Concept of Civil Wrong Are these acts wrongs ? A agrees to buy B’s house for 10 lakhs. He pays the amount but B refuses to hand over the possession of the house. A invites B for dinner at his house. B promises to attend the same but does not do it. A, who is starving approaches B and pleads to provide some food. B refuses to do so. A falls unconscious and later dies. A enters upon B’s property without his consent and continues to remain on it even when asked by B to get out of it. A enters upon the property of B injuring the watchman and steals fruits from his garden. Tort – derived from Latin term “Tortum” which implies conduct that is twisted Tortious liability Arises from a breach of duty fixed by law This duty is towards persons generally Its breach is redressed by civil action for unliquidated damages Essentials of a Tort There must be a wrongful act committed by a person It must result in legal damage to another Injury without damage actionable (injuria sine damno) Damage without injury not actionable (damnum sine injuria) It must give rise to a legal remedy (ubi jus ibi remedium) Distinction between a Tort and a Breach of Contract Tort Breach of Contract Duty imposed by law Violation of a right in Damages are unliquidated rem Duty imposed by the parties to the contract Violation of a right in personam Damages are liquidated Distinction between a Tort and a Crime Both are violations of rights in rem In both the cases, duties are imposed by law Tort Crime Private Wrong Public Wrong Breach of Private Duties Object of action is compensation Breach of Public Duties Individual has to approach a Civil Court for redressal Object of action is punishing the wrong doer State initiates prosecution against the wrong doer Kinds of Torts Torts affecting the person Assault – intentionally creating an apprehension in another person that force would be used against him Battery – intentional application of force to another without lawful justification False Imprisonment – total restraint on the liberty of the person without lawful justification Torts affecting reputation Defamation – publication of a statement which is false and defamatory by the defendant which refers to the plaintiff Libel – defamatory statement which is addressed to the eye and is actionable per se Slander – defamatory statement which is addressed to the ear and is actionable only on proof of damage Malicious Prosecution defendant instituting prosecution with malice and without reasonable and probable cause against the plaintiff thereby affecting his liberty, property and reputation and the prosecution must have ended in plaintiff’s favour Torts affecting Immovable Property Trespass – unlawful entry upon the land of another or unlawful interference with the possession of land of another Dispossession – withholding the possession of land from the rightful owner Injury to easements – injury to a right to support of land and buildings, right to light and air, right to way, right of water and right of privacy Torts affecting Moveable Property Trespass to goods – wrongfully taking goods out of plaintiff’s possession or forcibly interfering with the goods Detention – wrongfully withholding the immediate possession of goods from one who is entitled to it Conversion – willful interference without lawful justification with goods in a manner inconsistent with the rights of the owner Torts affecting both person and property Negligence – breach of duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiff resulting in harm to the plaintiff Nuisance – unlawful interference with the use or enjoyment of property or with the exercise of common right Fraud – making a false statement knowingly or recklessly with an intention that another should rely and act to his detriment and the other does so act Remedies Extra-judicial remedies – Remedies by the act of the parties Self help Abatement of Nuisance Distress damage feasant Judicial Remedies – Remedies available from the Courts Damages – pecuniary compensation Specific Restitution of property Injunctions (Temporary or Permanent), (Mandatory or Prohibitory) Damages Nominal – damages in recognition of a right Substantial – compensation for the actual loss Contemptuous – marks a disapproval of the plaintiff’s conduct Exemplary – punitive in nature Any Questions ? Thank you