of automation or ADR (Automatic Defect Recognition) capabilities. DR DR lends itself to the high-production, “lean manufacturing” environment. It is easily adaptable with any level of automation and can be outfitted with ADR (Automatic Defect Recognition) capabilities. In a variety of inspection applications, ADR offers the opportunity to remove the subjectivity of the interpreter, where the software automatically interprets the image data either fully or at an operator assist level. Also DR offers larger image formats, especially the CMOS line array systems offered by Envision. Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Cost CR The typical CR system consists of a reader/eraser workstation with PC, display monitor and software. A supply of image plates and cassettes is also required. The CR image plates are sometimes damaged through normal handling and either have to be replaced or the artifacts on the plate managed from one image to another. Image plates are a consumable item and their cost should be considered. One CR reader unit can be used to support more than one x-ray unit but often DR can eliminate the need for a secondary x-ray booth. DR When it comes to initial cost, DR is comparably priced to CR system, however for cost-of-ownership, DR excels especially with the performance and survivability of the Envision CMOS line arrays. There are no consumables with DR. With Envision’s unprecedented three-year warranty on its line array detectors, you won’t be concerned with after-the-sale costs. Main Menu Computed Radiography (CR) vs. Envision’s Digital Radiography (DR) Pros of Each CR CR excels for those applications where access is limited. CR is often considered a direct film replacement, however, as already discussed, requires the same intermediate steps as film. If the imaging plate needs to conform to a curved shape, then CR may be the only option. CR is often the best choice for use with isotope sources. DR DR excels for production applications where speed and/or image quality are paramount. It is often said that “If you can go with DR, then you will definitely want DR”. It makes little sense to go with CR, unless you absolutely need to. Often CR and DR can augment each other in the inspection environment where the image data from both systems can be brought into one image management program for image archival. Main Menu So what’s next? Call today for more information or to discuss your particular application, needs or interest. We want to hear from you. We can provide you a complimentary evaluation of your sample ... just send your sample directly to Envision at the address on the next slide. Please call us first to schedule your application study. You are welcome to come visit Envision’s facilities in Anchorage, Alaska ... You’ll be glad you did! We may want to schedule a visit to your facility and perhaps arrange an onsite demonstration. Again, just give us a call today. Get more info: Call 907-563-1141 Main Menu Contact information Please call: John Cope 907-232-3592 cell 907-563-1141 office Envision Product Design is located at: 7800 King Street Anchorage, AK 99518 Main Menu