“Critical Appraisal Of The Progress On Evacuation Bottlenecks” By Engr. O.O. Akinniranye Chief Executive Officer (TCN) 1 Enugu Power Summit: 11th -12th May, 2012 a: In road to Bottleneck Overview b: Causes of Bottlenecks c: Mitigation Plans What is bottleneck Funding Strategies to Eliminate bottlenecks Types of Bottleneck Way leave Short Term Effects of bottlenecks Vandalizm Medium Term Key bottleneck locations Human Capacity Ageing Equipment d: Elimination of Bottlenecks Grid Plans Long Term/Supergrid 2 In road to Bottlenecks 3 What is Bottleneck “Traffic Constriction: a junction or a narrow section of a road that slows traffic or causes traffic jam” Encarta Dictionary In Power Transmission A node or connection between nodes that is a constraint in moving power from one point to another in an electrical system 4 Types of Bottlenecks Generation -Transmission interface constraints Transmission Substation capacity constraints Transmission wheeling constraints Transmission - Distribution interface constraints 5 Effects of Bottlenecks Load Shedding Voltage/Frequency instability Stranded power System Collapse 6 Key Bottleneck locations Afam Onitsha Gombe Kano Alaoji Ihovbor Olorunsogo Aja Ikorodu # Power Plant Current Constrained Power (MW) 1 Afam VI (Shell) 120MW 2 Okpai (Agip) 100MW 3 Rivers State Government (Afam I & II) 120MW Total Project Owner 340MW Remarks 2nd Onitsha-Benin 330 kV Single Circuit (SC) Line TCN Limiting power supply from Okpai 3rd Onitsha-Benin 330kV DC Line TCN Limiting power supply from Okpai Alaoji-Onitsha 330 kV SC Line (NIPP Lot 6) NDPHC Limiting power supply from Alaoji and Gbarain NIPPs Alaoji – Ikot Ekpene – Calabar 330KV DC Line (Lot 25) NDPHC Limiting power supply from Alaoji and Afam power stations Ikot Ekpene – Ugwuaji – New Haven 330KV Line (Lot 3) NDPHC Limiting power supply from Alaoji through the alternative 7 loop Causes of Bottlenecks 8 Funding Funding 150 • Lack of adequate funding 100 • Inconsistency of funding • End of year clearing of unspent 50 0 funds • Funding from only FG • • • • • • REQUESTE D (Nb) APPROVED (Nb) 2009201020112012 RELEASED (Nb) 2012 Budget in Perspective Budget initially requested was N145b Budget envelop for TCN was N45.621b Budget later reduced to N41.325b Budget finally sent to Nat. Assembly N35.119b Budget finally approved by NAT Assembly N25.8b Budget eventually released??????????????????? 56.5% of budgeted amount was eventually approved 9 Radial Grid Structure REPUBLIC OF CHAD Niamey NIGER SOKOTO Sokoto Katsina 132 kV JIGAWA Birnin Kebbi YOBE Hadejia BORNO Gusau KATSINA Damaturu ZAMFARA Potiskum Kano KEBBI Maiduguri KANO REPUBLIC OF BENIN KADUNA BAUCHI Bauchi Kaduna KAINJI Jos Gombe ADAMAWA GOMBE 2 2 KWARA 2 SHIRORO NIGER 2 Minna JEBBA/GS Yola Abuja JEBBA/TS IIorin PLATEAU Jalingo ABUJA OYO Lafia NASSARAWA 3 NIGERIA REPUBLIC OF CAMEROON TARABA Lokoja Osogbo Makurdi Ado Ekiti Ibadan OGUN Olorunsogo AJAOKUTA EKITI OSUN MAKURDI Bali BENUE KOGI Abeokuta Akure ALAGBADO TO SAKETE EGBIN P/ST. Ikeja Mambila Aliade 2 ONDO TRANSMISSION LINE LEGEND ENUGU EDO 2 Benin LAGOS Asaba EBONYI Enugu Akwa Abakaliki ONITSHA 4 AN AMBRA SAPELE P/ST. IMO DELTA POWER ST. DELTA CROSS RIVER Umuahia 2 330KV LINES (EXISTING) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (FGN) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (NIPP) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (PROPOSED PROJECT) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 330KV LINES - EXISTING ABIA 330KV LINES - FGN Owerri 330KV LINES - NIPP RIVERS Port Harcourt Uyo 2 BAYELSA 330KV LINES - PROPOSED PROJECT Calabar AKWA IBOM 330 KV BULK SUPPLY POINT H HYDROELECTRIC POWER STATION AFAM POWER ST. ATLANTIC OCEAN THERMAL POWER STATIONS 10 Way leave Funding • Increasingly expensive to pay compensation • Lack of a national policy on right of way acquisition 11 Vandalizm Funding Vandalization of transmission lines has caused TCN to lose evacuation corridors and delay in the implementation of several evacuation projects e.g Abuja – Shiroro 330KV line was vandalized 14 times before it was energised in 2004 12 Human Capacity Funding No. of Staff 2000 1500 1000 No. of Staff 500 46% of the work force are between 41- 50Yrs while 30% are between 50 – 60yrs. Almost 80% of the work force in TCN are over 40years old 0 18- 30 31- 40 41-50 50-60 No. of staff to retire Age Bracket in Years An average growth of retirement of staff at 8% per annum 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 No. of staff to retire 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Years 13 AGEING TRANSMISSION INFRASTRUCTURE TCN MAJOR EQUIPMENT AGE DISTRIBUTION 160 140 120 Qty (Nos) 100 80 60 40 20 0 330kV Trfmrs 132kV Trfmrs 330kV CBs 132kV CBs 330kV TRX Lines 132kV TRX Lines REACTORS 0-10YR 5 48 39 81 5 5 1 11-20YR 1 48 35 49 0 26 1 21-25YR 3 26 59 118 16 19 1 26-30YR 24 64 107 150 16 27 9 31-40YR 5 45 0 47 29 44 6 41-50YR 0 11 1 10 4 14 0 50-ABOVE 0 2 0 6 0 0 0 14 MITIGATION PLANS 15 Strategies to Eliminate Bottlenecks Provide more wheeling corridors for generated power Increase the Transmission to Generation Capacity Gap at 330KV Level Increase The Transmission To Distribution Capacity gap at 132KV level Complete the Transmission ring structure to meet n-1 contingency criteria Implementing a 765KV super grid 16 Short Term Strategies.........Dec, 2012 Completion of 2nd and 3rd Benin Onitsha 330KV Lines Completion of Alaoji - IkotEkpene – Ugwuaji – New Haven 330KV Lines Completion of all on-going 2001 awarded south- eastern projects Complete the installation of 150MVA Transformer at Afam Installation 20No 132/33KV Power Transformers 17 Key Site – to – Site Evacuation Mitigation Plans by Dec’ 2012 Locations Mitigation Plans STRANDED POWER AT OKPAI POWER STATION 3rd Benin – Onitsha line ready by June’12 STRANDED POWER AT AFAM POWER STATION 150MVA Transformer at Afam ready by Aug’12 STRANDED POWER AT ALAOJI POWER STATION 300MVA 132/33KV TCN Substations to be ready by Dec, 12 and Completion of 1st phas of Lot 25 and 3 of NIPP Projects STRANDED POWER AT IHOVBOR POWER STATION Ihovbor Line to Benin – Osogbo 330KCV Line to be ready before 18 Dec’12 MITIGATION PLANS FOR EASTERN NETWORK POWER EVACUATION # Description 1 Alaoji – Ikot Ekpene – Calabar 330KV DC Line 2 Ikot Ekpene – Ugwuaji – New Haven 330KV DC Line (New Haven – Onitsha 330KV single circuit line is existing) 3 3rd Benin – Onitsha 330KV DC Line Timeline Remarks Dec,12 A single circuit would be ready by Dec, 2012 Dec,12 Two out of the four circuits would be ready by Dec, 2012 June, 12 N450m Outstanding compensation19 20 Status of Trx. Evacuation Projects To be Completed By Dec 2012 # Projects % Completion Compl. Date Constraints 1 2nd Benin – Onitsha 330KV DC Line 71 Dec, 2012 N1.2Billion Compensation 2 3rd Benin –Onitsha 330KV DC Line 90 June,2012 N450m Compensation 3 Umuahia - Mbalano 132KV SC Line 67 Oct, 2012 Re-procured 4 Ohafia - Arochukwu 132KV SC Line 62 Oct, 2012 Re-procured 5 Umuahia – Ohafia 132KV Line 50 Oct, 2012 Re-procured 6 Mbalano 132KV Substation 65 Dec, 2012 Require additional Funding 7 Okigwe 132KV Substation 65 Dec, 2012 Require additional funding 21 8 Ohafia 132KV Substation 65 Dec, 2012 Require additional Status of Trx. Transformer Procurement to be completed By Dec 2012 # Projects 1 4No. 300MVA 330KV Tranf. 2 4No. 150MVA 330KV Transf 3 10No. 100MVA 132KV Transf 4 10No. 60MVA 132KV Transf Capacity Delivery Status Expectation Time 1020MW Oct, 2012 LC Fully Funded 510MW Feb, 2013 LC Fully Funded 850MW June, Already 2012 Shipped 510MW Jan, 2012 Already at Site 22 Capacity to be added to the grid By Dec 2012 Projects Damaturu Maiduguri Alaoji -Umuahia Umuahia Substation Arochukwu Substation 3rd Benin Onitsha 2nd Benin Onitsha Calabar Jos - Kafachan Makeri -Pankshin Makeri and Pankshin Substation Katsina, Hadejia and Kontagora Tamburawa, Walalambe, Yauri Dangorawa Mbalano - Okigwe Ibom Power Okigwe, Mbalano and Ohafia Substations Umuahia- Ohafia 132KV Line Umuahia - Mbalano 132KV Line Nnewi, Oba, Ideato , Aboh Mbaise Substations Kafanchan Yelwa - Yauri Ogoja 150 MVA Trx Reinforcement Projects Substations (MVA) 330KV (MVA) 132KV (MVA) 150 150 50 80 80 262 131 300 80 122 180 180 240 30 20 2.5 240 49.5 30 480 120 100 80 300 100MVA Trf Reinforcement Projects 1000 60MVA Trf Reinforcement Projects 600 TOTAL Lines (KM) 330KV (KM) 132KV (KM) 900 3310 23 393 454 Nigerian 330KV Network Grid by Dec, 2012 REPUBLIC OF CHAD Niamey NIGER SOKOTO Sokoto Katsina 132 kV JIGAWA Birnin Kebbi YOBE Hadejia BORNO Gusau KATSINA Damaturu 2 ZAMFARA Potiskum Kano KEBBI Maiduguri KANO 2 2 REPUBLIC OF BENIN 2 KADUNA BAUCHI Bauchi Kaduna KAINJI Jos 2 Gombe ADAMAWA GOMBE 2 2 KWARA 2 SHIRORO NIGER 2 2 Minna JEBBA/GS Yola Abuja JEBBA/TS IIorin PLATEAU Jalingo ABUJA 2 2 OYO 2 Lafia NASSARAWA 3 NIGERIA TARABA Makurdi Ado Ekiti OGUN Olorunsogo OSUN 2 EKITI 2 AJAOKUTA MAKURDI Bali BENUE KOGI Abeokuta Akure 2 ALAGBADO TO SAKETE EGBIN P/ST. Ikeja ONDO 2 2 2 Lokoja Osogbo Ibadan REPUBLIC OF CAMEROON Mambila Aliade 2 2 ENUGU EDO 2 1 Benin 1 LAGOS 4 Asaba 1 SAPELE P/ST. Abakaliki ONITSHA 4 AN AMBRA IMO DELTA POWER ST. DELTA 2 EBONYI Enugu Akwa TRANSMISSION LINE LEGEND 2 330KV LINES (EXISTING) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (FGN) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (NIPP) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (PROPOSED PROJECT) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS CROSS RIVER Umuahia 330KV LINES - EXISTING 330KV LINES - FGN ABIA 330KV LINES - NIPP Owerri RIVERS Port Harcourt 2 2 Uyo 2 BAYELSA 2 330KV LINES - PROPOSED PROJECT Calabar AKWA IBOM 330 KV BULK SUPPLY POINT H HYDROELECTRIC POWER STATION AFAM POWER ST. ATLANTIC OCEAN THERMAL POWER STATIONS 24 Medium Term Strategies.........Dec, 2013 Completion of 2nd Alaoji – Onitsha loop 330KV Lines (NIPP Lot 6) Completion of grid closing loop (Ugwuaji – Jos 330KV Line Complete the reinforcement of substations with 300MVA, 150MVA,100MVA Transformers Complete the construction of some Transmission lines and substations Complete the re-conductoring of some Transmission lines 25 Capacity to be added to the grid By Dec 2013 # Projects 1 Katampe - National Stadium 2 Onitsha - Nnewi - Ihiala 3 Nsukka - Ayangba 4 Ayangba 5 Ogbomosho 6 Daura Substation 7 Katsina - Daura Line 8 Obudu - Ogoja 9 Lokoja - Obajana 10 Kukwaba Substation 11 Wudil 12 Kaduna - Jos 13 Lanlate 14 Igangan 15 New Ayobo 16 Odogunyan 17 4 x 300MVA Trf Reinforcement Projects 18 2 x 150MVA Trf Reinforcement Projects TOTAL Substations (MVA) 330KV 132KV Lines (KM) 330KV 132KV 18 43 80 120 120 80 80 45 25 120 30 200 120 120 120 120 1200 300 1500 950 225 266 26 Nigerian 330KV Power Grid by Dec, 2013 REPUBLIC OF CHAD Niamey NIGER SOKOTO Sokoto Katsina 132 kV JIGAWA Birnin Kebbi YOBE Hadejia BORNO Gusau KATSINA Damaturu 2 ZAMFARA Potiskum Kano KEBBI Maiduguri KANO 2 2 REPUBLIC OF BENIN 2 KADUNA BAUCHI Bauchi Kaduna KAINJI Jos 2 Gombe ADAMAWA GOMBE 2 2 KWARA 2 SHIRORO NIGER 2 2 Minna JEBBA/GS Yola Abuja JEBBA/TS IIorin PLATEAU 2 ABUJA 2 OYO Jalingo 2 Lafia NASSARAWA 3 2 NIGERIA TARABA Makurdi Ado Ekiti OGUN Olorunsogo OSUN 2 AJAOKUTA EKITI 2 MAKURDI Akure 2 ALAGBADO TO SAKETE EGBIN P/ST. Ikeja ONDO 2 2 Mambila Aliade 2 2 Bali BENUE 2 KOGI Abeokuta 2 Lokoja Osogbo Ibadan REPUBLIC OF CAMEROON 2 ENUGU EDO 2 1 Benin 1 LAGOS 4 Abakaliki ONITSHA 1 4 AN AMBRA SAPELE P/ST. IMO 2 2 330KV LINES (EXISTING) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (FGN) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (NIPP) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (PROPOSED PROJECT) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS CROSS RIVER Umuahia 330KV LINES - EXISTING 330KV LINES - FGN ABIA 2 DELTA POWER ST. DELTA EBONYI Enugu Akwa Asaba TRANSMISSION LINE LEGEND 2 330KV LINES - NIPP Owerri RIVERS Port Harcourt 2 2 2 BAYELSA 2 2 2 Uyo 330KV LINES - PROPOSED PROJECT Calabar AKWA IBOM 330 KV BULK SUPPLY POINT H HYDROELECTRIC POWER STATION AFAM POWER ST. ATLANTIC OCEAN THERMAL POWER STATIONS 27 Long Term Strategy Commence and complete the Supergrid. Origin of the Nigeria Supergrid • Evacuation of 2600MW from Mambilla Definition of the supergrid • Moving bulk power to major hubs over long distances at minimal losses Implementation of the supergrid in phases. 28 Nigerian Power Grid: Proposed 765KV Lines Network REPUBLIC OF CHAD Niamey NIGER SOKOTO Sokoto Katsina 132 kV JIGAWA Birnin Kebbi YOBE Hadejia BORNO Gusau KATSINA Damaturu ZAMFARA Potiskum Kano KEBBI Maiduguri KANO REPUBLIC OF BENIN 2 KADUNA BAUCHI Bauchi Kaduna KAINJI Jos 2 Gombe ADAMAWA GOMBE 2 2 KWARA 2 SHIRORO NIGER 2 Minna JEBBA/GS Yola Abuja JEBBA/TS IIorin PLATEAU Jalingo ABUJA OYO Lafia NASSARAWA 3 NIGERIA REPUBLIC OF CAMEROON TARABA Lokoja Osogbo Makurdi Ado Ekiti Ibadan OGUN Olorunsogo OSUN AJAOKUTA EKITI 2 MAKURDI Bali BENUE KOGI Abeokuta Akure ALAGBADO TO SAKETE ONDO 2 Ikeja 2 Mambila Aliade 2 2 ENUGU EDO 2 1 Benin 1 LAGOS Asaba EBONYI Enugu Akwa Abakaliki ONITSHA AN AMBRA SAPELE P/ST. IMO DELTA POWER ST. DELTA 2 TRANSMISSION LINE LEGEND 2 330KV LINES (EXISTING) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (FGN) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (NIPP) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (PROPOSED PROJECT) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS CROSS RIVER Umuahia 330KV LINES - EXISTING 330KV LINES - FGN ABIA 330KV LINES - NIPP Owerri 765KV Super-Grid line RIVERS Port Harcourt Uyo 2 BAYELSA 330KV LINES - PROPOSED PROJECT Calabar AKWA IBOM 330 KV BULK SUPPLY POINT H HYDROELECTRIC POWER STATION AFAM POWER ST. ATLANTIC OCEAN THERMAL POWER STATIONS 29 Implementation of Supergrid..Phase 1 PHASE 1 • • PHASE 1 PhasePhase 1: This involves construction of 765kV DC Transmission linesfrom Afam from– Alaoji Afam– – 1: This involves construction of 765kV DC Transmission lines AlaojiJos– -Jos - Kaduna. thesubstations: following substations: Kaduna. With theWith following • • • • • • • • • • 8 x 333MVA 765/330kV (2000MW) transformers 2.1.12.1.1 8 x 333MVA 765/330kV (2000MW) transformers atat Kaduna and associated inductive and reactive power Kaduna and associated inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. compensating equipment. 2.1.2 4 x 333MVA 765/330kV (1000MW) transformers at 2.1.2 4 x 333MVA 765/330kV (1000MW) transformers at Jos and associated inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. Jos and associated inductive and reactive power 2.1.3 8 x 333MVA 330/765kV (2000MW) step up transformers at compensating equipment. Afam and associated inductive and reactive power 2.1.3compensating 8 x 333MVA 330/765kV (2000MW) step up transformers at equipment. Afam2.1.3 and associated inductive and reactive power 4 x 333MVA 330/765kV (1000MW) step up transformers at compensating equipment. Alaoji and inductive and reactive power compensating 2.1.3equipment. 4 x 333MVA 330/765kV (1000MW) step up transformers at IMPACTS Alaoji and inductive and reactive power compensating Immediate evacuation of 3000MW generation will be achieved; at existing equipment. / on-going 330kV transmission corridors to Jos (3 Circuits), Kano (3 circuits) and Shiroro – Abuja (2 circuits). IMPACTS Immediate evacuation of 3000MW generation will be achieved; at existing / on-going 330kV transmission corridors to Jos (3 Circuits), Kano (3 circuits) and Shiroro – Abuja (2 circuits). 30 Implementation Supergrid......Phase 2 • Phase 2: This involves construction of 765kV DC Transmission lines from Afam – Benin and 765kV DC transmission lines to both Olorunsogo – Osogbo. With the following substations: 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 4 x 333MVA 765/330kV (1000MW) transformers at Olorunsogo and associated inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. 4 x 333MVA 765/330kV (1000MW) transformers at Osogbo with associated inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. 4 x 333MVA 330/765kV (1000MW) step up transformers at Benin with all the necessary inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. IMPACTS Medium term gains of evacuation 1000MW generation each to Olorunsogo and Osogbo. 31 Implementation of Supergrid... Phase 3 • Phase 3: This involves construction of 765kV DC Transmission lines from Osogbo – Shiroro (with a spur line to Birnin Kebbi) – Kaduna ( with a spur line to Kano). With the following substations: • 2.3.1 4 x 333MVA 765/330kV (1000MW) transformers at Kano with all the necessary inductive and reactive power compensating equipment. 32 Advantages of 765KV Supergrid CONCLUSIONS • A single-circuit 765kV line can carry as much power as three single-circuit 500kV lines, three double circuit 345kV lines, or six single circuit 345kV lines, reducing the overall number of lines and rights of way required to deliver equivalent capacity • Minimizes Loss of Power during Transmission. Loss of power during transmission is inversely proportional to the square of the voltage, hence if voltage is raised from 345kV to 765kV, loss of power decrease by 20%. 33 Nigerian Power Grid: Existing On-going 330KV and Proposed 765KV Lines Network REPUBLIC OF CHAD Niamey NIGER SOKOTO Sokoto Katsina 132 kV 2 2 JIGAWA Birnin Kebbi YOBE Hadejia BORNO Gusau KATSINA Damaturu 2 ZAMFARA Potiskum Kano KEBBI Maiduguri 2 KANO 2 2 REPUBLIC OF BENIN 2 2 KADUNA BAUCHI Bauchi Kaduna KAINJI Jos 2 Gombe 2 ADAMAWA GOMBE 2 2 KWARA 2 SHIRORO NIGER 2 2 Minna JEBBA/GS Yola Abuja JEBBA/TS IIorin PLATEAU 2 ABUJA 2 OYO Jalingo 2 Lafia NASSARAWA 3 2 NIGERIA TARABA Makurdi Ado Ekiti OGUN Olorunsogo OSUN 2 AJAOKUTA EKITI 2 MAKURDI Akure 2 ALAGBADO TO SAKETE EGBIN P/ST. Ikeja ONDO 2 2 Mambila Aliade 2 2 Bali BENUE 2 KOGI Abeokuta 2 Lokoja Osogbo Ibadan REPUBLIC OF CAMEROON 2 ENUGU EDO 2 1 Benin 1 LAGOS 4 Abakaliki ONITSHA 1 4 AN AMBRA SAPELE P/ST. IMO 2 2 330KV LINES (EXISTING) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (FGN) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (NIPP) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS 2 330KV LINES (PROPOSED PROJECT) – MULTIPLE CIRCUITS CROSS RIVER Umuahia 330KV LINES - EXISTING 330KV LINES - FGN ABIA 2 DELTA POWER ST. DELTA EBONYI Enugu Akwa Asaba TRANSMISSION LINE LEGEND 2 330KV LINES - NIPP Owerri RIVERS Port Harcourt 2 2 2 BAYELSA 2 2 2 Uyo 765KV Super-Grid line 330KV LINES - PROPOSED PROJECT Calabar AKWA IBOM 330 KV BULK SUPPLY POINT H HYDROELECTRIC POWER STATION AFAM POWER ST. ATLANTIC OCEAN THERMAL POWER STATIONS 34 Elimination of Bottlenecks •Continuous development of the network to meet grid plans •A lot more focus on maintenance of grid through provision of maintenance materials e.g breakers, isolators e.t.c 35 THANK YOU 36