best practice suggestions for 2012 - Kraus

advertisement

PRESENTOR

Patrick D. Kennedy, Vice President

Kraus-Anderson Insurance

| pkennedy@kainsurance.com | O: 952.707.8236

| http://www.linkedin.com/in/patrickdkennedy

Presentation available at www.kainsurance.com

REDUCE YOUR COST OF RISK

STRATEGIES FOR SHORT & LONG TERM SAVINGS

ON CORPORATE INSURANCE.

PROPERTY & CASUALTY - MARKET TREND.

INSURANCE - - A CORPORATE ASSET?

COST OF RISK

VS.

COST OF INSURANCE.

CONTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT -

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INDUSTRY

Carnac the Magnificent says . . . . .

First Half 2011 US CAT Losses Already Exceed Losses from All of 2010.

Even Modest Hurricane Losses Will Make 2011 Among the Most

Expensive Ever for CATs

Insurance Information Institute

August, 2011

- - Ratings company A.M. Best put the pre-tax tally from catastrophes through the first nine months of 2011 at

$38.6 billion in the U.S. alone. That figure doesn't include still mounting losses from the record- breaking earthquake in Japan and massive flooding in Thailand.

12/06/2011; Dow Jones News Service

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

100

90

80

70

Number of Federal Disaster Declarations,

1953-2011*

The average number of declarations per year is

34 from 1953-2010, though that few haven’t been recorded since 1995.

A new record set in 2011 with 86 declarations through Sept. 30.

It is no wonder that FEMA is broke!

17 18 16 16

7 7

12 12

25 25

11 11

17 17

46 46

27 28

45 45

53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11*

*Through October 31, 2011.

Source: Federal Emergency Management Administration: http://www.fema.gov/news/disaster_totals_annual.fema

;

Insurance Information Institute.

Top 12 Most Costly Disasters in U.S. History

(Insured Losses, 2010 Dollars, $ Billions)

$50

$45

$40

$35

$30

$25

$20

$15

$10

$5

$0

$4.3

Taken as a single event, the 2011

Spring tornado season would become the 5

$5.3

th costliest event in

US insurance history

$6.3

$6.7

$8.2

$8.6

$11.5 $12.8

$14.0

$17.5

$22.6 $23.1

$45.8

Jeanne

(2004)

Frances

(2004)

Rita

(2005)

Hugo

(1989)

Ivan

(2004)

Charley

(2004)

Wilma

(2005)

Ike

(2008)

Spring Northridge

Tornadoes* (1994)

(2011)

Andrew 9/11 Attack Katrina

(1992) (2001) (2005)

*Losses will actually be broken down into several “events” as determined by PCS.

Sources: PCS; Insurance Information Institute inflation adjustments.

5

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INDUSTRY

Carnac the Magnificent says . . . . .

- Travelers Chief Executive Jay Fishman, “said his company had increased prices for business-insurance clients by 5.2% in October and 5.8% in November, the largest rates increase in several years.”

12/06/2011; Dow Jones News Service

- S&P also called the workers comp industry’s track record of underwriting results “dismal,” with only three years of underwriting profits being earned during the past two decades. “Although many property/casualty insurers, especially those writing workers compensation, rely on investment incomes to offset underwriting losses, current historically low investment yields could also hinder such dependence going forward,” S&P said.

1/23/2012; Standard & Poor’s Corporation Report.

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INDUSTRY

Carnac the Magnificent says . . . . .

William R Berkley, CEO Berkley Companies

. . . . “Two and a half years ago, I thought the cycle was going to change because I expected AIG not to get the degree of help from the government that it did. I was incorrect. The government, as we all know, effectively bailed out AIG, which delayed the inevitable.”

“Berkley says the assistance allowed AIG to cut prices, and it ‘held the market in check,’ preventing widespread rate increases.”

NU Online News Service, December 7 th 2011

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INDUSTRY

Carnac . . . Please Translate!

What does all of this mean to me?

Industry-wide Rate increases for first time in 7 years.

Building/Property Rates are leading the way.

Market trend will last 2 Years - minimum.

Standard Market buyers: revise your composite rate / unit cost pricing renewal expectations.

Standard Market buyers: conduct early pre-renewal meetings, discuss what renewal strategy changes should take place because of this market change.

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INDUSTRY

Carnac . . . Please Translate!

What does all of this mean to me?

Consider Risk Financing Alternatives

- Higher Deductibles / Retentions.

- Loss Sensitive Plans.

- Self-Insurance.

- Captives

ADDITIONAL STRATEGIES:

- Negotiate to extend current policies at current rates in order to accomplish a Renewal Date change.

- Consider changing your Anniversary Date to a less popular time (ie., 3/31, 6/30, 9/30).

- Identify a Risk Control Action that you can specifically

‘monetize’ as a direct savings in your upcoming renewal.

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

Insurance Policies - - acquired and then put away.

However, when Loss occurs, recovery of the

‘Insurance Asset’ immediately becomes all too real.

FUNDEMENTALS OF INSURANCE AS AN ASSET

• Document Retention Policy

• Track / Retain “Additional Insured” Endorsements.

Why? Because they are one of your Insurance Assets.

• INSURANCE TEAM - Important to Work Together as Allies.

• Communicate, Communicate, Communicate . . . . .

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

INSURANCE TEAM

Focus on Insurance Program Fundamentals

- Catastrophe Protection.

- Loss Prevention.

- Claims Management.

- Benchmarking & Record Keeping.

- Contract Compliance.

- Bottom-line Price.

and

Communicate, Communicate, Communicate . . . .

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

CAN YOUR INSURANCE TEAM ANSWER

THE FOLLOWIG RISK COST QUESTIONS?

What are our significant risk cost drivers?

What is our organization’s Annual Cost of Risk?

What direction is it headed?

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

What are significant risk cost drivers?

Common categories are:

1. Retained (Uninsured) Losses

2. Transfer (Insurance) Costs

3. Administrative (Labor) Costs

4. Risk Control Costs

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

Driver #1) RETAINED (UNINSURED) LOSSES

“Cost of accidental losses not reimbursed by insurance or other outside sources”.

1. ACTIVE RETENTION; such as Deductibles, Self-

Insured Retentions or conscious noninsurance.

2. PASSIVE RETENTION; unplanned acceptance of losses because of failure to act, forgetting to act or failure to identify loss exposure.

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

Driver #2) TRANSFER COSTS

1. Insurance Premiums

2. Noninsurance Indemnity or outside sources to fund losses.

3. Loss Funding.

4. Agent/Broker Remuneration, if outside premiums.

5. Broker Fees for (a) safety services, (b) claims administration, (c) consulting/training

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

Driver #3) CLAIMS ADMINISTRATION EXPENSES

Claim expenses for losses not included in the Insurance Premiums.

1. Third Party claims administrator .

2. Public Adjuster or Claim Consultant.

3. Salary burden of in-house claims administration.

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

Driver #4) RISK CONTROL COSTS

“The costs associated with the prevention or reduction of accidental losses.”

Money spent on Risk Control can greatly influence the ultimate cost of

(a) Retained Losses,

(b) Transfer Costs, and

(c) Claims Administration.

INSURANCE IS AN ASSET,

NOT A CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT!

TOTAL COST OF RISK

CALCULATING THE COST OF RISK

Retained Losses

Transfer Costs

Admin Costs

Risk Control

Totals

WC Liability Property Professional Total

$14.3

$1.6

$0.1

$0.3

$16.3

$1.8

$3.9

$1.1

$0.9

$0.3

$0.0

$0.6

$0.0

$7.4

$1.2

$0.6

$0.1

$0.2

$17.6

$5.9

$1.4

$0.0

$0.9

$0.9

$25.8

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

Treat your Insurance / Risk Management Program as an Corporate Asset.

Create a Risk Management TEAM.

Have the TEAM Set Goals & Benchmark results.

The TEAM should include Owner/Sr. Mgmt,

Accounting, Safety, Legal and Insurance Personnel.

Include your Agent/Broker or Consultant. If not able or willing, get a new one.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

COST OF RISK

IDENTIFY IT

DOCUMENT IT

BENCHMARK IT

COMMUNICATE IT

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CONTRACT ALERT: Fix Your Out-of-Date

Insurance Requirements!

Insurance Terms and Demands that use out dated language / terms / Forms.

“Indemnification” Demand that does not match up with the ‘Additional Insured’ Demand; and Visa Versa . . . .

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CONTRACT ALERT: Fix Your Out-of-Date

Insurance Requirements!

Stop treating “Certificates of Insurance” like Insurance

Contracts - they are not! Changes to a Certificate do not change the Insurance Policy.

Stop asking for out-of-date ACORD Certificate forms.

Stop asking for ‘Notification’ by Insurers that is different and/or greater than provided for to the ‘Named Insured’.

‘Notification’; try asking for the same notification rights granted to the “first Named Insured”. Simply / Clear.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

Build a ‘BEST PRACTICE’ WC System - Really!

Most Contractors still employ a ‘reactive’ nonintegrated WC Management System.

A WC Best Practice System that is detailed, disciplined, reactive and accountable is a very realistic objective.

Start with this: Ask your Team- What is our lowest possible Experience Modifier? Ok, now, how are we going to get there?

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

UPDATE YOUR HIRING PROCESS

Now is the time after Economic slowdown.

“Hire Slow & Fire Fast”. Most do the opposite.

Subject to your CBA - Make Employment offers in writing and make them ‘Conditional’ upon:

Physical Assessment (yes expensive but significant ROI).

Drug Testing

Background Check / MVR Review

Update your Employment Application.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

TECHNOLOGY E&O COVERAGE - CONSIDER IT

Very Underestimated Risk.

All Companies today have Internet &

Technology-related exposures.

Tech exposure rises as digital wireless networks create nearly limitless access to information.

Liability associated with being breached by an outsider; Data Loss & Business Interruption.

Liability associated with malicious code (viruses) transmitted to a third-party.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES LIABILITY (EPL)

You don’t have this? You're kidding, right?

Could this happen to you?

Employee sues for wrongful termination, age and/or disability discrimination, sexual harassment, failure to promote, discipline, or hiring (or failure to hire) practices.

Lawsuit brought by customers, vendors, and service providers because your employee harassed them

{Optional third-party coverage }.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CONSIDER FLOOD INSURANCE

During a 30Yr Mortgage, 10.5% chance of Fire damage; 26% of experiencing flood damage

(3X greater chance).

Eff 1/1/09 (post Katrina) new mandatory ISO End. with broader ‘water’ exclusionary language.

Flood Coverage (including BI/EE) is available from private markets and NFIP.

Ask about ISO Flood End. CP6510.

Ask Broker to Flood Map and present Coverage

Options for all Owned Property.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

HARD MARKET COMING?

Concerned about -

Rising premiums?

Reduced or more expense Specialty Coverages?

Need to strengthen Loss Prevention Program but not sure you will see positive effect on your Cost of Risk?

Budgeting your Cost of Risk on Projects that are 2 to 4 years to complete and collect?

Explore Alternative Risk Financing Options;

Now vs Later!

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

ARE YOU A CANDIDATE FOR A CAPTIVE PROGRAM?

Ask Yourself & Your Team:

Are there sufficient premiums to justify the

Captive option?

Are you prepared to assume more risk?

Do you have accurately documented loss experience and do you believe in that history?

[ Look to your Cost of Risk benchmarked data ]

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS OF A CAPTIVE PROGRAM?

Because ‘Funding’ is linked to your actual Loss Experience, the immediate savings can be significant.

Joining a large financially sound Captive can provide more predictable short and long term pricing.

Possible Tax burden relief .

Investment Income on your ‘Funding’ and all Reserves.

More direct connection between enhanced Loss Control &

Prevention program and your actual costs.

MORE CONTROL OVER YOUR ‘COST OF RISK’!

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CRM for 2012 - REVIEW

1. Treat Your Corp Risk Mgmt Program more like the Corporate Asset that it is.

2. Cost of Risk; Figure it / Benchmark it /

Communicate it.

3. Update your Sub/Vendor Contracts; specifically update / coordinate your

‘Insurance’ & ‘Indemnity’ Sections.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CRM for 2012 - REVIEW

4. WC Best Practice Program; if you're not sure what this is, then you don’t have it.

5. Update Your Hiring Process today to realize some long-term ROI.

6. Technology E&O Coverage; currently a very undervalued and underutilized Risk

Transfer tool.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

BEST PRACTICE SUGGESTIONS FOR 2012

CRM for 2012 - REVIEW

7.

EPL; a mature coverage that should be considered part of a standard Insurance

Program.

8.

Flood Insurance; consider it on all owned

Property.

9.

Hard Market Strategy; seriously consider an

Alternative Risk Finance Option such as Large

Deductible, Loss Sensitive or Captive

Program.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE

REVIEW ‘GARAGING TERRITORY’ OF ALL VEHICLES.

IF YOUR FLEET CONSISTS OF 35 OR MORE PRIVIATE PASSENGER

VEHICLES, CONSIDER SELF-INSURING THE COLLISION

EXPOSURE. MAINTAIN COLLISION COVERAGE ON HIGHLY

VALUED VEHICLES.

REVIEW IDEA OF DROPPING (A) MEDICAL PAYMENTS, (B) PIP,

(C) UNINSURED COVERAGES. WHY? THE MAJORITY OF

PERSONS DRIVING OR RIDING IN A COMPANY VEHICLE HAVE

MEDICAL / LOST WAGE COVERAGE UNDER WC AND/OR AN

EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PROGRAM.

DELETE VEHICLES THAT QAUALIFY AS “MOBILE EQUIPMENT”

FROM YOUR AUTO POLICY SCHEDULE [WARNING; REVIEW &

UNDERSTAND THE DEFINITION OF “MOBILE EQUIPMENT” IN YOUR

CGL POLLICY].

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

LIABILITY INSURANCE

AUDIT AND UNDERSTAND YOUR CLASSIFICATION CODES.

MAKE SURE THE LOWEST-RATED CLASSIFICATION CODES

THAT APPLY TO YOUR OPERATIONS ARE BEING USED – BY ALL

BROKERS.

TRUCK DRIVER PAYROLL; EXCLUDE FROM YOUR CGL

OPERATIONAL PREMIUM BASIS. WHY? NEGLIGENCE ARISING

OUT OF THE OPERATION OF A VEHICLE IS COVERED UNDER

YOUR AUTOMOBILE POLICY.

‘OVERTIME’ SURCHARGES PAID TO EMPLOYEES – EXCLUDE

IN PREMIUM COMPUTATION.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

WORKERS COMPENSATION INSURANCE

LOSS SENSITIVE PLANS; CONSIDER THEM. WHY? DEPENDING

ON YOUR PREMIUM SIZE, YOUR ACTUAL LOSS HISTORY, AND IF

YOU ACTUALLY BELIEVE IN YOUR OWN HISTORICAL DATA; A

LARGE DEDUCTIBLE, RETROSPECTIVE OR SELF-INSURED

PROGRAM CAN HELP COVERT YOUR WC PROGRAM INTO A

PROFIT CENTER.

CLASSIFICATIN CODES; CONDUCT YOUR OWN AUDIT. WHY? IN

GENERAL, PROPER CLASS CODES IS A “BEST GUESS”

UNDERTAKING. INTELLIGENT USE OF THE SCOPES MANAUL CAN

WILL EFFECT THE COST OF YOUR CURRENT & PRIOR YEARS

COVERAGE.

PAYROLL LIMITATIONS; UNDERSTAND THEM. WH7Y? IN MOST

STATES, THERE ARE LIMITATIONS ON OWNER/OFFICER PAYROLL -

NO MATTER WHAT CLASSIFICATION YOU ARE IN.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

WC EXPERIENCE RATING

CALCULATE A ‘TEST’ MODIFIER WITH DATA YOU BELIEVE

TO BE ACCURATE THEN COMPARE TO BUREAU ISSUED

MODIFIER.

OPEN CLAIMS; REVIEW & NEGOTIATE 7 MONTHS FROM

YOUR RENEWAL DATE.

LARGE LOSSES; VERIFY THAT THYE HAVE BEEN

PROPERLY LIMITED.

AUDIT RESULTS; VERIFY THAT CORRECT ‘FINAL’ AUDIT

DATA IS BEING USED IN YOUR CALCULATION.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

PROPERTY INSURANCE

BLANKET LIMITS; DO WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO - BUT GET THEM.

DEBRIS REMOVAL INCLUDING ‘POLLUTION CLEAN-UP

COVERAGE; REVIEW / INCREASE IT. THIS CLAIM SCOPE HAS

THE POTENTIAL TO COST MORE THAN REPAIR OR REPLACING

THE DAMAGED PROPERTY.

LAW & ORDINANCE COVERAGE; MISUNDERSTOOD AND

UNDERVALUED. THE LACK OF THIS COVERAGE (OR ENOUGH

LIMITS) IS A MAJOR REASON BUSINESS DO NOT REBUILD

AFTER A SIGNIFICANT LOSS.

BUSINESS INCOME & EXTRA EXPENSE COVERAGE; VERY

MISUNDERSTOOD AND UNDERVALUED. FOCUS ON THE

‘EXTRA EXPENSE’ COVERAGE!

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

CLAIMS ADMINISTRATION

LOSS DATA; MAINTAIN YOUR OWN RECORDS. LOSS RUNS

ARE YOUR PROPERTY - - DEMAND THAT YOU AUTOMATICALLY

RECEIVE PERIODIC REPORTS.

HAVE PERIODIC CLAIMS MEETINGS DIRECTLY WITH KEY

STAFF MEMBERS OF YOUR INSURER.

PROPERTY / BUILDERS RISK CLAIMS; REQUEST ADVANCE

PAYMENTS.

LARGE PROPERTY LOSS THAT INCLUDES LOSS REVENUE

AND/OR SIGNIFICANT EXTRA EXPENSES; CONSIDER HIRING A

PUBLIC ADJUSTER. THE COST/BENEFIT RATIO CAN QUICKLY

MAKE THIS AN EASY DECISION.

CONSTRUCTION RISK MANAGEMENT

SPECIFIC INSURANCE STRATIGIES

MISCELLANEOUS

PREPARE FOR AND DEMAND EARLY DATE TO REVIEW HARD

RENEWAL OFFERS.

PREPARE AND MANAGE PRECISE SPECIFICATIONS.

PRECISE SPECIFICATIONS INCLUDE SIMPLE BUT ACCURATE

DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS, SUMMARY OF RISK(S), AND

OUTLINE OF MINIMUM COVERAGE SCOPE.

CONSOLIDATE EFFECTIVE / RENEWAL DATES.

REVIEW ALL CONTRACTS CAREFULLY. CONTRACTUAL RISK

TRANSFER IS APPROPRIATE AND COMMON IN

CONSTRUCTION; BUT BEWARE OF UNUSUALLY BROAD HOLD

HARMLESS AND INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENTS.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

 INSURANCE INFORMATION INSTITUTE

 Gregory L. Peters, Seaton, Peters & Revnew, P.A.

 IRMI / Practical Risk Management

 IRMI / Construction Risk Management

 Mark Garbowski, Anderson Kill & Olick, P.C.

 Aaron A. Dean, Fabyanske, Westra, Hart & Thomas, P.A.

 Staff & Risk Management Team of Kraus-Anderson

Insurance.

 National Underwriter Property & Casualty News

Download