What is a CGE Model? Miles K. Light, Ph.D. University of Colorado Armenian Ministry of Economy and Trade Yerevan, 2010 Basic Concepts: What is a CGE Model? A “Computable General Equilibrium” (CGE) model: • is an economic model that combines the following: • firms (factories,companies) that attempt to maximize profits and minimize costs • households who maximize “welfare” (consumption) by choosing consumption goods according to price • markets: where prices adjust until supply and demand is equal Basic Concepts: When is a CGE model used? Some Previous Uses: 1997: Determine how Carbon-Limits would impact OECD countries under the Kyoto Protocol 2002: Examine the economic effect of Free Trade with USA would impact the economy in Peru, Colombia, and Ecuador. 2003: Assess how migration would impact the EU’s economy with European enlargement 2004/2005: Consider the “total” economic impact of various taxreform packages in Jamaica and Mongolia Basic Concepts: Why are CGE Models Popular? Main Strengths: Combination of standard theory with detailed data Optimization and “Micro-foundations”: An improvement from Keynesian macroeconomic models Households respond to price changes Firms change output and inputs when markets shift Provides “evidence” to support claims: Benefits and costs can be calculated, and used as evidence to support particular policies Trade-offs between policies can be quantified Basic Concepts: Partial Equilibrium: Economic Theory + Data Theory Only Theory with: numbers Basic Concepts: Partial Equilibrium: Economic Theory Only: Effect of a Tax: Theoretical Basic Concepts: Impact using Numbers: Effect of a Tax: With numbers Basic Concepts: Using the previous Partial Equilibrium model, we can say: Effect of a 100% tax: • Output Declines: • $2,000 to $1,000 (50% decline) • Consumer prices rise: • $20/each to $30/each (50% increase) • Tax Revenues = $500 General Equilibrium: All markets interacting General Equilibrium: • Multiple markets • Multiple households • Multiple firms Typical Outputs General Outputs: • Production Levels • New Price Levels & Inflation • International Trade Volume (imports and exports) • Welfare (Equivalent Variation) • Factor Returns (Wages, Return to Capital) Specialized Outputs: (if integrated) • Productivity and Competition (for Increasing Returns to Scale Technology) • Environmental Indicators (CO2, Pollutants) for energy-economy models Example: Simple 2 x 2 x 2 Model - 2 Sectors - 2 Factors - 2 Goods Example: 2 x 2 x 2 Model An example Economy: 2 Production Sectors: Each sector produces an output good: “PX” is produced by the X Sector “PY” is the output of the Y Sector There are 2 “factors” of production: X Sector (e.g., farming); and Y Sector (e.g., industry) Labor, which commands a price “PL” Capital, which commands a price “PK” One “Household” – Represents the average family or “national family”. The household owns the factors of production, and purchases the goods. Example: 2 x 2 x 2 Model Historical Data: Production and Consumption in 2007 for the Example Economy Output: X Sector Output = 100 million USD ( 100 units at a price of 1.0 ) Y Sector Output = 100 million USD ( 100 units at a price of 1.0 ) Production Structure X Sector Purchased: Y Sector Purchased: 40 million USD in Labor (wages) / 60 million in capital expenses (rent/machines) 60 million USD in Labor (wages) / 40 million in capital expenses (rent/machines) Total purchases of labor and capital: 200 million USD. Consumption: The household purchased 100 million USD of good “PX” 100 million USD of good “PY” Example: 2007 Data The Social Accounting Matrix Production Sectors Consumers Markets | X Y W | CONS -----------------------------------------------------PX | 100 -100 | PY | 100 -100 | PW | 200 | -200 PL | -40 -60 | 100 PK | -60 -40 | 100 ------------------------------------------------------ Example: Task: 50% Tax on X Assignment: The government is considering a 50% tax on the production of the X Sector. They want to know the following: Tax Revenue Collections Change in Production for all Sectors Change in Employment & Return to Capital Overall impact upon consumption and prices (CPI) Example: Task: 50% Tax on X Now Build a CGE Model to Answer the Questions. Contact: Miles K. Light, Ph.D. miles@mileslight.com