Air Breathing Propulsion Systems
Integration Technical Committee
48th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit
Atlanta, GA
30 July - 1 August 2012
Michelle McMillan
July 30, 2012
ABPSI TC Meeting Agenda for JPC 12
Introductions
ABPSI Organization & Succession Planning
P&E and Steering Committee Meeting Overviews
New Initiatives and Subcommittee Reviews
PAW
GARTEUR (Group of Aeronautical Research and Technology in
Europe, http://www.garteur.eu/ - Thomas Berens
• Liaisons
• Technical Subcommittee
•
•
•
•
•
•
 Breakout Sessions
2
48th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference and Exhibit
Air Breathing Propulsion Organization
Updated July, 2012
P&E ABP Deputy
Jeff Hamstra
(817) 655-8894
jeffrey.w.hamstra@lmco.cm
Technical Committees
Gas Turbine
Engines
J.A. (Jimmy) Kenyon
High Speed Air
Breathing Propulsion
Ryan Starkey
(571) 372-6512
james.kenyon@osd.mil
(303) 492-0871
rstarkey@colorado.edu
Vice Chair: John Sordyl
ABPSI
Past
Chair: Membership
Ian Halliwell
Air Breathing Propulsion
Systems Integration
Michelle McMillan
(314) 324-4482
Michelle@SynGenics.com
Vice Chair: Dora Musielak
Membership
PastHSABP
Chair: Joaquin
Castro
Vice Chair: Bruce McKay
Past GTE
Chair: Membership
Jeff Flamm
Keith Blodgett
Common Elements(513) 243-3492
keith.blodgett@ge.com
Communications
Dora Musielac
Education
Dan Kirk
Membership
Keith Blodgett
Honors & Awards
Madhan Bala
(817) 471-7115
dmusielak@uta.edu
(321) 674-7622
dkirk@fit.edu
(513) 243-3492
keith.blodgett@ge.com
(408) 541-1484, XN:04
han@spg-corp.com
Aerospace Sciences Meeting
Mani Subramanian
Joint Propulsion Conference
Janet Convery
(xxx)-xxx-xxxx
mani.subramanian@quest-global.com
(540) 387-7579
janet.convery@ge.com
3
ABPSI TC Organization …and Successors
TC Chair
Michelle McMillan
Communications
Chair: Neal Herring
Vice: Anne-Laure Delot
Integrated Aero
Performance
Chair: Thomas Berens
Vice: Chris Hughes
Dick Scharnhorst
Vice Chair
Past Chair
Bruce McKay
(2014 Chen Chuck)
Jeff Flamm
Service Subcommittees
Honors & Awards
Education
Chair: Keith Blodgett
Vice: Vance Dippold
Chair: Rod Daebelliehn
Vice: Chen Chuck
Technical Subcommittees
Subsystem,
Propellers, Pistons,
Performance,
Turboprops
Optimization
Chair: Bruce McKay
Vice:
Membership
Chair: Charles Beard
Vice: Stephen Johnson
Chair: Keith Blodgett
Vice:
Requirements
Verification,
Certification and Testing
Chair: Bob Nichols
Vice: David Wang
Conference Subcommittees
Aerospace Sciences Meeting
Joint Propulsion Conference
Chair: Vance Dippold
Vice: Dyna Benchergui
Chair: Michelle McMillan
Vice: Bruce McKay
4
APBSI Roster
First Name
Charles
Dyna
Thomas
Norbert
Keith
Shane
Haixin
C. F. Lance
Chen
Roderick
Anne-Laure
Vance
Neal
Jeffrey
Charles
Lie-Mine
Ian
Jeffrey
Eric
Last Name
Beard
Benchergui
Berens
Bissinger
Blodgett
Bunnag
Chen
Chenault
Chuck
Daebelliehn
Delot
Dippold
Domel
Flamm
Gaharan
Gea
Halliwell
Hamstra
Hansen
Organization Name
Boeing Commercial Airplanes
Bombardier Inc
Cassidian
GE Aviation
Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Tsinghua University
Aerospace Business Development Associates
Boeing Commercial Airplanes
Aerojet
ONERA
NASA Glenn Research Center
Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
NASA Langley Research Center
Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
Boeing Engineering Operations & Technology
Power Systems Manufacturing LLC
Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB
Primary E-Mail
charles.s.beard@boeing.com
Dyna.Benchergui@aero.bombardier.com
Thomas.Berens@cassidian.com
n_c.bissinger@t-online.de
keith.blodgett@ge.com
shane.bunnag@ngc.com
chenhaixin@tsinghua.edu.cn
lance.chenault@abdainc.com
chen.chuck@boeing.com
roderick.daebelliehn@aerojet.com
anne-laure.delot@onera.fr
Vance.F.Dippold@nasa.gov
neal.d.domel@lmco.com
jeffrey.d.flamm@nasa.gov
charles.gaharan@lmco.com
lie-mine.gea@boeing.com
ianhalliwell@earthlink.net
jeffrey.w.hamstra@lmco.com
eric.hansen2@edwards.af.mil
5
APBSI Roster ctn
First Name
Neal
Christopher
Stephen
John
Douglas
Jonathan
Eric
Bruce
Michelle
Robert
Richard
Angie
David
Tim
William
Bryan
Last Name
Herring
Hughes
Johnson
Kelly
Kisling
Litt
Loth
McKay
McMillan
Nichols
Scharnhorst
Scribben
Wang
Warlick
Westphal
Westra
Organization Name
United Technologies Research Center
NASA Glenn Research Center
Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Department of Defense
Belcan Corporation
NASA Glenn Research Center
University of Virginia
Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
Syngenics Corporation
The University of Alabama at Birmingham
Boeing Defense, Space & Security
Air Force Reseach Laboratory
Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB
Raytheon Missile Systems
Rolls-Royce Corporation
Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Primary E-Mail
herrinnr@utrc.utc.com
christopher.e.hughes@nasa.gov
stephen.johnson@ngc.com
john.kelly@arnold.af.mil
douglas.kisling@att.net
jonathan.litt@grc.nasa.gov
loth@virginia.edu
bruce.mckay@lmco.com
michelle@syngenics.com
robert.nichols@arnold.af.mil
richard.k.scharnhorst@boeing.com
angela.scribben@wpafb.af.mil
David.Wang@jsf.mil
tim.warlick@raytheon.com
bill.westphal@rolls-royce.com
bryan.westra@ngc.com
6
Membership Profile
• 35 Total
–29 Regular
– 1 Associate
– 5 International
•
Category
–23 Industry (66%)
– 4 Academia (11%)
– 8 Government (23%)
•
International members
–1 Canada
–1 France
–2 Germany
–1 China
• 5 Rotated Off (Since May2011)
• 8 New Members
7
ABPSI Conference Leads
ASM
ASM 09 Jeff Flamm (Orlando)
ASM 10 Vance Dippold (Orlando)
ASM 11 –Don Malloy (Orlando)
ASM 12 – Vance Dippold (Nashville)
ASM 13 – Dyna Benchergui (Dallas)
ASM 14 – Richard Scharnhorst?
Anne-Laure Delot? Washington DC
 ASM 15 – Volunteer? Orlando






JPC







JPC 09 Doug Kisling (Denver)
JPC 10 Don Malloy (Nashville)
JPC 11 Rod Daebelliehn (San Diego)
JPC 12 – Michelle McMillan (Atlanta)
JPC 13 – Bruce McKay (San Jose)
JPC 14 – Chris Hughes (Cleveland)
JPC 15 – Shane Bunnag (TBD: Seattle,
Honolulu, Las Vegas, New Orleans, Los
Angeles, or Monterey)
All members are expected to
chair sessions and review abstracts
8
Conferences: Paper Statistics
Abstracts Received
JPC10
ASM11
JPC11
ASM12
JPC12
11
12
26
18
22
10 / 0
21 / 3
Transferred In/Out
Rejected
3
2
1
2
5
Withdraw/No-Show
1
2
6
5/0
8/0
Total ABPSI Papers
7
8
19
21
27
ABPSI Sessions
3
3
4
3
4
1-HS
2-APA
9-HS/GTE
5
5
13
Co-Sessions
Total Sessions
3
3
9
P&E Group Feedback
• Held workshop to discuss implementation of New Event Model
 5 Forums per year
–
–
–
–
–
AIAA Science & Technology Forum (Winter)
AIAA Defense & Security Forum (Winter/Spring)
AIAA Aviation & Aeronautics Forum (Early Summer)
AIAA Propulsion & Energy Forum (Mid Summer)
AIAA Space & Astronautics Forum (Late Summer)
 3 Tiers
– Plenary
– Integration
– Technical
 Asked to consider 2 questions
– How do we build successful expanded P&E Forum?
– How do we support other forums, especially Aviation for GTE TC?
• ABP TCs successfully expanded to full intent
• ITAR sessions at future AIAA conferences (including JPC/P&E Forum)
• Issue with Gordon C. Oates Award
ABP TC Steering Committee Feedback
• Considering how to reduce number/length of meetings
 Steering committees via teleconference before conferences
 Avoid duplication between individual TC and ABP TCs dinner
meeting
• ITAR sessions – need to solicit abstracts/papers/reviewers
• Subcommittee Structure
 Membership – individual vs. joint with other ABP TCs
 Nominations – GTE TC doing, should others join?
• Improving new member orientation
Other Strategic Initiatives
• Nominations Subcommittee
 New subcommittee to divide workload for Honors & Awards
Subcommittee
 Nominates award candidates and develops nomination packages,
ensures requisite number and quality of nominees to ensure annual
awards, monitors financial status of monetary awards (for consideration)
 Avoids conflicts of interest
• Subcommittee Standard Operating Procedures
 Current subcommittee chairs asked to develop and document standard
operating procedures
 Communications Approved SOP Document
 Conferences Subcommittee in work
 Other subcommittees initiating effort
 Goal completion date – September 30, 2012
AIAA Propulsion Aerodynamics Workshop (PAW)
(Chen Chuck)
17 Teams Participated at 29 July 2012 Workshop, Atlanta
Obtained Boeing Sponsored Scholarship for 6 Teams
Maintained Workshop Website, Sponsored by Tecplot
Planning Special Session for JPC 2013 Where Teams Will Present Their Work
2nd Workshop (JPC 2014) Planning in Progress
Exploring Collaboration with GTTC for Nozzle Geometries as a Test Case for
2nd Workshop
• Seeking Input for Other Future Test Cases
•
•
•
•
•
•
13
Integrated Aero Performance Technical Subcommittee
•
Idea communicated to GARTEUR Steering Committee in July 2011 with
support from all
•
Proposal was made in the ABPSI TC-Meeting at the JPC in San Diego, on
August 1st, 2011, and met positive acceptance
•
Proposal was presented at the GARTEUR Steering Committee Meeting on
19/20 September 2011 and was approved
•
Proposal was presented at the GARTEUR Council Meeting on 14/15 October
2011 and was approved
•
Council approval was communicated in the ABPSI TC-Meeting at the ASM in
Nashville, on January 9th, 2012, and the go-ahead was confirmed by the TC
•
Request for commitments for paper presentations from GARTEUR Action
Groups was sent to all AG chairmen in March 2012
•
So far (status of July 3rd, 2012) six commitments for paper presentations have
been received, confirmation will be stated at the ABPSI-TC Meeting at the JPC
in Atlanta
•
Final go-ahead for the organization of a Special GARTEUR Paper Session at
ASM 2014 could be decided at the ABPSI-TC Meeting at the JPC in Atlanta
14
Integrated Aero Performance Technical Subcommittee
Possible scope of a Special GARTEUR Paper Session
•
Session within the frame of ABPSI, Integrated Aero Performance
•
First paper in session: Introduction of GARTEUR, non-technical, presented by
a GARTEUR official
•
Six technical papers for one session
•
Papers invited by AIAA (note: conference fees and travel expenses must be
carried by authors)
•
Posters of different GARTEUR Action Groups possibly available for display
during technical sessions
15
Liaisons
•
Other AIAA TC’s/PC’s






•
Ground Test (Keith Blodgett)
Ground Test Committee – DOE Focus Group (Michelle McMillan & David Wang)
Aerodynamics – 2 Joint Sessions at ASM 2012 (Eric Loth)
Joint panel sessions with GTE TC for JPC 2012 (Michelle McMillan)
Joint technical sessions HSABP and GTE TC for JPC ’12 (Michelle McMillan)
Green Engineering PC (Keith Blodgett)
Other Societies
 AIAA/ASME Joint Engine competition judges
 Overset Meshing, Dayton Oct 15-18, 2012 (Lie-Mine Gea)
•
Local Sections




•
Hampton Roads (Jeff Flamm)
Pacific NW (Charles Beard)
Northern Ohio Section (Jonathan Litt)
Guest Speaker at May 2012 Atlanta AIAA Section Meeting (Bruce McKay)
Other




PPSA (Jeff Flamm)
NATO – Thermal Systems Modeling Working Group (Neal Herring)
Puget Sound Engineering Council – Mentoring (Charles Beard)
GARTEUR (Thomas Berens & Anne-Laure Delot)
16
Service Subcommittee Rosters
Communications
Honors & Awards
Education
Membership
Chair: Neal Herring
Vice: Anne-Laure Delot?
Chair: Keith Blodgett
Vice: Vance Dippold
Chair: Rod Daebelliehn
Vice: Chen Chuck
Chair: Keith Blodgett
Vice:
Thomas Berens
Anne-Laure DeLot
Dyna Benchergui
David Wang
John Kelly
Neil Herring
Norbert Bissinger
Jeffrey Flamm
Jeffrey Hamstra
Stephen Johnson
Tim Warlick
Charles Beard
Chen Chuck
Rod Daebelliehn
Ian Halliwell
William Westphal
Bryan Westra
Angela Scribben
Haixin Chen
Lie-Mine Gea
Eric Hansen
Dick Scharnhorst
Keith Blodgett
Lance Chenault
Neal Domel
Joint Propulsion Conference
Chair: Michelle McMillan
Vice: Bruce McKay
Douglas Kisling
Bruce McKay
Jonathan Litt
Michelle McMillan
Chris Hughes
Bob Nichols
Shane Bunnag
Charles Gaharan
Aerospace Sciences Meeting
Chair: Vance Dippold
Vice: Dyna Benchergui
Proposed Redistributing Conference Subcommittee
Vance Dippold
Members Among Service
Subcommittees
Eric Loth
17
Membership Subcommittee
Controls Membership Roster, Assigns Subcommittee Members, Works with TC Chair to
Designate Subcommittee Chairs and Ensure Orderly Succession of Leadership,
Recognizes High Performing TC Members through Awards and Membership Upgrades
• Chair: Keith Blodgett
• Vice Chair
• Welcome New Members!








Shane Bunnag, Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Haixin Chen, Tsinghua University
Neal Domel, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
Charles Gaharan, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics
Lie-Mine Gea, Boeing Engineering Operations & Technology
Eric Hansen, Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB
Robert Nichols, The University of Alabama at Birmingham
Richard Scharnhorst, Boeing Defense, Space & Security
18
Membership Subcommittee ctn
• JPC 2012 Initiatives
 Break Membership Subcommittee to TC Level
 New Member Orientation Initiatives
–
–
–
–
–
Joint Orientation but with Representatives from each TC
Outing at JPC – P&E Funds?
Assign Mentors to New Members
Streamline New Member Orientation Onsite Briefing
Generate and Provide New Member Handbook Prior to Orientation that Explains TC
Structure, Subcommittees (Service and Technical), Roles and Responsibilities
19
Communication Subcommittee
Disseminate Information Regarding TC Accomplishments, Activities, and
Announcements to AIAA through Year in Review Articles, ABP and ABPSI
Websites, and Promotional Material
• Chair: Neal Herring
• Vice Chair:
• Roles and Responsibilities
 Year in Review Article: Dyna Benchergui
 Newsletter:
 Website (https://info.aiaa.org/tac/PEG/ABPSITC/):
Anne-Laure Delot
• JPC 2012 Updates





Nominated New Chair: Dora Musielac
Approved Standard Operating Procedures Document
Initiated Creation of New-Member Handbook: Neal Herring
ABP Shared Folder: In Work
New Major Goal: Banner, Cover Slide, Branding for ASM
20
Education Subcommittee
Develop and Sponsor Short Courses




Aeropropulsion Short Course @ UTSI
Engine/Airframe Integration Short Course Via Purdue
PDE Short Course Introduced January 2003
Propulsion Integration Short Course
Develop Propulsion Specifications for Student Design Competitions and
Select Best Design Team
• Chair: Rod Daebelliehn
• Vice Chair – Chen Chuck
• Activities
 Student Design Competition
– Bill Westphal
– Neal Herring
 Outreach
– Chen Chuck
 Short Courses
21
Honors and Awards
Develop Award Specifications for ABP, Recommend Selection for ABP (Career
Achievement) Award, Select Gordon C. Oates Graduate Student Award and ABP Best
Paper Awards, Provide Young Engineer’s Recognition Certificates and Presents Chairman’s
Award when Appropriate
• Chair: Keith Blodgett
• Vice Chair: Vance Dippold
• Activity Leads
 Propulsion Award Packages: EVERYBODY
 Student Award: Vance Dippold
 Best Paper Award: Shane Bunnag, shane.bunnag@ngc.com
• Gordon C Oates Award – Not Awarded, No Funding
• Air Breathing Propulsion Award: Walter F. O’Brien, J. Bernard Jones Professor of
Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
• Professor O’Brien is being recognized for outstanding technical contributions, creativity, and
generosity that have inspired hundreds of students to achieve bright careers in gas turbine
22
and high speed propulsion
2011-2012 ABP Best Paper Award
Congratulations to
Dan Baruzzini, Neal Domel, and Daniel Miller
of
Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Company, Fort Worth, Texas
for their Work:
“Addressing Corner Interactions Generated by Oblique
Shock-Waves In Unswept Right-Angle Corners and
Implications for High-Speed Inlets”
(AIAA-2012-275)
Presented at ASM 2012
Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration TC
Scope & Charter
Scope
• The application of mechanical design, fluid mechanics and thermodynamics to
the science and technology of air vehicle propulsion and power systems
integration, including:




Installed performance and controls (SPO, PPT)
Propulsion aerodynamics; inlet and nozzle systems (IE)
Power and thermal management (SPO, PPT)
All aspects of propulsion system / air vehicle interface and certification (RVCT)
Charter: Advance air breathing propulsion integration technology by:
•
•
•
•
Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at ASM, JPC and other conferences of
interest
Working effectively with AIAA TCs and PCs and other technical societies to organize and
promote joint sessions and activities
Providing for technical communications and reviews, educational activities, and honors and
awards
Providing the Institute with authoritative technical opinions and public policy
recommendations
24
Subsystem, Performance, Optimization Technical Area
Scope & Charter
Chair : Bruce McKay, Lockheed Martin
Vice Chair:
Charter:
• Promote & Facilitate Communication in support of Efficient Interaction, And
Performance of Air Breathing Propulsion Systems
Scope:
• Exploit Synergies in Aeropropulsion, Thermal And Power Subsystems
• Performance Modeling And Validation
• Cognizance in the contributions of Advanced Materials, Sensing, Controls,
Maintenance
• New Challenges In Green Aircraft – Operations, Emissions, Noise
• Foster Discussions And Ideas - New Energy Sources, and synergies with
alternate energy being developed for ground based energy.
• Outline established for Technology Advocacy Paper examining auxiliary electric
concepts
25
Propellers/Pistons/Turboprops (Rotors) Technical Area
Scope & Charter
Chair: Charles Beard, Boeing Commercial Airplanes
Vice Chair: Stephen Johnson, Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Scope
Create the focal point for concepts and issue resolution related to the airframe
integration of propellers, pistons and turboprop engines
Charter
To provide a forum for the design, development and certification of powerplant
installations for piston and turboprop aircraft.
Topics for consideration
 Propellers
– Un-ducted fans (rotor burst, noise and icing protection)
 Pistons
– Avgas and Diesel FADEC Engines
– Elimination of Leaded AV Gas
 Turboprops
– 300 – 500 SHP engines for light GA Aircraft
26
Integrated Aero Performance Technical Subcommittee
Scope & Charter
Chair - Thomas Berens, CASSIDIAN
Vice chair - Christopher Hughes, NASA Glenn Research Center
(Updated 25 Jul 12)
Scope
Focus on the development and performance of aircraft inlets, nozzles and exhaust systems.
Charter
Emphasis on both computational and experimental results (including sub-scale and flight
components), component optimization, inlet and exhaust system design techniques, propulsion
test techniques at speeds ranging from subsonic through hypersonic.
Topics for consideration
Flow control application including scaling effects
Aircraft performance
Aerodynamic and structural integration of inlets and exhaust systems
Engine/inlet compatibility
Real world operation environmental issues (ice, sand, rain, FOD, etc.)
Acoustics
 Acoustic treatments
 Affect of inlet and nozzle on sonic boom
 High Speed Applications














STOVL
Jet effects
Thrust vectoring
Area control
Survivability
Thrust reversers
Nacelle/wing interaction
Unducted fan
27
Requirements Verification, Certification and Testing Technical Area
Scope & Charter
Chair: Bob Nichols
Vice Chair: Dave Wang
Scope
All aspects of air breathing propulsion integration certification and testing
including:
Installed performance and controls
Propulsion aerodynamics; inlet, nozzle and systems
Power and thermal management
Charter
Advance air breathing propulsion integration testing technology by:
• Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at the IGTI Turbo Expo in
collaboration with ASME IGTI Aircraft Engine TC
• Develop and Sponsoring Technical Sessions at the ASM, JPC and other
conferences of interest in collaboration with the SAE S-16 Engine Inlet Flow
Distortion TC
• Working effectively with the ABPSI Inlets/Exhausts and SPO technical areas and28
other technical societies to organize and promote joint sessions and actives
What is the role of a Tech sub-committee
• At minimum
 Help define call for papers - assure relevance and timeliness of the call
 Support conferences by organizing special topic sessions/panels
• Expanding







White papers
Position papers
Develop Short course or module in a short course
Liason with other TC’s and societies
Text books
Standards definitions
Workshops
29
Technical Subcommittee Rosters
Integrated Aero
Performance
Chair: Thomas Berens
Vice: Chris Hughes
Keith Blodgett
Chen Chuck
Roderick Daebelliehn
Vance Dippold
Jeffrey Flamm
Douglas Kisling
Bryan Westra
Eric Loth
Michelle McMillan
Anne-Laure DeLot
Angela Scribben
Shane Bunnag
Neal Domel
Haixin Chen
Lie-Mine Gea
Dick Scharnhorst
Subsystem,
Performance,
Optimization
Propellers, Pistons,
Turboprops
Chair: Bruce McKay
Vice:
Chair: Charles Beard
Vice: Stephen Johnson
Lance Chenault
Jeffrey Hamstra
Jonathan Litt
Neal Herring
Tim Warlick
Dyna Benchergui
Norbert Bissinger
Ian Halliwell
Charles Gaharan
Requirements
Verification,
Certification and
Testing
Chair: Bob Nichols
Vice: David Wang
William Westphal
John Kelly
Eric Hansen
30