Interactive Vocabulary Instruction Emily Whiteside Technology and Deaf Education Symposium, June 21, 2010 Speech/Language Pathologist – With an interest in Deaf/Hard of Hearing Students Instructional Technologist – Seeking to design, develop, implement, and research a technology solution for vocabulary improvement 2 Deafness Language Acquisition Speech Pathology vocabulary Literacy Technology 3 Hyperlinked, digital learning environments animated videos of published books live-action video sign language* interpretation multimedia instructional activities and games 4 Research Project Examples of Signed Storybooks Tips and Basics of how to create MMS 5 Limited access to language of home or school Limited incidental vocabulary acquisition Delayed language development Poor reading comprehension skills Social isolation 6 Knowledge Receptive vocabulary skills Experiences Multimedia vocabulary instruction Attitudes Multimedia vocabulary instruction 7 Degree of Loss Profound 9 Severe 3 Mild 1 Type of Loss Sensory-Neural 10 Mixed 2 Auditory 1 Neuropathy Assistive Listening Device Cochlear Implant FM Listening Device Student Primary Language Spoken English 4 ASL 9 Home Primary Language Spoken English 12 Spoken Spanish 1 ASL 0 3 10 8 My hard of hearing students do not understand age-appropriate vocabulary in text, speech, or sign language. 9 The selected technology for the intervention was multimedia storybooks with sign language interpretation and accompanying multimedia vocabulary instructional activities. 15 sessions/student – 10.5 hours 90 instructor sessions – 60 hours 5 weeks; 5 books; 5 activities 25 targeted vocabulary words 10 Before •Word Pretest •Word Meaning Pretest •Student Perception Survey During •Teacher Journal After •Word Posttest •Word Meaning Posttest •Student Perception Survey 11 Research Question 1: Receptive Vocabulary Achievement Word Pretest Word Posttest Meaning Pretest Meaning Posttest Word Difference Meaning Difference M 0.7969 0.9200 0.7846 0.8831 0.1231* 0.0985** SD 0.2156 0.1744 0.2088 0.2182 0.1205 0.1184 N 13 13 13 13 13 13 *p < .0031, **p < .0111 12 Student Engagement Research Question 2: Student Experiences Teacher Reflective Journal Student choice Attention to signing Game-like activities Video length Linguistic complexity 13 Group Interaction Research Question 2: Student Experiences -Teacher Reflective Journal Cooperation Peer Coaching Shared schema Argument Competition Group size 14 Communication Research Question 2: -Teacher Reflective Journal - Student Experiences Imitative Spontaneous Reading Word Combinations Shared Schema Transfer 15 Interaction with Digital Media Research Question 2: Student Experiences Teacher Reflective Journal Response to media Media controls Input device Interest in technology Insufficient RAM Inactive links 16 Research Question 2: Student Experiences - Teacher Reflective Journal Percent Occurrence 100 98 80 60 96 81 92 88 81 51 40 20 0 Guiding Question Domains Engagement Peer Interaction Communication Digital Media Interaction 17 Research Question 3: Attitudes - Student Perception Survey 4 Very Happy 3.5 3 A Little Happy A Little Sad 2.5 2 1.5 Very Sad 1 0.5 0 1 Pre-survey Mean Post-survey Mean 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 N = 13 18 Research Question 3: Attitudes - Student Perception Survey pretest posttest M SD M SD MD 1. My mom reads me a book, but she does not sign. 2.31 1.11 2.38 1.18 +.08 3. I watch a video story with sign language on the computer. 3.77 .44 3.85 0.38 +.08 7. I learn new words with video stories and computer games. 3.31 .95 3.85 0.38 +.54 9. I read the same book many 3.46 .52 times. 3.54 0.66 +.08 Survey Item 19 Research Question 3: Attitudes - Student Perception Survey pretest Survey Item 2. A teacher shows me a book and signs me a story. M 3.46 posttest SD M SD MD 0.78 3.38 .87 -.08 4. I watch a video story without signs 3.46 on the computer, but I can read the captions. .66 3.00 1.15 -.46 5. I use a dictionary to learn new words. 3.62 .87 3.31 .75 -.31 6. A teacher shows me how to sign new words. 3.46 .66 3.31 .94 -.15 8. I watch a video story many times. 3.31 .75 3.23 .93 -.08 10. I know many new words. 3.69 .48 3.61 .65 -.07 20 Achievement – significant positive Experiences - positive Attitude - positive 21 Pre/Post vocabulary tests did not discriminate well enough Many students knew most of the target words prior to instruction Language barrier for survey Small sample size Novelty may have been a factor Teacher Journal may show bias 22 Vocabulary selection Time-intensive Transfer of learning Primary language access Choice and entertainment Rich, relevant environment Implicit/explicit/expressive study 23 Carney, A. E., & Moeller, M. P. (1998). Treatment efficacy: Hearing loss in children [Supplement]. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 41, S61-S81. Retrieved June 22, 2007, from http://asha.org Easterbrooks, S. (1999). Improving practices for students with hearing impairments. Exceptional Child. 65(4), 537-554. Retrieved June 28,2007, from the PsycINFO database. Golos, D. B. (2006). Using instructional videos in American Sign Language as a tool to facilitate the development of emergent literacy skills in Deaf and hard of hearing preschool children. Ann Arbor, MI: U.M.I. LaSasso, C., & Davey, B. (1987). The relationship between lexical knowledge and reading comprehension for prelingually, profoundly hearing-impaired students. Volta Review, 89(4), 211-220. Retrieved July 19, 2007, from the PsycINFO database. Loeterman, M., Paul, P., & Donahue, S. (2002). Reading and deaf children. Reading Online. Retrieved June 8, 2007, from Academic Search Premier database. 24 25 Think about what you want to do… and think about it again. Consider : • Audience •Constraints •Media 26 Now plan : It’s all in the details. Goals and Objectives Instructional Strategy Product* * Template available at http://www.slideshare.net/ewhites/multimedia-storybook-template 27 Finally. . . . the fun part PowerPoint Movie Maker Discovery Education Streaming CamStudio Audacity Picnik Picasa Flickr Wikimedia Commons * Resources on Handout 28 •Media •Instruction •Interactivity 29 Manually Use existing document (Outline view; New Slide arrow) Flow chart is blueprint Save as template before adding content * Template available at http://www.slideshare.net/ewhites/multimedia-storybook-template 30 Logical Simple Descriptive Read me 31 Images: clip art, photos, scanned Video: commercial or user created Audio: commercial or user created Script: definitions, prompts, games, simpler storyline 32 Flikr Wikimedia Commons Picasa PowerPoint Clipart Windows Movie Maker Create File; Save; Stay Put! * Resources on Handout 33 Discovery Learning Fair Use for class Restrictions apply Need a password and username Download online Import into Windows Movie Maker Create File; Save; Stay Put! 34 Child-friendly definitions Simplified story line, if needed Prompts and Questions Navigational Instructions 35 Voice talent Signing talent Singing talent Acting talent 36 Quiet, well-lit room Extra lights Tripod and digital camera Solid backdrop Contrasting, solid shirts Script 37 Audacity Definitions prompts, Simpler story line navigational instructions 38 Windows Movie Maker Import images, audio & video clips Trim clips Add title, text overlays, and credits. 39 Storyboard to the Rescue! •Color •Font •Graphics •Audio •Video •Links •Icons •Text •Animation * Template available at http://www.slideshare.net/ewhites/multimedia-storybook-template 40 Navigation and Action Action Buttons Hyperlinks Embedded Objects Animations 41 Animations Embedded Objects Hyperlinks Action Buttons Play a Game! 42 HORSE 43 oYou picked the goat. oA horse has a mane. oA goat has horns. oGo back and try again. 44 45 Test / Repair / Test / Repair . . . Quality Control Is Key •Check links •Run through every option •Watch someone else use the product 46 Template Slideshare.net search Emily Whiteside http://www.slideshare.net/ewhites/mul timedia-storybook-template 47 Licensed for Non-Commercial Reuse 48 Change colors * Delete image portions * Redraw lines *Windows Meta Files (wmf) only 49 Change colors * Delete image portions * Redraw lines. *Windows Meta Files (wmf) only 50 51 Reuse in: •Non-MS Office programs •Web sites •Movies •Adobe Acrobat 52 Emily Whiteside ewhites@knology.net www.everythingvocabulary.blogspot.com 53